• No results found

Interaction Infrastructure: a Holistic Approach to Support Co-Modality for Freight

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Interaction Infrastructure: a Holistic Approach to Support Co-Modality for Freight"

Copied!
200
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)In this thesis I have illustrated how information is essential for the management of transport chains. I have explored the notion of transparency as well as its importance for transport chains. The conclusion drawn is that transparency does not mean that every player should know everything at all times. This is not possible from the point of view of competition neither needed from a point of view of quality and efficiency of the transport chains. Instead transparency should be viewed as knowledge accessible to the players in the transport chain. Thereby enabling controllability of the common task, focus of actions on a common goal and the understanding of each player’s area of responsibility. The production of this knowledge depends on all players being aware of and respecting their role. I argue that it is not enough with cooperation between the traditional transport chain partners to reach transparency. Instead interaction with a broader set of players is required. I have chosen to cluster the extended group of players into the following three domains Transport management, Infrastructure management and Institutional management. The interaction between the domains needs to be facilitated, i.e. formalised and structured. For this I introduce the concept of Interaction Infrastructure. It helps develop a common understanding of mutual benefits of transparency, leading to a willingness to share information. It helps negotiate the different points of view and vested interest of the. players involved and leads to the commitments needed for the implementation of information sharing across the domains. Interaction Infrastructure is a conceptual framework that supports the definition of the appropriate processes needed for achieving interaction in a particular context. Promoting Interaction Infrastructure is a task that requires strong leadership. Society must dare to redefine its role in the area of freight transports and to extend its involvement by starting processes that will lead to a better interaction between and within the domains and in turn, a higher overall efficiency and a reduced environmental footprint of freight transport. A policy should comprise responsibility for infrastructure in the conventional sense, but also include a responsibility for the processes performed on the infrastructure. Reaching transparency in the context that I describe will require trust and for this a change of mind set is essential including a move: • From viewing information from a silo or ver tical perspective to a horizontal perspective. • From a “we and them view” to an “us view”. • From viewing the players as “providers or users” to “providers and users”. I have positioned myself and my research within a transdisciplinary practice and have experienced that awareness of situated and context sensitive knowledge as well as distributed knowledge production are good starting points for addressing logistic issues characterised by social and organisational complexity.. interaction infrastructure. ABSTRACT. Inger Gustafsson. ISSN 1653-2090 ISBN 978-91-7295-127-3. 2008:01. 2008:01. interaction infrastructure a holistic approach to support co-modality for freight. Inger Gustafsson. Blekinge Institute of Technology Doctoral Dissertation Series No. 2008:01 School of Technoculture, Humanities and Planning.

(2)

(3) Interaction Infrastructure A Holistic Approach to Support Co-Modality for Freight. Inger Gustafsson.

(4)

(5) Blekinge Institute of Technology Doctoral Dissertation Series No 2008:01 ISSN 1653-2090 ISBN 978-91-7295-127-3. Interaction Infrastructure A Holistic Approach to Support Co-Modality for Freight. Inger Gustafsson. Division of Technoscience Studies School of Technoculture, Humanities and Planning Blekinge Institute of Technology SWEDEN.

(6) © 2008 Inger Gustafsson Division of Technoscience Studies School of Technoculture, Humanities and Planning Publisher: Blekinge Institute of Technology Printed by Printfabriken, Karlskrona, Sweden 2008 ISBN 978-91-7295-127-3.

(7) )NTRODUCTIONAND!CKNOWLEDGEMENT &ċDJFOUGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNTBSFDPSOFSTUPOFTPGPVSFDPOPNZBOEBQSFSFRVJTJUFGPS FDPOPNJDEFWFMPQNFOUCVUGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUJTBMTPDPOOFDUFEUPBOVNCFSPGOFHBUJWF JNQBDUT/PUPOMZUIFTFWFSFUISFBUPGHMPCBMXBSNJOH CVUBMTPJTTVFTMJLFDPOHFTUJPO  BDDFTTJCJMJUZ TBGFUZBOETFDVSJUZIBWFUPCFBDLOPXMFEHFEBOEBEESFTTFE8FBSFDIBMMFOHFE UPđOETPMVUJPOTUIBUSFTQPOEUPUIFEFNBOEGPSUSBOTQPSUTBOEBUUIFTBNFUJNFBMMPXB TVTUBJOBCMFEFWFMPQNFOU$PNPEBMJUZ JFUIFFċDJFOUVTFPGEJĈFSFOUNPEFTJOUIFJSPXO BOEJODPNCJOBUJPOJTTVHHFTUFEBTBXBZGPSXBSECZUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPO ăJTEPDUPSJBMUIFTJTJTUIFSFTVMUPGSFTFBSDIDBSSJFEPVUJOEJĈFSFOUTFUUJOHT.ZFOUSBODF JOUPUIFSFTFBSDIBSFBm*OGPSNBUJPOBOEDPPQFSBUJPOJO'SFJHIU5SBOTQPSU4ZTUFNTXBT UISPVHIQBSUJDJQBUJOHJOUIF*/'0-0(QSPKFDU BUI'SBNFXPSLSFTFBSDIQSPHSBNNF PGUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPOUIBUTUBSUFEJO 8SJUJOHUIJTUIFTJTIBTJODMVEFEFMFNFOUTPGSFĔFDUJPO(PJOHCBDLUPUIFWJTJPOTFYQSFTTFE JO*/'0-0( *DBOTFFUIBUUIFQSPCMFNPGTIBSJOHJOGPSNBUJPOXJUIJOGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSU JTTUJMMBOJTTVF)PXFWFS UPNZVOEFSTUBOEJOHNBKPSDIBOHFTDIBSBDUFSJTFUIFEFWFMPQNFOU UIFMBTUEFDBEFăFSFBSFOFXQPTTJCJMJUJFTGPSTJNQMJđFEDPNNVOJDBUJPOUISPVHIUIF FNFSHFODF PG UIF *OUFSOFU BOE SFMBUFE DPNNVOJDBUJPO QMBUGPSNT BOE UIFSF JT BMTP B NBUVSFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFDPNQMFYJUZPGGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUJOHFOFSBMBOEDPNPEBMJUZ JOQBSUJDVMBSăJTJTNBOJGFTUFEJOBNPSFPQFOWJFXPODPPQFSBUJPOBOEJOGPSNBUJPO TIBSJOHBNPOHUIFQMBZFSTJOGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSU *U JT NZ CFMJFG UIBU XF IBWF B XJOEPX PG PQQPSUVOJUZ GPS DSFBUJOH NPSF FċDJFOU BOE TVTUBJOBCMF GSFJHIU USBOTQPSU TZTUFNT UISPVHI JNQSPWFE JOUFSBDUJPO BOE JOGPSNBUJPO TIBSJOH4VDIEFWFMPQNFOUXJMMSFRVJSFGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUUPCFHJWFOBIJHIFSQSJPSJUZPO UIFQPMJDZBHFOEB *IPQFUIBUUIPTFJOWPMWFEJOUIFQSBDUJDBMXPSLPGCVJMEJOHBOENBOBHJOHDPNQMFYGSFJHIU USBOTQPSUTZTUFNTXJMMSFDPHOJTFUIFJSTJUVBUJPOJONZBOBMZTJTPGUIFTUBUFPGUIFBSUBOE UIBUNZBSHVNFOUTGPSJODSFBTFEUSBOTQBSFODZBOEUSVTUDBOCFFOEPSTFECZDPNNFSDJBM BTXFMMBTQVCMJDTUBLFIPMEFST.ZDPOUSJCVUJPOUPBGVSUIFSEFWFMPQNFOUJTUPTVHHFTUUIBU NVDIDPVMECFBDIJFWFEUISPVHIUIFNVUVBMSFDPHOJUJPOPGUIFOFFEGPSBGPSNBMTUSVDUVSF GBDJMJUBUJOHUIFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOUIPTFJOWPMWFEJONBLJOHUSBOTQPSUNPSFFċDJFOUBOE SFBMJTJOHDPNPEBMJUZ *XPVMEMJLFUPFYQSFTTNZHSBUJUVEFUPNZTVQFSWJTPST1SPGFTTPS-FOB5SPKFS 1SPGFTTPS 1FUFS7ÅSCSBOEBOE-BST,ÅMMTUSÕN8JUIUIFJSEJĈFSFOUCBDLHSPVOETBOEDPNQFUFODFT PVSNFFUJOHTIBWFCFFOWFSZGSVJUGVMBOEUIFJSTVQQPSUIBTHVJEFENFUISPVHIUIFXSJUJOH QSPDFTT .

(8) *BNWFSZHSBUFGVMUPUIFđOBODJOHCPEJFTUIBUIBWFTVQQPSUFENZSFTFBSDIJOEJĈFSFOU GPSNBUTJODMVEJOHUIF4XFEJTI3PBE"ENJOJTUSBUJPO UIF4XFEJTI3BJM"ENJOJTUSBUJPO  UIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPO #.5(SPVQ-UE #MFLJOHF*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZBOEUIF 3FHJPOPG#MFLJOHF *IBWFCFFOWFSZMVDLZUPXPSLXJUIDPNQFUFOUBOEJOTQJSJOHDPMMFBHVFTUISPVHIPVUUIF ZFBSTBOE*BNDPOWJODFEUIBUUIJTJTUIFTJOHMFNPTUJNQPSUBOUFOBCMJOHGBDUPSGPSNZ SFTFBSDI*OUIFQSPDFTTPGđOBMJTJOHNZXPSL *IBWFSFDFJWFENBOZWBMVBCMFDPNNFOUT BOE*XPVMEMJLFUPUIBOLZPVBMMGPSUBLJOHUJNFUPDPNNFOUBOEUPHFUGBNJMJBSXJUIUIF NBUFSJBM4QFDJBMUIBOLTUPNZDPMMFBHVF%FUMFW'JTDIFSGPSIJTDSJUJDJTNBOEDPOTUSVDUJWF DPNNFOUT 'JOBMMZ *IBWFFYQFSJFODFEHSFBUTVQQPSUBOEJOUFSFTUJONZXSJUJOHGSPNGBNJMZBOEGSJFOET *BQQSFDJBUFUIJTWFSZNVDI CPUIUIFNFOUBMBOEQSBDUJDBMTVQQPSUZPVIBWFHJWFO 'BHFSTBOOB %FDFNCFS *OHFS(VTUBGTTPO. .

(9) 4OTHE2EADER. ăJTEPDUPSBMUIFTJTDPOTJTUTPGTFWFOQBSUT1BSU"UISPVHI1BSU( XIFSF1BSU(JODMVEFT UIFBSUJDMFTPGUIFUIFTJT%VSJOHUIFXSJUJOH UIFUIFTJTIBTEFWFMPQFEJOUPBIZCSJECFUXFFO BNPOPHSBQIBOEBDPMMFDUJPOPGBSUJDMFT8JUINPSFUJNFHJWFO *XPVMEIBWFJOUFHSBUFE UIFBSUJDMFTJOUPUIFNBJOUFYUUPUVSOUIFUIFTJTJOUPBNPOPHSBQIBOEBDIJFWFEBNPSF VTFSGSJFOEMZUFYU3FBEJOHHVJEBODFBOEBEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFEJĈFSFOUQBSUTBOEUIFJS DIBQUFSTBSFHJWFOCFMPX 1BSU"QSPWJEFTUIFUIFPSFUJDBMCBDLHSPVOEGPSUIFSFTFBSDI 'PSUIFSFBEFSXIPXBOUT UPHFUBRVJDLPWFSWJFXPGUIFUIFTJT*SFDPNNFOESFBEJOH$IBQUFSPG1BSU" XIJDI TVNNBSJTFTUIFNBJODPOUSJCVUJPOGSPNNZSFTFBSDIăFSFBEFSXIPJTJOUFSFTUFEJONZ NFUIPEPMPHJDBMBQQSPBDIDBOSFBE$IBQUFS 1BSU" XIFSFBTUIFQPMJDZPSJFOUFESFBEFS NJHIUđOEDIBQUFS  1BSU" PGJOUFSFTU 1BSU#BOE1BSU$BSFUIFNBJODPOUSJCVUJPOTGSPNNZFNQJSJDBMNBUFSJBM1BSU#EFTDSJCFT BOVNCFSPGQSPKFDUTUIBU*IBWFQBSUJDJQBUFEJOăFđOEJOHTGSPNUIFTFQSPKFDUTGPSN UIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHGPSNZOPUJPOPGUSBOTQBSFODZTFF$IBQUFS  1BSU# GPSEFĖOJUJPOT PGUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPO*O1BSU$BOVNCFSPGJOJUJBUJWFTBSFQSFTFOUFEUIBUIBWF DPOUSJCVUFEUPNZSFTFBSDI1BSU#BOE1BSU$DBOCFVTFEBTBSFGFSFODFPOEJĈFSFOUBTQFDUT UIBUNJHIUCFPGJOUFSFTUUPBTQFDJđDSFBEFS *O1BSU%BOE1BSU&UIFđOEJOHTQSFTFOUFEJOUIFFBSMJFSQBSUTBTXFMMBTJOUIFBSUJDMFTBSF BOBMZTFEBOEDPODMVTJPOTBSFESBXO*OUIFTFQBSUTNZNBJODPOUSJCVUJPOTBSFEFTDSJCFE  JO TQFDJGJD NZ SFRVFTU GPS JODSFBTFE JOUFSBDUJPO BOE NZ EFGJOJUJPO PG *OUFSBDUJPO *OĚBTUSVDUVSF 1BSU'DPOTUJUVUFTUIFMJTUPGSFGFSFODFT 'JOBMMZ UIFUISFFBSUJDMFTUIBU*IBWFJODMVEFEUPUIFUIFTJTDBOCFGPVOEJO1BSU( 1BSU"4FUUJOHUIF4DFO. ăFđSTUDIBQUFSi.BJO$POUSJCVUJPOTuJTBLFZDIBQUFSJOXIJDINZOPUJPOTBSFEFđOFE BOE NZ NBJO đOEJOHT BSF QSFTFOUFE ăJT DIBQUFS TFSWFT BT B TVNNBSZ PG UIF NBJO DPOUSJCVUJPOT ăFTFDPOEDIBQUFSi.FUIPEPMPHJDBM$POTJEFSBUJPOTuQSFTFOUTNZNFUIPEPMPHJDBMTUBOEJOH QPJOUBOEQPTJUJPOJOUSBOTEJDJQMJOBSZQSBDUJDFTăFDIBQUFSBMTPJODMVEFTBOPWFSWJFXPG NFUIPEPMPHJDBMBQQSPBDIFTJOUIFSFTFBSDIPGMPHJTUJDBOE5FDIOPTDJFODF4UVEJFTBTXFMM BTBEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFSFTFBSDINFUIPET*IBWFBQQMJFE ăFUIJSEDIBQUFSi'SBNFPG3FGFSFODFuQSPWJEFTBOPWFSWJFXPGPOHPJOHSFTFBSDIJOđFMET DPOOFDUJOHUPNZSFTFBSDIBOEBDPNNFOUPOIPXUIFTFđOEJOHTQSPWJEFBGVOEBNFOU GPSNZSFTFBSDI .

