• No results found

The formation of doctoral education

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "The formation of doctoral education"

Copied!
112
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

The formation of doctoral education

Maja Elmgren, Eva Forsberg, Åsa Lindberg-Sand, Anders Sonesson

Maja Elmgren, Eva Forsberg, Åsa Lindberg-Sand, Anders Sonesson

Th e f or m ati on o f d oc to ra l e du ca tio n

This report describes and analyses doctoral education as a strategically important instrument by which universities produce and reproduce knowledge. It identifies changing conditions as well as heightened expectations and general trends. Leadership and quality in doctoral education is discussed in terms of policy, practice and knowledge. Doctoral education emerges as a focal point for national and international policy, as deeply incorporated within universities’ core practices, and as an object for experience-based knowledge, evaluations and research. It is integral to universities’ whole mission, today and in the future and also serves as the gatekeeper to academia. Hence, on-going changes with regard to, for example, the composition of doctoral groups, formal requirements on the organisation of doctoral education and research funding have consequences for academia and its practices. High quality in doctoral education involves safeguarding experiences gained, protecting desirable qualities and creating opportunities for further development. The authors of this report aim to provide a basis for institutions, leaders and supervisors to critically question and challenge both the status quo and the on- going changes of doctoral education. The policy trends, changing circumstances and challenges discussed are to a large extent international and Sweden specifically, with its long history of government regulation of doc- toral education and swiftness to adapt to the ideas of the knowledge economy, provides an interesting case.

Together, the authors – Maja Elmgren, Eva Forsberg, Åsa Lindberg-Sand and Anders Sonesson – have held positions as heads of department, directors of study for doctoral education, faculty board members, quality coordinators and educational developers at the two largest Swedish universities, Lund and Uppsala. This report has been translated from Swedish and adapted for an international audience. The original report was commissioned by the Association of Swedish Higher Education.

(2)

!

!

! !

(3)

!

! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$!%&'()*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$#!%&'()*+,!%-#!./)01*)(,!20#!34+51*)(67#+5!8!9+5*)0!7/+*00/+!

! !

(4)

! !

"#$%!&'()&*!$%!+,-'!.('/!011'%%!$/!,11)&-,/1'!2$*#!*#'!*'&+%!)3!*#'!4&',*$5'!

4)++)/%!0**&$67*$)/!44!89:;4!<=>!?$1'/%'@!2#$1#!('&+$*%!)*#'&%!*)!-$%*&$67*'@!

,-,(*!,/-!67$?-!7()/!*#$%!2)&A!/)/:1)++'&1$,??B@!(&)5$-'-!*#'!)&$C$/,?!2)&A!$%!

(&)('&?B!1$*'-=!D''E!#**(EFF1&',*$5'1)++)/%=)&CF?$1'/%'%F6B:/1F<=>F!

!

G,H,!I?+C&'/J@!I5,!K)&%6'&CJ@!L%,!M$/-6'&C:D,/-N!O!0/-'&%!D)/'%%)/N!

!J!P((%,?,!P/$5'&%$*B!

N!M7/-!P/$5'&%$*B!

!QD8;!RST:RJ:TSTUU:TJ:V!W(&$/*X!

QD8;!RST:RJ:TSTUU:TN:U!W(-3X!

!Y&$/*'-!$/!D2'-'/!6B!G'-$,:"&B1A@!M7/-!P/$5'&%$*B!

M7/-!N>JV!!

!

! !

(5)

!

YZIK04I!

"#+1! '$2&'*! #)1! 3$$,! *'),1/)*$-! %'&(! 45$-+1#! ),-! )-)2*$-! %&'! ),! +,*$',)6

*+&,)/! )0-+$,.$7! "#$! &'+8+,)/! '$2&'*9! 3*#5*)0:4;! </)! =>#&4?@! 4+! 5/A?/)#&!

*5>A#?4/+B9!5)1!.&((+11+&,$-!3:!*#$!;11&.+)*+&,!&%!45$-+1#!<+8#$'!=-0.)6

*+&,7!!

<$'$!5$!-$1.'+3$!),-!-+1.011!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!;/&4A@9!;)#A?4A*!),-!)1!#+!

/1$*A?!/<!C+/D&*5(*9!),-!#+8#/+8#*!)!,0(3$'!&%!>0$1*+&,1!*#)*!)'$!+(2&'*),*!

%&'!*#$!(),)8$($,*!),-!/$)-$'1#+2!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,9!*&-):!)1!5$//!)1!+,!

*#$! %0*0'$7! "#$! 2&/+.:! *'$,-19! .#),8+,8! .+'.0(1*),.$19! ),-! .#)//$,8$1! 5$!

-+1.011!#$'$!)'$!*&!)!/)'8$!$?*$,*!+,*$',)*+&,)/7!45$-$,!12$.+%+.)//:9!5+*#!+*1!

/&,8!#+1*&':!&%!8&@$',($,*!'$80/)*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!),-!15+%*,$11!*&!

)-)2*!*&!*#$!+-$)1!&%!*#$!A,&5/$-8$!$.&,&(:9!2'&@+-$1!),!+,*$'$1*+,8!.)1$7!!

B$! '$2'$1$,*! *5&! -+%%$'$,*! 45$-+1#! 0,+@$'1+*+$19! *#'$$! -+1.+2/+,$1! ),-! %&0'!

.&,*$?*17!"&8$*#$'9!5$!#)@$!#$/-!2&1+*+&,1!)1!#$)-1!&%!-$2)'*($,*9!-+'$.*&'1!

&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-+$19!%).0/*:!3&)'-!($(3$'19!>0)/+*:!.&&'-+,)*&'1!),-!$-0.)6

*+&,)/! -$@$/&2$'17! B$! #)@$! -$@$/&2$-! ),-! 8+@$,! .&0'1$1! %&'! -&.*&')/!

102$'@+1&'19! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*19! ),-! /$)-$'1! &%! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +,! (&1*!

103C$.*!%+$/-17!D0'!'$1$)'.#!+,./0-$1!)11$11($,*!2').*+.$1!+,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)6

*+&,9! *#$! 2').*+.$1! &%! 2$$'! '$@+$59! /$)-$'1#+2! ),-! (),)8$($,*! &%! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,9! ),-! *#$! =0'&2$),! #+8#$'! $-0.)*+&,! .0''+.0/0(! '$%&'(7! E0'*#$'6 (&'$9!5$!#)@$!2$'1&,)/!$?2$'+$,.$1!&%!102$'@+1+&,9!102$'@+1&'!.&//$8+)9!),-!

*#$! 2').*+.$1! &%! 2$$'! '$@+$5! 5+*#+,! -+%%$'$,*! 103C$.*! %+$/-17! ;1! )! '$10/*9! 5$!

#)@$!8)+,$-!)!3'&)-!+,1+8#*!+,*&!*#$!-+@$'1$!2').*+.$1!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

),-! 102$'@+1+&,9! ),-! +,*&! *#$! -+%%$'$,*! 5):1! +,! 5#+.#! 2&/+.+$1! ():! )%%$.*!

%+$/-1!&%!'$1$)'.#!),-!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!!

F:! -$1.'+3+,89! .&,*$?*0)/+G+,89! .&,*')1*+,8! ),-! 2'&3/$()*+G+,8! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,!5$!)+(!*&!2'&@+-$!1022&'*!%&'!*#$!.&,*+,0$-!-$@$/&2($,*!&%!*#+1!

/$@$/!&%!$-0.)*+&,!

B$!)'$!@$':!8')*$%0/!*&!"#$!;11&.+)*+&,!&%!45$-+1#!<+8#$'!=-0.)*+&,H1!%E;*)?!

;#+*&!</)!=>#&4?@!#00>)#+A*!=>*)4*0!),-!*&!*#$!2)'*+.+2),*1!)*!*#$!.&,%$'$,.$!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

J!M'-/$/C!3)&!A5,?$*'*!$!3)&%A,&7*6$?-/$/C'/!

(6)

3*#5*)0:4;! #+5! =>#&4?@! 4+! *5>A#?4/+,! )*0*#)A:! #+5! 5/A?/)#&! *5>A#?4/+!F!%&'!

.&,1*'0.*+@$!.&(($,*1!&,!@)'+&01!-')%*1!&%!*#+1!'$2&'*7!

!

"#$#!%&'()*+,!%-#!./)01*)(,!20#!34+51*)(67#+5!8!9+5*)0!7/+*00/+!

!

! !

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

N!!""#$%&'#()*#+,'$-"%"#-#."/-$&0-012#(3*4+0-01#356#(3*4+'*."/-$&0-01!

(7)

!

"08MI!.K!4.;"I;"D!

IDJ"DK;L!=IMJ;"NDO!NO!JDO"=P"Q!"<=!4B=IN4<!J;4=!777777777777777777777777777777777777777!R!

;+(1!),-!20'2&1$1!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!S! 45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+,!,0(3$'1!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!T! I'&26&0*1!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!U! V#I1!&,!*#$!/)3&0'!()'A$*!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!RW! IDJ"DK;L!=IMJ;"NDO!;4!VDLNJX!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!RY! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!Z!)!3&0,-)':!&3C$.*!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!RY! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!'$1$)'.#!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!RT! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!$-0.)*+&,!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!R[! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!203/+.!&0*'$).#!),-!$,8)8$($,*!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777!R\! E'&(!),!)22'$,*+.$1#+2!*&!),!$-0.)*+&,!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!SR! 45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!6!;,!$($'8+,8!/),-1.)2$!&%!8&@$',),.$!!7777777777777777777777!SS! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!),-!8/&3)/+1)*+&,!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!S[! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+,!)!=0'&2$),!.&,*$?*!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!S\! IDJ"DK;L!=IMJ;"NDO!;4!VK;J"NJ=!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!YR! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!),-!).)-$(+)!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!YR!

"#$!#+8#$1*!/$@$/!&%!$-0.)*+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!YS!

"#$!8)*$5):!*&!*#$!).)-$(:!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!YS! I&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1H!'$1$)'.#!2'&-0.*+&,!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!YY! K$8$,$')*+&,!&%!).)-$(+)!'$>0+'$1!(&'$!*#),!'$1$)'.#!.&(2$*$,.$!777777777777!Y]! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!%&//&51!'$1$)'.#!Z!5+*#!.&,1$>0$,.$1!%&'!).)-$(+)!77777!YT! V'$1*+8$!),-!%0*0'$!2'&12$.*1!*#'&08#!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777!Y[!

^),)8$($,*!),-!/$)-$'1#+2!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!Y\!

^),)8$($,*!),-!/$)-$'1#+2!&,!-+%%$'$,*!/$@$/1!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!Y_! 402$'@+1&'1!),-!'$1$)'.#!/$)-$'1!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!Y_! I$2)'*($,*)/!'$12&,1+3+/+*+$1!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]W! E).0/*:!/$)-$'1#+2!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]S! O$5!5+,-&51!&%!&22&'*0,+*:!%&'!0,+@$'1+*:!)-(+,+1*')*+&,!7777777777777777777777777777777!]Y! J&0'1$1!%&'!/$)-$'1!),-!102$'@+1&'1!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]Y!

