Editors Author Guidelines Home
About Us Contact
R E V I E W S F E A T U R E S
C O M M E N T
Photo: L1030216 from Nite_Owl Flickr Photostream
In the London Review of Books, Paul Farmer Paul Farmer argues the case for building hospitals as a necessity, not a luxury, for poor countries and rich countries alike. Farmer points to the hypocrisy of a ‘basic minimum package’ for ‘resource poor settings’ that excludes the tertiary care that we assume to be our right as tax-paying citizens in the rich world. Specialist hospital care encompassing all the necessary ‘staff, stuff and systems’ (as Farmer puts it) saves the lives of those suffering complex trauma, infectious disease and complications of childbirth. The poor need these services as much as the rest of us, even if they also need clean water and vaccination programmes.
The neoliberal trend towards privatising profits while simultaneously socialising the losses involved in healthcare provision hits poor countries hardest. In the search for new ways of funding healthcare across the globe, mechanisms to pass the costs to the ‘consumer’, reducing public sector spending, have current primacy. Since hospitals for poor people, especially in rural or sparsely populated areas, cannot be built for profit, they are labelled unsustainable. Hospitals are unsustainable for poor people and so the poor die from, TB, cancer or serious injury. This is illustrated by an ethnography of a provincial hospital in ethnography of a provincial hospital in Papua New Guinea Papua New Guinea where the lack of staff (doctors, nurses, cleaners), stuff (equipment, drugs, food, accommodation) and systems (inter-disciplinary communication, pathology services, professional development to name but a few), compounds the suffering of marginalised people (both staff and patients) who have no alternative recourse. In global economic terms it is not the hospital that is unsustainable, but the poor.
In the rich world our hospitals were built by statutory money from central taxation, from charitable donations and philanthropic gestures. Charitable or developmental aid sources of funding are now dismissed as unsustainable for the world’s poor. To illustrate how profit is not the best means of making a new hospital, Paul Farmer contrasts a private finance hospital construction in the city of Maseru in Lesotho with a construction in Mirebalais city of Maseru in Lesotho with a construction in Mirebalais, in central Haiti. Drawing on local labour and voluntary technical assistance from US craftsmen, the Mirebalais hospital Mirebalais hospital cost less to construct than the one in Maseru, and, in its first year of operation has treated a similar number of patients. Furthermore, the running costs in Mirebalais are less then the private-financed Maseru hospital. Training programmes Training programmes have been launched in Mirebalais and one estimate suggests that for every dollar invested in the hospital (now central Haiti’s biggest employer), two are generated in the local economy. Could the hospital in Mirebalais, which is the largest solar-power hospital in the developing world, also be halting the emigration of trained healthcare staff? The exodus of staff, to the capital city, to local foreign-funded research or clinical settings is often part of the story of failing hospitals hospitals.
Tweet 0
SHARE THIS
SEEN ELSEWHERE
RT @JaneElliott66@JaneElliott66: Our nine-point guide to spotting a dodgy statistic
https://t.co/bMP1UIsCc5https://t.co/bMP1UIsCc5 1 day ago
RT @clarkmike@clarkmike: 'Hunt's Houdini act: What next?' - https://t.co/nqaeKa40kZhttps://t.co/nqaeKa40kZ via
@BBCNews@BBCNews 1 day ago
RT @TheLancet@TheLancet: Editorial & front cover:
#Brexit#Brexit and #juniordoctors#juniordoctors contracts:
the real threats to the #NHS#NHS https://t.co/KrgT5MAlXbhttps://t.co/KrgT5MAlXb https://…
3 days ago
RT @profsaulbecker@profsaulbecker: Please read this all the way through if you only read one thing today: https://t.co/FsjsLxzQ4Uhttps://t.co/FsjsLxzQ4U 3 days ago
RT @Prof DavidNutt@Prof DavidNutt: Why isn't cycling illegal? https://t.co/2o34zmmjCchttps://t.co/2o34zmmjCc via
@wordpressdotcom@wordpressdotcom 3 days ago
RT @peterjukes@peterjukes: Fantastic, fun and informative summary of Theresa May's Brexit nightmare by @IanDunt@IanDunt
https://t.co/ghcUGVVJcXhttps://t.co/ghcUGVVJcX 4 days ago
RT @NHSConfed_EU@NHSConfed_EU: How will #Brexit#Brexit affect NHS patients; our latest blog explains https://t.co/0IO3zcsSchhttps://t.co/0IO3zcsSch
https://t.co/wC2SmZnb9Dhttps://t.co/wC2SmZnb9D 4 days ago
Everything you need to know about #Brexit#Brexit trade deals (including some small print about NHS) @IanDunt@IanDunt -
https://t.co/CudHiOjHJUhttps://t.co/CudHiOjHJU 4 days ago
RECENT POSTS
Brexit and its discontentsBrexit and its discontents Jul 13, 2016Jul 13, 2016
On bulls, men and riskOn bulls, men and risk Jul 6, 2016Jul 6, 2016
‘Corporate Wellness’: blurring the‘Corporate Wellness’: blurring the lineslines
Jun 29, 2016Jun 29, 2016
How many Zikas will it take?How many Zikas will it take?
S E A R C H
What is the point of hospitals?
by HANNAH BRADBYHANNAH BRADBY May 22, 2015
5 Like Like
Submit
Hadassah hospital Hadassah hospital, a big state hospital in Jerusalem treats all Israeli citizens; Jews and Arabs alike. The corridor meeting of Jewish and Arabic patriarchs, in the wake of cancer treatment, is described as a comic and hopeful scene comic and hopeful scene by a fellow cancer patient. Providing life-saving treatments to citizens, regardless of their background, has been central to medicine’s role in nation-building and provides hope, not just of bodily recovery, but of social cohesion.
Hope is what fuelled the philanthropic building of hospitals in industrialising cities of the 19
thcentury: a hope that medicine could benefit the poor and rich alike. This echoes the hope of an Israeli hospital offering non-partisan treatment in the face of deeply entrenched divisions elsewhere in society. The pioneering solar-powered hospital in Haiti is exemplary in being a centre of excellence for quality care centre of excellence for quality care that is free of charge.
What is the point of a hospital? To provide specialist care. To provide a centre of employment and training. But most of all to provide hope. Hope of recovery, both individual and social.
Y O U R C O M M E N T S Y O U R C O M M E N T S
Name Name required required
Email Email required required
Website Website
Jun 22, 2016Jun 22, 2016
Caring for CarersCaring for Carers Jun 15, 2016Jun 15, 2016
Partners Partners Stay up to date Stay up to date
Follow us on Twitter Like us on Facebook MedSocNews Subscribe in a reader Subscribe to our newsletter Who we follow
Sites we like Sites we like
BSA MedSoc Study Group Centre for Medical Humanities Blog Charisma
Critical Public Health Discover Society Guerilla Policy Medical Sociology Online No way to make a living ourNHS openDemocracy Pop Theory
Social Science Space Sociological Images Sociology of Health and Illness
All content © 2015 Cost Of Living. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy and Cookie Policy | Site by Rainbird Studio