TEKNISK RAPPORT. Partialkoefficienter för hållfasthet i betongbroar längs Malmbanan. Martin Nilsson, Ulf Ohlsson, Lennart Elfgren.

Martin Nilsson, Ulf Ohlsson, Lennart Elfgren

Partialkoefficienter för hållfasthet i betongbroar längs Malmbanan

TEKNISK RAPPORT

Teknisk rapport

Institutionen för Väg- och vattenbyggnad Avdelningen för Konstruktionsteknik

1999:03 • ISSN: 1402-1536 • ISRN: LTU-TR--99/03--SE

EHWRQJEURDUOlQJV0DOPEDQDQ

0DUWLQ

0$57,11,/6621 8/)2+/6621 /(11$57(/)*5(1

$YGHOQLQJHQ I|U .RQVWUXNWLRQVWHNQLN ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ I|U 9lJ RFK 9DWWHQE\JJQDG

/XOHn WHNQLVND XQLYHUVLWHW

  /XOHn

3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUI|UKnOOIDVWKHWL EHWRQJEURDUOlQJV0DOPEDQDQ

0DUWLQ

0$57,11,/6621 8/)2+/6621 /(11$57(/)*5(1

.RQVWUXNWLRQVWHNQLNYLG/XOHnWHNQLVNDXQLYHUVLWHW6\QSXQNWHURFKNRPPHQ

WDUHUSnSUHOLPLQlUDYHUVLRQHUKDUOlPQDWVDY/DUVgVWOXQG6WXUHcNHUOXQG5R

EHUW 5RQQHEUDQW RFK 3HU gYIHUEHFN (Q UHIHUHQVJUXSS IUnQ %DQYHUNHW PHG EOD +nNDQ .HOOQHU %M|UQ 7|\Ul /DUV gVWU|P RFK .HQ 5\EHUJ KDU LQLWLHUDW RFKVW\UWDUEHWHW

/XOHnLVHSWHPEHU

0DUWLQ1LOVVRQ 8OI2KOVVRQ /HQQDUW(OIJUHQ

9

6DPPDQIDWWQLQJ

'HQQDWHNQLVNDUDSSRUWUHGRYLVDUWYnPHWRGHUDWWEHVWlPPDQ\DQVHUDGHYlUGHQ Sn EHWRQJKnOOIDVWKHWHQV SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHU I|U EHILQWOLJD EHWRQJEURDU OlQJV 0DOPEDQDQ5DSSRUWHQSUHVHQWHUDUGlUHIWHUGLPHQVLRQHUDQGHGUDJRFKWU\FN

KnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQI|UVMXEURDUPHOODQ/XOHnRFK%RGHQ'HVVDKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQ lUEDVHUDGHGHOVSnGHQ\DSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDGHOVSnSURYUHVXOWDW7KXQHWDO 3URYUHVXOWDWHQOLJJHUWLOOJUXQGI|UNDUDNWHULVWLVNDKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQVRP EHVWlPWVHQOLJW%%.

3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUI|UKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQDηγ_PKDUEHVWlPWVPHGYDGVRPLUDS

SRUWHQEHQlPQVWDEHOOPHWRGHQRFKVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG7DEHOOPHWRGHQ lUKlPWDGIUnQ1.%RFK 1.%  0HWRGHQ E\JJHU VRP QDPQHW LQGLNHUDUSnWDEHOOHUYDUXUI\UDGHOIDNWRUHUWLOOSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_PEHVWlPV

)DNWRUHUQDEHKDQGODURVlNHUKHWHULNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHQRFKLI|UKnOODQGHW PHOODQKnOOIDVWKHWLNRQVWUXNWLRQRFKLSURYNURSSHWFRVlNHUKHWHULEHUlN

QLQJVPRGHOOHUEURWWNDUDNWlUVHJWHOOHUVSU|WWRFKRPIDWWQLQJHQDYNRQ

WUROO YLG XSSI|UDQGHW DY EURDUQD 'HQ VDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVND PHWRGHQ I|U DWW EHVWlPPD SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_P WDU L VLQ WXU RFNVn KlQV\Q WLOO RVlNHUKHWHU L NDUDNWHULVWLVND YlUGHQ L I|UKnOODQGHW PHOODQ KnOOIDVWKHW L NRQVWUXNWLRQ RFK L SURYNURSSRFKRVlNHUKHWHULEHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHU0HWRGHQWDUlYHQPHGSDUWL

DONRHIILFLHQWHUI|UODVWHUYLONDKlUKDUVDWWVWLOOQRUPHQOLJDYlUGHQI|UXWRPWnJ

ODVWHQV SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ₄ VRP VDWWV WLOO  HQOLJW HQ XWUHGQLQJ DY gVWOXQG L ELODJD $γ₄ DQYlQGV KlUHQGDVW YLGVWDWLVWLVND EHUlNQLQJDU RFK JRGWDVGlUI|ULQWHDY%DQYHUNHW,QYHUNDQDYWnJODVWRFKODVWDYEHWRQJRFKEDOO

DVWLQJnUbYHQEURDUQDVLQGLYLGXHOODOlQJGHUEHDNWDVGnWnJODVWHUQDVG\QDPLVND I|UVWRULQJVIDNWRUHUEHVWlPV

5HVXOWDWHQ DY EHVWlPQLQJ DY SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_P PHG WDEHOOPHWRGHQ RFK GHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQJHUI|UGHVMXEURDUQDPHOODQ/XOHnRFK%R

GHQQnJRWVNLOGDUHVXOWDW7DEHOOPHWRGHQJHUJHQHUHOOWK|JUHYlUGHQlQGHQVDQ

QROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVND PHWRGHQ 7DEHOOPHWRGHQV YlUGHQ YDULHUDU PHOODQ  RFK

I|UGUDJKnOOIDVWKHWHQRFKPHOODQRFKI|UWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHQ9lU

GHQDIUnQGHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQOLJJHUFDOlJUH9LI|URUGDUL I|UVWDKDQGSnJUXQGDYVLQHQNHOKHWDWWWDEHOOPHWRGHQDQYlQGVYLGEHVWlPQLQJ DY SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_P 'HQ VDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVND PHWRGHQ lU QnJRW PHU NRPSOLFHUDGRFKPnVWHRIWDNRPSOHWWHUDVPHGNYDOLILFHUDGHEHG|PQLQJDU

'H GLPHQVLRQHUDQGH KnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQD VRP EHVWlPV L UDSSRUWHQ lU EHW\GOLJW K|JUHlQGHYlUGHQVRPI|UHVNULYQDKnOOIDVWKHWVNODVVHUJHU'HQVW|UVWDLQYHUNDQ SnGHWWDKDUGHSURYDGHKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQDVRPOLJJHUYlVHQWOLJW|YHUGHI|UH

VNULYQDYlUGHQD3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDVLQYHUNDQlUPLQGUH

9,

5DSSRUWHQ DYVOXWDV PHG HQ GLVNXVVLRQRP LQYHUNDQ DY KnOOIDVWKHWHQV YDULDWLRQ LQRPNRQVWUXNWLRQVGHODUYLONHQNDQKDVWRULQYHUNDQSnElUI|UPnJDQ/LNDVnKDU OlJHWI|UXWWDJQDSURYNURSSDULI|UKnOODQGHWLOODNWXHOOWEHUlNQLQJVVQLWWEHW\GHOVH

%nGDGHVVDIDNWRUHUE|ULQJnYLGHQEHVWlPQLQJDYKnOOIDVWKHWHUVSDUWLDONRHIILFL

HQWHULEHILQWOLJDNRQVWUXNWLRQHU

9,,

$EVWUDFW

7KLVWHFKQLFDOUHSRUWSUHVHQWVWZRPHWKRGVWRGHWHUPLQHSDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWVIRU FRQFUHWH VWUHQJWK 7KH FRHIILFLHQWV DUH XVHG WR GHWHUPLQH GHVLJQ YDOXHV RI VWUHQJWK LQ VHYHQ H[LVWLQJ FRQFUHWH EULGJHV EHWZHHQ /XOHn DQG %RGHQ DORQJ 0DOPEDQDQ 0DOPEDQDQ LV D UDLOZD\ OLQH EHWZHHQ 1DUYLN LQ 1RUZD\ DQG /XOHnLQ6ZHGHQEXLOWDURXQGIRUWKHWUDQVSRUWDWLRQRILURQRUH7KHGH

VLJQYDOXHVDUHGHWHUPLQHGSDUWO\ZLWKFKDUDFWHULVWLFYDOXHVRIVWUHQJWKIURPWHVW UHVXOWV7KXQHWDOSDUWO\ZLWKWKHSDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWV7KHFKDUDFWHULVWLF YDOXHV RI WKH FRQFUHWH VWUHQJWK LV GHWHUPLQHG DQG FDOFXODWHG DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH 6ZHGLVKFRQFUHWHFRGH%%.

3DUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWVIRUVWUHQJWKηγ_PKDYHEHHQFDOFXODWHGZLWKWZRPHWKRGVD WDEOHPHWKRGDVGHVLJQDWHGLQWKHUHSRUWDQGDSUREDELOLVWLFPHWKRG7KHWDEOH PHWKRGZDVGHYHORSHGLQ1.%DQG1.%7KHPHWKRGFRQVLVWV RIDVWKHQDPHLQGLFDWHVWDEOHVIURPZKLFKIDFWRUVRIWKHSDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWηγ_P DUHEHLQJGHWHUPLQHG7KHIDFWRUVGHDOZLWKXQFHUWDLQWLHVLQWKHFKDUDFWHULV

WLFYDOXHVDQGLQWKHUDWLREHWZHHQWKHFRQFUHWHVWUHQJWKLQWKHVWUXFWXUHDQGLQ WKHWHVWVSHFLPHQVXQFHUWDLQWLHVLQWKHGHVLJQPRGHOVWKHFKDUDFWHURI IDLOXUH GXFWLOH RU EULWWOH DQG  WKH DPRXQW RI TXDOLW\ FRQWURO ZKHQ WKH EULGJHVZHUHEXLOW7KHSUREDELOLVWLFPHWKRGIRUGHWHUPLQLQJWKHSDUWLDOFRHIIL

FLHQWηγ_P GRHV DOVR WDNH LQWR FRQVLGHUDWLRQ XQFHUWDLQWLHV LQ WKH FKDUDFWHULVWLF YDOXHVLQWKHUDWLREHWZHHQWKHFRQFUHWHVWUHQJWKLQWKHVWUXFWXUHDQGLQWKHWHVW VSHFLPHQV DQG XQFHUWDLQWLHV LQ WKH GHVLJQ PRGHOV 7KH PHWKRG DOVR LQFOXGHV SDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWVIRUORDGVZKLFKLQWKLVUHSRUWDUHJLYHQYDOXHVDFFRUGLQJWR WKHFRGHVH[FHSWWKHSDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWRIWKHWUDLQORDGηγ₄JLYHQWKHYDOXH

DFFRUGLQJWRDQLQYHVWLJDWLRQE\gVWOXQGLQFOXGHGDV$SSHQGL[$γ₄ LVKHUHRQO\XVHGIRUVWDWLVWLFDOFDOFXODWLRQVDQGLVQRWDFFHSWHGE\%DQYHU

NHWWKH6ZHGLVK1DWLRQDO5DLOURDG$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ7KHLQIOXHQFHVRIWKHWUDLQ ORDGDVZHOODVWKHORDGVIURPWKHFRQFUHWHDQGWKHEDOODVWDUHLQFOXGHG,QDGGL

WLRQWKHLQGLYLGXDOOHQJWKVRIHDFKEULGJHDUHUHJDUGHGZKHQWKHG\QDPLFDP

SOLILFDWLRQIDFWRUVIRUWKHWUDLQORDGVDUHGHWHUPLQHG

'HWHUPLQDWLRQ RI WKH SDUWLDO FRHIILFLHQWηγ_P ZLWK WKH WDEOH PHWKRG DQG WKH SUREDELOLVWLFPHWKRGJLYHVVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQWUHVXOWVIRUWKHVHYHQEULGJHVEHWZHHQ /XOHn DQG %RGHQ 7KH WDEOH PHWKRG JLYHV JHQHUDOO\ KLJKHU YDOXHV WKDQ WKH SUREDELOLVWLF PHWKRG 7KH YDOXHV RI WKH WDEOH PHWKRG YDU\ EHWZHHQ  DQG

 IRU WKH WHQVLOH VWUHQJWK DQG EHWZHHQ  DQG  IRU WKH FRPSUHVVLYH VWUHQJWK 7KH SUREDELOLVWLF PHWKRG UHVXOWV JHQHUDOO\ LQ FD  ORZHU YDOXHV

7KHUHSRUWUHFRPPHQGVDVDILUVWFKRLFHWKHWDEOHPHWKRGIRUGHWHUPLQLQJWKH

9,,,

SDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWηγ_P,WLVHDVLHUWRXVHWKDQWKHSUREDELOLVWLFPHWKRGZKLFKLV PRUHFRPSOLFDWHGDQGRIWHQLQQHHGRIDGGLWLRQDOMXGJHPHQWDQGGHOLEHUDWLRQ

7KHGHVLJQYDOXHVRIWKHFRQFUHWHVWUHQJWKWKDWDUHGHWHUPLQHGLQWKHUHSRUWDUH FRQVLGHUDEO\ KLJKHU WKDQ YDOXHV DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH VWUHQJWK FODVVHV EHLQJ SUH

VFULEHGZKHQWKHEULGJHVZHUHEXLOW7KHODUJHVWLQIOXHQFHRQWKLVKDVWKHWHVWHG VWUHQJWKYDOXHVRIWKHFRQFUHWH7KHLQIOXHQFHRIWKHSDUWLDOFRHIILFLHQWVLVOHVV

7KH UHSRUW HQGV ZLWK D GLVFXVVLRQ DERXW WKH LQIOXHQFH RI VWUHQJWK YDULDWLRQ ZLWKLQ VWUXFWXUHV RQ WKH ORDG EHDULQJ FDSDFLW\ ,Q DGGLWLRQ WKH SRVLWLRQV RI GULOOHG WHVW VSHFLPHQV LQ UHODWLRQ WR DFWXDO GHVLJQ VHFWLRQV GR LQIOXHQFH %RWK WKHVH IDFWRUV VKRXOG EH LQFOXGHG LQ D GHWHUPLQDWLRQ RI SDUWLDO FRHIILFLHQWV RI VWUHQJWKLQH[LVWLQJVWUXFWXUHV

,;

,QQHKnOOVI|UWHFNQLQJ

)g525',,, 6$00$1)$771,1* 9

$%675$&7 9,,

 ,1/('1,1*

 $OOPlQW  

 6lNHUKHWVNODVVRFKVlNHUKHWVLQGH[ 

 6lNHUKHWVNODVV  

 6lNHUKHWVLQGH[β 

 6DQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG  

 $OOPlQW  

 /DVWHIIHNW 

 %lUI|UPnJD 

 'LPHQVLRQHULQJVYLOONRU 

 3$57,$/.2()),&,(170(72'(17,//b03$'3c

%b5)g50c*$  

 ,QOHGQLQJ 

 1RUPYlUGHQ 

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_P 

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQη 

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_Q 

 $OWHUQDWLYDYlUGHQ  

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQ 

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_PHQOLJWVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG  

 7,//b031,1*3c%(721*%52$5 

 ([HPSHOSnEHUlNQLQJDYγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQ  

 6MXYHUNOLJDEURDU  

 ,QOHGQLQJ 

 .DUDNWHULVWLVNGUDJRFKWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHW  

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRG 

 'LPHQVLRQHUDQGHGUDJRFKWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHW 

;

 .200(17$5(52&+6/876$76(5 

 5()(5(16(5 

%,/$*$$ 6WXGLXPDYHUIRUGHUOLJWYlUGHSnSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQI|U WnJODVW YLG GLPHQVLRQHULQJ DY MlUQYlJVEURDU 8WUHGQLQJ DY/DUVgVWOXQGGHFHPEHU$

%,/$*$% 3ULQFLSHUI|UHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGRFKI|USDU

WLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQXU$.%



 ,QOHGQLQJ

 $OOPlQW

(QDOOPlQEDNJUXQGWLOOKlUEHKDQGODGHIUnJRUJHVL1.%RFK$.