"#$!%&'()*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!Z!%'&(!'$.'0+*($,*!*&!203/+.!-$%$,.$!777777777777!]]! E0,-+,8!),-!'$.'0+*($,*!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]]!

;-(+11+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]T!

"#$!2'&C$.*!2/),!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!]\! 402$'@+1+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!TW! V/),,+,89!(&,+*&'+,8!),-!)11$11($,*!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!T[!

"#$!%&'()*+&,!&%!45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!T_!

(8)

IDJ"DK;L!=IMJ;"NDO!;4!;O!DF`=J"!DE!aODBL=Ib=!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777![Y! E'&(!1$/%6'$%/$.*+&,!*&!2'&@$,!$?2$'+$,.$!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777![]! c0)/+*:!)110'),.$!),-!$@)/0)*+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!\Y! K$1$)'.#!&,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!77777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!\_! L=;I=K4<NV!;OI!cM;LN"X!NO!IDJ"DK;L!=IMJ;"NDO!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!U\! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!Z!*#$!0/&#)!;&*E>0!&%!).)-$(+)!777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!U\!

=,#),.+,8!),-!1)%$80)'-+,8!>0)/+*:!+,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!UU! N,*$',)/!.&//$8+)/!>0)/+*:!1:1*$(1!5+*#+,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,7!777777777777777777777777777777!U_!

=?*$',)/!>0)/+*:!1:1*$(1!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!_R! I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!1#)2$1!).)-$(+)!Z!5#)*!1#)2$1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!77777777777777777!_Y! FNFLNDbK;V<X!7777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777777!_T!

!

(9)

J!

[.4".Z0M!I[P40"Q.;!Q;!4.;"I\"E!"]I!D^I[QD]!40DI!

N,!'$.$,*!-$.)-$19!$-0.)*+&,!&,!*#$!-&.*&')/!/$@$/!#)1!+,.'$)1$-!+,!1+G$!),-!

1*')*$8+.!+(2&'*),.$! %&'! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! 5&'/-5+-$7! B$! .),! &31$'@$! )! 8'&5+,8!

+,*$'$1*!+,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!;/&4A@9!;)#A?4A*!),-!)1!#+!/1$*A?!/<!C+/D&*5(*7!!

E'&(! #)@+,8! 3$$,! .&,1+-$'$-! 2'+()'+/:! )! .&,.$',! %&'! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! ),-!

'$1$)'.#! .&((0,+*+$19! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! #)1! ,&5! 3$.&($! (0.#! (&'$!

-$3)*$-!),-!2&/+*+.+1$-7!"#$!,0(3$'!&%!1*)A$#&/-$'1!$?2'$11+,8!$?2$.*)*+&,1!

&,!*#$!.&,*$,*!),-!&'8),+1)*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!#)1!8'&5,7!N,!45$-$,9!

-&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! #)1! 1$$,! ),! +,.'$)1+,8!,0(3$'! &%! '0/$19! '$80/)*+&,1! ),-!

'$.&(($,-)*+&,1!)1!5$//!)1!,$5!%&'(1!&%!>0)/+*:!)110'),.$!2'&.$-0'$1!),-!

*#$! '$10/*1! &%! 102'),)*+&,)/! .&&'-+,)*+&,! ),-! C&+,*! 2&/+.+$17! B#+/$! *#$1$!

-$@$/&2($,*1! #)@$! )! #&(&8$,+1+,8! $%%$.*! &,! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! 5$! .),!

-+1.$',! -+%%$'$,.$1! '$/)*$-! *&! -+1.+2/+,)':! %+$/-1! )1! 5$//! )1! )12+')*+&,1! %&'!

)0*&,&(:!),-!),!+,.'$)1+,8!-+@$'1+*:!5+*#+,!*#$!1*0-$,*!8'&027!

B#$,! *#$! .&,-+*+&,1! %&'! )! 0,+@$'1+*:! )'$! .#),8$-9! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +1!

)%%$.*$-! 3&*#! -+'$.*/:! ),-! +,-+'$.*/:! )1! +*! +1! +,*$8')*$-! +,*&! *#$! 0,+@$'1+*:H1!

$,*+'$! (+11+&,Q! '$1$)'.#9! $-0.)*+&,! ),-! 203/+.! &0*'$).#7! I$.+1+&,1! ),-!

1*')*$8+.!2'+&'+*+$1!()-$!&,!0,+@$'1+*:!/$@$/!+(2).*!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!),-9!+,!

*0',9! *#$! &'8),+1)*+&,9! 1+G$! ),-! &'+$,*)*+&,! &%! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! )%%$.*! *#$!

0,+@$'1+*:H1! .)2).+*:! *&! %0/%+/! +*1! (+11+&,! +,! 3&*#! 1#&'*6*$'(! ),-! /&,86*$'(!

2$'12$.*+@$17!

I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!$11$,*+)/!%&'!*#$!$-0.)*+&,!),-!*')+,+,8!&%!%0*0'$!8$,$'6 )*+&,1! &%! ).)-$(+.1! ),-9! *#$'$3:9! )/1&! %&'! #+8#$'! $-0.)*+&,! ),-! %&'! *#$!

2'&-0.*+&,!&%!,$5!A,&5/$-8$7!O&*!&,/:!)%*$'!30*!)/1&!-0'+,8!*#$+'!$-0.)*+&,9!

-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!.&,*'+30*$!1+8,+%+.),*/:!*&!'$1$)'.#!),-!*$).#+,87!I&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,! +1! *#01! .&,C&+,$-! 5+*#! *#$! 2').*+.$19! >0)/+%+.)*+&,19! $1*$$(9! ),-!

%0*0'$!2'&12$.*1!&%!0,+@$'1+*+$19!-$2)'*($,*19!*$)(1!),-!+,-+@+-0)/!102$'@+6 1&'17!;*!*#$!1)($!*+($!*#$'$!+1!),!+,.'$)1+,8!-$(),-!+,!*#$!A,&5/$-8$!1&.+$*:!

%&'!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!*&!.&,*'+30*$!*&!101*)+,)3+/+*:!),-!,)*+&,)/!.)2).+*:!+,!

),!+,.'$)1+,8/:!.&(2$*+*+@$!5&'/-7!!

"#$'$! #)1! 3$$,! .&,1+-$')3/$! -$@$/&2($,*! &%! &0'! A,&5/$-8$! &%! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,7!V').*+.$19!*')-+*+&,1!),-!$?2$'+$,.$1!#)@$!.&($!*&!3$!.&(2)'$-9!

-$1.'+3$-!),-!2'&3/$()*+G$-!*#'&08#!,$*5&'A19!.&,%$'$,.$1!),-!.&0'1$1!%&'!

102$'@+1&'1! ),-! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .&&'-+,)*&'17! ;--+*+&,)//:9! ./)+(1! %&'!

(10)

N!

+,.'$)1$-! 8&@$',),.$! ),-! *'),12)'$,.:! #)@$! ()-$! 2').*+.$1! @+1+3/$! ),-!

$?2&1$-!*&!*'+)/!),-!'$%/$.*+&,7!;*!*#$!1)($!*+($9!'$1$)'.#63)1$-!A,&5/$-8$!

#)1!+,.'$)1$-!+,!1.&2$!)/*#&08#!+*!+1!1*+//!/+(+*$-7!

"#+1!'$2&'*!-$1.'+3$1!),-!2'&3/$()*+G$1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!)!1*')*$8+.)//:!

+(2&'*),*! +,1*'0($,*! %&'! 0,+@$'1+*+$1H! 2'&-0.*+&,! ),-! '$2'&-0.*+&,! &%!

A,&5/$-8$7!B$!+-$,*+%:!.#),8+,8!.+'.0(1*),.$19!*'$,-19!),-!+,.'$)1$-!$?2$.6

*)*+&,19!),-!-+1.011!>0)/+*:!),-!/$)-$'1#+2!+,!'$/)*+&,!*&!2&/+.:9!2').*+.$!),-!

A,&5/$-8$!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,7!B$!#)@$!1*'+@$-!*&!.)2*0'$!*#$!-+@$'1+*:!&%!

-&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! ),-! *&! 1*'$11! +*1! (),:! ),-! +(2&'*),*! %0,.*+&,1! %&'! *#$!

).)-$(:!),-!%&'!1&.+$*:!+,!8$,$')/9!),-!*#01!*&!2'&@+-$!)!01$%0/!%&0,-)*+&,!

%&'!'$%/$.*+&,!),-!-$@$/&2($,*7!!

0$+%!,/-!(7&()%'%!)3!-)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!

I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!1$'@$1!(),:!20'2&1$17!I+%%$'$,*!1*)A$#&/-$'1!#)@$!/$8+*6 +()*$!$?2$.*)*+&,19!),-!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!&%!%0,-)($,*)/!+(2&'*),.$!,&*!

&,/:!%&'!'$1$)'.#!),-!%&'!*#$!'$8$,$')*+&,!&%!).)-$(+)!30*!)/1&!%&'!2'&@+-+,8!

.&(2$*$,.$!),-!A,&5/$-8$!%&'!)0*#&'+*+$19!+,-01*':9!.&(($'.$!),-!2&/+*+.17!

"#$!1+8,+%+.),.$!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!%&'!*#&1$!5&'A+,8!./&1$!*&!+*!+1!2)'*/:!

-+%%$'$,*! %'&(! *#$! 1+8,+%+.),.$! +*! #)1! %&'! 1&.+$*:! +,! 8$,$')/7! E&'! +,-+@+-0)/!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*19! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .),! 3$! &%! .'0.+)/! +(2&'*),.$! *&! *#$+'!

/+@$1!),-!.)'$$'17!4*0-$,*1!)'$!8+@$,!&22&'*0,+*:9!%&'!),!$?*$,-$-!2$'+&-!&%!

*+($9! *&! 8'&5! )1! +,-+@+-0)/19! *&! -$@$/&2! .&(2$*$,.$19! *&! ()A$! +(2&'*),*!

-$.+1+&,1!),-!*&!C&+,!,$*5&'A1!),-!$1*)3/+1#!+(2&'*),*!'$/)*+&,1#+217!!

^&'$&@$'9!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!)!.&(2/$?!).*+@+*:!)*!*#$!#$)'*!&%!).)-$(+)7!N*!

1#)2$1!*#&1$!%0*0'$!8$,$')*+&,1!*#)*!5+//!.)'':!).)-$(+.!+-$)/1!),-!2').*+.$1!

&,5)'-1!)*!*#$!1)($!*+($!)1!+*!2'&-0.$1!,$5!A,&5/$-8$7!I$2$,-+,8!&,!#&5!

).)-$(+)9!'$1$)'.#!),-!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)'$!2$'.$+@$-9!-+%%$'$,*!+-$)/1!),-!

