• No results found

Usability Design: A framework for designing usable interactive systems in practice

N/A
N/A
Info
Download
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Usability Design: A framework for designing usable interactive systems in practice"

Copied!
116
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Download now ( 116 Page )

Full text

(1)IT Licentiate theses 2001-006. Usability Design: A Framework for Designing Usable Interactive Systems in Practice BENGT GÖRANSSON. UPPSALA UNIVERSITY Department of Information Technology.

(2)

(3) 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH ,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH. BY BENGT GÖRANSSON June 2001. DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN-COMPUTER INTERACTION INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY UPPSALA UNIVERSITY UPPSALA SWEDEN. Dissertation for the degree of Licentiate of Philosophy in Human-Computer Interaction at Uppsala University 2001.

(4) . Usability Design: A Framework for Designing Usable Interactive Systems in Practice %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ Bengt.Goransson@hci.uu.se.  'HSDUWPHQWRI+XPDQ&RPSXWHU,QWHUDFWLRQ ,QIRUPDWLRQ7HFKQRORJ\ 8SSVDOD8QLYHUVLW\ %R[ 6(8SSVDOD 6ZHGHQ  http://www.it.uu.se/.   Bengt Göransson 2001 ISSN 1404-3203 Printed by the Department of Information Technology, Uppsala University, Sweden.

(5) $EVWUDFWL. $EVWUDFW p="©:˜h"m©˜4phz"maF’˜^"¦F˜’›"›F=˜›p˜*F4phF˜"§"F˜pO˜›^F˜"=¦"m›"VF’˜ pO˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜ p§F¦F:˜a›˜a’˜F¨›FhFd©˜"F˜›^"›˜4phz"maF’˜"=pz›˜ "˜O¤dd©˜am›FV"›F=˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜"zzp"4^˜am˜pmF˜’›"›FVa4˜’^aO›˜ "›^F:˜4phz"maF’˜›Fm=˜›p˜"=pz›˜z"4›a4F’˜"m=˜hF›^p=’˜am˜’›"VF’˜p˜"=pz›˜ "˜z"›a4¤d"˜hF›^p=˜p˜z"4›a4F˜pmd©˜§^Fm˜"˜4phzdF¨˜’F›˜pO˜O"4›p’˜"daVm˜ ›p˜4F"›F˜F"=amF’’˜^FF˜a’˜"˜*aV˜h"cF›˜Op˜4phz"maF’˜¦Fm=amV˜¤’"*ada›©˜ hF›^p=’:˜*¤›˜zpp˜¤’"*ada›©˜pO˜’©’›Fh’˜"m=˜zp=¤4›’˜a’˜’›add˜¦F©˜4ph_ hpmI›^F˜¦Fm=p’˜pO›Fm˜*d"hamV˜a›˜pm˜O"4›p’˜p¤›’a=F˜›^Fa˜ahhF=a"›F˜am_ Od¤Fm4F˜^a’:˜"hpmV˜p›^F˜›^amV’:˜a’˜"˜4"dd˜Op˜¤’˜›p˜§pc˜Op˜"˜¤’F_ 4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜"››a›¤=F˜"’˜"˜h"bp˜’›"›FV©˜Op˜›^F˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜ zp4F’’˜ ^F˜4pm›Fm›˜pO˜›^a’˜›^F’a’˜a’˜=F=a4"›F=˜›p˜›^F˜„¤F’›apm˜pO˜^p§˜›p˜=F_ ¦Fdpz˜¤’"*dF˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’˜am˜z"4›a4F˜"am˜Op4¤’˜a’˜pm˜^p§˜§F˜4"m˜ "a’F˜›^F˜"§"FmF’’˜pO˜¤’"*ada›©”˜"›a4¤d"›F˜›^F˜mFF=˜Op˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜ §a›^am˜›^F˜am=¤’›©˜"m=˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜pV"ma’"›apm’”˜"m=˜z"4›a4F˜¤’F_ 4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜˜O"hF§pc˜Op˜¤’"*ada›©˜=F’aVm˜"’˜"m˜¤mzF›Fm›ap¤’˜§"©˜ pO˜"zzd©amV˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜a’˜=F’4a*F=˜"m=˜=a’4¤’’F=. ˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(6) LL$EVWUDFW. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(7) . ˜ ˜. p˜ddamp˜"m=˜"d:˜§a›^˜dp¦F˜. .

(8) . .

(9) $FNQRZOHGJHPHQWVY. $FNQRZOHGJHPHQWV "m©˜›^"mc’˜›p˜h©˜OaFm=’˜"m=˜’¤zF¦a’p’:˜FmV›˜"m=*d"=˜"m=˜ "m˜ ¤d_ dac’Fm:˜Op˜^FdzamV˜hF˜p¤›˜§a›^˜›^a’˜›^F’a’˜"m=˜V¤a=amV˜hF˜am˜h©˜F’F"4^˜

(10) ˜§p¤d=˜dacF˜›p˜"4cmp§dF=VF˜"m=˜^pmp¤˜"dd˜h©˜4p_§a›F’9˜ac˜pÆd¦:˜ m=F’˜ a’c:˜ "m˜ ¤ddac’Fm:˜"Vm¤’˜aO:˜¦"˜d’’pm:˜FmV›˜"m=*d"=:˜ p’›Fm˜"m=*Æ4c˜"m=˜Fddp˜^ph"’’pm˜^"mc˜©p¤˜Op˜"dd˜©p¤˜^Fdz˜am˜ h"camV˜›^a’˜›^F’a’˜zp’’a*dF:˜Op˜F§"=amV˜=a’4¤’’apm’˜"m=˜dp›’˜pO˜O¤m˜ p˜"dd˜h©˜4pddF"V¤F’˜"m=˜OaFm=’˜"›˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_ phz¤›F˜

(11) m›F"4›apm˜"›˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©:˜

(12) ˜VF"›d©˜"zzF4a"›F˜©p¤˜ ’¤zzp›˜"m=˜*"4c_¤z˜

(13) ˜p§F˜mF"˜F=am":˜h©˜OaFm=’˜"m=˜4pddF"V¤F’˜›^FF:˜ "˜=FFz˜"m=˜^pmF’›˜›^"mc˜©p¤˜Op˜’¤zzp›:˜Fm4p¤"VFhFm›:˜"’˜§Fdd˜"’˜am›F_ F’›amV˜"m=˜O¤a›O¤d˜=a’4¤’’apm’˜©˜OaFm=’˜"›˜›^F˜F=a4"d˜"m=˜apdpVa4"d˜

(14) mOph"›a4’˜a¦a’apm˜"›˜›^F˜ Fh"m˜"m4F˜F’F"4^˜Fm›F˜| ! }˜am˜ Fa=Fd*FV:˜ Fh"m©9˜›^"mc˜©p¤˜Op˜›^F˜ 

(15)  ˜’›¤OO˜"m=˜"dd˜›^F˜¤mOp_ VF››"*dF˜F¦FmamV’˜am˜ Fa=Fd*FV˜

(16) ˜"d’p˜§a’^˜›p˜F¨zF’’˜h©˜"zzF4a"›apm˜›p˜h©˜Oa’›˜›¤›p˜"›’˜am=˜§^p˜ am›p=¤4F=˜hF˜›p˜›^F˜’¤*bF4›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(17) m›F"4›apm˜ ^"mc’˜›p˜"dd˜zF’pm’˜§a›^˜§^ph˜

(18) ˜^"¦F˜*FFm˜§pcamV˜"›˜›^F˜§F=a’^˜ "›apm"d˜"¨˜p"=˜| }:˜am˜z"›a4¤d"9˜bFddÄcF˜ Fmac’’pm:˜’*b¶m˜ "m«Ám˜"m=˜"dam˜F››F’’pm˜

(19) ˜"d’p˜§a’^˜›p˜hFm›apm˜"˜OF§˜p›^F’˜

(20) ˜^"¦F˜ ^"=˜›^F˜pzzp›¤ma›©˜›p˜§pc˜§a›^9˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜›F"h˜"›˜^"h"˜ pam›:˜F’zF4a"dd©˜mp˜adbF="^d”˜›^F˜hFh*F’˜pO˜›^F˜"d›pm˜zpbF4›˜"›˜h_ F’^"h˜^"h"4a"˜ap›F4^”˜"m=˜mmac"˜ "=Fma¤’˜"›˜mF"˜¤’amF’’˜pO›_ §"F˜

(21) ˜§p¤d=˜dacF˜›p˜F¨zF’’˜h©˜^¤h*dF˜"=ha"›apm˜›p˜"dd˜z"›a4az"m›’˜am˜›^F˜ F’F"4^˜"m=˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zpbF4›’˜

(22) ˜^"¦F˜*FFm˜am¦pd¦F=˜am˜=¤amV˜h©˜zp_ OF’’apm"d˜4"FF:˜"m=˜"*p¦F˜"dd:˜›p˜"dd˜¤’F’˜p¤›˜›^FFM˜ ^F˜§F=a’^˜p¤m4ad˜Op˜pc˜aOF˜F’F"4^˜| }˜^"’˜z"›d©˜Oa_ m"m4F=˜h©˜F’F"4^:˜›^"mc˜©p¤˜ am"dd©:˜h©˜dp¦F˜VpF’˜›p˜h©˜O"had©˜ddamp˜"m=˜"dI©p¤˜h"=F˜a›˜zp’’a_. *dF˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(23) YL$FNQRZOHGJHPHQWV. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(24) 3UHIDFHYLL. 3UHIDFH ^a’˜›^F’a’˜^"’˜›§p˜’FVhFm›’9˜›^F˜Oa’›˜§a›^˜"˜*"4cVp¤m=˜"m=˜’¤hh"©˜pO˜ h©˜§pc”˜Opddp§F=˜*©˜pmF˜§a›^˜z"zF’˜FzF’Fm›amV˜›^F˜’4aFm›aOa4˜F’¤d›˜pO˜ h©˜§pc˜^F˜z"zF’˜"F˜"’˜Opddp§’9˜. L $8VHU&HQWHUHG$SSURDFKWR2EMHFW2ULHQWHG8VHU,QWHUIDFH'H VLJQ˜ "m˜ ¤ddac’Fm:˜FmV›˜ ¶"m’’pm˜"m=˜"Vm¤’˜aO˜|¢¬¬s}˜. ppc˜4^"z›F˜am9˜*bF4›˜p=FdamV˜"m=˜’F˜

(25) m›FO"4F˜F’aVm:˜F=_ a›F=˜*©˜"c˜¦"m˜ "hFdFm:˜==a’pm_F’dF©:˜

(26)  ˜¬_¢¬s_–Q•Gn_ n˜. LL 5HHQJLQHHULQJWKH6\VWHPV'HYHORSPHQW3URFHVVIRU8VHU&HQWUHG 'HVLJQ˜ "m˜ ¤ddac’Fm˜"m=˜FmV›˜ ¶"m’’pm˜|¢¬¬s}˜"zF˜"4_. 4Fz›F=˜›p˜*F˜zF’Fm›F=˜"›˜›^F˜aV^›^˜

(27)

