Additional numerical results for the
quasi-Newton interior point method for
low order H-infinity controller synthesis
Daniel Ankelhed, Anders Helmersson, Anders Hansson
Division of Automatic Control
E-mail: ankelhed@isy.liu.se, andersh@isy.liu.se,
hansson@isy.liu.se
5th July 2010
Report no.: LiTH-ISY-R-2964
Address:
Department of Electrical Engineering
Linköpings universitet
SE-581 83 Linköping, Sweden
WWW: http://www.control.isy.liu.se
AUTOMATIC CONTROL
REGLERTEKNIK
LINKÖPINGS UNIVERSITET
Technical reports from the Automatic Control group in Linköping are available from
http://www.control.isy.liu.se/publications.
to include these results in the article due to limited amount of space. Also
results from our evaluation of Hifoo on the same systems are included.
Keywords: Numerical results, H-in nity synthesis, Linear Matrix
Inequal-ities, rank constraints, rational constraints, interior point methods,
quasi-Newton methods.
order H-in nity controller synthesis
Daniel Ankelhed, Anders Helmersson, Anders Hansson
2010-07-05
Abstract
Here we present numerical results and timings obtained using our
quasi-Newton interior point method on a set of 44 systems. We were
not able to include these results in the article due to limited amount of
space. Also results from our evaluation of Hifoo on the same systems
are included.
1 Introduction
The purpose of this report is to provide additional numerical results from the
evaluation of the primal-dual quasi-Newton (QN) method in [1]. The other
method mentioned in the article is Hifoo, see [2] for details. The systems used
in the evaluation are taken from Compl
e
ib, see [3].
2 Contents
The tables included in this report are as follows.
•
The quasi-Newton primal-dual method (QN): Tables 187, odd numbers.
•
Hifoo: Tables 288, even numbers.
3 Notation
3.1 QN
In the tables for QN (Tables 187, odd numbers), the rst column lists the γ
values, starting with the nominal value for the full order controller, and then
the percentage increase of that value further down the rst column. The other
columns lists the values obtained for the controllers of the order displayed at
the top of the column. A dash (-) means that the corresponding controller was
not calculated and an underlined value in
red
indicates that a controller of that
order was calculated but failed to satisfy the requirements regarding stability,
feasibility etc. These controllers are not counted as successful controllers, e.g.
the QN method cannot nd a zeroth order controller for AC1 within +900%
The bottom part of the tables shows the required time to calculate the
controllers corresponding to the values on the upper part of the tables. At the
bottom row, the total amount of time is summed up for the whole table.
3.2 Hifoo
In the tables for Hifoo (Tables 288), the rst column of the upper part lists
the number of the runs. The other columns list the achieved H
∞
norms, where
numbers corresponding to unstable controllers are written in underlined
red
text. The middle part lists the statistics regarding the achieved H
∞
norm, such
as the minimum value, the maximum value, the mean value, the median value
and the standard deviation. The lower part lists the same statistics, but for the
required time.
4 Calculations
The closed loop system was calculated in Matlab using
K = ss(Ka,Kb,Kc,Kd);
G = ss(A,[B1 B2],[C1;C2],[D11 D12;D21 zeros(ny,nu)]);
Gc = lft(P,K,nu,ny);
where (Ka, Kb, Kc, Kd) are the controller parameters and nu, ny are the
number of inputs and outputs of the system G, respectively. The achieved H
∞
norm was calculated using
norm(Gc,inf,1e-6)
and the required time was calculated using
t = cputime;
to start the stop watch and
t = cputime - t;
to stop it.
5 Numerical results
Table 1: Compleib system AC1, 5 states, QN method.
γ/ k 4 3 2 1 0 1.000·10−5 1.145·10−8 2.352·10−7 1.610·10−7 4.239·10−7 2.986 +5% - - - - 2.433·10−2 +10% - - - - 1.756·10−3 +20% - - - - 2.387·10−2 +35% - - - - 1.015·10−2 +50% - - - - 1.922·10−2 +100% - - - - 8.579·10−3 +200% - - - - 1.416·10−2 +400% - - - - 7.797·10−3 +900% - - - - 2.844·10−2 t [s] +0% 9.859 4.344 4.656 4.375 7.563 +5% 8.219 +10% 7.063 +20% 7.203 +35% 7.328 +50% 7.250 +100% 7.406 +200% 7.328 +400% 7.453 +900% 7.078 Total: 9.713·101 sTable 2: Compleib system AC1, 5 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 4 3 2 1 0 1 5.307·10−4 3.819·10−5 5.610·10−2 6.328·10−5 5.366·10−3 2 1.284·10−3 9.906·10−6 1.824·10−6 2.589·10−7 9.460·10−5 3 4.474·10−5 2.078·10−4 2.868·10−6 1.761·10−4 3.435·10−2 4 3.517·10−6 6.192·10−5 5.343·10−3 3.822·10−3 1.890·10−5 5 6.147·10−6 1.301·10−4 8.346·10−5 4.800·10−5 8.687·10−7 6 9.923·10−4 3.598·10−2 1.158 8.254·10−5 2.675·10−2 7 2.276·10−8 9.598·10−6 2.260·10−3 5.021·10−6 2.103·10−5 8 1.475·10−4 1.865·10−4 1.370·10−4 1.009·10−6 7.113·10−6 9 4.034·10−4 3.886·10−4 2.597·10−4 1.089·10−7 1.189·10−5 10 1.947·10−4 3.678·10−3 9.764·10−5 6.035·10−3 1.995·10−2 min 2.276·10−8 2.078·10−4 1.824·10−6 2.589·10−7 8.687·10−7 max 1.284·10−3 3.678·10−3 5.343·10−3 6.035·10−3 3.435·10−2 mean 3.607·10−4 4.503·10−4 8.086·10−4 9.857·10−4 8.106·10−3 med 1.711·10−4 5.006·10−5 4.316·10−5 7.291·10−5 5.782·10−5 std 4.519·10−4 1.141·10−3 1.739·10−3 2.142·10−3 1.349·10−2 t [s] tmin 1.377·102 1.545·102 1.555·102 9.578·101 6.750·101 tmax 5.268·102 8.036·102 4.322·102 5.024·102 1.823·102 tmean 2.298·102 3.990·102 2.364·102 1.993·102 1.089·102 tmed 1.836·102 2.836·102 2.307·102 1.718·102 1.040·102 tstd 1.172·102 2.339·102 7.553·101 1.157·102 3.332·101
3
Table 3: Compleib system AC2, 5 states, QN method.
γ/ k 4 3 2 1 0 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 t [s] +0% 3.141 3.078 2.906 3.000 2.891 Total: 1.502·101 sTable 4: Compleib system AC2, 5 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 4 3 2 1 0 1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 2 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 3 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 4 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 5 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 6 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 7 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 8 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 9 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 10 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 min 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 max 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 mean 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 med 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 1.115·10−1 std 2.986 1.125 7.203 4.732 1.245·10−9 t [s] tmin 5.625 4.641 5.453 5.828 4.578 tmax 1.748·101 2.791·101 2.131·101 1.797·101 4.770·101 tmean 1.228·101 1.406·101 1.067·101 1.136·101 2.032·101 tmed 1.279·101 1.407·101 9.172 1.084·101 1.209·101 tstd 4.364 7.443 4.977 4.306 1.725·101
4
Table 5: Compleib system AC3, 5 states, QN method.
γ/ k 4 3 2 1 0 2.970 2.970 2.970 2.970 2.970 9.975 +5% - - - - 4.712 +10% - - - - 4.424 +20% - - - - 4.080 +35% - - - - 3.926 t [s] +0% 4.625 5.906 5.359 5.172 7.922 +5% 6.156 +10% 8.031 +20% 7.000 +35% 1.027·101 Total: 6.044·101 sTable 6: Compleib system AC3, 5 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.987 3.020 3.129 3.290 3.647 2 3.012 3.292 3.179 3.316 3.716 3 2.989 3.180 3.071 3.141 3.646 4 3.153 3.023 3.116 3.379 3.740 5 2.992 3.012 3.185 3.269 3.731 6 2.981 3.157 3.277 3.543 3.645 7 2.990 3.334 3.176 3.180 3.883 8 2.984 2.996 3.296 3.373 3.639 9 3.001 3.101 3.393 3.555 4.659 10 3.022 3.127 3.068 3.517 4.665 min 2.981 2.996 3.068 3.141 3.639 max 3.153 3.334 3.393 3.555 4.665 mean 3.011 3.124 3.189 3.356 3.897 med 2.991 3.114 3.178 3.345 3.723 std 5.153·10−2 1.188·10−1 1.047·10−1 1.460·10−1 4.099·10−1 t [s] tmin 1.244·102 7.272·101 8.950·101 6.620·101 1.056·101 tmax 4.448·102 6.120·102 4.699·102 3.081·102 4.780·101 tmean 2.931·102 2.969·102 2.300·102 1.721·102 2.680·101 tmed 3.481·102 2.599·102 1.776·102 1.288·102 2.445·101 tstd 1.129·102 2.084·102 1.351·102 9.280·101 1.474·101
5
Table 7: Compleib system AC4, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 5.579·10−1 5.575·10−1 5.575·10−1 9.183·10−1 -+5% - - 2.063 -+10% - - 5.912·10−1 2.627 +20% - - - 3.401 +35% - - - 2.189 +50% - - - 1.254 +100% - - - 9.507·10−1 t [s] +0% 4.047 4.531 6.359 +5% 5.375 +10% 3.156 4.047 +20% 4.906 +35% 5.094 +50% 4.922 +100% 2.750 Total: 4.519·101 sTable 8: Compleib system AC4, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.596·10−1 9.355·10−1 2 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 6.733·10−1 9.355·10−1 3 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.966·10−1 9.355·10−1 4 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.620·10−1 9.355·10−1 5 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.585·10−1 9.355·10−1 6 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.606·10−1 9.355·10−1 7 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.577·10−1 9.355·10−1 8 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.591·10−1 9.355·10−1 9 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.574·10−1 9.355·10−1 10 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.578·10−1 9.355·10−1 min 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.574·10−1 9.355·10−1 max 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 6.733·10−1 9.355·10−1 mean 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.743·10−1 9.355·10−1 med 5.573·10−1 5.573·10−1 5.593·10−1 9.355·10−1 std 1.009·10−5 9.575·10−6 3.678·10−2 1.791·10−9 t [s] tmin 5.030·101 8.667·101 6.711·101 1.688·101 tmax 2.148·102 4.120·102 2.569·102 3.891·101 tmean 1.177·102 1.361·102 1.048·102 2.992·101 tmed 1.091·102 1.008·102 8.838·101 3.077·101 tstd 4.140·101 9.897·101 5.736·101 6.423
6
Table 9: Compleib system AC5, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 0.000 - - - -+5% 6.641·102 6.677·102 6.674·102 6.913·102 t [s] +0% +5% 3.703 3.703 3.781 3.813 Total: 1.500·101 sTable 10: Compleib system AC5, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 6.683·102 6.697·102 6.673·102 6.755·102 2 6.680·102 6.679·102 6.676·102 6.942·102 3 6.688·102 6.687·102 6.732·102 6.720·102 4 6.916·102 6.942·102 6.702·102 6.683·102 5 6.724·102 6.677·102 6.659·102 6.836·102 6 6.685·102 6.672·102 6.431·102 1.006·102 7 6.696·102 6.680·102 6.679·102 6.737·102 8 6.709·102 6.679·102 6.427·102 6.952·102 9 6.426·102 6.777·102 6.704·102 6.715·102 10 6.683·102 6.674·102 6.696·102 6.833·102 min 6.426·102 6.672·102 6.427·102 1.006·102 max 6.916·102 6.942·102 6.732·102 6.952·102 mean 6.689·102 6.717·102 6.638·102 6.218·102 med 6.687·102 6.680·102 6.677·102 6.746·102 std 1.168·101 8.518 1.120·101 1.834·102 t [s] tmin 1.633·101 3.938 3.703 4.688·10−1 tmax 5.252·102 3.115·102 3.167·102 3.656 tmean 1.381·102 4.431·101 7.104·101 2.700 tmed 4.890·101 1.494·101 1.091·101 2.938 tstd 1.949·102 9.426·101 1.295·102 9.060·10−1
7
Table 11: Compleib system AC6, 7 states, QN method.
