• No results found

Uppföljande studie av Sidas resultatanalyser

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Uppföljande studie av Sidas resultatanalyser"

Copied!
18
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

(ITEVXQIRXJSV)ZEPYEXMSR

ERH-RXIVREP%YHMX

7MHE7XYHMIWMR)ZEPYEXMSR

8SSI|OMDQGHVWXGLHDY

6LGDVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU

+¸VER7GLMPP

(2)
(3)

6LGD6WXGLHVLQ(YDOXDWLRQ 'HSDUWPHQWIRU(YDOXDWLRQ DQG,QWHUQDO$XGLW

8SSI|OMDQGHVWXGLHDY6LGDV

UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU

*|UDQ6FKLOO

(4)

6:(',6+,17(51$7,21$/'(9(/230(17&223(5$7,21$*(1&< $GGUHVV66WRFNKROP6ZHGHQ2IILFH6YHDYlJHQ6WRFNKROP 7HOHSKRQH  7HOHID[   7HOHJUDPVLGDVWRFNKROP3RVWJLUR² (PDLOLQIR#VLGDVH+RPHSDJHKWWSZZZVLGDVH 6LGD6WXGLHVLQ(YDOXDWLRQLVDVHULHVFRQFHUQHGZLWKFRQFHSWLDODQGPHWKRGRORJLFDO LVVXHVLQWKHHYDOXDWLRQRIGHYHORSPHQWFRRSHUDWLRQ,WLVSXEOLVKHGE\6LGD·V 'HSDUWPHQWIRU(YDOXDWLRQDQG,QWHUQDO$XGLW5HSRUWVPD\EHRUGHUHGIURP %LVWnQGVIRUXP6LGD 66WRFNKROP 3KRQH   )D[   (PDLOLQIR#VLGDVH+RPHSDJHKWWSZZZVLGDVH $XWKRU*|UDQ6FKLOO 7KHYLHZVDQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVH[SUHVVHGLQWKLVUHSRUWDUHWKHDXWKRU·VDQGGRQRWQHFHVVDULO\UHIOHFW WKRVHRIWKH6ZHGLVK,QWHUQDWLRQDO'HYHORSPHQW&RRSHUDWLRQ$JHQF\6LGD 6LGD6WXGLHVLQ(YDOXDWLRQ &RPPLVVLRQHGE\6LGD'HSDUWPHQWIRU(YDOXDWLRQDQG,QWHUQDO$XGLW &RS\ULJKW6LGDDQGWKHDXWKRU 5HJLVWUDWLRQ1R 'DWHRI)LQDO5HSRUW'HFHPEHU 3ULQWHGLQ6WRFNKROP6ZHGHQ ,661³;

(5)

,QQHKnOOVI|UWHFNQLQJ

 ,QWURGXNWLRQ   cWJlUGHUI|UI|UElWWUDGNYDOLWHW   %HG|PQLQJDY6LGDVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU +XUP\FNHWELVWnQGDQDO\VHUDV"  9LONDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUDV"  +XUDQDO\VHUDVUHVXOWDWHQ"  bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDWLOOI|UOLWOLJD"  bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDDQYlQGEDUD"   5HNRPPHQGDWLRQHU  %LODJD$879VNODVVLILFHULQJDYUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVXSSJLIWHU 

(6)
(7)

1

8SSI|OMDQGHVWXGLHDY6LGDVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU

,QWURGXNWLRQ

8QGHUK|VWHQJMRUGH6HNUHWDULDWHWI|U8WYlUGHULQJRFK,QWHUQ5HYLVLRQ 879 SnXSSGUDJDY6LGDVJHQHUDOGLUHNW|U%R*|UDQVVRQHQJUDQVNQLQJDYGH UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUVRPGLWWLOOVSURGXFHUDWVLVDPEDQGPHG6LGDVODQGVWUDWHJLDUEHWH 879VJUDQVNQLQJSHNDGHSnHWWDQWDOEULVWHUDYVHHQGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVNYDOLWHW PHQRFNVnSnGHJHQHUHOODSUREOHPVRPI|UNQLSSDV HOOHUERUGHI|UNQLSSDV PHG VW\UQLQJDYRIIHQWOLJYHUNVDPKHWSnJUXQGYDODYWLGLJDUHUHVXOWDWRFKHUIDUHQKHWHU ,VDPEDQGPHGnUVJUDQVNQLQJEHVWlPGHVDWW879VNXOOHJ|UDHQ XSSI|OMDQGHVWXGLHDYGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUVRPIUDPVWlOOWVDY6LGDXQGHU )|UHOLJJDQGHUDSSRUWlUUHVXOWDWHWDYGHQQDDQGUDVWXGLH*UDQVNQLQJDUQDlUHWW OHGL879VDUEHWHXQGHUWHPDW´)|UlQGULQJRFK/lUDQGHLQRP6LGDµ 5DSSRUWHQLQOHGVPHGHQVDPPDQIDWWQLQJDYGHnWJlUGHUVRP6LGDYLGWDJLWXQGHU SHULRGHQLV\IWHDWWI|UElWWUDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVNYDOLWHWGHQIRUWVlWWHU PHGHQEHG|PQLQJDYGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUVRPIUDPVWlOOWVXQGHUVDPPDSHULRG RFKGHQDYVOXWDVPHGWUHVDPPDQIDWWDQGHUHNRPPHQGDWLRQHU5DSSRUWHQlU JHQRPJnHQGHGLVSRQHUDGSnHWWVlWWVRPP|MOLJJ|UHQNODMlPI|UHOVHUPHG879V I|UVWDJUDQVNQLQJ