(28) ˜ s˜4pmOFFm4F˜pm˜ ¤_ h"m_phz¤›F˜

(29) m›F"4›apm9˜

(30)  Œ¬s:˜pc©p:˜ "z"m:˜ ¤d©˜n_ s:˜¢¬¬s˜. LLL 8VDELOLW\GHVLJQHUVLPSURYHWKHXVHUFHQWUHGGHVLJQSURFHVV˜ FmV›˜ ¶"m’’pm˜"m=˜p’›Fm˜"m=*Æ4c˜|snnn}˜

(31) m˜›^F˜zp4FF=amV’˜ pO˜›^F˜

(32)

(33) ˜ s˜

(34) m›Fm"›apm"d˜pmOFFm4F˜pm˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(35) m›F"4›apm9˜

(36)  Œnn:˜¦pd˜

(37)

(38) :˜zz˜s–_s–•:˜=am*¤V^:˜ :˜ ¤V¤’›˜¬˜J˜Fz›Fh*F˜:˜snnn˜. LY 7KH'HVLJQRID6PDUW&DUG%DVHG+RPH+HOS6\VWHP˜m=F’˜ a’c:˜FmV›˜ ¶"m’’pm:˜p’›Fm˜"m=*Æ4c˜"m=˜Fddp˜^ph"’’pm˜ |¢¬¬s}˜"zF˜"44Fz›F=˜›p˜*F˜zF’Fm›F=˜"›˜›^F˜aV^›^˜

(39)

(40) ˜ s˜ 4pmOFFm4F˜pm˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(41) m›F"4›apm9˜

(42)  Œ¬s:˜p_ c©p:˜ "z"m:˜ ¤d©˜n_s:˜¢¬¬s˜. Y $7HOHUDGLRORJ\6\VWHP'HVLJQ&DVH˜ac˜pÆd¦˜"m=˜FmV›˜. ¶"m’’pm˜|snn•}˜

(43) m9˜ Fa››˜¦"m˜=F˜FF:˜¤’›am˜ Fm=F’pm:˜ ¤’"m˜pdF’9˜F’aVmamV˜

(44) m›F"4›a¦F˜©’›Fh’9˜p4F’’F’:˜"4›a4F’:˜ F›^p=’˜"m=˜F4^ma„¤F’˜

(45)  Žn•˜4pmOFFm4F˜zp4FF=amV’˜pO˜›^F˜  ˜zF4a"d˜

(46) m›FF’›˜ p¤z˜am˜phz¤›F_ ¤h"m˜

(47) m›F"4›apm˜|

(48) _. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(49) YLLL3UHIDFH. 

(50) }˜am˜4p_pzF"›apm˜§a›^˜›^F˜

(51) m›Fm"›apm"d˜ F=F"›apm˜Op˜

(52) mOp_. h"›apm˜p4F’’amV˜|

(53)

(54)  ˜ ˜s¢}:˜zz˜¢•_¬:˜h’›F="h:˜¤V¤’›˜ sG_¢¬:˜snn•˜. YL 8VDELOLW\DQGHIILFLHQF\7KH+HOLRVDSSURDFKWRGHYHORSPHQWRI XVHULQWHUIDFHV˜ac˜pÆd¦:˜FmV›˜ ¶"m’’pm:˜¦"˜d’’pm˜"m=˜. FmV›˜"m=*d"=˜|snnT}˜

(55) m9˜˜mVFdh"mm:˜ ˜˜ F"m˜"m=˜˜F_ Vp¤dF›˜|=’}:˜^F˜ 

(56)  ˜pO›§"F˜mVamFFamV˜m¦apmhFm›:˜ ¤zzdFhFm›˜›p˜phz¤›F˜F›^p=’˜"m=˜pV"h’˜am˜aphF=a4amF:˜ TQ:˜zz˜–_•–˜ Fzam›’˜§FF˜h"=F˜§a›^˜zFha’’apm˜Oph˜z¤*da’^F’˜§^FF˜"zzda4"*dF˜ $XWKRU·VJXLGHWRWKHUHDGHU

(57) ˜=p˜mp›˜F¨zF4›˜›^F˜F"=F˜›p˜F"=˜›^a’˜›^F’a’˜Oph˜›^F˜Oa’›˜z"VF˜›p˜›^F˜d"’›:˜ ¤mdF’’˜©p¤˜"F˜z"›a4¤d"d©˜am›FF’›F=˜am˜›^F˜’¤*bF4›˜^F˜’¤hh"©˜a›’FdO˜a’˜ §p›^§^adF˜F"=amV˜Op˜›^p’F˜am›FF’›F=˜am˜¤’"*ada›©˜"m=˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F_ ’aVm˜am˜VFmF"d˜^F˜Oa’›˜Op¤˜4^"z›F’˜"F˜hpF˜pO˜"˜*"4cVp¤m=:˜§^adF˜am˜ 4^"z›F’˜Q˜"m=˜–˜

(58) ˜Oph¤d"›F˜’phF˜mF§˜a=F"’˜"m=˜="§˜4pm4d¤’apm’˜Oph˜ h©˜F’F"4^˜F’¤d›’˜^"z›F˜•˜a’˜"˜’^p›˜=F’4az›apm˜pO˜›^F˜z"zF’˜am_ 4d¤=F=:˜"m=˜am˜4^"z›F˜G˜

(59) ˜Va¦F˜"˜OF§˜^am›’˜"*p¤›˜h©˜O¤›¤F˜F’F"4^˜=aF4_ ›apm˜ FV"=amV˜›^F˜z"zF’˜am˜›^F˜’F4pm=˜z"›˜pO˜›^F˜›^F’a’9˜›^FF˜a’˜"m˜amOp_ h"d˜Vp¤zamV˜pO˜›^F˜z"zF’˜am›p˜›^FF˜Vp¤z’˜

(60) O˜©p¤˜h"am˜4pm4Fm˜a’˜›^F˜ =F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’:˜F"=9˜a:˜aa˜"m=˜aaa˜

(61) O˜©p¤˜"F˜hpF˜am›FF’›F=˜am˜=F_ ›"adF=˜=F’aVm˜a’’¤F’˜"m=˜zp›p›©zamV:˜F"=˜z"zF’9˜a¦˜"m=˜¦˜

(62) O˜©p¤˜§"m›˜›p˜ cmp§˜hpF˜"*p¤›˜›^F˜’¤*bF4›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(63) m›F"4›apm˜"m=˜=F’aVm˜ zam4azdF’˜F"=˜z"zF˜m¤h*F˜¦a˜ $ERXWP\FRZULWHUV (ULN%RUlOY˜p’›_V"=¤"›F˜’›¤=Fm›˜"›˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_. phz¤›F˜

(64) m›F"4›apm:˜

(65) mOph"›apm˜F4^mpdpV©:˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜ $QGHUV)ULVN˜F¦FdpzF˜"m=˜4pm’¤d›"m›˜"›˜^"h"’pO›˜ ˜. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(66) 3UHIDFHL[. -DQ*XOOLNVHQ˜’’p4a"›F˜zpOF’’p˜"›˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_. phz¤›F˜

(67) m›F"4›apm:˜

(68) mOph"›apm˜F4^mpdpV©:˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜ 0DJQXV/LI˜^aFO˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(69) m›F"4›apm˜OOa4F˜"›˜

(70) 4pm˜F=a"d"*˜. pm=pm˜"daF˜"›˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(71) m›F"4›apm:˜

(72) m_ Oph"›apm˜F4^mpdpV©:˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜ (YD2OVVRQ˜p’›_V"=¤"›F˜’›¤=Fm›˜"›˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤h"m_. phz¤›F˜

(73) m›F"4›apm:˜

(74) mOph"›apm˜F4^mpdpV©:˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜ %HQJW6DQGEODG˜’’p4a"›F˜zpOF’’p˜"m=˜ F"=˜pO˜›^F˜Fz"›hFm›˜pO˜ ¤_. h"m_phz¤›F˜

(75) m›F"4›apm:˜

(76) mOph"›apm˜F4^mpdpV©:˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜ 7RUVWHQ6DQGElFN˜F¦FdpzF˜"m=˜4pm’¤d›"m›˜"›˜mF"˜F=am"˜ ˜ 9HOOR7KRPDVVRQ˜F¦FdpzF˜"m=˜4pm’¤d›"m›˜"›˜ "©*a’˜ ˜. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(77) [3UHIDFH. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(78) 7DEOHRI&RQWHQWV[L. 7$%/(2)&217(176 6800$5<. . . ,QWURGXFWLRQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. . 5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. . . 5HVHDUFKVFRSHDQGP\DLPV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. . 5HVHDUFKPHWKRGVDQGZRUNSUDFWLFH BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. +XPDQ&RPSXWHU,QWHUDFWLRQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  . . . . 'LVFXVVLRQDERXW+&, BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . 8VDELOLW\ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  . 'HILQLQJXVDELOLW\BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 8VDELOLW\JRDOV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 'LVFXVVLRQDERXWXVDELOLW\ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . 8VHU&HQWUHG'HVLJQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  . ,QWURGXFWLRQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . %DFNJURXQGDQGKLVWRU\ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 8VHUFHQWUHGGHVLJQWKHSULQFLSOHVBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 'HYHORSPHQWSURFHVVHVLQWKHLQGXVWU\ BBBBBBBBBBB . . +HXULVWLFVIRU8&' BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 'LVFXVVLRQDERXW8&' BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  . :KDWLVXVDELOLW\GHVLJQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(79) [LL7DEOHRI&RQWHQWV. . $SURFHVVIRUXVDELOLW\GHVLJQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 7KH8VDELOLW\'HVLJQHU BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 'LVFXVVLRQDERXWXVDELOLW\GHVLJQ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 3DSHUVLQWKLVWKHVLV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . &RQFOXVLRQV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB  . . )XWXUHZRUN BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . 5HIHUHQFHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB . . 3$3(56L²YL. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(80) 6XPPDU\,QWURGXFWLRQ. 6800$5< J˜^F˜^aV^_›F4^˜am=¤’›©˜a’˜am˜=Fma"d˜pO˜"˜’ahzdF˜O"4›˜›^"›˜F¦F©˜ zF’pm˜§a›^˜"˜4Fdd˜z^pmF˜p˜"˜§p=˜zp4F’’p˜4"m˜4dF"d©˜’FF9˜ ¤˜4phz¤›Fa«F=˜›ppd’˜"F˜›pp˜^"=˜›p˜¤’F˜^F˜’pO›§"F˜FmVa_ mFF’˜§^p˜4F"›F˜›^Fh˜^"¦F˜›aF=˜"’˜^"=˜"’˜›^F©˜4"m˜›p˜h"cF˜ ›^Fh˜F"’©˜›p˜¤’F˜"m=˜›^F©˜^"¦F˜h"=F˜’phF˜hamp˜zpVF’’˜ ^F©˜*FdaF¦F˜›^"›˜›^Fa˜zp=¤4›’˜"F˜"’˜F"’©˜›p˜¤’F˜"’˜a›˜a’˜›F4^_ ma4"dd©˜zp’’a*dF˜›p˜h"cF˜›^Fh˜’˜FmVamFF’:˜›^Fa˜*FdaFO˜a’˜am˜ ›F4^mpdpV©:˜"m=˜›^F©˜^"¦F˜O"a›^˜›^"›˜pmd©˜’phF˜mF§˜›F4^mpdpV©:˜ dacF˜¦pa4F˜F4pVma›apm˜p˜"›aOa4a"d˜am›FddaVFm4F:˜§add˜ahzp¦F˜›^F˜ ¤’FŒ’˜F¨zFaFm4F˜ $ODQ&RRSHULQ´7KHLQPDWHVDUHUXQQLQJWKHDV\OXP:K\KLJK WHFKSURGXFWVGULYHXVFUD]\DQGKRZWRUHVWRUHWKHVDQLW\µ S.  ,QWURGXFWLRQ ^F˜"F"’˜pO˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(81) m›F"4›apm˜| 