(10) *OUIFDIBQUFSi%BSFUP4IBSFu *IJHIMJHIUBMUFSOBUJWFWJFXTPOTIBSJOHBOEQSPEVDJOH JOGPSNBUJPOBOEVTFUIFUIFPSZPGJOOPWBUJPOUPJMMVTUSBUFEJTUSJCVUFEDPPQFSBUJPOCFUXFFO QVCMJDBOEQSJWBUFQBSUOFST 1BSU " JT đOBMJTFE CZ UIF DIBQUFS i4OBQTIPUT GSPN 1PMJDZ 'SBNFXPSLTu XIFSF B TIPSU PWFSWJFXJTQSPWJEFEPOUIF&VSPQFBOBOE64QPMJDZGSBNFXPSLJOSFHBSEPGJOUFSNPEBM USBOTQPSUTBOEJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH 1BSU#5SBOTQBSFODZBOE*OUFSBDUJPO. *O1BSU# *BNVTJOHNZQSPKFDUFYQFSJFODFTUPJMMVTUSBUFBOEEJTDVTTUIFJNQPSUBODFPG JOGPSNBUJPOJOUSBOTQPSUDIBJOT*OUPUBMđWFQSPKFDUTBSFEFTDSJCFE*BMTPEFđOFUIFOPUJPOT PGUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPO $IBQUFSi*OGPSNBUJPOJOUSBOTQPSUDIBJOTBOEJOGPSNBUJPONPEFMTuQSPWJEFTBEJTDVTTJPO POJOGPSNBUJPOJOUSBOTQPSUDIBJOT*BMTPQSFTFOUUISFFNPEFMTUIBU*BNVTJOHJONZ SFTFBSDIUPJMMVTUSBUFUIFUBTLTBUTUBLF $IBQUFSUPDIBQUFSQSFTFOUUIFđOEJOHTGSPNUIFQSPKFDUT*/'0-0( %% #BOJOGP  ,PNCJ5*'BOE1($4ăFDIBQUFSTQSFTFOUUIFPCKFDUJWFPGUIFQSPKFDUT BOBOBMZTJTBOE UIFNBJOđOEJOHT"DPNQBSBUJWFBOBMZTJTJTDBSSJFEPVUJOUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBQUFSBTXFMM BTJO1BSU%BOE1BSU&1MFBTFOPUFUIBUUIFQSPKFDUT#BOJOGP ,PNCJ5*'BOE1($4BSF BMTPTFSWJOHBTFNQJSJDBMNBUFSJBMGPSUIFQBQFSTJO1BSU( *ODIBQUFSi%JTDVTTJPOPO5SBOTQBSFODZBOE*OUFSBDUJPOuUIFđOEJOHTGSPNUIFQSPKFDUT BSFEJTDVTTFEBOEVTFEUPEFđOFUIFOPUJPOTPGUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPO 1BSU$-FBSOJOHGSPN"QQSPBDIFTUPUVSO5SBOTQPSU1PMJDZJOUP"DUJPOT. *O1BSU$ *QSFTFOUBOVNCFSPGJOJUJBUJWFTUIBUBMMTIBSFUIFPCKFDUJWFPGUVSOJOHUSBOTQPSU QPMJDZJOUPBDUJPOT1BSU$JTNBJOMZEFTDSJQUJWFBOEJODMVEFTOPBOBMZTJTăJTJTJOTUFBE DBSSJFEPVUJO1BSU%BOE1BSU& $IBQUFSQSPWJEFTBOJOUSPEVDUJPOUP1BSU$ $IBQUFSUPDIBQUFSEFTDSJCFUIFGPVSJOJUJBUJWFT răF&'.QSPHSBNJOJUJBUJWFCZUIF64%FQBSUNFOUGPS5SBOTQPSUUPTVQQPSUUIF JOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFXJUIJOUIFTVQQMZDIBJO r 3*4  BO JOJUJBUJWF CZ UIF &VSPQFBO $PNNJTTJPO GPS JNQSPWJOH UIFJOGPSNBUJPO FYDIBOHFGPSJOMBOEXBUFSXBZT r 'SFJHIU 5SBOTQPSU 5FMFNBUJDT "SDIJUFDUVSF  B OBUJPOBM TZTUFN BSDIJUFDUVSF DPNNJTTJPOFECZUIF'JOOJTI.JOJTUSZPG5SBOTQPSU r'3&*()58*4& BSFTFBSDIQSPKFDUXJUIJOUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPOTUISFTFBSDI GSBNFXPSL QSPHSBN XJUI UIF BJN UP GBDJMJUBUF DPNNVOJDBUJPO JO JOUFSNPEBM USBOTQPSUDIBJOT. .

(11) 1BSU%*OUFSBDUJPO*OGSBTUSVDUVSF. 1BSU%JTEFEJDBUFEUPUIFEFđOJUJPOPG*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFBOEJUTDPOUFOU *ODIBQUFS i%JTDVTTJOH*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFu *JMMVTUSBUFUIBUUIFUISFFEPNBJOT* IBWFEFđOFEBSFJOUFHSBUFEQBSUTPGGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSU*VTFđOEJOHTGSPNUIFQSPKFDUTBOE JOJUJBUJWFTUPQSPWJEFFYBNQMFTPGMBDLPGUSVTUCFUXFFOUIFEPNBJOT *QSPQPTF*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFBTBIPMJTUJDBQQSPBDIXIJDIHSBEVBMMZUSBOTMBUFTUIF IJHIMFWFMPCKFDUJWFTPGQPMJDZJOUPCVTJOFTTSFMBUFE PSHBOJTBUJPOBMBOEUFDIOJDBMEFUBJMT *BOBMZTFUIFđOEJOHTGSPN1($4 ,PNCJ5*' &'.BOE3*4UPFYFNQMJGZUIFOPUJPOPG *OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFBOEQPJOUPVUUIBUEJĈFSFOUTFHNFOUGPSJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH BSFBEESFTTFE *O$IBQUFS i%FđOJOH*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFu *GPDVTPONBLJOHNZEFđOJUJPOPG *OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFNPSFUBOHJCMF*EFTDSJCFUIBU*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFDBOIBWF EJĈFSFOUMFWFMTPGEFUBJMEFQFOEJOHPODPOUFYUBOEBNCJUJPOTGPSJOUFSBDUJPO*GVSUIFS TVHHFTUUIFDPOUFOUPGBO*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFBOENBQUIFDPOUFOUUPUIF1($4 QSPKFDU 1BSU&"8JOEPXPG0QQPUVOJUZ. *G 1BSU % GPDVTFE PO BOBMZTJOH BOE EFđOJOH XIBU *OUFSBDUJPO *OGSBTUSVDUVSFJT 1BSU& DPOUJOVFTXJUIBSHVNFOUTPOXIZJUJTOFFEFEBOEUIFSFRVJSFNFOUTGPSJUTSFBMJTBUJPO *ODIBQUFSBTIPSUJOUSPEVDUJPOUP1BSU&JTQSPWJEFE *ODIBQUFSi"$BMMGPS4USPOH-FBEFSTIJQu *TUSFTTUIFOFFEGPSTUSPOHMFBEFSTIJQGPS QSPNPUJOH*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFBOEQSPWJEFBOVNCFSPGFYBNQMFTGSPNNZSFTFBSDI* DPODMVEFCZEFđOJOHUISFFEJĈFSFOUBQQSPBDIFTGPSQSPNPUJOH*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSF *ODIBQUFSiăF3PMFPG1PMJDZu *BSHVFUIBUJOGPSNBUJPOJTTVFTOFFEUPHFUBTIJHI TUBUVTJOBQPMJDZBTUIFJTTVFPGJOGSBTUSVDUVSFJOJUTDMBTTJDBMNFBOJOH*GVSUIFSEJTDVTTUIF JNQPSUBODFPGQPMJDZUPTVQQPSU*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSF *ODIBQUFSi"8JOEPXPG0QQPSUVOJUZu*TVNNBSJTFUIFđOEJOHTGSPN1BSU&BOEBSHVF UIBUBOVNCFSPGDVSSFOUESJWJOHGPSDFTPQFOBXJOEPXPGPQQPSUVOJUZUPXBSETJODSFBTFE JOUFSBDUJPOBOEJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH 1BSU'3FGFSFODFT. *OQBSU'UIFSFGFSFODFTGSPN1BSU"UP1BSU&BSFMJTUFE 1BSU(4DJFOUJđD1BQFST. 1BSU(JODMVEFTUIFGPMMPXJOHUISFFTDJFOUJđDQBQFST r*OUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFO5SBOTQPSU *OGSBTUSVDUVSFBOE*OTUJUVUJPOBM.BOBHFNFOU " $BTF4UVEZPOB1PSU$PNNVOJUZ4ZTUFN(VTUBGTTPO*   1VCMJTIFEJO 5SBOTQPSUBUJPO3FTFBSDI3FDPSE  533 QQ .

(12) r *OUFSBDUJPO *OGSBTUSVDUVSF GPS *NQSPWFE *OGPSNBUJPO  &YQFSJFODFT GSPN BO *OJUJBUJWF $BSSJFE PVU CZ UIF 4XFEJTI 5SBċD "ENJOJTUSBUJPOT (VTUBGTTPO *   1SPDFFEJOHTGSPN53" (PUIFOCVSH+VOF r1FSDFJWFECFOFđUTPGJNQSPWFEJOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFmBDBTFTUVEZPOSBJMBOE NVMUJNPEBMUSBOTQPSU5ÕSORVJTU+ BOE(VTUBGTTPO*   1VCMJTIFEJO&MTFWJFST TQFDJBMFEJUJPO FE #FLBSJT & 8IFSFUIFPSZBOEQSBDUJDFNFFU*OOPWBUJPOTBOE DBTFTUVEJFTJOBTTFTTJOHUIFFDPOPNJDJNQBDUTPG*54BOEUFMFNBUJDT JOUIFCPPL TFSJFT3FTFBSDIJO5SBOTQPSUBUJPO&DPOPNJDT. .

(13) 4ABLEOF#ONTENT.  

(14)        !! " !# ! " $%&% !!'% !''!( ! )%%'#!!!$(#* + %'!%*! ,*'!'*'!! , %'!% ,. ,)%##! , ''*  %'  % ,  #% ,/  '*% #% %%!! ' .*%!! . .0 ." 01( '! ." 2- .3 $ . "'#%'!*#%(1 ./ ' %% ./ 4 ", 0! "" 5  6 0   7. 3 #%'!#%% 3  )787  3" +00  /5. )7 / -9% ) +"  : %%**%##   +/ 0!'!* ! /, '!* /, ! /". .

(15)  .

(16)               ! "# #$%&&$#'#($&'  )*# +'&#*#, %##(+*# +'&#*#, %##*#.&',#*# +'&#*#,/ 0 "&1&#2&3,%#''34   5 #$%&,(#"#'&,%## 6 6 

(17) 1   7 8      98,,,$ #&& #& +&,# 6 $'#,+#&2%&:&#,#+("&3#, 76 #& +&,#  ;#'("+3$ #& +&,#%$%<': =

(18) = &  -8#+$ #& +&,#  1 81   7   ) 7&""+$#&#,%(  6 77%#"#+"3 ) 712+((3 ))     5 

(19)     56. .

(20) 0ART! 3ETTINGTHE3CENE. .

(21) .

(22) -AIN#ONTRIBUTIONS 8JUINZSFTFBSDI*IBWFJMMVTUSBUFEUIBUJOGPSNBUJPOJTFTTFOUJBMGPSUIFNBOBHFNFOUPG GSFJHIU USBOTQPSU TZTUFNT ăF OPUJPO PG USBOTQBSFODZ IBT CFFO FYQMPSFE BT XFMM BT JUT JNQPSUBODFGPSUSBOTQPSUDIBJOTăFDPODMVTJPOESBXOJTUIBUUSBOTQBSFODZEPFTOPUNFBO UIBUFWFSZQMBZFSTIPVMEIBWFBDDFTTUPBMMJOGPSNBUJPOSFMBUFEUPUIFGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSU TZTUFNBUBMMUJNFTăJTJTOPUQPTTJCMFGSPNUIFQPJOUPGWJFXPGDPNQFUJUJPOOFJUIFS OFFEFEGSPNBQPJOUPGWJFXPGRVBMJUZBOEFċDJFODZPGUIFUSBOTQPSUDIBJOT*OTUFBE USBOTQBSFODZTIPVMECFWJFXFEBTBDDFTTJCJMJUZPGSFMFWBOULOPXMFEHFUPUIFQMBZFSTJOUIF GSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNCBTFEPOBXFMMEFđOFETIBSJOHPGTFMFDUFEJOGPSNBUJPOăFSFCZ FOBCMJOHUIFDPOUSPMMBCJMJUZPGUIFDPNNPOUBTLUIFGPDVTJOHPGBDUJPOTPOBDPNNPO HPBMBOEUIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGQMBZFS{TBSFBTPGSFTQPOTJCJMJUZăFQSPEVDUJPOPGUIJT LOPXMFEHFEFQFOETPOBMMQMBZFSTCFJOHBXBSFPGBOESFTQFDUJOHUIFJSSPMF ăFđOEJOHTJOEJDBUFUIBUFYQFSUJTFJOUIFGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNJTEJTUSJCVUFEBNPOHJUT QMBZFST XIPQPTTFTTTJUVBUFELOPXMFEHFBOEIBWFUIFJSPXOJOUFSOBMBHFOEB5SVTU NVUVBM CFOFđUT JODPSQPSBUJPOPGTJUVBUFELOPXMFEHFBOESFTQFDUPGBMMQMBZFSTCVTJOFTTDPOUFYUT BSFLFZGBDUPSTGPSBDIJFWJOHTPDJBMMZSPCVTUTPMVUJPOTGPSUSBOTQBSFODZ ăFSFBSFJOEJDBUJPOTPGBDIBOHFPGNJOETFUXJUISFHBSEUPJOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHF*UJT CFJOHBQQSPBDIFEXJUIMFTTSFTQFDUBOEXJUINPSFQSBHNBUJTNUIBOCFGPSFăFSFTPVSDF JOUFOTJWF JNQMFNFOUBUJPO PG &%*'"$5  JT CFJOH JODSFBTJOHMZ SFQMBDFE CZ UIF NPSF BDDFTTJCMF9.- NFTTBHFT"UUJUVEFTSFHBSEJOHUIFVTFPGUIF*OUFSOFUGPSJOGPSNBUJPO FYDIBOHFIBWFCFDPNFNPSFQPTJUJWF*OBEEJUJPO JOQFPQMFTQSJWBUFMJGF UIFJNQPSUBODF  &%*'"$5 JT BO &%* TUBOEBSE &%* TUBOET GPS &MFDUSPOJD %BUB *OUFSDIBOHF BOE JT EFđOFE BT. iFMFDUSPOJDUSBOTGFSGSPNDPNQVUFSUPDPNQVUFSPGDPNNFSDJBMPSBENJOJTUSBUJWFUSBOTBDUJPOTVTJOH BOBHSFFETUBOEBSEUPTUSVDUVSFUIFUSBOTBDUJPOPSNFTTBHFEBUBu 6/&%*'"$5  &%*'"$5 JTDPNQMJDBUFEBOEBMUIPVHIUIFNFTTBHFTBSFEFđOFEUIFSFJTTUJMMNVDIUPBHSFFVQPO+ÛSHFO8FIOFSU POFPGUIF&%*'"$5WPPEPPNBTUFSTFYQMBJOFEUIFSJDIOFTTPGUIFNFTTBHFTXJUIUIFGPMMPXJOH FYBNQMFJNBHJOFIBWJOHBUPPMSJDIFOPVHIUPPSEFSBOVDMFBSQMBOUBOEZPVXBOUUPVTFJUUPPSEFS UPPUICSVTIFT JUXJMMSFRVJSFBIJHIMFWFMPGTJNQMJđDBUJPOTXIJDIZPVIBWFUPBHSFFPOXJUIZPVS CVTJOFTTQBSUOFST (VTUBGTTPO  &YUFOTJCMF.BSLVQ-BOHVBHF. .