cWJlUGHUI|UI|UElWWUDGNYDOLWHW

8QGHUXWDUEHWDGHUHJLRQDYGHOQLQJDUQDVPHWRGJUXSSDQYLVQLQJDUI|U UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVIUDPVWlOOQLQJIRUPDWRFKLQQHKnOO%HVOXWRPDQYLVQLQJDUQD IDWWDGHVDY$VLHQDYGHOQLQJHQ(QOLJWEHVOXWHWVNDHQUHVXOWDWDQDO\VEHVWnDY • HQUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJLPDWULVIRUPPHGNRVWQDGVLQIRUPDWLRQRFKXSSJLIWHURP SODQHUDWRFKIDNWLVNWYHUNVDPKHWVXWIDOOVDPWUHVXOWDW • HQlPQHVPlVVLJUHVXOWDWDQDO\VGYVHQlPQHVPlVVLJWLQGHODGRFKSn UHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJHQJUXQGDGDQDO\VDYXWYHFNOLQJVVDPDUEHWHWVUHVXOWDWRFK 6FKLOO*|UDQ*UDQVNQLQJDYUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDL6LGDVODQGVWUDWHJLDUEHWH6LGD6WXGLHVLQ(YDOXDWLRQ  1LFDUDJXD6UL/DQND9LHWQDP9lVWEDQNHQ*D]D)LOLSSLQHUQD/DRV6\GDIULNDRFK1DPLELD 5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDI|U(VWODQG/HWWODQGRFK/LWDXHQKDUH[NOXGHUDWVIUnQ879VVWXGLHHIWHUVRP GHLQWHNRQFHQWUHUDVWLOOHQJLYHQWLGVSHULRG'lUPHGVDNQDVHQDYXWJnQJVSXQNWHUQDI|U879V VWXGLH QlPOLJHQIDNWLVNDXWEHWDOQLQJDUXQGHUHQYLVVWLGVSHULRG  5HJLRQDYGHOQLQJDUQDV0HWRGJUXSS$QYLVQLQJDUI|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\V

(8)

2 • HQVDPPDQIDWWDQGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VVRPEDVHUDVSnGHQlPQHVPlVVLJD UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHQRFKVRPKHOWHOOHULVLQDYlVHQWOLJDGHODULQJnUL ODQGVWUDWHJLGRNXPHQWHW (QOLJWEHVOXWHWVNDGHWYnVLVWQlPQGDDQDO\VGHODUQDNRQFHQWUHUDVWLOOVOXWVDWVHURP ELVWnQGHWVVDPPDQWDJQDUHVXOWDW SUHVWDWLRQHURFKHIIHNWHU VDPWRPGHWVlWWSn YLONHWJMRUGDHUIDUHQKHWHUE|USnYHUNDLQULNWQLQJSnRFKLQQHKnOOLQlVWNRPPDQGH ODQGVWUDWHJL (QWLOOI|UOLWOLJRFKXWW|PPDQGHUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJEHWUDNWDVVnOHGHVVRPHQ JUXQGOlJJDQGHI|UXWVlWWQLQJI|UEnGHlPQHVPlVVLJRFKVDPPDQIDWWDQGH UHVXOWDWDQDO\V'HWlUGRFNYLNWLJWDWWQRWHUDDWWUHGRYLVQLQJHQLQWHHIWHUIUnJDVDY UHJHULQJHQ'HWlUVQDUDUH6LGDVHJHQWRONQLQJDYUHJHULQJHQVLQVWUXNWLRQDWW UHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJLPDWULVIRUPDWlUHQYLNWLJI|UXWVlWWQLQJI|UWLOOI|UOLWOLJ UHVXOWDWDQDO\VLODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQ $QYLVQLQJDUQDI|UUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJLPDWULVIRUPDWlUHQNODRFKW\GOLJD )RUPDWHWPHGNROXPQHUI|UNRUWIDWWDGHNRPPHQWDUHUNRVWQDGVXWIDOORFK XSSJLIWHURPPnOVlWWQLQJDURFKUHVXOWDWSnSUHVWDWLRQVRFKHIIHNWQLYnlUULPOLJW PHGWDQNHSnDWWUHGRYLVQLQJHQLI|UVWDKDQGVNDDQYlQGDVVRPHQV\VWHPDWLVN JUXQGI|UGHSnVWnHQGHQVRPJ|UVLGHlPQHVPlVVLJDRFKVDPPDQIDWWDQGH DQDO\VGHODUQD 0HGWDQNHSnUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVUROOL6LGDVODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHUlUGHW DQJHOlJHWDWWPHWRGJUXSSHQVDQYLVQLQJDUJHQRP*'EHVOXWJHVVWDWXVVRP YHUNVJHPHQVDPPDULNWOLQMHUI|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVIUDPVWlOOQLQJIRUPRFKLQQHKnOO 'HWlULGDJWLOOH[HPSHORNODUWnWPLQVWRQHI|U879KXUXYLGD6LGDgVWVND RPIDWWDVDY$VLHQDYGHOQLQJHQVEHVOXW 0LQVWOLNDYLNWLJWlUDWWDQYLVQLQJDUQDJHVHQP|MOLJKHWDWWEOLOnQJVLNWLJWKnOOEDUD /LYVOlQJGHQI|UWLGLJDUHULNWOLQMHU 6$03%$%6RFK5(6$VLQVWUXNWLRQIUnQ  KDULQWHYDULWPHUlQHWWSDUnU'HQQDRPE\WOLJKHWKDUNQDSSDVWYDULW J\QQVDPI|UP\QGLJKHWHQVDUEHWVUXWLQHURFKSURGXNWLYLWHWLODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQ 'HWNDQJLYHWYLVILQQDVVNlODWWILQVOLSDRFKYLGDUHXWYHFNODP\QGLJKHWHQVULNWOLQMHU I|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\V879NDQGRFNNRQVWDWHUDDWWSUREOHPHQPHGGH UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUVRPXWIRUPDWVPHGKMlOSDYPHWRGJUXSSHQVDQYLVQLQJDUVQDUDUH KDUDWWJ|UDPHGGHDQVYDULJDDPEDVVDGHUQDVRFKDYGHOQLQJDUQDVWLOOlPSQLQJlQ PHGDQYLVQLQJDUQDVRPVnGDQD