2').*+.$1! )'$! %&'($-7! E&'! $?)(2/$9! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .),! 3$! @+$5$-! )1!

3+/-0,89! $-0.)*+&,9! '$1$)'.#9! 5&'A9! )22'$,*+.$1#+2! &'! )1! )! .)//+,8! Z! &'! )1! )!

.&(3+,)*+&,! &%! *5&! &'! (&'$! &%! *#$1$! 2$'12$.*+@$17! B+*#! *#$1$! -+%%$'$,*!

2$'12$.*+@$1! %&//&5! -+%%$'$,*! ),-! 1&($*+($1! .&,%/+.*+,8! +-$)1! )3&0*! 5#)*! )!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*! .),! 3$! ),-! #&5! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .&0/-! &'! 1#&0/-! 3$!

-$1+8,$-7!!

(11)

U!

E+80'$! R! 1#&51! #&5! @)'+&01! )12$.*1! &%! *#$! &0*.&($! &%! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,!

$($'8$!5#$*#$'!%&.01+,8!&,!*#$!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*!)1!),!+,-+@+-0)/9!&'!&,!*#$!

).)-$(+.!.&((0,+*:!*&!5#+.#!*#$!1*0-$,*!3$/&,817!!

! "#$%&'(#!$)%!%(*#(+,()$-./!

! 0)12()3! 4&()3! %1()3!

5)%(6(%7$,!

+&-*+&#8(6&! J&(2$*$,.$! N-$,*+*:! I+11$'*)*+&,!

91,,&#8(6&!

+&-*+&#8(6&! J)2).+*:! J0/*0'$! V'&-0.*+&,!

E+80'$!R7!G4<<*)*+?!;*)0;*A?4-*0!/+!?:*!;>);/0*0!/<!5/A?/)#&!*5>A#?4/+7!!

B+*#+,!*#$!).)-$(:9!%&.01!+1!&%*$,!8$)'$-!*&5)'-1!#A#5*'4A!#+5!540A4;&4+#)@!

5/4+(!),-!-&.*&')/!'$1$)'.#!+1!*#$,!2'+()'+/:!'$8)'-$-!)1!'$1$)'.#7!I&.*&')/!

1*0-$,*1! 2'&8'$11! %'&(! /$)',+,8! *#$! A,&5,! *&! $?2/&'+,8! *#$! 0,A,&5,7! ;!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*H1! 10..$11! +1! $11$,*+)//:! ($)10'$-! 3:! 5):! &%! #+1! &'! #$'!

'$1$)'.#! '$10/*17! J&0'1$1! ()+,/:! 1$'@$! *&! 2'&@+-$! *#$! ,$.$11)':! 1A+//1! ),-!

A,&5/$-8$!*&!2$'%&'(!'$1$)'.#7!K$1$)'.#!.),!3$!2'&-0.$-!$+*#$'!+,-+@+-0)//:!

&'!.&//$.*+@$/:9!-$2$,-+,8!&,!*#$!).)-$(+.!$,@+'&,($,*!),-!103C$.*!%+$/-7!N%!

'$1$)'.#! +1! 2'$-&(+,),*/:! ),! +,-+@+-0)/! $,-$)@&0'9! *#$! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*H1!

.&,*'+30*+&,!),-!+(2&'*),.$!*&!*#$!.&//$.*+@$!():!3$!1()//7!N%9!&,!*#$!&*#$'!

#),-9!'$1$)'.#!+1!)!#+8#/:!.&//$.*+@$!).*+@+*:9!*#$!+,-+@+-0)/!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*H1!

/$)',+,8!),-!-$@$/&2($,*!():!3$!,$8/$.*$-!+,!%)@&0'!&%!*#$!'$1$)'.#!2'&-0.6

*+&,!&%!*#$!.&//$.*+@$7!!

B#$,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+,1*$)-!+1!'$8)'-$-!)1!5&'AY9!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!():!

3$!@+$5$-!)1!2)'*!&%!)!5&'A%&'.$!5+*#!5&'A!)11+8,($,*19!-$)-/+,$1!),-!5&'A6 +,8!#&0'17!N,!&*#$'!.&,*$?*19!5#$'$!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!')*#$'!+1!@+$5$-!)1!)!

.)//+,89! 1*0-$,*1! ():! +,1*$)-! 3$! $?2$.*$-! *&! 2'+&'+*+1$! *#$! '$1$)'.#! 2'&C$.*!

)3&@$!*#$+'!&5,!,$$-1!%&'!),!)22'&2'+)*$!5&'A/&)-7!

"#$!.&,*'+30*+&,1!%'&(!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!*&!*#$!5/4+(!&%!'$1$)'.#!8'&021!&'!

-$2)'*($,*1! )'$! &%! 8'$)*! 1+8,+%+.),.$! *&! *#$+'! )11+(+/)*+&,! +,*&! ).)-$(+)7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

U!Q/!,11)&-,/1'!2$*#!"#'!]$C#'&!I-71,*$)/!.&-$/,/1'@!*#'!+,H)&$*B!)3!D2'-'/_%!-)1*)&,?!

%*7-'/*%!,&'!'+(?)B'-!*)!%*7-B!

(12)

<!

I&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!)'$!:&0,8!'$1$)'.#$'1!)(&,8!&*#$'!'$1$)'.#$'1!),-!.),!3$!

@+$5$-! )1! 2$'+2#$')/! ($(3$'1! &%! .&((0,+*+$1! &%! 2').*+.$! dL)@$! e! B$,8$'!

R__Rf7!I$2)'*($,*)/!-0*+$1!5+*#+,!*#$!%')($5&'A!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,9!$787!

*$).#+,89! )/1&! .&,*'+30*$! *&! *#$! .&//$.*+@$! ),-! .),! 2'&@+-$! 2&11+3+/+*+$1! %&'!

/$)',+,8!),-!+,1+8#*!+,*&!*#$!@)'+&01!*)1A1!&%!).)-$(+)!)1!5$//!)1!*&!)!%$$/+,8!

&%!%$//&51#+2!5+*#!&*#$'!).)-$(+.17!!

N%!%&.01!+,1*$)-!+1!&,!#A#5*'4A!#+5!540A4;&4+#)@!C+/D4+(9!*#$!.&(2$*$,*!V#I9!

5#&! .),! .&,*'+30*$! *&! 1&.+$*)/! -$@$/&2($,*! 3&*#! 5+*#+,! ),-! &0*1+-$! &%!

).)-$(+)9! )22$)'1! ),-! )1! )! '$10/*9! -&.*&')/! '$1$)'.#! +1! 2'+()'+/:! 1$$,! )1!

$-0.)*+&,7! I&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! 1#&0/-! .&,-0.*! '$1$)'.#9! 30*! 2'+,.+2)//:! )1! )!

($),1!%&'!-$@$/&2+,8!.&(2$*$,.$!')*#$'!*#),!)1!),!+(($-+)*$!.&,*'+30*+&,!

*&! '$1$)'.#7! 40..$11%0/! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! 1#&0/-! /$)-! *&! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1H!

-$@$/&2($,*!&%!2'&%&0,-!A,&5/$-8$!),-!1A+//1!),-9!%&'()//:!12$)A+,89!*&!*#$!

%0/%+/($,*! &%! *#$! /$)',+,8! &0*.&($1! +,! *#$! 45$-+1#! I$8'$$! D'-+,),.$]7!

K$1$)'.#!).*+@+*+$1!),-!.&0'1$1!1#&0/-!3$!-$1+8,$-!+,!10.#!)!5):!)1!*&!3$1*!

.)*$'!*&!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1H!-$@$/&2($,*!),-!2'$2)')*+&,1!%&'!/+%$!)%*$'!*#$+'!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-+$17! "#+1! 2$'12$.*+@$! +1! &%*$,! 2'$1$,*! 5#$,! 2&/+*+.+),1! 5),*! *&!

+,.'$)1$!*#$!,0(3$'!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!),-!+,!'$/)*+&,!*&!12$.+%+.!+,+*+)*+@$1!

%&'!8')-0)*$!1.#&&/17!

D,! )! .&//$.*+@$! /$@$/9! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .),! .&,*'+30*$! *&! *#$! 8'&5*#! &%!

.)2).+*:! %&'! *#$! $,*+'$! &'8),+1)*+&,7! V&11+3+/+*+$1! )'+1$! %&'! )//! 2)'*+.+2),*1!

*#'&08#! ,$5! 2$'12$.*+@$19! *#'&08#! @$,*0'$1! +,! ,$5! )'$)1! *#)*! ,$$-! -$@$/6

&2($,*! ),-! *#'&08#! *#$! %&'()*+&,! &%! $,@+'&,($,*1! *#)*! .),! +,.'$)1$! *#$!

.)2).+*:!%&'!'$1$)'.#!),-!$-0.)*+&,!)1!5$//!)1!&0*'$).#!),-!$,8)8$($,*7!!

E+,)//:9! +%! )**$,*+&,! +1! 8$)'$-! *&5)'-1! #A#5*'4A! #+5! 540A4;&4+#)@! 1*4+(,!

-&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .),! 3$! 2$'.$+@$-! )1! )! C&0',$:! &%! 14&5>+(! 3:! 5#+.#! *#$!

1*0-$,*!+1!1#)2$-9!),-!5#+.#!1#)2$19!*#$!.&((0,+*:!),-!.0/*0'$!#$!&'!1#$!+1!

2)'*! &%7! <$'$9! *+($! ),-! '&&(! %&'! $?.#),8$! &%! $?2$'+$,.$1! ),-! '$%/$.*+&,!

3$.&($1!+(2&'*),*!1&!*#)*!3&*#!*#$!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*!),-!*#$!.&//$.*+@$!.),!

-$@$/&27! K$1$)'.#! )11+8,($,*19! .&0'1$1! ),-! -$2)'*($,*)/! -0*+$1! .),! 3$!

-$1+8,$-!*&!3'&)-$,!2$'12$.*+@$1!),-!2'&@+-$!).)-$(+.!*')+,+,8!)*!*#$!1)($!

*+($! )1! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1H! .&,*'+30*+&,1! )'$! ()-$! )@)+/)3/$! *&! &*#$'17! "#$!

1*0-$,*! +1! $?2$.*$-! *&! -$@$/&2! ),! ).)-$(+.! +-$,*+*:! ),-! )-&2*! ).)-$(+.!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

<!0//'`!N!)3!*#'!D2'-$%#!]I!)&-$/,/1'=!M$%*%!&'a7$&'+'/*%!3)&!-'C&''%!,2,&-'-!,*!3$&%*@!

%'1)/-!,/-!*#$&-!W&'%',&1#X!?'5'?=!M'5'?!-'%1&$(*)&%!,&'!%*,*'-!,%!$/*'/-'-!?',&/$/C!

)7*1)+'%!

(13)

b!

+-$)/17!E0'*#$'(&'$9!*#$!1*0-$,*!+1!1$$,!)1!)!@$#+./$!%&'!A,&5/$-8$!5+*#!),!