%%.%HQJWVVRQHWDO(&RFK.|QLJ HWDO

(Q NRQVWUXNWLRQ HOOHU HWW NRQVWUXNWLRQVHOHPHQW VNDOO GLPHQVLRQHUDV Vn DWW GHW ILQQVHQSnI|UKDQGEHVWlPGVDQQROLNKHWDWWLQWHQnJRWDYGHUHOHYDQWDJUlQVWLOO

VWnQGHQ|YHUVNULGV

6lNHUKHWVYlUGHULQJHQNDQJHQRPI|UDVXWLIUnQI|OMDQGHVlNHUKHWVPHWRGHU

SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQ

GHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQ

6lNHUKHWPRWEURWWLHQNRQVWUXNWLRQNDQXSSVNDWWDVPHGHQPRWVWnQGVSDUDPH

WHU5^ElUI|UPnJDRFKHQSnNlQQLQJVSDUDPHWHU6^ODVWHIIHNW

%HURHQGHSnGHWYnSDUDPHWUDUQDVLQE|UGHVVWRUOHNDUJlOOHUDWW

≥ ⇒HMEURWW

5 6 

< ⇒EURWW

5 6 

.UDYHW Sn HQ ElUDQGH NRQVWUXNWLRQ VYDUDQGH PRW HWW JLYHW JUlQVWLOOVWnQG NDQ DQVHV XSSI\OOW QlU GHW SnYLVDV DWW EHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQΘ⋅ XSSI\OOHU I|OMDQGH NUDY

(

)

Θ 

GlU

Q lUDQWDOHWODVWHU

ψ_L lUHQIDNWRUVRPWDUKlQV\QWLOOHQODVWVYDULDWLRQLWLGHQRFKVRP DQYlQGVLVDPEDQGPHGNRPELQHULQJDYYDULDEODODVWHU

)_LG GLPHQVLRQHUDQGHODVWYlUGH

I_G GLPHQVLRQHUDQGHKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGH

O_G GLPHQVLRQHUDQGHJHRPHWULVNSDUDPHWHU

*UlQVWLOOVWnQGHWNDQLPnQJDIDOOXWWU\FNDVPHGElUI|UPnJDQ5RFKODVWHIIHNWHQ

6VRP



5 RFK 6 DQYlQGV DOOPlQW LQWHUQDWLRQHOOW I|U DWW XWWU\FND ElUI|UPnJD RFK ODVWHIIHNW 'H NRPPHU IUnQ GH IUDQVND RUGHQ UpVLVWDQFH RFK VROOLFLWDWLRQ



()

Θ 5_G 6_G 

'HWYnSDUDPHWUDUQDNDQEHWUDNWDVVRPWYnVWRNDVWLVNDYDULDEOHUPHGJLYQDIUH

NYHQVIXQNWLRQHU I₅

( )

( )

P₆ P₅ [

\

\ I₆V \ I₅U

)LJXU)UHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHUQDI|UODVWHIIHNWHQI₆VRFKElUI|UPnJDQI₅U 0HGHOYlUGHQDEHWHFNQDVP₅RFKP₆RFKVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHUQDV₅RFKV₆8QGHU I|UXWVlWWQLQJHQDWW5RFK6lUVWRNDVWLVNDJlOOHUGHWlYHQI|UEHUlNQLQJVPRGHO

OHQΘ⋅DWWGHVVPHGHOYlUGH

6

5 P

P

P_Θ = − 

RFKGHVVVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVH



 6

5 V

V

V_Θ = + 

lUVWDWLVWLVND

)UHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQI|UΘIΘEOLUVH)LJXU

β⋅VΘ

PΘ

IΘ

S_IΘ

 Θ

)LJXU)UHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQI|UΘIΘ βL)LJXUlUHWWVnNDOODWVlNHUKHWVLQGH[VRPEHVNULYVQHGDQ



 6lNHUKHWVNODVVRFKVlNHUKHWVLQGH[

 6lNHUKHWVNODVV

(QOLJW%.5JlOOHUPHGKlQV\QWLOORPIDWWQLQJHQDYGHSHUVRQ

VNDGRU VRP NDQ EHIDUDV XSSNRPPD YLG EURWW L HQ E\JJQDGVGHO DWW GHQQD VNDOO KlQI|UDVWLOOQnJRQDYI|OMDQGHVlNHUKHWVNODVVHU

− VlNHUKHWVNODVVOnJOLWHQULVNI|UDOOYDUOLJDSHUVRQVNDGRU

− VlNHUKHWVNODVVQRUPDOQnJRQULVNI|UDOOYDUOLJDSHUVRQVNDGRU

− VlNHUKHWVNODVVK|JVWRUULVNI|UDOOYDUOLJDSHUVRQVNDGRU

 6lNHUKHWVLQGH[β

+XU P\FNHW VW|UUH ElUI|UPnJDQ 5 VNDOO YDUD lQ ODVWHIIHNWHQ 6 VSHFLILFHUDV L E\JJQRUPHULROLNDVlNHUKHWVNODVVHUJHQRPDQJLYQDYlUGHQSnGHWVnNDOODGHVl

NHUKHWVLQGH[HWβ

βNDQGHILQLHUDVJHQRPHQIRUPHOOEURWWVDQQROLNKHWS_IVRP

 S_I

β = −Φ− 

GlUΦ^⋅EHWHFNQDUGHQLQYHUVDIXQNWLRQHQDYGHQVWDQGDUGLVHUDGHQRUPDOI|U

GHOQLQJHQ



 

  

[ [

[ H G[

−

−∞

Φ =

∫

PHGIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQVH)LJXU



   I|U



[

I [ H   [ 

−

= ∞ ∞

π 

E I[









Φ[

[

 [    

D Φ[











Φ[ [

 [    

)LJXUD1RUPDOI|UGHOQLQJHQΦ[RFKEGHVVIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQI[



6DQQROLNKHWHQI|UEURWWS_I

[

]

\WDQL)LJXUGlUDYVWnQGHWPHGVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHQVRPHQKHWIUnQPHGHO

YlUGHWPΘWLOOEURWWJUlQVHQΘ VNULYVVRPβ⋅V .RHIILFLHQWHQ_Θ β EHQlPQV VlNHUKHWVLQGH[RFKGHILQLHUDVDY



 6

5 6 5

V V

P P V P

+

= −

= β

Θ

Θ 

8QGHUDQWDJDQGHWDWW5RFK6lUQRUPDOI|UGHODGHlUlYHQΘQRUPDOI|UGHODG

%URWWVDQQROLNKHWHQInVVRP

[

]

( )

( )

Θ

Θ 

 

V

S_I P 

ΦlUI|UGHOQLQJVIXQNWLRQHQI|UGHQVWDQGDUGLVHUDGHQRUPDOI|UGHOQLQJHQ8U

VHVDWWRYDQJlOOHURFKDWWVlNHUKHWVLQGH[HWNDQEHVWlPPDVXU

( )

(

)

Φ S_I 

YLONHWJHUI|OMDQGHVlNHUKHWVLQGH[PRWVYDUDQGHROLNDEURWWVDQQROLNKHWHU7DEHOO



7DEHOO6DPEDQGPHOODQVlNHUKHWVLQGH[βRFKEURWWVDQQROLNKHWHQS_I β         

S_I    ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^

6lNHUKHWVLQGH[NRSSODVWLOOVlNHUKHWVNODVVHQOLJWI|OMDQGH2PVDQQROLNKHWHQI|U SHUVRQVNDGDlUOnJ VlNHUKHWVNODVVPRWVYDUDUGHW HQ EURWWVDQQROLNKHW DY S_I

^RFKβ 3nVDPPDVlWWJlOOHUI|UVlNHUKHWVNODVVHUQDRFKVH7DEHOO



 7DEHOO.RSSOLQJHQPHOODQVlNHUKHWVLQGH[βEURWWVDQQROLNKHWS_IRFKVlNHUKHWVNODVV

6lNHUKHWVLQGH[β   

%URWWVDQQROLNKHWS_I ^ ^ ^

6lNHUKHWVNODVV   

.UDYHQSnβVRPVlWWVLUHODWLRQWLOOGHWEHWUDNWDGHJUlQVWLOOVWnQGHWVNDOOEDVHUDV SnDWWβEHUlNQDVSnnUVEDVLV

 6DQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG

 $OOPlQW

/DUV gVWOXQG  KDU PHG VDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVN PHWRG VWXGHUDW HUIRUGHUOLJW YlUGH Sn SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQ I|U WnJODVW YLG GLPHQVLRQHULQJ DY MlUQYlJVEURDU

1HGDQVWnHQGHIUDPVWlOOQLQJE\JJHUSnGHQQDUDSSRUWRFKSnPRWVYDUDQGHDYVQLWW L1.%5DSSRUWHQnWHUJHVLVLQKHOKHWL%LODJD$(QDOOPlQSUHVHQWDWLRQ DYGHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQJHVlYHQL$.6FKQHLGHU RFK.|QLJHWDO

 /DVWHIIHNW

/DVWHIIHNWHQ6NDQVNULYDVVRP

= + + + _Qϕ

6 E* F% G4 G4 ()

GlU

* lUHJHQW\QJGDYEURQ*lUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHW P_*RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9_*

% lUEDOODVWHQVW\QJGSnEURQ%lUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHO

YlUGHWP_%



4 lUWnJODVW4lUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHWP₄RFKYDUL

DWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9₄

4_Q lUQRPLQHOOWYlUGHI|UWnJODVWHQ2PDOODYDJQDUYlJVJHVP|MOLJKHW DWWYlOMDHQ|YUHJUlQVI|UODVWHQVVWRUOHNRFKDWWNRQWUROOHUDDWWGHQ LQWH|YHUVNULGV+lUDQWDVDWWHQVnGDQJUlQV4_JKDUYDOWVRFKDWWGHQ lUNQXWHQWLOOGHQQRPLQHOODODVWHQ4_QHQOLJWVDPEDQGHWQg =ζQn E lUHQGHWHUPLQLVWLVNNRHIILFLHQW

F lUHQGHWHUPLQLVWLVNNRHIILFLHQW



G lUHQGHWHUPLQLVWLVNNRHIILFLHQW

ϕ lUHQIDNWRUVRPDQJHUG\QDPLVNLQYHUNDQϕlUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULD

EHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHWPϕRFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9ϕϕUHODWHUDV WLOOGHWQRPLQHOODYlUGHW4_QRFKLQQHKnOOHUGHOVRVlNHUKHWHUL4RFK GHOVRVlNHUKHWHULGHG\QDPLVNDHIIHNWHUQD

(QNRHIILFLHQWνVRPDQJHUI|UKnOODQGHWPHOODQPHGHOYlUGHQDDYODVWHIIHNWHUQD DYHJHQW\QJGRFKWnJODVWUHVSHNWLYHPHGHOYlUGHQDDYODVWHIIHNWHUQDDYEDOODVWRFK WnJODVWLQI|UV

ν =_* ^*

4

EP

GP D

ν =_% ^%

4

FP

GP E

)|UKnOODQGHWPHOODQPHGHOYlUGHRFKQRPLQHOOWYlUGHI|UWnJODVWHQVNULYV

Q 4

4

= P

λ 

9LNDQGnVNULYD

= λ

= ν λ

= ν λ

4 Q

* * Q

% % Q

GP G4

EP G4

FP G4



,GHIDOOYLEHDNWDUζHQOLJWRYDQHUVlWWVλDYζλ

'HVWRNDVWLVNDYDULDEOHUQD*%4RFKϕDQWDVYDUDQRUPDOI|UGHODGH

 %lUI|UPnJD

%lUI|UPnJDQ5NDQVNULYDVVRP I

&D

5= ρ 

GlU

& lUHQIDNWRUVRPEHVNULYHURVlNHUKHWHQLEHUlNQLQJVPHWRGHQ &lU HQ VWRNDVWLVN YDULDEHO PHG PHGHOYlUGHW P_& RFK YDULDWLRQVNRHIILFL

HQWHQ9_&

D lUHQJHRPHWULVNVWRUKHWWH[WYlUVQLWWVDUHDDlUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULD

EHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHWP_DRFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9_D

 ρ lU HQ IDNWRU VRP |YHUI|U SURYNURSSDUV KnOOIDVWKHW WLOO KnOOIDVWKHW L YHUNOLJNRQVWUXNWLRQρlUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHP_ρ RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9ρ

I lUKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHWIlUHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHWP_I RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9_I

&DρRFKIVDPPDQVlWWVVnDWWPHGHOYlUGHW

I D

&

5 P P P P

P = _ρ 

RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ







 D I

&

5 9 9 9 9

9 = + + _ρ + 

,IRUWVlWWQLQJHQDQYlQGV5P₅RFK9₅8SSGHOQLQJHQL&DρRFKIJ|UVVH

QDUH'HVWRNDVWLVNDYDULDEOHUQD5&DρRFKIDQWDVYDUDORJDULWPLVNWQRUPDO

I|UGHODGH

 'LPHQVLRQHULQJVYLOONRU 6RPGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYLOONRUDQYlQGV

Θ = 5 6− = 5 E* F% G4 G4− − − − _Qϕ ≥  

9LGEHUlNQLQJPHGVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGDQYlQGVGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGH

QDI|UGHVWRNDVWLVNDYDULDEOHUQD5*%4ϕRFKVDPK|UDQGHKMlOSYlUGHQκ

VH%LODJD%

5 5 9 5H P

5^∗ = ^{−α β} κ₅ =5^∗9₅ 

(

)

* 9

P

*^∗ = −α β κ = −_* EP 9_{* *} = −G4_{Q *}ν λ9_* 

( )

∗ = _% − α β_{% %}

% P 9 κ = −_% FP 9_{% %} = −G4_{Q %}ν λ9_% 

(

)

4 9

P

4^∗ = −α β κ = −₄ GP 9_{4 4} = −G4 9_Qλ ₄ 

(

)

∗ = ϕ −α β

ϕ P  9 κ = −_ϕ G4 P 9_{Q ϕ ϕ} 

0HGGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQDLQVDWWDLJlOOHUOLNKHWVWHFNQHW'nInV

∗− ∗− ∗− ∗− _Qϕ =∗ 

5 E* F% G4 G4 

,RYDQVWnHQGHXWWU\FNlUαNlQVOLJKHWVNRHIILFLHQWHUVRPVNDOOXSSI\OODYLOONRUHW

α + α + α + α + α =^_{5 *}^{ }_{% 4}^ ϕ^  



.RHIILFLHQWHUQDKDUYlUGHQ²≤α≤.lQVOLJKHWVNRHIILFLHQWHQαlUSRVLWLYI|U J\QQVDPPD IDNWRUHU RFK QHJDWLY I|U RJ\QQVDPPD -X VW|UUH NRHIILFLHQWHQ lU GHVWRVW|UUHEHW\GHOVHKDURVlNHUKHWHQLPRWVYDUDQGHYDULDEHO

9LGDUHJlOOHUDWWKMlOSYlUGHQκ_LGHILQLHUDVHQOLJWI|OMDQGH

2P;_LlUQRUPDOI|UGHODG

[

;L L L L

L P9 ;

∂ =

Θ

= ∂

κ 

L L L

κ Σ

= κ

α D

 

L L L L

[ =P − α β9

2P;_LlUORJDULWPLVNWQRUPDOI|UGHODG

L [ L ; L L

L [ 9 ;

∂ =

Θ

= ∂

κ 

L L L

κ Σ

= κ

α D

9L L L

L PH

[ = ^−αβ

8WWU\FNHQJlOOHUI|U9_L2P9_LlUVWRUWHUVlWWVLDRFKDP_L PHGP_L +9_L^ RFK9_LPHG ^OQ

(

)

( )

=

κ = + ∂Θ

+ ∂



 OQ 

 _L

L L L

L ; [ L

P 9

9 ; ^_L

L L

κ Σ

= κ

α E

( )

= − α β +

+



 OQ 



L L L L

L

[ P 9

9

RFKGn;_LlUORJDULWPLVNWQRUPDOI|UGHODG

( )

=

κ = + ∂Θ

∂

OQ  

L

L L L

L ; [

[ 9

; ^L Σκ^{L }_L

= κ

α E

( )

−α β +

= +

OQ  

 

L 9L

L L

L

[ P H

9

,)LJXUYLVDVHQJHRPHWULVNWRONQLQJDYPHWRGHQVSULQFLSHUI|UWYnQRUPDO

I|UGHODGHYDULDEOHU5 RFK 6 RFKI|UJUlQVWLOOVWnQGHWΘPHGGHQHQNOD IRUPHQ 6

5−

=

Θ 'HQWYnGLPHQVLRQHOODIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQIUVlULILJXUHQnVNnGOLJ

JMRUGPHGQLYnNXUYRU

= + β ν

6

6 6

P

V VLQ

V V

UV₅

VV₆ IVV₆

S_I β IUV₅ IUV₅VV₆

P₅V₅

U V₅

P₆V₆ V V₆

= − β ν

5

5 5

P

U FRV

V V

ν

∗

∗

∂Θ∂ κ ν = = = −∂Θ = κ

∂

WDQ ^{5 6 6 6}

6 5 5

5

U V V V V

V V V V

V 56 

56

EURWW 56!

