• No results found

Democrats without borders A critique of transnational democracy

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Democrats without borders A critique of transnational democracy"

Copied!
2
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

Democrats without borders

A critique of transnational democracy

JOHAN KARLSSON

Gothenburg Studies in Politics 114

Akademisk avhandling för filosofie doktorsexamen i statsvetenskap som med tillstånd av samhällsvetenskapliga fakultetsnämnden

vid Göteborgs universitet framläggs till offentlig granskning fredag den 28 november 2008 kl. 13 i sal 10,

(2)

Karlsson, Johan, 2008. Democrats without borders: A critique of transnational

democracy. English text. Gothenburg Studies in Politics 114. Department of Political Science, Box 711, 405 30 Gothenburg, Sweden. Gothenburg 2008. 229 pages. ISBN: 798-91-89246-38-6. ISSN: 0346-5942.

Abstract

Some scholars claim that globalisation compels us to radically rethink demo-cracy both in theory and practice. This dissertation disputes such claims by arguing against two suggested normative models of transnational democracy: cosmopolitan democracy and deliberative democracy.

The argument is arranged in two parts: The first part addresses the nor-mative foundations of transnational democracy. Central in justifying claims for transnational democracy, the so-called all-affected principle states that those who are affected by political decisions have a right to participate in making them. Criticising the all-affected principle, I argue that a better crite-rion for determining the boundaries of democratic communities is a principle according to which all who are subject to the law ought to be included. Next, I criticise another central normative claim in transnational democratic theory: That there is no tension between human rights and democracy. How-ever, by defining democracy as the implementation of a rigid scheme of human rights, cosmopolitan democracy leaves little scope for democratic politics. Deliberative democracy, on the other hand, insists that democracy and human rights are internally related or co-original, but this claim is problematic too, not least because it cannot justify international human rights in the absence of global democratic procedures.

Turning in the second part to the practical feasibility of transnational democracy, I argue that while cosmopolitan democracy suggests an ideal political order based on the dispersion of sovereign authority, it fails to ac-knowledge how a multi-level order would undermine central cosmopolitan objectives. Moreover, cosmopolitan democracy presents an ambiguous account of change in international order. Some theorists suggest that deliberative democracy provides a more feasible way of realising democracy in multi-level transnational governance, but I argue that in such settings, deliberative democracy has difficulties to overcome the problem of scale by means of representation.

References

Related documents

John Parkinson suggests terms on which a theory of deliberative de- mocracy could accept representation as a legitimate form of exclusion (apart from solv-.. Most theorists

Based in these results, the hypothesis in this thesis is that using the index measure will result in a better policy responsiveness of public opinion than

Although the notion of a power shift from the North to the South West underlined the “pact” of the ruling elite to have General Obasanjo as a Presidential can- didate in the

With a point of departure in some central lines of thought in Claude Ake’s work on democracy, such as Ake’s discus- sion on liberal vs popular democracy and the ‘potential’

Deploying official human rights discourses, governmental organisations and rep- resentatives of the so-called civil society argue in favour of human rights even if the

I also conduct a case study on the United Nations Transition Assistance Group (UNTAG) peacekeeping mission, deployed in Namibia 1989- 1990, to examine how the

This dissertation aims to address this research gap and examine how the in- terplay between 1) democratic institutions that shape how the demand for en- vironmental policies

Dynamic, random-effects, and fixed-effects estimators confirm the same result: in an intolerant environment, economic growth hinders party competition and reinforces