γ/ k 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 3.433 3.432 3.433 2.795·101 - - - -+5% - - 3.594 3.595 3.583 3.687 -+10% - - - 3.765 4.891 +20% - - - 4.119 t [s] +0% 3.652·101 3.497·101 3.456·101 +5% 8.422 1.019·101 9.078 3.217·101 +10% 8.594 3.208·101 +20% 1.163·101 Total: 2.182·102 sTable 12: Compleib system AC6, 7 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 3.525 3.533 3.545 3.567 3.579 3.600 4.114 2 3.516 3.556 3.544 3.604 3.585 3.658 4.114 3 3.549 3.563 3.568 3.507 3.759 3.653 4.114 4 3.528 3.597 3.564 3.541 3.573 3.586 4.114 5 3.533 3.555 3.502 3.812 3.601 3.649 4.114 6 3.577 3.519 3.685 3.596 3.699 3.753 4.114 7 3.507 3.479 3.568 3.575 3.582 3.638 4.114 8 3.497 3.537 3.529 3.596 3.591 3.804 4.114 9 3.551 3.448 3.556 3.599 3.658 3.612 4.114 10 3.544 3.528 3.633 3.546 3.630 3.616 4.114 min 3.497 3.448 3.502 3.507 3.573 3.586 4.114 max 3.577 3.597 3.685 3.812 3.759 3.804 4.114 mean 3.533 3.532 3.569 3.594 3.626 3.657 4.114 med 3.530 3.535 3.560 3.585 3.596 3.644 4.114 std 2.371·10−2 4.260·10−2 5.271·10−2 8.275·10−2 6.186·10−2 6.934·10−2 4.296·10−5 t [s] tmin 1.249·103 8.141·102 8.086·102 6.695·102 3.620·102 3.883·102 5.470·101 tmax 1.408·103 1.143·103 9.928·102 7.649·102 5.868·102 4.810·102 1.662·102 tmean 1.337·103 1.030·103 8.704·102 7.095·102 5.198·102 4.350·102 1.018·102 tmed 1.331·103 1.049·103 8.599·102 7.020·102 5.336·102 4.358·102 9.108·101 tstd 4.916·101 8.688·101 4.849·101 3.042·101 6.350·101 2.893·101 3.691·101
8
Table 13: Compleib system AC7, 9 states, QN method.
γ/ k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 3.840·10−2 3.831·10−2 3.835·10−2 5.284·10−2 - - - -+5% - - 4.004·10−2 4.009·10−2 4.014·10−2 4.025·10−2 4.012·10−2 7.551·10−2 -+10% - - - 7.063·10−2 -+20% - - - 5.796·10−2 -+35% - - - 5.416·10−2 -+50% - - - 5.658·10−2 7.139·10−2 +100% - - - 6.654·10−2 t [s] +0% 2.933·101 2.956·101 3.000·101 +5% 9.406 9.656 1.017·101 1.059·101 9.156 3.023·101 +10% 3.002·101 +20% 2.888·101 +35% 2.873·101 +50% 9.703 2.864·101 +100% 7.609 Total: 3.017·102 sTable 14: Compleib system AC7, 9 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 3.929·10−2 4.147·10−2 3.954·10−2 3.938·10−2 3.953·10−2 3.967·10−2 3.979·10−2 4.964·10−2 6.509·10−2 2 3.930·10−2 3.938·10−2 4.082·10−2 4.422·10−2 3.984·10−2 3.968·10−2 4.217·10−2 5.528·10−2 6.509·10−2 3 3.982·10−2 3.912·10−2 3.942·10−2 4.208·10−2 3.938·10−2 3.942·10−2 3.954·10−2 5.005·10−2 6.509·10−2 4 4.123·10−2 3.938·10−2 3.956·10−2 4.093·10−2 3.960·10−2 4.286·10−2 5.022·10−2 4.968·10−2 6.509·10−2 5 3.964·10−2 3.963·10−2 3.944·10−2 3.961·10−2 4.479·10−2 3.943·10−2 4.540·10−2 4.983·10−2 6.509·10−2 6 3.916·10−2 3.913·10−2 4.002·10−2 3.940·10−2 4.080·10−2 4.011·10−2 4.021·10−2 4.971·10−2 6.509·10−2 7 4.058·10−2 3.959·10−2 3.935·10−2 3.957·10−2 3.999·10−2 3.961·10−2 3.967·10−2 4.958·10−2 6.509·10−2 8 3.920·10−2 3.937·10−2 3.982·10−2 3.916·10−2 3.953·10−2 3.988·10−2 3.965·10−2 5.528·10−2 6.509·10−2 9 4.052·10−2 3.931·10−2 3.936·10−2 3.973·10−2 3.947·10−2 3.946·10−2 3.965·10−2 4.963·10−2 6.509·10−2 10 3.908·10−2 3.926·10−2 3.954·10−2 3.951·10−2 3.966·10−2 4.001·10−2 4.962·10−2 4.957·10−2 6.509·10−2 min 3.908·10−2 3.912·10−2 3.935·10−2 3.916·10−2 3.938·10−2 3.942·10−2 3.954·10−2 4.957·10−2 6.509·10−2 max 4.123·10−2 4.147·10−2 4.082·10−2 4.422·10−2 4.479·10−2 4.286·10−2 5.022·10−2 5.528·10−2 6.509·10−2 mean 3.978·10−2 3.956·10−2 3.969·10−2 4.036·10−2 4.026·10−2 4.001·10−2 4.259·10−2 5.082·10−2 6.509·10−2 med 3.947·10−2 3.938·10−2 3.954·10−2 3.959·10−2 3.963·10−2 3.967·10−2 4.000·10−2 4.969·10−2 6.509·10−2 std 7.441·10−4 6.892·10−4 4.510·10−4 1.627·10−3 1.643·10−3 1.027·10−3 4.273·10−3 2.352·10−3 4.973·10−2 t [s] tmin 2.613·102 2.469·102 2.345·102 1.763·102 1.476·102 1.445·102 1.122·102 3.966·101 1.234·101 tmax 3.868·102 9.662·102 1.241·103 6.008·102 2.734·102 2.895·102 3.816·102 1.005·102 1.570·101 tmean 3.197·102 3.499·102 3.694·102 3.097·102 2.053·102 2.221·102 1.910·102 6.732·101 1.412·101 tmed 3.072·102 2.718·102 2.651·102 2.254·102 2.111·102 2.136·102 1.732·102 7.089·101 1.415·101 tstd 4.007·101 2.181·102 3.095·102 1.608·102 3.663·101 4.160·101 7.399·101 1.995·101 1.005
9
Table 15: Compleib system AC8, 9 states, QN method.
γ/ k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1.622 1.620 1.620 1.620 1.620 1.620 1.653 - - -+5% - - - 1.671 1.690 1.690 2.380 +10% - - - 3.580 +20% - - - 2.845 +35% - - - 2.175 t [s] +0% 4.388·101 1.252·101 1.494·101 1.664·101 1.586·101 4.552·101 +5% 1.369·101 1.364·101 1.323·101 3.373·101 +10% 4.611·101 +20% 4.466·101 +35% 1.322·101 Total: 3.276·102 sTable 16: Compleib system AC8, 9 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 1.617 1.626 1.618 1.619 1.619 1.625 1.628 1.651 2.005 2 1.618 1.618 1.617 1.618 1.620 1.625 1.627 1.651 2.005 3 1.619 1.619 1.621 1.620 1.621 1.627 1.627 1.651 2.005 4 1.619 1.622 1.619 1.625 1.620 1.619 1.628 1.652 2.005 5 1.620 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.620 1.627 1.651 2.005 6 1.618 1.620 1.619 1.619 1.623 1.627 1.629 1.652 2.005 7 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.624 1.619 1.627 1.651 2.005 8 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.624 1.629 1.627 1.652 2.005 9 1.620 1.619 1.617 1.620 1.619 1.628 1.627 1.652 2.005 10 1.620 1.619 1.622 1.620 1.621 1.626 1.627 1.651 2.005 min 1.617 1.618 1.617 1.618 1.619 1.619 1.627 1.651 2.005 max 1.620 1.626 1.622 1.625 1.624 1.629 1.629 1.652 2.005 mean 1.619 1.620 1.619 1.620 1.621 1.624 1.628 1.651 2.005 med 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.619 1.621 1.625 1.627 1.651 2.005 std 9.440·10−4 2.514·10−3 1.528·10−3 2.003·10−3 1.990·10−3 3.726·10−3 5.971·10−4 3.022·10−4 2.760·10−6 t [s] tmin 1.055·103 9.311·102 8.771·102 4.814·102 3.490·102 3.426·102 2.699·102 1.561·102 3.041·101 tmax 1.795·103 1.640·103 1.489·103 1.097·103 9.511·102 8.247·102 5.072·102 3.446·102 2.175·102 tmean 1.472·103 1.162·103 1.152·103 7.652·102 7.566·102 5.191·102 3.585·102 2.209·102 9.108·101 tmed 1.468·103 1.145·103 1.168·103 7.104·102 7.802·102 5.054·102 3.368·102 2.066·102 6.205·101 tstd 1.967·102 1.935·102 2.423·102 1.966·102 2.023·102 1.491·102 9.061·101 5.946·101 6.378·101
10
Table 17: Compleib system AC9, 10 states, QN method.