)3+/+*:!*&!-$$2$,!&0'!0,-$'1*),-+,8!&%!&0'1$/@$1!),-!&%!*#$!5&'/-!)'&0,-!019!

)3+/+*+$1! *#)*! ():! 3$,$%+*! 1&.+$*:! +,! @)'+&01! 5):17! N,! .&0,*'+$1! 5#$'$! *#$!

-$8'$$!&%!-&.*&'!+1!@+$5$-!)1!),!+(2&'*),*!.'$-$,*+)/9!%&'!$?)(2/$9!%&'!2&/+*+6 .+),1! ),-! &*#$'! 2$&2/$! +,! 2&5$'9! *#$! $-0.)*+&,)/! 20'2&1$! &%! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,!+1!&%*$,!1*'$11$-7!

I&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +1! &%*$,! '$8)'-$-! )1! ),! )22'$,*+.$1#+2! 5#$'$! *#$! /$11!

$?2$'+$,.$-! 5&'A! 1+-$! 3:! 1+-$! 5+*#! *#$! (&'$! $?2$'+$,.$-7! "#$! .&,.$2*! &%!

)22'$,*+.$1#+2! +,./0-$1! $/$($,*1! &%! *')+,+,8! ),-! 102$'@+1+&,9! ),-! 3:!

.&,*'+30*+,8!*&!*#$!.&//$.*+@$!2').*+.$1!*#$!1*0-$,*!,)*0')//:!3$.&($1!)11+(+6 /)*$-7! E&'! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! #&5$@$'9! *#$! )22'$,*+.$1#+2! ($*)2#&'! 5&0/-!

,$$-! *&! 3$! $?*$,-$-7! "&! -$@$/&2! *#$! )22'&2'+)*$! A,&5/$-8$! ),-! 1A+//19! *#$!

1*0-$,*! ,$$-1! (&'$! *#),! )! 102$'@+1&'! ),-! )! 2'&C$.*7! "#$! +,*$//$.*0)/! $,@+6 '&,($,*! 10''&0,-+,8! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! +1! .'0.+)/! ),-! )! 1$,1$! &%! .&//$.*+@$!

'$12&,1+3+/+*:! %&'! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1H! -$@$/&2($,*! +1! $11$,*+)/! %&'! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,!*&!3$!10..$11%0/!dB)/A$'!$*!)/7!SWWUf7!

I$2$,-+,8!&,!5#+.#!)12$.*1!)'$!$(2#)1+1$-!Z!*#$!C+/D4+(9!1*4+(9!&'!5/4+(,!

$+*#$'!&,!),!4+54-45>#&!&'!A/&&*A?4-*!/$@$/!Z!*#$!20'2&1$!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,9!

%&'!*#$!).)-$(:!&'!%&'!1&.+$*:!)1!)!5#&/$9!.),!3$!1$$,!+,!@$':!-+%%$'$,*!5):17!

I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!.),!3$!2$'.$+@$-!-+%%$'$,*/:!-$2$,-+,8!&,!'$1$)'.#!*')-+6

*+&,19! &,! *#$! .&,-+*+&,1! %&'! )! 2)'*+.0/)'! '$1$)'.#! %+$/-9! ),-! &,! *#$! %0*0'$!

/)3&0'!()'A$*!%&'!8')-0)*$17!

D2'-$%#!-)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!$/!/7+6'&%!

"#$!H4(:*)!*5>A#?4/+!4+!7D*5*+!0?#?>0!)*;/)?!dSWRYf!1#&51!*#)*!*#$!,0(3$'!

&%!$,'&//$-!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!+,!45$-$,!#)1!3$$,!+,.'$)1+,8!%&'!1$@$')/!:$)'1!

),-!+,!SWRS!*#$'$!5$'$!)3&0*!Y!\WW!$,*'),*1!+,!*#$!*#+'-!.:./$T7!"#$!,0(3$'!

&%!+,*$',)*+&,)/!$,*'),*1!+1!1*$)-+/:!+,.'$)1+,8!),-!+,!SWRS!*#$:!'$2'$1$,*$-!

Y_! 2$'!.$,*! &%! *#$! $,*'),*1! )1! .&(2)'$-! *&! R[! 2$'!.$,*! +,! R__\7! "#$! *&*)/!

,0(3$'1!&%!$,*'),*1!)*!*#$1$!*5&!2&+,*1!+,!*+($!5$'$!/)'8$/:!*#$!1)($!5#+.#!

($),1!*#)*!*#$!*'),1%$'!&%!45$-+1#!1*0-$,*1!%'&(!0,-$'8')-0)*$!),-!8')-06 )*$! /$@$/1! *&! -&.*&')/! /$@$/! #)1! 8')-0)//:! -$.'$)1$-7! "#$'$! +1! ,&! /&,8$'! ),!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T!I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!3$/&,81!*&!*#$!*#+'-!/$@$/!+,!*#$!%')($5&'A!&%!*#$!=0'&2$),!

<+8#$'!=-0.)*+&,!;'$)7!N,!45$-$,9!*#+'-!/$@$/!$-0.)*+&,!+,./0-$1!3&*#!*#$!-&.*&')/!

-$8'$$!d]!:$)'1f!),-!*#$!1#&'*$'!/+.$,*+)*$!-$8'$$!dS!:$)'1f!!

(14)

V!

+(3)/),.$-!-+1*'+30*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!+,!*$'(1!&%!8$,-$'!)1!*#$'$!5)1!

+,! *#$! R__W17! "#$! 8$,-$'! 3)/),.$! #)1! 3$$,! (&'$! &'! /$11! $@$,! 1+,.$! SWWW7!

<&5$@$'9! *#$! ,0(3$'! &%! 5&($,! +1! 1/+8#*/:! /&5$'! )(&,8! +,*$',)*+&,)/!

$,*'),*1!d]W!gf7!!

! E+80'$! S7! %+?)#+?0,!0?>5*+?0!#+5!#D#)5*5!5*()**0!4+!?:4)56A@A&*!;)/()#''*0,!

BIIJ6FJBFK!7/>)A*L!H4(:*)!*5>A#?4/+!4+!7D*5*+,!FJBM!0?#?>0!)*;/)?,!;K!MNK!!

;,! +,.'$)1+,8! ,0(3$'! &%! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! .&($! %'&(! )3'&)-! ),-! *#+1! +1!

2)'*+.0/)'/:!.&((&,!+,!*#$!,)*0')/!1.+$,.$1!),-!+,!$,8+,$$'+,87!^&1*!+,*$',)6

*+&,)/!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!&'+8+,)*$!%'&(!;1+)!d)22'&?7!TW!gf!),-!%'&(!*#$!=M!

d)/(&1*! YW! gf7! =@$,! )(&,8! *#$! [R!2$'!.$,*! &%! -&.*&')/! $,*'),*1! *#)*! )'$!

-&($1*+.!*&!45$-$,9!SW!2$'!.$,*!#)@$!1&($!*:2$!&%!+,*$',)*+&,)/!3).A8'&0,-7!

"#$!*&*)/!,0(3$'!&%!1*0-$,*1!&,!-&.*&')/!/$@$/!#)1!+,.'$)1$-!1&($5#)*!),-!

)(&0,*$-! *&! )/(&1*! R_!WWW! +,! *#$! )0*0(,! &%! SWRS7! ;2)'*! %'&(! *#$1$! *#$'$!

5$'$! S!_WW! 1*0-$,*1! 5#&! 5$'$! ,&*! ).*+@$7! N,! SWRS! *#$! ,0(3$'! &%! -&.*&')/!

(15)

S!

-$8'$$1! )5)'-$-! )(&0,*$-! *&! S!TWW! ),-! *#$! ,0(3$'! &%! /+.$,*+)*$! -$8'$$1!

)5)'-$-!5$'$!UWW7!!

"#$'$! )'$! '$/)*+@$/:! /)'8$! -+%%$'$,.$1! 3$*5$$,! *#$! 1+?! '$1$)'.#! -&()+,1!

)..&0,*$-! %&'! +,! *#$! '$2&'*7! "#$! ()C&'+*:! ,0(3$'! &%! -$8'$$1! )'$! )5)'-$-!

5+*#+,!*#$!%+$/-!&%!($-+.+,$!),-!#$)/*#!1.+$,.$1!dRhYf9!%&//&5$-!3:!*#$!,)*0')/!

1.+$,.$1! dRh]f9! *$.#,&/&8:! dRhTf9! *#$! 1&.+)/! 1.+$,.$1! dRh\f9! *#$! #0(),+*+$1!

dRhRTf! ),-! *#$! )8'+.0/*0')/! 1.+$,.$1! dRhTWf7! L+.$,*+)*$! -$8'$$1! )'$! (&1*!

.&((&,!5+*#+,!*#$!%+$/-!&%!*$.#,&/&8:!%&//&5$-!3:!*#$!,)*0')/!1.+$,.$1!dRh]f7!!

E+80'$!Y!1#&51!*#$!,0(3$'!&%!$,*'),*1!5+*#+,!-+%%$'$,*!'$1$)'.#!-&()+,17!N,!

SWRW! -&.*&')/! ),-! /+.$,*+)*$! -$8'$$1! 5$'$! +,*'&-0.$-! %&'! *#$! %+,$9! )22/+$-!

),-!2$'%&'(+,8!)'*17!"#$1$!()A$!02!)!1()//!,0(3$'!&%!*#$!*&*)/!10(!),-!)'$!

2)'*!&%!*#$!'$2&'*!%&'!*#$!#0(),+*+$17!!

!!

E+80'$!Y7!O>'1*)!/<!*+?)#+?0!540?)41>?*5!#AA/)54+(!?/!)*0*#)A:!5/'#4+0!BIII6 FJBFK!7/>)A*L!9++>#&!)*;/)?!</)!:4(:*)!*5>A#?4/+,!FJBM,!;K!MPK!!

(16)

T!

B&($,!)'$!8$,$')//:!1/+8#*/:!&/-$'!5#$,!*#$:!3$8+,!*#$+'!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

),-!&/-$'!$,*'),*1!)'$!(&'$!.&((&,!5+*#+,!*#$!1&.+)/!1.+$,.$19!*#$!#0(),+6

*+$1!),-!+,!($-+.+,$!),-!*#$!#$)/*#!1.+$,.$1!*#),!+,!&*#$'!%+$/-17!!

=+8#*:!2$'!.$,*!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!.)'':!&0*!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!)*!,+,$!&%!*#$!/)'86

$1*! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! +,! *#$! .&0,*':7!"')-+*+&,)//:9! &,/:! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! #)@$! #)-! *#$!

'+8#*!*&!)5)'-!-&.*&')/!-$8'$$1!30*!1+,.$!SWRW9!0,+@$'1+*:!.&//$8$1!.),!)22/:!

%&'!2$'(+11+&,!5+*#+,!2)'*+.0/)'!'$1$)'.#!%+$/-17!4&!%)'!RS!0,+@$'1+*:!.&//$8$1!