%HG|PQLQJDY6LGDVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU

,OLNKHWPHG879VI|UVWDJUDQVNQLQJJ|UVNYDOLWHWVEHG|PQLQJHQDY6LGDV UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUXWLIUnQIHPIUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU • +XUP\FNHWELVWnQGDQDO\VHUDV" 7HOHIRQVDPWDOPHG)UHGULN6YHGlQJ

(9)

3 • 9LONDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUDV" • +XUDQDO\VHUDVUHVXOWDWHQ" • bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDWLOOI|UOLWOLJD" • bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDDQYlQGEDUD" +XUP\FNHWELVWnQGDQDO\VHUDV" )UnJDQNDQEHVYDUDVSnROLNDVlWW879KDUGHODWLQUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVXSSJLIWHUL WUHNDWHJRULHU H[HPSHOnWHUILQQVL%LODJD$  • XSSJLIWHUVRPVSHFLILFHUDUXWEHWDOQLQJDUQDVVWRUOHN NDWHJRUL  • XSSJLIWHURPXWEHWDOQLQJDUVRPlYHQLGHQWLILHUDUGHQ6LGDILQDQVLHUDGH YHUNVDPKHWHQ NDWHJRUL RFK • XSSJLIWHURPLGHQWLILHUDGHXWEHWDOQLQJDUVRPGHVVXWRPJ|UHQEHG|PQLQJDY YHUNVDPKHWHQVUHVXOWDW NDWHJRUL  5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVLQIRUPDWLRQJUXSSHUDGHIWHU879VWUHXSSJLIWVNDWHJRULHU UHGRYLVDVLI|OMDQGHWDEHOO 7DEHOO.ODVVLILFHULQJDYUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVXSSJLIWHURP6LGDVXWEHWDOQLQJDU WNU 7LGV

SHULRG 8WEHWDODWHQOLJW($ NDWHJRUL 8WEHWDODW ,GHQWLILHUDW NDWHJRUL NDWHJRUL %HG|PW EHG|PW$QGHO EHG|PQLQJDU$QWDO 1LFDUDJXD        6UL/DQND        /DRV        1DPLELD        9LHWQDP        6\GDIULND        9lVWE*D]D        )LOLSSLQHUQD        7RWDOW       7RWDOW       'HWlUYLNWLJWDWWXSSPlUNVDPPDDWWWDEHOOHQVEDNRPOLJJDQGHEHUlNQLQJDUlU SUREOHPDWLVNDSnROLNDVlWW)OHUDXSSVNDWWQLQJDUKDUJMRUWVSnHWWRIWDRNODUW XQGHUODJ'HWlUWLOOH[HPSHOLEODQGRNODUWYLONHQWLGVSHULRGVRPHQVNLOGDXSSJLIWHU RPXWEHWDOQLQJDUHJHQWOLJHQDYVHULQVDWVDYWDOHWVWLGVSHULRGHOOHUGHQWLGVSHULRG VRPUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHQNRQFHQWUHUDWVWLOO"bQPHURVlNHUWlUKXUVWRUGHODYGH

(10)