γ/ k 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.213 - -+5% - - - 1.025 1.026 1.225 +10% - - - 1.103 +20% - - - 1.187 t [s] +0% 5.730·101 2.339·101 2.264·101 2.142·101 2.081·101 2.367·101 2.558·101 5.381·101 +5% 1.516·101 1.223·101 5.144·101 +10% 5.188·101 +20% 1.700·101 Total: 3.963·102 sTable 18: Compleib system AC9, 10 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 1.009 1.006 1.007 1.004 1.005 1.004 1.007 1.009 1.005 1.012 2 1.008 1.008 1.010 1.009 1.008 1.005 1.002 1.006 1.005 1.010 3 1.005 1.005 1.005 1.006 1.005 1.006 1.007 1.004 1.006 1.008 4 1.006 1.002 1.006 1.006 1.006 1.013 1.005 1.007 1.004 1.005 5 1.006 1.003 1.005 1.006 1.007 1.006 1.007 1.003 1.013 1.009 6 1.005 1.006 1.005 1.005 1.005 1.004 1.005 1.004 1.012 1.006 7 1.004 1.005 1.007 1.009 1.004 1.005 1.005 1.004 1.012 1.004 8 1.003 1.008 1.012 1.006 1.006 1.004 1.004 1.004 1.006 1.003 9 1.012 1.005 1.006 1.003 1.012 1.005 1.008 1.008 1.009 1.003 10 1.007 1.006 1.005 1.007 1.004 1.004 1.005 1.006 1.017 1.004 min 1.003 1.002 1.005 1.003 1.004 1.004 1.002 1.003 1.004 1.003 max 1.012 1.008 1.012 1.009 1.012 1.013 1.008 1.009 1.017 1.012 mean 1.007 1.005 1.007 1.006 1.006 1.006 1.005 1.006 1.009 1.006 med 1.006 1.005 1.006 1.006 1.005 1.005 1.005 1.005 1.007 1.006 std 2.369·10−3 1.818·10−3 2.217·10−3 1.774·10−3 2.520·10−3 2.696·10−3 1.855·10−3 1.937·10−3 4.389·10−3 2.887·10−3 t [s] tmin 6.918·102 7.695·102 5.046·102 7.075·102 5.132·102 2.780·102 2.933·102 2.961·102 2.034·102 1.447·102 tmax 2.090·103 1.832·103 1.723·103 1.622·103 1.817·103 1.144·103 8.938·102 1.008·103 5.610·102 3.772·102 tmean 1.431·103 1.178·103 1.190·103 1.126·103 1.145·103 7.059·102 4.968·102 5.356·102 4.089·102 2.429·102 tmed 1.495·103 1.007·103 1.360·103 1.064·103 1.133·103 7.164·102 4.100·102 4.672·102 4.160·102 2.439·102 tstd 4.953·102 3.685·102 4.093·102 2.770·102 4.155·102 3.130·102 1.930·102 2.428·102 1.167·102 6.941·101
11
Table 19: Compleib system AC11, 5 states, QN method.
γ/ k 4 3 2 1 0 2.812 2.812 2.812 2.812 2.812 3.149 +5% - - - - 2.949 t [s] +0% 4.188 5.422 4.797 4.328 1.153·101 +5% 4.656 Total: 3.492·101 sTable 20: Compleib system AC11, 5 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.832 2.820 2.834 2.821 3.543 2 2.822 2.833 2.824 2.823 3.544 3 2.818 2.819 2.815 2.836 3.554 4 2.819 2.826 2.833 2.837 2.830 5 2.816 2.816 2.839 2.854 3.530 6 2.814 2.824 2.816 2.823 3.531 7 2.812 2.824 2.837 2.827 3.593 8 2.836 2.818 2.827 2.858 3.553 9 2.819 2.830 2.891 2.841 2.821 10 2.831 2.848 2.853 2.831 2.838 min 2.812 2.816 2.815 2.821 2.821 max 2.836 2.848 2.891 2.858 3.593 mean 2.822 2.826 2.837 2.835 3.334 med 2.819 2.824 2.834 2.834 3.537 std 8.173·10−3 9.410·10−3 2.224·10−2 1.302·10−2 3.482·10−1 t [s] tmin 1.480·102 1.091·102 9.408·101 6.838·101 7.984 tmax 6.710·102 4.866·102 3.415·102 3.613·102 1.882·102 tmean 2.690·102 2.697·102 1.912·102 1.638·102 6.362·101 tmed 2.360·102 2.268·102 1.601·102 1.179·102 2.341·101 tstd 1.522·102 1.433·102 9.517·101 1.102·102 7.112·101
12
Table 21: Compleib system AC12, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 5.831·10−2 3.809·10−2 3.581 - -+5% - 9.119·10−1 - -+10% - 2.374·10−2 3.220·10−2 2.137·101 +20% - - - 5.751·10−2 t [s] +0% 6.266 4.359 +5% 4.969 +10% 4.672 4.078 5.313 +20% 4.641 Total: 3.430·101 sTable 22: Compleib system AC12, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 3.189·10−1 3.198·10−1 3.169·10−1 1.385 2 3.080·10−1 3.102·10−1 3.177·10−1 3.175·10−1 3 3.121·10−1 3.145·10−1 1.863 3.216·10−1 4 3.201·10−1 3.143·10−1 3.234·10−1 3.143·10−1 5 3.297·10−1 3.123·10−1 3.167·10−1 3.159·10−1 6 3.217·10−1 2.866·10−1 3.325·10−1 3.150·10−1 7 3.151·10−1 3.172·10−1 3.169·10−1 3.174·10−1 8 3.181·10−1 3.133·10−1 3.145·10−1 3.163·10−1 9 3.157·10−1 3.179·10−1 3.041·10−1 3.191·10−1 10 3.159·10−1 2.849·10−1 3.078·10−1 3.266·10−1 min 3.080·10−1 2.849·10−1 3.041·10−1 3.143·10−1 max 3.297·10−1 3.198·10−1 1.863 1.385 mean 3.175·10−1 3.091·10−1 4.714·10−1 4.249·10−1 med 3.170·10−1 3.138·10−1 3.169·10−1 3.175·10−1 std 5.856·10−3 1.263·10−2 4.892·10−1 3.375·10−1 t [s] tmin 6.286·101 6.942·101 6.116·101 4.709·101 tmax 7.908·102 5.102·102 5.685·102 4.172·102 tmean 3.030·102 2.058·102 2.227·102 1.610·102 tmed 1.576·102 1.466·102 1.458·102 9.854·101 tstd 2.806·102 1.334·102 1.836·102 1.348·102
13
Table 23: Compleib system AC15, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 1.488·101 1.488·101 1.488·101 1.488·101 3.891·101 +5% - - - 1.528·101 t [s] +0% 3.672 3.922 3.844 8.844 +5% 3.344 Total: 2.363·101 sTable 24: Compleib system AC15, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 1.488·101 1.501·101 1.528·101 1.613·101 2 1.489·101 1.488·101 1.520·101 1.517·101 3 1.487·101 1.492·101 1.487·101 1.517·101 4 1.489·101 1.489·101 1.494·101 1.575·101 5 1.487·101 1.488·101 1.497·101 1.517·101 6 1.487·101 1.509·101 1.504·101 1.517·101 7 1.489·101 1.491·101 1.555·101 1.517·101 8 1.488·101 1.488·101 1.548·101 1.517·101 9 1.490·101 1.489·101 1.601·101 1.517·101 10 1.489·101 1.498·101 1.592·101 1.517·101 min 1.487·101 1.488·101 1.487·101 1.517·101 max 1.490·101 1.509·101 1.601·101 1.613·101 mean 1.488·101 1.493·101 1.533·101 1.532·101 med 1.488·101 1.490·101 1.524·101 1.517·101 std 9.037·10−3 7.056·10−2 4.055·10−1 3.375·10−1 t [s] tmin 8.086·101 8.358·101 5.373·101 2.869·101 tmax 3.801·102 4.228·102 2.384·102 2.105·102 tmean 1.831·102 2.280·102 1.243·102 7.085·101 tmed 1.473·102 1.907·102 9.870·101 5.871·101 tstd 1.055·102 1.195·102 7.404·101 5.062·101
14
Table 25: Compleib system AC16, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 1.489·101 1.487·101 1.488·101 1.488·101 1.488·101 t [s] +0% 3.375 3.141 3.078 2.891 Total: 1.248·101 sTable 26: Compleib system AC16, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.487·101 1.490·101 2 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.512·101 1.501·101 3 1.493·101 1.486·101 1.499·101 1.486·101 4 1.487·101 1.487·101 1.489·101 1.525·101 5 1.486·101 1.487·101 1.493·101 1.497·101 6 1.486·101 1.610·101 1.648·101 1.491·101 7 1.487·101 1.489·101 1.497·101 1.664·101 8 1.493·101 1.486·101 1.535·101 1.658·101 9 1.486·101 1.487·101 1.644·101 1.604·101 10 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.486·101 min 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.486·101 1.486·101 max 1.493·101 1.610·101 1.648·101 1.664·101 mean 1.487·101 1.499·101 1.529·101 1.540·101 med 1.486·101 1.487·101 1.498·101 1.499·101 std 2.780·10−2 3.894·10−1 6.339·10−1 7.275·10−1 t [s] tmin 2.745·101 2.088·101 1.631·101 2.520·101 tmax 5.982·102 3.720·102 4.664·102 1.927·102 tmean 1.855·102 1.118·102 9.844·101 7.482·101 tmed 9.931·101 6.681·101 4.542·101 3.273·101 tstd 1.979·102 1.168·102 1.373·102 7.330·101
15
Table 27: Compleib system AC17, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 0 6.613 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 t [s] +0% 2.969 3.109 2.953 2.813 Total: 1.184·101 sTable 28: Compleib system AC17, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 0 1 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 2 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 3 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 4 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 5 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 6 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 7 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 8 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 9 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 10 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 min 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 max 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 mean 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 med 6.612 6.612 6.612 6.612 std 2.382·10−8 2.745·10−8 2.327·10−7 6.088·10−6 t [s] tmin 9.375·10−1 9.688·10−1 8.125·10−1 6.406·10−1 tmax 4.031 1.984 2.547 2.453 tmean 2.005 1.339 1.587 1.222 tmed 1.766 1.219 1.523 1.117 tstd 1.026 3.593·10−1 5.721·10−1 5.041·10−1
16
Table 29: Compleib system AC18, 10 states, QN method.
