The industry role in policymaking : Policy learning in climate politics

Full text

(1)Mälardalen University Press Dissertations No. 78. THE INDUSTRY ROLE IN POLICYMAKING: POLICY LEARNING IN CLIMATE POLITICS. Peter Stigson 2009 . . School of Sustainable Development of Society and Technology.

(2) Copyright © Peter Stigson, 2009 ISSN 1651-4238 ISBN 978-91-86135-40-9 Printed by Mälardalen University, Västerås, Sweden.

(3) Mälardalen University Press Dissertations No. 78. THE INDUSTRY ROLE IN POLICYMAKING: POLICY LEARNING IN CLIMATE POLITICS. Peter Stigson. Akademisk avhandling som för avläggande av teknologie doktorsexamen i energi- och miljöteknik vid Akademin för hållbar samhälls- och teknikutveckling kommer att offentligen försvaras måndagen 2 november, 2009, 13.30 i Zeta, Mälardalens högskola, Västerås. Fakultetsopponent: prof. Thomas B. Johansson, University of Lund, The International Institute for Industrial Environmental Economics. Akademin för hållbar samhälls- och teknikutveckling.

(4) Abstract Climatic change has sparked a broad range of responses on all societal levels. New initiatives and negotiations, scientific findings, and technological developments, have established a novel framework for policymaking and industrial abatement investments. Lessons on the evolving framework should be analysed and utilised to handle the dynamic reality of climate policymaking processes. Governments in the majority of economies only have an indirect and long-term influence on reducing industrial emissions, as they do not own the emitting operations. As representing one-third of the global carbon dioxide emissions, industry is therefore a key stakeholder group in whether or not the political agenda will be fulfilled. How industry perceives that obstacles and opportunities affect investment calculi are thus important. Hence, policymakers should facilitate policy learning (PL) to aid the creation of effective and efficient political agendas. This is important to acknowledge the policy and investment experiences of industrial actors and to deal with a number of plausible investment obstacles identified under the novel framework. Taking stock of PL and other policy theories, this thesis is aimed to develop recommendations for facilitating PL and thus contributing to more effective and efficient climate policy frameworks. The results highlight the role of industry in abatement and political strategies where policymakers need to gain knowledge on how industries perceive abatement investment obstacles and how these may be bridged. The intrinsic learning values of government-industry negotiated agreements (NAs) are emphasised and a framework for operationalising PL through NA designs is developed. PL is furthermore identified as important, and NAs are recommended as a policy instrument, to fill knowledge gaps identified in two case-studies of promoting complex and novel industrial operations. This thesis also recommends a participatory policy evaluation tool that is sensitive to industrial competitiveness and establishes a forum for discussions on perceived investment obstacles and opportunities under different conditions. The results are not aimed to provide a blueprint for a comprehensive climate policy framework but as a contribution to literature and the incremental learning that this thesis strongly promotes.. ISSN 1651-4238 ISBN 978-91-86135-40-9.

(5) <MNL;=N "FCG;NC==B;HA?B;MMJ;LE?>;<LI;>L;HA? I@ L?MJIHM?MIH;FFMI=C?N;FF?P?FM -?Q CHCNC;NCP?M ;H> H?AINC;NCIHM M=C?HNC@C= @CH>CHAM ;H> N?=BHIFIAC=;F >?P?FIJG?HNM B;P? ?MN;<FCMB?> ; HIP?F @L;G?QILE @IL JIFC=SG;ECHA ;H> CH>OMNLC;F ;<;N?G?HN CHP?MNG?HNM +?MMIHMIHNB??PIFPCHA@L;G?QILEMBIOF><? ;H;FSM?>;H> ONCFCM?> NIB;H>F? NB? >SH;GC=L?;FCNSI@=FCG;N?JIFC=SG;ECHA JLI=?MM?M &IP?LHG?HNM CH NB? G;DILCNS I@ ?=IHIGC?M IHFS B;P? ;H CH>CL?=N ;H> FIHA

(6) N?LG CH@FO?H=? IH L?>O=CHA CH>OMNLC;F ?GCMMCIHM ;M NB?S >I HIN IQH NB? ?GCNNCHA IJ?L;NCIHM M L?JL?M?HNCHA IH?

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

(8) CH>OMNLS H?AINC;N?> ;AL??G?HNM - M ;L? ?GJB;MCM?> ;H> ; @L;G?QILE @IL IJ?L;NCIH;FCMCHA /+ NBLIOAB- >?MCAHMCM>?P?FIJ?> /+ CM @OLNB?LGIL?C>?HNC@C?>;MCGJILN;HN ;H> - M ;L?L?=IGG?H>?>;M ;JIFC=SCHMNLOG?HN NI@CFFEHIQF?>A?A;JMC>?HNC@C?>CH NQI =;M?

(9) MNO>C?M I@ JLIGINCHA =IGJF?R ;H> HIP?F CH>OMNLC;F IJ?L;NCIHM 3BCM NB?MCM ;FMIL?=IGG?H>M ;J;LNC=CJ;NILSJIFC=S?P;FO;NCIHNIIFNB;NCMM?HMCNCP?NI CH>OMNLC;F =IGJ?NCNCP?H?MM ;H> ?MN;<FCMB?M ; @ILOG @IL >CM=OMMCIHM IH J?L=?CP?> CHP?MNG?HN I<MN;=F?M ;H> IJJILNOHCNC?M OH>?L >C@@?L?HN =IH>CNCIHM 3B? L?MOFNM ;L? HIN ;CG?> NI JLIPC>? ; <FO?JLCHN @IL ; =IGJL?B?HMCP? =FCG;N? JIFC=S @L;G?

(10) QILE <ON ;M ; =IHNLC<ONCIH NI FCN?L;NOL? ;H> NB? CH=L?G?HN;F F?;LHCHA NB;N NBCM NB?MCMMNLIHAFSJLIGIN?M ,@>69+: "FCG;N? JIFC=S /IFC=S F?;LHCHA /;LNC=CJ;NILS JIFC=SG;ECHA /IFC=S ?P;FO;NCIH5IFOHN;LS;AL??G?HNM-?AINC;N?>;AL??G?HNM(H>OMNLS. C.

(11) 2;GG;H@;NNHCHA #?HONG;HCHAMIGEFCG;N@aLXH>LCHA;LH;MNXFF?LM;GBXFF?NCH@aLB;LL?MOFN?L;NC?H JIFCNCME IGPXFPHCHA $H ONaE;> M;NMHCHA JZ HS; N?EHCE?L G?H;>? ;NN GCHME; ONMFXJJ?H;PPXRNBOMA;M?L M?MMIG?HPCENCA>?F C>?NN;;L<?N? #?NN;ELXP?L ?NN HSNN JIFCNCMEN L;GP?LE @aL M;G;L<?N?N G?FF;H JIFCNCE?L I=B HXLCHAMFCP >XL <Z>; J;LN?L GZMN?<SAA;OJJEOHME;J ELCHA HS;MNSLG?>?FI=BN?EHCE?L $HPCENCAMNZH>JOHEN C>?HH;;PB;H>FCHA XL;NN L?A?LCHA;L ?H>;MN CH>CL?ENI=BJZ FZHA MCEN E;H GCHME; ONMFXJJ?H ;P PXRNBOMA;M?L (H>OMNLCH MDXFP XL >?H J;LN MIG B;L >CL?EN EIHNLIFF aP?L >?MM ONMFXJJMEXFFIL PCFE; MNZL @aL ?H NL?>D?>?F ;P >? AFI<;F; EIF>CIRC>ONMFXJJ?H #XLG?> MJ?F;L CH>OMNLC?FF; ;ENaL?L ?H GS=E?N PCENCA LIFF C OJJ@SFF;H>?N ;P >? EFCG;NJIFCNCME; ;G<CNCIH?LH; 2IG ?NN L?MOFN;N E;H CH>OMNLCH?L<DO>; ?H PCENCAZN?LEIJJFCHANCFF JIFCNCE?L ;PM??H>? PCFE; JLI<F?GI=B GaDFCAB?N?L MIGC>?HNC@C?L;M @aL ;NNCHP?MN?L;CONMFXJJMGCHME;H>?ZNAXL>?L ,IN >?HH; <;EALOH> <?FSM?M CH>OMNLCHM LIFF C OJJ@SFF;H>?N ;P EFCG;NJIFCNCE?H PB;H>FCHA?HM MS@N? XL ;NN A? @aLMF;A JZ JIFCNCME; CHCNC;NCP MIG @LXGD;L >?H ZN?LEIJJFCHAMIG CH>OMNLCHE;H?L<DO>; I=B>XLCA?HIG<C>L;NCFFaE;>?@@?ENCPCN?NC EFCG;NJIFCNCE?H ( ;PB;H>FCHA?H C>?HNC@C?L;M MJ?=C@CE; CHP?MN?LCHAMBCH>?L M;GN EFCG;NJIFCNCME; GaDFCAB?N?L ;NNaP?L<LSAA;>?MM;BCH>?L #?NN;CHEFO>?L;L JIFCNCME; CHCNC;NCP XGH;>? ;NN@LXGD;>C;FIA?HG?FF;HJIFCNCE?LI=BCH>OMNLC $NN ;H;FSMP?LENSA JL?M?HN?L;M >XL >?MM;;ENaL?L A?G?HM;GN;H;FSM?L;L BOLIFCE; MNSLG?>?F I=B >?L;M L?MJ?ENCP? ON@ILGHCHA JZP?LE;L CH>OMNLCHM EIHEOLL?HMEL;@N PB;H>FCHA?H FS@N?L @L;G @LCPCFFCA; ;PN;F MIG ?NN @aL>?F;ENCAN MNSLG?>?F N;=E P;L? >?MM>?MCAH@F?RC<CFCN?NI=BGaDFCAB?N;NNMNCGOF?L;EOHME;JMON<SN? #?NM?H;L?B;L >I=E@aL<CM?NNMCNC>CA;L?@ILMEHCHA I=BGIN>?HH;<;EALOH>L?EIGG?H>?L;M?NN L;GP?LE @aL ;NN ON@ILG; >?MM; ;PN;F MZ ;NN FXL;H>?N G?FF;H MN;N I=B CH>OMNLC @LXGD;M PB;H>FCHA?H ?R?GJFC@C?L;L MCNO;NCIH?H G?> HS; N?EHCME; FaMHCHA;L A?HIG ;NN ;H;FSM?L; MCNO;NCIH?H G?> EIF>CIRC>CH@ZHAHCHA I=B >?JIH?LCHA >XL <?NS>;H>? CH@ILG;NCIHM;MSGG?NLC?L C>?HNC@C?L;NM $H ;HH;H @;FFMNO>C? AaLM JZ L?MOLM?@@?ENCP;JLI>OENCIHMFaMHCHA;LMIGMNLXP;L ?@N?LCH>OMNLC?FF MSG<CIM C*CH; #XL L?EIGG?H>?L;M @LCPCFFCA;;PN;F@aL;NNEOHH;;HJ;MM;MNCFFP;LC?L;H>?JLI>OE

(12) NCIHMGaHMN?LI=B@aL;NNMNa>D;?HEOHME;JM@LXGD;H>?;ENaLM>C;FIA. CC.