(23) PGUIF*OUFSOFUIBTJODSFBTFEBOEVTFSTIBWFTUBSUFEUPQBSUJDJQBUFBOEQSPEVDFDPOUFOU ăFSFTVMUTPGNZSFTFBSDIQPJOUUPPCTUBDMFTPOUIFXBZUPNPSFUSBOTQBSFODZ4PNFPG UIFPCTUBDMFTBSFPGBUFDIOJDBMOBUVSFBOEXJMMEJTBQQFBSBTUIFUFDIOPMPHJDBMEFWFMPQNFOU DPOUJOVFTBOEUIFBWBJMBCMFUFDIOPMPHZJTBDDFQUFEBOEJNQMFNFOUFE0UIFSPCTUBDMFT TVDI BTUSVTUCFUXFFOUIFQBSUOFSTJOUIFGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNBOESFDPHOJUJPOPGNVUVBM CFOFđUT NVTUTUJMMCFTPMWFE*OGPSNBUJPOIBTQPUFOUJBMMZBIJHIDPNNFSDJBMWBMVFGPSUIF QMBZFSTJOBUSBOTQPSUDIBJO5SBEJUJPOBMMZ USBOTQPSUTFSWJDFQSPWJEFSTDPOTJEFSUIFNTFMWFT FYDMVTJWF PXOFST PG USBOTQPSUSFMBUFE JOGPSNBUJPO BOE EP OPU FBTJMZ TFF UIF CFOFđU PG TIBSJOHJOGPSNBUJPOPSDPPQFSBUJOHXJUIPUIFSTUPJNQSPWFUIFRVBMJUZPGJOGPSNBUJPO 5PTPNFQMBZFSTUIFMBDLPGJOGPSNBUJPOJTFWFOUIFCVTJOFTTJEFBBOEUIFWFSZCBTJTPG UIFJSFYJTUFODF 5SBOTQBSFODZJTBQSFSFRVJTJUFGPSTFDVSJUZ JFJOGPSNBUJPOPOUIFPSJHJOBOEUIFIBOEMJOH PGUIFDPOTJHONFOUTJTSFRVJSFEGPSBVEJUJOH)PXFWFS USBOTQBSFODZBDDFTTFECZTPNFPOF OPU BVUIPSJTFE DBO CF EBOHFSPVT 0CWJPVTMZ  UIFSF BSF DPNQMFY SFMBUJPOTIJQT CFUXFFO USBOTQBSFODZ TFDVSJUZBOEDPNQFUJUJPOXIJDIOFFEUPCFBDLOPXMFEHFE *O BO FBSMZ TUBHF PG NZ SFTFBSDI * XBT MPPLJOH JOUP UIF JOUFSBDUJPO CFUXFFO USBOTQPSU NBOBHFNFOUBOEJOGSBTUSVDUVSFNBOBHFNFOUXJUIJOUIFSBJMTFDUPSăFVOEFSTUBOEJOH PGUIFDMPTFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOCPUIđFMETXBTBLFZđOEJOHUIBUJOGPSNFENZGVSUIFS SFTFBSDI*UJMMVTUSBUFEIPXJNQPSUBOUJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFJOGSBTUSVDUVSFPQFSBUPSJTGPS UIFUSBOTQPSUNBOBHFNFOU QSPWJEJOHWBMVBCMFJOGPSNBUJPOGPSQMBOOJOH JOGPSNBUJPOPO TUBUVTBOEEJTUVSCBODFTBTXFMMBTDPOUSJCVUJOHUPUIFSFEVDUJPOPGUIFDPOTFRVFODFTPG EJTUVSCBODFT "OPUIFSQSPKFDUUIBUIBTJOĔVFODFEUIFEJSFDUJPOPGNZSFTFBSDIJTUIFQSPKFDU,PNCJ5*' ăF QSPKFDU XBT JOJUJBUFE CZ UIF 4XFEJTI HPWFSONFOU BOE DBSSJFE PVU CZ UIF USBċD BENJOJTUSBUJPOTGPSSPBE SBJM NBSJUJNFBOEBJSUSBOTQPSUăFPCKFDUJWFPGUIFQSPKFDUXBT UPTVQQPSUJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUUISPVHIFMFDUSPOJDJOGPSNBUJPOGSPNUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOT #ZQBSUJDJQBUJOHJO,PNCJ5*'*MFBSOFEUIBUJTTVFTSFMBUFEUPDPPQFSBUJPOCPUICFUXFFO UIFEJĈFSFOUUSBċDBENJOJTUSBUJPOTBOECFUXFFOUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOTBOEUIFUSBOTQPSU NBSLFUBSFCZOPNFBOTUSJWJBMăFSPMFPGUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOTBTXFMMBTXIBUUPQSPWJEF BOEUIFDPOEJUJPOTGPSQSPWJEJOHJUXFSFDPOUFOUJPVTJTTVFT BMUIPVHIUIFSFXBTBHFOFSBM PQJOJPOBNPOHUIFBENJOJTUSBUJPOTUIBUCFUUFSJOGPSNBUJPOUPUIFJSDVTUPNFSTDPVMECF VTFGVMăFđOEJOHTXFSFJNQPSUBOUGPSNZDPODMVTJPOUIBUDPPQFSBUJPOCFUXFFOQVCMJDBOE QSJWBUFQBSUOFSTDBOCSJOHWBMVFUPUIFĚFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFN #BTFEPOUIFSFTVMUTSFHBSEJOHUSBOTQBSFODZBOEUIFJNQPSUBODFPGJOGPSNBUJPOJOUSBOTQPSU DIBJOTBOEJOTQJSFECZUIFđOEJOHTGSPN,PNCJ5*'*BSHVFUIBUJUJTOPUFOPVHIXJUI 4FF8FC  ăJTXBTUIF#BO*OGPQSPKFDUEFTDSJCFEJO1BSU#BOEJOUIFQBQFSi1FSDFJWFECFOFđUTPGJNQSPWFE. JOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFmBDBTFTUVEZPOSBJMBOENVMUJNPEBMUSBOTQPSUu JO1BSU(. ,PNCJ5*'JTEFTDSJCFEJO1BSU#BOEJOUIFQBQFSi*OUFSBDUJPO*OGSBTUSVDUVSFGPS*NQSPWFE*OGPSNBUJPO. &YQFSJFODFTGSPNBO*OJUJBUJWF$BSSJFEPVUCZUIF4XFEJTI5SBċD"ENJOJTUSBUJPOTuăFQBQFSDBO CFGPVOEJO1BSU(. .

(24) BUUSBDUJWFOFTTPG&'.XPVMECFUIFGVODUJPOBMJUZBTJOHMFTVCNJTTJPOPGEBUBGPS SFHVMBUPSZSFRVJSFNFOUTBTEFNPOTUSBUFEJO1($4 r"DDSFEJUBUJPOBOEUSVTUCVJMEJOH BTEFNPOTUSBUFECZUIF4XFEJTIDVTUPNTXJUI UIF 4UBJSXBZ QSPHSBNNF XIFSF USVTUFE DMJFOUT BSF HJWFO BDDFTT UP TJNQMJđFE SPVUJOFT " GVSUIFS m BOE VSHFOU  BSHVNFOU GPS JNQSPWFE USBOTQBSFODZ BOE JOUFSBDUJPO JT UIF PWFSSJEJOHJTTVFPGHMPCBMXBSNJOH*UJTOPUBOPQUJPOUPJHOPSFUIFPWFSBMMEFNBOEGPS SFEVDJOH$0FNJTTJPOTIFODFBNBKPSSFTQPOTJCJMJUZJTQMBDFEPOGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNT EVFUPUIFJSMBSHFBOEJODSFBTJOHTIBSFPGUIFDBSCPOFNJTTJPOT *ODSFBTFE FċDJFODZ PG GSFJHIU USBOTQPSU TZTUFNT JT BMTP OFDFTTBSZ UP đHIU DPOHFTUJPO PO PVS JOGSBTUSVDUVSF BOE UP NFFU TBGFUZ BOE TFDVSJUZ SFRVJSFNFOUT " QPMJDZ TIPVME DPNQSJTFSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPSJOGSBTUSVDUVSFJOUIFDPOWFOUJPOBMTFOTF CVUBMTPJODMVEFB SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ GPS UIF QSPDFTTFT QFSGPSNFE PO UIF JOGSBTUSVDUVSF 4PDJFUZ NVTU EBSF UP FYUFOEJUTJOWPMWFNFOUCZTUBSUJOHQSPDFTTFTUIBUXJMMMFBEUPBCFUUFSJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFO UIFEPNBJOTBOEJOUVSO BIJHIFSPWFSBMMFċDJFODZBOEBSFEVDFEFOWJSPONFOUBMGPPUQSJOU PGGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUăFJTTVFPGUSBOTQBSFODZOFFETUPCFJODMVEFEJOUPUIFQPMJDZBHFOEB  CPUIPOBSFHJPOBM OBUJPOBMBOEJOUFSOBUJPOBMMFWFMCFDBVTFJUJTBOPCKFDUJWFXIJDIMFBET UPJNQSPWFEUSBOTQPSUFċDJFODZ * IBWF DPNQBSFE QPMJDZ BQQSPBDIFT CFUXFFO &VSPQF BOE UIF 64 BOE EFNPOTUSBUFE TJNJMBSJUJFTJOQPMJDZCVUBMTPEJĈFSFOUBQQSPBDIFTUPXBSETTPMVUJPOT*SFDPNNFOETIBSJOH PGFYQFSJFODFTCFUXFFOUIFDPOUJOFOUT BOEBTSFDPHOJTFECPUIJO64BOE&VSPQF UIF GSFJHIUJOEVTUSZJTHMPCBMBOETPTIPVMECFUIFIBSNPOJTFEJOGPSNBUJPO *QSPQPTFBDMPTFSJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOUIFEJĈFSFOUEPNBJOT CBTFEPONVUVBMSFTQFDU BOEDPODFSOGPSUIFTJUVBUJPOPGUIFPUIFSQMBZFST DPNCJOFEXJUIBOVOEFSTUBOEJOHPG UIFSPMFUIFPXOPSHBOJTBUJPOJTQFSGPSNJOHJOUIJTDPOUFYUăJTJTDIBMMFOHJOHTJODFJUJT NJYJOHQSJWBUFBOEQVCMJDQMBZFSTBOEJTTVFT*UJTNZCFMJFGUIBUBOVNCFSPGESJWJOHGPSDFT PQFOBXJOEPXPGPQQPSUVOJUZUPXBSETJNQSPWFEJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH'JSTUMZUIFSFJTBO JODSFBTFEBXBSFOFTTPGUIFQSPCMFNTSFMBUFEUPGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUTXIJDIXJMMQSPWJEFUIF QPMJDZNBLFSXJUIBTUSPOHFSQMBUGPSNUPBDUGSPNBOEBOJODSFBTFEBDDFQUBODFGSPNUIF USBOTQPSUJOEVTUSZUPXBSETTUSPOHFSQPMJDZJOWPMWFNFOU4FDPOEMZ UISPVHIUIFPOHPJOH EFWFMPQNFOUSFMBUFEUPDPNNVOJDBUJPO UFDIOPMPHZJTMFTTPGBOPCTUBDMFăJSEMZ UIFSF JTBOPOHPJOHDIBOHFPGNJOETFUUPXBSETWJFXJOHJOGPSNBUJPOBTTPNFUIJOHUIBUJTOPU QSJNBSJMZFYDMVTJWFGPSPOFTPXOQVSQPTFCVUDBOCFNBEFBWBJMBCMFBOECFOFđUBXJEFS HSPVQPGQMBZFST'PVSUIMZ UIFSFJTBUSFOEPGBOJODSFBTJOHCMVSSJOHPGUIFCPVOEBSJFT CFUXFFOQVCMJDBOEQSJWBUFUBTLT XIJDIJTBNBUFSJBMCBTJTGPSJODSFBTFEJOUFSBDUJPO. 1PSUPG(PUIFOCVSH1PSU$PNNVOJUZ4ZTUFN1($4JTEFTDSJCFEJODIBQUFSBOEJOUIFBSUJDMF. i*OUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFO5SBOTQPSU *OGSBTUSVDUVSFBOE*OTUJUVUJPOBM.BOBHFNFOU "DBTF4UVEZPOB 1PSU$PNNVOJUZ4ZTUFNuUIBUDBOCFGPVOEJO1BSU( ăF4UBJSXBZQSPHSBNNFJTEFTDSJCFEJODIBQUFS. .