(82) }:˜’F_Fm›F=˜F’aVm˜ | }˜"m=˜¤’"*ada›©˜^"¦F˜*FFm˜F4pVma’F=˜"m=˜›"cFm˜hpF˜’Fap¤’d©˜*©˜›^F˜ am=¤’›©˜=¤amV˜›^F˜d"’›˜4p¤zdF˜pO˜©F"’˜^FF˜"F˜’F¦F"d˜F"’pm’˜Op˜›^a’:˜ *¤›˜pmF˜ahzp›"m›˜"m=˜›"mVa*dF˜F"’pm˜a’I›^F˜a’F˜"m=˜ahz"4›˜pO˜›^F˜

(83) m›FmF›˜"m=˜›^F˜pd=˜a=F˜F*˜|§F*}˜F§˜4phz"maF’˜Op4¤’amV˜pm˜›^F˜

(84) m›FmF›˜|FV˜›^F˜‰=p›_4phŠ˜4phz"maF’}˜^"¦F:˜"hpmV˜p›^F˜›^amV’:˜"m_ p›^F˜ha¨˜pO˜’cadd’˜am˜›^Fa˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜¨zp’amV˜’F¦a4F’˜ pm˜›^F˜

(85) m›FmF›:˜’¤4^˜"’˜›^F˜§F*:˜›p˜›^F˜VFmF"d˜z¤*da4˜^"’˜4"ddF=˜Op˜"˜mF§˜ "§"FmF’’˜pO˜¤’"*ada›©˜"m=˜^"’˜z¤›˜Op4¤’˜pm˜›^F˜am›F"4›apm˜*F›§FFm˜¤’F’˜ "m=˜›^F˜’F¦a4F’˜zp¦a=F=˜¦a"˜"˜=F¦a4F˜’¤4^˜"’˜"˜4phz¤›F˜phz"maF’˜"m=˜ pV"ma’"›apm’˜›^"›˜"F˜mp§˜’›"›amV˜›p˜am4pzp"›F˜ 

(86) ˜cmp§dF=VF:˜¤’F_ 4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜"4›a¦a›aF’˜"m=˜¤’"*ada›©˜4phzF›Fm4F˜am›p˜›^Fa˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦Fd_ pzhFm›˜zp4F’’F’˜=p˜mp›˜=p˜›^a’˜Op˜4^"a›©˜F"’pm’:˜›^F©˜’FF˜"˜4phhF_ 4a"d˜am›FF’›˜am˜=F¦FdpzamV˜’©’›Fh’˜›^"›˜"F˜¤’"*dF9˜hpF˜¤’F’IhpF˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(87) 6XPPDU\,QWURGXFWLRQ. hpmF©”˜hpF˜’"›a’OaF=˜¤’F’IhpF˜hpmF©”˜hpF˜zp=¤4›a¦F˜¤’F’IhpF˜ hpmF©˜F›4˜ ^FF˜a’˜F"dd©˜"m˜am›FF’›˜Oph˜›^F˜am=¤’›©˜›p˜’›"›˜›p˜¤’F˜hF›^p=’˜"m=˜ zp4F’’F’˜›^"›˜^"¦F˜›^F˜zp›Fm›a"d˜›p˜zp=¤4F˜hpF˜¤’"*dF˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’_ ›Fh’˜^a’˜^"’˜*FFm˜=F’4a*F=˜am˜’F¦F"d˜am=FzFm=Fm›˜Fzp›’˜p¦F˜F4Fm›˜ ©F"’˜mF˜F¨"hzdF˜a’˜›^F˜Fzp›˜*©˜"›«FOO˜%˜¦Æ=˜|snnQ}˜^Fa˜am¦F’_ ›aV"›apm˜›pd=˜¤’˜›^"›˜›^F˜§F=a’^˜am=¤’›©˜am˜VFmF"d˜§"’˜mp›˜¦F©˜h"›¤F˜ §^Fm˜a›˜4"hF˜›p˜›^F˜¤’"*ada›©˜"’zF4›’˜pO˜"˜’©’›Fh˜ p§F¦F:˜›^F˜4phz"maF’˜ ’›¤=aF=˜§FF˜¦F©˜am›FF’›F=˜am˜’›"›amV˜›p˜dF"m˜hpF˜"*p¤›˜›^a’˜"F"˜^F˜ =F¦FdpzhFm›˜pO˜hF›^p=’˜"m=˜zp4F’’F’˜›pVF›^F˜§a›^˜›^F˜am›FV"›apm˜pO˜ ¤’"*ada›©_Fd"›F=˜"4›a¦a›aF’˜am›p˜›^Fa˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’˜§"’˜^aV^d©˜ "mcF=˜˜ ^p¤V^˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜"zzdaF=˜§pc˜

(88) ˜^"¦F˜p*’F¦F=˜›^"›˜4phz"_ maF’˜"m=˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"zzp"4^˜›^F˜4^"ddFmVF˜pO˜=F¦FdpzamV˜¤’"*dF˜am›F_ "4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’˜am˜=aOOFFm›˜§"©’9˜ ™˜h"bpa›©˜=p˜mp›˜’FF˜›^F˜mFF=˜›p˜=F=a4"›F˜›^Fh’Fd¦F’˜›p˜¤’"*ad_ a›©˜^F©˜’FF˜›^F˜¤’"*ada›©˜pO˜"˜’©’›Fh˜"’˜’phF›^amV˜›^"›˜4"m˜*F˜ ›"cFm˜4"F˜pO˜§a›^˜hamp˜^"m=’_pm˜"4›a¦a›aF’˜’¤4^˜"’˜"==amV˜ ’phF˜V"z^a4’˜›p˜›^F˜¤’F˜am›FO"4F˜ ™›^F’˜’›"›˜›p˜am4pzp"›F˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜"4›a¦a›aF’˜am›p˜›^Fa˜4¤_ Fm›˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’˜pm˜"˜hpF˜FV¤d"˜*"’a’˜^F©˜§add˜’›add˜ ¤’F˜§^"›F¦F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’˜›^F©˜"F˜¤’amV:˜*¤›˜"==˜’phF˜ "4›a¦a›aF’˜ ™F©˜OF§˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"F˜§addamV˜›p˜Vp˜›^F˜ §^pdF˜§"©˜"m=˜"=pz›˜"˜›¤d©˜ ˜zp4F’’˜^F’F˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜ pV"ma’"›apm’˜F"da’F˜›^"›˜*FamV˜4phha››F=˜›p˜¤’"*ada›©˜hF"m’˜ ›^"›˜›^FF˜h¤’›˜*F˜"˜’^aO›˜am˜›^F˜§"©˜›^"›˜›^F©˜=F¦Fdpz˜am›F"4_ ›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’˜^F©˜›"cF˜"˜’›"m4F˜"m=˜4phha›˜›^Fh’Fd¦F’˜›p˜"˜ ¤’F_4Fm›F=˜z^adp’pz^©˜ "©˜"m=˜aFVFd˜|snnG:˜zs–}˜=a’4¤’’˜›^a’˜am˜"m˜am›FF’›amV˜"›a4dF9˜ ‰H4phz"maF’˜›Fm=˜›p˜"=pz›˜ ˜z"4›a4F’˜"m=˜hF›^p=’˜am˜’›"VF’˜p˜ "=pz›˜"˜z"›a4¤d"˜hF›^p=˜p˜z"4›a4F˜pmd©˜§^Fm˜"˜4phzdF¨˜’F›˜pO˜O"4›p’˜. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(89) 6XPPDU\,QWURGXFWLRQ. "daVm˜›p˜4F"›F˜F"=amF’’Š˜^Fm˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜mp§˜F¨_ zdpF˜›^F˜"F"’˜pO˜ 

(90) ˜"m=˜¤’"*ada›©:˜h"m©˜pO˜›^Fh˜§add˜¤m=p¤*›F=d©˜O"dd˜ am›p˜›"z’˜"dF"=©˜¦a’a›F=˜*©˜F"daF˜"=pz›F’˜pO˜›^F’F˜"F"’˜¤4^˜"˜›"z˜a’˜ ›^F˜¦F©˜›F"’amV˜"››Fhz›˜›p˜b¤’›˜Op4¤’˜pm˜›^F˜¤’F˜am›FO"4F˜pO˜›^F˜’©’›Fh˜ am’›F"=˜pO˜›"camV˜›^F˜§^pdF˜’zF4›¤h˜pO˜¤’"*ada›©˜am›p˜"44p¤m›˜mp›^F˜ 4phhpm˜"zzp"4^˜a’˜›p˜4pm›am¤F˜›p˜Op4¤’˜pm:˜FV˜›F4^mpdpV©˜"m=˜mp›˜ F"da’F˜›^F˜mFF=˜Op˜ ˜’"*ada›©˜§add˜"d§"©’˜*F˜’¤OOFamV˜aO˜›^F˜=F¦Fdpz_ hFm›˜a’˜›F4^mpdpV©_4Fm›F=˜d"m˜ppzF˜=F’4a*F’˜›^a’˜§a›^˜"˜dp›˜pO˜am_ ’aV^›˜"m=˜^¤hp¤˜am˜^a’˜*ppc9˜^F˜amh"›F’˜"F˜¤mmamV˜›^F˜"’©d¤h˜|pp_ zF:˜snnn}˜^F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜h¤’›˜*F˜Op4¤’’F=˜pm˜§^"›˜a’˜hp’›˜"44¤"›F˜ "m=˜¤’"*dF˜Op˜›^F˜¤’F˜"m=˜mp›˜b¤’›˜§^"›˜a’˜›F4^ma4"dd©˜zp’’a*dF˜›p˜=F_ ¦Fdpz9˜‰pV"hhF’˜›"=F˜’ahzda4a›©˜Op˜4pm›pd˜^F©˜F¨4^"mVF˜’¤44F’’˜ Op˜¤m=F’›"m=amV˜^F©˜Op4¤’˜pm˜§^"›˜a’˜zp’’a*dF˜›p˜›^F˜F¨4d¤’apm˜pO˜ §^"›˜a’˜zp*"*dFŠ˜|ppzF:˜snnn:˜z˜n}˜ ^FF˜"F˜"˜dp›˜pO˜p›^F˜›"z’˜›p˜O"dd˜am›p:˜h"m©˜pO˜›^Fh˜Fd"›F=˜›p˜›^F˜ O"4›˜›^"›˜ 