HMEURWW

)LJXU'HQWYnGLPHQVLRQHOODIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQ I U V

( )

(

) ( )

OLJJMRUGPHGQLYnNXUYRU)UnQ1.%PRGLILHUDG6HlYHQ%LODJD%

,QVlWWQLQJLJHUPHGGP₄ = λG4 _Q EP_* = ν λ_* G4 RFK_Q FP_% = ν λ_% G4_Q HQOLJW

∗ ∗ ∗ ∗

− − − − ϕ =∗ 

Q Q Q Q

5 E* F% 4

G4 G4 G4 4

( ) ( )

( ) ( )

−α β

ϕ ϕ ϕ

− ν λ − α β − ν λ − α β − λ − α β − − α β =

 

  

5 95

5 * * * % % %

Q

4 4

P H 9 9

G4

9 P 9



YLONHWPHG= = P G4 RFKψ VXPPDQDYGHI\UDVHQDUHWHUPHUQDL_{5 Q} NDQVNULYDV

= ψ

β −

α

− ₅ 9₅

=H YDUXU

5 5 9

H

= =ψ ^{α β} 

=lUHUIRUGHUOLJWPHGHOYlUGHSnElUI|UPnJDQP₅VDWWLUHODWLRQWLOOGHQQRPLQHOOD ODVWHQG4_Q=NDQEHVWlPPDVRPYlUGHQSnαβνλζFϕRFK9lUNlQGD



%HUlNQLQJVJnQJHQNDQYDUDI|OMDQGHVHgVWOXQG  (WWYlUGHSnα_ϕDQWDV

 ^ϕ

ϕ ϕ

ν λ α α =_* ^* 9^*

P 9  ^ϕ

ϕ ϕ

ν λ α α =_% ^% 9^%

P 9 RFK ^ϕ

ϕ ϕ

α =₄ λ α9⁴

P 9 EHUlNQDV  ψEHUlNQDVPHG

 5^∗ = G4 RFKκ_Qψ ₅EHUlNQDV

 = Σκ^ =

(

) (

)

( )

(

)

(

)

Q

1 9 9 9 P 9 9

G4

 _ϕ − ^{ϕ ϕ}

α = P 9

1 EHUlNQDVRFKMlPI|UVPHGDQWDJDQGHWL  α =_* −ν λ^* 9^*

1 α =_% −ν λ^% 9^%

1  −λ

α =₄ 9⁴

1 RFKα₅ =ψ9₅EHUlN

 QDV=EHUlNQDV



 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQWLOOlPSDGSnElUI|UPnJD

 ,QOHGQLQJ

3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQlUHQVlNHUKHWVPHWRGVRPlUEDVHUDGSnNDUDNWHULVWLVND YlUGHQRFKSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHU

'LPHQVLRQHUDQGHPDWHULDOYlUGHQEHVWlPVHQOLJW%%.VRP

Q P

G IN

I = ηγ γ 

*HQRPηEHDNWDVV\VWHPDWLVNDVNLOOQDGHUYLGIDVWVWlOODQGHWDYYlUGHWSnKnOOIDVW

KHWHQLSURYNURSSRFKLNRQVWUXNWLRQ

*HQRPγ_P EHDNWDV KnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQDV VOXPSPlVVLJD RVlNHUKHW 9lUGHW Snγ_Q EHURUSnDNWXHOOVlNHUKHWVNODVV

 1RUPYlUGHQ

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_P

,EURWWJUlQVWLOOVWnQGVNDOOSURGXNWHQηγ_PI|UEHWRQJVlWWDVOLNDPHGYLGEH

VWlPQLQJDYKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHRFK YLGEHVWlPQLQJ DY HODVWLFLWHWVPRGXO )|U DUPHULQJVNDOOPRWVYDUDQGHSURGXNWηγ_PVlWWDVOLNDPHGYLGEHVWlPQLQJDY KnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHRFKYLGEHVWlPQLQJDYHODVWLFLWHWVPRGXO

2PPnWWDYYLNHOVHUEHDNWDVGLUHNWLEHUlNQLQJDUQDHQOLJW%%.SXQNWE InUI_GPXOWLSOLFHUDVPHGI|UEHWRQJRFKPHGI|UDUPHULQJVVWnORPηγ_P EHVWlPVHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQVHDYVQLWWQHGDQ

'HWNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHWI_NSnElUI|UPnJDQWDUKlQV\QWLOOGHQVWRNDVWLVNDYDUL

DWLRQHQ DY PRWVWnQGVSDUDPHWHUQ EHVWlPW XWLIUnQ VWDQGDUGLVHUDGH SURYNURSSDU RFKSURYPHWRGHU

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQη

ηlUVRPQlPQWVRYDQGHQV\VWHPDWLVND DYYLNHOVHQ PHOODQ GHQ YHUNOLJD KnOO

IDVWKHWHQ L NRQVWUXNWLRQHQ RFK KnOOIDVWKHWHQ L SURYNURSSDUη EHUlNQDV VRP

PHGHOYlUGHWDYρGlUρlUHQIDNWRUVRP|YHUI|USURYNURSSDUQDVKnOOIDVWKHW WLOOKnOOIDVWKHWHQLNRQVWUXNWLRQHQ9lUGHQDSnηEHURUSnNRQVWUXNWLRQVPDWHULD

OHWI|UYLVVDPDWHULDOlYHQDYODVWHQVYDUDNWLJKHWRFKNRQVWUXNWLRQHQVIXNWLJKHW RFKHYHQWXHOOWDYGHVVnOGHU(QOLJW%%.lUηI|UEHWRQJ RFK I|U DUPHULQJ



 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_Q

3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_QEHURUHQOLJWRYDQSnDNWXHOOVlNHUKHWVNODVV)|OMDQGHYlU

GHQJlOOHUHQOLJW%%.

7DEHOO6lNHUKHWVNODVVPHGWLOOK|UDQGHSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ_Q7DEHOOHQlUNRPSOHWWHUDG PHGPRWVYDUDQGHYlUGHQSnEURWWVDQQROLNKHWHQS_IRFKVlNHUKHWVLQGH[βHQOLJW7DEHOO



6lNHUKHWVNODVV   

γ_Q   

%URWWVDQQROLNKHWS_I ^ ^ ^

6lNHUKHWVLQGH[β   

 $OWHUQDWLYDYlUGHQ

$WWILQQDηHOOHUρlUP\FNHWVYnUWI|UHQIlUGLJNRQVWUXNWLRQ,1.%

DQYlQGV HQ H[WUD SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ_   YLONHQ LQWH nWHUILQQV L 1.%

9LI|UHVOnUDWWηVlWWVOLNDPHGGHWWDγ_ YLONHWlUHQVlQNQLQJPHG

 MlPI|UW PHG %%.  $YYLNHOVHQ PHOODQ HQ XWERUUDG SURYNURSS RFKIlUGLJNRQVWUXNWLRQE|UYDUDPLQGUHlQDYYLNHOVHQPHOODQHQJMXWHQSURY

NURSSRFKIlUGLJNRQVWUXNWLRQ'lUDYPLQVNQLQJHQDYηIUnQWLOO

$OWHUQDWLYDYlUGHQI|USDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQRFKGHQVDQ

QROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQEHKDQGODVQHGDQLDYVQLWWHQRFK

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQ

3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_PEHVWlPVHQOLJW1.%VRPSURGXNWHQDYI\UDIDN

WRUHU







 P P P

P

P =γ γ γ γ

γ 

GlU

γ_P WDUKlQV\Q WLOO RVlNHUKHWHU L GHW NDUDNWHULVWLVND YlUGHW I|U GHQ KnOO

IDVWKHWIVRPYLGNRQWUROOEHVWlPVSnVlUVNLOGDSURYNURSSDUVDPWRVl

NHUKHWHU L I|UKnOODQGHW PHOODQ KnOOIDVWKHWHQ L NRQVWUXNWLRQHQ RFK KnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHWI

γ_P WDUKlQV\QWLOORVlNHUKHWHULEHUlNQLQJVPRGHOORFKPnWW



γ_P WDUKlQV\QWLOOEHW\GHOVHQDYEURWWHWVNDUDNWlU

γ_P WDUKlQV\QWLOOLQYHUNDQDYNRQWUROO

9LGXQGHUV|NQLQJDULEURWWJUlQVWLOOVWnQGHWDQYlQGVHQOLJW1.%I|OMDQGH YlUGHQSnSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDWLOOPRWVWnQGVSDUDPHWUDUQD9lUGHQDlUEHVWlPGD PHGDQYlQGQLQJDYHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGSnOLNQDQGHVlWWVRPL$Y

VQLWW

2VlNHUKHWLKnOOIDVWKHWγ_P

7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_P

9_I

9ρ    

    

    

    

9_I lUYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQI|UKnOOIDVWKHWHQIEHVWlPGPKDVWDQGDU

GLVHUDGHSURYNURSSDU

9_ρ lUYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQI|UIDNWRUQρVRP|YHUI|USURYNURSSDUQDV KnOOIDVWKHWWLOONRQVWUXNWLRQHQV