(25) 8JUINZSFTFBSDI*IBWFDPOUSJCVUFEUP răFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBEFFQFSVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFDPODFQUPGUSBOTQBSFODZ răFEFWFMPQNFOUPGBOVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGXIBUJOUFSBDUJPOJT r"EFđOJUJPOPGUIFDPODFQUPG*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSF r&YBNQMFTPOXIBUBO*OUFSBDUJPO*OĚBTUSVDUVSFDBODPOTJTUPG *IBWFBMTPDPOUSJCVUFEUPUIFNFUIPEPMPHJDBMEFWFMPQNFOUPGUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSZLOPXMFEHF QSPEVDUJPO*IBWFQPTJUJPOFENZTFMGBOENZSFTFBSDIXJUIJOBUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSZQSBDUJDF* IBWFDIPTFOUPQMBDFMPHJTUJDSFMBUFEJTTVFTJOUIFBDBEFNJDđFMEPG5FDIOPTDJFODF4UVEJFT BUUIF'BDVMUZPG5FDIOPMPHZăJTBQQSPBDIJODMVEFEBSJTLPGCFDPNJOHBTUSBOHFSJO CPUIBDBEFNJDđFMET*OTUFBEJUQSPWFEUPQSPWJEFNFXJUIBOBMUFSOBUJWFPQQPSUVOJUZ GPSLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPOăFBXBSFOFTTPGTJUVBUFEBOEDPOUFYUTFOTJUJWFLOPXMFEHF BTXFMMBTEJTUSJCVUFELOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPOUIBUBSFDPSOFSTUPOFTJONZFQJTUFNPMPHJDBM QMBUGPSNXJUIJO5FDIOPTDJFODF4UVEJFTBSFHPPETUBSUJOHQPJOUTGPSBEESFTTJOHMPHJTUJD JTTVFTDIBSBDUFSJTFECZTPDJBMBOEPSHBOJTBUJPOBMDPNQMFYJUZ .Z BDUJWJUJFT BSF SPPUFE JO QSBYJT UISPVHI NZ CBDLHSPVOE BT DPOTVMUBOU BT XFMM BT JO BDBEFNJBUISPVHINZBDUJWJUJFTBTB1I%TUVEFOU*XBOUUPWJFXUIFLOPXMFEHFUIBU* QSPEVDFBTSPCVTUJOUIFTFOTFPG/PXPUOZFUBM  BOE*IBWFJODMVEFEUIFMPDBM LOPXMFEHFPGUIFEJĈFSFOUQMBZFSTJOUIFEPNBJOTXIFOEFđOJOHUIFDPODFQUJOUFSBDUJPO JOGSBTUSVDUVSF "GVSUIFSBTQFDUPGUSBOTEJDJQMJOBSJUZJTUIBUUIFSFTFBSDIGPDVTJTOPUXJUIJOPOFPGUIF EFđOFEEPNBJOTPGUSBOTQPSUNBOBHFNFOU JOGSBTUSVDUVSFNBOBHFNFOUBOEJOTUJUVUJPOBM NBOBHFNFOU CVU JT TJUVBUFE JO UIF CPSEFSMBOE CFUXFFO UIFN XIFSF NZ *OUFSBDUJPO *OĚBTUSVDUVSFJTQPTJUJPOFE. .

(26) -ETHODOLOGICALCONSIDERATIONS ăFđOEJOHTBOESFTVMUTQSFTFOUFEJOUIJTUIFTJTIBWFCFFOBDIJFWFEUISPVHIJOUFHSBUFE SFTFBSDIBOEDPOTVMUBODZBDUJWJUJFTDBSSJFEPVUCFUXFFOBOEăFXPSLIBT JODMVEFEBSFBTTVDIBTUIFSFPSHBOJTBUJPOPGUSBOTQPSUQSPDFTTFTBOEUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPG JOGPSNBUJPOBOEDPPQFSBUJPOTUSBUFHJFTCVUBMTPUIFJNQMFNFOUBUJPOPGBSPBEVTFSDIBSHJOH TZTUFNGPSIFBWZHPPETWFIJDMFTăFXPSLIBTDPODFOUSBUFEPOGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSU BOEUIF NBJOGPDVTUISPVHIPVUUIFEJĈFSFOUSFTFBSDIBOEDPOTVMUBODZBDUJWJUJFTJTJOGPSNBUJPOJO UIFĚFJHIUUSBOTQPSUBUJPOEPNBJO ăF NBJO PCKFDUJWF PG UIJT DIBQUFS JT UP QSPWJEF BO PWFSWJFX POCPUI UIF UIFPSFUJDBM GSBNFXPSLVTFEJONZBOBMZUJDBMXPSLBTXFMMBTNZVTFPGFNQJSJDBMNFUIPET*TUBSUUIF DIBQUFSXJUIBOPWFSWJFXPGUIFSFTFBSDIXJUIJOUIFBSFBPGMPHJTUJDTXIFSFQPTJUJWJTNJT UIFEPNJOBOUFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMWJFX*BMTPTIPXUIBUUIJTWJFXJTDIBMMFOHFECZBOVNCFS PGSFTFBSDIFST.ZFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMQMBUGPSNJTXJUIJOUFDIOPTDJFODFTUVEJFTBOETPNFPG JUTGVOEBNFOUBMBTTVNQUJPOTJTQSFTFOUFE"EJTDVTTJPOGPMMPXTPOEJĈFSFOUWJFXPGUIF iSFBMJUZuBOEUIFSPMFPGUIFSFTFBSDIFSBOESFTFBSDIăFDIBQUFSBMTPJODMVEFTBEJTDVTTJPO PO NZ QPTJUJPO JO USBOTEJTJQMJOBSZ QSBDUJDFT BT XFMM BT B QSFTFOUBUJPOPOUIFFNQJSJDBM NFUIPETUIBU*IBWFVTFEUISPVHIPVUUIFSFTFBSDI. 2ESEARCHINTHEAREAOFLOGISTICS .VDISFTFBSDIIBTCFFOVOEFSUBLFOJOUIFBSFBPGTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOUBOEMPHJTUJDT EVSJOHUIFMBTUTFWFSBMEFDBEFT"DDPSEJOHUP(VCJFUBM  UIFSFTFBSDIJOMPHJTUJDT BOE4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUJOUIF/PSEJDDPVOUSJFTFYQFSJFODFEBTJHOJđDBOUCPPN "U5',*OTUJUVUFGPS5SBOTQPSU3FTFBSDImB4XFEJTISFTFBSDIJOTUJUVUJPOPXOFECZUIF4XFEJTI. USBOTQPSU JOEVTUSZ  TFF XXXUGLTF GPS B DPNQBOZ EFTDSJQUJPO *O 0DUPCFS  UIF )BNCVSH EJWJTJPO PG 5', XBT TPME UP #.5 #SJUJTI .BSJUJNF 5FDIOPMPHZ  TFF XXXCNUUTDPN GPS B DPNQBOZEFTDSJQUJPO4JODF.BZ*BNBEEJUJPOBMMZFOSPMMFEBTB1I%TUVEFOUBUUIFEJWJTJPOPG 5FDIOPTDJFODF4UVEJFTBU#MFLJOHF*OTUJUVUFPG5FDIOPMPHZ TFFXXXCUITFULTUFLOPWFUOTGGPSBO JOUSPEVDUJPOUP5FDIOPTDJFODFTUVEJFT. .

(27) EVSJOHUIFTăFBVUIPSTJEFOUJGZSFTFBSDIFOWJSPONFOUTBOEUIFTFTQVCMJTIFE CFUXFFOBOE "SMCKÕSOBOE)BMMPETPO  TUSFTTUIBUSFTFBSDIFSTJOMPHJTUJDTIBWFEJĈFSFOUBDBEFNJD CBDLHSPVOETTVDIBTCVTJOFTTNBOBHFNFOU FOHJOFFSJOH PSHBOJTBUJPOBOEUSBOTQPSUBOE UIFSFGPSFNJHIUMPPLBUMPHJTUJDTGSPNEJĈFSFOUBOHMFTMFBEJOHUPEJĈFSFOUFQJTUFNPMPHJDBM QFSDFQUJPOTPGUIFDPOUFYUBOEJOUVSO UIFSFTFBSDIQSPCMFNăFZBSHVFUIBUUIFCPVOEBSJFT PGUIFMPHJTUJDTEJTDJQMJOFBSFIBSEUPEFđOFBOENBZBDUVBMMZCFGSBHNFOUFEăFZTVHHFTU UIBUUIFDPOUFOUPGMPHJTUJDTLOPXMFEHFTIPVMECFEJWJEFEJOUPBiIBSEDPSFuXIJDIDPOTJTUT PGBDPNNPOTUVEZiPGUIFPCKFDUuBOEBiQSPUFDUJPOCFMUuUIBUSFĔFDUTUIFIFUFSPHFOFJUZ PGDPODFQUTVTFEUPFYQMBJOBOEVOEFSTUBOEUIFIBSEDPSFăFVOJUPGBOBMZTJTSFHBSEJOH UIFIBSEDPSFJTFTTFOUJBMMZUIFĔPX PGNBUFSJBM JOGPSNBUJPOBOETFSWJDFT XIFSFBT GPS FYBNQMF NPEFSO JOGPSNBUJPO UFDIOPMPHZ UP TPMWF MPHJTUJDT QSPCMFNT JT B QBSU PG UIF QSPUFDUJPOCFMU #POUFLPOJOHFUBM  SFWJFXSFTFBSDIDBSSJFEPVUXJUIJOUIFđFMEPG*OUFSNPEBM ĚFJHIUUSBOTQPSUăFZDPODMVEFUIBUUIFSFJTNVDIJTPMBUFESFTFBSDIBOETNBMMSFTFBSDI DPNNVOJUJFTGPDVTJOHPOTQFDJđDBTQFDUTPGJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUăFZDMBJNUIBUUPEBZ OP BVUIPSJUBUJWFQVCMJDBUJPOTFYJTUBOEUIBUUIFSFJTOPUFWFOBDPNNPOMZBDDFQUFEEFđOJUJPO PGJOUFSNPEBMGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUăFBVUIPSTEJTUJOHVJTIFJHIUSFTFBSDIDBUFHPSJFT POFPG XIJDIJTNVMUJBDUPSDIBJONBOBHFNFOUBOEDPOUSPM'PSUIJTBSFBBOVNCFSPGRVFTUJPOT BSFIJHIMJHIUFE JODMVEJOH*TUIFPQUJNVNPGBUSBOTQPSUDIBJOBMTPUIFPQUJNVNGPSUIF JOEJWJEVBMBDUPSTJOUIFDIBJO )PXDBODPTUBOECFOFđUTPGDIBOHFTCFSFEJTUSJCVUFEXIFO UIJTEPFTOPUUBLFQMBDFBVUPNBUJDBMMZWJBNBSLFUNFDIBOJTNT 8IBUBSFUIFDPOTFRVFODFT GPSJOEJWJEVBMPSHBOJTBUJPOTXIFOUIFZIBWFUPHJWFVQTPNFBVUPOPNZGPSUIFTBLFPG DIBJOPCKFDUJWFT  3VTTFM BOE )PBH   BSHVF UIBU TPDJBM BOE PSHBOJTBUJPOBM DPNQMFYJUZ JT BO BSFB PG JODSFBTJOHJNQPSUBODFJOTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOU CVUPOFUIBU UPEBUF IBTSFDFJWFE NJOJNBMDPWFSBHFJOUIFUPQKPVSOBMT 3VTTFMBOE)PBH  ăFZFTQFDJBMMZQPJOU PVUUIFMPXSFTFBSDIBUUFOUJPOMPHJTUJDTBOETVQQMZDIBJOTDIPMBSTIBWFGPSTPDJBMBTQFDUT PG*5JNQMFNFOUBUJPOT. ăFZSFWJFXFEQVCMJDBUJPOT TDJFOUJđDKPVSOBMT EJTTFSUBUJPOT CPPLTBOEQSPDFFEJOHT. QVCMJDBUJPOTJODMVEFEBEFđOJUJPOCVUPOMZUISFFVTFEUIFEFđOJUJPOCZ&$.5mUIF&VSPQFBO. $POGFSFODF PG .JOJTUFST PG 5SBOTQPSU NPWFNFOU PG HPPET JO POFBOE UIF TBNF MPBEJOH VOJU PS WFIJDMFUIBUVTFTVDDFTTJWFMZTFWFSBMNPEFTPGUSBOTQPSUXJUIPVUIBOEMJOHPGUIFHPPETUIFNTFMWFTJO DIBOHJOHNPEFT ăFGPMMPXJOH+PVSOBMTXFSFSFWJFXFEJOBUJNFQFSJPECFUXFFOUP+PVSOBMPG#VTJOFTT -PHJTUJDT  5SBOTQPSUBUJPO +PVSOBM  *OUFSOBUJPOBM +PVSOBM PG 1IZTJDBM %JTUSJCVUJPO  -PHJTUJDT .BOBHFNFOUBOE*OUFSOBUJPOBM+PVSOBMPG-PHJTUJDT.BOBHFNFOU. .