(91) :˜ ˜"m=˜’phF›ahF’˜F¦Fm˜¤’"*ada›©˜"F˜"F"’˜›^"›˜’›add˜"F˜ Fd"›a¦Fd©˜¤mcmp§m˜›p˜›^F˜am=¤’›©:˜"m=˜mp›˜O¤dd©˜¤m=F’›pp=˜mF˜F"’pm˜ Op˜›^a’˜a’˜›^"›˜ 

(92) ˜›"=a›apm"dd©˜a’˜"˜"›^F˜"4"=Fha4˜OaFd=:˜"=pz›F=˜hp’›d©˜ *©˜"›^F˜d"VF˜am_^p¤’F˜pV"ma’"›apm’:˜"m=˜Op4¤’’F=˜pm˜F’F"4^˜¤›:˜"’˜ ¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜mp§˜"F˜am4F"’amVd©˜"44Fz›F=˜"’˜"˜4phzF›a›a¦F˜"=¦"m›"VF:˜ ›^F˜am=¤’›©˜§add˜F¨zdpF˜ 

(93) :˜ ˜"m=˜¤’"*ada›©˜"m=˜h"cF˜›^F˜4phh¤ma›©˜ pO˜ 

(94) ˜"4›˜am˜"˜hpF˜z"Vh"›a4˜"m=˜^¤h*dF˜§"©˜©˜›^F˜ 

(95) ˜4phh¤ma›©˜

(96) ˜ hF"m˜"dd˜pO˜¤’˜§^p˜"F˜F’F"4^F’˜p˜zpOF’’apm"d˜ 

(97) ˜z"4›a›apmF’˜ ^FF˜a’˜’›add˜"˜dpmV˜§"©˜›p˜Vp˜*FOpF˜ 

(98) ˜ cmp§dF=VF”˜›^F˜4pm4Fz›˜pO˜  ˜"m=˜›^F˜"4›a¦a›aF’˜Fm’¤amV˜¤’"*ada›©˜"F˜O¤dd©˜am›FV"›F=˜am˜›^F˜am=¤’_. ›©Œ’˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’F’˜

(99) m˜›^F˜hF"m›ahF˜

(100) ˜"m=˜h©˜OFddp§˜F’F"4^F’˜ "m=˜=F¦FdpzF’˜›©˜"’˜^"=˜"’˜§F˜4"m˜›p˜h"cF˜›^a’˜^"zzFm˜ ©˜§pc:˜"’˜=F’4a*F=˜am˜›^a’˜›^F’a’:˜a’˜=F=a4"›F=˜›p˜›^F˜›"’c˜pO˜zp¦a=_ amV˜cmp§dF=VF˜"m=˜F¨zFaFm4F’˜pm˜^p§˜›p˜=F¦Fdpz˜¤’"*dF˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’_ ›Fh’˜am˜z"4›a4F˜

(101) ›˜a’˜h©˜F¨zFaFm4F˜"m=˜*FdaFO˜›^"›˜›p˜"4^aF¦F˜¤’"*dF˜am_ ›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’:˜©p¤˜^"¦F˜›p˜"zzd©˜ 

(102) ˜cmp§dF=VF˜"m=˜¤’F˜"˜¤’F_ 4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜zp4F’’˜p˜*F˜4dF"˜"*p¤›˜§^"›˜

(103) ˜hF"m˜*©˜"m˜am›F"4›a¦F˜ ’©’›Fh:˜

(104) ˜¤’F˜›^F˜=FOama›apm˜pO˜›^a’˜›Fh˜"’˜=FOamF=˜am˜›^F˜am›Fm"›apm"d˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(105) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. ’›"m="=˜

(106)  1˜sT¬•˜ ¤h"m_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜zp4F’’F’˜Op˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’_ ›Fh’˜|snnn}˜m˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh˜a’˜"9˜‰4ph*am"›apm˜pO˜^"=§"F˜"m=˜ ’pO›§"F˜4phzpmFm›’˜›^"›˜F4Fa¦F˜amz¤›˜Oph˜"m=˜4phh¤ma4"›F˜p¤›z¤›˜›p˜ "˜^¤h"m˜¤’F˜am˜p=F˜›p˜’¤zzp›˜^a’˜p˜^F˜zFOph"m4F˜pO˜"˜›"’c˜˜ ^F˜›Fh˜‹’©’›FhŒ˜a’˜pO›Fm˜¤’F=˜"›^F˜›^"m˜‹am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›FhŒŠ˜

(107) ˜§add˜¤’F˜ ›^F˜›FhampdpV©˜’©’›Fh˜"m=˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh˜am›F4^"mVF"*d©˜›^p¤V^p¤›˜ ›^F˜’¤hh"©˜pO˜›^a’˜›^F’a’˜

(108) ˜"zzd©˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜§pc˜am˜›^F˜*p"=˜4pm›F¨›˜pO˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦Fdpz_ hFm›:˜"m=˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜4"m˜*F˜’FFm˜"’˜"m˜"zzp"4^˜›p˜am›F"4›a¦F˜ ’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜›^"›˜Op4¤’F’˜’zF4aOa4"dd©˜pm˜h"camV˜’©’›Fh’˜¤’"*dF˜ d›^p¤V^˜h¤4^˜pO˜h©˜§pc˜4"m˜*F˜"zzdaF=˜›p˜zp=¤4›’˜’¤4^˜"’˜4pm’¤hF˜ FdF4›pma4’˜p˜"zzda"m4F’:˜h©˜Op4¤’˜a’˜pm˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’˜¤’F=˜›^p¤V^˜ "˜4phz¤›F˜*©˜zpOF’’apm"d’˜"’˜"˜›ppd˜am˜›^Fa˜="ad©˜§pc˜

(109) m˜›^a’˜’¤hh"©˜

(110) ˜§add˜=F’4a*F˜"m=˜=a’4¤’’˜›^F˜"F"’˜pO9˜ 

(111) :˜¤’"*ada›©˜ "m=˜ ˜ ¤›^F˜pm:˜

(112) ˜§add˜am›p=¤4F˜"˜O"hF§pc˜Op˜z¤››amV˜¤’"*ada›©˜ "m=˜ ˜am˜z"4›a4F˜›^"›˜

(113) ˜4"dd˜’"*ada›©˜F’aVm˜^a’˜O"hF§pc˜*¤ad=’˜ pm˜F’¤d›’˜"m=˜F¨zFaFm4F’˜Oph˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜z"4›a4F˜.  5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV J˜4›apm˜F’F"4^˜4ph*amF’˜›^Fp©˜"m=˜z"4›a4F˜|"m=˜F’F"4^_ F’˜"m=˜z"4›a›apmF’}˜›^p¤V^˜4^"mVF˜"m=˜FOdF4›apm˜am˜"m˜ah_ hF=a"›F˜zp*dFh"›a4˜’a›¤"›apm˜§a›^am˜"˜h¤›¤"dd©˜"44Fz›"*dF˜ O"hF§pc˜4›apm˜F’F"4^˜a’˜"m˜a›F"›a¦F˜zp4F’’˜am¦pd¦amV˜F_ ’F"4^F’˜"m=˜z"4›a›apmF’˜"4›amV˜›pVF›^F˜pm˜"˜z"›a4¤d"˜4©4dF˜ pO˜"4›a¦a›aF’:˜am4d¤=amV˜zp*dFh˜=a"Vmp’a’:˜"4›apm˜am›F¦Fm›apm:˜ "m=˜FOdF4›a¦F˜dF"mamV˜ $YLVRQ/DX0\HUVDQG1LHOVHQ´$FWLRQ5HVHDUFKµLQ&RPPXQL FDWLRQVRIWKH$&0 -DQXDU\9RO1RS. ˜dp›˜pO˜¤’F’˜=pamV˜zpOF’’apm"d˜§pc˜"m=˜¤’amV˜am›F"4›a¦F˜’©’›Fh’˜"’˜ ›ppd’˜p˜"a=˜^"¦F˜Oph˜›ahF˜›p˜›ahF˜=aOOa4¤d›aF’˜am˜¤’amV˜›^F’F˜›ppd’:˜am˜pmF˜ ˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜ 1. ,62 LVWKHODEHOXVHGIRUVWDQGDUGVFRPLQJIURPWKH,QWHUQDWLRQDO2UJDQL]DWLRQIRU 6WDQGDUGL]DWLRQ. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(114) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. §"©˜p˜"mp›^F˜^a’˜4"m˜*F˜Fd"›F=˜›p˜"˜m¤h*F˜pO˜F"’pm’:˜h"m©˜pO˜›^Fh˜ p*¦ap¤’d©˜damcF=˜›p˜zpp˜¤’"*ada›©˜pO˜›^F˜’©’›Fh’˜^a’˜^"’˜*FFm˜Fzp›F=˜ am˜m¤hFp¤’˜Fzp›’:˜*ppc’˜F›4˜p¦F˜›^F˜d"’›˜=F4"=F˜|F¨›Fm’a¦Fd©˜Fzp›F=˜ *©:˜FV9˜ "cp*˜aFd’Fm˜pm˜^a’˜§F*˜’a›F˜^››z9——§§§¤’Fa›4ph—˜"m=˜am˜^a’˜ *ppc’:˜FV˜‰’"*ada›©˜mVamFFamVŠ˜|snn"}˜"m=˜d"›Fd©˜‰F’aVmamV˜F*˜ ’"*ada›©Š˜|¢¬¬¬}”˜d"m˜ppzF˜am˜‰^F˜amh"›F’˜"F˜¤mmamV˜›^F˜"’©d¤hŠ˜ |snnn}:˜F›4}˜¦Fm˜aO˜›^FF˜a’˜mp˜›p›"d˜OaV¤F˜"¦"ad"*dF˜’›"›amV˜›^F˜p¦F"dd˜ ¤’"*ada›©˜pO˜"dd˜’©’›Fh’˜›^p¤V^p¤›˜›^F˜§pd=:˜§F˜4"m˜F"=˜"*p¤›˜a›˜am˜ 

(115) ˜ da›F"›¤F:˜am˜z"zF’:˜da’›Fm˜›p˜a›˜"›˜4pmOFFm4F’:˜^F"˜am=a’z¤›"*dF˜V¤¤’˜ ›"dc˜4pm›Fhz›¤p¤’d©˜"*p¤›˜a›:˜^F"˜¤’F’˜›"dc˜"*p¤›˜a›˜§a›^˜O"›aV¤F:˜F¨zFa_ Fm4F˜a›˜p¤’Fd¦F’:˜F›4:˜"m=˜›p="©˜F¦Fm˜’FF˜a›˜pm˜›^F˜ ˜mF§’˜¦Fm˜O¤›^F:˜ h"©*F˜›^F˜§p’›˜›^amV˜a’˜"dd˜›^p’F˜’©’›Fh’˜›^"›˜§F˜=p˜mp›˜^F"˜"*p¤›:˜¤’F=˜ §a›^am˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜§^FF˜›^F˜¤’F’˜=p˜mp›˜^"¦F˜"˜4^pa4F˜