#)@$!#)-!10.#!)22/+.)*+&,1!)22'&@$-!+,!SY!%+$/-17!4031$>0$,*/:9!*#$!,0(3$'!

&%! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! 5#&! 1*0-:! )*! )! 0,+@$'1+*:! .&//$8$! 5#$'$! *#$:! #)@$! ,&*!

3$$,! $,'&//$-! #)1! -$.'$)1$-9! /$)@+,8! *#$1$! *:2$1! &%! )''),8$($,*1! &,/:! )*!

*#'$$!2$'!.$,*!&%!*#$!*&*)/!,0(3$'!&%!).*+@$!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!+,!SWRS7!!

;/(&1*!*5&6*#+'-1!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!d1/+8#*/:!(&'$!.&((&,!%&'!($,f!.)'':!

&0*! *#$+'! 1*0-+$1! %0//6*+($! dUW6RWW! g! ).*+@+*:f7! I&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1#+219! +7$7!

5#$'$! *#$! 1*0-$,*! +1! $(2/&:$-! *&! 1*0-:! ),-! 2$'%&'(! 02! *&! SW!g! -$2)'*6 ($,*)/! -0*+$1f! )'$! *#$! (&1*! .&((&,! ($),1! &%! 1022&'*! 5+*#+,! )//! 103C$.*!

)'$)19!30*!)'$!/$11!.&((&,!+,!*#$!($-+.)/!),-!#$)/*#!1.+$,.$17!!

E&'! *#&1$! 5#&! '$.$+@$-! *#$+'! -&.*&')/! -$8'$$! +,! SWRS9! *#$! )@$')8$! ,$*!

.&(2/$*+&,! *+($! 5)1! U7]! *$'(1[!),-! *#$! 8'&11! .&(2/$*+&,! *+($! 5)1! RR7W!

*$'(17!"#$!$>0+@)/$,*!%+80'$1!%&'!)!/+.$,*+)*$!-$8'$$!5$'$!T7Y!),-!\7W!*$'(1!

'$12$.*+@$/:7!O$*!.&(2/$*+&,!*+($1!)'$!*#$!#+8#$1*!5+*#+,!*#$!#0(),+*+$1!),-!

*#$!/&5$1*!5+*#+,!($-+.)/!),-!#$)/*#!1.+$,.$17!

[&)(:)7*%!

K$)1&,1! %&'! 1*0-$,*! -'&26&0*1! 5$'$! $?)(+,$-! +,! )! >0$1*+&,,)+'$! +110$-! 3:!

*#$!45$-+1#!O)*+&,)/!;8$,.:!%&'!<+8#$'!=-0.)*+&,!+,!SWRS!d<i81A&/$@$'A$*!

SWRS.f7!"5&6*#+'-1!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!5#&!#)-!-+1.&,*+,0$-!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!

./)+($-!*&!#)@$!-&,$!1&!%&'!1&.+)/!'$)1&,1!dYT!gf!&'!%&'!2'&3/$(1!'$/)*$-!*&!

*#$+'! $-0.)*+&,! dYR! gf7! "#$! '$()+,+,8! 2$'.$,*)8$1! +,@&/@$-! R\! 2$'!.$,*! &%!

1*0-$,*1!5#&!#)-!+,*$''02*$-!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!-0$!*&!/)3&0'!()'A$*!.&,1+-$')6

*+&,1!),-!RS!2$'!.$,*!5#&!#)-!%+,),.+)/!'$)1&,1!%&'!-'&22+,8!&0*7!"#$!/$)1*!

.&((&,! '$)1&,! %&'! -+1.&,*+,0)*+&,! #)-! *&! -&! 5+*#! -$2)'*($,*)/! -0*+$1!

dT!gf7! Y[!2$'!.$,*! &%! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! 1*)'*+,8! *#$+'! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +,!

R_UW! %+,+1#$-! *#$+'! -$8'$$! 5+*#+,! U! :$)'17! 4+,.$! *#$,! *#$! %'$>0$,.:! &%!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

V!"#'!D2'-$%#!%*7-B!B',&!$%!<>!2''A%!-$5'-!)5'&!*2)!*'&+%!

(17)

R!

.&(2/$*+&,! #)1! +,.'$)1$-7! ]_!2$'!.$,*! &%! $,*'),*1! +,! R__W! #)-! .&(2/$*$-!

*#$+'!1*0-+$1!+,!*#$!1)($!)(&0,*!&%!*+($!),-![_!2$'!.$,*!&%!*#&1$!3$8+,,+,8!

*#$+'!1*0-+$1!+,!SWWW!#)-!'$.$+@$-!*#$+'!-$8'$$1!5+*#+,!U!:$)'17!!

4&.+)/!'$)1&,1!%&'!*$'(+,)*+&,!5$'$!(&'$!.&((&,!)(&,8!5&($,!*#),!($,!

),-!(&'$!.&((&,!5+*#+,!*#$!#0(),+*+$1!),-!+,!($-+.+,$!*#),!+,!*$.#,&/&8:!

),-! *#$! ,)*0')/! 1.+$,.$1! ),-9! %0'*#$'(&'$9! (&'$! .&((&,! )(&,8! :&0,8$'!

-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*17!"#$!'$@$'1$!+1!*'0$!%&'!'$)1&,1!'$/)*+,8!*&!-&.*&')/!$-0.)6

*+&,7!<&5$@$'9!+*!+1!(&'$!.&((&,!*#)*!5&($,!-+1.&,*+,0$!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!%&'!

1&.+)/!'$)1&,1!+,!)//!)8$!8'&0217!^$,!./)+(!*&!-+1.&,*+,0$!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!-0$!*&!

%+,),.+)/!'$)1&,1!(&'$!&%*$,!*#),!5&($,!5+*#+,!)//!%+$/-1!),-!)8$!8'&0217!!

B#$,!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!5$'$!$,.&0')8$-!*&!1*)*$! (&'$!12$.+%+.!'$)1&,1!%&'!

-'&22+,8!&0*9!'$)1&,1!'$/)*+,8!-+'$.*/:!*&!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!5$'$!*#$!(&1*!

.&((&,7!"#$!*#'$$!(&1*!%'$>0$,*!.)01$1!+,@&/@$-!+,10%%+.+$,*!1022&'*!%'&(!

102$'@+1&'1! d]W!gf9! /&11!&%! (&*+@)*+&,!dY\! gf!),-! +,)-$>0)*$! 21:.#&1&.+)/!

5&'A+,8!$,@+'&,($,*1!dSU!gf7!K$)1&,1!2$'*)+,+,8!*&!1&.+)/!%).*&'1!5$'$!&,/:!

*#$! %&0'*#! (&1*! .&((&,! %).*&'9! ),-! *#$1$! 12$.+%+.)//:! .&,.$',$-! -&.*&')/!

1*0-$,*1!5#&!-+-!,&*!$,C&:!-&.*&')/!1*0-+$1!dST!gf7!!

E)(+/:!'$)1&,1!'$80/)'/:!%$)*0'$-!)1!.)01$!%&'!-+1.&,*+,0)*+&,Q!R[!2$'!.$,*!&%!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! ()+,*)+,$-! *#)*! *#$:! #)-! -+%%+.0/*+$1! %+,-+,8! )! 3)/),.$!

3$*5$$,!-&.*&')/!1*0-+$1!),-!%)(+/:!/+%$!),-!T!2$'!.$,*!2+,2&+,*$-!2)'$,*)/!

/$)@$!)1!)!'$)1&,!%&'!-'&22+,8!&0*7!I+1.&,*+,0)*+&,!&,!8'&0,-1!&%!-+1.'+(+,)6

*+&,!&'!#)')11($,*\!5)1!')'$!30*9!,$@$'*#$/$119!2'$1$,*!dY!gf7!!

"#$! ()C&'+*:! &%! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! 5#&! -+1.&,*+,0$-! *#$+'! 1*0-+$1! -+-! 1&!

3$%&'$!*#$:!#)-!.&($!(+-5):!+,!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!d\S!gf7!<&5$@$'9!&,$!+,!*$,!

-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!#)-!.&(2/$*$-!UW!2$'!.$,*!&'!(&'$!&%!*#$+'!$-0.)*+&,!5#$,!

*#$:! *$'(+,)*$-! *#$+'! 1*0-+$17! "#$! ,0(3$'! &%! 1*0-$,*1! 5#&! -+1.&,*+,0$-!

*#$+'!1*0-+$1!/)*$!+,!*#$+'!$-0.)*+&,!#)1!2'&3)3/:!3$$,!0,-$'$1*+()*$-!-0$!*&!

*#$!%).*!*#)*!1*0-$,*1!5#&!%+,+1#$-!*#$+'!-&.*&')/!1*0-+$1!5+*#!)!d/$11$'f!/+.$,6

*+)*$!-$8'$$!+,1*$)-!&%!)!-&.*&')/!-$8'$$!5$'$!,&*!+,./0-$-!+,!*#$!2&20/)*+&,7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

S!"#'!D2'-$%#![$%1&$+$/,*$)/!01*!(&)#$6$*%!-$&'1*!,/-!$/-$&'1*!-$%1&$+$/,*$)/@!#,&,%%+'/*!

,/-!&'(&$%,?%!&'?,*'-!*)!%'`@!*&,/%C'/-'&!$-'/*$*B!)&!'`(&'%%$)/@!'*#/$1$*B@!&'?$C$)/!)&!

)*#'&!6'?$'3@!-$%,6$?$*B@!%'`7,?!)&$'/*,*$)/@!,/-!,C'!

(18)

J>!

;22'&?+()*$/:! *#$! 1)($! )(&0,*! &%! ($,! ),-! 5&($,! -+1.&,*+,0$-! *#$+'!

-&.*&')/! 1*0-+$1! )*! )! /)*$! 1*)8$7! <&5$@$'9! &/-$'! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! ),-!

1*0-$,*1!5+*#+,!*#$!#0(),+*+$1!),-!,)*0')/!1.+$,.$1!)'$!&@$'6'$2'$1$,*$-7!!

Y#[%!)/!*#'!?,6)7&!+,&A'*!

N,%&'()*+&,!&,!*#+'-!.:./$!8')-0)*$1!+,!45$-$,!#)1!3$$,!'$*'+$@$-!2'+()'+/:!

%'&(!1*0-+$1!.&,-0.*$-!+,!SWW\7!"#$'$!5$'$!)22'&?+()*$/:!TR!WWW!-&.*&')/!

8')-0)*$1!+,!SWW\9![W!2$'!.$,*!&%!5#+.#!5$'$!($,!),-!\\!2$'!.$,*!5+*#!45$6 -+1#! 3).A8'&0,-17! "#$! ,0(3$'! &%! 2$&2/$! %'&(! ,&,645$-+1#! 3).A8'&0,-1!