γ/ k 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 5.397 1.545·101 - - - -+5% 5.659 5.645 1.139·101 - - - -+10% - - 5.909 6.186 - - - -+20% - - - 6.201 - - - -+35% - - - 7.029 - - - -+50% - - - 3.186·101 - - - -+100% - - - 1.011·101 1.682·101 - - - - -+200% - - - - 1.589·101 1.563·101 1.923·101 - - -+400% - - - 1.837·101 2.321·101 2.102·101 -+900% - - - 4.395·101 5.634·101 t [s] +0% 5.350·101 +5% 4.744·101 4.728·101 4.689·101 +10% 4.714·101 4.672·101 +20% 4.658·101 +35% 4.561·101 +50% 4.569·101 +100% 1.278·101 4.594·101 +200% 1.338·101 1.498·101 4.567·101 +400% 1.392·101 1.520·101 4.575·101 +900% 3.264·101 4.609·101 Total: 7.132·102 sTable 30: Compleib system AC18, 10 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 6.833 6.312 1.696·101 6.356 6.331 6.409 6.488 1.363·101 7.769 1.277·101 2 6.329 1.519·101 6.291 6.296 6.953 6.996 6.969 7.345 7.769 1.271·101 3 6.282 6.749 6.357 6.461 6.987 6.474 6.409 7.149 8.226 2.727·101 4 6.309 9.713 6.378 1.423·101 6.552 6.367 1.893·101 1.241·102 7.769 1.260·101 5 6.302 6.953 6.898 6.290 1.467·101 6.353 6.947 7.413 9.831 2.727·101 6 6.356 6.367 6.227 6.492 6.327 6.363 6.409 7.117 7.769 1.278·101 7 1.123·101 6.437 6.312 6.523 6.320 6.417 7.147 7.242 7.769 2.727·101 8 7.085 6.155 1.248·101 6.348 7.071 6.317 6.489 7.117 7.769 2.728·101 9 6.332 6.408 7.802 6.976 7.143 6.354 6.440 7.117 2.192·101 2.728·101 10 1.011·101 6.252 6.309 6.886 6.165 6.378 6.409 7.404 8.144 2.728·101 min 6.282 6.155 6.227 6.290 6.165 6.317 6.409 7.117 7.769 1.260·101 max 1.123·101 1.519·101 1.696·101 1.423·101 1.467·101 6.996 1.893·101 1.241·102 2.192·101 2.728·101 mean 7.317 7.654 8.201 7.286 7.452 6.443 7.864 1.956·101 9.473 2.145·101 med 6.344 6.422 6.368 6.477 6.752 6.372 6.489 7.294 7.769 2.727·101 std 1.808 2.850 3.625 2.451 2.563 1.991·10−1 3.898 3.678·101 4.419 7.518 t [s] tmin 1.334·103 1.134·103 9.404·102 4.664·102 6.729·102 4.290·102 1.804·102 5.525·101 2.373·101 4.953 tmax 1.761·103 1.655·103 1.392·103 1.261·103 1.054·103 6.746·102 3.980·102 2.572·102 2.314·102 1.531·102 tmean 1.506·103 1.378·103 1.218·103 9.449·102 8.149·102 5.757·102 3.086·102 1.927·102 9.528·101 3.236·101 tmed 1.485·103 1.408·103 1.222·103 9.623·102 8.165·102 6.048·102 3.091·102 2.206·102 6.669·101 1.088·101 tstd 1.498·102 1.581·102 1.403·102 2.133·102 1.229·102 8.743·101 6.061·101 6.207·101 7.379·101 4.562·101
17
Table 31: Compleib system ROC1, 8 states, QN method.
γ/ k 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 1.131 1.131 1.131 1.150 - - - -+5% - - 1.162 1.397 - - -+10% - - - 1.205 1.511 - -+20% - - - - 1.306 1.302 3.057 +35% - - - 2.332 +50% - - - 1.762 +100% - - - 1.912 t [s] +0% 1.369·101 1.781·101 1.509·101 +5% 5.844 1.305·101 +10% 1.198·101 2.023·101 +20% 6.063 5.828 1.938·101 +35% 1.914·101 +50% 1.897·101 +100% 5.000 Total: 1.721·102 sTable 32: Compleib system ROC1, 8 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 1 1.199 1.181 1.185 1.202 1.201 1.244 1.426 2 1.200 1.199 1.199 1.202 1.201 1.244 1.426 3 1.200 1.198 1.200 1.218 1.207 1.244 1.426 4 1.201 1.131 1.199 1.200 1.200 1.244 1.426 5 1.199 1.144 1.201 1.200 1.199 1.244 1.426 6 1.200 1.201 1.199 1.200 1.199 1.244 1.426 7 1.200 1.200 1.195 1.192 1.201 1.244 1.426 8 1.199 1.174 1.198 1.167 1.200 1.244 1.426 9 1.199 1.180 1.168 1.201 1.202 1.244 1.426 10 1.200 1.195 1.178 1.201 1.192 1.244 1.426 min 1.199 1.131 1.168 1.167 1.192 1.244 1.426 max 1.201 1.201 1.201 1.218 1.207 1.244 1.426 mean 1.200 1.180 1.192 1.198 1.200 1.244 1.426 med 1.200 1.188 1.198 1.201 1.201 1.244 1.426 std 4.879·10−4 2.457·10−2 1.134·10−2 1.267·10−2 3.552·10−3 2.076·10−4 5.547·10−8 t [s] tmin 4.154·102 2.712·102 2.344·102 2.079·102 8.906·101 5.847·101 1.886·101 tmax 7.796·102 6.256·102 5.285·102 3.793·102 3.215·102 2.056·102 7.144·101 tmean 6.697·102 4.999·102 4.056·102 3.051·102 1.955·102 1.114·102 2.701·101 tmed 7.013·102 5.088·102 4.079·102 3.092·102 1.831·102 8.730·101 2.093·101 tstd 1.037·102 9.948·101 8.724·101 5.945·101 7.037·101 5.069·101 1.605·101
18
Table 33: Compleib system ROC2, 9 states, QN method.
γ/ k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 4.141·10−2 4.131·10−2 4.127·10−2 4.129·10−2 4.130·10−2 4.134·10−2 5.998·10−2 - -+5% - - - 4.253·10−2 1.719·10−1 -+10% - - - 7.333·10−2 -+20% - - - 5.426·10−2 -+35% - - - 5.545·10−2 5.943·10−2 +50% - - - 7.823·10−2 +100% - - - 7.554·10−2 +200% - - - 9.672·10−2 +400% - - - 1.342·10−1 +900% - - - 2.391·10−1 t [s] +0% 1.470·101 2.964·101 1.158·101 1.430·101 1.433·101 2.736·101 +5% 8.266 2.923·101 +10% 2.945·101 +20% 2.906·101 +35% 1.005·101 2.922·101 +50% 3.069·101 +100% 3.128·101 +200% 2.913·101 +400% 2.916·101 +900% 2.906·101 Total: 3.965·102 sTable 34: Compleib system ROC2, 9 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 1 4.568·10−2 4.430·10−2 4.592·10−2 4.486·10−2 4.699·10−2 5.050·10−2 5.071·10−2 2.843 2 5.469·10−2 4.368·10−2 4.537·10−2 4.526·10−2 4.423·10−2 4.523·10−2 4.812·10−1 2.843 3 4.311·10−2 4.413·10−2 4.536·10−2 5.263·10−2 4.424·10−2 4.870·10−2 5.056·10−2 2.841 4 5.844·10−2 4.478·10−2 4.826·10−2 4.353·10−2 4.932·10−2 5.055·10−2 5.138·10−2 2.843 5 5.652·10−2 4.660·10−2 5.020·10−2 5.496·10−2 4.638·10−2 5.046·10−2 5.057·10−2 2.842 6 4.402·10−2 4.293·10−2 5.095·10−2 4.473·10−2 4.548·10−2 5.037·10−2 5.066·10−2 2.843 7 4.429·10−2 4.980·10−2 5.062·10−2 5.096·10−2 5.392·10−2 4.990·10−2 5.247·10−2 2.841 8 4.806·10−2 4.341·10−2 4.897·10−2 5.576·10−2 2.777 4.580·10−2 5.253·10−2 2.842 9 4.468·10−2 4.260·10−2 4.280·10−2 4.302·10−2 4.283·10−2 4.687·10−2 5.056·10−2 2.842 10 5.094·10−2 4.392·10−2 5.523·10−2 4.460·10−2 8.898·10−2 5.068·10−2 5.056·10−2 2.842 min 4.311·10−2 4.260·10−2 4.280·10−2 4.302·10−2 4.283·10−2 4.523·10−2 5.056·10−2 2.841 max 5.844·10−2 4.980·10−2 5.523·10−2 5.576·10−2 2.777 5.068·10−2 4.812·10−1 2.843 mean 4.904·10−2 4.461·10−2 4.837·10−2 4.803·10−2 3.239·10−1 4.890·10−2 9.412·10−2 2.842 med 4.687·10−2 4.402·10−2 4.861·10−2 4.506·10−2 4.669·10−2 5.014·10−2 5.068·10−2 2.842 std 5.715·10−3 2.131·10−3 3.614·10−3 4.980·10−3 8.620·10−1 2.142·10−3 1.360·10−1 9.078·10−4 t [s] tmin 8.297·102 1.630·102 4.775·102 4.111·102 2.517·102 1.031·102 1.468·102 3.500·101 tmax 1.060·103 9.081·102 7.824·102 6.475·102 6.432·102 4.822·102 3.661·102 1.098·102 tmean 1.004·103 7.588·102 6.637·102 5.587·102 4.926·102 3.613·102 3.025·102 6.415·101 tmed 1.028·103 8.772·102 7.188·102 5.678·102 5.062·102 3.863·102 3.322·102 5.731·101 tstd 6.933·101 2.469·102 1.024·102 7.337·101 1.055·102 1.049·102 7.094·101 2.255·101
19
Table 35: Compleib system ROC3, 9 states, QN method.
