THE INFLUENCE OF BIOGENIC ORGANIC COMPOUNDS ON CLOUD FORMATION
Sanna Ekström
The influence of biogenic organic compounds on cloud formation
Sanna Ekström
©Sanna Ekström, Stockholm 2010
ISBN 978-91-7447-175-5, pp. 1-43
Printed in Sweden by US-AB, Stockholm 2010
Distributor: Department of Applied Environmental Science (ITM)
”Tralala lilla molntuss,
kom hit skall du få en
puss” -Bob hund
List of papers
This thesis is based on the following papers. They are referred by their Roman numerals.
I. Ekström, S., Nozière, B., and Hansson, H.-C. 2009. The cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) properties of 2- methyltetrols and C3–C6 polyols from osmolality and sur- face tension measurements. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 9, 973–980.
II. Ekström, S., Nozière, B., Hultberg, M., Alsberg, T., Mag- nér, J., Nilsson, E. D., Artaxo, P. 2010. A possible role of ground-based microorganisms on cloud formation in the atmosphere. Biogeosciences, 7 387-394.
III. Nozière, B., Ekström, S., Alsberg, T., and Holmström, S.
2010. Radical-initiated formation of organosulfates and sur- factants in atmospheric aerosols. Geophysical Research Let- ters, 37, L05806, doi:10.1029/2009GL041683.
IV. Ekström, S., Wittbom, C., Svenningsson, B., Nozière, B.
2010. Biosurfactants as CCN: comparison between on-line and off-line measurements. Manuscript.
Papers I, II and III have been reproduced by permission from European
Geosciences Union (I, II) and American Geophysical Union (III), re-
spectively.
Contents
1. Introduction ... 11
1.1 Aerosols, clouds and climate ... 11
1.2 Köhler theory ... 14
1.3 Surface active organic compounds ... 15
1.4 The effect of life on earth on cloud formation ... 16
1.5 Main objectives ... 17
2. Measuring the cloud forming potential ... 18
2.1 Off-line technique ... 18
2.2 On-line techniques ... 19
3. Sampling and analysis ... 21
3.1 Aerosol sampling sites ... 21
3.2 Instrumentation ... 22
3.3 Chemical characterization of surfactant molecules ... 23
4. Results ... 25
4.1 Paper I - “The Cloud Condensation Nuclei (CCN) properties of 2- methyltetrols and C3-C6 polyols from osmolality and surface tension measurements” ... 26
4.2 Paper II - “A possible role of ground-based microorganisms on cloud formation in the atmosphere” ... 27
4.3 Paper III - “Radical-initiated formation of organosulfates and surfactants in atmospheric aerosols” ... 29
4.4 Paper IV - “Biosurfactants as CCN: comparison between on-line and off- line measurements” ... 30
5. Key conclusions ... 31
6. Outlook ... 32
Appendix – contribution to the papers ... 34
Acknowledgements ... 35
Bibliography ... 36
1. Introduction
This thesis concerns the ability of organic compounds present in aerosol particles to form clouds, and specifically the contribution of compounds emitted by living organisms. First, an introduction to the topic.
1.1 Aerosols, clouds and climate
The climate is very likely to be changing as a consequence of hu- man activities. The greenhouse gases are warming the troposphere by absorbing incoming short wave radiation from the sun. Aerosols, small particles suspended in air, can on the other hand interact with incoming solar radiation either by absorbing or scattering the light.
This so-called direct aerosol effect can thus lead to both cooling and warming, which is illustrated together with the cloud albedo effect in Figure 1. All cloud droplets are formed by the condensation of water vapor on aerosol particles, referred to as cloud condensation nuclei (CCN). The cloud albedo effect, or the indirect aerosol effect, is the influence that aerosols have on the climate by producing cloud drop- lets that can scatter and absorb radiation, which is illustrated in Figure 2. The direct and indirect aerosol effects result in a net cooling on the climate and they are the largest unknown factors in the atmospheric radiation budget (IPCC, 2007).
The atmosphere can contain from a few particles per cubic centi- meter in very clean environments and up to a million in polluted areas.
There can also be large differences in size distribution and the chemi-
cal composition between various atmospheric environments (Heint-
zenberg, 1989). The smallest particles are in the nanometer size range
(10
-9m) and the largest several hundred micrometers in diameter. A
particle is classified as “fine” if it has a diameter smaller than 2.5 µm,
and “coarse” if the diameter is larger than 2.5 µm. The size class indi-
cates the physical, chemical and health related properties of the par-
ticle. A former common generalization was that natural or aged par-
ticles are larger than newly formed or anthropogenic particles. There
are now evidences showing that this is not always true. For instance,
natural aerosol particles containing polyols, which are mainly emitted from fungi, exist in both fine and coarse aerosol (Graham et al., 2003;
Ion et al., 2005).