(13) =EHIQF?>AG?HNM 3B?L?;L?;HOG<?LI@J?IJF?;H>CHMNCNONCIHMNB;N(QIOF>FCE?NINB;HE@ILNB?CL =IHNLC<ONCIHMNIP;LCIOM;MJ?=NMI@GSL?M?;L=B 3BCMNB?MCMQIOF>HINB;P?=IG? ;<IONQCNBIONNB?CL @OH>CHA EHIQF?>A?

(14) MB;LCHA L?MJIHM?M >CM=OMMCIHM B?FJ ;H> ?H=IOL;A?G?HNM %CLMN ;H>@IL?GIMN (QIOF>FCE?NINB;HE 1=*%8,)6 ;MNB?G;CH=IHNLC<ONILQBI B;MG;>?CNJIMMC<F?@ILG?NI=;LLS IONNBCM L?M?;L=B;H>OFNCG;N?FS=IH=FO>?NBCM NB?MCM 3B;HE SIO NB;HE SIO ;H> NB;HE SIO H> ( QCFF ?P?H NBLIQ CH ;H ?RNL; IH?@ILSIO b QBC=BLOGIOLB;M CNCMJL?PCIOMFSOHJL?=?>?HN?> 3B;HESIO8IOL MOJJILN B;M <??H P;FO;<F? @LIG ?P?LS ;MJ?=N ;H> B;M ;FFIQ?> OM NI B;P? MIG? P?LSCHN?L?MNCHA>CM=OMMCIHM b (AO?MMNINB?@;GCFC?Mc@LOMNL;NCIH QB?HB;JJ?HCHA NII I@N?H ;H> AICHA IH @IL NII FIHA 6BCF? Q? B;P? GIMNFS <??H CH ;AL??G?HN NB?>CM;AL??G?HNM B;P? J?LB;JM <??H GIMNCHN?L?MNCHA !?CHA;/B#=;H>C>;N?QCNB 63*-2=9) !%2 ;MMOJ?LPCMIL B;M<??H;P?LS P?LS L?Q;L>CHA ?RJ?LC?H=? 3B?IJJILNOHCNC?MSIOB;P?JLIPC>?>@ILG? NIJ;LNC=CJ;N? CH;HOG<?LI@L?M?;L=BJLID?=NMCH>C@@?L?HN;L?;M B;P? <??HNLOFSCHN?L?MNCHA;H> ?>O=;NCP? (NB;M<??H@;HN;MNC=NI ?RJ?LC?H=? MIGO=BI@"BCH;;H> NB?"BCH?M? =FCG;N? ;A?H>; 8IO B;P? =IHNCHOIOMFS ;G;T?> G? CH NB;N SIO B;P? ;FQ;SM L?MJIH>?>NIGSKO?MNCIHM;H>?G;CFMQCNBCH;@?QBIOLM ?P?HNBIOABSIOB;P? <??HNL;P?FFCHACH>C@@?L?HNNCG?TIH?M 3B;HESIOMIGO=B@IL;FFSIOL?@@ILNM (.92'8 463*)7736 6-/ 38>%9)6 NB;HE SIO ?P?L MI GO=B @IL ;FF SIOL CHMJCLCHA QIL>M =;L?@OF L?PC?QM ;H> IP?L;FF =IH=?LH @IL GS L?M?;L=B 8IO L?;FFS B;P? =IHNLC<ON?>NIGSL?M?;L=B;H>@ILNB;N(;G?P?LAL;N?@OF 3B?L?;L?M?P?L;FINB?L=IFF?;AO?M;N,XF;L>;F?H4HCP?LMCNScM 2=BIIFI@2OMN;CH;

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

(16) MCIHM NB;N ( B;P? MBIQ?> OJ CH NB? B;FFQ;SM 2J?=C;F NB;HEM NI 6)(6-/ 8%6*)08 QCNBQBIG(F?;LHNNI?HDISNB?"BCH?M?dBINJINMe;H>QILE?>QCNBIHNB?$=I

(17) (H>OMNLC;F /;LE JLID?=N AL?;N <CA <;ME?N I@ NB;HEM NI (HA?L !DaLEFOH> (HA?L #;BF<S "F;M3?A?LMNL;H> HHCE;*;LFMMIH 8PIHH? LF?MNL;H>

(18) +OH>AL?H;H> INB?L. CCC.

(19) =IFF?;AO?M;NNB?4HCP?LMCNS QBIB;P?;C>?>GSQILE;H>JLID?=NJ;LNC=CJ;NCIHMI GO=BNBLIOABIONNB?S?;LM ( QIOF> ;FMI FCE? NI NB;HE 6 A68)2 -2( ;H> 6 2()67 %27732 @IL ; AL?;N =IFF;<IL;NCIH <INB IH NB? 231 ". JLID?=N ;H> CH QLCNCHA NB? ;LNC=F? IH =;L<IH =;JNOL? ;H> MNIL;A? (N B;M <??H ; JF?;MOL? A?NNCHA NI EHIQ SIO <INB ,ZLN?H NL;P?FFCHA <;=E ;H> @ILNB NI !LOMM?FM ;H> !?CDCHA B;M =?LN;CHFS <??H GO=B GIL? ?HDIS;<F??RJ?LC?H=?CHSIOL=IGJ;HS (;AL?? F?NOME??JCHNIO=B (;FMINB;HE INB?L L?M?;L=B=IHMILNCOGG?G<?LMI@NB? 231 ". $=I

(20) (H>OMNLC;F /;LE ;H> 2Q?>?H

(21) "BCH; "#, JLID?=NM @IL CHN?L?MNCHA L?M?;L=B =IFF;<IL;NCIHM ,;HSNB;HEMNI %2-)06%,0 @ILMBIQCHAG?;LIOH>!?CDCHA;H>N;ECHAG?<;=ENI GS@;PILCN?L?MN;OL;HNM ;MQ?FF;M 3,2%= @ILJONNCHAOJQCNBG?;@N?LQILE ( QIOF>HINB;P?F?;LHNNI;JJL?=C;N?!?CDCHAMIGO=BQCNBIONSIO 3B?M?JLID?=NM QIOF> HIN B;P? <??H JIMMC<F? QCNBION NB? @OH>CHA @LIG NB? $OLIJ?;H "IGGCM

(22) MCIH ;H> NB? 2Q?>CMB $H?LAS A?H=S #OLCHA NB? S?;LM I@ L?M?;L=B ( B;P? ;FMI L?=?CP?> @OH>CHA @IL NL;P?FM @LIG NB? "BCH?M? =;>?GS I@ $HACH??LCHA ;H> 3B? 1IS;F2Q?>CMB =;>?GSI@$HACH??LCHA2=C?H=?M *OHAFCA;(HA?HDaLMP?N?HME;JM;

(23) E;>?GC?H 3B? =IHNLC<ONCIH @LIG NB?M? CHMNCNONCIHM B;M ;FFIQ?> G? NI A;CH CHP;FO;<F??RJ?LC?H=?M@ILQBC=B(@??FF;LA?AL;NCNO>? 2IG? I@ NB? GIMN L?Q;L>CHA GIG?HNM I@ <?CHA ; /B# =;H>C>;N? B;P? <??H NB? CHN?L?MNCHA >CM=OMMCIHM I@ P;LCIOM L?M?;L=B =IOLM?M 3B?M? B;P? HIN IHFS <??H ?>O=;NCP? ;H> <LI;>?H?> GS L?M?;L=B J?LMJ?=NCP?M NB?S B;P? ;FMI <??H >IQH

(24) LCABN @OH 3B? GIMN G?GIL;<F? =IOLM? Q;M IH? IH /IFCNC=;F $=IFIAS QBC=B ( QIOF>FCE?NINB;HE$LCE;!DOL?<S@ILG;ECHAMICHN?L?MNCHA;H>CH>??>J;LNC=CJ;

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

(26) =IP?L NBIOAB H> ( QCFF HIN @ILA?N NB;N P?LS >CMNL?MMCHA >CM=OMMCIH IH? F;N? ?P?HCHACH&?H?P;QB?H(Q;MNIF>NIMNIJ@I=OMCHAMIGO=BIH<?CHAJO<FCMB?> )??T 3B?AL;NCNO>?(@??F@ILNB?OH>?LMN;H>CHA;H>MOJJILN@LIG SIO $FFC =;HIHFS<? ?RJL?MM?> NBLIOAB FIPCHA SIO ?P?H GIL? ( AO?MM NB;N QCNBCH MBILN Q? QCFF HI FIHA?L <? =IFF?;AO?M ;N NB? BIG? I@@C=? ;H> Q;HN SIO NI EHIQ NB;N ( QCFF GCMM FIIECHA IP?L NI GS F?@N DOMN NI M?? SIO MCNNCHA NB?L? 2;GG; M;E AXFF?L >CA GCH 3CF>;

(27) 3IE /;JJ;NS=E?L;NN>?N B;LP;LCN MZGSMCAN HXL>OEIGGCNCHMJLCHA;H>?@aL ;NNMHOLL;JZ GCHMNIF I=BNCNN;JZLIFCA;@CFG?LJZ>;NILH );ABIJJ;M<;L;;NN>O CHN?NS=E?L;NND;AP;FN<ILN>CAI=B<;L;DI<<;NCMNXFF?N@aL;NNF?E;I=BAIM; );A XFME;L>CAG;MMILI=BG;MMIL);AGZMN?I=EMZN;=E;FCFF;e2HILE?HeMIGXLJZPXA IGHZAL;P?=EIL@aL;NN>ONPCHA;NJ;JJ;;NNFXAA;H?L<a=E?LH;I=B<FCEF;LCHH;H >OEIGG?LNCFFPXLF>?H H> G;HSNB;HEM NI;FFI@SIOQBIG(B;P?@ILAINN?H1?GCH>G?H?RNNCG?Q? G??N;H>NB?<??LCMIHG?. ,;,9!;0.:65 %087.C9:2?7 )48)1&)6. P.