5)19!*#019!#+8#$'!)(&,8!V#I1!dSY!gf!*#),!+,!*#$!45$-+1#!2&20/)*+&,!8$,$')/6 /:!dR\!g9!1&0'.$!4*)*+1*+.1!45$-$,f7!;/(&1*!#)/%!&%!*#$1$!V#I1!#)-!.&(2/$*$-!

*#$+'!-$8'$$1!5+*#+,!*#$!%+$/-1!&%!($-+.+,$9!,)*0')/!1.+$,.$1!),-!()*#$()*+.17!!

;(&,8! V#I1! )8$-! YW6[]9! )*! /$)1*! _W! 2$'!.$,*! 5$'$! $(2/&:$-7! "#+1! ,0(3$'!

5)1!#+8#$'!)(&,8!($,!),-!)(&,8!V#I1!%'&(!45$-+1#!3).A8'&0,-1!)1!5$//!

)1!)(&,8!V#I1!)1!.&(2)'$-!*&!/+.$,*+)*$1!),-!V#I1!8')-0)*$-!+,!&*#$'!.&0,6

*'+$17! "#$! @)'+)*+&,! &%! $(2/&:($,*! 3)1$-! &,! '$1$)'.#! 103C$.*! &1.+//)*$-!

3$*5$$,!U]!),-!_R!2$'!.$,*!%&'!(&1*7!N,!)!1*0-:!*#)*!+,./0-$-!$@$':&,$!5#&!

.&(2/$*$-!)!-&.*&')/!-$8'$$!)*!L0,-!M,+@$'1+*:!+,!SWWU!d<&/(1*'i(!SWRYf!

_\!2$'!.$,*!5$'$!$(2/&:$-!),-!&,/:!R!2$'!.$,*!'$2&'*$-!*&!3$!0,$(2/&:$-!+,!

I$.$(3$'!&%!SWRR!d[W!g!'$12&,1$!')*$f7!

;!/+**/$!/$11!*#),!)!*#+'-!&%!'$1$)'.#!8')-0)*$1!5&'A$-!+,!*#$!#+8#$'!$-0.)*+&,!

1$.*&'! ./&1$/:! %&//&5$-! 3:! #$)/*#! .)'$! )1! *#$! 1$.&,-! /)'8$1*! &..02)*+&,)/!

1$.*&'7! ^),:! 5$'$! )/1&! +,@&/@$-! +,! '$1$)'.#! ),-! $-0.)*+&,)/! $(2/&:($,*!

&0*1+-$!*#$!).)-$(:7!"#$!-+1*'+30*+&,!&%!8')-0)*$1!5+*#+,!-+%%$'$,*!&..02)6

*+&,1!@)'+$-!8'$)*/:!5+*#!-$8'$$!103C$.*7!N,!<&/(1*'i(H1!1*0-:!&%!)/0(,+!%'&(!

L0,-!M,+@$'1+*:9!dSWRYf!]_!2$'!.$,*!&%!*#$!)/0(,+!5&'A$-!5+*#+,!0,+@$'1+*+$1!

),-!0,+@$'1+*:!.&//$8$1!*#'$$!:$)'1!)%*$'!.&(2/$*+,8!*#$+'!-$8'$$17!!

N,!8$,$')/9!()/$!V#I1!'$.$+@$-!#+8#$'!1)/)'+$1!*#),!%$()/$!V#I1!),-!1)/)'+$1!

+,.'$)1$-! 5+*#! )8$7! V#I1! ,)*+@$! *&! 45$-$,! '$.$+@$-! #+8#$'! 1)/)'+$1! *#),!

8')-0)*$1!%'&(!,&,645$-+1#!3).A8'&0,-17!

7.88'*9#

N,! *#+1! +,*'&-0.*+&,! 5$! #)@$! -+1.011$-!-&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,H1! (),:! 20'2&1$1!

),-!%0,.*+&,1!),-!#&5!+*!():!#)@$!-+%%$'$,*!1+8,+%+.),.$!%&'!+,-+@+-0)/1!),-!

.&//$.*+@$1! 5+*#+,! ).)-$(+)7! "#$! 1*)*+1*+.)/! -)*)! 2'$1$,*$-! 1#&51! *#)*! *#$!

,0(3$'!&%!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!#)1!+,.'$)1$-!+,!*#$!/)1*!*5&!-$.)-$19!2)'*+.0/)'6

(19)

JJ!

/:!C01*!3$%&'$!*#$!*0',!&%!*#$!.$,*0':7!"#$!3)/),.$!3$*5$$,!($,!),-!5&($,!

+,! *#$! $,*+'$! -&.*&')/! 8'&02! #)1! +(2'&@$-7! "#$! ,0(3$'! &%! ,&,645$-+1#!

$,*'),*1! #)1! +,.'$)1$-! ),-! *#$! ,0(3$'! &%! 45$-$1! #)1! -$.'$)1$-7! "&*)/!

.&(2/$*+&,!*+($1!#)@$!-$.'$)1$-!),-!*#'&08#20*!#)1!+,.'$)1$-7!;/1&9!-+1.&,6

*+,0)*+&,!#)1!-$.'$)1$-!30*!5#$,!+*!&..0'1!*#$!(&1*!.&((&,!.)01$!+1!1&.+)/!

%).*&'1! &'! 2'&3/$(1! +,! *#$! -&.*&')/! 2'&8')(($1! *#$(1$/@$17! "#$! /)3&0'!

()'A$*! 3&*#! 5+*#+,! ),-! &0*1+-$! &%! ).)-$(+)! )22$)'1! %)@&0')3/$! %&'! V#I17!

V&11+3/$! '$)1&,1! %&'! *#$! -$.'$)1+,8! ,0(3$'! &%! 45$-+1#! 1*0-$,*1! $,*$'+,8!

-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)'$!:$*!0,A,&5,7!

! !

(20)

JN!

!

! !

(21)

JU!

[.4".Z0M!I[P40"Q.;!0D!Y.MQ49!

I&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +1! $,@$/&2$-! 3:! 1$@$')/! /):$'1! &%! 2&/+.:! 5#+.#9! +,! *0',9!

.&(2'+1$!),!)''):!&%!'$80/)*+&,19!80+-$/+,$1!),-!'$.&(($,-)*+&,1!1*+20/)*$-!

3:! )0*#&'+*+$19! +,1*+*0*+&,19! .&&2$')*+,8! 3&-+$1! ),-! +,*$'$1*! 8'&021! &,!

,)*+&,)/! )1! 5$//! )1! +,*$',)*+&,)/! )'$,)17! "#$1$! 2&/+.:! *$?*1! 8)+,! ($),+,8!

*#'&08#! 2'&.$11$1! 3:! 5#+.#! @)'+&01! ).*&'1! +,*$'2'$*9! *'),1/)*$9! '$+,*$'2'$*!

),-!*'),1%&'(!*#$(!*&!2'&2&1)/19!-+'$.*+&,1!&'!%')($5&'A1!%&'!*#$!).*+@+*+$1!

*#$:!)'$!2)'*!&%!dF)//!*?!#&K!SWRSf7!;1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!#+8#/:!+,*$8')*$-!

+,*&! (&1*! +,1*+*0*+&,1H! (+11+&,1! ),-! ).*+@+*+$19! 2&/+.+$1! %'&(! -+%%$'$,*! /$@$/1!

),-!)+($-!)*!-+%%$'$,*!).*+@+*+$1!5+//!&%*$,!.&,@$'8$!5+*#+,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

5#$'$!*#$:!():!#)@$!3&*#!0,+,*$,-$-!),-!0,-$1+')3/$!$%%$.*17!

`$,,+$! <)')/-11&,! dSWRWf! #+8#/+8#*1! #&5! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! #)1! 3$$,!

8&@$',$-!3:!*#$!1*)*$!*#'&08#!/$8+1/)*+&,9!)22'&2'+)*+&,!-+'$.*+&,19!'$%&'(1!

&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!),-!'$1$)'.#!3+//17!b&@$',),.$!)*!*#$!+,1*+*0*+&,)/!/$@$/!

+,@&/@$1! 80+-$/+,$1! ),-! '$.&(($,-)*+&,19! &%*$,! '$/)*$-! *&! >0$1*+&,1! &%!

)-(+11+&,!2'&.$-0'$19!$(2/&:($,*!*$'(19!%0,-+,89!.&0'1$1!),-!)11$11($,*9!

102$'@+1&'! *')+,+,8! ),-! 1*0-$,*1H! '+8#*1! *&! +,%&'()*+&,! ),-! '$2'$1$,*)*+&,!

5#$,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!-+1.011$-!),-!-$.+1+&,1!)'$!()-$7!

"#'&08#!*#$!2)'*+.+2)*+&,!&%!45$-+1#!)0*#&'+*+$19!0,+@$'1+*+$1!),-!&'8),+1)6

*+&,1! +,! @)'+&01! +,*$',)*+&,)/! .&//)3&')*+&,19! 2'+()'+/:! =0'&2$),9! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,! #)1! 3$.&($! (&'$! ./&1$/:! /+,A$-! *&! *#$! 8/&3)/+1)*+&,! &%! #+8#$'!

$-0.)*+&,! ),-! '$1$)'.#7! "#+1! (&@$($,*! +,@&/@$19! )(&,8! &*#$'! *#+,819! *#$!

-$@$/&2($,*!&%!1#)'$-!2&/+.+$1!5+*#+,!(),:!)'$)19!5#+.#!'$+,%&'.$1!)/'$)-:!

$1*)3/+1#$-! 2').*+.$1! +,! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! ),-! +(2$/1! ,$5! &,$1! 5#+/$!

/$)@+,8! &*#$'1! +,! *#$! 3).A8'&0,-7! F$/&59! 5$! 5+//! -$1.'+3$! *#$($1! ),-!

*$,-$,.+$1!)*!*#$!,)*+&,)/!/$@$/!),-!*#$,!8+@$!1&($!$?)(2/$1!%'&(!*#$!=0'&6 2$),! /$@$/! *#)*! %0'*#$'! $(2#)1+1$! *#$1$7! E+'1*9! #&5$@$'9! 5$! 5+//! -+1.011!

-&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! )1! )! j3&0,-)':! &3C$.*k! ),-! )/1&! 1&($9! +,! *#+1! .&,*$?*9!

$11$,*+)/! .#),8$1! *&! *#$! 45$-+1#! #+8#$'! $-0.)*+&,! /),-1.)2$! *#)*! %&'(! )!

3).A8'&0,-!%&'!1&($!(&'$!12$.+%+.!'$80/)*+&,1!'$/)*+,8!*&!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,7!

[)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!c!,!6)7/-,&B!)6H'1*!

I&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! .),! 3$! @+$5$-! )1! )! 2').*+.$! %&'($-! +,! *#$! +,*$'1$.*+&,!

3$*5$$,! *#$! *#'$$! ()C&'! (+11+&,1! &%! 0,+@$'1+*+$1Q! '$1$)'.#9! $-0.)*+&,! ),-!

(22)

J<!