(116) m˜h"m©˜’a›¤"›apm’˜zFpzdF˜"F˜Op4F=˜›p˜¤’F˜4F›"am˜’©’›Fh’˜"’˜"˜z"›˜pO˜ ›^Fa˜="ad©˜§pc:˜mp˜h"››F˜^p§˜zpp˜›^F˜¤’"*ada›©˜a’˜ FF˜a’˜b¤’›˜pmF˜ ’h"dd˜F¨"hzdF˜pO˜¤’"*ada›©_Fd"›F=˜zp*dFh’˜Oph˜‰F"d˜daOFŠ˜

(117) m˜"˜F4Fm›˜ "›a4dF˜am˜"˜§F=a’^˜hF=a4"d˜bp¤m"d:˜z^©’a4a"m’˜4phzd"amF=˜"*p¤›˜›^F˜ 4phz¤›Fa’F=˜hF=a4"d˜F4p=˜mF˜z^©’a4a"m˜4d"ahF=˜›^"›˜"˜=a’"=¦"m›"VF˜ §a›^˜›^F˜4phz¤›Fa’F=˜hF=a4"d˜F4p=˜a’˜›^"›˜a›˜=pF’˜mp›˜Va¦F˜"˜’¤OOa4aFm›˜ p¦F¦aF§˜pO˜amOph"›apm˜ F˜§"’˜Op4F=˜›p˜Vp˜›p˜=aOOFFm›˜z"›’˜pO˜›^F˜’©’_ ›Fh˜›p˜VF›˜Fmp¤V^˜amOph"›apm˜›p˜h"cF˜"˜=F4a’apm˜¦Fm˜§p’F˜a’˜›^F˜O"4›˜ ›^"›˜›^F˜zpp˜p¦F¦aF§˜h"=F˜^ah˜dF’’˜4pmOa=Fm›˜am˜›^F˜=F4a’apm_h"camV˜ F˜F’›ah"›F=˜›^"›˜›^F˜¤’F˜pO˜›^F˜4phz¤›Fa’F=˜hF=a4"d˜F4p=˜zpdpmVF=˜ ^a’˜§pcamV˜="©˜*©˜pmF˜^p¤˜|"VFm’˜F=a4am:˜¬T—¬s}˜^a’˜cam=’˜pO˜¤’_ "*ada›©˜zp*dFh’˜"F˜*©˜mp˜hF"m’˜mF§˜¤˜=Fz"›hFm›˜"›˜zz’"d"˜ma_ ¦F’a›©˜^"’˜Op˜=F4"=F’˜|F¨"hzdF˜a’9˜dd"=:˜am=:˜"m=*d"=˜"m=˜4^mFa=F:˜ snGT}˜=pmF˜F’F"4^˜pm˜›^F˜›pza4˜pO˜h"camV˜›^F˜4phz¤›Fa’F=˜hF=a4"d˜F_ 4p=˜"’˜¤’"*dF˜"’˜zp’’a*dF:˜*¤›˜’›add˜’©’›Fh’˜"’˜›^F˜pmF˜hFm›apmF=˜"F˜=F_ ¦FdpzF=˜

(118) ˜^"¦F˜"’cF=˜h©’FdO˜›^F˜„¤F’›apmI^p§˜4"m˜

(119) ˜"’˜"˜F’F"4^F˜"m=˜z"4›a_ ›apmF˜ahzp¦F˜›^a’˜’a›¤"›apm˜"m=˜’¤zzd©˜›^F˜¤’F’˜§a›^˜’©’›Fh’˜›^"›˜"F˜ ¤’"*dF ˜©˜hp=F’›˜"m’§F˜›p˜›^a’˜„¤F’›apm˜a’˜›^"›˜

(120) ˜^"¦F˜›p˜*F˜zF’Fm›˜am˜ ›^F˜’a›¤"›apm’˜§^FF˜’©’›Fh’˜"F˜=F’aVmF=˜"m=˜*¤ad›˜m=˜§^Fm˜

(121) ˜"h˜am˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(122) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. ›^"›˜zp’a›apm:˜amOd¤Fm4F˜"m=˜V¤a=F˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"m=˜›^F˜ am=a¦a=¤"d˜zpbF4›’˜›p˜*F˜hpF˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜

(123) ˜4"m˜=p˜›^a’˜*©˜am›p=¤4amV˜ hF›^p=’:˜zp4F’’F’˜"m=˜z"4›a4F’:˜"m=˜^"¦F˜"˜=a"dpV¤F˜"*p¤›˜¤’"*ada›©:˜’p˜ ›^"›˜"dd˜z"›a4az"m›’˜"F˜"§"F˜pO˜›^F˜ahzp›"m4F˜pO˜›"camV˜¤’"*ada›©˜’Fa_ p¤’d©˜ ¤›^F˜pm:˜"’˜"˜F’F"4^F˜

(124) ˜4"m˜FOdF4›˜am˜z"4›a4F˜"m=˜4phh¤ma_ 4"›F˜h©˜F’¤d›’˜›p˜p›^F’˜Op˜O¤›^F˜¤›ada’"›apm:˜"m=˜^pzFO¤dd©˜h"cF˜’phF˜ 4^"mVF˜am˜›^F˜am=¤’›©˜›^"›˜a’˜*FmFOa4a"d˜Op˜›^F˜¤’F’˜

(125) m˜h©˜F’F"4^˜›^F˜z"4›a4"d˜"zzda4"*ada›©˜a’˜¦F©˜ahzp›"m›:˜

(126) ˜§p¤d=˜ ›^FFOpF˜dacF˜›p˜4d"aO©˜h©˜¦aF§˜pm˜›^F˜=FOama›apm˜pO˜z"4›a4F9˜‰"4›a4F˜˜ ›F4^ma4"d˜p˜h"m"VFhFm›˜"4›a¦a›©˜›^"›˜4pm›a*¤›F’˜›p˜›^F˜4F"›apm˜pO˜›^F˜ p¤›z¤›˜|§pc˜zp=¤4›’}˜pO˜"˜zp4F’’˜p˜Fm^"m4F’˜›^F˜4"z"*ada›©˜pO˜"˜zp4_ F’’Š˜|

(127)  —  ˜sGQ¢n9¢¬¬¬|}}˜"4›a4F˜a’˜p*¦ap¤’d©˜4pmmF4›F=˜›p˜’phF˜’p›˜ pO˜"4›a¦a›©˜4"aF=˜p¤›:˜zFOF"*d©˜*©˜"˜’caddF=˜z"4›a›apmF2˜^a’˜Fd"›apm˜a’˜ ahzp›"m›˜’am4F˜a›˜a’˜h©˜*FdaFO˜›^"›˜›^F˜pdF˜pO˜›^F˜z"4›a›apmF˜a’˜pO˜¦a›"d˜ ahzp›"m4F˜Op˜*p›^˜›^F˜p¤›4phF˜"m=˜›^F˜zFOph"m4F˜pO˜"˜zp4F’’˜.  5HVHDUFKVFRSHDQGP\DLPV ’˜h©˜h"am˜"ah˜"m=˜F’F"4^˜zp*dFh˜a’˜§a=F_"mVamV˜"m=˜cam=˜pO˜zF›Fm_ ›ap¤’I^p§˜›p˜=F¦Fdpz˜¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜am˜z"4›a4F:˜

(128) ˜F"da’F˜›^"›˜

(129) ˜^"¦F˜ O"4F=˜"˜Opha="*dF˜›"’c˜^a’˜a’:˜pO˜4p¤’F:˜hpF˜pO˜"˜¦a’apm˜"m=˜4"m˜ zp*"*d©˜"4›˜"’˜h©˜h"am˜F’F"4^˜p*bF4›a¦F:˜*¤›˜^"’˜›p˜*F˜hpF˜=F›"adF=˜›p˜ *F˜F"dd©˜¤’FO¤d˜p:˜§^"›˜

(130) ˜=p˜a’˜›p˜Op4¤’˜pm˜›^F˜zp*dFh’˜"m=˜"F"’˜›^"›˜

(131) ˜ ^"¦F˜Op¤m=˜hp’›˜¤VFm›:˜*"’F=˜pm˜h©˜"m=˜p›^F’Œ˜F¨zFaFm4F’˜Oph˜’F¦_ F"d˜pV"ma’"›apm’:˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜zpbF4›’˜ ˜4Fm›"d:˜hpmpda›^a4˜zp*dFh˜|"’˜O"˜"’˜¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜"F˜4pm4FmF=}˜ a’˜›p˜FOOa4aFm›d©˜am›FV"›F˜¤’"*ada›©˜"’zF4›’˜"m=˜"˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜zF’zF4›a¦F˜ am›p˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’F’˜. ˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜ 2. 3UDFWLWLRQHULV´2QHSHUVRQZKRSUDFWLFHVDQDUWRUSURIHVVLRQµ:HEVWHU·VVWXGHQW GLFWLRQDU\. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(132) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. ^a’˜zp*dFh˜4"m˜*F˜*pcFm˜=p§m˜am›p˜"˜’F›˜pO˜am›FF’›amV˜F’F"4^˜ ›pza4’˜"m=˜"F"’˜›^"›˜

(133) ˜¤’F˜"’˜V¤a="m4F˜am˜h©˜F’F"4^9˜ ™"cF˜4phz"maF’˜"m=˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"§"F˜pO˜›^F˜ahzp›"m4F˜pO˜ =F¦FdpzamV˜¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜ ™¤›˜¤’"*ada›©˜pm˜›^F˜am=¤’›aF’Œ˜"VFm="˜’"*ada›©˜a’˜’›add˜›^F˜¤m_ =F=pV˜am˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zpbF4›’˜"m=˜am˜*¤’amF’’˜’›"›FVaF’˜˜ ™ am=˜p¤›˜|=F¦Fdpz}˜‰F"’©˜›p˜¤’FŠ˜›F4^ma„¤F’9˜hF›^p=’:˜"4›a¦a›aF’:˜ zp4F’’F’:˜zpbF4›˜pdF’:˜F›4˜"m©˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜^"¦F˜zp*dFh’˜ am˜"zzd©amV˜F¨a’›amV˜hF›^p=’˜"m=˜zp4F’’F’˜d›^p¤V^˜zFpzdF˜am˜ pV"ma’"›apm’˜^"¦F˜^F"=˜"*p¤›˜¤’"*ada›©:˜›^F©˜=p˜mp›˜cmp§˜^p§˜ ›p˜"4^aF¦F˜a›˜ ™

(134) m˜›^F˜dpmV˜¤m˜h"cF˜›^F˜am=¤’›©˜F"da’F˜›^F˜zp›Fm›a"d˜am˜"=pz›_ amV˜"˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜"zzp"4^˜›"›amV˜§a›^˜‰¤’"*ada›©˜am˜ F¦F©˜zpbF4›Š˜ ™FF˜^p§˜›^FF˜4"m˜*F˜hpF˜¤’"*ada›©˜’caddF=˜=F¦FdpzF’˜"m=˜z"4_ ›a›apmF’˜am˜›^F˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜am=¤’›©˜^FF˜"F˜›pp˜OF§˜ ›p="©˜