(28) 09:6- (7,89

(29)

(30)

(31)

(32)

(33)

(34)

(35) $"!!"# . ":0.965 6:?(;,8 '(5 !$ !% $$

(36) ! "$ " 7730,+5,8.> . . ":0.965 6:?(;,8'(5 $$ ! ! ! 5:,85(:065(3 6;85(36-8,,55,8.>

(37)

(38) . . ":0.965 6:?(;,8'(5 $! $ **,7:,+-687;)30*(:065(-:,88,<09065905 :/, 5:,85(:065(3 6;85(36-304(:,/(5., ":8(:,.0,9(5+(5(.,4,5: ;88,5:<,8906505 :/, 86*,,+05.96-:/,36)(365-,8,5*,6536)(3&(8405. & 9:(5);3#;82,> ;3>

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

(40) "#"!"#"!!. "/,:,: 2NCAMIH / )(9'-2+;)(-7,'%6&32(-3<-())1-77-327*6318,)&%7-' -2(9786=%2()2)6+=98-0-8-)7 2%'836%2(430-'=%2%0=7-7 +C=?HNC;N?NB?MCM ,XF;L>;F?H4HCP?LMCNS/L?MM 5XMN?LZM 2Q?>?H JJ (2!-

(41)

(42)

(43)

(44) . ,769;: (5+6;/,97<)30*(;065: 2NCAMIH / $>CNIL ;H> 6ILE/;=E;A?+?;>?L ,IOP?N " *L;BF # -; + %;S ) -2%2'-2+3*%2()'3231-'-2')28-:-7%8-321)',%2-717*36 1?JILNI@ 6ILE/;=E;A?I@NB?JLID?=Nd2OJJILNNIL?AOF;NILS;=NCPCNC?M@IL=;L<IH=;JNOL? ;H>MNIL;A?231 ". e %ILNB=IGCHA 6CFF<?;P;CF;<F?IHFCH?;N BNNJQQQ ?O=BCH;

(45) ==M ILA #INT;O?L $ 2NCAMIH / :)27/%/0-1%80%+%6-38%/81)(:%6%2(6%;)(-7, '0-1%8)%'87238%0-+2)(83)%',38,)6 +?NN?LNINB??>CNIL #;A?HM(H>OMNLC OAOMN (H2Q?>CMB 2NCAMIH / 8;H ) 9)78-322%-6)%2%0=7-73*;)(-7,78%/),30()67 32 %2('0)%28)',2303+=86%27*)6 1?M?;L=BL?JILNQCNBCHNB?JLID?=Nd"F?;H3?=BHIF

(46) IAS3L;HM@?L.JJILNOHCNC?MNBLIOAB"#,@ILNB?2Q?>?H

(47) "BCH;";M?e/

(48) NINB?2Q?>CMB$H?LAS A?H=S 2NCAMIH / 30(-3<-(9870?44*6A2-2(9786-3',)0463(9/8-32 - :)6-+) D ?+)76%443682%/8C67 3',430-'=%2%0=7*C61-27/%()9870?443',)2,A00&%6 98:)'/0-2+ %6&32(-3<-())1-77-327*6318,);)(-7,-2(9786=%2()0)'86-'-8= 463(9'8-32 D 8%8)3*8,)%68 2%'836%2(430-'=%2%0=7-7*366)(9')()1-77-327 %2(%7978%-2%&0)():)0341)28 1?M?;L=BL?JILN #?J;LNG?HNI@/O<FC= 3?=BHIFIAS ,XF;L>;F?H4HCP?LMCNS (H2Q?>CMB . PCC.

(49) +CMNI@N;<F?M;H>@CAOL?M 0:;6-"()3,: 3;<F?

(50) +?;LHCHAJIN?HNC;FI@>C@@?L?HNNSJ?MI@PIFOHN;LS;AL??G?HNM 3;<F?

(51) 1?MNLO=NOL?> JIMNJIH?> ;H>=;H=?FF?>""2JLID?=NM . 0:;6-0.<9,: %CAOL?

(52) 3BL??JIFC=SJLI=?MM?MMN;A?MQCNB )<%28) ;H> )<4378 F?;LHCHA %CAOL?

(53) /IFC=S;L?H;M;H>CH@ILG;NCIH>CMM?GCH;NCIHCH;<INNIG

(54) OJ;JJLI;=B %CAOL?

(55) /IMCNCIHI@;JJ?H>?>J;J?LMCHL?F;NCIHNI?;=BINB?L %CAOL?

(56) /IFC=SG;E?LL?MJIHM?NICH>OMNLC;FCHP?MNG?HNI<MN;=F?MJ?L=?JNCIHM %CAOL?

(57) "IGJ?NCNCP?H?MMCH>?R@IL>C@@?L?HNJIFC=SCHMNLOG?HNM %CAOL?

(58) /IFC=SF?;LHCHAMN;A?MI@H?AINC;N?>;AL??G?HNM %CAOL?

(59) .<MN;=F?MNINB?=IGG?L=C;FMO==?MMI@""2 >CPC>?>CHNI@IOLALIOJM . PCCC.

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

(61) MNO>S#?JFISCHA=;L<IH=;JNOL?;H>MNIL;A? . . ";M?

(62) MNO>S/LIGINCHA$=I

(63) (H>OMNLC;F/;LEMCH"BCH; . CR.

(64) . 630*@04730*(;065: . .P?L=IGCHAI<MN;=F?MNICHP?MNCH;<;N?G?HNG?;MOL?M . . (GJLIPCHAJIFC=SF?;LHCHA . . 3B?<?H?@CNMI@H?AINC;N?>;AL??G?HNM .

(65) . 65*3<:065:

(66) . . ,-,9,5*,:

(67) . R.

(68) =LIHSGM;H>;<<L?PC;NCIHM ! 4. !OMCH?MM;MOMO;F. ""2. ";L<IH=;JNOL?;H>MNIL;A?. "./. "IH@?L?H=?I@NB?/;LNC?MNINB?4-%""" M??<?FIQ. $(/. $=I

(69) (H>OMNLC;F/;LE. $4. $OLIJ?;H4HCIH. $4

(70) $32. $OLIJ?;H4HCIH$GCMMCIH3L;>CHA2=B?G?. &'&. &L??HBIOM?A;M. ($. (HN?LH;NCIH;F$H?LAS A?H=S. (/. (H>OMNLC;FJ;LE. (/"". (HN?LAIP?LHG?HN;F/;H?FIH"FCG;N?"B;HA?. */. *SINI/LINI=IF. -. -?AINC;N?>;AL??G?HN. -&.. -IH

(71) AIP?LHG?HN;FILA;HCM;NCIH. .$"#. .LA;HCM;NCIH@IL$=IHIGC="I

(72) IJ?L;NCIH;H>#?P?FIJG?HN. /+. /IFC=SF?;LHCHA. 1#. 1?M?;L=B;H>>?P?FIJG?HN. 1##. 1?M?;L=B >?P?FIJG?HN ;H>>?GIHMNL;NCIH. 1###. 1?M?;L=B >?P?FIJG?HN >?GIHMNL;NCIH ;H>>?JFISG?HN. 4-$/. 4HCN?>-;NCIHM$HPCLIHG?HN/LIAL;GG?. 4-%""". 4HCN?>-;NCIHM%L;G?QILE"IHP?HNCIHIH"FCG;N?"B;HA?. 5. 5IFOHN;LS;AL??G?HN. RC.

(73) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:.

(74) . 5;96+<*;065. (HNLI>O=NCIH . (*2.96<5+. 3B?=B;FF?HA?I@ FCGCNCHA =FCG;N?=B;HA? B;M L?MOFN?>CH ;MOLA? I@ CHN?L?MNCHFIQ

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

(76) MJ?=C@C=JIFC=SL?MJIHM?MNIL?ACIH;F=B;FF?HA?M;H> =IH>CNCIHM ;MQ?FF;MMOJL;H;NCIH;F=IGGCNG?HNM MMO=B NB?H;NOL?I@=FCG;N? JIFCNC=M CM CH ; >SH;GC= J?LCI> (H ;>>CNCIH ;H> F;LA?FS J;L;FF?F NI NB? >SH;GC=. . 1?A;L>F?MM I@ <?CHA >?@CH?> ;M ; G;RCGOG U" ;P?L;A? AFI<;F N?GJ?L;NOL? LCM? IL MN;<CFCM;NCIH I@ =;L<IH >CIRC>? =IH=?HNL;NCIHM ;N =IGGIHFS >CM=OMM?> =;L<IH >CIRC>? ?KOCP;F?HNF?P?FMI@ ILJ;LNMJ?LGCFFCIH .