4 DQJLYQDNRVWQDGHUQDVRPUHVXOWDWXSSJLIWHUQDIDNWLVNWRPIDWWDUVNDHQJLYHQHIIHNW EHWUDNWDVVRPHQHIIHNWDYKHODVW|GHWHOOHUHQGDVWDYGHQGHODYVW|GHWVRP UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHQEHKDQGODU"6YnULJKHWHUQDDWWEHVYDUDGHVVDRFKOLNQDQGHIUnJRU LQQHElUDWWWDEHOOHQVXSSJLIWHUIUDPI|UDOOWYDGJlOOHUDQGHOHQEHG|PWELVWnQG GYVNDWHJRUL NQDSSDVWNDQEHWUDNWDVVRPH[DNWD (IWHUVRPVDPPDEHUlNQLQJVSUREOHPJlOOHUI|UVDPWOLJDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUlUGHW GRFNLQWUHVVDQWDWWMlPI|UDGHWVDPPDQODJGDXWIDOOHWPHGXWIDOOHWLWLGLJDUHnUV UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU'HWNDQNRQVWDWHUDVDWWDQGHOHQEHG|PWELVWnQGKDU|NDWWLOO MlPI|UWPHGL879VI|UVWDJUDQVNQLQJ7URWVDWWGHQI|UVWD JUDQVNQLQJHQRPIDWWDGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUGYVQlVWDQGXEEHOWVnPnQJDVRP I|UHOLJJDQGHVWXGLHKDUGHWWRWDODDQWDOHWEHG|PQLQJDUWUHGXEEODWVIUnQWLOO EHG|PQLQJDURP6LGDVELVWnQGXQGHUGHDNWXHOODWLGVSHULRGHUQD (QRUVDNWLOOGHW|NDGHEHG|PDQGHLQVODJHWLGHVHQDVWHnUHQVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUlU GHQUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJLPDWULVIRUPVRPXWDUEHWDWVDYUHJLRQDYGHOQLQJDUQDV PHWRGJUXSS0DWULVHQP|MOLJJ|UHWWNODUWVW|UUHDQWDONRUWIDWWDGHEHG|PQLQJDU RPELVWnQGHWVUHVXOWDWlQYDGVRPlUP|MOLJWHOOHUWLOOUnGOLJWLO|SDQGHWH[WIRUP 'HQlUGHVVXWRPHWW LSULQFLS XWPlUNWXQGHUODJI|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDV lPQHVPlVVLJDRFKVDPPDQIDWWDQGHGHODU 'HWPnVWHGRFNSnSHNDVDWWGHWlURP|MOLJWDWWIUnQ7DEHOOGUDQnJUDVOXWVDWVHU RPUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVNYDOLWHW)|UGHWI|UVWDE\JJHUWDEHOOHQXWHVOXWDQGHSn NYDQWLWDWLYDEHUlNQLQJDU(QOLJW879VVlWWDWWUlNQDLQQHKnOOHUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQD EHG|PQLQJDURP6LGDVELVWnQGPHQKXUXYLGDGHVVDXSSJLIWHUlUWLOOI|UOLWOLJD RFKDQYlQGEDUDLODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQlUIRUWIDUDQGHRNODUW )|UGHWDQGUDlUGHWRFNVnRNODUWPHGYLONHQPnWWVWRFNUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDE|U EHG|PDVbUEHG|PWELVWnQG GYVNDWHJRUL P\FNHWHOOHUOLWH"lUHQ RP|MOLJKHWHIWHUVRPP\QGLJKHWHQKHOWHQNHOWLQWHKDUXWYlUGHULQJVLQIRUPDWLRQRP DOOWELVWnQGRFKHIWHUVRPSURGXNWLRQVNRVWQDGHUQDI|UHQIXOOVWlQGLJUHVXOWDWDQDO\V VNXOOHEOLRULPOLJWK|JD2PIXOOVWlQGLJKHWlUHQRP|MOLJKHWYLONDNDWHJRULHUDY ELVWnQGHWE|UGnH[NOXGHUDV"879VI|UVODJlUDWWUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDV lPQHVPlVVLJDRFKVDPPDQIDWWDQGHGHODUE|UNRQFHQWUHUDVWLOOGH VWUDWHJL|YHUYlJDQGHQVRPIDNWLVNWlUI|UHPnOI|UGLVNXVVLRQLGHQDNWXHOOD ODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQ VHDYVQLWW  'HQI|UHVODJQDDYJUlQVQLQJHQWLOODNWXHOODVWUDWHJL|YHUYlJDQGHQE|UGRFNHMJlOOD UHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJHQLPDWULVIRUP'HQQDUHGRYLVQLQJERUGHLVWlOOHWYDUDI|UHPnO I|UHQDQQDQVRUWVDYJUlQVQLQJ'HWYRUHQlPOLJHQKHOWRULPOLJWDWWDY -lPI|UHOVHUPHOODQGHVVDXSSJLIWHUlUlYHQGHYDQVNOLJD(QDQOHGQLQJWLOODWWnUVJUDQVNQLQJ GURJVOXWVDWVHQDWW´HQGDVWµDYGHWDNWXHOODELVWnQGHWJLYLWVQnJRQIRUPDYEHG|PQLQJYDUDWW UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDI|U0R]DPELTXH7DQ]DQLD=DPELDRFK=LPEDEZHLQWHJMRUGHQnJRQNRSSOLQJ PHOODQXWEHWDODGHPHGHORFKUHGRYLVQLQJRFKDQDO\VDYIDNWLVNDUHVXOWDW2PGHVVDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU KDGHH[NOXGHUDWVIUnQJUDQVNQLQJHQVNXOOHDQGHOHQEHG|PWELVWnQGL879VI|UVWDJUDQVNQLQJYDUD  LQWH 

(11)

5 ELVWnQGVDQVODJHWVNDUHGRYLVDVLPDWULVIRUP8QGHUXWJMRUGHXWEHWDOQLQJDUSn PLQGUHlQHQPLOMRQNURQRUDYGHWWRWDODDQWDOHWLQVDWVHUPHQHQGDVWDY WRWDOWXWEHWDODGHPHGHO nWPLQVWRQHRPPDQInUWURGHWJDPOD($V\VWHPHWV XSSJLIWHU 'HWILQQVGlUI|UVNlOI|U6LGDDWWDQJHULNWOLQMHUlYHQI|U UHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJDUQDVLQQHKnOOWLOOH[HPSHODWWUHGRYLVQLQJDUQDHQGDVWVNDDYVH LQVDWVHU|YHUHQPLOMRQNURQRU6YDUSnGHVVDRFKDQGUDYLNWLJDIUnJRUE|UHQOLJW 879VXSSIDWWQLQJLQJnLRYDQQlPQGD*'EHVOXW VH$YVQLWW U|UDQGH P\QGLJKHWHQVYHUNVJHPHQVDPPDQRUPHURFKULNWOLQMHUI|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDV IUDPVWlOOQLQJIRUPRFKLQQHKnOO 9LONDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUDV" )|UDWWEHVYDUDIUnJDQKDU879IRNXVHUDWSnXSSJLIWHUVRPLQQHKnOOHUHQ EHG|PQLQJDYELVWnQGHWVUHVXOWDW GYVNDWHJRUL 8SSJLIWHUQDKDUVHGDQ NODVVLILFHUDWVXWLIUnQ/)$PRGHOOHQVWUHUHVXOWDWQLYnHUSUHVWDWLRQHUNRUWVLNWLJD HIIHNWHURFKOnQJVLNWLJDHIIHNWHU(WWVXEMHNWLYWLQVODJLNODVVLILFHULQJHQKDUYDULW RXQGYLNOLJW'HWUHVXOWDWVRPSUHVHQWHUDVL7DEHOOlUGlUI|UXQJHIlUOLJW 7DEHOO$QGHOEHG|PGDXSSJLIWHUSHUUHVXOWDWQLYn