γ/ k 8 7 6 5 4 4.650·101 4.660·101 - - - -+5% 4.868·101 4.869·101 4.868·101 3.940·101 -+10% - - - 1.338·102 -+20% - - - 1.029·103 -+35% - - - 1.834·102 -+50% - - - 2.591·102 -+100% - - - 2.680·102 -+200% - - - 1.246·102 4.962·102 +400% - - - - 7.798·102 +900% - - - - 5.280·102 t [s] +0% 1.762·102 +5% 1.547·102 4.025·101 3.133·101 1.567·102 +10% 1.527·102 +20% 1.517·102 +35% 1.511·102 +50% 1.514·102 +100% 1.510·102 +200% 6.613·101 1.545·102 +400% 1.515·102 +900% 1.517·102 Total: 1.841·103 sTable 36: Compleib system ROC3, 9 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 1.508·103 7.609·102 3.610·104 3.661·103 3.386·104 1.104·104 3.831·104 2 9.928·103 1.429·104 6.921·102 1.288·103 6.654·104 2.249·106 1.330·104 3 9.474·102 1.405·104 6.378·102 1.540·103 3.597·103 1.902·105 4.589·101 4 4.059·103 2.646·104 3.266·103 3.266·103 2.464·104 2.464·104 8.420·102 5 6.103·102 8.961·103 2.005·104 9.345·102 5.771·103 1.612·105 8.539·101 6 4.206·104 9.315·104 1.756·104 3.783·103 1.583·105 1.378·104 1.248·103 7 4.617·102 4.920·102 6.810·101 5.387·103 1.870·101 1.059·104 2.178·101 8 9.380·102 1.508·104 1.104·104 1.293·103 3.469·102 3.053·106 1.384·103 9 1.811·103 9.735·102 1.422·103 4.533·105 9.741·103 2.731·107 8.750·103 10 5.150·103 9.563·102 3.180·104 1.931·103 4.152·103 1.141·104 3.574·102 min 4.617·102 4.920·102 6.810·101 9.345·102 1.870·101 1.059·104 2.178·101 max 4.206·104 9.315·104 3.610·104 4.533·105 1.583·105 2.731·107 3.831·104 mean 6.747·103 1.752·104 1.226·104 4.764·104 3.070·104 3.303·106 6.434·103 med 1.660·103 1.150·104 7.155·103 2.598·103 7.756·103 9.291·104 1.045·103 std 1.275·104 2.793·104 1.357·104 1.425·105 4.941·104 8.504·106 1.207·104 t [s] tmin 7.469·102 4.797·102 1.107·102 1.558·102 7.803·101 3.466·101 1.828 tmax 1.144·103 1.089·103 7.495·102 6.001·102 4.434·102 3.835·102 2.201·102 tmean 9.698·102 8.395·102 6.013·102 5.001·102 3.769·102 2.766·102 8.068·101 tmed 9.933·102 8.742·102 6.710·102 5.564·102 4.133·102 3.141·102 3.525·101 tstd 1.228·102 1.681·102 1.853·102 1.388·102 1.112·102 1.172·102 9.510·101
20
Table 37: Compleib system ROC4, 8 states, QN method.
γ/ k 7 6 0.000 ∞ -+5% ∞ -+10% ∞ -+20% ∞ -+35% ∞ -+50% 2.397·101 7.173 +100% - 9.131·101 +200% - 4.835·101 +400% - 7.325·101 +900% - 1.707·102 t [s] +0% 1.547 +5% 1.547 +10% 1.563 +20% 1.547 +35% 1.578 +50% 2.002·101 1.967·101 +100% 1.983·101 +200% 1.889·101 +400% 1.891·101 +900% 1.881·101 Total: 1.239·102 sTable 38: Compleib system ROC4, 8 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 1 1.324·102 2.029·102 1.279·102 2.268·102 2.662·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 2 2.217·102 2.137·102 2.570·102 2.725·102 2.661·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 3 1.046·102 2.239·102 2.143·102 2.357·102 2.662·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 4 2.241·102 2.056·102 2.333·102 2.304·102 2.705·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 5 1.679·102 1.244·102 2.078·102 2.539·102 2.684·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 6 1.521·102 2.261·102 1.799·102 2.658·102 2.730·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 7 1.424·102 2.651·102 2.294·102 2.543·102 2.741·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 8 2.486·102 2.231·102 2.313·102 2.260·102 2.704·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 9 2.359·102 2.290·102 2.311·102 2.438·102 2.698·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 10 2.306·102 2.003·102 1.380·102 2.323·102 2.661·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 min 1.046·102 1.244·102 1.279·102 2.260·102 2.661·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 max 2.486·102 2.651·102 2.570·102 2.725·102 2.741·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 mean 1.860·102 2.114·102 2.050·102 2.441·102 2.691·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 med 1.948·102 2.184·102 2.218·102 2.397·102 2.691·102 3.022·102 6.294·102 std 5.162·101 3.576·101 4.299·101 1.668·101 2.983 5.406·10−3 9.044·10−5 t [s] tmin 4.820·102 3.840·102 3.439·102 2.659·102 2.011·102 5.623·101 2.503·101 tmax 7.125·102 5.723·102 4.580·102 3.963·102 3.193·102 2.038·102 1.421·102 tmean 5.934·102 4.812·102 4.087·102 3.175·102 2.616·102 1.149·102 9.419·101 tmed 5.833·102 4.898·102 4.087·102 3.138·102 2.616·102 9.173·101 1.199·102 tstd 7.418·101 5.324·101 3.419·101 3.646·101 3.935·101 5.372·101 4.818·101
21
Table 39: Compleib system ROC5, 6 states, QN method.
γ/ k 5 4 3 2 1 4.976·10−5 6.527·10−6 1.374·10−5 2.425·10−5 3.609·10−5 1.723·10−5 t [s] +0% 7.125 5.484 5.359 6.438 5.531 Total: 2.994·101 sTable 40: Compleib system ROC5, 6 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 5 4 3 2 1 1 1.114·10−2 1.923·10−3 3.585·10−3 3.613·10−4 4.482·10−3 2 6.957·10−3 2.272·10−4 2.505·10−3 4.856·10−3 3.531·10−3 3 3.287·10−3 3.321·10−3 2.565·10−3 4.097·10−3 4.586·10−3 4 3.303·10−3 2.082·10−3 2.382·10−3 3.014·10−3 9.668·10−3 5 3.366·10−3 4.568·10−3 2.783·10−3 2.112·10−3 2.087·10−3 6 2.102·10−3 4.080·10−3 2.342·10−3 6.908·10−3 5.002·10−3 7 2.582·10−3 5.344·10−3 4.856·10−3 3.051·10−3 5.672·10−3 8 3.397·10−3 3.345·10−3 2.802·10−3 1.042·10−2 2.129·10−4 9 1.306·10−2 2.932·10−3 3.625·10−3 2.732·10−3 6.713·10−3 10 4.422·10−3 3.801·10−3 4.568·10−3 2.768·10−3 4.217·10−3 min 2.102·10−3 2.272·10−4 2.342·10−3 3.613·10−4 2.129·10−4 max 1.306·10−2 5.344·10−3 4.856·10−3 1.042·10−2 9.668·10−3 mean 5.362·10−3 3.162·10−3 3.201·10−3 4.032·10−3 4.617·10−3 med 3.381·10−3 3.333·10−3 2.792·10−3 3.032·10−3 4.534·10−3 std 3.813·10−3 1.469·10−3 9.168·10−4 2.833·10−3 2.546·10−3 t [s] tmin 1.267·102 6.198·101 5.492·101 4.292·101 2.898·101 tmax 5.787·102 4.342·102 1.627·102 2.496·102 8.584·101 tmean 2.749·102 1.734·102 1.008·102 1.092·102 6.093·101 tmed 1.623·102 1.122·102 8.911·101 8.957·101 6.423·101 tstd 1.827·102 1.404·102 3.699·101 6.962·101 1.652·101
22
Table 41: Compleib system ROC6, 3 states, QN method.
γ/ k 2 2.160·101 2.155·101 t [s] +0% 2.656 Total: 2.656 sTable 42: Compleib system ROC6, 3 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 2 1 2.255·101 2 2.168·101 3 2.154·101 4 2.161·101 5 2.158·101 6 2.154·101 7 2.162·101 8 6.020·101 9 2.155·101 10 2.155·101 min 2.154·101 max 6.020·101 mean 2.554·101 med 2.159·101 std 1.218·101 t [s] tmin 6.628·101 tmax 2.288·102 tmean 1.117·102 tmed 1.057·102 tstd 4.459·101
23
Table 43: Compleib system ROC7, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 1 1.125 1.125 1.125 1.125 t [s] +0% 2.922 2.875 2.875 Total: 8.672 sTable 44: Compleib system ROC7, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 1 1.122 1.122 1.123 2 1.122 1.122 1.122 3 1.122 1.122 1.123 4 1.122 1.122 1.122 5 1.122 1.122 1.122 6 1.122 1.122 1.122 7 1.122 1.122 1.123 8 1.122 1.122 1.123 9 1.122 1.122 1.122 10 1.122 1.121 1.122 min 1.122 1.121 1.122 max 1.122 1.122 1.123 mean 1.122 1.122 1.122 med 1.122 1.122 1.122 std 1.561·10−4 2.494·10−4 2.315·10−4 t [s] tmin 2.314·101 2.819·101 2.266·101 tmax 8.064·101 6.434·101 5.703·101 tmean 5.649·101 4.882·101 3.756·101 tmed 5.823·101 4.650·101 3.787·101 tstd 1.535·101 1.105·101 1.219·101
24
Table 45: Compleib system ROC8, 6 states, QN method.
γ/ k 5 4 3 3.488 3.487 1.328·101 -+5% - 4.189 -+10% - 4.321 -+20% - 4.165 4.136 t [s] +0% 3.688 1.405·101 +5% 1.166·101 +10% 9.969 +20% 4.172 4.281 Total: 4.781·101 sTable 46: Compleib system ROC8, 6 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 5 4 3 1 3.542 3.664 3.759 2 3.597 3.680 3.761 3 3.573 3.774 3.761 4 3.538 3.554 3.760 5 3.842 3.555 4.460 6 3.552 3.560 3.762 7 3.589 3.549 5.379·103 8 3.580 3.558 6.328 9 3.548 3.556 3.760 10 3.527 3.530 3.887 min 3.527 3.530 3.759 max 3.842 3.774 5.379·103 mean 3.589 3.598 5.416·102 med 3.563 3.557 3.762 std 9.203·10−2 7.989·10−2 1.700·103 t [s] tmin 3.720·102 1.081·102 8.294·101 tmax 6.263·102 5.212·102 2.256·102 tmean 4.807·102 3.463·102 1.789·102 tmed 4.505·102 3.424·102 1.965·102 tstd 8.351·101 1.109·102 5.156·101
25
Table 47: Compleib system ROC9, 4 states, QN method.
γ/ k 3 2 2.241 2.241 9.112 +5% - 9.704·101 +10% - 2.259·101 +20% - 9.091 +35% - 2.220·101 +50% - 1.013·101 +100% - 4.321 t [s] +0% 3.438 6.750 +5% 6.375 +10% 6.172 +20% 6.125 +35% 6.141 +50% 4.734 +100% 2.656 Total: 4.239·101 sTable 48: Compleib system ROC9, 4 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 3 2 1 2.277 3.577 2 3.041 3.597 3 3.248 3.585 4 2.311 3.576 5 2.494 3.576 6 2.639 3.576 7 2.282 3.590 8 2.380 3.586 9 2.281 3.589 10 2.369 3.584 min 2.277 3.576 max 3.248 3.597 mean 2.532 3.584 med 2.374 3.585 std 3.453·10−1 7.222·10−3 t [s] tmin 1.251·102 5.823·101 tmax 3.647·102 2.729·102 tmean 2.570·102 2.097·102 tmed 2.570·102 2.369·102 tstd 8.071·101 7.012·101
26
Table 49: Compleib system ROC10, 5 states, QN method.