'HRYDQDQJLYQDYlUGHQDJlOOHULVDPEDQGPHGIUDNWLOYlUGHQDYKnOOIDVWKHWV

SDUDPHWHUQ 2P DQGUD IUDNWLOYlUGHQ DQYlQGV VNDOO GH DQJLYQD YlUGHQD Snγ_P

PXOWLSOLFHUDVPHGIDNWRUQ

( N)9

H^− 

GlU9lUYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQRFKNVYDUDUPRWGHQDQYlQGDIUDNWLOHQ9lUGHQ SnNVRPEHVWlPVDYQRUPDOI|UGHOQLQJHQDQJHVI|UQnJUDIUDNWLOHULQHGDQVWnHQ

GHWDEHOO

7DEHOO.RHIILFLHQWHQN

)UDNWLO      

N      



9DULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9InVHQOLJW

PHGHOYlUGH YLNHOVH VWDQGDUGDY

=

=P

9 V 

2VlNHUKHWLEHUlNQLQJVPRGHOORFKPnWWγ_P 7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_P

%HUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQVQRJJUDQQKHW

K|J QRUPDO GnOLJ

γ_P   

1RUPDO QRJJUDQQKHW L EHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQ VYDUDU PRW YDQOLJD EHUlNQLQJDU DY QRUPDOD NRQVWUXNWLRQHU RFK NRQVWUXNWLRQVHOHPHQW +|J QRJJUDQQKHW I|UH

NRPPHUH[HPSHOYLVGHOVGnGHWWDJLWVVlUVNLOGKlQV\QWLOOH[FHQWULFLWHWHUDQGUD RUGQLQJHQVPRPHQWRFKOLNQDQGHLEHUlNQLQJDUQDRFKGHOVGnEHUlNQLQJVPR

GHOOHUQDlUVlUVNLOWYHULILHUDGHH[HPSHOYLVYLGI|UV|N

%URWWHWVNDUDNWlUγ_P

7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_P

%URWW\S VHJWEURWWPHG

ElULJKHWVUHVHUY VHJWEURWWXWDQ

ElULJKHWVUHVHUY VSU|WWEURWW

γ_P   

%URWW\SRPIDWWDUIDOOPHGVHJDEURWWVDPWDWWGHWILQQVHQNYDUYDUDQGHElUI|U

PnJDXW|YHUGHWEHVWlPGDPRWVWnQGHWWLOOH[HPSHOLIRUPDYW|MQLQJVKnUGQDQGH

%URWW\SRPIDWWDUIDOOPHGVHJDEURWWXWDQQnJRQH[WUDNYDUYDUDQGHElUI|UPnJD

%URWW\SRPIDWWDUIDOOPHGVSU|GDEURWWVnVRPVWDELOLWHWVEURWWRFKPRWVYDUDQGH EURWW



,QYHUNDQDYNRQWUROOγ_P

7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQγ_P

2PIDWWQLQJ DY NRQWUROO PDS PDWHULDO RFKXWI|UDQGH

VlUVNLOG QRUPDO OLWHQ

γ_P   

0HGHNYDWLRQLInVQXHWWVOXWOLJWVDPEDQGI|Uγ_P

( )





 

  N9 P P P P

P =γ H γ γ γ

γ ⁻ 

([HPSHOEHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQ

%HUlNQDPRWVWnQGVSDUDPHWHUQγ_PI|UHQEHWRQJYDUVWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWSURYDWVYDUD I_FFN 03DIUDNWLOHQ$QWDYLGDUHDWWYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQI|UWU\FNKnOO

IDVWKHWHQlUYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9ρ DWWGHWlUQRUPDOQRJJUDQQKHWL EHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQ DWWVHJW EURWWXWDQElULJKHWVUHVHUY NDQWlQNDV VNH RFK DWW GHW VNHUHQQRUPDONRQWUROODYPDWHULDORFKXWI|UDQGH

/|VQLQJ

9_I I|UKnOOIDVWKHWHQRFK9_ρ JHU γ_P =

IUDNWLOYlUGHSnWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHQJHU H^{(−)} =

1RUPDOQRJJUDQQKHWLEHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQJHU γ_P =

6HJWEURWWXWDQElULJKHWVUHVHUYJHU γ_P =

1RUPDONRQWUROODYPDWHULDORFKXWI|UDQGHJHU γ_P =

'HWWDVDPPDQWDJHWJHU γ_P =⋅⋅⋅⋅=

 3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHQηγ_PHQOLJWVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG 'LPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQDNDQPHGSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUγVNULYDV

5 59 N 5

5 5

G 5N P H

5 ⁻

= γ

= γ 

*

* N

*

G * P

* =γ = γ 

= γ = γ

G % N % %

% % P 



Q 4 N 4

G 4 4

4 =γ =γ 

(

)

(NYDWLRQEOLULGHWWDIDOO

( )

− − − − ϕ = 

G G G G Q G

5 E* F% G4 G 4 

0HGYlUGHQHQOLJWRFKPHG= P G4 InV= _{5 Q}

( )

− − ν γ − ν γ − γ + ϕ =

γ ^{N 95 5} _{* * * % % % 4}  _G 

5

= H P P 

9lUGHQSn=EHUlNQDVPHGVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGHQOLJW9lUGHWSn HQDYSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDγ₅γ_*γ_%RFKγ₄NDQGlUHIWHUEHVWlPPDVRPYlUGH

QDSnGHWUH|YULJDlUNlQGD

1XPHULVNDYlUGHQ

gVWOXQGDQVlWWHUHIWHUHQGHO|YHUYlJDQGHQRFKEHUlNQLQJDUI|OMDQGHODVW

RFKPDWHULDOYlUGHQI|UHQEHWRQJEURPHGOlQJGHQ/ P RFK ODVWHQ4_Q

N1)|UEURDUPHGP/PHUKnOOHUKDQOlJUHSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHU

7DEHOO9DOGDODVWYlUGHQ β ν =EP_* FP₄ ζ λ 9_* 9₄ /

>P@ 4_Q

>N1@ ϕ_Q P_ϕ 9_ϕ

          

7DEHOO9DOGDPDWHULDOYlUGHQ

9_I 9_& 9_D 9_5EHU YDOW9₅ N_I I_N P_I N_& &_N P_& D_N P_D 5_N P₅

          



%HUlNQLQJDU

0HGYlUGHQHQOLJWRYDQHUKnOOVI|OMDQGH

7DEHOO%HUlNQDGHYlUGHQ

α_ϕDQW α_* α₄ ψ 1 α_ϕ α_* α₄ α₅ =

         

7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHU

$OW $OW

γ_QYDOG γ_*YDOG ηγ_PYDOG γ_4EHU γ_4YDOG γ_5EHU ηγ_PEHU

      

0DQNDQQXEHUlNQDVDPK|UDQGHYlUGHQI|USDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDI|UODVWRFK PDWHULDOPHGROLNDDQWDJDQGHQI|UODVWRFKPDWHULDOSDUDPHWUDUQD

2PWH[β VlNHUKHWVNODVVWnJODVWHQVSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ₄VlWWVWLOO

HQOLJWgVWOXQGRFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHUQD9_IRFK9_&YDULHUDVHUKnOOV

7DEHOORFK)LJXU

7DEHOO3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUI|UMlUQYlJVEURDUDYEHWRQJ

9_I     

9₅I|U9_&      

γ₄I|Uηγ_P RFK9_&      

γ₅I|Uγ₄ I|U9_&      

ηγ_PI|Uγ₄ RFK9_&      

ηγ_PI|Uγ₄ RFK9_&      

ηγ_PI|Uγ₄ RFK9_&      



β 

/ Pλ=P₄ 4_Q =

4_Q N1 ϕ_Q 

P_ϕ 

9_* 

9₄  9ϕ 

9_I

     



ηγ_P













γ₄ 9_& 

γ₄ 9_& 

γ₄ 9_& 

)LJXUηγ_PVYDULDWLRQVRPIXQNWLRQDYKnOOIDVWKHWHQVYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW9_I7nJ

ODVWHQVSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ₄ HQOLJWXWUHGQLQJDYgVWOXQGVDPWγ_* 

2PLVWlOOHWEURQRUPHQVSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUI|UODVWHUDQYlQGVγ₄ InVI|O

MDQGH YlUGHQ Snηγ_P VRP IXQNWLRQ DY KnOOIDVWKHWHQV YDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW VH )LJXU

%HUlNQLQJDUQDXWJnUIUnQVDPPDRVlNHUKHWLPDWHULDOYlUGHQRFKVDPPDWRWDOVl

NHUKHWβYLONHWJHUPLQVNDGηγ_PRPγ₄|NDURFK|NDGηγ_PRPγ₄PLQVNDU3n GHWWDVlWWHUKnOOVLQJHQ|NQLQJDYNDSDFLWHWHQ9DUMHSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPnVWHVWX

GHUDVYDUI|UVLJRFKGlUHIWHUNDQODVWQLYnQ|NDVPHGELEHKnOOHQWRWDOVlNHUKHW

9_I

     