5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHU 3UHVWDWLRQHU .RUWVLNWLJDHIIHNWHU /nQJVLNWLJDHIIHNWHU         6RPHQGLUHNWI|OMGDYPHWRGJUXSSHQVDQYLVQLQJDUKDUDQGHOHQLQIRUPDWLRQRP NRUWVLNWLJDHIIHNWHU|NDWPHGQlVWDQHQWUHGMHGHOLMlPI|UHOVHPHGnUV JUDQVNQLQJ$QGHOHQLQIRUPDWLRQRPSUHVWDWLRQHUKDUVMXQNLWXQJHIlUOLNDP\FNHW 'HQQDWUHQGOLJJHUDQWDJOLJHQKHOWLOLQMHPHGUHJHULQJHQV|QVNHPnO +XUDQDO\VHUDVUHVXOWDWHQ" )|UDWWEHVYDUDIUnJDQKDU879NODVVLILFHUDWUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDV EHG|PQLQVXSSJLIWHUHIWHUXWYlUGHULQJVNULWHULHUQDUHOHYDQVNRVWQDGVHIIHNWLYLWHW PnOXSSI\OOHOVHHIIHNWHU SnNRUWRFKOnQJVLNW RFKElUNUDIWLJKHW(WWPLQGUHDQWDO EHG|PQLQJVXSSJLIWHUlUGRFNLQWHDQQDWlQDOOPlQQDRPG|PHQVRPVSHFLILFHUDU DWWPHQLQWHYDUI|UHOOHUSnYLONHWVlWWUHVXOWDWHQlUEUDHOOHUGnOLJD 7DEHOO$QGHOEHG|PGDXSSJLIWHUSHUDQDO\VYHUNW\J

$OOPlQQDRPG|PHQ 5HOHYDQV .RVWQDGVHIIHNWLYLWH

W 0nOXSSI\OOHOVH (IIHNWHU %lUNUDIWLJKHW

      

      

,MlPI|UHOVHPHGnUVJUDQVNQLQJKDUDQGHOHQDOOPlQQDRPG|PHQVMXQNLW JDQVNDGUDVWLVNWYLONHWlUEUDHIWHUVRPVnGDQDXSSJLIWHUNQDSSDVWJDJQDU UHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVIRUPDWLYDV\IWHDWWOLJJDWLOOJUXQGI|UHQQ\ODQGVWUDWHJL

(12)

6 'HQVWDUNDVWHWUHQGHQlUGRFNDWWDQGHOHQXSSJLIWHURPELVWnQGHWVHIIHNWHUXWJ|U WUHIMlUGHGHODUDYVDPWOLJDEHG|PQLQJVXSSJLIWHU MlPI|UWPHGNQDSSWKlOIWHQL nUVJUDQVNQLQJ bYHQGHQQDWUHQGWRUGHOLJJDLOLQMHPHGUHJHULQJHQV |QVNHPnO bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDWLOOI|UOLWOLJD" (QGLVNXVVLRQRPWLOOI|UOLWOLJKHWNDQVHXWSnROLNDVlWW,JUDQVNQLQJHQIUnQ YDOGH879DWWIRNXVHUDSnNlOOKlQYLVQLQJRFKVDNOLJKHW .lOOKlQYLVQLQJ (QQRJJUDQQEHG|PQLQJDYWLOOI|UOLWOLJKHWI|UXWVlWWHUHQJHQRPJnQJDYGHNlOORU VRPUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDIDNWLVNWE\JJHUSn(QVnGDQEHG|PQLQJKDULQWHYDULW P|MOLJDWWJ|UDLQI|UGHQQDVWXGLH879KDULVWlOOHWI|UV|NWNDUWOlJJD NlOOKlQYLVQLQJDUQDI|UGHEHG|PQLQJVXSSJLIWHUVRPGLVNXWHUDWVLI|UHJnHQGH DYVQLWW/LNVRPLJUDQVNQLQJHQIUnQKDUWYnIUnJRUVWlOOWV • ,QQHKnOOHUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDW\GOLJDKlQYLVQLQJDUWLOOXSSJLIWHUQDVNlOORU" • ,YLONHQXWVWUlFNQLQJlUXSSJLIWHUQDVNlOORUXWYlUGHULQJVUDSSRUWHU" 2PPDQPHG´W\GOLJµNlOOKlQYLVQLQJPHQDUDWWGHWSnHWWHQNHOWVlWWJnUDWW NRQWUROOHUDHOOHUInPHULQIRUPDWLRQRPHQJLYHQXSSJLIWVnlUVYDUHWDWWGHWWD JHQHUHOOWVHWWLQWHlUP|MOLJWIUnQGHVHQDVWHWYnnUHQVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU 5HVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJDUQDLYLONDPHUSDUWHQDYGHXSSJLIWHUQDnWHUILQQVVDNQDU LUHJHOW\GOLJDNlOOKlQYLVQLQJDUbYHQRPGHWLEODQGILQQVHQNlOOI|UWHFNQLQJL VOXWHWDYUHGRYLVQLQJHQlUGHWVYnUWI|UHQXWRPVWnHQGHDWWLGHQWLILHUDYLOND XSSJLIWHUVRPIDNWLVNWK|UWLOOHQJLYHQNlOODEODQGDQQDWHIWHUVRP NlOOKlQYLVQLQJHQRIWDlURSUHFLVWLOOH[HPSHO´.lOORUPRWWDJDUUDSSRUWHULQJµ 5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVEULVWHUDYVHHQGHNlOOKlQYLVQLQJLQQHElUDWWGHWLQWHlUP|MOLJW DWWEHVYDUDI|OMGIUnJDQRPLYLONHQXWVWUlFNQLQJNlOORUQDXWJ|UVDYXWYlUGHULQJDU 6DNOLJKHW 5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVXSSJLIWHUlURIWDVnDOOPlQWKnOOQDDWWHQEHG|PQLQJDY VDNOLJKHWlUVYnUDWWJ|UD+XUXYLGDSnVWnHQGHQRPWLOOH[HPSHO´|NDG LQVWLWXWLRQHOONDSDFLWHWµHOOHU´|NDGPHGYHWHQKHWKRVEHIRONQLQJHQµNDQEHWUDNWDV VRPNRUUHNWDEHURUJLYHWYLVSnYDGVRPLGHWDNWXHOODIDOOHWPHQDVPHG|NDG NDSDFLWHWRFK|NDGPHGYHWHQKHW8WDQQlUPDUHLQIRUPDWLRQRPGHWWDlUGHW NQDSSDVWP|MOLJWDWWEHG|PDXSSJLIWHUQDVVDNOLJKHW(QXSSJLIWRP´|NDG LQVWLWXWLRQHOONDSDFLWHWµNDQVNHLQWHLQQHElUPHUlQDWWHWWNRQWRUKDUXWUXVWDWV PHGWLRGDWRUHURFKDWWGHODUDYSHUVRQDOHQYDULWSnNXUVL6YHULJH,VnIDOOILQQV GHWNDQVNHPLQGUHDQOHGQLQJDWWEHWYLYODSnVWnHQGHWVVDNOLJKHWlQRPGHWlUHQ PHUGMXSJnHQGHRFKRPIDWWDQGHI|UlQGULQJVRPDYVHV ,QnJUDIDOOILQQVGHWLUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDXSSJLIWHUVRPI|UHQQRUPDONULWLVNOlVDUH I|UHIDOOHUWlPOLJHQRVDQQROLND'HWlUWLOOH[HPSHOLQWHVDQQROLNWDWWHWW IRUVNQLQJVELGUDJSnPLOMRQHUNURQRUVRPDQYlQWVI|UDWWIUDPVWlOODROLND