(135) ˜›^amc˜›^a’˜a’˜"˜dpVa4"d˜4pm4d¤’apm˜›p˜›^F˜O"4›˜›^"›˜’p˜h"m©˜ ’©’›Fh’˜^"¦F˜"˜„¤F’›apm"*dF˜¤’"*ada›©˜ ^F˜m"›¤F˜pO˜›^F’F˜›pza4’˜a’˜›^"›˜›^F©˜"F˜"›^F˜*aV˜a’’¤F’:˜cam=˜pO˜ah_ zF4a’F˜"m=˜h"©*F˜mp›˜=F›"adF=˜Fmp¤V^˜ p§F¦F:˜›^F©˜am=a4"›F˜›^F˜ *F"=›^˜pO˜h©˜F’F"4^˜

(136) ˜"h˜=Fda*F"›Fd©˜Op4¤’’F=˜pm˜›^F˜*F"=›^˜’am4F˜

(137) ˜ *FdaF¦F˜›^"›˜›^a’˜a’˜›^F˜cF©˜›p˜›^F˜„¤F’›apm9˜^p§˜›p˜=F¦Fdpz˜¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜ am˜z"4›a4F˜

(138) ˜^"¦F˜›p˜h"cF˜"˜Fh"c˜"*p¤›˜h©˜’›"m=zpam›˜pm˜h"camV˜¤’"*dF˜’©’_ ›Fh’˜"˜F"da›©˜

(139) ˜4pmOpm›˜›^F˜zp*dFh˜Oph˜"˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zF’zF4_ ›a¦F˜^a’˜a’:˜pO˜4p¤’F:˜mp›˜›^F˜pmd©˜§"©˜›p˜=F"d˜§a›^˜›^F˜zp*dFh˜¤›˜a›˜a’˜ h©˜m"›¤"d˜zp’a›apm˜"’˜"˜4phz¤›F˜’4aFm4F˜V"=¤"›F˜"m=˜"d’p˜pmF˜pO˜›^F˜ h"am˜zF’zF4›a¦F’˜§a›^am˜ 

(140) ˜›^F˜F’F"4^F’˜O"4F˜›^F˜zp*dFh˜Oph˜ ›^Fa˜zpam›˜pO˜¦aF§˜mF˜F¨"hzdF˜a’˜›p˜F=¤4"›F˜p˜amOph˜›^F˜z¤4^"’F˜›p˜ *F˜hpF˜"§"F˜pO˜^p§˜›p˜p=F˜p˜z¤4^"’F˜¤’"*dF˜’©’›Fh’˜^a’˜a’˜"m˜am_ ›FF’›amV˜zF’zF4›a¦F:˜*¤›˜mp›˜am˜h©˜zah"©˜F’F"4^˜Op4¤’˜©˜cF©˜›"VF›˜. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(141) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. Vp¤z˜a’˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜pV"ma’"›apm˜ p§F¦F:˜

(142) ˜*FdaF¦F˜›^"›˜h¤4^˜pO˜ h©˜§pc˜4"m˜*F˜pO˜*FmFOa›˜›p˜p›^F˜’›"cF^pd=F’:˜’¤4^˜"’˜zFpzdF˜§pcamV˜ §a›^˜F„¤aFhFm›’˜ 5(6($5&+&217(;7˜

(143) ˜§pc˜z"›˜›ahF˜"’˜"˜=F¦FdpzF—4pm’¤d›"m›˜"›˜. mF"˜F=am"˜"m=˜z"›˜›ahF˜"’˜"˜F’F"4^F˜"›˜zz’"d"˜ma¦F’a›©˜^a’˜ 4pm=a›apm˜a’˜pO˜¦a›"d˜ahzp›"m4F˜Op˜›^F˜¤m=F’›"m=amV˜pO˜h©˜§pc˜"m=˜h©˜ F’F"4^˜"zzp"4^˜

(144) ˜^"¦F˜4^p’Fm˜›p˜Vp˜*p›^˜›^F’F˜§"©’˜am˜›^F˜›p›"d˜4pmOa_ =Fm4F˜›^"›˜›^F©˜*FmFOa›˜Oph˜F"4^˜p›^F:˜"m=˜›^"›:˜*©˜^"¦amV˜›^a’˜"z_ zp"4^:˜

(145) ˜4"m˜h"cF˜›^F˜hp’›˜ahz"4›˜˜

(146) ˜^"¦F˜*FFm˜am¦pd¦F=˜am˜zpbF4›’˜§^FF˜

(147) ˜^"¦F˜^"=˜›^F˜zp’’a*ada›©˜›p˜ 4"©˜p¤›˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜z"4›a4F˜"›:˜FV:˜ ›^F˜Opddp§amV˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"m=˜4phz"maF’˜ p¦F˜›^F˜d"’›˜4p¤zdF˜pO˜©F"’9˜^F˜§F=a’^˜ "›apm"d˜"¨˜p"=˜| }:˜^F˜§F=a’^˜"_ ›apm"d˜p4a"d˜

(148) m’¤"m4F˜p"=˜|  }:˜§F=a’^˜ F=a4"d˜p=¤4›’˜VFm4©˜|ÆcFhF=Fd’¦FcF›}:˜^"h"˜pam›:˜OOƏ’"›":˜ "VFm’˜©^F›F:˜hF’^"h˜^"h"4a"˜ap›F4^:˜Fda"˜"m=˜ Fh"m˜"m_ 4F˜F’F"4^˜Fm›F˜| ! }˜^F©˜"dd˜FzF’Fm›˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜§a›^˜„¤a›F˜ =aOOFFm›˜4^""4›Fa’›a4’˜^F©˜=F¦Fdpz˜’©’›Fh’˜am˜=aOOFFm›˜4pm›F¨›’˜phF˜ ^"¦F˜am_^p¤’F˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜Op˜’©’›Fh’˜=F¦FdpzhFm›:˜p›^F’˜"F˜zp=¤4›˜ 4phz"maF’˜"m=˜’phF˜*¤©˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜F’p¤4F’˜pm˜"˜4pm›"4›˜*"’a’˜^F©˜ ^"¦F˜"dd˜"==F=˜¦"d¤F’˜›p˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜4pm›a*¤›F=˜›p˜›^F˜*F"=›^˜.  5HVHDUFKPHWKRGVDQGZRUNSUDFWLFH 4›apm˜F’F"4^˜"’˜"˜F’F"4^˜hF›^p=˜h"cF’˜a›˜zp’’a*dF˜Op˜›^F˜F’F"4^F˜ ›p˜"zzd©˜^a’—^F˜›^FpaF’˜am˜z"4›a4F:˜am˜"˜F"da’›a4˜§pc˜’a›¤"›apm:˜›"cF˜"4_ ›apm˜"m=˜h"cF˜"˜4^"mVF˜am˜›^"›˜’a›¤"›apm˜4›apm˜F’F"4^˜a’˜mp›˜dacF˜4pm_ ›pddF=˜F¨zFahFm›"d˜F’F"4^˜§a›^˜Oa¨F=˜z""hF›F’˜am˜"˜d"*p"›p©˜’F›_. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(149) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. ›amV˜

(150) m’›F"=:˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜zpbF4›’˜"F˜4pm=¤4›F=˜am˜F"d˜daOF˜zpbF4›’˜"›˜ ›^F˜z"4›a›apmFŒ’˜§pc˜zd"4F3˜ ©˜F’F"4^˜"zzp"4^˜O"dd’˜am›p˜›^F˜4"›FVp©˜pO˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜4›apm˜ F’F"4^˜a’˜"˜hF›^p=pdpV©˜›^"›˜^"’˜›^F˜=¤"d˜"ah’˜pO˜"4›apm˜"m=˜F’F"4^˜ |a4c:˜snn}9˜ ™4›apm˜›p˜*amV˜"*p¤›˜4^"mVF˜am˜’phF˜4phh¤ma›©˜p˜pV"ma’"_ ›apm˜p˜zpV"h˜ ™F’F"4^˜›p˜am4F"’F˜¤m=F’›"m=amV˜pm˜›^F˜z"›˜pO˜›^F˜F’F"4^F˜ p˜›^F˜4daFm›:˜p˜*p›^˜|"m=˜pO›Fm˜’phF˜§a=F˜4phh¤ma›©}˜ ^F˜ha¨˜pO˜"4›apm˜"m=˜F’F"4^˜4"m˜*F˜›¤mF=˜›p˜›^F˜dF¦Fd˜›^"›˜a’˜"44¤_ "›F˜Op˜›^F˜F’F"4^FŒ’˜"ah’˜mF˜ahzp›"m›˜"’zF4›˜a’˜›^"›˜›^F˜F’F"4^F˜ ›"cF’˜z"›˜am˜›^F˜’›¤=aF=˜’a›¤"›apm:˜Op˜am’›"m4F˜"˜zpbF4›:˜mp›˜b¤’›˜"’˜"m˜ p*’F¦F˜*¤›˜"d’p˜"’˜"˜O¤dd©˜z"›a4az"›amV˜zpbF4›˜hFh*F˜

(151) m˜›^F˜"›a4dF˜^F˜ a’›p©˜pO˜4›apm˜F’F"4^:˜ "mF›˜"’›F’˜|snnQ}˜=F_ ’4a*F’˜›^F˜O¤m="hFm›"d’˜pO˜›^a’˜F’F"4^˜’4^ppd˜^F˜’¤hh"a’F’˜›^F˜^a’_ ›p©˜"m=˜*"4cVp¤m=˜pO˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜am›p˜Op¤˜*"’a4’˜›^FhF’9˜Fhzp§_ FhFm›˜pO˜z"›a4az"m›’”˜4pdd"*p"›apm˜›^p¤V^˜z"›a4az"›apm”˜"4„¤a’a›apm˜pO˜ cmp§dF=VF”˜"m=˜’p4a"d˜4^"mVF˜

(152) ˜›©˜›p˜"zzd©˜›^F˜F’’Fm4F˜pO˜›^F’F˜›^FhF’˜am˜ h©˜F’F"4^˜^F˜Fhzp§FamV˜pO˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzF’˜"m=˜›^F˜¤’F’˜am˜=F¦Fdpz_ hFm›˜zpbF4›’˜a’˜F¨›FhFd©˜ahzp›"m›:˜"’˜§Fdd˜"’˜O¤dd˜z"›a4az"›apm˜pm˜F„¤"d˜ ›Fh’˜pO˜"dd˜am¦pd¦F=˜am˜p¤˜zpbF4›˜›F"h’˜^a’˜a’˜mp›˜"m˜F"’©˜›"’c˜’am4F˜ F’p¤4F’:˜›ahF:˜F›4˜¤’¤"dd©˜"F˜¦F©˜daha›F=˜p˜O¤dd©˜¤m=F’›"m=˜"m=˜›"cF˜ pm˜"˜¤’F_4Fm›F=˜=F’aVm˜¦aF§˜a’˜¤’¤"dd©:˜"hpmV˜p›^F˜›^amV’:˜"˜h"bp˜"››a_ ›¤=am"d˜"m=˜’p4a"d˜4^"mVF˜Op˜"˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜pV"ma’"›apm˜^a’˜a’˜mp›˜"˜ 4^"mVF˜p˜F¦pd¤›apm˜›^"›˜^"zzFm’˜O"’›˜p˜F"’ad©:˜pm˜›^F˜4pm›"©˜a›˜a’˜"m˜ F¦pd¤›apm"©˜zp4F’’˜›^"›˜›"cF’˜©F"’˜^F˜"4„¤a’a›apm˜pO˜cmp§dF=VF˜a’˜ ˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜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|UDQVVRQ.