(77) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. =FCG;N?JIFCNC=M NB?=OLL?HNMCNO;NCIHCMOH=?LN;CH ;M;L?MOFNI@ QB?NB?L ILL;NB?L QB?H NB?4-%"""JLI=?MMQCFF MO==??>NIJLI>O=?;H;AL??G?HN ;H> L?A;L>MNI NB? MJ?=C@C=M I@ MO=B ;H ;AL??G?HN 3BCM CH=FO>?M -28)6 %0-% NB? >?N;CFM I@ ; =IHNCHOIOM IJ?L;NCIH I@ AFI<;F ?GCMMCIHM NL;>CHA H?Q M=C?HNC@C= @CH>CHAM IH =FCG;N? =B;HA? ;H> ?G?LACHA N?=BHIFIAC?M ;H> ?HACH??LCHA MIFONCIHM (N ;FMI CH=FO>?M NB? OJ>;NCHA ;H> ;G?H>G?HNM I@ JIFC=C?M NB;N QCFF <? L?KOCL?> >O? NI NB?M?;H>INB?L@;=NILM 3B? GOFNCNO>?I@L?=?HN JIFCNC=;F=FCG;N?CHCNC;NCP?MB;M <??HCHNLI>O=?> QCNBCH; FCGCN?>NCG?@L;G?;H> B;M L?MOFN?> CH HIP?FJIFC=S @L;G?QILEM CHGIMNH;NCIHM M ; L?MOFN <OMCH?MM CH A?H?L;F ;H> NB? =;L<IH >CIRC>? CHN?HMCP? CH>OMNLC?M CH MJ?=C@C= HIQ IJ?L;N?M OH>?L GIL? MNLCHA?HN =IH>CNCIHM /IFC=SG;E?LM =;H BIQ?P?LCH@FO?H=? QB;N ?@@?=NMNB;N;GIL?MNLCHA?HNJIFC=S @L;G?QILE CGJIM?M IH NB? JLCP;N? M?=NIL NBLIOAB NB? =BIC=? I@ JIFC=S CHMNLOG?HNM NB? >?MCAH I@ JIFC=SCHMNLOG?HNM;H> NB?G;H;A?G?HNI@JIFC=SCHMNLOG?HNM 2O=B =IHMC>?L;

(78) NCIHM ;L? OH>?L NB? ;<IP?G?HNCIH?> MCNO;NCIH ;M Q?FF ;M INB?L @;=NILM MO=B ;M NB? AFI<;FCM;NCIH I@ G;LE?NM ;H> CHN?LH;NCIH;F >C@@?L?H=?M CH L?AOF;NILS MNLCH

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

(80) . 5;96+<*;065. I@ -28)6%0-% >?JFISG?HN=IMNM L?Q;L>M@LIGJIFC=SCH=?HNCP?M ;H>IJ?L;NCIH;F L?FC;<CFCNS /L?PCIOM L?M?;L=B B;M MBIQH NB;N NB? =IMNM I@ ;<;NCHA ?GCMMCIHM NI H?=?MM;LS F?P?FM ;L? G;H;A?;<F? <ON ;FMI NB;N JIMNJIHCHA ;=NCIH QCFF MB;LJFS CH=L?;M? NB? =IMNM I@=IG<;NCHA=FCG;N?=B;HA?2N?LH -IH?NB?F?MM ;<;NCHA?GCMMCIHM ;==IL>CHANINB?H?=?MM;LSFIHA

(81) N?LGNL;D?=NILS QCFF?HN;CF?RJ?HM?MIH;FFMI=C?N;F F?P?FM QBC=BCH?PCN;<FSQCFF=;OM?CH?LNC;NI CHMNCA;N? ;=NCIH 1?=?HNL?M?;L=BB;M ;FMI ;LAO?> NB;N =FCG;N?M?HMCNCPCNS;H>CLL?P?LMC<CFCNS?@@?=NM G;S<? F;LA?LNB;H JL?PCIOMFS ?MNCG;N?> QBC=B CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? F?P?FM NB;N GOMN <? L?;=B?> ;H> NB? NCG?@L;G? QCNBCH QBC=B NB?M? F?P?FM MBIOF> <? ;NN;CH?> ;L? GIL? MNLCHA?HN NB;NJL?PCIOMFSJ?L=?CP?> 2GCNB?N;F 2IFIGIH?N;F HCGJ?L;NCP? =IH=FOMCIH CM NB?L?@IL? NB;N =FCG;N? JIFC=C?M GOMN <? ?@@?=NCP? ;H> ?@@C=C?HN C ? JLIGINCHA ?GCMMCIH L?>O=NCIHM CH NB? MBILN G?>COG ;H> FIHA

(82) N?LG ;H> CH ; =IMN

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

(85) N?LG 3BCM NB?MCM QCFF NB?L?@IL? ;LAO? NB;N AIP?LHG?HNM MBIOF> ?HA;A? CH /+ ;H> // ;=NCPCNC?M QCNB NB? CH>OMNLS ;M NI ;=KOCL? CH@ILG;NCIH IH I<MN;=F?M NB;N CGJ?>? ;<;N?G?HN CHP?MNG?HNM ;H> MOAA?MNCIHM @IL JIFC=S ;G?H>G?HNM NI <LC>A? MO=B .

(86) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. I<MN;=F?M -IN ONCFCMCHANBCMCH@ILG;NCIH@;CFMNI;=EHIQF?>A?NB?LIF?I@CH>OMNLS ;M NB? >?=CMCIH

(87) G;E?LM >?N?LGCHCHA QB?NB?L ?GCMMCIHM CH NB? M?=NIL QCFF <? ;<;N?> IL HIN 3BCM EHIQF?>A?

(88) MB;LCHA CM BIQ?P?L ;N JL?M?HN HIN JIMMC<F? NI ;==IGJFCMB ?@@?=NCP?FS ;H> ?@@C=C?HNFS ;M NB?L? CM ; MBILN;A? I@ @ILOGM ;H> ; =IGGIHF;HAO;A?NB;N=;H@;=CFCN;N?NBCM>C;FIAO? FMI AIP?LHG?HN L?JL?M?HN;

(89) NCP?M QCNBCHNB?4-%"""JLI=?MMB;P?=F?;LFSMN;N?>NB;N<OMCH?MM JL?M?H=? CMHIN Q;HN?>QCNBCHNB?M?JLI=?MM?M 3BCM >?GIHMNL;N?M NB? =IHN?RN QCNBCH QBC=B NBCM NB?MCM CM QLCNN?H H;G?FS ; MCNO;NCIHQB?L?NB?;L?H;@ILQILECHANI=IG<;N=FCG;N?=B;HA?CMHIP?F@IL<INB AIP?LHG?HNM;H>CH>OMNLC?M A;CHMNNBCM<;=EALIOH> NB?;ONBIL B;M=;LLC?>ION; HOG<?LI@MNO>C?MQCNB;@I=OMIHBIQCGJLIP?>F?;LHCHA=;H;=EHIQF?>A?;H> ONCFCM? CH>OMNLC;F JIFC=S ?RJ?LC?H=?M ;M NI CH=L?;M? JIFC=SG;E?LMc =;J;=CNC?M NI CGJF?G?HN?@@?=NCP?;H>?@@C=C?HN=FCG;N?JIFC=S@L;G?QILEM. . !*67,. (H N?LGM I@ ;=NILM CH=FO>?> CH NBCM NB?MCM NB? L?M?;L=B N;LA?NM JIFC=SG;E?LM ;H> CH>OMNLC?M 3B?N?LGJIFC=SG;E?LL?@?LMNI;=NILM;H>CHMNCNONCIHMQCNBCHNB?JO<FC= >IG;CH QBC=B B;P? L?MJIHMC<CFCNC?M QCNBCH NB? M?F?=NCIH >?MCAH IJ?L;NCIH IL ?P;FO;NCIH I@ ; JIFC=S ;FMI M?? 2?=NCIH <?FIQ M MO=B CN ?H=IGJ;MM?M ;A?H=C?MNB;N;L?A?H?L;FFSL?MJIHMC<F?@ILNB?IJ?L;NCIHI@;JIFC=SCHMNLOG?HNIH ;>;S

(90) NI

(91) >;S<;MCM 3B?JIFC=SG;E?L=;HNBOM<? G;>?OJI@ M?P?L;F;=NILM CH NB? G;CHJIFCNC=;F>IG;CH;MQ?FF;M>C@@?L?HNMO<

(92) >IG;CHM 6BIJF;SMNB?G;CHLIF? I@ JIFC=SG;E?L NB?L?@IL? NSJC=;FFS =B;HA?M IP?L NCG? ;FNBIOAB JIFCNC=C;HM B;P? NB? F?ACMF;NCP? L?MJIHMC<CFCNS ;H> L?G;CH OFNCG;N?FS L?MJIHMC<F? 3B? INB?L G;CH MN;E?BIF>?L ALIOJ CH>OMNLC?M ;L? CHP?MNILM CH 1### I@ ;<;N?G?HN IJJILNOHC

(93) NC?M 6CNBCHNBCMM?=NILNB?L? CM;@I=OMIH '%6&32-28)27-:) &%7-' -2(9786-)7 QBC=B. . HIHSGIOMOH>?L"B;NB;G'IOM?1OF? MJLCHA . 3BCM>?@CHCNCIHCM ?KO;FNI NB;NI@ NB?,CFF?HHCOG$=IMSMN?G MM?MMG?HN";LJ?HN?L?N;F d J?LMIH QCNB JIQ?L NI CH@FO?H=? IL >?N?LGCH? JIFC=C?M ;H> JL;=NC=?M ;N ;H CHN?LH;NCIH;F H;NCIH;F L?ACIH;F IL FI=;F F?P?F e 3BCM =IGJ;L?M NI ; >?=CMCIH

(94) G;E?L C<C> d J?LMIH QBIM? >?=CMCIHM ;H> NB? ;=NCIHM NB;N @IFFIQ @LIG NB?G =;H CH@FO?H=? ; =IH>CNCIH JLI=?MM IL CMMO? OH>?L =IHMC>?L;NCIHe ( ? ; JIFC=SG;E?L CM ; >?=CMCIH

(95) G;E?L QCNBCHNB?JIFCNC=;F>IG;CH 3B?N?LG>?=CMCIH

(96) G;E?LMCMQCNBCHNBCMNB?MCMOM?>NIJIMCNCIH ;=NILM CH NB? JLCP;N? >IG;CH NI CH>C=;N? NB? CH>OMNLC?Mc M?F@

(97) >?N?LGCH;NCIH L?A;L>CHA CHP?MNG?HN>?=CMCIHM .