Figure 1: Components of radiative forcing (RF) for emissions of aerosols and aero- sol precursors. Values represent RF in 2005 due to emissions and changes since 1750. (IPCC 2007).
The chemical composition varies amongst an aerosol population
and it is likely to consist of a large amount of compounds of which
hundreds can be organic compounds (Hahn, 1980; Simoneit and Ma-
zurek, 1982; Graedel, 1986; Rogge et al., 1993a-c). Organic particles
have been shown to play an important role in cloud formation (Nova-
kov and Penner, 1993; Matsumoto et al., 1997). The contribution of
organic particles to CCN can be up to 80% of the total number of
CCN in marine regions (Rivera-Carpio et al., 1996) and 20% at a con-
tinental semi-rural site (Chang et al., 2007). The aerosol can be exter-
nally, internally mixed, or both, which means chemicals can exist in-
dividually or together in each single particle. One particle may have a
liquid organic coating on top of an insoluble core, another might be a
completely mixed liquid of several compounds, and the third could be
a particle consisting of pure salt (Gieray et al., 1997; Ghermandi et al.,
2005). It is now well established that organic compounds almost al-
ways exist as internal mixtures with inorganic compounds in atmos-
pheric particles (Middlebrook et al., 1998; Murphy et al., 2006; Zhang
et al., 2007, Froyd et al., 2009). The presence of the organic material might alter the properties that influence cloud forming efficiency (Saxena et al., 1996; Cruz and Pandis, 2000; Dick et al., 2000), and the cloud forming properties of inorganic compounds are better un- derstood than that of pure organic compounds and mixtures. To sum- marize, the properties of atmospheric aerosols vary widely between each individual particles and this complicates the attempt to estimate their behaviour in the climate system.
Figure 2: The global annual mean radiation balance reprinted from Kiehl and Tren- berth (1997).
An important reason to obtain knowledge about the size spectrum of the atmospheric particles is that different physical processes depend on size. Particles with a diameter in the order of magnitude of 100 nm are commonly involved in cloud processes as CCN. The largest par- ticles will activate very easily no matter what compound(s) they con- sist of whilst the smaller will depend more on chemical composition (Dusek et al., 2006).
The particle numbers in a given aerosol mass can vary tremend-
ously if it consists of mainly fine or coarse particles. The mass, or vo-
lume, is mostly dominated by particles from approximately 0.1 µm to
50 µm in diameter and the number of particles is mostly contributed
by around 100 nm or smaller particles.
Large scale climate models calculate the radiative forcing from aerosols by inserting assumed primary emissions of particles, estima- tions of secondary particle formation and using parameterizations to estimate cloud droplet numbers. A parameterization can be derived from observations or physical relationships. Therefore, although this thesis focuses on molecular-scale properties, the results could affect the prediction of cloud formation at a global scale.
The main uncertainties in the existing descriptions of cloud forma- tion are the aerosol emissions, the aerosol population and composi- tion, and the effect of composition on cloud droplet formation. This results in different predictions in optical properties of the clouds.
There is a need to improve the approximation of the cloud albedo ef- fect, and the parameterizations plugged in the models. These physical and chemical parameters that are required to estimate the cloud drop- let numbers from an existing aerosol population in climate models are expressed using Köhler theory.
1.2 Köhler theory
Clouds would not exist if there were no particles for the water va- por to condense upon. Not all particles are equally efficient as conden- sation nuclei due to differences in both size and chemistry. Köhler theory (Köhler, 1936) expresses the required amount of water vapor in the atmosphere necessary for a particle to activate and grow into a cloud droplet. The solute effect and the surface tension effect are in- fluenced by the chemical composition of the particles.
Forces between the dissolved molecules in the droplet will affect its properties. Dissolved organic compounds influence the solute ef- fect, or Raoult effect but salts have a particularly strong effect by dis- sociating into ions which interact with each other.
The surface tension effect, or Kelvin effect, describes the vapor pressure over a curved surface, which is always larger than that of a flat surface. Droplets with a diameter larger than approximately 100 nm have a negligible surface tension effect, which is a significant force during the initial cloud droplet growth. Organic compounds gen- erally have a larger influence on the Kelvin effect than salts.
By combining the Raoult effect and the Kelvin effect we obtain the so-called Köhler equation. The Köhler equation describes cloud droplet activation and can be expressed as:
4 1
exp
P w
sol w
w