(153) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. z"›˜pO˜›^F˜dF"mamV˜zp4F’’˜›^"›˜›"cF’˜zd"4F˜§a›^am˜F¦F©˜pV"ma’"›apm˜|p˜ "›˜dF"’›˜am˜hp’›˜pO˜›^Fh}˜ p˜F¦F©˜zpbF4›:˜cmp§dF=VF˜a’˜"==F=˜›p˜›^F˜p_ V"ma’"›apmŒ’˜cmp§dF=VF˜*"’F˜

(154) ›˜a’˜›^F˜F’F"4^FŒ’˜F’zpm’a*ada›©˜›p˜FOdF4›˜ ¤zpm:˜"m"d©’F˜"m=˜VFmF"da’F˜›^F˜F’¤d›’˜Oph˜"˜zpbF4›˜"m=˜›p˜z¤›˜a›˜Op_ §"=˜"’˜V"amF=˜cmp§dF=VF˜"m=˜4phh¤ma4"›F˜a›˜›p˜p›^F’˜Op˜O¤›^F˜¤›ada_ ’"›apm˜˜ ^F˜zp4F’’˜›^"›˜›^F˜F’F"4^F˜VpF’˜›^p¤V^˜›p˜"4^aF¦F˜›^F’F˜›^FhF’˜a’˜ "˜’za"d˜pO˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜4©4dF’˜4pm’a’›amV˜pO˜Op¤˜h"bp˜z^"’F’9˜zd"m_ mamV:˜"4›amV:˜p*’F¦amV˜"m=˜FOdF4›amV˜|"’›F’:˜snnQ}˜^F˜OaV¤F˜*Fdp§˜ ›aF’˜›p˜z¤›˜›^a’˜4©4dF˜am›p˜"˜zpbF4›˜4pm›F¨›˜’˜›^F˜F’F"4^F˜VpF’˜ ›^p¤V^˜"dd˜’›Fz’˜am˜›^F˜4©4dF:˜=F¦FdpzF’˜¤’¤"dd©˜4phF˜am˜§^Fm˜›^F˜zpbF4›˜ ’›"›’:˜"m=˜hp¦F˜pm˜§^Fm˜›^F˜zpbF4›˜a’˜Oama’^F=˜^F˜F’F"4^F˜’›"›’˜›^F˜ F’F"4^˜am˜"=¦"m4F˜*©˜zd"mmamV:˜›^Fm˜z"›a4az"›F’˜am˜›^F˜zpbF4›˜"m=˜4pm_ ›am¤F’˜"O›F˜›^F˜zpbF4›˜›p˜FOdF4›˜"m=˜"m"d©’F˜|’FF˜ aV¤F˜s}˜^a’:˜"hpmV˜ p›^F˜›^amV’:˜=a’›amV¤a’^F’˜›^F˜F’F"4^˜Oph˜z¤F˜4pm’¤d›"m›˜p˜=F¦Fdpz_ hFm›˜§pc:˜§^FF"’˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzF˜pmd©˜z"›a4az"›F’˜am˜›^F˜F¨F4¤›apm˜pO˜ ›^F˜zpbF4›˜ 3ODQQLQJSKDVH. $FWLQJDQGREVHUYLQJSKDVH. 5HIOHFWLRQSKDVH. ,QWURGXFHPHWKRGV SURFHVVHV SUDFWLFHVHWF. ([HFXWLQJWKHSURMHFW. $QDO\VHDQG UHIOHFW. 3ODQQLQJ. ([HFXWLQJWKHSURMHFW. (YDOXDWLQJ. )HHGEDFN 7DNHWKHUHVXOWDQGXVHDVLQSXW WRWKHQH[WSURMHFW. )LJXUH$F\FOLFSURFHVVRISODQQLQJDFWLQJREVHUYLQJDQGUHIOHFWLQJ. FOdF4›apm˜a’˜"˜¦F©˜ahzp›"m›˜amVF=aFm›˜am˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜

(155) ›˜a’˜FOdF4_ ›apm˜"’˜"˜=a"dpV¤F˜*F›§FFm˜"˜m¤h*F˜pO˜F’F"4^F_z"›a4az"m›’”˜p˜*F_ ›§FFm˜›§p˜F’F"4^F_z"›a4az"m›’”˜p˜F¦Fm˜am˜a›’˜hp’›˜F¨›FhF˜Oph˜›^F˜ FOdF4›apm’˜pO˜"˜’amVdF˜F’F"4^F_z"›a4az"m›˜4›apm˜F’F"4^˜a’˜Fa›^F˜F_ ’F"4^˜*©˜z"4›a›apmF’:˜p˜"›˜dF"’›˜F’F"4^F’˜4pdd"*p"›amV˜§a›^˜z"4›a_ ›apmF’:˜FmV"VF=˜am˜"˜’©’›Fh"›a4˜"››Fhz›˜›p˜¤m=F’›"m=˜"m=˜4^"mVF˜z"4_. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH. ˜.

(156) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. ›a4F˜*©˜›^Fa˜p§m˜"4›apm’˜"m=˜FOdF4›apm˜¤zpm˜›^p’F˜"4›apm’IFOdF4›a¦F˜ z"4›a4F˜|F**:˜snnQ}˜ ^F˜m"›¤F˜pO˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜a’˜„¤"da›"›a¦F˜hF"’¤FhFm›˜^a’˜am˜zF_ ’zF4›a¦F˜›p˜›^F˜hpF˜4phhpm˜„¤"m›a›"›a¦F˜hF"’¤FhFm›_*"’F=˜hF›^p=’˜am˜ 

(157) ˜F’F"4^I^"=˜OaV¤F’:˜dacF˜Oph"d˜F¨zFahFm›"d˜F’F"4^˜am˜z’©4^pd_. pV©˜a›^am˜p¤˜zpbF4›’˜§F˜¤’F˜¦"ap¤’˜hF›^p=’˜›p˜4pddF4›˜="›"˜’¤4^˜"’˜ „¤F’›apmm"aF’:˜OaFd=˜’›¤=aF’:˜p*’F¦"›apm’:˜am›F¦aF§’:˜¦a=Fp˜’›¤=aF’:˜F›4˜ ^F˜4phh¤ma4"›a¦F˜p¤›4phF˜pO˜h©˜F’F"4^˜a’˜¤’¤"dd©˜"˜z"zF˜=F’4a*amV˜ "˜4"’F:˜FOdF4›apm’:˜Oam=amV’:˜F›4˜^F©˜"F˜¤’¤"dd©˜=F’4az›a¦F˜"m=˜"ahF=˜›p˜ =F’4a*F˜§^©˜§F˜=a=˜’phF›^amV”˜§^"›˜§F˜=a=”˜^p§˜§F˜=a=˜a›”˜"m=˜›^F˜dF’_ ’pm’˜dF"m›˜ pF˜¤’FO¤d˜amOph"›apm˜pm˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜4"m˜*F˜Op¤m=˜am˜›^F˜pm_damF˜ bp¤m"d˜4›apm˜F’F"4^˜

(158) m›Fm"›apm"d:˜ http://www.scu.edu.au/schools/gcm/ar/ari/arihome.html˜. 3UDFWLWLRQHUFHQWUHGUHVHDUFK "›Fd©˜

(159) ˜^"¦F˜*FFm˜am4F"’amVd©˜4pm4FmF=˜§a›^˜›^F˜„¤F’›apm9˜ p§˜4"m˜§F˜ "a’F˜›^F˜ahz"4›˜pO˜F’F"4^˜am˜zpOF’’apm"d˜z"4›a4F ˜"›’˜pO˜›^a’˜4"m˜*F˜ ›"cFm˜4"F˜pO˜*©˜4pm=¤4›amV˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜"’˜=a’4¤’’F=˜"*p¦F:˜*¤›˜

(160) ˜§"m›˜ ›p˜Vp˜O¤›^F˜ ˜’4^ppd˜4"ddF=˜"4›a›apmF_Fm›F=˜F’F"4^˜| }:˜Fd"›F=˜›p˜"4›apm˜ F’F"4^˜^"’˜d"›Fd©˜am’zaF=˜*p›^˜h©˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜h©’FdO˜

(161) ›˜^"’˜a›’˜*"4c_ Vp¤m=˜am˜›^F˜am’aV^›˜pO˜›^F˜daha›F=˜4pm›a*¤›apm˜pO˜F’F"4^˜›p˜zpOF’_ ’apm"d˜z"4›a4F˜|p¤mF˜%˜Œ "":˜snnn}˜ ˜4phF’˜Oph˜"F"’˜’¤4^˜"’˜ ^aV^F˜F=¤4"›apm:˜z"4›a4F˜pO˜d"§˜"m=˜hF=a4"d˜z"4›a4F˜

(162) ˜4"m˜’FF˜›^"›˜›^FF˜ "F˜’ahad"a›aF’˜am˜›^F˜§"©˜›^"›˜

(163) ˜z"4›a4F˜ 

(164) ˜am˜pV"ma’"›apm’˜"m=˜am˜›^F˜ §"©:˜FV˜"˜dF4›¤F˜›F"4^F’˜"˜4d"’’˜F˜"F˜*p›^˜4pm4FmF=˜"*p¤›˜4phh¤_ ma4"›amV˜cmp§dF=VF˜am˜’¤4^˜"˜§"©˜›^"›˜›^F˜"zzFm›a4F˜4"m˜z¤›˜a›˜am›p˜z"4_ ›a4F˜ ^F˜am›FF’›amV˜›^amV˜"*p¤›˜ ˜a’˜›^F˜ha¨›¤F˜pO˜zpOF’’apm"d˜z"4›a4F˜ "m=˜F’F"4^˜p¤mF˜"m=˜Œ ""˜=a’4¤’’˜›^a’˜›pza4˜am˜›Fh’˜pO˜ ˜dp_ 4"›F=˜§a›^am˜›^F˜=ph"am˜pO˜›^F˜F’F"4^amV˜zpOF’’apm"d˜"›^F˜›^"m˜›^F˜ zpOF’’apm"d˜F’F"4^FIa›˜a’˜pmF˜›^amV˜›p˜’^"F˜mF§˜cmp§dF=VF:˜*¤›˜"m_. 8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH%HQJW*|UDQVVRQ.