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

(100) . 5;96+<*;065. CGJILN;HN ;M NB? =BIC=? I@ JIFC=S CHMNLOG?HN CH NB? @CLMN MN;A? FI=EM

(101) CH =?LN;CH JIFC=S =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M B?H=? FCGCNCHA NB? >?MCAH @F?RC<CFCNS NI CH@FO?H=? JIFC=S =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M ;MCMMBIQHCH/;J?L (( 3B? 8,-6( JLI=?MM CH=FO>?M NB?=IHNCHOIOM G;H;A?G?HNI@;JIFC=S>OLCHANB? J?LCI>NB;NCNCMCGJF?G?HN?> 3BCM CHN?LJL?N;NCIH I@ NB? JIFC=S JLI=?MM?M CM >C@@?L?HN NI @IL ?R;GJF? NB;N I@ 'IQF?NN ;H> 1;G?MB QBI C>?HNC@S @CP? MN;A?M ;A?H>; M?NNCHA JIFC=S @ILGOF;NCIH >?=CMCIH

(102) G;ECHA JIFC=S CGJF?G?HN;NCIH ;H> JIFC=S ?P;FO;NCIH 3B?CL GI>?FCMBIQ?P?L@I=OM?>NI?RJF;CHJO<FC=JIFC=SG;ECHACHA?H?L;F QBCF? NB?GI>?F;JJFC?><SNB?;ONBILCMOM?>;M;@L;G?QILENI;H;FSM?QBC=BLIF?NB;N CH>OMNLS =;H JF;S CH ?R?LNCHA ; JIMCNCP? CH@FO?H=? >OLCHA >C@@?L?HN MN;A?M I@ NB? JIFC=SG;ECHA JLI=?MM?M 3B? GI>?F OM?> CH NBCM NB?MCM >I?M HIN >CPC>? JIFC=S G;H;A?G?HN CHNI JIFC=S CGJF?G?HN;NCIH ;H> JIFC=S ?P;FO;NCIH 3BCM CM >IH? CH IL>?L NI ;=EHIQF?>A? ;H> JON ?GJB;MCM IH NB? =IHNCHOIOM ;H> CHN?LNQCH?> H;NOL?I@NB?M?NQIJIFC=SJLI=?MM?M;FMIM??2?=NCIH /IFC=SG;H;A?G?HN CH NBCM CHN?LJL?N;NCIH CH=FO>?M @??>

(103) <;=E FIIJM QB?L? F?MMIHM @??> <;=E CHNI NB? JIFC=S;H>G;S;G?H>CNM>?MCAH (NG;S;FMIG?;H=BIIMCHA;H?QJIFC=SCHMNLO

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

(105) MJ?=C@C= CH>OMNLS ;H> >?P?FIJCHA =IOHNLS =IHN?RN 3B? CHN?LH;NCIH;F CH@FO?H=? IH NB? L?M?;L=B CM HIH?NB?F?MM <INB MNLIHA ;H> CH?PCN;<F?>O?NINB?AFI<;FCM;NCIHI@G;LE?NM;H>=FCG;N?H?AINC;NCIHM. .

(106) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. 5;,95(;065(35,.6;0(;065: (5+*6440;;4,5;:. #. (;065(3.6=,954,5;:. !;(;,(.,5*0,:. 5+<:;9@. /IFC=SG;E?LM. /IFC=S?HPCLIHG?HN. 0.<9, 630*@(9,5(: (5+05-694(;065+0::,405(;06505 ()6;;64<7(7796(*/. 3BCMG?;HMNB;NNB?JIFC=S;L?H;M>CM=OMM?>CHNBCM NB?MCM;H>BIQNB?SL?F;N?;L? ;M>?JC=N?>CH %CAOL? QB?L?$4IHFS;JJFC?MNI,?G<?L2N;N?M 3B? CH@ILG;

(107) NCIH @FIQ CM M??H ;M ILCACH;NCHA @LIG NB? CH>OMNLS ;M NBCM CM NB? MIOL=? I@ CH@ILG;NCIHNB;NCMN;LA?N?>CHNBCMNB?MCM '?H=? NB?L?M?;L=B>I?MHINCHA?H?L;F G;E? ;HS >CMNCH=NCIH <?NQ??H QBC=B JIFC=SG;ECHA CHMNCNONCIHM IL ;=NILM NB;N JLI=?MM?M NB? EHIQF?>A? @LIG NB? CH>OMNLC?M CH NB? JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN 3B? @CAOL? CM MCGJFC@C?> ;H> CH L?;F FC@? CH=FO>?M M?P?L;F MO<

(108) F?P?F CHMNCNONCIHM ;H> ;=NILM ;MQ?FF;MFI=;FAIP?LHG?HNM;H>=IGGCNN??M;NNB?>C@@?L?HN;L?H;M 3B? JOLJIM? B?L? CM BIQ?P?L NI =F;LC@S NB? >C@@?L?H=? I@ JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN ;H> JIFC=SG;E?LM ;M Q?FF ;M NB? F;NN?L <?CHA ALIOJ?> NIA?NB?L (N MBIOF> <? HIN?> BIQ?P?LNB;N/;J?L(( @I=OM?MGIL?IH JIFCNC=C;HM NB;H;=NILM;NNB?;A?H=SF?P?F %LIG ;H CH>OMNLS J?LMJ?=NCP? NB? JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN ;L?H; CH=FO>?M <INB CH>OMNLC?M;H>CH>OMNLSILA;HCM;NCIHM. .

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

(110) NCP?M ;H>NB?H??>@ILF?;LHCHACHL?F;NCIHNI ;HIP?FN?=BHIFIAC?M;H>JLI>O=NCIH J;NN?LHM 3B?NQIJ;J?LMCHNB?F?@N=IFOGH;L?GIL?NB?IL?NC=;FQBCF?NB?NQINI NB? LCABN ;L? GIL? ;JJFC?> 3B? CH>CPC>O;F L?MOFNM ;FMI CH=FO>? MIG? MBILN <;=E

(111) ALIOH>MNINB?MJ?=C@C=;L?;MNB;N;L?MNO>C?> %IL?RN?H>?><;=EALIOH> L?;>?LM ;L?;>PCM?>NIL?;>NB?;JJ?H>?>J;J?LMCHNB?CL?HNCL?NS %4)6 ?MN;<FCMB?MNB?NQIIP?L;L=BCHA NB?ILC?M b QBI=;HL?>O=??GCMMCIHM;H> QBC=BI<MN;=F?M@ILNBCM>I;HIP?F=FCG;N?@L;G?QILEJL?M?HN b NB;N ?MN;<FCMBNB? NB?M?M=IHN?RN 1?MOFNMIONFCH?>CH2?=NCIHM %4)6 CHNLI>O=?M ; >?=CMCIH ;H;FSNC=;F @L;G?QILE CH N?LGM I@ ; J;LNC=CJ;NILS JIFC=S?P;FO;NCIHNIIF QBC=B CM ;CG?>NICGJLIP?JIFC=SG;ECHAJLI=?MM?M2?=NCIH . .

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cM=IP?L?MM;S ;MNIG;CHN;CHNB?@I=OMIHF?;LHCHA;H>NB?JIFC=SG;E?L

(113) CH>OMNLSL?F;NCIHMBCJ %4)6 ;H;FSM?M 5 M @LIG NB? J?LMJ?=NCP? I@ HIP?F JLI>O=NCIH J;NN?LHM CH NB? @ILGI@"BCH?M?$=I

(114) (H>OMNLC;F/;LEM$(/M 3B?=IHN?HNMI@NBCMJ;J?L CMHINJON CHNI ;/+=IHN?RN;M CNQ;MNB?@CLMNJ;J?LQLCNN?H I@NBIM?;JJ?H>?>NINBCMNB?MCM ;H>M??CHANB;NNB?;ONBILcML?M?;L=BCHN?L?MN@ILF?;LHCHAQ;MCHCNMCH@;H=S;NNB? NCG? #O?NINBCM 2?=NCIH >?P?FIJMNB?F?;LHCHA;MJ?=NMI@ /;J?L5 CHL?F;NCIH NI/+NB?ILC?M. . ,;/6+ (5+(04. 3B?L?M?;L=B@I=OM ILCACH;N?M @LIG NB?;ONBILcM JL?PCIOM QILE QBC=BCH=FO>?>CH

(115) >?JNBCHN?LPC?QMQCNB G;H;A?G?HNF?P?F L?JL?M?HN;NCP?M@LIG 2Q?>CMB CH>OMNLC?M ;H>ILA;HCM;NCIHMQCNBL?MJIHMC<CFCNC?M@ILNB?L?MJ?=NCP?CHMNCNONCIHMc=FCG;N?;H> ?H?LAS QILE2NCAMIH 3B? L?M?;L=B CH NB? ;JJ?H>?> J;J?LM CM BIQ?P?L G;CHFS <;M?> IH FCN?L;NOL? MNO>C?M ;FNBIOABMIG? L?M?;L=BL?MOFNM;L?<;M?>IHCHN?LPC?QM G;CHFSCH/;J?L ( ;H>KO?MNCIHH;CL?MOLP?SM /;J?L(5 3B? =?HNL;F G;CH ;L?;MI@ ;H;FSM?MB;P? <??H /+ // CHP?MNG?HN I<MN;=F?M ;H> 5 M (H N?LGM I@ I<MN;=F?M NB? L?M?;L=B B;MN;LA?N?>BIQ CH>OMNLC?MJ?L=?CP? CHP?MNG?HNI<MN;=F?M;H> QBC=B CGJFC=;NCIHM NB;N NBCM B;M IH ; /+ ;A?H>; 3BCM B;M <??H OM?> NI ;LAO? BIQ NB? C>?HNC@C?> I<MN;=F?M =;H <? IP?L=IG? NBLIOABONCFCM;NCIHI@ CH>OMNLC?Mc ?RJ?LC?H=?M I@@;=NO;F CHP?MNG?HN=IH>CNCIHM 3BCM NB?MCMNBOM ;LAO?M@IL ;<INNIG

(116) OJ;JJLI;=BNIJIFC=S ;H;FSMCM QBC=B B;M NB? ;>P;HN;A? C>?HNC@SCHA JIFC=S MO<MSMN?GM NB;N ;L? CGJIL

(117) N;HN NINB?JIFC=SG;ECHAJLI=?MM?M'IQF?NN;H>1;G?MB 3B?L?M?;L=BCM;CG?>NI BCABFCABNNB?JIFC=S ;>PC=? NB;N CH>OMNLC?M =;H JLIPC>? NI JIFC=SG;E?LM <;M?> IH NB?CL ?RJ?LC?H=?M ;M CHP?MNILM ;H> NB;N NBCM JIN?HNC;F CM ?GJB;MCM?> CH FCABN I@ NB? =OLL?HN MCNO;NCIH QCNB L;JC> =B;HA?M CH ; =IGJF?R =FCG;N?JIFC=S ;H>N?=BHC=;F ?HPCLIHG?HN 3BCMCMNOLH?>CHNI JIFC=S L?=IGG?H>;

(118) .