(28) 0OSITIVISM

(29) ADOMINATINGBUTCRITICISEDEPISTEMOLOGICALAPPROACH WITHINLOGISTIC "ĕFSSFWJFXJOHQVCMJTIFESFTFBSDIBSUJDMFT .FOU[FSBOE,BIO  DPODMVEFUIBUUIF EPNJOBUJOHFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMBQQSPBDIXJUIJOMPHJTUJDJTQPTJUJWJTNăFBVUIPSTEFđOF QPTJUJWJTNBTi1PTJUJWJTNIBTUIFHPBMUPFYQMBJOBOEQSFEJDUSFBMJUZ XIFSFSFBMJUZJTDPOTJEFSFE UPCFPCKFDUJWF UBOHJCMF BOEĚBHNFOUBCMF1FPQMFBSFDPOTJEFSFEUPCFEFUFSNJOJTUJDBOE SFBDUJWF3FTFBSDIĖOEJOHTJOUIFQPTJUJWJTUUSBEJUJPOBSFDPOTJEFSFEWBMVFĚFF UJNFĚFF BOE DPOUFYUJOEFQFOEFOU XJUIUIFHFOFSBMBHSFFNFOUUIBUDBVTBMSFMBUJPOTIJQTDBOCFEJTDPĂFSFE 1PTJUJWJTUSFTFBSDIFSTDPOTJEFSUIFNTFMĂFTTFQBSBUFĚPNUIFSFTFBSDITFUUJOHBOEBUBQSJWJMFHFE QPJOUPGPCTFSWBUJPOu 5IF EPNJOBOU SPMF PG UIF QPTJUJWJTUJD BQQSPBDI BOE JUT VTF PG NBJOMZ RVBOUJUBUJWF SFTFBSDINFUIPETIBWFCFFODIBMMFOHFECZBOVNCFSPGMPHJTUJDSFTFBSDIFST.BOHBOFU BM  QPJOUPVUUIBUUIFEJTDJQMJOFPGMPHJTUJDTDBOCFFOSJDIFECZUIFBQQMJDBUJPOPG NPSF RVBMJUBUJWF NFUIPEPMPHJFT ăF BVUIPST VSHF MPHJTUJDT SFTFBSDIFST UP UIJOL BCPVU UIFQBSBEJHNUISPVHIXIJDIUIFZWJFXUIFXPSMEBOEUPFYQMPSFUIFVTFPGBMUFSOBUJWF NFUIPEPMPHJFT ăFZ BMTP EJTDVTT USJBOHVMBUJPO  JF VTJOH RVBOUJUBUJWF BOE RVBMJUBUJWF NFUIPET BOEDMBJNTUIBUJUJODSFBTJOHMZQSPWJEFTNVMUJEJNFOTJPOBMJOTJHIUTJOUPNBOZ NBOBHFNFOUSFTFBSDIQSPCMFNT.BOHBOFUBMDJUF/ÅTMVOE  XIPTUSFTTFTUIBUUP EFWFMPQBOEBEWBODFMPHJTUJDSFTFBSDIUIFVTFPGCPUIRVBOUJUBUJWFBOERVBMJUBUJWFNFUIPET  JTSFRVJSFE/ÅTMVOEBSHVFTUIBUMPHJTUJDQSPCMFNTPĕFOBSFJMMTUSVDUVSFEBOEOFFEUPCF UBDLMFEJOUIFBCTFODFPGBđSNEFđOJUJPOPGUIFQSPCMFN0OFPGUIFRVBMJUBUJWFNFUIPET IFSFDPNNFOETJTBDUJPOSFTFBSDI"DDPSEJOHUP/Å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ÅTMVOE  GVSUIFSVSHFTVTUPRVFTUJPOUIFEPNJOBODFPGUIFQPTJUJWJTUJDBQQSPBDIBOE RVBOUJUBUJWFNFUIPET QSJNBSJMZTVSWFZT)FFWFOBTLTIPXVTFGVMTVDIBOBQQSPBDIJTUP BEWBODFBOBDBEFNJDEJTDJQMJOFXIFOFWFSZPOFDPOEVDUTTJNJMBSUZQFTPGSFTFBSDI HVJEFECZ MFBEJOHBDBEFNJDTDIPJDFPGQBSBEJHN)FBOTXFSTIJTRVFTUJPOCZTBZJOHUIBUUIFEJTDJQMJOF NPTUMJLFMZXJMMOPUFWPMWFBOEUIFSFTFBSDINBZOPUCFVTFGVMUPUIFQSBDUJUJPOFS (BNNFMHBBSE  GPMMPXT/ÅTMVOETRVFTUJPOBOEIFSBOTXFSJTUIBUUIFSFTFBSDIXJMM CFVTFGVMCVUOPUVTFGVMFOPVHI*OIFSBSUJDMF (BNNFMHBBSEBQQMJFTUIFNFUIPEPMPHJDBM GSBNFXPSL EFđOFE CZ "SCOPS BOE #KFSLF   (BNNFMHBBSE    4IF BSHVFT UIBUUIFJSGSBNFXPSLDBOCFVTFEUPDBUFHPSJ[FGPSNFSMPHJTUJDTSFTFBSDIBOEUPPVUMJOF OFXBQQSPBDIFTUPGVUVSFSFTFBSDIăFGSBNFXPSLJODMVEFTUIFBMUFSOBUJWFBQQSPBDIFT .

(30) BOBMZUJDBM BQQSPBDI  TZTUFNT BQQSPBDI BOE BDUPST BQQSPBDI XIFSF CPUI UIF BOBMZUJDBM BQQSPBDIBOEUIFTZTUFNTBQQSPBDIBSFJOMJOFXJUIQPTJUJWJTNăFBDUPSTBQQSPBDIPOUIF PUIFSIBOEJTNPSFSFMBUFEUPTPDJBMTDJFODFBOETFFLTUPTIPXUIBUUFSNTTVDIBTTVQQMZDIBJO NBOBHFNFOUNVTUCFVOEFSTUPPEBOEJNQMFNFOUFEEJĈFSFOUMZJOEJĈFSFOUPSHBOJTBUJPOT BDDPSEJOHUPUIFJSJOEJWJEVBMDPOUFYUT#ZBOBMZTJOHFYFNQMBSZDBTFTJOMPHJTUJDTSFTFBSDI (BNNFMHBBSEđOETUIBUUIFBOBMZUJDBMBQQSPBDIBOEUIFTZTUFNTBQQSPBDIBSFQSFWBMFOU  TVHHFTUJOHUIBUUIFZGPSNUIFUXPTDIPPMTJOMPHJTUJDT4IFDPODMVEFTUIBUBOVOEFSTUBOEJOH PGMPHJTUJDTSFTFBSDINVTUJODMVEFBMTPUIFBDUPSTTDIPPMBOEUIBUUIJTBQQSPBDIXPVME FOBCMFVTUPFYQMPSFUIFIVNBOTJEFPGMPHJTUJDTTUSBUFHJFTBOEJNQMFNFOUBUJPOTJOBOFX BOEBMUFSOBUJWFXBZ .BOHBOFUBM  EJTDVTTBQIFOPNFOPMPHJDBMQBSBEJHNBTBOBOUJUIFTJTUPUIFQPTJUJWJTU QBSBEJHN JOXIJDIUIFXPSMEJTWJFXFEBTTVCKFDUJWFBOEBTPDJBMDPOTUSVDU(VNNFTTPO  EJTDVTTFTUIFEJĈFSFODFTCFUXFFOBQPTJUJWJTUJDBOEBIFSNFOFVUJDSFTFBSDIFS'PS SFTFBSDIFST XJUIJO UIF IFSNFOFVUJD QBSBEJHN IF NBLFT UIF GPMMPXJOH TUBUFNFOU QSF VOEFSTUBOEJOHUIBUPěFODBOOPUCFBSUJDVMBUFEJOXPSETPSJTOPUFOUJSFMZDPOTDJPVTmUBDJU LOPXMFEHFmUBLFTPOBOJNQPSUBOUSPMFBOESFTFBSDIFSTBDDFQUJOęVFODFCPUIĚPNTDJFODFBOE QFSTPOBMFYQFSJFODFUIFZVTFUIFJSQFSTPOBMJUZBTBOJOTUSVNFOU. &UNDAMENTALASSUMPTIONSOFTECHNOSCIENCEANDVIEWSOFREALITY 5SPKFS  BSHVFTUIBUXIFOXFIBWFBDLOPXMFEHFEUIBUXFEPSFTFBSDICZESBXJOHPO BDFSUBJOFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMJOGSBTUSVDUVSF UIFOJUJTIJHIUJNFUPRVFTUJPOUIJTJOGSBTUSVDUVSF XIFUIFSJTSFMFWBOUBOEBQQSPQSJBUFGPSPVSMPDBUFEOFFET.ZFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMQMBUGPSN JTXJUIJO5FDIOPTDJFODFTUVEJFTXJUIQPJOUTPGEFQBSUVSFJODMVEJOHTJUVBUFELOPXMFEHF  EJTUSJCVUFELOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPOBOEUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ ăF OPUJPO PG TJUVBUFE LOPXMFEHF XBT JOUSPEVDFE CZ )BSBXBZ   "DDPSEJOH UP )BSBXBZ  BMM LOPXMFEHF JT MPDBM BOE IJTUPSJDBMMZ BOE DVMUVSBMMZ TJUVBUFE 0CKFDUJWJUZ XPVMESFRVJSFEFUBDINFOUCVUEFUBDINFOUJTOPUQPTTJCMFăFSFTFBSDIFSJTBMXBZTMPDBUFE TPNFXIFSFBOE)BSBXBZTUSFTTFTUIBUXFBSFBMMDBVHIUVQJOBNBUFSJBMTFNJPUJDOFUXPSL 4IFGVSUIFSTUSFTTFTUIBUXIBUXFDBODPOUSJCVUFUPUIFLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPODBOOFWFS CFNPSFUIBOQBSUJBMUSBOTMBUJPOTBOEUIBUUSBOTMBUJPOTBSFBMXBZTJOUFSQSFUBUJWF DSJUJDBM BOEKVTUQBSUJBM )BSBXBZ 5POPUBDLOPXMFEHFUIJTJTUPCFJSSFTQPOTJCMFBOEUPGBMM GPSUIFiHPEUSJDLu UIBUJTUPTFFFWFSZUIJOHGSPNOPXIFSFăFSFJTOPPCKFDUJWFPCTFSWFS BOEUIFSFTFBSDIFSNVTUBDLOPXMFEHFIFSPSIJTJOWPMWFNFOUJOUIFLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDJOH QSPDFTT )BSBXBZ 0S BT#BSBE  TUBUFTi8FBSFOPUPVUTJEFPCTFSWFSTPGUIF XPSME/PSBSFXFTJNQMZMPDBUFEBUQBSUJDVMBSQMBDFTJOUIFXPSMESBUIFS XFBSFQBSUPGUIBU OBUVSFJOJUTPOHPJOHJOUSBBDUJWJUZąJTJTBQPJOU/JFMT#PISUSJFEUPHFUBUJOIJTJOTJTUFODFUIBU PVSFQJTUFNPMPHZNVTUUBLFBDDPVOUPGUIFGBDUUIBUXFBSFQBSUPGUIBUOBUVSFUIBUXFTFFLUP VOEFSTUBOE8FBSFQBSUPGUIFXPSMEJOJUTEJčFSFOUJBMCFDPNJOHu#BSBE  QQ -BUPVSEJTDVTTFTUIFEJĈFSFODFCFUXFFOTDJFODFBOESFTFBSDI*OUIFMBTUDFOUVSZBOEB IBMG TDJFOUJĖDEFWFMPQNFOUIBTCFFOCSFBUIUBLJOH CVUUIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIJTQSPHSFTT .

(31) IBTESBNBUJDBMMZDIBOHFE*UJTDIBSBDUFSJ[FECZUIFUSBOTJUJPOĚPNUIFDVMUVSFPGiTDJFODFuUP UIFDVMUVSFPGiSFTFBSDIu4DJFODFJTDFSUBJOUZSFTFBSDIJTVODFSUBJOUZ4DJFODFJTTVQQPTFEUPCF DPME TUSBJHIU BOEEFUBDIFESFTFBSDIJTXBSN JOĂPMĂJOH BOESJTLZ4DJFODFQVUTBOFOEUP UIFWBHBSJFTPGIVNBOEJTQVUFTSFTFBSDIDSFBUFTDPOUSPĂFSTJFT4DJFODFQSPEVDFTPCKFDUJWJUZCZ FTDBQJOHBTNVDIBTQPTTJCMFĚPNUIFTIBDLMFTPGJEFPMPHZ QBTTJPOT BOEFNPUJPOTSFTFBSDI GFFETPOBMMPGUIPTFUPSFOEFSPCKFDUTPGJORVJSZGBNJMJBS -BUPVS  QQ  -BX  EJTDVTTFTUIFWJFXPGTJOHVMBSJUZ UIFFYJTUFODFPGPOFSFBMJUZPVUUIFSF BOE QMVSBMJTNJOSFHBSEPGUIFWJFXPOSFBMJUZBOETIPXUIBUCPUIWJFXTIBWFXFBLOFTTFT)F JOUSPEVDFTUIFDPODFQUPGNVMUJQMJDJUZGSBDUJPOBMJUZBTBUIJSEXBZCFUXFFOTJOHVMBSJUZ BOEQMVSBMJTN BOEDMBJNTUIBUXFEPOPUIBWFUPNBLFBDIPJDFCFUXFFOTJOHVMBSJUZBOE QMVSBMJTN-BXJTDSJUJDBMBCPVUUIFQSPEVDUJPOPGTJOHVMBSJUZTJODFJOIJTPQJOJPO JUIJEFT UIFQSBDUJDFUIBUFOBDUTJUBOEDPODFBMTUIFQPTTJCJMJUZPGFOBDUJOHSFBMJUJFTJOEJĈFSFOU XBZT)FGVSUIFSFYQMBJOTUIBUOPUBDDFQUJOHTJOHVMBSJUZEPOPU MFBE VT UP B XPSE GVMM PGQMVSBMJTN BOEIFTUBUFT'PSUIFBCTFODFPGTJOHVMBSJUZEPFTOPUJNQMZUIBUXFMJWFJOB XPSMEDPNQPTFEPGBOJOEFĖOJUFOVNCFSPGEJčFSFOUBOEEJTDPOOFDUFECPEJFT w *UEPFTOPU JNQMZUIBUSFBMJUZJTĚBHNFOUFE*OTUFBEJUJNQMJFTTPNFUIJOHNVDINPSFDPNQMFY*UJNQMJFT UIBUUIFEJčFSFOUSFBMJUJFTPWFSMBQBOEJOUFSGBDFXJUIPOFBOPUIFSą  FJSSFMBUJPOT QBSUJBMMZ DPPSEJOBUFE BSFDPNQMFYBOENFTTZ QQ*O5BCMF BOPWFSWJFXPG-BXTEFTDSJQUJPOPG UIFEJĈFSFOUWJFXTDBOCFGPVOE .VMUJQMJDJUZGSBDUJPOBMJUZ 1MVSBMJTN 4JOHVMBSJUZ  FIPSSPSPGSFMBUJWJTN  3FFOBDU&VSP"NFSJDBO .PSFUIBOPOFBOEFTTUIBO ă NBOZ FQJTUFNPMPHJDBM FUIJDBMBOE TJOHVMBSJUZ QPMJUJDBM 0VSIJOUFSMBOETQBSUJBMMZ 'SBHNFOUFESFBMJUJFT BXPSME 8FTFFUIFUSVFXPSME PUIFSThQFSTQFDUJWFTBSF JOUFSTFDUXJUIPOFBOPUIFS DPNQPTFEPGBOJOEFđOJUF JODPNQMFYXBZ OVNCFSPGEJĈFSFOUBOE ĔBXFE EJTDPOOFDUFEPCKFDUT  IJOUFSMBOEOPUDPOOFDUFE /PHMPCBMUSVUI 7BSJFUJFTPGUSVUI0VS 0OFUSVUI BSHVNFOUTXPSLCVUPOMZ QBSUJBMMZ 5BCMF"OPWFSWJFXPG-BXTEFTDSJQUJPOPGTJOHVMBSJUZ QMVSBMJTNBOENVMUJQMJDJUZ. )BSBXBZ  HJWFTBQSPNQUBOTXFSUPUIFGFBSPGSFMBUJWJTNCZTUBUJOHUIBUi3FMBUJWJTN JTUIFQFSGFDUNJSSPSUXJOPGUPUBMJTBUJPO TJOHVMBSJUZ BVUIPSTSFNBSL JOUIFJEFPMPHJFTPG PCKFDUJWJUZCPUIEFOZUIFTUBLFTJOMPDBUJPO FNCPEJNFOUBOEQBSUJBMQFSTQFDUJWFCPUINBLF ă  FOPUJPOPGFOBDUNFOUJTDFOUSBMUP-BXBOEIFFYQMBJOTJUBTUIFDMBJNUIBUSFMBUJPOT BOETP. SFBMJUJFTBOESFQSFTFOUBUJPOTPGSFBMJUJFTBSFCFJOHFOEMFTTMZPSDISPOJDBMMZCSPVHIUJOUPCFJOHJOB DPOUJOVJOHQSPDFTTPGQSPEVDUJPOBOESFQSPEVDUJPO BOEIBWFOPTUBUVT TUBOEJOHPSSFBMJUZPVUTJEF UIPTFQSPDFTTFT. .