(165) 6XPPDU\5HVHDUFKREMHFWLYHV. p›^F˜›^amV˜Fm›aFd©˜›p˜’^"F˜mF§˜z"4›a4F˜^F˜’p›˜pO˜mF§˜cmp§dF=VF˜›^"›˜ z"4›a›apmF’˜mFF=˜aO˜›^F©˜"F˜›p˜"=pz›˜"˜mF§˜z"4›a4F˜a’˜*p›^˜p*bF4›a¦F:˜"m˜ "m’§F˜›p˜›^F˜„¤F’›apm˜‰4"m˜a›˜§pc Š˜"m=˜’¤*bF4›a¦F:˜"m˜"m’§F˜›p˜›^F˜ „¤F’›apm˜‰4"m˜a›˜§pc˜Op˜hF Š˜

(166) ˜§pc˜*p›^˜"’˜"˜z"4›a›apmF˜"m=˜F’F"4^F˜"m=˜^"¦F˜›^F˜pzzp›¤ma›©˜ ›p˜¤’F˜F¨a’›amV˜hF›^p=’:˜"m=˜z"›d©˜=F¦FdpzamV˜mF§˜’©’›Fh˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜ hF›^p=’˜"m=˜zp4F’’F’:˜z¤››amV˜›^Fh˜am›p˜z"4›a4F˜"m=˜¤’amV˜›^Fh˜"’˜"4_ ›a¦a›aF’˜am˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzhFm›˜zp4F’’˜

(167) m˜›^a’˜§"©˜

(168) ˜VF›˜›^F˜4^"m4F˜›p˜’›¤=©:˜ "m"d©’F˜"m=˜FOdF4›˜¤zpm˜›^F˜›¤F˜¦"d¤F˜pO˜›^F˜zpzp’F=˜4p¤’F˜pO˜"4›apm’˜ p˜zp4F=¤F’˜’˜"˜F’¤d›˜pO˜›^F’F˜’›¤=aF’˜

(169) ˜4"m˜O¤›^F˜ahzp¦F˜›^F˜hF›^_ p=’˜"m=˜z"4›a4F’˜›p˜Oph¤d"›F˜mF§˜›^FpaF’˜"m=˜’p˜pm˜^a’˜a’˜"m˜a›F"›a¦F˜ zp4F’’˜›^"›˜^"’˜›^F˜zp›Fm›a"d˜›p˜FmV"VF˜"dd˜z"›aF’˜am¦pd¦F=˜am˜"˜’©’›Fh˜ =F¦FdpzhFm›˜zpbF4›˜^F˜F’¤d›˜pO˜’¤4^˜"˜zpbF4›˜a’˜mp›˜pmd©˜›^F˜=F¦FdpzF=˜ ’©’›Fh:˜*¤›˜"d’p˜cmp§dF=VF˜"m=˜F¨zFaFm4F’˜"*p¤›˜›^F˜zp4F’’˜a›’FdO˜"m=˜ ›^F˜z"4›a4F˜pO˜a›˜ 5HOLDELOLW\DQGYDOLGLW\RIP\UHVHDUFK Fda"*ada›©˜"m=˜¦"da=a›©˜"F˜ahzp›"m›˜"’zF4›’˜pO˜F’F"4^˜am˜p=F˜Op˜›^F˜ F"=F˜›p˜"’’F’’˜›^F˜F’¤d›’˜"m˜§F˜FzF"›˜›^F˜’"hF˜‰F¨zFahFm›Š˜"m=˜VF›˜ ›^F˜’"hF˜F’¤d›’ ˜"m˜§F˜*F˜’¤F˜›^"›˜§F˜"F˜‰hF"’¤amVŠ˜›^F˜aV^›˜›^amV:˜ §a›^p¤›˜’©’›Fh"›a4˜Fp’ ˜©˜"m’§F˜a’˜›^"›˜§F˜4"mmp›˜zp’’a*d©˜¤m˜›§p˜ p˜hpF˜zpbF4›’˜am˜z""ddFd:˜p˜am˜’F„¤Fm4F˜§a›^˜F¨"4›d©˜›^F˜’"hF˜Fm¦a_ pmhFm›:˜4pm›F¨›˜p˜zF’¤hz›apm’˜^a’˜a’˜b¤’›˜mp›˜OF"’a*dF˜"’˜§F˜4pm=¤4›˜ p¤˜F’F"4^˜am˜4daFm›’Œ˜F"d˜zpbF4›’˜F˜^"¦F˜›p˜zd"m:˜›"cF˜"4›apm:˜p*’F¦F˜ "m=˜FOdF4›˜am˜pmF˜zpbF4›:˜›"camV˜am›p˜"44p¤m›˜›^"›˜zpbF4›Œ’˜’zF4aOa4˜4pm_ ›F¨›˜^a’˜§add˜*¤ad=˜¤z˜"˜cmp§dF=VF˜*"’F˜›^"›˜4"m˜*F˜¤›ada’F=˜am˜›^F˜mF¨›˜ zpbF4›:˜F›4˜

(170) m˜›^a’˜’Fm’F:˜§F˜da¦F˜"’˜§F˜dF"m9˜ahzp¦FhFm›˜*©˜a›F"›apm˜ |’FF˜›^F˜4^"z›F˜’F_Fm›F=˜F’aVm}˜

(171) ›˜a’˜^"=˜Op˜hF˜›p˜VFmF"da’F˜›^F˜ F’¤d›’˜Oph˜pmF˜zpbF4›˜"m=˜’"©˜›^"›˜a›˜a’˜›¤F˜Op˜"dd˜p›^F˜zpbF4›’˜

(172) ›˜a’˜am˜ ›^F˜m"›¤F˜pO˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^˜›^"›˜›^F˜F"=F˜pO˜›^F˜F’¤d›’˜h¤’›˜*F"˜am˜ ham=˜›^F˜zF’¤hz›apm’˜Op˜"4›apm˜F’F"4^:˜›^F˜’zF4aOa4˜zpbF4›˜"m=˜h"cF˜ ^F˜p˜^a’˜b¤=VFhFm›˜*"’F=˜pm˜›^"›I4"m˜a›˜§pc˜"m=˜4"m˜a›˜§pc˜Op˜hF ˜. %HQJW*|UDQVVRQ8VDELOLW\'HVLJQ$)UDPHZRUNIRU'HVLJQLQJ8VDEOH,QWHUDFWLYH6\VWHPVLQ3UDFWLFH.

(173) 6XPPDU\+XPDQ&RPSXWHU,QWHUDFWLRQ.  +XPDQ&RPSXWHU,QWHUDFWLRQ J˜ ¤h"m_4phz¤›F˜am›F"4›apm˜a’˜"˜=a’4azdamF˜4pm4FmF=˜§a›^˜ ›^F˜=F’aVm:˜F¦"d¤"›apm˜"m=˜ahzdFhFm›"›apm˜pO˜am›F"4›a¦F˜4ph_ z¤›amV˜’©’›Fh’˜Op˜^¤h"m˜¤’F˜"m=˜§a›^˜›^F˜’›¤=©˜pO˜h"bp˜z^F_ mphFm"˜’¤p¤m=amV˜›^Fh˜ $&06SHFLDO,QWHUHVW*URXSRQ&RPSXWHU+XPDQ,QWHUDFWLRQ 6,* &+,

(174) &XUULFXOXP'HYHORSPHQW*URXSVHFWLRQ. p˜Va¦F˜"˜*"4cVp¤m=˜›p˜›^F˜"F"˜p˜’¤*bF4›˜pO˜ 

(175) ˜

(176) ˜§p¤d=˜dacF˜›p˜›"cF˜ ›^F˜=FOama›apm˜"*p¦F˜"’˜"˜’›"m4F˜^a’˜=FOama›apm˜a’:˜Op˜am’›"m4F:˜¤’F=˜"m=˜ =a’4¤’’F=˜am˜›^F˜›§p˜zF=pham"m›˜4p¤’F˜*ppc’˜am˜ 

(177) ˜4d"’’F’˜am˜§F=Fm9˜ a¨˜F›˜"d˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(178) m›F"4›apm˜|a¨:˜ amd"©:˜*p§=˜%˜F"dF:˜ snnG}˜"m=˜FF4F˜F›˜"d˜ ¤h"m_phz¤›F˜

(179) m›F"4›apm˜|FF4F:˜pVF’:˜ ^"z:˜Fm©pm:˜ pdd"m=˜%˜"F©:˜snnT}˜^F˜F¨zF’’apm˜^¤h"m_ 4phz¤›F˜am›F"4›apm˜§"’˜"=pz›F=˜=¤amV˜›^F˜ha=_snG¬’:˜F4pVma’amV˜ 

(180) ˜ "’˜"˜F’F"4^˜"m=˜’¤*bF4›˜h"››F˜pO˜a›’˜p§m˜ 

(181) ˜^"=˜*©˜›^Fm˜F¦pd¦F=˜Oph˜ ›^F˜hpF˜daha›F=˜"F"’˜pO˜¤’F˜am›FO"4F˜"m=˜h"m_h"4^amF˜am›FO"4F:˜4ph_ hpmd©˜¤’F=˜=¤amV˜›^F˜sn•¬’˜©˜am›p=¤4amV˜›^F˜F¨zF’’apm˜ 

(182) :˜›^F˜"F"˜ §"’˜"44Fz›F=˜"’˜*FamV˜*p"=F˜›^"m˜b¤’›˜›^F˜=F’aVm˜pO˜›^F˜am›FO"4F˜"m=˜ §"’˜F4pVma’F=˜›p˜*F˜4pm4FmF=˜§a›^˜"dd˜›^p’F˜"’zF4›’˜›^"›˜Fd"›F˜›p˜›^F˜am_ ›F"4›apm˜*F›§FFm˜¤’F’˜"m=˜4phz¤›F’˜

(183) O˜§F˜§"m›˜›p˜=aV˜=FFzF˜am˜›^F˜ paVam’˜pO˜ 

(184) ˜"m=˜a›’˜"m4F’›p’:˜§F˜Oam=˜›^"›˜›^F˜"F"’˜pO˜FVpmpha4’˜"m=˜ ^¤h"m_O"4›p’˜4"m˜*F˜4pm’a=FF=˜›p˜*F˜›^F˜hp›^F’˜pO˜ 

References

Download now ( PDF - 116 Page - 1.49 MB )

Related documents

A framework for designing a modular muffler system by global optimization

Keywords: Muffler Optimization, Four-pole Method, Transfer Matrix Method (TMM), Global Search, MultiStart, Genetic Algorithm, Pattern Search, Simulated

A Framework for the Design ofOrganizational DecisionSupport Systems

organization? How could knowledge be better managed in the organization than it is today? How could this be

1 Department of Astronomy and Space Physics, Uppsala University, Sweden

The more recent Gaia Data Release 2 (GDR2) contains radial velocities for 7 million stars (Gaia Collaboration et al. 2018), this enables a more di- rect method where positions

Design in Telemedicine : Development and Implementation of Usable Computer Systems

The research presented here is targeted towards finding ways – methods and practices – to design and develop computer systems especially in the medical domain that will give users

Operationalizing the SDGs in a Systems Engineering Framework for ship design concept studies

- Investigate if the same outline as the SE4SS-framework but with different activities could be applied in the later stages of a project as well (such as design and production). What

Uppsala University Department of Economics Uppsala, Sweden B.Sc. Thesis Fall, 2005

1) All K instruments are exogenous (valid). This tests size. The K:th instrument is either weak like the K-1 instruments or it is strong. 2) K-1 instruments are exogenous

Interactive and more usable approach towards Customer Product Information by Yasir Bilal

According to the study [13], the search function should give the user some suggestions so he finds quickly the right word; for instance, when the users misspell, there should be a

Rätten till inskränkning : I förhållande till artikel 5:s undantag

Vid genomgång av de rättigheter som finns i Konventionen, märktes det tydligt att denna uppsats måste fokusera på en enda artikel för att ha det utrymme som