(119) . 5;96+<*;065. NCIHM NB;N ;L? ;CG?> NI CGJLIP? JIFC=S M?F?=NCIH >?MCAH ;H> G;H;A?G?HN JLI=?MM?M 3INBCM?H> NB?OFNCG;N?AI;FI@NB?L?M?;L=BCM BIQJIFC=C?M=;H<LC>A? NB?M? I<MN;=F?M ;H> =IHNLC<ON? NI ; GIL? ?@@?=NCP? ;H> ?@@C=C?HN =FCG;N? JIFC=S @L;G?QILE 6CNBCH NBCM =IHN?RN NBCM NB?MCMcM NB?ILC?M <ICF >IQH NI NB? @IFFIQCHA L?M?;L=B KO?MNCIHM . 'IQ>I?MNB?>SH;GC=;H>HIP?F=FCG;N? @L;G?QILE MCNO;NCIH;@@?=N JIFC=SG;ECHAJLI=?MM?M. . 6BC=BI<MN;=F?MMJLCHA@LIGNBCMMCNO;NCIH. . 6BC=BLIF?=;HNB?CH>OMNLSJF;SCHNB?M?JLI=?MM?M. . 'IQ=;HJIFC=C?M<?>?MCAH?>;MNI@OLNB?L /+. . 'IQ>IHIP?FN?=BHIFIAC?M;@@?=NNB?H??>@IL /+. . 6BC=BJIFC=SL?=IGG?H>;NCIHM=;H <? @F?RC<F? ;H>;>;JN;<F?NI HIP?F N?=BHIFIAC?M;H>IJ?L;NCIHM. . "/,:0:6<;305,. 2?=NCIHJLIPC>?M CH@ILG;NCIHIH /+ ;MNIJLIPC>?NB? <;=EALIOH> IH ?RJ?LC?H=?M CH NB? JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN <?H?@CNCHA JIFC=SG;ECHA 'IQ?P?L NB? =IH=?JN CM =IHNCHOIOMFS>?P?FIJ?>NBLIOABIONNB?M?=NCIHM;MNIJONCH>CPC>O;FL?MOFNMCHNI ;H;JJLIJLC;N?=IHN?RN 2?=NCIH FIIEM GIL? CHNI NB? >C@@?L?HN LIF?M I@ JIFC=SG;E?LM ;H> CH>OMNLS ;H> BIQNB?M?NQI;=NILALIOJM;H>NB?CLL?MJ?=NCP?QILEL?F;N?NI?;=BINB?L 2?=NCIH IONFCH?M NB? G;CH L?MOFNM I@ NB? ;JJ?H>?> J;J?LM ;M Q?FF ;M MIG? =IH=FO>CHAL?G;LEM 2?=NCIH BCABFCABNM NB? JIFC=S CGJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB? L?M?;L=B @CH>CHAM CH N?LGM I@ ;<;N?G?HNCHP?MNG?HNI<MN;=F?M @OLNB?LCHA/+ ;H><?H?@CNMI@=?LN;CH5 M 2?=NCIH JLIPC>?M NB? =IH=FOMCIHM ;H> MOGG;LCM?M NB? ;HMQ?LM NB? L?M?;L=B KO?MNCIHM;<IP?. .

(120) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. .

(121) . 630*@3,(9505.. /IFC=SF?;LHCHA 3BCM NB?MCM ;LAO?M NB;N JIFC=SG;E?LM MBIOF> ;=EHIQF?>A? ;H> ONCFCM? NB? JIFC=S ?RJ?LC?H=?;H>?RJ?LNCM?NB;NNB?CH>OMNLSA;CHM;MJIFC=SMO<D?=NM FFIQCHAMO=B ?RJ?LC?H=? CH NB? JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN NI @??> CHNI NB? JIFC=S JLI=?MM?M CM NB?I

(122) LAOCHA NB;N NB? CH>OMNLS MBIOF> <? ;FFIQ?> NI ?HA;A? GIL? LCM?> ;M /+ NBILIOABFSCHNB?JIFC=SJLI=?MM?MCM;FMIJ;L;FF?FNI // IL CHN?L;=NCP?JIFC=SG;E

(123) CHA 3B? <?H?@CNM I@ <INB NB?M? NB?ILC?M ;L? MOJJILN?> <S ; MNLIHA <I>S I@ FCN?L;NOL? MO=B;MP;H MN;H>!IIN #LC?MM?H?N;F $NB?L?>A?;H> 2BILN &?OLNM ;H> )IF>?LMG; ;H> 2T;LE; (GJILN;HNFS BIQ?P?L NB? ;ONBIL /;J?L ( ;AL??M QCNB J;MN @CH>CHAM I@ !?HH?NN ;H> 'IQF?NN NB;NNB?<?H?@CNMI@/+B;MF;=E?>;NN?HNCIH<SJIFC=SG;E?LM %OLNB?LGIL? 2=BI@C?F> C>?HNC@SNB;NQBCF?MIG?FCN?L;NOL?L?@?LMNI/+CHN?LGMI@JIFC=S =S=F?M L?M?;L=B CM F;=ECHA CH N?LGM I@ JLI=?>OL;F ?F?G?HNM I@ CGJF?G?HNCHA F?;LHCHA 3BCM JLIPC>?M ; A;J QCNBCH QBC=B NB? L?M?;L=B CM JIMCNCIH?> ?MJ?=C;FFS /;J?L((( (H A?H?L;F N?LGM /+ G?;HM NB;N EHIQF?>A? CH NB? JIFC=S ?HPCLIHG?HN b J;MN ?RJ?LC?H=?M;H>?RJ?=N;NCIHMI@NB?@ONOL? b CM ONCFCM?> ?CNB?L NI CGJLIP?JIFC=S

(124) G;ECHA =IHNLC<ON?NI?HFCABN?HJIFC=SG;E?LM IL<INB '?H=? /+ ;LAO?M@IL NB? <?H?@CNM I@ <INNIG

(125) OJ ;JJLI;=B?M CH JIFC=SG;ECHA 3BLIOAB CH=ILJIL;NCHA. . 2O=B JLI=?MM?M =;H ;FMI <? L?F;N?> NI INB?L =IH=?JNM MO=B ;M H?IFC<?L;FCMG ;H> H?I

(126) =ILJIL;NCMG 3B?@I=OMB?L?CMBIQ?P?LFCGCN?>NI/+;H>//;MNB?M?NB?ILC?M;L?C>?HNC

(127) @C?>NIJLIPC>?NB?GIMNMOCN;<F?@L;G?QILE@ILNB?L?M?;L=B@I=OM <?H?@CNI@/+ L?F;NCP? NB?NB?ILC?M;<IP? CMNB;NNB?NB?ILSB;MHI<C;MILJL?@?L?H=?CHL?F;NCIHNICH>OMNLS;M;H ;=NILCH;F?;LHCHA?HPCLIHG?HN .

(128) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. ?RIA?HIOM EHIQF?>A? /+ ?H;<F?M ; F;LA?L ALIOJ I@ MN;E?BIF>?LM QCNB JIFC=S EHIQF?>A?NI;=N;MJIFC=S;H;FSMNM 3BCMG?;HMNB;NNB?CH>OMNLS GIP?M @LIG;H ?RN?LH;F ;H> H?ONL;F JIMCNCIH NI JIFC=S ;>PCMILM QBI ;=NCP?FS =IHNLC<ON? NI NB? JIFC=SG;ECHA JLI=?MM?M #O? NI NBCM AIP?LHG?HNM ;=N GIL? ;M JIFC=SG;ECHA @;=CFCN;NILML;NB?LNB;H MCHAF?>?=CMCIH

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cM @I=OM IH JIFCNC=;F CHMNCNONCIHM CM ;FMI MOCN;<F? CH NB;N NBCM NB?MCM ;LAO?M NB;N /+ MBIOF> <? @;=CFCN;N?> ;H> JL?@?L;<FS IJ?L;NCIH;FCM?> <S JIFC=SG;E?LM 3B? L?;MIH @IL HIN L?@?LLCHA NI AIP?LHG?HN F?;LHCHA CM BIQ?P?L NB;NJ;L;FF?FNB?ILC?M;L?I@ P;FO? >O?NI -28)6%0-% ; <LI;>?LM=IJ?I@F?;LHCHA ;A?HNM ;H>NB;NNB? HILG;NCP?P;FO?MI@ /+CMGIL?=IGGIHFSEHIQH +IIECHA ;N QB?NB?L /+ MBIOF> <? CHN?LJL?N?> ;M ?HFCABN?HCHA IL CGJLIPCHA JIFC=SG;ECHA ;MG?HNCIH?>;<IP? CN CM ?GJB;MCM?>NB;N?MN;<FCMBCHA;L?H;M;H> ?@@ILNM @IL F?;LHCHA GOMN HIN H?=?MM;LCFS G?;H NB;N NB? CH>OMNLS OFNCG;N?FS CH@FO?H=? JF;HH?> >?=CMCIHM <S JIFC=SG;E?LM 3B? NB?ILS BIQ?P?L JLIPC>?M ; >CMNCH=NJIN?HNC;F@ILCGJLIP?G?HNM CH >ICHAMI 3BCMMCNO;NCIH=;H<?=IGJ;L?>NI @CH>CHAM<S2=BI@C?F> QBIC>?HNC@C?MNB;N?R;=NJIFC=S?@@?=NM;L?>C@@C=OFNNI C>?HNC@S )< %28) ;H> NB;N ; >C;FIAO? >OLCHA CGJF?G?HN;NCIH NB?L?@IL? MBIOF> N;LA?NQBC=BLCMEMNB;NNB?JIFC=SMO<D?=NCMQCFFCHANI ;MMOG? 3B?CHN?LJL?N;NCIH NBOM>?J?H>MIHQBC=BNSJ?I@F?;LHCHANB;NI==OLMM??<?FIQ . . 2?? -28)6 %0-% !?HH?NN ;H> 'IQF?NN ;H> 2=BI@C?F> @IL >CM=OMMCIHM IH >C@@?L?HNCHN?LJL?N;NCIHM;H>NB?ILC?MQCNBCHJIFC=SF?;LHCHA. .

(130) . 630*@3,(9505.. /+CM;FMIJ;L;FF?FNIILA;HCM;NCIH;FF?;LHCHAQCNBCHQBC=BNB?L?;L? =IH=?JNMNB;N F?H>M Q?FF NI NB? M=IJ? I@ NBCM NB?MCM ;FMI M?? /;J?L ((( 3BCM F?;LHCHA NB?ILS A?H?L;FFS >CMNCHAOCMB?M <?NQ??H NBL?? F?;LHCHA F?P?FM QBC=B ;L? CH=L?;MCHAFS CGJ;=NCHANB?@OH>;G?HN;F<;MCMI@BIQNB?F?;LHCHA;@@?=NMNB?F?;LHCHA ILA;HC

(131) M;NCIH C ? JIFC=SG;E?LMCHNB?=;M?I@ NBCMNB?MCM 3BCMCM>CPC>?>CHNI MCHAF?

(132) FIIJ >IO<F?