ηγ_P















γ₄ 9_& 

γ₄ 9_& 

γ₄ 9_& 

β 

/ Pλ=P₄ 4_Q =

4_Q N1 ϕ_Q 

P_ϕ 

9_* 

9₄  9ϕ 

)LJXUηγ_PVYDULDWLRQVRPIXQNWLRQDYKnOOIDVWKHWHQVYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW9_I7nJ

ODVWHQVSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWγ₄ HQOLJWEURQRUPHQVDPWγ_* 



 7LOOlPSQLQJSnEHWRQJEURDU

 ([HPSHOSnEHUlNQLQJDYγ_PHQOLJWWDEHOOPHWRGHQ

(QOLJWDYVQLWWNDQI|OMDQGHQnJRWJ\QQVDPPDUHYlUGHSnηγ_PlQGHWVRPJHV L%%.HUKnOODVI|UH[HPSHOYLVHQNRUWOnGEURXWPHGVWUlFNDQ*lOOLYDUH

/XOHnXQGHUI|OMDQGHDQWDJDQGHQ

 %HWRQJHQVWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWI_FFNIUDNWLOYlUGH^lUEHVWlPGPHGHQYD

ULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW9_I RFK9_ρ 

( ) 



 ^{ }

  H ^{  } 

P = =

γ ⁻

 1RUPDOQRJJUDQQKHWLEHUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQ

γ_P 

 6HJWEURWWPHGElULJKHWVUHVHUY6HJWEURWWDQWDVHQOLJWI|UV|NYLG/78

γ_P 

 1RUPDONRQWUROODYXWI|UDQGHW

γ_P 

8QGHURYDQVWnHQGHDQWDJDQGHQInVI|OMDQGHJ\QQVDPPDUHYlUGHSnηγ_P























     

P = ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ =

ηγ

YLONHWLQQHElUDWWEHWRQJHQVGLPHQVLRQHUDQGHKnOOIDVWKHWNDQ|NDVPHG











 





  



 = ⇔

 6MXYHUNOLJDEURDU

 ,QOHGQLQJ

6MXROLNDMlUQYlJVEURDUDYEHWRQJSnVWUlFNDQPHOODQ/XOHnRFK%RGHQKDUXQ

GHUV|NWVPHGDYVHHQGHSnEHWRQJHQVGUDJRFKWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHW8WERUUDGHNlU

QRUPHG∅PPVYDUYDGHRFKPHG∅PPQRWFKKDUSURYDWVJHQRP HQD[LHOODGUDJI|UV|NVH7KXQHWDOPHGI|OMDQGHUHVXOWDW7DEHOO



(QOLJW %%. VNDOO HWW NDUDNWHULVWLVNW YlUGH DYVHV PRWVYDUD GHQ VDQQD IUDNWLOHQ I|U WU\FN

KnOOIDVWKHWHQ KRV EHWRQJF\OLQGUDU PHG  PP GLDPHWHU RFK  PP K|MG ODJUDGH L YDWWHQ YLG

±°& IUDP WLOO SURYQLQJVWLOOIlOOHW RFK SURYDGH HQOLJW 'UDIW 6WDQGDUG ,62',6 



7DEHOO6DPPDQVWlOOQLQJDYHQD[LHOODGUDJI|UV|N

%UR 3URYQU )_PD[

>N1@ I_FW

>03D@

  

%RGHQ&   

  

*$5  

*DUQLVRQVYlJHQ *$5  

*$5  

  

*DPPHOVWDG   

  

127  

1RWYLNHQ 127  

127  

+$3  

+DSDUDQGDYlJHQ +$3  

+$3  

  

.DOONlOOHYlJHQ   

  

%(1  

%HQVE\YlJHQ %(1  

%(1  

I_FW  lU YlUGHQ IUnQ SURYQLQJDU XU VLGREDONDU L DNWXHOOD REMHNW 2P DQGUD NRQ

VWUXNWLRQVGHODUlQWUnJEDONDUQDVNDOOVWXGHUDVE|USURYQLQJVNHLGHVVDGHODUHOOHU KlQV\QWDVWLOORVlNHUKHWHQ(YHQWXHOOWNDQGHWWDVNHPHGHQH[WUDSDUWLDONRHIILFL

HQWVH.DSLWHORFK7KXQHWDO

bYHQ WU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHQ KDU SURYDWV PHG XWERUUDGH F\OLQGUDU∅ PP RFK I|OMDQGHUHVXOWDWHUK|OOV



7DEHOO6DPPDQVWlOOQLQJDYWU\FNSURYPHGXWERUUDGHNlUQRU

%UR 3URYQU )_PD[

>N1@ I_FF

>03D@

  

%RGHQ&    ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

  

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

*DUQLVRQVYlJHQ    ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

*DPPHOVWDG   

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

  

1RWYLNHQ    ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

  

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

+DSDUDQGDYlJHQ   

  

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

.DOONlOOHYlJHQ    3URYHW I|U NRUW (M WHVWDW

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO



  

%HQVE\YlJHQ    ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

   ,QQHK|OO  VW DUPHULQJVVWnO

I_FF  lU YlUGHQ IUnQ SURYQLQJDU XU WUnJEDONDU L DNWXHOOD REMHNW 2P DQGUD NRQ

VWUXNWLRQVGHODUlQWUnJEDONDUQDVNDOOVWXGHUDVE|USURYQLQJVNHLGHVVDGHODUHOOHU KlQV\QWDVWLOORVlNHUKHWHQ(YHQWXHOOWNDQGHWWDVNHPHGHQH[WUDSDUWLDONRHIILFL

HQWVH.DSLWHORFK7KXQHWDO

8UUHVXOWDWHQEHUlNQDVPHGHOYlUGHPRFKVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHVHQOLJW



Q [ P

Q

L L

∑

= ^ 

( )







−

−

=

∑

=

Q P [ V

Q

L L



RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9

P

9 = V 

7DEHOO0HGHOYlUGHVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHRFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWI|UVMXSURYDGHEURDU

%UR 'UDJKnOOIDVWKHW 7U\FNKnOOIDVWKHW

>03D@P V

>03D@ 9

>@ P

>03D@ V

>03D@ 9

>@

%RGHQ&      

*DUQLVRQVJDWDQ      

*DPPHOVWDG      

1RWYLNHQ      

+DSDUDQGDYlJHQ      

.DOONlOOHYlJHQ      

%HQVE\YlJHQ      

 .DUDNWHULVWLVNGUDJRFKWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHW

'HQNDUDNWHULVWLVNDKnOOIDVWKHWHQKDUKlUXWYlUGHUDWVSnWUHROLNDVlWW

• VWDWLVWLVNW

• HQOLJWHNYDWLRQGDYVQLWWL'LPHQVLRQHULQJJHQRPSURYQLQJ

• HQOLJW%%.DYVQLWW

'HWUHXWYlUGHULQJDUQDlUJMRUGDPHGV\IWHDWWXSSI\OODNUDYHQL%%.RPDWW GHWNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHWVNDOOPRWVYDUDGHQVDQQDIUDNWLOHQDYKnOOIDVWKHWHQ



'HQ VWDWLVWLVND XWYlUGHULQJHQ lU JMRUG XQGHU DQWDJDQGHW DWW KnOOIDVWKHWHQ lU QRU

PDOI|UGHODG PHG VNDWWDGH PHGHOYlUGHQ P RFK VWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHU V 'HW ND

UDNWHULVWLVNDIUDNWLOYlUGHWInVJHQRPDWWV|NDGHWYlUGHVRPXSSI\OOHU

(

)

3 ξ≥ _FWN =

( )

−3 ξ≤ I_FWN = 









V  P I_FWN =



 



 −

Φ

−

< 



GlUNYRWHQLQRPSDUHQWHVHQlUPLQGUHlQQROOHIWHUVRPGHWNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHW lUPLQGUHlQPHGHOYlUGHW







 

V I

P _FWN =







 

 Φ −

−

−







 

V I P _FWN=



 

 Φ − +

−

VRPPHGKMlOSDYWDEHOOYHUNJHUMlPI|UlYHQ7DEHOO



V 

I P− _FWN =

= −

IFWN P V 

6DPPDDQWDJDQGHQVRPRYDQJlOOHUI|UXWYlUGHULQJHQOLJW'LPHQVLRQHULQJJHQRP SURYQLQJGlUGHWNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHWInVHQOLJWHNYDWLRQGLDYVQLWW

PHGNRQILGHQVQLYnWLOO

(

)

P

I_FWN = − _SQ⋅ = − _SQ

GlUN_SQEHURUDYDNWXHOOIUDNWLORFKDQWDOPlWYlUGHQHQOLJWWDEHOODLELODJDL'L

PHQVLRQHULQJJHQRPSURYQLQJRFKlU





N_SQ =

I|UIUDNWLORFKWUHPlWYlUGHQ'HWWDJHU V

P

I_FWN = − ^ 



*lOOHU YLG WUH  SURYYlUGHQ )|U .DOONlOOHYlJHQ PHG IHP  SURYYlUGHQ DQYlQGV PV



-lPI|UHOVHPHG(&WDEHOO'JHUN_SQ RP9lURNlQGRFKN_SQ

RP9lUNlQG

8WYlUGHULQJ HQOLJW %%.  J|UV HQOLJW DYVQLWW  9LOONRU $ I|U HQ VHULHRPWUHSURYXUHQNRQVWUXNWLRQVGHOJHU



 +

≥ I_7.