(32) JUJNQPTTJCMFUPTFFXFMMąFBMUFSOBUJWFUPSFMBUJWJTNJTQBSUJBM MPDBUBCMF DSJUJDBMLOPXMFEHFT TVTUBJOJOH UIF QPTTJCJMJUZ PG XFCT PG DPOOFDUJPOT DBMMFE TPMJEBSJUZ JO QPMJUJDT BOE TIBSFE DPOĂFSTBUJPOTJOFQJTUFNPMPHZu ăSPVHI UIF BCTFODF PG B TJOHVMBSJUZ  PS UIF BCTFODF PG POF SFBMJUZ PVUUIFSF  NFUIPE CFDPNFTBUSJDLZJTTVF-BXBSHVFTUIBUNFUIPEJTOPUBTFUPGQSPDFEVSFTUPSFQPSUPO B HJWFO SFBMJUZ *OTUFBE  NFUIPE JT QFSGPSNBUJWF BOE IFMQT QSPEVDF SFBMJUJFT ăFSFGPSF NFUIPEDBOOFWFSCFJOOPDFOU"DPSFJTTVFJTIPXXFDIPTFUPTFUUIFCPSEFSTCFUXFFO QSFTFODF NBOJGFTUBCTFOUBOE0UIFSOFTTTJODFUIFTFCPVOEBSJFTXJMMJOĔVFODFPVSSFTVMUT 1SFTFODF -BXFYQMBJOTBTXIBUJTJOIFSF NBEFQSFTFODFBOEJUEFQFOETCPUIPONBOJGFTU BCTFOUBOEPUIFSOFTT.BOJGFTUBCTFOUJTXIBUJTEFTDSJCFEBTOPUCFJOHQSFTFOUBOEOPU UBLFOJOUPBDDPVOUCVUJUTSFDPHOJTFEUIBUJUJTFYDMVEFE0UIFSOFTTPOUIFPUIFSIBOEJT TJNQMZFYDMVEFE-BXBSHVFTUIBUUIFSFJTOPQSPCMFNBTTVDIXJUI0UIFSOFTT CPVOEBSJFT BSFOFDFTTBSZBOEUIFSFXJMMBMXBZTCF0UIFSJOHăFQSPCMFNJTXIFOXFEFOZUIBUUIJOHT BSFCFJOHFYDMVEFE-BXQSPWJEFTBOVNCFSPGSFBTPOTGPS0UIFSJOH FHUIJOHTDBOCF PCWJPVTPSVOJOUFSFTUJOH)PXFWFSUIFZDBOBMTPCFSFQSFTTFEGPSPOFSFBTPOPSBOPUIFS ăFSFGPSFXFOFFEUPBUUFOEUPUIFXBZJOXIJDINFUIPEFOBDUTEJWJTJPOTCFUXFFONBOJGFTU BCTFOUBOE0UIFSOFTT %FQFOEJOHPOXIJDINFUIPEPMPHJDBMTDIPPMPOFDIPPTFTUPMFBOPO UIFSPMFPGUIFiSFBMJUZu PSUIFiPVUUIFSFOFTTuWBSJFTBTXFMMBTUIFVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIFSPMFPGUIFSFTFBSDIFS*O UIFUSBEJUJPOBMQPTJUJWJTUJDBQQSPBDIUIFSFTFBSDIFSJTBOPCTFSWFSXIPCZEJĈFSFOUNFBOT USZUPQSPEVDFWBMVFGSFFLOPXMFEHFBCPVUBOiPCKFDUJWFuSFBMJUZ*OPUIFS OPOQPTJUJWJTUJD BQQSPBDIFT UIFSFBMJUZJTBDPOTUSVDUBOEUIFSFTFBSDIFSJTCPUIBWJFXFSBOEJOĔVFODFS-BX FWFOBSHVFTUIBUSFTFBSDIFSQSPEVDFTSFBMJUJFT#BSBE  TUSFTTFTPVSSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFT i8FBSFSFTQPOTJCMFGPSUIFXPSMEJOXIJDIXFMJWFOPUCFDBVTFJUJTBOBSCJUSBSZDPOTUSVDUJPO PGPVSDIPPTJOH CVUCFDBVTFJUJTTFEJNFOUFEPVUPGQBSUJDVMBSQSBDUJDFTUIBUXFIBWFBSPMFJO TIBQJOHu. )MPLICATIONSONMYRESEARCH ăFEPNJOBOUQPTJUJWJTUJDBQQSPBDIJOMPHJTUJDSFTFBSDIJTRVJUFBEJTUBODFBQBSUGSPNUIF FQJTUFNPMPHJDBMQPJOUPGEFQBSUVSFJOUFDIOPTDJFODF CVUUIFNFUIPETPGBDUPSTDIPPM  BDUJPOSFTFBSDIBOEUIFQIFOPNFOPMPHJDBMQBSBEJHNCSJEHFUIFHBQUPTPNFFYUFOU)BWJOH XPSLFEXJUIJOUIFBSFBPGUSBOTQPSUBUJPO MPHJTUJDTBOEJOUFMMJHFOUUSBOTQPSUTZTUFNT*IBWF MFBSOUUIBUUIJTđFMEPGTUVEZJTNFTTZ DPNQMFYBOEDIBSBDUFSJTFECZBCSPBENJYUVSFPG QMBZFSTXJUIEJĈFSFOUESJWJOHGPSDFT8IFO*FYQFSJFODFUIFiSFBMJUZu*TFFUIBUJUJTGVMMPG DPOUSBEJDUJPOT4FMFDUJOHBSFTFBSDIRVFTUJPOBMSFBEZJOUSPEVDFTBDIPJDFUIBUGPSFHSPVOET TPNF BTQFDUT BOE QVTIFT CBDL PUIFST  DSFBUJOH DPNNJUNFOUT UIBU XJMM JOWBSJBCMZ TLFX UIFđFMEPGSFTFBSDIJUTFMGăJTNFBOTUIBUBOZDIPJDFPGUPQJDBOENFUIPEDBOOFWFSCF JOOPDFOUBOEOFJUIFSBN*BTBSFTFBSDIFS 3FBMJUZQSPEVDJOHBTQFDUTJOSFTFBSDIBSFJOUIFDPSFPGUFDIOPTDJFODFUIBUJTJOTQJSFECZ%POOB. )BSBXBZ TFFXXXCUITFULTUFLOPWFUOTG. .

(33) *XFMDPNFUIFBMUFSOBUJWFLOPXMFEHFWJFXTPGLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPOEFQBSUJOHGSPNUIF QPTJUJWJTUJDBQQSPBDI BOE*TFFJUBTBDIBMMFOHFUPTUVEZIPXUIFTZTUFNTUJTTVFJTNBEF VQPGiTUJDLZuFDPOPNJD UFDIOJDBM QPMJUJDBM PSHBOJDBOEIJTUPSJDBMUISFBET*TVCTDSJCFUP -BUPVSzTEFTDSJQUJPOPGSFTFBSDIBTXBSN JOWPMWJOHBOESJTLZBTXFMMBT)BSBXBZTJEFBTPG TJUVBUFELOPXMFEHF*BMTPBDLOPXMFEHF-BXTEFTDSJQUJPOPGNVMUJQMJDJUZBOEGSBDUJPOBMJUZ XJUIIJOUFSMBOETPWFSMBQQJOHFBDIPUIFS XIFSFJUJTQPTTJCMFUPEFUFDUSFTPOBODFQBUUFSOT 3FHBSEJOHNZOPUJPOTPGUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPO *CFMJFWFUIBUUIFSFBSFNJOJNVN MFWFMTPGOFFETUIBUDPSSFTQPOEBDSPTTTJUFT UIBUUIFSFJTBiMFBTUDPNNPONVMUJQMFu)PXFWFS  UPEBZUIFOFFETBSFCFJOHEJĈFSFOUMZFYQSFTTFEUISPVHIUIFVTBHFPGiMPDBMMBOHVBHFTu *UJTNZCFMJFGUIBUUPđOEBOBDDFQUBCMFTPMVUJPOGPSUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPONVDI NPSF JT SFRVJSFE UIBO UP đOE B UFDIOJDBM TPMVUJPO *G NZ SFTFBSDI XBT UP GPMMPX UIF QPTJUJWJTUJDMPHJTUJDSFTFBSDIUSBEJUJPOUIFHPBMXPVMECFUPHFOFSBMJTFBOEđOEBHFOFSJD NPEFMGPSUSBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPO*EPOPUCFMJFWFUIBUTVDIBOBQQSPBDIJTGSVJUGVM *OTUFBENZBJNJTUPVTFBTFUPGDBTFTXIJDI*DBOBOBMZTFUPBSSJWFBUDPNNPOBMJUJFTXIJDI *DBOMJĕUPBNPSFUIFPSFUJDBMMFWFMăFTFUIFPSFUJDBMDPOTUSVDUTNBZUIFOSFWFBMDFSUBJO DIBSBDUFSJTUJDT QBUUFSOTPSACFIBWJPVSTJONZđFMEPGTUVEZBOEPĈFSOFXFYQMBOBUJPOT UIBUBQPTJUJWJTUJDBQQSPBDIXPVMETJNQMZCFVOBCMFUPQSPWJEF*CBTFUIFTFBTTFSUJPOTPO UIFGPMMPXJOHBSHVNFOUT r5FDIOJDBMTPMVUJPOTBMPOFGBJMUPTPMWFUIFQSPCMFN r5SBOTQBSFODZBOEJOUFSBDUJPOEFQFOEPOIVNBOSFMBUJPOTIJQTUSVTU FYQFDUBUJPOT  SJTLTFUD BMMPGXIJDIIBWFBSFBMJNQBDUPOQFSGPSNBODFJOPQFSBUJOHDIBJOTBDSPTT NBOZBDUPST r"CSPBEFSTFUPGNFUIPETNBZQSPWJEFBOPQQPSUVOJUZUPVOEFSTUBOEUIFTPDJBMBOE QTZDIPMPHJDBMEZOBNJDTUIBUJNQBDUPOQFSGPSNBODFCFDBVTFUIFTFEZOBNJDTQMBZ BWJUBMSPMFJOJOTUBOUJBUJOHUIFQSPDFTTFTUIBUUIFQPTJUJWJTUSFTFBSDIFSTJNQMZUSFBUT POBOBCTUSBDUGVODUJPOBMBOEDBVTBMMFWFM r3FTFBSDIJOHJOUFSBDUJPOTCFUXFFOCFIBWJPVSBOEUIFFDPOPNJDBOENBUFSJBMDPOUFYU PGMPHJTUJDQSPDFTTFTDBOQSPEVDFJOTJHIUTVTFGVMCPUIGPSNBOBHJOHBHFOUTBOEUIF PSHBOJTBUJPOBMDPOUFYUPGQSPDFTTFT FHTFUUJOHSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFTJOUSPEVDJOHCFUUFS XBZTPGNPOJUPSJOH SFQPSUJOH PSMFBSOJOH BTXFMMBTQSPWJEFBCFUUFSVOEFSTUBOEJOH PGUIFPQFSBUJPOBMDPOUFYUPGTZTUFNTBOEUFDIOPMPHJFT MFBEJOHUPNPSFVTFBCMF BOEGBVMUUPMFSBOUTZTUFNTu 8JUINZSFTFBSDI *BEESFTT(BNNFMHBBSET  DMBJNUIBUSFTFBSDIQPUFOUJBMDBOCF SFMFBTFECZBEPQUJOHBQQSPBDIFTBMUFSOBUJWFUPQPTJUJWJTUJDPOFTăSPVHINZDIPJDFPG NFUIPET*BNSFTQPOEJOHUP.BOHBOT  QPJOUUIBUUIFEJTDJQMJOFPGMPHJTUJDTDBO CFFOSJDIFECZBQQMZJOHRVBMJUBUJWFNFUIPETBOENZDIPJDFPGUPQJDTBEESFTTFTBTQFDUTPG JEFOUJđFESFTFBSDIOFFET răFMBDLPGSFTFBSDIPOPSHBOJTBUJPOBMDPNQMFYJUZJOTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOUBT JEFOUJđFECZ3VTTFMBOE)PFH   răFJTTVFTSFMBUFEUPUIFđFMEPG.VMUJBDUPSDIBJONBOBHFNFOUUIBUOFFETUPCF GVSUIFSJOWFTUJHBUFEBTQPJOUFEPVUCZ#POUFLPOJOHFUBM   .