(133) FIIJ ;H> >?ON?LI F?;LHCHA ;FMI M?? 2?=NCIH -2+0)0334 0)%62-2+ I==OLM QB?H NB? ILA;HCM;NCIH <?=IG? ;Q;L? I@ ;H I<MN;=F? IL ?LLIL QBC=B CM NB?H MCGJFS =ILL?=N?> 3BCM =IHNLC<ON?M NI ;H CH=L?;M?> EHIQF?>A?

(134) <;M? QCNBCH NB? ILA;HCM;NCIH 39&0)0334 0)%62-2+ CM GIL? @OH>;G?HN;F ;H> L?MOFNM CH NB? ILA;HCM;NCIH KO?MNCIHCHA CNM G;H;A?G?HN JIFC=C?M ?N= <;M?> IH QB;N CM F?;LHN ;<IONNB?=ILL?=N?>I<MN;=F? !?MC>?MQC>?HCHANB?EHIQF?>A?<;M? >IO<F?

(135) FIIJ F?;LHCHA=B;HA?MNB?G;H;A?G?HNLIONCH?M;CG?>NI;>>L?MMNB?MIOL=?I@ ;H> JL?P?HN NB? JLI<F?G )98)63 0)%62-2+ I==OLM QB?H ILA;HCM;NCIHM F?;LH ;<ION BIQNI;==IGJFCMB >IO<F?

(136) FIIJF?;LHCHA 3BCMG?;HMNB;NNB?ILA;HCM;NCIHL?;FCM?M NB;N F?;LHCHA H??>M NI I==OL ;H> NB;N NB? =IGJ?N?H=?M @IL NBCM H??>M NI <? =L?;N?> NBLIOAB >?P?FIJCHA H?Q MNL;N?AC?M @IL F?;LHCHA 3BCM CH=FO>?M F?;LHCHA ;<IONQBC=BG?;MOL?MNB;NCML?KOCL?>NIF?;LH !;M?>IHNBCM NBCMNB?MCM ;CGMNI =IHNLC<ON?NI;FFNBL??NSJ?MI@F?;LHCHANBLIOABBCABFCABNCHAI<MN;=F?M ;P;CF;<F? JIFC=S ?RJ?LC?H=?M ;H> BIQ NBCM F?;LHCHA =;H <? IJ?L;NCIH;FCM?> 4FNCG;N?FS BIQ?P?L NB? NB?MCM ;CGM NI CH>O=? >?ON?LI F?;LHCHA NBLIOAB BCABFCABNCHA NB? H??>;H><?H?@CNMI@/+OH>?L=OLL?HN=IH>CNCIHM 6B?NB?LILHIN ILL;NB?L;NQBC=BF?P?F NB;N/+I==OLM FIAC=;FFS>C@@?LM '?H=? MI >I?M NB? H??> NI CH>O=? F?;LHCHA ;H> JLIPC>? L?=IGG?H>;NCIHM @IL >ICHA MI 2IG? @;=NILM NB;N CH@FO?H=? ;H> L?MOFN CH F?;LHCHA P;LC;NCIHM ;L? >C@@?L?H=?M <?NQ??H L?ACIHM ;H> JIFC=S ;L?;M <?NQ??H QBC=B ;=NILM NB;N F?;LHCHA I==OLM >?P?FIJG?HNMIP?LNCG? JIFCNC=;F=OFNOL?M J;LNSJIFCNC=M =LCM?M ?N= %IL?R;GJF? H?I

(137) =ILJIL;NCMN IL H?I

(138) FC<?L;F JIFC=SG;E?LM G;S <? GIL? ;=NCP? CH ;FFIQCHA IJCHCIHM @LIG <OMCH?MM NI <? B?;L> &L??H J;LNC?M G;S <? JLIH? NI FCMN?H NI -&.M +?@NAIP?LHG?HNMF?;LHCHA@LIG NL;>?

(139) OHCIHM;H> INB?LF?@NAIP?LHG?HNM ?N= -?P?LNB?F?MM NBCM>I?MHING?;HNB;NF?;LHCHAI==OLM BIQ?P?LG?;HCHANB;N ;L?H;M@IL>C;FIAO?G;S<?@;=CFCN;N?> 3B? P;LSCHA F?P?FMI@/+ NB;NCMC>?HNC@C?> CH FCN?L;NOL? >IHINJLIPC>?;=IH=FOMCP? ?PC>?H=? I@ QB?H/+I==OLMILHIN 2??CHANB;N =FCG;N?=B;HA?CM;L?=?HN ?G?L

(140). . %ILGIL?CH@ILG;NCIHIHMCHAF?;H>>IO<F?F?;LHCHAFIIJM JF?;M?M?? ? A LASLCM MCGCF;LCHN?LJL?N;NCIHI@MCHAF?;H>>IO<F?

(141) FIIJF?;LHCHA;L? FIQ?L

(142) F?P?F;H>BCAB?L

(143) F?P?F F?;LHCHA%CIF;H>+SF?M .

(144) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. A?HN JIFC=S ;L?; C>?HNC@SCHA ?PC>?H=? I@ F?;LHCHA CM ?P?H F?MM I<PCIOM >O? NI FCGCN?> NCG? MJ;H I@ F?;LHCHA I==OLLCHA ;H> ?PC>?H=? NB?L?I@ B?H=? <?CHA JLI

(145) PC>?> 3B?L? ;L? BIQ?P?L MIG? MNO>C?M NB;N ;L? I@ CHN?L?MN %LIG ; J;MN J?LMJ?=NCP? !?HH?N ;H> 'IQF?NN C>?HNC@C?> NB;N QBCF? /+ Q;M Q?FF L?

(146) M?;L=B?> CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? CN Q;M F?MM ;JJFC?> <S JIFC=SG;E?LM 3B? ;ONBIL B;M MNO>C?>NB?MO<D?=NCH/;J?L(2?=NCIH QB?L?CNCM=IH=FO>?>NB;NNB??PC>?H=? JICHNMNIQ;L>;FIQF?P?FI@/+N;ECHAJF;=? 1?A;L>F?MM BIQ?P?L NBCMNB?MCMQCFF JICHN NI ; HOG<?L I@ JIN?HNC;F ;H> JF;OMC<F? I<MN;=F?M ILCACH;NCHA @LIG ; HIP?F =FCG;N?JIFC=S@L;G?QILE MMO=B ;H>>O? NIINB?LFCN?L;NOL?NB;NCML?@?LL?>NI CHNB?L?MOFNM;H>;JJ?H>?>J;J?LM NB?H??>@IL/+CM?GJB;MCM?>. .

(147) . 630*@4(2,9:(5+05+<:;9@. /IFC=SG;E?LM;H> CH>OMNLS 3BCM 2?=NCIH QCFF JLIPC>? ; GIL? =IGJL?B?HMCP? <;=EALIOH> CHNI NB? LIF?M ;H> L?MJIHMC<CFCNC?MI@JIFC=SG;E?LM;H>CH>OMNLS 3B?JOLJIM? CM NI?RJF;CHBIQNB?M? ;=NIL ALIOJM ;L? PC?Q?> QCNBCH NB? ;JJ?H>?> J;J?LM ;H> NBOM NI CGJLIP? NB? L?;>?LcM OH>?LMN;H>CHA I@ NB? MO<M?KO?HN M?=NCIHM 3BCM 2?=NCIH ;FMI JLIPC>?M ; GIL?A?H?L;FPC?QI@BIQQBC=BCHP?MNG?HNI<MN;=F?MNB;NJIFC=C?MG;S?MN;<FCMB 3B?M?MBIOF><?M??H;MJ;L;FF?F;H> NI;H?RN?HN CHN?LFCHE?>QCNBNB?I<MN;=F?M C>?HNC@C?> CH NB? L?M?;L=B 2?=NCIH 3B?S ;L? CH=FO>?> B?L? NI JLIPC>? ; GIL? =IGJL?B?HMCP? PC?Q I@ BIQ NB? JIFC=S @L;G?QILE ;@@?=NM CH>OMNLS CHP?MNG?HNM 2??CHA NB;N NBCM NB?MCM >?;FM QCNB CH>OMNLS J?L=?JNCIHM NBCM 2?=NCIH @OLNB?LGIL? >CM=OMM?MNB?=L?>C<CFCNSI@MO=BJ?L=?JNCIHM;H>NB?=IHM?KO?H=?MI@EHIQF?>A? ;MSGG?NLC?M. . "/, 963,(5+9,:765:0)030;0,: 6-.6=,954,5;:. &IP?LHG?HNM ;H> JIFC=SG;E?LM B;P? NB? L?MJIHMC<CFCNS NI AOC>? NB? =IOHNLScM >?P?FIJG?HN NIQ;L>M NB? =IGGIHAII> I@MI=C?NS 3BCMG?;HM CHNB?=IHN?RNI@ NBCM NB?MCM NI ;MM?LN NB;N NB? CH>OMNLS L?>O=? NB?CL =;L<IH >CIRC>? ?GCMMCIHM ;==IL>CHANI H;NCIH;F =FCG;N? N;LA?NM;H>MOJL;H;NCIH;F=IGGCNG?HNM (HIL>?L NI ;==IGJFCMBNBCM AIP?LHG?HNMG;SCGJF?G?HN >C@@?L?HNJIFC=S CHMNLOG?HNMNB;N. . (N=;H;FMI<?;LAO?>NB;NAIP?LHG?HNM>O?NI?NBC=;FL?MJIHMC<CFCNC?MMBIOF>AI<?SIH> =OLL?HN N;LA?NM CH FCABN I@ M=C?HNC@C= @CH>CHAM NB;N GIL? @;L

(148) L?;=BCHA MBILN ;H> FIHA

(149) N?LG ?GCMMCIH L?>O=NCIH N;LA?NM NB;H NBIM? =OLL?HNFS ?MN;<FCMB?> MBIOF> <? ;=BC?P?> NI ;PIC> M?P?L?CGJ;=NMI@=FCG;N?=B;HA? .