P



 −

≥

7.

FW 7.I

I I













GlUI_7.lUIRUGUDWYlUGHSnGUDJKnOOIDVWKHWYLGSURYQLQJDYEHWRQJLIlUGLJNRQ

VWUXNWLRQ'HWWDVDPEDQGOHGHUWLOOI|OMDQGHNUDY







+

−

=



















 PLQ

PLQ PLQ

FW FW 7.

I I P I

9LOONRU%InUWLOOlPSDVI|UGHWIDOODWWPLQVWVH[SURYXWI|UWVRFKJHUGn

P V 7.H I P≥ ^



 −

≥

7.

FW 7.I

I I













YLONHWOHGHUWLOONUDYHW

 −



=  +







PLQ PLQ

PLQ 



V P

7. FW

FW

PH

I I

I

9LOONRU%lUVWUlQJDUHlQYLOONRU$I|UK|JDYlUGHQSnPHGHOYlUGHWPRFKYDULD

WLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ9HQOLJWI|OMDQGH



P

9 = V ^P

(

)

 ⇒ P!03D

 ⇒ P!03D

 ⇒ P!03D

)|UDWWYDUDSnVlNHUVLGDE|UGHWVWUlQJDVWHDYYLOONRUHQ$RFK%WLOOlPSDVYLONHW JHU

− −

 −

 =

= 

 +



 

PLQ PLQ



PLQ 



V 9

P 7.

FW FW

P

PH PH

I I

I



3nVDPPDVlWWInVI|UWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHQ

−

 −



= 

 +





PLQ PLQ



PLQ 



V P ..

FF FF

P I PH

I I



)|UDWWInIUDPNDUDNWHULVWLVNDKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQPnVWHYLVVDNRUUHNWLRQHUJ|UDVDY I_7.RFKI_..YlUGHQD2PUlNQLQJWLOOKnOOIDVWKHWVNODVVYlUGHJ|UVJHQRPDWWGLYL

GHUDI_7.YlUGHQDPHGRFKI_..YlUGHQDPHGPHGKlQV\QWLOODWWKnOOIDVW

KHWLIlUGLJNRQVWUXNWLRQYLGQRUPDOWDUEHWVXWI|UDQGHlURPNULQJUHVSHNWL

YHOlJUHlQLVWDQGDUGSURYVHWDEHOOHUQDDRFKEL%%. 7U\FNKnOOIDVWKHWVYlUGHQDKlUU|UGRFNIUnQF\OLQGUDU[PPVRPPRWVYDUDU NXEHU [[PP 'HVVD YlUGHQ PnVWH UlNQDV RP WLOO L %%. 

DYVQLWWDQJLYQDVWDQGDUGLVHUDGHSURYF\OLQGUDU[PP'HWWDJ|UV JHQRPDWWPXOWLSOLFHUDWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWVNODVVYlUGHQDPHGIDNWRUQ'HQND

UDNWHULVWLVND WU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHQ InV VOXWOLJHQ JHQRP DWW \WWHUOLJDUH PXOWLSOLFHUD YlUGHQDPHGI|UDWWWDKlQV\QWLOOOnQJWLGVHIIHNWHU

'HVVDNRUUHNWLRQHUOHGHUIUDPWLOOI|OMDQGHVDPEDQGPHOODQNDUDNWHULVWLVNDKnOO

IDVWKHWHURFKXWYlUGHUDGHYlUGHQHQOLJW%%.



= =

^7.

FWN I 7.

I I 

⋅ ⋅

=   = 

 ^..

FFN I ..

I I 

6HlYHQ7KXQHWDO

0HG HNYDWLRQHUQD    InV I|OMDQGH YlUGHQ Sn XWYlUGHUDGH GUDJ RFK WU\FNKnOOIDVWKHWHUVH7DEHOORFK7DEHOO

7DEHOO8WYlUGHUDGGUDJKnOOIDVWKHW

%%.

%UR 6WDWLVWLVN

PHWRG HNY

'LPHQ

VLRQHULQJ JHQRP SURYQLQJ HNY

HNY

'UDJKnOO

IDVWKHWV

NODVVHQOLJW WDEHOO

E

I_FWN

%RGHQ&   % 7 

*DUQLVRQVJDWDQ   $ 7 

*DPPHOVWDG   $ 7 

1RWYLNHQ   $ 7 

+DSDUDQGDYlJHQ   $ 7 

.DOONlOOHYlJHQ   $ 7 

%HQVE\YlJHQ   % 7 



7DEHOO8WYlUGHUDGWU\FNKnOOIDVWKHW

%%.

%UR 6WDWLVWLVN

PHWRG HNY

'LPHQ

VLRQHULQJ JHQRP SURYQLQJ HNY

HNY

7U\FNKnOO

IDVWKHWVNODVV HQOLJWWDEHOO

D

I_FFN

%RGHQ&   % . 

*DUQLVRQVJDWDQ   % . 

*DPPHOVWDG   % . 

1RWYLNHQ   % . 

+DSDUDQGDYlJHQ   % . 

.DOONlOOHYlJHQ   % . 

%HQVE\YlJHQ   % . 

(QMlPI|UHOVHPHOODQGHWUHPHWRGHUQDJHUI|OMDQGH

'HWVWDWLVWLVNDPHWRGHQXQGHUVNDWWDUOLNDRIWDVRPGHQ|YHUVNDWWDUGHQYHUNOLJD

NYDQWLOHQ0HQJHQRPDWWDQYlQGDPHWRGHQSnHQRFKVDPPDNRQVWUXNWLRQ InVHQOlJUHVSULGQLQJlQLHQWlQNWSRSXODWLRQ

'LPHQVLRQHULQJJHQRPSURYQLQJVNDOODQYlQGDVQlUSURWRW\SHUDYE\JJHOHPHQW SURYDV I|U DWW EHVWlPPD GHQ NDUDNWHULVWLVND ElUI|UPnJD VRP NDQ DQVlWWDV L HQ NRQVWUXNWLRQVEHUlNQLQJ 'HW DQWDV DWW IOHUD E\JJHOHPHQW NRPPHU DWW WLOOYHUNDV WLOOYLONDGHWHUKnOOQDNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHWNQ\WV(QVNDWWQLQJVPHWRGPHGIL[

K|J VDQQROLNKHW DWW LQWH |YHUVNDWWD SRSXODWLRQHQV YHUNOLJD NYDQWLO YlOMV

'HWWDLQQHElUDWWNYDQWLOHQRIWDVWXQGHUVNDWWDVYLONHWOHGHUWLOOGHOnJDYlUGH

QDL7DEHOORFK7DEHOO

%%.DQYlQGHULQWHSURYVHULHQVYDULDWLRQGLUHNWLYLOONRU$'HQlUJMRUG I|UGHQVLWXDWLRQVRPJlOOHUKlUDWWXWYlUGHUDKnOOIDVWKHWHQLHQIlUGLJNRQVWUXN

WLRQ'HQlUGRFNXWIRUPDGPHGKlQV\QWLOODWWSURGXNWHQηγ_P 'HQlU GlUI|ULQWHWLOOI|UDWWEDNYlJHQEHVWlPPDHWWNDUDNWHULVWLVNWYlUGHYLONHWYLJ|U KlU9LYlOMHUlQGnDWWWLOOlPSD%%.VPHWRG

$WWGUDJKnOOIDVWKHWVNODVVHQHQOLJW7DEHOOEL%%.EOLUQnJRWK|JUH lQI_7.EHURUSnDWWKnOOIDVWKHWHUYLGQRUPDOWDUEHWVI|UIDUDQGHEOLUOlJUHLHWWE\JJ

QDGVYHUNlQLVWDQGDUGSURYVH0|OOHUHWDODYVQLWW+nOOIDVWKHWV

XWYHFNOLQJLEHWRQJE\JJQDGHU