γ/ k 4 3 2 1 7.561·10−2 7.534·10−2 7.559·10−2 7.548·10−2 7.542·10−2 t [s] +0% 5.781 6.141 5.828 5.141 Total: 2.289·101 sTable 50: Compleib system ROC10, 5 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 4 3 2 1 1 8.274·10−2 9.099·10−2 8.027·10−2 9.088·10−2 2 9.180·10−2 8.691·10−2 8.617·10−2 9.121·10−2 3 7.724·10−2 8.663·10−2 8.846·10−2 9.973·10−2 4 9.283·10−2 8.920·10−2 7.877·10−2 9.875·10−2 5 8.800·10−2 7.687·10−2 8.062·10−2 1.034·10−1 6 7.771·10−2 1.016·10−1 8.815·10−2 1.261·10−1 7 8.125·10−2 8.584·10−2 8.481·10−2 9.578·10−2 8 8.113·10−2 8.182·10−2 8.552·10−2 1.041·10−1 9 7.928·10−2 8.029·10−2 9.968·10−2 9.053·10−2 10 8.650·10−2 8.426·10−2 8.799·10−2 9.202·10−2 min 7.724·10−2 7.687·10−2 7.877·10−2 9.053·10−2 max 9.283·10−2 1.016·10−1 9.968·10−2 1.261·10−1 mean 8.385·10−2 8.644·10−2 8.605·10−2 9.925·10−2 med 8.199·10−2 8.624·10−2 8.585·10−2 9.726·10−2 std 5.635·10−3 6.779·10−3 5.942·10−3 1.073·10−2 t [s] tmin 8.180·101 8.992·101 6.042·101 3.516·101 tmax 1.793·102 2.414·102 1.980·102 1.039·102 tmean 1.261·102 1.339·102 1.088·102 6.135·101 tmed 1.204·102 1.250·102 1.002·102 5.826·101 tstd 2.937·101 4.278·101 3.889·101 2.278·101
27
Table 51: Compleib system NN11, 16 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 2.791·10−2 2.775·10−2 1.058·10−1 - - - -+5% - 3.534·10−2 - - - -+10% - 3.055·10−2 3.082·10−2 - - - -+20% - - 3.329·10−2 3.320·10−2 3.538·10−2 - - - -+35% - - - - 5.616·10−2 - - - -+50% - - - - 4.189·10−2 - - - -+100% - - - - 5.496·10−2 5.464·10−2 5.472·10−2 5.494·10−2 5.507·10−2 1.682·10−1 -+200% - - - 8.362·10−2 2.238·10−1 +400% - - - 1.361·10−1 t [s] +0% 1.800·102 1.949·102 +5% 1.807·102 +10% 1.796·102 1.851·102 +20% 1.152·102 1.248·102 1.836·102 +35% 1.791·102 +50% 1.810·102 +100% 5.891·101 6.867·101 5.238·101 5.225·101 6.513·101 1.779·102 +200% 1.254·102 1.783·102 +400% 7.631·101 Total: 2.559·103 sTable 52: Compleib system NN11, 16 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.147·10−2 3.446·10−2 3.352·10−2 3.646·10−2 3.426·10−2 4.842·10−2 4.549·10−2 4.459·10−2 4.659·10−2 1.017·10−1 1.072·10−1 2 2.778·10−2 2.670·10−2 2.606·10−2 2.457·10−2 3.139·10−2 3.145·10−2 2.693·10−2 4.227·10−2 1.001·10−1 9.849·10−2 1.090·10−1 3 2.484·10−2 2.998·10−2 2.850·10−2 3.152·10−2 3.295·10−2 3.224·10−2 4.286·10−2 3.811·10−2 9.839·10−2 1.001·10−1 1.076·10−1 4 2.647·10−2 3.440·10−2 5.722·10−2 3.674·10−2 4.246·10−2 3.349·10−2 3.612·10−2 4.707·10−2 4.661·10−2 9.786·10−2 1.054·10−1 5 3.373·10−2 2.396·10−2 3.677·10−2 3.334·10−2 3.738·10−2 2.933·10−2 3.438·10−2 5.747·10−2 5.227·10−2 1.013·10−1 1.083·10−1 6 2.312·10−2 3.530·10−2 3.695·10−2 2.831·10−2 3.692·10−2 3.088·10−2 3.166·10−2 3.964·10−2 9.558·10−2 1.028·10−1 1.071·10−1 7 3.608·10−2 2.995·10−2 2.744·10−2 3.043·10−2 2.954·10−2 5.417·10−2 4.290·10−2 5.319·10−2 4.700·10−2 1.023·10−1 1.073·10−1 8 3.686·10−2 3.218·10−2 2.814·10−2 3.304·10−2 3.462·10−2 3.364·10−2 4.060·10−2 4.800·10−2 9.915·10−2 1.028·10−1 1.068·10−1 9 2.831·10−2 3.529·10−2 3.102·10−2 3.638·10−2 2.577·10−2 3.358·10−2 3.475·10−2 4.451·10−2 4.856·10−2 9.937·10−2 1.026·10−1 10 3.110·10−2 2.630·10−2 2.612·10−2 3.696·10−2 2.958·10−2 2.679·10−2 3.807·10−2 4.201·10−2 4.766·10−2 1.024·10−1 1.080·10−1 min 2.147·10−2 2.396·10−2 2.606·10−2 2.457·10−2 2.577·10−2 2.679·10−2 2.693·10−2 3.811·10−2 4.659·10−2 9.786·10−2 1.026·10−1 max 3.686·10−2 3.530·10−2 5.722·10−2 3.696·10−2 4.246·10−2 5.417·10−2 4.549·10−2 5.747·10−2 1.001·10−1 1.028·10−1 1.090·10−1 mean 2.898·10−2 3.085·10−2 3.317·10−2 3.278·10−2 3.349·10−2 3.540·10−2 3.738·10−2 4.569·10−2 6.819·10−2 1.009·10−1 1.069·10−1 med 2.805·10−2 3.108·10−2 2.976·10−2 3.319·10−2 3.361·10−2 3.286·10−2 3.710·10−2 4.455·10−2 5.042·10−2 1.015·10−1 1.072·10−1 std 5.330·10−3 4.133·10−3 9.371·10−3 4.145·10−3 4.766·10−3 8.748·10−3 5.739·10−3 6.002·10−3 2.599·10−2 1.827·10−3 1.808·10−3 t [s] tmin 2.697·102 2.099·102 1.253·102 1.849·102 1.599·102 9.969·101 6.448·101 1.703·101 3.828 2.828 1.313 tmax 9.755·102 4.903·102 1.340·103 4.993·102 3.548·102 3.338·102 2.520·102 1.833·102 1.220·102 5.109 1.438 tmean 4.585·102 3.114·102 5.318·102 2.522·102 2.415·102 2.071·102 1.542·102 1.112·102 5.081·101 3.841 1.352 tmed 3.302·102 2.968·102 3.883·102 2.286·102 2.278·102 2.066·102 1.406·102 1.228·102 5.539·101 3.688 1.344 tstd 2.419·102 7.888·101 4.006·102 9.051·101 5.827·101 5.664·101 5.640·101 4.584·101 4.465·101 7.983·10−1 3.845·10−2
28
Table 53: Compleib system REA3, 12 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.664·101 - - - -+5% - - 7.594·101 9.198·101 - - - -+10% - - - 7.817·101 7.425·101 7.461·101 7.440·101 7.426·101 7.609·101 7.433·101 7.509·101 t [s] +0% 9.188·101 1.238·102 2.269·102 +5% 2.898·102 3.465·102 +10% 3.431·102 2.909·102 9.102·101 8.939·101 1.065·102 1.263·102 1.022·102 2.919·102 Total: 2.520·103 sTable 54: Compleib system REA3, 12 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 2 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 3 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 4 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 5 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 6 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 8 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 9 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 10 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 min 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 max 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 mean 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 med 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 7.425·101 std 2.050·10−2 6.386·10−2 3.344·10−2 1.739·10−2 1.658·10−2 3.543·10−2 1.552·10−2 4.889·10−2 5.637·10−2 1.193·10−2 1.288·10−2 t [s] tmin 2.109 1.500 2.141 1.500 1.828 1.547 1.844 1.844 1.828 1.516 1.469 tmax 3.500 8.984 6.031 6.719 1.834·101 5.438 5.200·101 1.545·101 3.828 1.788·101 2.281 tmean 2.823 3.833 3.223 3.100 4.552 3.169 8.252 3.822 2.570 3.484 1.870 tmed 2.742 3.547 2.836 2.813 3.180 2.820 2.211 2.133 2.508 1.836 1.766 tstd 5.123·10−1 2.197 1.325 1.410 4.895 1.297 1.577·101 4.169 6.498·10−1 5.061 3.083·10−1
29
Table 55: Compleib system CM1, 20 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 8.174·10−1 8.181·10−1 - - - -+5% 8.247·10−1 8.315·10−1 8.334·10−1 8.199·10−1 8.418·10−1 8.315·10−1 8.411·10−1 8.397·10−1 8.376·10−1 8.191·10−1 8.231·10−1 t [s] +0% 6.685·102 +5% 6.305·102 6.230·102 4.738·102 7.424·102 2.520·102 7.911·102 2.273·102 2.825·102 6.237·102 1.781·102 1.420·102 Total: 5.635·103 sTable 56: Compleib system CM1, 20 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 2 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 3 8.166·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 4 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 5 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 6 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 7 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8 8.165·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 9 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 10 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 min 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 max 8.166·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.166·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 mean 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 med 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 8.165·10−1 std 3.158·10−5 2.031·10−5 2.222·10−5 1.080·10−5 2.229·10−5 1.128·10−5 3.490·10−6 2.273·10−8 2.277·10−7 1.433·10−8 1.246·10−8 t [s] tmin 1.017·102 7.323·101 5.803·101 6.336·101 3.939·101 5.944·101 2.569·101 2.384·101 1.258·101 1.561·101 9.063 tmax 9.047·102 1.911·103 1.131·103 3.738·102 2.260·102 4.531·102 2.570·102 1.438·102 2.102·102 4.698·101 1.838·101 tmean 4.514·102 3.994·102 2.857·102 1.295·102 1.183·102 1.209·102 8.596·101 5.645·101 4.653·101 2.538·101 1.534·101 tmed 4.204·102 2.489·102 2.114·102 8.777·101 1.133·102 7.507·101 6.777·101 4.291·101 2.531·101 2.427·101 1.602·101 tstd 2.414·102 5.430·102 3.057·102 1.004·102 6.638·101 1.194·102 6.703·101 3.486·101 5.920·101 9.546 2.592
30