&0*'$).#!d1$$!%+80'$!]f7!V$'#)21!+*!+1!2&11+3/$!*&!.&,1+-$'!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

)1!*#)*!5#+.#!b$&%%'$:!J7!F&5A$'!),-!401),!L7!4*)'!'$%$'!*&!)1! )!j3&0,-)':!

&3C$.*k7!

Q/>+5#)@!/1$*A?0!#)*!?:/0*!/1$*A?0!?:#?!1/?:!4+:#14?!0*-*)#&!A/''>+4?4*0!

/<! ;)#A?4A*! #+5! 0#?40<@! ?:*! 4+</)'#?4/+#&! )*=>4)*'*+?0! /<! *#A:! /<! ?:*'K!

Q/>+5#)@!/1$*A?0!#)*!?:>0!;&#0?4A!*+/>(:!?/!#5#;?!?/!&/A#&!+**50!#+5!A/+6 0?)#4+?0! /<! ?:*! 0*-*)#&! ;#)?4*0! *';&/@4+(! ?:*',! @*?! )/1>0?! *+/>(:! ?/!

'#4+?#4+!#!A/''/+!45*+?4?@!#A)/00!04?*0K!RQ/DC*)!8!7?#)!BIII,!;K!FIPS!

l+$5$-!)1!)!3&0,-)':!&3C$.*9!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!3&*#!.&#$'$,*!),-!(0/*+6

%).$*$-7! I+1.+2/+,)':! -+%%$'$,.$1! #)@$! 3$$,! ()-$! @+1+3/$9! %&'! +,1*),.$9! +,!

J#)'/$1!V$'.:!4,&5H1!T:*!TD/!U>&?>)*0!dR_[Rf!),-!+,!"&,:!F$.#$'H1!9A#5*'4A!

T)41*0!#+5!T*))4?/)4*0!dR_U_f7!<&5$@$'9!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!.),!3$!@+$5$-!)1!)!

3&0,-)':! &3C$.*! )/1&! 3$.)01$! +*! +1! 3&*#! 2)'*! &%! )1! 5$//! )1! *'),1.$,-1! *#$!

0,+@$'1+*+$1H! -+%%$'$,*! (+11+&,17! I&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! 2)'*)A$! +,! 3&*#! '$1$)'.#!

),-! $-0.)*+&,7! ;1! )! '$10/*! &%! 8/&3)/+1)*+&,! ),-! *#$! 8'&5+,8! +(2$*01! %&'!

'$1$)'.#!),-!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!*&!(&'$!-+'$.*/:!.&,*'+30*+,8!*&!*#$!8&&-!&%!

1&.+$*:9!(&'$!),-!(&'$!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!)'$!.)'':+,8!&0*!*#$+'!1*0-+$1!&0*6 1+-$! &%! *')-+*+&,)/! -$2)'*($,*1! ),-! 5+*#! 102$'@+1&'1! %'&(! -+%%$'$,*!

0,+@$'1+*+$17!!

"#$!0,+@$'1+*+$1H!*#'$$!(+11+&,1!)'$!(+''&'$-!+,!*#'$$!-+%%$'$,*!$(2#)1$1!&,!

-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,7!D@$'!*+($9!*#$1$!$(2#)1$1!#)@$!3$$,!$?2'$11$-!*&!@)':6 +,8!-$8'$$1!+,!2&/+.+$1!'$/)*$-!*&!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,7!!

! .4(>)*!VK!T:)**!*';:#0*0!4+!5/A?/)#&!*5>A#?4/+K!!

K$1$)'.#!

=-0.)*+&,!

! I&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,!

D0*'$).#!

(23)

Jb!

[)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!,%!&'%',&1#!

"#$!%+'1*!$(2#)1+1!+1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!'$1$)'.#!),-!*#$!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*!

)1!)!:&0,8!'$1$)'.#$'!$(3)'A+,8!&,!#+1!&'!#$'!'$1$)'.#!.)'$$'7!"#$!$(2#)1+1!

&,!'$1$)'.#!#)1!3$$,!1)/+$,*!1+,.$!*#$!%+'1*!'$80/)*+&,1!&,!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

5$'$!1*+20/)*$-!+,!(&-$',!0,+@$'1+*+$1!+,!*#$!(+-6,+,$*$$,*#!.$,*0':7!E'&(!)!

2&/+*+.)/! 2$'12$.*+@$9! *#$! 2'&?+(+*:! &%! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! 5+*#! '$1$)'.#! +1!

(),+%$1*$-! +,! *#$! -+1*'+30*+&,! &%! '$1&0'.$1! *&! 45$-+1#! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! 5#$'$!

'$1$)'.#!),-!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!%&'(!)!0,+%+$-!.)*$8&':7!!

M1+,8!;),*!=/G+,8)!dR__Wf!5$!.),!12$)A!&%!)!-')()!5#$'$!@)'+&01!).*&'1!)'$!

1*'088/+,8! %&'! 2&5$'! ),-! .&,*'&/! &%! '$1$)'.#Q! *#$! ).)-$(+.! &/+8)'.#:9! 1*)*$!

30'$)0.').:! ),-! ()'A$*! %&'.$1! +,! *#$! %&'(! &%! 301+,$11! ),-! .&(($'.$7! "#$!

).)-$(+.!&/+8)'.#:!.),!3$!/+,A$-!*&!*')-+*+&,)/!)0*&,&(&01!'$1$)'.#!$(),)*6 +,8! %'&(! .0'+&1+*:7! "#$! @)/0$! &%! *#$! '$1$)'.#! +1! -$*$'(+,$-! /)'8$/:! 3:! +*1!

.&,*'+30*+&,! *&! *#$! '$1$)'.#! %+$/-7! 4*)*$! 30'$)0.').:! .),! 3$! .&,,$.*$-! *&!

45$-$,H1!1$.*&')/!'$1$)'.#!),-!1031$>0$,*!.'&116-+1.+2/+,)':!'$1$)'.#!.&0,6 .+/1!),-!-+%%$'$,*!$?*')6-+1.+2/+,)':!),-!2&/+*+.)/!&3C$.*+@$17!"#$!()'A$*!%&'.$1!

.),! 3$! /+,A$-! *&! 203/+.! &0*'$).#! ),-! .&//)3&')*+&,! 5+*#! +,-01*':9! ),-! *&!

$?*')6-+1.+2/+,)':! &3C$.*+@$1! ),-! $.&,&(+.)/! -$@$/&2($,*! *#'&08#! +,,&@)6

*+&,7!"#$!*5&!/)**$'!5):1!&%!'$8)'-+,8!'$1$)'.#!.),!)/1&!3$!.&,,$.*$-!*&!1#+%*1!

+,! #&5! 2'&3/$(1! )'$! +-$,*+%+$-! ),-! 1*0-+$-! )1! 5$//! )1! #&5! A,&5/$-8$! +1!

2'&-0.$-! ),-! 12'$)-7! =/G+,8)! dR_U_f! -+1.011$1! )! .#),8$! +,! '$1$)'.#$'1H!

@+$51! &,! '$1$)'.#! )1! ),! $2+1*$(+.! -'+%*! *&5)'-1! 5#)*! 1&.+$*:9! +,-01*':! ),-!

.&(($'.$!'$8)'-!)1!'$/$@),*!'$1$)'.#!2'&3/$(17!!

N,! .&,*$?*1! 5#$'$! '$1$)'.#! 2&/+.+$1! )'$! %&'(0/)*$-! ),-! 2&/+*+.)/! -$.+1+&,1!

()-$9! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +1! .&((&,/:! *'$)*$-! )1! ),! +,*$8')*$-! )12$.*! &%!

'$1$)'.#7!;!1*'&,8!),-!&,$61+-$-!$(2#)1+1!&,!$?*')6-+1.+2/+,)':!&'!$.&,&(+6 .)/!&0*.&($1!%&'!'$1$)'.#!'+1A1!-+(+,+1#+,8!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!*&!)!*&&/!%&'!

10.#!&3C$.*+@$17!I&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,H1!%0,-)($,*)/!'&/$!%&'!'$8$,$')*+,8!),-!

-$@$/&2+,8!*#$!).)-$(:9!+*1!-+1.+2/+,$1!),-!*#$!#+8#$'!$-0.)*+&,!1:1*$(!():!

*#$,! 3$! &@$'6/&&A$-7! B#$,! %0,-+,8! )8$,.+$1! $?*$',)/! *&! 0,+@$'1+*+$1! %0,-!

/)'8$! +,*$',)*+&,)/! '$1$)'.#! 2'&C$.*19! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! 5+*#+,! *#$1$! )'$)1!

$?2),-19!)..&'-+,8!*&!*#$!2'+,.+2/$!j5#$'$!'$1$)'.#!8&$19!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!

%&//&51k7!

!

!

(24)

JV!

[)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!,%!'-71,*$)/!

"#$!1$.&,-!$(2#)1+1!#+8#/+8#*1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!$-0.)*+&,!),-!*#$!-&.6

*&')/! 1*0-$,*! )1! )! 1*0-$,*7! D,! )! %&'()/! ),-! 8$,$')/! /$@$/9! )..&'-+,8! *&!

45$-+1#!/$8+1/)*+&,9!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+1!%+'1*!&%!)//!$-0.)*+&,7!"#+1!5)1!'$+,6

%&'.$-! 3:! *#$! F&/&8,)! 2'&.$119! 5#+.#! +,! SWWT! +,.&'2&')*$-! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,! +,*&! *#$! =0'&2$),! %')($5&'A! %&'! >0)/+%+.)*+&,1! .)#'*D/)C! </)!

W>#&4<4A#?4/+0! 4+! ?:*! %>)/;*#+! H4(:*)! %5>A#?4/+! 9)*#! dcE6=<=;! SWWTf! ),-!

+,*&!*#$!=MH1!>0)/+%+.)*+&,!%')($5&'A!%&'!/+%$/&,8!/$)',+,8!%>)/;*#+!W>#&4<4A#6

?4/+0!.)#'*D/)C!d=cE!SWWUf7!"#$!/)**$'!-$1.'+3$1!*#$!.&(2$*$,.$!).#+$@$-!

*#'&08#!)!-&.*&')/!-$8'$$!)1!*#$!$+8#*#!),-!#+8#$1*!/$@$/!+,!*#$!$-0.)*+&,)/!

1:1*$(7!"#$!'&/$!),-!2&1+*+&,!&%!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!+,!*#$!$-0.)*+&,)/!1:1*$(!

)/1&!8+@$1!'+1$!*&!>0$1*+&,1!)3&0*!)-(+11+&,!),-!*#$!/$,8*#!&%!2'&8')(($17!N,!

'$/)*+&,!*&!)!3+//!2)11$-!+,!45$-+1#!2)'/+)($,*!+,!SWW[9!+*!5)1!2'+()'+/:!*#$!

'$/)*+&,1#+2!*&!*#$!()1*$'H1!/$@$/!),-!*#$!/$,8*#!&%!-&.*&')/!2'&8')(($1!*#)*!