(13)

7 SXEOLNDWLRQHURFKI|UDWWILQDQVLHUDHWWEHJUlQVDWDQWDOGRNWRUDQGRFK PDVWHUVXWELOGQLQJDUKDUUHVXOWHUDWLHWWLQIRUPDWLRQVFHQWHURFKHQJnUGI|U XWELOGQLQJDYE|QGHUSn6UL/DQND7URWVDWWXSSJLIWHUVRPSnGHWWDVlWWIDOOHUSn VLQHJHQRULPOLJKHWlUUHODWLYWVlOOV\QWDSnYHUNDUGHUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJDUQDV WURYlUGLJKHWLVWRUW bUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDDQYlQGEDUD" 5HVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDKDUHWWKXYXGVDNOLJWDQYlQGQLQJVRPUnGHQlPOLJHQVRP XQGHUODJI|UEHVOXWRPQ\ODQGVWUDWHJL7DQNHQlUDWW6LGDJHQRPDWWGUDOlUGRP DYWLGLJDUHUHVXOWDWRFKJHQRPDWWDQYlQGDGHVVDOlUGRPDULGHWQ\D ODQGVWUDWHJLI|UVODJHWVNDnVWDGNRPPDHWWElWWUHIUDPWLGDELVWnQG0HQWURWVDWW ´OlUDQGHµRFK´UHVXOWDWVW\UQLQJµlUIOLWLJWDQYlQGDEHJUHSSLQRPP\QGLJKHWHQlU GHWLQWHVMlOYNODUWnWPLQVWRQHLQWHI|U879YDGVRPHJHQWOLJHQNlQQHWHFNQDUHWW UHVXOWDWEDVHUDWODQGVWUDWHJLI|UVODJ'lUPHGlUGHWLQWHKHOOHUVMlOYNODUWYDGVRPL SUDNWLNHQNDUDNWlULVHUDUHQDQYlQGEDUUHVXOWDWDQDO\V 8WDQHQNODUXSSIDWWQLQJRPYDGVRPlUHQDQYlQGEDUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VlUGHW JLYHWYLVLQWHKHOOHUP|MOLJWDWWEHVYDUDIUnJDQRPGHVHQDVWHnUHQVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHU lUDQYlQGEDUD(QOlPSOLJXWJnQJVSXQNWI|UDWWUHGDXWIUnJDQRPYDGVRP NDUDNWlULVHUDUHQDQYlQGEDUUHVXOWDWDQDO\VlUGHVWUDWHJLVND|YHUYlJDQGHQVRP J|UVLODQGVWUDWHJLI|UVODJHW'HWlUQlPOLJHQI|UVWPHGHQNODUXSSIDWWQLQJRP NDUDNWlUHQSnGHVVD|YHUYlJDQGHQVRPGHWlUP|MOLJWDWWGLVNXWHUDYLONHQW\SDY UHVXOWDWLQIRUPDWLRQVRPlUUHOHYDQWRFKGlUPHGDQYlQGEDU I|UROLNDW\SHUDY |YHUYlJDQGHQ  (QVQDEEJHQRPJnQJDY6LGDVODQGVWUDWHJLHUYLVDUDWWROLNDVHNWRUYDOlUGHQNODUW YDQOLJDVWHW\SHQDY|YHUYlJDQGHQVRPJ|UVLODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQEHVO|W UHJHULQJHQWLOOH[HPSHODWWDYVOXWDVW|GHWWLOO6UL/DQNDLQRPXQGHUYLVQLQJVVHNWRUQ RFKLVWlOOHWVDWVDSnQlULQJVOLYVXWYHFNOLQJ (QP|MOLJKHWDWWJ|UDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDPHUDQYlQGEDUDWRUGHYDUDDWW NRQFHQWUHUDGHlPQHVPlVVLJDRFKVDPPDQIDWWDQGHDQDO\VGHODUQDWLOOGH |YHUYlJDQGHQVRPIDNWLVNWJ|UVNRPPHUDWWJ|UDVLGHQDNWXHOOD ODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQ2PHWW|YHUYlJDQGHJnUXWSnDWWDYVOXWDHWW XQGHUYLVQLQJVVW|GWLOOI|UPnQI|UQlULQJVOLYVXWYHFNOLQJVnE|UUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHQ IRNXVHUDSnRFKVNUlGGDUV\VI|UMXVWGHWWDVDPPDQKDQJ1RUPDOWE|UHQ ´K\SRWHVµRPHWWVnGDQWVHNWRUYDONXQQDJ|UDVUHGDQLGHQI|UHJnHQGH ODQGVWUDWHJLSURFHVVHQGYVWUHnULQQDQ6LGDVVWUDWHJLI|UVODJIDNWLVNWVNLFNDVLQWLOO UHJHULQJHQ'lUPHGILQQVGHWRFNVnWLOOUlFNOLJWPHGWLGI|UDWWSODQHUDRFK JHQRPI|UDXWYlUGHULQJDUVRPNDQOLJJDWLOOJUXQGI|UHQVNUlGGDUV\GG UHVXOWDWDQDO\V (WWODQGVWUDWHJLI|UVODJNDQJLYHWYLVLQQHKnOODROLNDW\SHUDY|YHUYlJDQGHQ0HQ GHWVSHODUPLQGUHUROO3RlQJHQlUDWWUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHQI|UDWWYDUDDQYlQGEDU RFKNRVWQDGVHIIHNWLY HQGDVWE|UDQDO\VHUDVnGDQDUHVXOWDWVRPlUUHOHYDQWDI|U DNWXHOODVWUDWHJLVND|YHUYlJDQGHQ