Table 57: Compleib system EB4, 20 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1.799 4.671 - - - -+5% 2.407 - - - -+10% 1.952 1.932 2.305 - - - -+20% - - 2.066 1.990 2.059 2.055 2.053 2.047 2.057 2.030 2.423 +35% - - - 2.454 +50% - - - 2.323 t [s] +0% 6.461·102 +5% 6.328·102 +10% 5.777·102 1.990·102 6.297·102 +20% 1.676·102 1.859·102 1.740·102 5.517·102 1.744·102 1.918·102 1.851·102 1.674·102 6.432·102 +35% 6.473·102 +50% 6.469·102 Total: 6.421·103 sTable 58: Compleib system EB4, 20 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 1.804 1.804 1.803 1.804 1.804 1.811 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 2 1.803 1.806 1.803 1.807 1.803 1.805 1.813 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 3 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.807 1.814 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 4 1.803 1.804 1.802 1.803 1.807 1.804 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 5 1.803 1.804 1.803 1.804 1.805 1.804 1.809 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 6 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.803 1.804 1.806 1.810 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 7 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.808 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 8 1.804 1.803 1.804 1.804 1.805 1.807 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 9 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.803 1.806 1.807 1.809 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 10 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.805 1.807 1.815 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 min 1.803 1.803 1.802 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.809 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 max 1.804 1.806 1.804 1.807 1.807 1.811 1.815 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 mean 1.803 1.804 1.803 1.804 1.805 1.806 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 med 1.803 1.803 1.803 1.804 1.805 1.807 1.811 1.818 1.865 1.905 2.056 std 4.976·10−4 9.106·10−4 4.427·10−4 1.100·10−3 9.878·10−4 2.166·10−3 2.056·10−3 1.179·10−4 3.640·10−5 8.447·10−8 5.076 t [s] tmin 4.275·102 3.742·102 3.804·102 1.921·102 1.873·102 1.208·102 9.316·101 8.686·101 3.139·101 1.272·101 7.969·10−1 tmax 2.037·103 1.416·103 1.573·103 1.159·103 1.013·103 5.963·102 3.013·102 2.428·102 8.130·101 4.088·101 1.563 tmean 1.070·103 8.152·102 8.691·102 4.766·102 5.172·102 4.024·102 1.710·102 1.566·102 4.851·101 2.413·101 1.172 tmed 1.017·103 6.692·102 9.168·102 4.129·102 4.416·102 4.463·102 1.733·102 1.397·102 4.845·101 2.045·101 1.109 tstd 5.357·102 4.472·102 3.897·102 3.030·102 2.920·102 1.540·102 6.116·101 5.928·101 1.432·101 8.758 2.739·10−1
31
Table 59: Compleib system HE6, 20 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 2.388 2.388 4.139·101 - - - -+5% - 2.425 2.433 2.441 4.218·102 - - - -+10% - - - - 8.183·101 - - - -+20% - - - - 2.864 4.440·102 - - -+35% - - - 3.553·102 - - -+50% - - - 4.117·102 - - -+100% - - - 4.749 4.342·102 - -+200% - - - 6.969 5.389·102 -+400% - - - 4.341·102 -+900% - - - 1.895·101 5.075·102 t [s] +0% 8.080·102 7.829·102 +5% 2.282·102 3.562·102 2.432·102 7.305·102 +10% 7.557·102 +20% 3.054·102 7.493·102 +35% 7.459·102 +50% 7.302·102 +100% 3.399·102 7.341·102 +200% 2.847·102 7.451·102 +400% 7.385·102 +900% 2.102·102 7.610·102 Total: 1.025·104 sTable 60: Compleib system HE6, 20 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.500 6.135 2.784 6.604 7.075 1.126·101 2.531·101 1.249·101 1.729·101 1.878·102 1.927·102 2 4.096 3.385 2.995 2.631 4.083 5.228 1.085·101 1.795·101 1.863·102 1.875·102 1.924·102 3 4.231 4.364 2.894 5.022 4.815 1.172·101 9.457 1.408·101 2.212·101 1.884·102 1.924·102 4 5.296 2.495 2.437 2.840·101 6.803 1.673·101 8.576 1.001·101 1.550·101 1.902·102 1.924·102 5 2.473 4.340 3.050 4.228 4.477 7.775 1.003·101 1.002·101 2.747·101 1.874·102 1.926·102 6 2.454 2.457 3.727 4.647 4.351 8.621 4.737 1.002·101 1.882·102 1.875·102 1.924·102 7 3.420 3.425 2.826 3.041 3.893 1.060·101 1.434·101 1.002·101 2.564·101 1.902·102 1.974·102 8 4.808 2.613 3.657 3.656 4.415 3.909 6.282 1.856·101 1.871·101 1.878·102 2.030·102 9 2.546 2.540 3.557 6.131 3.876 5.080 8.294 1.004·101 1.651·101 1.875·102 1.924·102 10 3.367 2.907 4.515 4.736 2.778 1.383·101 8.385 1.456·101 4.864·101 1.877·102 1.947·102 min 2.454 2.457 2.437 2.631 2.778 3.909 4.737 1.001·101 1.550·101 1.874·102 1.924·102 max 5.296 6.135 4.515 2.840·101 7.075 1.673·101 2.531·101 1.856·101 1.882·102 1.902·102 2.030·102 mean 3.519 3.466 3.244 6.910 4.657 9.476 1.063·101 1.278·101 5.664·101 1.882·102 1.942·102 med 3.394 3.146 3.023 4.692 4.383 9.612 9.016 1.127·101 2.388·101 1.877·102 1.925·102 std 1.049 1.181 6.125·10−1 7.653 1.321 4.125 5.767 3.384 6.951·101 1.090 3.492 t [s] tmin 1.560·103 1.547·103 1.410·103 1.318·103 1.340·103 1.139·103 1.014·103 8.804·102 6.326·102 4.134·102 1.041·102 tmax 2.379·103 2.112·103 1.754·103 1.783·103 1.756·103 1.522·103 1.296·103 1.048·103 8.060·102 5.598·102 4.514·102 tmean 1.833·103 1.660·103 1.612·103 1.550·103 1.557·103 1.343·103 1.148·103 9.504·102 7.566·102 5.027·102 3.363·102 tmed 1.774·103 1.632·103 1.643·103 1.564·103 1.551·103 1.348·103 1.157·103 9.518·102 7.744·102 5.059·102 3.560·102 tstd 2.230·102 1.660·102 1.158·102 1.464·102 1.336·102 1.265·102 1.013·102 5.277·101 5.278·101 4.575·101 1.009·102
32
Table 61: Compleib system HE7, 20 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 2.614 6.602·102 - - - -+5% 2.668 2.665 2.692 2.688 4.435·102 - - - -+10% - - - - 4.850·101 - - - -+20% - - - - 3.109 4.359·102 - - -+35% - - - 3.459 4.795·102 - -+50% - - - 5.227·102 - -+100% - - - 1.661·102 - -+200% - - - 7.668 5.142·102 -+400% - - - 3.217·102 -+900% - - - 2.289·101 6.740·102 t [s] +0% 8.642·102 +5% 3.720·102 2.373·102 2.472·102 3.202·102 8.680·102 +10% 8.574·102 +20% 3.630·102 8.840·102 +35% 8.212·102 8.687·102 +50% 8.868·102 +100% 9.293·102 +200% 3.541·102 9.130·102 +400% 8.572·102 +900% 3.115·102 9.311·102 Total: 1.189·104 sTable 62: Compleib system HE7, 20 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 3.292 2.646 4.052 4.653 8.876 1.719·101 1.633·101 1.086·101 4.879·101 1.889·102 1.924·102 2 2.670 4.388 2.678 3.783 1.063·101 5.871 3.636·101 1.083·101 2.736·101 1.908·102 1.924·102 3 3.273 2.648 4.100 3.489 4.377 7.686 1.120·101 1.084·101 4.565·101 1.907·102 1.928·102 4 3.870 2.628 2.659 4.502 6.977 4.241 3.157·101 3.839·101 2.779·101 1.875·102 1.926·102 5 2.659 2.635 2.734 3.508 1.168·101 6.902 1.220·101 1.084·101 2.561·101 1.877·102 1.924·102 6 3.026 8.301 2.902 2.272·101 6.032 1.230·101 7.822 1.961·101 2.655·101 1.913·102 1.924·102 7 2.674 4.573 7.273 1.121·101 4.881 2.984 1.769·101 1.163·101 2.791·101 1.877·102 1.924·102 8 2.634 4.718 4.125 1.754·101 5.002 4.971 9.518 1.118·101 2.838·101 2.089·102 1.966·102 9 2.664 4.119 3.566 4.290 7.151 3.036 1.114·101 1.896·101 3.764·101 1.875·102 1.924·102 10 1.281·101 8.476 4.936 2.759 7.229 1.987·101 8.820 1.771·101 3.432·101 1.875·102 1.924·102 min 2.634 2.628 2.659 2.759 4.377 2.984 7.822 1.083·101 2.561·101 1.875·102 1.924·102 max 1.281·101 8.476 7.273 2.272·101 1.168·101 1.987·101 3.636·101 3.839·101 4.879·101 2.089·102 1.966·102 mean 3.957 4.513 3.903 7.846 7.284 8.506 1.627·101 1.609·101 3.300·101 1.909·102 1.929·102 med 2.850 4.254 3.809 4.396 7.064 6.386 1.170·101 1.141·101 2.814·101 1.883·102 1.924·102 std 3.137 2.219 1.417 6.998 2.455 5.966 9.893 8.658 8.399 6.519 1.302 t [s] tmin 1.634·103 1.746·103 1.000·103 1.371·103 1.365·103 1.266·103 1.184·103 9.352·102 7.236·102 5.005·102 8.825·101 tmax 2.152·103 2.047·103 1.848·103 1.747·103 1.630·103 1.684·103 1.427·103 1.201·103 9.884·102 6.495·102 5.150·102 tmean 1.882·103 1.838·103 1.672·103 1.633·103 1.488·103 1.490·103 1.318·103 1.044·103 8.363·102 5.651·102 2.889·102 tmed 1.858·103 1.840·103 1.750·103 1.702·103 1.467·103 1.501·103 1.333·103 1.055·103 8.372·102 5.499·102 2.731·102 tstd 1.442·102 8.485·101 2.505·102 1.366·102 9.263·101 1.384·102 7.395·101 7.712·101 8.540·101 5.409·101 1.664·102
33