5$'$!103C$.*!*&!-$3)*$7!"#$!3+//!$,*)+/$-!)!%&0'6:$)'!/&,8!-&.*&')/!2'&8')(($!

*#)*!.&0/-!3$!1*)'*$-!%&'()//:!)%*$'!&,$!:$)'!&%!)-@),.$-!d1$.&,-f!/$@$/!1*0-6 +$17!"#$!.&(2$*$,.$!/$@$/!02&,!.&(2/$*+&,9!#$,.$9!1#&0/-!3$!.&,1+-$'$-!*&!3$!

&,! )! 2)'! 5+*#! )! *#'$$6:$)'! /&,8! 2'&8')(($! %&//&5+,8! )! *5&6:$)'! ()1*$'H1!

-$8'$$U7!=@$,!*#&08#!(&'$!),-!(&'$!45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*1!#)@$!)!*5&6 :$)'! ()1*$'H1! -$8'$$! 5#$,! )-(+**$-! *&! -&.*&')/! 1*0-+$19! @$':! %$5! .#&&1$! )!

*#'$$6:$)'!V#I7!45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,9!+,!2').*+.$9!*#019!.&0/-!3$!1)+-!*&!

3$!2&1+*+&,$-!&,!)!#+8#$'!/$@$/!*#),!*#$!8$,$')/!=0'&2$),!%')($5&'A7!

B#$,! 45$-$,! )-)2*$-! +*1! $-0.)*+&,)/! /$8+1/)*+&,! *&! *#$! %')($5&'A! &%! *#$!

=0'&2$),!<+8#$'!=-0.)*+&,!;'$)!+,!SWW\9!>0)/+*:!-$1.'+2*&'1!+,!*#$!%&'(!&%!

+,*$,-$-! /$)',+,8! &0*.&($1! 5$'$! +,*'&-0.$-! +,! *#$! 45$-+1#! <+8#$'!

=-0.)*+&,!D'-+,),.$!%&'!)//!/$@$/1!&%!#+8#$'!$-0.)*+&,9!+,./0-+,8!*#$!-&.*&')/!

/$@$/7!N*!+1!,&*+.$)3/$!*#)*!1$@$')/!)12$.*1!&%!*#$!'$>0+'$($,*1!&,!3'&)-!),-!

.&(2/$?! .&(2$*$,.$! $?2'$11$-! &,! *#$! =0'&2$),! 2&/+.:! /$@$/! )'$! ,&*! *&! 3$!

%&0,-!+,!*#$!/$)',+,8!&0*.&($1!%&'(0/)*$-!%&'!*#$!45$-+1#!-&.*&')/!-$8'$$7!

=?)(2/$1!+,./0-$!*#$!.)2).+*:!%&'!*$).#+,8_9!.'&116-+1.+2/+,)':!.&//)3&')*+&,9!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

T!"#'!'-71,*$)/,?!%*&71*7&'!2$*#$/!*#'!I7&)(',/!]$C#'&!I-71,*$)/!0&',!Q%!U!d!N!d!U!B',&%!

3)&!*#'!6,1#'?)&@!+,%*'&!,/-!&'%',&1#!?'5'?!&'%('1*$5'?B!

R!./'!)3!*#'!$/*'/-'-!?',&/$/C!)7*1)+'%!3)&!*#'!-)1*)&,?!-'C&''!-)'%!$/1?7-'!*#'!

(#&,%$/C!e%7(()&*!*#'!?',&/$/C!)3!)*#'&%f!67*!$*!$%!1)++)/!*#,*!*#$%!)7*1)+'!$%!

,1#$'5'-!*#&)7C#!-'(,&*+'/*,?!-7*$'%!)&!*#&)7C#!%#)&*!1)7&%'%!)/!*',1#$/C!,/-!

?',&/$/C!$/!#$C#'&!'-71,*$)/!2#$1#!$/!%)+'!1,%'%!,&'!/)*!$/1?7-'-!,%!(,&*!)3!*#'!3)&+,?!

17&&$17?7+!!

(25)

JS!

+,,&@)*+&,9! $,*'$2'$,$0'1#+29! 2'&C$.*! (),)8$($,*! ),-! /$)-$'1#+27! "#$!

$-0.)*+&,)/! $(2#)1+1! +1! )/1&! @+1+3/$! *#'&08#! '$>0+'$($,*1! %&'! 3&*#! 8$,$')/!

),-!+,-+@+-0)/!1*0-:!1://)3+RW7!"&8$*#$'9!*#$1$!1://)3+!-$1.'+3$!*#$!+,-+@+-0)/!

1*0-$,*H1!$-0.)*+&,)/!2)*#!),-!'$80/)*$!#+1!&'!#$'!.&0'1$!5&'A!),-!-+11$'*)6

*+&,! )1! 5$//! )1! &*#$'! )12$.*1! &%! *#$! 1*0-$,*1H! 2'&8')(($7! D*#$'! -+'$.*+@$1!

'$80/)*$! *#$! $?*$,*! &%! -$2)'*($,*)/! -0*+$1! )//&5$-! 2)')//$/! *&! *#$! 1*0-$,*H1!

1*0-+$17!"#$!+(2&'*),.$!&%!*#$!1*0-$,*!-$@$/&2+,8!2$-)8&8+.)/!),-!)-(+,+16

*')*+@$! .&(2$*$,.$! )1! 5$//! )1! /$)-$'1#+2! >0)/+*+$1! +1! -$(&,1*')*$-! +,! *#$!

)22&+,*($,*!.'+*$'+)!%&'!1$,+&'!/$.*0'$'17!!

V&/+.+$1! &,! #+8#$'! /$@$/! &%*$,! $?2'$11! )! 5+//! *&! 1*'$,8*#$,! *#$! $-0.)*+&,)/!

$(2#)1+1! +,! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,7! N,*$',)*+&,)/! &'8),+1)*+&,1! ),-! )'$,)1! %&'!

-&.*&')/!1*0-$,*19!%&'!$?)(2/$!*#$!=M;!d%>)/;*#+!X+4-*)04?@!900/A4#?4/+f!&'!

*#$! =4M! d%>)/;*#+! 7?>5*+?0Y! X+4/+f9! #)@$! )/1&! $?2'$11$-! *#+1! 5+//7! "#+1!

*$,-$,.:!.),!)/1&!3$!&31$'@$-!&,!*#$!)-(+,+1*')*+@$!/$@$/1!%&'!+,*$',)*+&,)/!

.&//)3&')*+&,1! &,! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! 10.#! )1! =K;4^M462'&8')(($1! &'! +,!

'$/)*+&,!*&!*#$!-$@$/&2($,*!&%!C&+,*!-$8'$$17!;!,$$-!*&!.&(2/$($,*!103C$.*6 12$.+%+.!A,&5/$-8$!5+*#!(&'$!8$,$'+.!.&(2$*$,.+$1!)'+1$1!+,!*#$1$!.&,*$?*1!

d1$$! 4DM! SWW]QS\fRR7! "#$! $($'8$,.$! &%! (&'$! 1*'0.*0'$-! 1*0-:! .0''+.0/)! +,!

*#$!%&'(!&%!2'&8')(($1!),-!8')-0)*$!1.#&&/1!.),!)/1&!3$!@+$5$-!+,!*#+1!/+8#*7!!

"#$!%).*!*#)*!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!%&'()//:!+1!$-0.)*+&,!-&$1!,&*!-+1>0)/+%:!+*!)1!

)! 3&0,-)':! &3C$.*7! ;! *$//+,8! 1+8,! +1! *#)*! -&.*&')/! 1*0-$,*1! )'$! $?2$.*$-! *&!

).>0+'$!*#$!'$>0+'$-!.&(2$*$,.+$1!%+'1*!),-!%&'$(&1*!3:!.&,-0.*+,8!'$1$)'.#7!

;/1&9! %0,-+,8! %&'! -&.*&')/! $-0.)*+&,! +1! &%*$,! -+'$.*/:! /+,A$-! *&! 12$.+%+.!

'$1$)'.#!2'&C$.*1!),-!'$1$)'.#!$,@+'&,($,*17!!

[)1*)&,?!'-71,*$)/!,%!(76?$1!)7*&',1#!,/-!'/C,C'+'/*!!

"#$!*#+'-!$(2#)1+1!+1!-&.*&')/!$-0.)*+&,!)1!203/+.!&0*'$).#!),-!$,8)8$($,*9!

),-!*#$!1*0-$,*!)1!),!)8$,*!+,!*#$!+,*$').*+&,!3$*5$$,!-+%%$'$,*!1$.*&'17!"#+1!

$(2#)1+1! )/1&! -$1+8,)*$1! 2)'*+.+2)*+&,! +,! .&,*$?*1! 5#$'$! A,&5/$-8$! +1!

.&((0,+.)*$-! ),-! 12'$)-! *&! *#$! 203/+.7! E'&(! *#+1! 2$'12$.*+@$9! -&.*&')/!

$-0.)*+&,! )22$)'1! )1! ),! +,*$'61$.*&')/! 2#$,&($,&,! 5+*#! +*1! 3)1+1! +,!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

J>!0??!-)1*)&,?!(&)C&,++'%!,&'!)6?$C'-!*)!1)/%*&71*!C'/'&,?!%*7-B!%B??,6$=!0?%)@!,/!

$/-$5$-7,?!%*7-B!%B??,67%!%#)7?-!,?%)!6'!-'%$C/'-!3)&!'5'&B!%*7-'/*!

JJ!D2'-$%#!g)5'&/+'/*!.33$1$,?!Z'()&*%!WD.PX!$%!,!%'&$'%!$/!2#$1#!,!1)++$%%$)/!)3!$/a7$&B!

(&'%'/*%!$*%!(&)()%,?!*)!*#'!C)5'&/+'/*!

References

Related documents

When the students have ubiquitous access to digital tools, they also have ubiquitous possibilities to take control over their learning processes (Bergström &amp; Mårell-Olsson,

Har arbetstagaren varit frånvarande från arbetet av orsak, som omförmäles i 4 § andra stycket, skall vid beräkning av semesterlönens storlek hänsyn tagas, beträffande frånvaro

Det är viktigt att ta reda på behovet och de förväntningar och mål som studenten har, både på utbild- ningsplatsen och handledaren, för att hitta rätt nivå för

Sammanfattningsvis visar studien att användningen av lärplattor i förskolan är en pågående process där pedagogernas intresse för lärplattan som digitalt verktyg och åsikt

Den svenska biogasproduktionen sker nästan undantagslöst i totalomblandade tankreaktorer (CSTR, continuous stirred tank reactors), medan biogasproduktion genom användande

Under våren 2014 skriver jag mitt examensarbete och syftet med detta arbete är att belysa variationerna i hur lärare inom grundskolan, grundsärskolan och inriktningen

Surprisingly, in contrast to charge transport in undoped P3HT, we find that the molecular weight of the polymer does not strongly in fluence the electrical conductivity, which

mental rlume meter and enolose herewith erection and operating instructions which have been prepared cover-.. ing this type of