(34) răFJTTVFPGSFMBUJPOTIJQTJOTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOUUIBUJTEFđOFEBTJNQPSUBOU GPSGVSUIFSSFTFBSDICZ1PXFS   . -YPOSITIONINTRANSDISCIPLINARYPRACTICES 3FTFBSDIFST BU 5FDIOPTDJFODF TUVEJFT BDLOPXMFEHF UIBU UIF QSPEVDUJPO PG LOPXMFEHF JT UBLJOH QMBDF JO EJTUSJCVUFE TZTUFNT  JF LOPXMFEHF JT QSPEVDFE JO UIF CPSEFSMBOE CFUXFFO VOJWFSTJUJFT  DPNQBOJFT BOE PUIFS SFHJPOBM  OBUJPOBM BOE JOUFSOBUJPOBM BDUPST 5SPKFS  8IBUXFGBDFBSFQSPDFTTFTPGOPOMJOFBSDIBSBDUFSGBSSFNPWFEGSPNPVS USBEJUJPOBM QFSDFQUJPOT PG TFRVFOUJBM QSPDFTTFT JO LOPXMFEHF NBLJOH JO CBTJD SFTFBSDI GPMMPXFECZBQQMJFESFTFBSDIPSEJTTFNJOBUJPOUPFYQMPJUBUJPOPGLOPXMFEHFJOQSPEVDUT (VMCSBOETFOFUBM   5SBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJUZJTEJTDVTTFECZ#SVVOFUBM  JOUIFJSTUVEZPOJOUFSEJTDJQMJOBSZ SFTFBSDI JO 'JOMBOE 5SBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJUZ JT B UFSN EFGJOFE CZ (JCCPOT FU BM   UIBU GPMMPXT PO UIF USBOTHSFTTJPO PG TPDJFUZ BOE TDJFODF (JCCPOT FU BM JCJE  EFđOF USBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJUZBTBDPHOJUJWFBOEFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMGSBNFXPSLUIBUJTiHFOFSBUFEBOE TVTUBJOFEJOUIFDPOUFYUPGBQQMJDBUJPOTBOEOPUEFWFMPQFEđSTUBOEUIFOBQQMJFEUPUIBU DPOUFYUMBUFSCZBEJĈFSFOUHSPVQPGQSBDUJUJPOFSTu#SVVOFUBM  DJUF4DIVM[BOE.BSLT  BOETUBUFTUIBUUSBOTEJTDJQMJOBSJUZIBTCFDPNFBMBCFMGPSDPMMBCPSBUJWFSFTFBSDIBOE QSPCMFNTPMWJOHUIBUDSPTTCPUIEJTDJQMJOBSZCPVOEBSJFTBOETFDUPSTPGTPDJFUZ FOHBHJOHB TIJĕGPSNTDJFODFPOBCPVUTPDJFUZUPXBSETTDJFODFGPSXJUITPDJFUZ $SFBUJPOPGLOPXMFEHFJOUIFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOTPDJFUZBOETDJFODFJTUIFDPSFUPQJDGPS /PXPUOZFUBM  XIPTUSFTTUIBUiTPDJBMMZSPCVTUuLOPXMFEHFPOMZDBOCFQSPEVDFE JOBNJYFEFOWJSPONFOUBOEUIBUJUJTUIFQSPEVDUPGJOUFOTJWFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOSFTVMUT BOEUIFJSJOUFSQSFUBUJPO QFPQMFBOEFOWJSPONFOUT BQQMJDBUJPOTBOEJNQMJDBUJPOT4PDJBMMZ SPCVTULOPXMFEHFJTGVSUIFSEFTDSJCFECZ/PXPUOZFUBM  iSFMJBCMFLOPXMFEHF UIF USBEJUJPOBMHPBMPGTDJFOUJĖDJORVJSZ JTOPMPOHFS TFMG TVĐDJFOUJOUIFNPSFPQFOLOPXMFEHF FOĂJSPONFOUT UIBU BSF FNFSHJOH LOPXMFEHF BMTP OFFET UP CF iTPDJBMMZ SPCVTUu  CFDBVTF JUT WBMJEJUZJTOPMPOHFSEFUFSNJOFETPMFMZ PSQSFEPNJOBOUMZ CZOBSSPXMZDJSDVNTDSJCFETDJFOUJĖD DPNNVOJUJFT CVUNVDIXJEFSDPNNVOJUJFTPGFOHBHFNFOUDPNQSJTJOHLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDFST  EJTTFNJOBUPST USBEFSTBOEVTFSTu ăFNJYUVSFPGSFTFBSDIBOEDPOTVMUBODZFOBCMFTBDPNCJOBUJPOCFUXFFOUIFXPSMETPG BDBEFNJBBOEQSBDUJDF#SVMJOFUBM  TUBUFTUIBULOPXMFEHFJOUIFFNFSHJOHLOPXMFEHF TPDJFUZJTJODSFBTJOHMZDSFBUFEJOJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOSFTFBSDIFSTBOEQSBDUJUJPOFSTXIJDI JNQMJFT B EJĈFSFOU GPSN PG LOPXMFEHF GPSNBUJPO ăFZ OBNF UIJT EJĈFSFOU GPSNBUJPO iJOUFSBDUJWFLOPXMFEHFGPSNBUJPOuBOEFYQMBJOJUBTLOPXMFEHFGPSNBUJPOJOEJSFDUDPOUBDU XJUIQSBDUJUJPOFSTJOUIFEFWFMPQNFOUQSPDFTTFT CPUIUFDIOJDBMBOETPDJBM*UJTGVSUIFS FYQMBJOFEUIBUOPUKVTUFNQJSJDBMSFTVMUTBNFOEBCMFUPDPEJđDBUJPOIBTUPCFCSPVHIUJOUP UIFLOPXMFEHFGPSNBUJPOQSPDFTT CVUBMTPUBDJUBOEQSBDUJDBMLOPXMFEHF *OUIFSFTFBSDIQSPKFDUT *BTBSFTFBSDIFSđMMFEBDFOUSBMSPMFBTBTTJTUBOUQSPKFDUNBOBHFS SFTQPOTJCMFGPSUIFFWBMVBUJPO *OGPMPH SFTQPOTJCMFGPSVTFSSFRVJSFNFOUT %% BOE QSPKFDUNBOBHFS #BOJOGP *OUIFDPOTVMUBODZQSPKFDUT*XBTSFTQPOTJCMFGPSUIFGSFJHIU .

(35) JTTVFT ,PNCJ5*'  BOE QSPKFDU NBOBHFNFOU GPS UIF DPOTVMUBODZ QBSU PG UIF QSPKFDU 1($4 ă  FSFTFBSDIQSPKFDUBTXFMMBTUIFDPOTVMUBODZQSPKFDUTJODMVEFEUBTLTTVDIBT EFđOJOHWJTJPOTBOENJTTJPOT TFUVQBOEDBSSZPVUJOUFSWJFXT PSHBOJTFXPSLTIPQT DPMMFDU VTFSSFRVJSFNFOUT BOBMZTFSFTVMUTBOEEFWFMPQTPMVUJPOTă  FQSPKFDUTIBWFJODPNNPOUIBU UIFZTUSFUDIFEPVUPWFSBMPOHQFSJPEPGUJNF*OGPMPHNPOUIT #BOJOGPNPOUITBOE %%NPOUIT ,PNCJ5*'NPOUITBOE1($4DMPTFUPBZFBS BMMFOBCMJOHMPOHJUVEJOBM TUVEJFT ă  JTDMPTFJOWPMWFNFOUJOUIFQSPKFDUTJTUPNZVOEFSTUBOEJOHJOMJOFXJUIUIFBQQSPBDI PGBDUJPOSFTFBSDIBOEUIFNJYFEFOWJSPONFOUTDPSSFTQPOEUPUIFQSPEVDUJPOPGTPDJBMMZ SPCVTULOPXMFEHFBTEFTDSJCFECZ/PXPUOZFUBMBOEUIFiJOUFSBDUJWFLOPXMFEHFGPSNBUJPOu PG#SVMJOFUBM*WJFXNZJOWPMWFNFOUJOUIFQSPKFDUTBTNFIBWJOHBOJOTJEFSQFSTQFDUJWF JODPOUSBTUUPUIFPVUTJEFSQFSTQFDUJWFUIBU*IBEJOPUIFSQBSUTPGUIFSFTFBSDI FHXIFO DPNQBSJOH EJĈFSFOU QPMJDZ JOJUJBUJWFT 5BCMF  QSPWJEFT BO PWFSWJFX PG UIF EJĈFSFOU DIBSBDUFSJTUJDTCFUXFFOUIFQFSTQFDUJWFTUIBU*FYQFSJFODFE $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTPVUTJEFSQFSTQFDUJWF ,OPXMFEHFHBJOFEUISPVHIMJUFSBUVSFBOE JOUFSWJFXTă  FTUVEJFEPCKFDUJTJOEFQFO EFOUPGSFTFSBDIFS %Jċ DVMUUPDBUDIUIFXIPMFQJDUVSF. &BTZUPLFFQBEJTUBODF. õVBMJUBUJWFMJNJUFENBUFSJBM. $IBSBDUFSJTUJDTJOTJEFSQFSTQFDUJWF ,OPXMFEHF QSPEVDFE JO B NJYFE FOWJSPO NFOU  SFTFBSDIFS BDUJWFMZ JOWPMWFE JO UIF QSPDFTT 1PTTJCMF UP HBJO UBDJU LOPXMFEHF BOE UP VOEFSTUBOE QFSTPOBM SFMBUJPOT BOE IJEEFO DBVTFT *OGMVFODFE CZ UIF TJUVBUJPO  EJGGJDVMU UP LFFQ EJTUBODF BOE UP QPJOU PVU OFHBUJWF JTTVFT XIFO JOWPMWFE XJUI QFPQMF BOE PSHBOJTBUJPOT õVBOUJUBUJWFMJNJUFENBUFSJBM. 5BCMFBOPWFSWJFXPGJOTJEFSPVUTJEFSQFSTQFDUJWF. "UUIFUJNF*XBTFNQMPZFEBU5', JUXBTBSFTFBSDIJOTUJUVUFXJUIBGPDVTPOEJĈFSFOU BSFBTPGUSBOTQPSU FH JOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUTBOE*OUFMMJHFOU5SBOTQPSU4ZTUFNTă  FOBUVSF PGSFTFBSDIDBSSJFEPVUBU5',XBTDIBSBDUFSJTFECZJUTDMPTFDPOOFDUJPOUPUIFUSBOTQPSU JOEVTUSZXIPBMTPXFSFNFNCFSTPGUIFJOTUJUVUF"OVNCFSPGDPNNJUUFFTDPOTJTUJOH PG NFNCFST  DIBJSFE CZ B NFNCFS BOE XJUI B SFTFBSDIFS BT TFDSFUBSZ  CPUI FYDIBOHFE FYQFSJFODFTBOEJEFOUJđFEQSPCMFNTPGSFMFWBODFUIBUXBTGVSUIFSEFWFMPQFEJOUPSFTFBSDI QSPKFDUTă  FSFTFBSDIQSPKFDUTXFSFPĕFOQBSUMZGPVOEFECZEJĈFSFOUOBUJPOBMQSPHSBNTGPS USBOTQPSUSFTFBSDIBOEUPTPNFFYUFOUBMTPCZUIFSFTFBSDIQSPHSBNNFTSVOCZUIF&VSPQFBO $PNNJTTJPO/PSNBMMZUIFNFNCFSTXIPIBECFFOJOWPMWFEJOUIFJEFOUJđDBUJPOPGUIF QSPCMFNTBMTPQBSUJDJQBUFEJOUIFQSPKFDUTă  JTTFUVQFOBCMFEBNFFUJOHCFUXFFOTPDJFUZ BOETDJFODFBOEDPOUFYUVBMJTBUJPOBTEFTDSJCFECZ/PXPUOZFUBM  PDDVSSFEă  JT XBTNZđSTUSFTFBSDIFOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDINZVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGLOPXMFEHFQSPEVDUJPO XBTFNCPEJFE*ONZVOEFSTUBOEJOH JUXBTBNJYFEBOEPQFOFOWJSPONFOUUIBUBMMPXFE .

(36) GPSDPMMBCPSBUJWFQSPCMFNJEFOUJđDBUJPO QSPKFDUTJONJYFEFOWJSPONFOUTBOEDPOTUBOU SFOFHPUJBUJPOTBTBCBTJTJGOPUBQSFSFRVJTJUFGPSQSPEVDJOHSFMFWBOUBTXFMMBTSPCVTU LOPXMFEHF. %MPIRICALMETHODS ăFFNQJSJDBMNBUFSJBMGPSUIFđSTUQBSUPGUIFSFTFBSDIXJUIGPDVTPOUSBOTQBSFODZXBT HBJOFE GSPN UIF SFTFBSDI QSPKFDUT *OGPMPH  %% BOE #BOJOGP #BOJOGP XBT B OBUJPOBM 4XFEJTISFTFBSDIQSPKFDU BOE*OGPMPHBOE%%XFSFQBSUPGUIFUIBOEUI'SBNFXPSL SFTFBSDIQSPHSBNNFTPGUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPOăFSFTFBSDIQPMJDZPGUIF$PNNJTTJPO IBTBTUSPOHGPDVTPOCSJOHJOHUPHFUIFSVTFSBOEVTFSOFFETXJUIBEJWFSTFHSPVQPGQSPCMFN TPMWFSTBOEJUJTFYQMJDJUMZQSPCMFNESJWFO*OUIFDBTFPG*OGPMPHBOE%% UIFUPQMFWFM PCKFDUJWFTFUCZUIF$PNNJTTJPOXBTUPQSPNPUFJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUTăFDPOTPSUJVNT BSPVOE*OGPMPH BOE %% XFSFNBEFVQCZ BNJYUVSF PGJOEVTUSJBM QBSUOFST BT XFMM BT SFTFBSDIFSTGSPNEJĈFSFOUJOTUJUVUFTBOEVOJWFSTJUJFTăFQBSUOFSTPGUIFDPOTPSUJVNTDBNF GSPNEJĈFSFOUQBSUTPG&VSPQF IBEEJĈFSFOUTUZMFTPGXPSLJOHBOEJOUFSOBMBHFOEBTBOEBMM XFSFXPSLJOHQBSUUJNFJOUIFQSPKFDUTăFNBOBHFNFOUPGTVDIQSPKFDUTJTDIBMMFOHJOH  IPXFWFS CPUI*OGPMPHBOE%%QSPWJEFEBIFUFSPHFOFPVTFOWJSPONFOUBMMPXJOHDMPTF JOUFSBDUJPOT CFUXFFO SFTFBSDIFS BOE JOEVTUSJBM QBSUOFST 5IF JOEVTUSZ QBSUOFST OPU POMZCSPVHIUQSPCMFNTUPCFTPMWFECVUBMTPQSPWJEFEEFFQLOPXMFEHFPOUIFCVTJOFTT FOWJSPONFOUJOXIJDIUIFSFTFBSDIXBTBQQMJFE ăFTFDPOEQBSUPGUIFSFTFBSDIXIJDIGPDVTFTPOJOUFSBDUJPOJTNBJOMZVTJOHFNQJSJDBM NBUFSJBMGSPNUIFQSPKFDUT,PNCJ5*'BOE1($4mBOBOBMZTJTGPSBQPSUDPNNVOJUZTZTUFN GPSUIF1PSUPG(PUIFOCVSH"ĕFSEJTDVTTJPOTXJUIUIFDPNNJTTJPOFSPGUIFQSPKFDUT *IBWF CFFOBMMPXFEUPVTFNBUFSJBMGSPNUIFQSPKFDUTJONZSFTFBSDIBOEIBWFCFFOBCMFUPBOBMZTF UIFNBOEBQQMZUIFNPONZJEFBTSFHBSEJOHJOUFSBDUJPO"OBEEJUJPOBMFMFNFOUUPUIF SFTFBSDIPOJOUFSBDUJPOJTUIFDPNQBSBUJWFTUVEZCFUXFFOBOJOJUJBUJWFMFECZUIF&VSPQFBO $PNNJTTJPOPO3JWFS*OGPSNBUJPO4ZTUFNTBOEBOJOJUJBUJWFGSPNUIF64%FQBSUNFOUGPS 5SBOTQPSUPOJNQSPWFEJOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFXJUIJOTVQQMZDIBJOT ăSPVHINZQSPGFTTJPO*IBWFQBSUJDJQBUFEJOBOVNCFSPGEJĈFSFOUQSPKFDUTBOEHBJOFE FYQFSJFODFTUIBUBSFOPUFYQMJDJUMZVTFEJONZSFTFBSDI)PXFWFS JGBDDFQUJOH(VNNFTTPO  JEFBTBCPVUQSFVOEFSTUBOEJOHBOEUIFSFTFBSDIFSBDDFQUJOHJOĔVFODFBMTPGSPN QFSTPOBMFYQFSJFODFT UIFTFFYQFSJFODFTIBWFTVQQPSUFEBOJNQSPWFEVOEFSTUBOEJOHPGUIF SFTFBSDIBSFBBOEBSFJOUFHSBUFEJOBOJNQMJDJUXBZJOUIFUIFTJTBTXFMMBTBDLOPXMFEHJOH NZFQJTUFNPMPHJDBMCBTJOUFDIOPTDJFODFTUVEJFT ăFFNQJSJDBMNBUFSJBMVTFEJOUIFSFTFBSDIJTEFTDSJCFEJOUIFQBQFSTBUUBDIFE*TFFBOFFE UPTUSFTTUIBUUIFSFTVMUTGSPNUIFQSPKFDUTBSFDPOUFYUEFQFOEFOUBOETIBQFECZTQFDJđD MPDBMDPOEJUJPOT&BDIQBQFSBMTPJODMVEFTBEFTDSJQUJPOPGUIFNFUIPETVTFEJOUIFTQFDJđD QSPKFDUT JOUFSWJFXT XPSLTIPQT SFGFSSBMQSPDFTTFTFUD 5BCMFQSPWJEFTBOPWFSWJFXPGUIF NFUIPETBQQMJFE1MFBTFSFGFSUPUIFQBQFSTGPSNPSFEFUBJMFEEFTDSJQUJPOT  .