Table 63: Compleib system JE3, 24 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0.000 ∞ - - - -+5% 2.937 2.950 2.938 2.936 2.939 2.943 2.970 3.051 - - -+10% - - - 3.111 3.181 - -+20% - - - 3.292 3.557 -+35% - - - 3.736 1.250·101 +50% - - - 1.302·101 +100% - - - 1.242·101 +200% - - - 1.127·101 +400% - - - 9.624 t [s] +0% 1.747·101 +5% 1.157·103 1.117·103 1.127·103 1.140·103 4.933·102 7.660·102 5.185·102 1.139·103 +10% 1.205·103 1.068·103 +20% 1.075·103 1.082·103 +35% 1.081·103 1.072·103 +50% 1.078·103 +100% 1.083·103 +200% 1.083·103 +400% 1.080·103 Total: 1.838·104 sTable 64: Compleib system JE3, 24 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.889 2.889 2.891 2.901 2.915 3.134 5.096 2 2.889 2.889 2.889 2.889 2.888 2.890 2.889 2.890 2.907 3.115 5.096 3 2.891 2.889 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.895 2.896 2.900 3.114 5.096 4 2.888 2.888 2.889 2.889 2.889 2.888 2.892 2.892 2.896 3.115 5.096 5 2.897 2.887 2.892 2.889 2.888 2.889 2.889 2.894 2.897 3.114 5.096 6 2.896 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.889 2.890 2.897 2.932 3.115 5.096 7 2.894 2.889 2.889 2.888 2.895 2.889 2.891 2.895 2.896 3.116 5.536 8 2.888 2.888 2.887 2.900 2.890 2.890 2.895 2.896 2.905 3.114 5.096 9 2.891 2.888 2.888 2.890 2.889 2.888 2.896 2.892 2.898 3.131 5.096 10 2.889 2.898 2.889 2.889 2.888 2.888 2.889 2.896 2.897 3.114 5.096 min 2.888 2.887 2.887 2.888 2.888 2.888 2.889 2.890 2.896 3.114 5.096 max 2.897 2.898 2.892 2.900 2.895 2.890 2.896 2.901 2.932 3.134 5.536 mean 2.891 2.889 2.889 2.890 2.889 2.889 2.892 2.895 2.904 3.118 5.140 med 2.890 2.888 2.889 2.889 2.889 2.889 2.891 2.895 2.899 3.115 5.096 std 3.579·10−3 3.165·10−3 1.308·10−3 3.613·10−3 2.048·10−3 8.092·10−4 2.680·10−3 3.102·10−3 1.134·10−2 7.480·10−3 1.389·10−1 t [s] tmin 1.585·103 1.473·103 1.364·103 1.482·103 9.150·102 8.135·102 7.534·102 9.067·102 5.257·102 4.227·102 3.203·102 tmax 2.183·103 2.400·103 2.142·103 1.853·103 1.952·103 1.709·103 1.454·103 1.158·103 9.931·102 7.313·102 5.748·102 tmean 1.986·103 1.832·103 1.733·103 1.602·103 1.429·103 1.251·103 1.266·103 1.054·103 8.890·102 5.967·102 4.656·102 tmed 2.025·103 1.830·103 1.770·103 1.569·103 1.361·103 1.284·103 1.324·103 1.064·103 9.280·102 6.195·102 4.701·102 tstd 1.623·102 2.486·102 2.651·102 1.203·102 3.435·102 3.683·102 2.062·102 6.689·101 1.328·102 9.351·101 7.694·101
34
Table 65: Compleib system AGS, 12 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 8.174 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 t [s] +0% 2.568·102 2.598·102 6.481·101 7.980·101 6.219·101 5.181·101 5.444·101 4.948·101 4.942·101 4.925·101 4.450·101 Total: 1.022·103 sTable 66: Compleib system AGS, 12 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 2 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 3 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 4 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 5 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 6 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 7 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 9 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 10 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 min 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 max 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 mean 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 med 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 8.173 std 2.226·10−3 1.684·10−3 2.875·10−3 9.280·10−4 7.630·10−3 2.256·10−3 2.561·10−3 3.013·10−3 7.055·10−3 2.368·10−3 1.373·10−3 t [s] tmin 3.673·101 3.130·101 3.447·101 2.967·101 2.800·101 2.492·101 2.063·101 2.402·101 2.222·101 1.644·101 8.875 tmax 1.936·102 1.378·102 1.402·102 1.388·102 1.117·102 1.453·102 9.492·101 7.933·101 8.392·101 5.908·101 3.172·101 tmean 8.898·101 8.135·101 7.643·101 6.564·101 6.451·101 7.579·101 4.847·101 4.269·101 4.306·101 3.604·101 1.671·101 tmed 7.705·101 9.036·101 6.793·101 4.990·101 5.546·101 7.957·101 3.991·101 3.746·101 4.078·101 3.123·101 1.607·101 tstd 5.295·101 3.920·101 3.914·101 3.842·101 2.891·101 3.774·101 2.213·101 1.902·101 1.909·101 1.672·101 6.978
35
Table 67: Compleib system BDT1, 11 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 2.662·10−1 2.665·10−1 - - - -+5% 2.667·10−1 2.780·10−1 2.777·10−1 2.782·10−1 2.778·10−1 2.770·10−1 2.771·10−1 2.775·10−1 2.777·10−1 2.780·10−1 3.318·10−1 +10% - - - 3.003·10−1 +20% - - - 3.183·10−1 t [s] +0% 4.225·101 +5% 3.572·101 1.170·101 1.161·101 1.020·101 1.308·101 1.209·101 1.233·101 1.400·101 1.131·101 8.734 3.963·101 +10% 3.892·101 +20% 8.438 Total: 2.700·102 sTable 68: Compleib system BDT1, 11 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.663·10−1 2 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 3 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 4 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 5 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.663·10−1 6 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.663·10−1 7 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.663·10−1 8 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 9 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.665·10−1 10 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 min 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.663·10−1 max 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.665·10−1 mean 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 med 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.662·10−1 2.664·10−1 std 4.009·10−6 3.267·10−6 1.961·10−6 1.095·10−6 2.791·10−6 8.030·10−6 1.523·10−6 9.730·10−6 4.803·10−6 7.471·10−6 6.919·10−5 t [s] tmin 1.766 1.500 1.484 1.391 1.172 1.078 1.156 1.922 1.047 1.016 2.031·10−1 tmax 8.578 4.328 5.547 6.125 5.719 5.219 7.594 8.719 5.016 4.230·101 1.281 tmean 3.464 2.841 2.758 2.833 2.808 2.692 2.711 3.745 2.669 8.361 9.000·10−1 tmed 2.594 2.641 2.523 2.344 2.281 2.250 2.156 2.469 2.086 2.852 9.609·10−1 tstd 2.019 1.013 1.261 1.404 1.590 1.308 1.899 2.416 1.436 1.289·101 3.129·10−1
36
Table 69: Compleib system IH, 21 states, QN method.
γ/ k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 0.000 ∞ - - - -+5% ∞ - - - -+10% ∞ - - - -+20% ∞ - - - -+35% 2.639·10−4 2.902·10−4 3.605·10−4 2.265·10−4 2.112·10−4 2.093·10−4 1.594·10−4 1.817·10−4 2.296·10−4 5.762·10−4 4.498·10−4 t [s] +0% 8.266 +5% 8.313 +10% 8.328 +20% 8.328 +35% 9.425·102 1.040·103 1.035·103 1.026·103 1.026·103 3.743·102 3.644·102 3.860·102 3.963·102 2.882·102 2.553·102 Total: 7.167·103 sTable 70: Compleib system IH, 21 states, Hifoo, normal mode.
Run / k 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 1 1.624 1.505 1.572 1.472 1.456 1.713 1.670 1.045 1.179 1.600 1.450 2 1.405 4.266·10−1 1.358 1.490 1.510 1.387 9.698·10−1 1.536 1.527 6.568·10−1 9.593·10−1 3 1.511 1.257 1.127 1.353 1.217 6.765·10−1 1.520 1.233 1.143 1.810 5.692·10−1 4 4.064·10−1 1.440 7.515·10−1 1.664 1.425 1.472 7.995·10−1 1.136 1.270 1.056 5.013·10−1 5 1.577 1.373 1.508 1.252 1.352 1.372 1.469 3.266·10−1 1.270 1.907 1.521 6 1.540 1.324 1.362 1.359 1.462 1.550 1.417 1.557 1.337 1.462 1.361 7 7.824·10−1 2.478 1.521 1.138 1.272 1.382 9.269·10−1 1.244 4.819·10−1 1.340 1.377 8 1.529 1.633 9.943·10−1 1.673 1.340 1.408 1.588 1.374 1.521 1.545 1.429 9 1.582 1.032 1.401 1.121 1.534 1.952 1.417 1.624 1.568 1.540 1.294 10 1.725 1.431 1.269 1.163 1.421 1.342 6.406·10−1 1.362 1.377 1.445 1.596 min 4.064·10−1 4.266·10−1 7.515·10−1 1.121 1.217 6.765·10−1 6.406·10−1 3.266·10−1 4.819·10−1 6.568·10−1 5.013·10−1 max 1.725 2.478 1.572 1.673 1.534 1.952 1.670 1.624 1.568 1.907 1.596 mean 1.368 1.390 1.286 1.368 1.399 1.425 1.242 1.244 1.268 1.436 1.206 med 1.534 1.402 1.360 1.356 1.423 1.397 1.417 1.303 1.304 1.501 1.369 std 4.252·10−1 5.098·10−1 2.596·10−1 2.045·10−1 1.020·10−1 3.252·10−1 3.688·10−1 3.729·10−1 3.126·10−1 3.610·10−1 3.922·10−1 t [s] tmin 2.505·103 2.460·103 2.349·103 2.289·103 2.311·103 1.914·103 1.937·103 1.689·103 1.757·103 1.645·103 1.715·103 tmax 3.004·103 2.793·103 2.588·103 2.554·103 2.545·103 2.320·103 2.190·103 2.145·103 1.996·103 2.100·103 1.982·103 tmean 2.842·103 2.601·103 2.462·103 2.425·103 2.407·103 2.139·103 2.043·103 1.955·103 1.879·103 1.876·103 1.874·103 tmed 2.842·103 2.568·103 2.453·103 2.427·103 2.394·103 2.150·103 2.033·103 1.947·103 1.891·103 1.874·103 1.880·103 tstd 1.487·102 1.011·102 7.763·101 6.725·101 8.016·101 1.129·102 8.190·101 1.344·102 8.389·101 1.329·102 6.891·101