(14)

8 'HQFHQWUDODIUnJDQlUGlUI|UYDGVRPXWJ|UUHOHYDQWDUHVXOWDWJLYHWROLNDW\SHUDY |YHUYlJDQGHQ")UnJDQlUVYnUDWWEHVYDUDPHQQnJUDULNWOLQMHUERUGHNXQQDJHV JHQRPDWWQlUPDUHGLVNXWHUDNDUDNWlUHQSnW\SLVNDVWUDWHJL|YHUYlJDQGHQ DQDO\VHUDYDGVRPNDQYDUDUHOHYDQWUHVXOWDWLQIRUPDWLRQI|UGHVVD|YHUYlJDQGHQ RFKDWWXQGHUV|ND6LGDVP|MOLJDWLOOJnQJSnUHVXOWDWLQIRUPDWLRQVRPLROLND VDPPDQKDQJEHG|PVVRPUHOHYDQW

5HNRPPHQGDWLRQHU

,MlPI|UHOVHPHGGHUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUVRPSURGXFHUDGHVDY6LGDXQGHUSHULRGHQ LQQHKnOOHUGHVHQDVWHnUHQVUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUNYDQWLWDWLYWVHWWPnQJGXEEHOW IOHUEHG|PDQGHXSSJLIWHURPELVWnQGHWVUHVXOWDW(QNYDOLWDWLYMlPI|UHOVHlUVYnU DWWJ|UDPHQGHWlU879VLQWU\FNDWW6LGDKDUWDJLWIOHUDYLNWLJDVWHJIUDPnWL DUEHWHWDWW|NDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVNYDOLWHW 'HWDUEHWHVRPnWHUVWnUI|U6LGDDWWJ|UDLWHUPHUDYDQYLVQLQJDUKDQGODUHQOLJW 879VXSSIDWWQLQJIUDPI|UDOOWRPDWW|NDDQDO\VGHODUQDVDQYlQGEDUKHWRFKDWW DYJUlQVDUHVXOWDWUHGRYLVQLQJDUQDVRPIDWWQLQJ6LGDUHNRPPHQGHUDVGlUI|U • DWW|YHUYlJDRFKE\JJDYLGDUHSn879VI|UVODJWLOODWW|NDUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDV DQYlQGEDUKHW VHDYVQLWW  • DWWDQJHYHUNVJHPHQVDPPDULNWOLQMHUI|UKXUP\FNHWRFKYLONDGHODUDY6LGDV ELVWnQGVRPVNDUHGRYLVDVLPDWULVIRUP VHDYVQLWW • DWWJHQRP*'EHVOXWJHGHDQYLVQLQJDUVRPEHVOXWDWVDY$VLHQDYGHOQLQJHQ VWDWXVVRPYHUNVJHPHQVDPPDDQYLVQLQJDU

(15)

9

%LODJD$879VNODVVLILFHULQJDYUHVXOWDWDQDO\VHUQDVXSSJLIWHU

.DWHJRUL

,QVDWVEHVOXW

RFKWLGVSHULRG 6HNWRUPnO 3URMHNWPnO 8SSQnGGDHIIHNWHU 3ODQHUDGHSUHVWDWLRQHU 8SSQnGGDSUHVWDWLRQHU .RVWQDG 06(. 6NDWWHGDWDH[S HUWJHQRP ,0)81'3 1\WW GDWDEDVHUDW V\VWHPI|U PRPV XWYHFNODWRFK WHVWDW ,QIR VDNQDV 5nGJLYQLQJI|UXWYRFKWHVWDYGDWDSURJUDPI|U WLOOlPSQLQJLGQUI|U VNDWWVN\OGLJD%LVWnPHG NUDYVSHFI|U SLORWSURMHNWHQVDPWI|U XSSKDQGOLQJRFK LQVWDOODWLRQDYXWUXVWQ %LVWnPHGXWEI|U UHOHYDQWSHUVRQDO ,QIRVDNQDV )DNWLVNW  3ODQHUDW  7DEHOO$LQQHKnOOHUXSSJLIWHURP6LGDVXWEHWDOQLQJDUWLOOGHWDNWXHOODSURMHNWHW PHQLQWHXSSJLIWHUVRPLGHQWLILHUDUSURMHNWHWVIDNWLVNDSUHVWDWLRQHURFKLQWHKHOOHU XSSJLIWHUVRPJ|UHQEHG|PQLQJDYSURMHNWHWVXSSQnGGDHIIHNWHU .DWHJRUL ,QVDWVEHVOXW