(150) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. L?KOCL? @CH;H=? IL CH=?HNCPCM? CH>OMNLC;F CHP?MNG?HNM CH ?GCMMCIH ;<;N?G?HN G?;MOL?M 3BCMCH=FO>?M<;F;H=CHANB?LCMEM ;H>L?Q;L>MI@ NB?M? CHP?MNG?HNM ;M Q?FF;ML?GIPCHA<INBJIFC=S;H>INB?LI<MN;=F?M NB;NCGJ?>?CHP?MNG?HNM 3B? $OLIJ?;H4HCIH$4 B;M?MN;<FCMB?>NB?AI;F I@FCGCNCHA NB?AFI<;FN?GJ?L;

(151) NOL? CH=L?;M? ;M ; L?MOFN I@ =FCG;N? =B;HA? NI U" $OLIJ?;H "IGGCMMCIH ; 3B? (/""; B;MC>?HNC@C?> NB;NE??JCHANB?N?GJ?L;NOL?CH=L?;M?NI.

(152) U"QCFFL?KOCL?&'&?GCMMCIHL?>O=NCIHMI@

(153) NI=IGJ;L?>NI F?P?FM 3BCM M=?H;LCI G?;HM NB;N ?GCMMCIH GOMN J?;E <?NQ??H

(154) >>CHANI NB?OLA?H=S I@;=NCHA ;L?NB?@CH>CHAMI@NB?2N?LH1?JILNNB;NNB?=IMNM I@ ?;LFS G?;MOL?M QCFF <? MCAHC@C=;HNFS FIQ?L NB;H >?;FCHA QCNB BCAB?L &'& =IH=?HNL;NCIHMCHNB?FIHA?LN?LG 2N?LH #?F;SCHA;=NCIHHIQQIOF>G?;H NB;NF;LA?L=ONMQIOF><? H??>?>CHNB?@ONOL?NI=OL<NB??GCMMCIHMNL?H>M;H> >?;F QCNB ; BCAB?L =IH=?HNL;NCIH I@ &'&M CH NB? ;NGIMJB?L? 3B? G;AHCNO>? I@ NB?;<;N?G?HNG?;MOL?MH??>?> G?;HMNB;NNB?SQCFF<?=IMNFS;H> NBOM >C@@C=OFN NI CGJF?G?HN H?=?MMCN;NCHA NB;N =FCG;N? JIFC=C?M JLIGIN? NB?M? G?;MOL?M ;H> CHP?MNG?HNM ;N FIQ?MN =IMN .$"# '?H=? NB? =OLL?HN =FCG;N? ;A?H>; MBIOF>JLIGIN? MCAHC@C=;HN?GCMMCIH;<;N?G?HNM ;M L?KOCL?>CH<INB NB?MBILN;H> FIHA

(155) N?LG@ONOL? H> NBCMMBIOF><?;=BC?P?>CH;=IMN

(156) =IHN;CHCHA@;MBCIH 'IQ?P?L CH>OMNLC;F JIFC=S A?H?L;FFS MJ?=C@C?M NB;N =FCG;N? JIFC=C?M GOMN HIN CHN?L@?L? QCNBNB?H;NCIH;F=IGJ?NCNCP?H?MM 2Q?>CMBJIFC=C?M @IL?R;GJF? =F?;LFS MNCJOF;N? NB;N =FCG;N? ;H> ?H?LAS JIFC=C?M GOMN =IHMC>?L CH>OMNLC;F =IGJ?NCNCP?

(157) H?MM &IP?LHG?HN .@@C=?M I@ 2Q?>?H ; < 3B? MCNO;NCIH CM MCGCF;L CH NB?$4 CHL?F;NCIHNINB? ,?G<?L2N;N?McCH>OMNLC?M$OLIJ?;H"IGGCMMCIH %LIG;HCHN?LH;NCIH;FJ?LMJ?=NCP? NB?4-%""";FMIBCABFCABNNB;NH;NCIH;F =FCG;N?JIFC=C?MMBIOF><?=IMN

(158) ?@@C=C?HN 4- 3BIOAB ;M/;J?L((>CM=OMM?M NB?L? ;L? INB?L ;MJ?=NM <?MC>?M =IMN

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b ; L?MOFN I@ NB? AFI<;F =FCG;N? =B;HA? ;A?H>; b G?;HM NB;N H;NCIH;F JIFC=SG;E?LM B;P? L?MNLC=N?> ;ONIHIGS CH >?MCAHCHA NB? H;NCIH;F =FCG;N? JIFC=S @L;G?QILE !?MC>?M 4-%""" .

(160) . 630*@4(2,9:(5+05+<:;9@. H?AINC;NCIHM NBCM ;JJFC?M @IL ?R;GJF? CH NB? $4 QB?L? ,?G<?L 2N;N?M ;<C>? OH>?L4HCIHcMF?ACMF;NCP?JIQ?LM 3B?L?CM ;M;L?MOFN ;HCH=L?;M?>JL?MMOL? ;H> OLA?H=S@IL H;NCIH;FJIFC=SG;E?LMNI>?MCAHJIFC=C?MNB;N JLIN?=N NB? =IGJ?NCNCP?

(161) H?MM I@ NB?>IG?MNC= CH>OMNLC?M 3BCMCH=FO>?MNB;NJIFC=SG;E?LMB;MNI <? @F?RC<F? NI=B;HA?MCHNB?JIFC=S?HPCLIHG?HN 3BCMCM?GJB;MCM?><SNB?OH=?LN;CHNC?MNB;N MOLLIOH>MNB?MOJL;H;NCIH;F;A?H>;M MO=B;MQB?NB?LNB?J;LNC?MI@NB?4-%""" QCFF=IG?NI;H;AL??G?HN;N NB?"./CH"IJ?HB;A?H;H> NB?MJ?=C@C=>?MCAHI@ MO=B;H;AL??G?HN 3B?MCNO;NCIHCMJ;L;FF?FCHNB?$4 QB?L?NB?$H?LAS$H>

(162) 4M? #CL?=NCP? $" MNCJOF;N?M NB;N ;H ?H?LAS ?@@C=C?H=S =?LNC@C=;N?M M=B?G? G;S <? @IL=?> C@ NB? ,?G<?L 2N;N?Mc @;CF NI L?;=B NB? ?MN;<FCMB?> ?H?LAS ?@@C

(163) =C?H=SN;LA?NM A;CHMNNBCM<;=EALIOH> NB?JIFC=SG;ECHAL?MJIHMC<CFCNC?M;FMICH=FO>?GIHCNILCHA ;H>?P;FO;NCHANB?@OH=NCIHI@NB?CGJF?G?HN?>JIFC=S@L;G?QILE ;H>CNM?@@?=NM ?MJ?=C;FFSM??CHA NB? =IGJF?R;H>=B;HACHA JIFC=S?HPCLIHG?HN 3BCMG?;HMNB;N ;H CN?L;NCP?F?;LHCHAJLI=?MM ?P;FO;NCHAJIN?HNC;F;H>@;=NO;FJIFC=SJLI<F?GM;H> MIFONCIHM MBIOF> <?J;LNI@NB?JIFC=SG;E?LMc;A?H>;M. . "/,963,(5+9,:765:0)030;0,:6-05+<:;90,:. 3B? CH>OMNLS M?=NILM MNO>C?> CH NBCM NB?MCM ;L? PC?Q?> ;M JLCP;N?FS IQH?> ;H> FCMN?>IHNB?MNI=E?R=B;HA? ;MNBCMCMGIMN=IGGIHCH G;LE?N?=IHIGC?M 3BCM G?;HMNB;N NB?LIF?M;H>L?MJIHMC<CFCNC?M I@CH>OMNLC;F;=NILM CH=FO>?NB;N NB?S ;L? <IOH><SF?A;FMNCJOF;NCIHMNIIJ?L;N?NB?CL<OMCH?MM?MCH;H?=IHIGC=;FFSMIOH> G;HH?L ;H> GOMN ;CG NI JLIPC>? ; P;FO? @IL NB?CL MB;L?BIF>?LM 3B?S ;L? @OL

(164) NB?LGIL?<IOH>NIIJ?L;N?QCNBCH NB?F?A;F@L;G?QILE MO=B;M NB;N ?MN;<FCMB?> <S=FCG;N?JIFC=C?M %LIGNBCM@IFFIQM NB;NIH?=;HHIN?RJ?=NCH>OMNLC?MNICHP?MN CH;<;N?G?HN;=NCPCNC?MNB;N>IHING;E?<OMCH?MMM?HM? (NBIQ?P?L;FMIG?;HM NB;N;HSCH>OMNLSNB;N>I?MHINFCP?OJNIF?A;FMNCJOF;NCIHMMBIOF>@;=?J?H;FNC?M I@ MO=B ; G;AHCNO>? NB;N J?LP?LM? I<D?=NCP?M NI G;RCGCM? JLI@CN NI NB? =IMN I@ =FCG;N?CGJ;=N CM>?N?LL?>. . 2IG?FCMN?>CH>OMNLC?MG;S<?MN;N?IQH?> (NCMBIQ?P?L?GJB;MCM?>NB;NJIFC=SG;E?LM B;P?HI>?=CMCIH

(165) G;ECHAJIQ?LQCNBCHNB?MNO>C?>CH>OMNLC?M .

(166) "/,05+<:;9@963,057630*@4(205.630*@3,(9505.05*304(;,7630;0*:. 3BCM@??>MCHNI;H ?MM?HNC;FNB?ILSI@ NBCMNB?MCM H;G?FS NB;NAIP?LHG?HNM=;HHIN L?>O=??GCMMCIHMNB?GM?FP?M M NB? G;DILCNSI@NB?QILF>cMCH>OMNLC;F?GCMMCIHM ILCACH;N?@LIG JLCP;N?FSIQH?> IJ?L;NCIHM NB?>?=CMCIH

(167) G;ECHAJIQ?LCH;<;N?

(168) G?HN CHP?MNG?HNM FC?M IONMC>? I@ NB? JO<FC= AIP?LH;H=? 3BCM G?;HM NB;N NB? AIP?LHG?HNM;L?>?J?H>?HNIHNB?CH>OMNLS ;MQ?FF;MINB?LMI=C?N;FM?=NILM NI ;==IGJFCMBNB?CL=FCG;N?;A?H>; ,IL?IP?L CH>OMNLC?MJF;S;HCGJILN;HNLIF?HIN IHFS ;M CHP?MNILM CH ;<;N?G?HN G?;MOL?M <ON ;FMI ;M JLIPC>?LM I@ AII>M ;H> N?=BHIFIAC?M '?H=? NB? CH>OMNLS M?=NIL MNLIHAFS CH@FO?H=?M ?GCMMCIHM CH INB?L MI=C?N;FM?=NILM 3B?LIF?NB;NCH>OMNLSJF;SM;M;<;N?G?HN>?=CMCIH

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

No results found