RFKWLGVSHULRG 6HNWRUPnO 3URMHNWPnO 8SSQnGGDHIIHNWHU 3ODQHUDGHSUHVWDWLRQHU 8SSQnGGDSUHVWDWLRQHU .RVWQDG 06(. %HO\VQLQJ

,1(&8UEDQ gNDGVlNHUKHWLIDWWLJD RPUnGHQ 6WDWLVWLN VDNQDV 8SSI|UDQGHDYEHO\VQLQJV PDVWHUJDWXEH O\VQLQJXWPHG KXYXGVWUnN EHO\VQLQJV PDVWHUXSSI|UGD JDWXEHO\VQLQJ XWPHGKXYXG VWUnNKDUVOXWI|UWV   7RWDOW  7DEHOO%LQQHKnOOHUXSSJLIWHURP6LGDVXWEHWDOQLQJDUWLOOGHWDNWXHOODSURMHNWHW VDPWXSSJLIWHUVRPLGHQWLILHUDUSURMHNWHWVIDNWLVNDDNWLYLWHWHWHURFKSUHVWDWLRQHU PHQLQWHXSSJLIWHUVRPJ|UHQEHG|PQLQJDYSURMHNWHWVXSSQnGGDHIIHNWHU .DWHJRUL ,QVDWVEHVOXW

RFKWLGVSHULRG 6HNWRUPnO 3URMHNWPnO 8SSQnGGDHIIHNWHU 3ODQHUDGHSUHVWDWLRQHU 8SSQnGGDSUHVWDWLRQHU .RVWQDG 06(. 2PVWUXNWXUH ULQJDY WUDQVSRUW PLQLVWHULXP 6lNUDRFK HIIHNWLYD WUDQVSRUW WMlQVWHU /lJUHSULVHU |NDWDQVYDUV WDJDQGHHIIHN WLYLWHWRFK NDSDFLWHWSn PLQLVWHULHW 5HJHULQJVEHVOXW RPSROLF\I|U NRPPHUVLDOLVH ULQJRFKSULYDWL VHULQJK|MG PHG YHWDQGHJUDGRFK VDWVQLQJSn +5' (IIHNWLYDUHRFK PLQGUHRUJDQL VDWLRQ HWDEOHUDGH IO\JSODWVERODJ YlJYHUN YlJIRQGRFK YlJHQWUH SUHQ|UHU 2UJDQLVDWLRQV I|UVODJEHVOXW RPNRPPHU VLDOLVHULQJDY IO\JSODWVHU HWDEOHUDGHYlJ YHUNRFKYlJ IRQGXWELOG QLQJVLQVDWVHU   7RWDOW  7DEHOO&LQQHKnOOHUXSSJLIWHURP6LGDVXWEHWDOQLQJDUWLOOGHWDNWXHOODSURMHNWHW XSSJLIWHUVRPLGHQWLILHUDUSURMHNWHWVIDNWLVNDSUHVWDWLRQHUVDPWGHVVXWRPXSSJLIWHU VRPJ|UHQEHG|PQLQJDYSURMHNWHWVXSSQnGGDHIIHNWHU

(16)

6LGD6WXGLHVLQ(YDOXDWLRQ

96/1 Evaluation and Participation - some lessons. Anders Rudqvist, Prudence Woodford-Berger

Department for Evaluations and Internal Audit

96/2 Granskning av resultatanalyserna i Sidas landstrategiarbete. Göran Schill

Department for Evaluations and Internal Audit

96/3 Developmental Relief? An Issues Paper and an Annotated

Bibliography on Linking Relief and Development. Claes Lindahl Department for Evaluations and Internal Audit

96/4 The Environment and Sidas Evaluations. Tom Alberts, Jessica

Andersson

Department for Evaluations and Internal Audit

97/1 Using the Evaluation Tool. A survey of conventional wisdom and common practice at Sida. Jerker Carlsson, Kim Forss, Karin Metell, Lisa Segnestam, Tove Strömberg

Department for Evaluations and Internal Audit

97/2 Poverty Reduction and Gender Equality. An Assessment of Sida’s

Country Reports and Evaluations in 1995-96. Eva Tobisson, Stefan de Vylder

Secretariat for Policy and Corporate Development.

98/1 The Management of Disaster Relief Evaluations. Lessons from a Sida evaluation of the complex emergency in Cambodia. Claes Lindahl Department for Evaluation and Internal Audit

(17)
(18)

7;)(-7,-28)62%8-32%0():)0341)28'334)6%8-32%+)2'= 77XSGOLSPQ7[IHIR

8IP  *E\   8IPIKVEQWMHEWXSGOLSPQ4SWXKMVSr )QEMPMRJS$WMHEWI,SQITEKILXXT[[[WMHEWI

References

Related documents

Styrelsen och verkställande direktören för addVise inredning skyddsventilation ab (publ) får härmed avge förvaltningsberättelse för år 2007.05.01 –

Till årsstämman i addVise inredning skyddsventilation ab (publ) org nr 556363-2115 Jag har granskat årsredovisningen, koncernredovisningen och bokföringen samt styrelsens och

Utöver vår revision av årsredovisningen och koncernredovisningen har vi även utfört en revision av förslaget till dispositioner beträffande bolagets vinst eller förlust

Dock kan noteras att en föreslagen förändring av IFRS inne- bär att goodwill fortsättningsvis inte skall skrivas av utan istället årligen prövas för nedskrivning. Vidare avviker

TMA372/MMG800: Partial Differential Equations, 2017–03–15, 14:00-18:00 Telephone: Mohammad Asadzadeh: ankn 3517.. Calculators, formula notes and other subject related material are

[r]

Av de tio siffrorna kan vi bilda hur många tal som

9288 Förråd / Flik Saldokontroll - Detaljer Fälten ”Modell” resp ”Artikelnr” har förlängts. 9289 Förråd / Artikelkatalog / Flik Leverantörer