(37) .FUIPE *OUFSWJFXT 8PSLĔPXBOBMZTJT. %JTDVTTJPOHSPVQT. -JUFSBUVSFBOEDPOUFOUBOBMZTJT. $PNNFOUT .BJOMZTFNJTUSVDUVSFEGBDFUPGBDFJOUFSWJFXT#BOJOGP JOUFSWJFXT 1($4JOUFSWJFXT .BQQJOHPGQSPDFTTFTJOBUSBOTQPSUDIBJOQSPDFTTFT BSF JEFOUJđFE BOE CSPLFO EPXO JOUP TVCQSPDFTTFT  BDUJWJUJFT JOGPSNBUJPOFYDIBOHFTBOEVTFPG*5TZTUFNT JTNBQQFEJOUPEJBHSBNT&OBCMFTBOBMZTJTGPSQSPDFTT JNQSPWNFOUT.FUIPEPMPHZBQQMJFEBOEJNQSPWFEJO %%"QQMJFEBMTPJO#BOJOGPBOE,PNCJ5*' %JTDVTTJPO HSPVQT IBWF CFFO VTFE JO NPTU QSPKFDUT UPHBJOJOTJHIUJOUPUIFQSPCMFNTCVUBMTPGPSRVBMJUZ BTTVSBODF  F H EJTDVTTJOH UIF SFTVMUT GSPN EJĈFSFOU BOBMZTFT0OFTQFDJđDFYBNQMFJTUIFSFGFSFODFHSPVQ DPOTJTUJOHQBSUJDJQBOUTUIBUGPMMPXFEUIF,PNCJ5*' QSPKFDU 6TFEUISPVHIPVUUIFSFTFBSDI. 5BCMFPWFSWJFXPGVTFENFUIPETGPSDPMMFDUJOHFNQJSJDBMNBUFSJBM. .

(38) .

(39) &RAMEOFREFERENCE ăFGPMMPXJOHDIBQUFSBJNTUPQSPWJEFBOPWFSWJFXPGSFTFBSDIDBSSJFEPVUJOđFMETPG 4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOU 4$. 4IBSJOHPGJOGPSNBUJPO *OUFMMJHFOU5SBOTQPSU4ZTUFNT *54 *OGPSNBUJPOBOE$PNNVOJDBUJPO5FDIOPMPHJFT *$5 JOUSBOTQPSUBUJPOBOE4ZTUFN BSDIJUFDUVSF4PNFPGUIFđOEJOHTQSPWJEFBGVOEBNFOUGPSNZSFTFBSDI r4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUSFTFBSDIJMMVTUSBUFTBOJODSFBTFEMFWFMPGDPPQFSBUJPO  DMPTFSSFMBUJPOTIJQTBOEQBSUOFSTIJQTCFUXFFOUIFQMBZFSTXJUIJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOH BTBOJNQPSUBOUFMFNFOU r3FTFBSDIJOUIFđFMEPGTIBSJOHJOGPSNBUJPOQPJOUTPVUCFOFđUTGPSCPUIQVCMJDBOE QSJWBUFQBSUOFSTGSPNJNQSPWFEJOGPSNBUJPOTIBSJOHCFUXFFOUSBċDBOEUSBOTQPSU NBOBHFNFOU CVU BMTP UIBU MBDL PG JOUFHSBUJPO CFUXFFO USBOTQPSUNPEFT DBVTFT OFHBUJWFJNQBDUPOUIFVTFST r*OGPSNBUJPOBOE$PNNVOJDBUJPOUFDIOPMPHJFTBSFTUSFTTFEUPCFJNQPSUBOUGPS BDIJFWJOH FċDJFOU 4$. BOE USBOTQPSUBUJPO ăF NBSLFU QFOFUSBUJPO JT IJHIMZ IFUFSPHFOFPVT EVF UP QSPCMFNT GPS TNBMM BOE NFEJVN TJ[FE DPNQBOJFT UP HFU BDDFTTUP*$5TPMVUJPOT r4ZTUFNBSDIJUFDUVSFJTWJFXFEBTJNQPSUBOUGPSJOUFSPQFSBCJMJUZCFUXFFOEJĈFSFOU TZTUFNT&ĈPSUTIBWFCFFOQVUPOBSDIJUFDUVSFGPSJOEJWJEVBMUSBOTQPSUNPEFTCVU UIFSFJTBOJODSFBTJOHGPDVTJOTZTUFNBSDIJUFDUVSFGPSJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSU. 3UPPLY#HAIN-ANAGEMENTAND4RANSPORT#HAIN-ANAGEMENT (MPCBMJTBUJPO MFBEUJNFSFEVDUJPO DVTUPNFSPSJFOUBUJPOBOEPVUTPVSDJOHBSFFYBNQMFTPG DIBOHFTJOCVTJOFTTUIBUJOĔVFODFUIFNBOBHFNFOUPGMPHJTUJDT4VQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOU  TVQQMZDIBJOJOUFHSBUJPOBOEDPMMBCPSBUJPOBSFUPQJDTUIBUIBWFCFFONVDIEJTDVTTFEEVSJOH UIFMBTUTFWFSBMZFBSTBTXBZTUPHBJODPNQFUJUJWFBEWBOUBHFTăFDPNQFUJUJPOCFUXFFO BOEBNPOHTVQQMZDIBJOTIBTTVQFSTFEFEDPNQFUJUJPOBNPOHđSNT "OHFMT  4LKPUU -BSTFO FU BM  EJTDVTT UIF DIBOHJOH DIBSBDUFS PG TVQQMZ DIBJO SFMBUJPOT DIBSBDUFSJTFE CZ iQBSUOFSTIJQTuPSiTUSBUFHJDBMMJBODFTuBTPQQPTFEUPUIFUSBEJUJPOBMiBSNTMFOHUIuUZQFPG .

(40) SFMBUJPOTăFBVUIPSTDPODMVEFUIBUUIFOFXSFMBUJPOTTIBSFUIFGPMMPXJOHDIBSBDUFSJTUJDT  JODSFBTFERVBMJUZFNQIBTJT   DPPQFSBUJPOPODPTUSFEVDUJPOQSPHSBNTBOEDPOUJOVPVT JNQSPWFNFOUT   FYDIBOHFPGJOGPSNBUJPOBOEPQFODPNNVOJDBUJPO BOE  BMPOHUFSN BQQSPBDIJODMVEJOHTIBSJOHSJTLTBOESFXBSET  4LKPUU-BSTFOFUBM   4VQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOUSFGFSTUPUIFNBOBHFNFOUPGEJĈFSFOUQSPDFTTFT TVDIBTDVTUPNFS SFMBUJPOTIJQNBOBHFNFOU DVTUPNFSTFSWJDF EFNBOENBOBHFNFOU PSEFSNBOBHFNFOU  QSPEVDUJPOBOENBUFSJBMĔPXTBOEQVSDIBTJOH -BNCFSUFUBM  5SBOTQPSUDIBJO NBOBHFNFOUPOUIFPUIFSIBOEDBOCFWJFXFEBTBTVCQSPDFTTPGTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOU BTJUPSHBOJTFTUIFNPWFNFOUBOEIBOEMJOHPGHPPETCFUXFFOUXPTQFDJđDQPJOUTUISPVHI UIFEFQMPZNFOUPGBQPTTJCMZJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUDIBJOJOWPMWJOHBEEFEWBMVFTFSWJDFT "TUSBUFHJDQBSUOFSTIJQCFUXFFOUXPDPNQBOJFT XIFUIFSJUJTBCVZFSTVQQMJFSPSBUIJSEQBSUZ MPHJTUJDTBSSBOHFNFOU DBOCFDPOTJEFSFEBTBTFHNFOUPGBOFYUFOEFETVQQMZDIBJO 4LKPUU -BSTFOFUBM  ăFTVQQMZDIBJOOPSNBMMZDPOUBJOTJOUFSNPEBMFMFNFOUTBOESFTFBSDI PO4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUDBOQSPWJEFHPPEJOTJHIUJOUIFQSPCMFNTPGJOUFSNPEBM USBOTQPSUDIBJOT *OBMJUFSBUVSFSFWJFXPOTVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFNFOUJOUFHSBUJPO 1PXFSQSPWJEFTFYBNQMFT PGUIFTJHOJđDBODFPGJOUFSDPNQBOZSFMBUJPOTIJQT*UJTFNQIBTJ[FEUIBUUFDIOPMPHZBOE QIZTJDBM USBOTGFS FMFNFOUT BSF VOEFSTUPPE  CVU UIBU UIF JTTVF PG SFMBUJPOTIJQT JT NPSF EJċDVMUBOEMFTTXFMMVOEFSTUPPEBOEUIFSFGPSFNPSFGVOEBNFOUBMMZJNQPSUBOUBTBUPQJD GPSGVSUIFSSFTFBSDI)FBMTPEJTDVTTFTUIFDIBMMFOHJOHTJUVBUJPOXIFOCFOFđUTMBOEXJUI TPNFNFNCFSTBUUIFDPTUPGPUIFST 1PXFS   )VNQISJFTFUBMQSPWJEFBSFWJFXPGMJUFSBUVSFXJUIGPDVTPOUIFJNQPSUBODFPGSFMBUJPOTIJQT XJUIJO4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUBOETIPXUIBUSFTFBSDISFTVMUTTUSFTTUIBUTVDDFTTGVM 4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUEFQFOETPODPPQFSBUJWFSFMBUJPOTIJQTUISPVHIPVUUIFTVQQMZ DIBJOJOPSEFSUPBDIJFWFCFOFđUTGPSBMMQBSUJDJQBOUTăJTJOWPMWFTDMPTFSSFMBUJPOTIJQT CFUXFFONFNCFSTJODMVEJOHUSVTU DPNNJUNFOUBOEDPMMBCPSBUJPO"MUIPVHITVQQMJFST SFDPHOJTF UIF OFFE UP JOUFHSBUF XJUI UIFJS DVTUPNFST  JU JT BQQBSFOU UIBU GVMM 4VQQMZ $IBJO.BOBHFNFOUJNQMFNFOUBUJPOJTOPUCFJOHBDIJFWFEGPSBOVNCFSPGSFBTPOTăF JNQPSUBODFPGMPOHUFSNQBSUOFSJOHSFMBUJPOTIJQTBSFBDLOPXMFEHFE CVUUIFOFFEUPCBTF UIFTFBSSBOHFNFOUTPOPQFOOFTT TIBSFESJTLTBOESFXBSETUIBUMFWFSBHFUIFTLJMMTPGFBDI QBSUOFSUPBDIJFWFDPNQFUJUJWFQFSGPSNBODFOPUBDIJFWFECZUIFJOEJWJEVBM JTBTUFQUIBU đSNTđOEEJċDVMUUPUBLFăFSFWJFXJTDPODMVEFEXJUIUIFGPMMPXJOHTUBUFNFOUiUIF JNQPSUBODFPGJNQSPWJOHSFMBUJPOTIJQTUPBDIJFWFTVDDFTTGVM4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOU JNQMFNFOUBUJPOTBQQFBSTUPCFXFMMLOPXOUPBDBEFNJBBOECVTJOFTTFTBMJLFBOE BĕFSNPSF UIBOBEFDBEF JUJTTUJMMBDUJWFMZQVSTVFEBTBTUSBUFHZCZUIFQSJWBUFBOEQVCMJDTFDUPSTu )VNQISJFTFUBM . ăFJNQPSUBODFPGDPMMBCPSBUJPOJTGVSUIFSQPJOUFEPVUCZ4BOEFSTFUBM XIPTUBUFTUIBU UIFQIJMPTPQIZPG4VQQMZ$IBJO.BOBHFNFOUJTGPVOEFEPODPMMBCPSBUJPOCFUXFFOUIF TVQQMZDIBJOQBSUOFSTBOEUIBUUIFDPMMBCPSBUJPOJODMVEFTFYDIBOHFPGMBSHFBNPVOUTPG JOGPSNBUJPOăFZSFGFSUPJOGPSNBUJPOBTUIFiHMVFuUIBUIPMETUIFCVTJOFTTTUSVDUVSFT UPHFUIFS  4BOEFSTFUBM  ăFLFZQPJOUPGMPHJTUJDJOGPSNBUJPOJOUFHSBUJPOJTUIFSFBM UJNFBDRVJTJUJPOBOESFDPHOJUJPOPGEJTUSJCVUJPOJOGPSNBUJPO )PVBOE)VBOH   .

(41) 3HARINGINFORMATION 5PJEFOUJGZUIFQFSTQFDUJWFPGHMPCBMTIJQQFSTPOUIFPOHPJOHDIBMMFOHFTJOUIFTIJQQJOH PQFSBUJPOT JOEFQUIJOUFSWJFXTPGUPQMPHJTUJDTBOETVQQMZDIBJONBOBHFSTJONBKPS JOUFSDPOUJOFOUBMDPNQBOJFTXFSFDBSSJFEPVU  4IBXEPO  ăFTUVEZJODMVEFEUIF WJFXPGUIFTIJQQFSTPOJOGPSNBUJPOBCPVUTIJQNFOUTăFTIJQQFSTDIPTFFTUJNBUFEUJNF PGBSSJWBMBTUIFSFBMUJNFJOGPSNBUJPOUIBUJTPGNPTUWBMVBCMFUPUIFNăBUJOGPSNBUJPO SFDFJWFEBPOBđWFQPJOUTDBMF XIFSFQPJOUTXBTUIFIJHIFTUTDPSF ăFFTUJNBUFE UJNF PG BSSJWBM JOGPSNBUJPO JT DMPTFMZ DPOOFDUFE UP JOGPSNBUJPO PO EFWJBUJPOT BOE UIF TIJQQFSTFYQSFTTFEBQSFGFSFODFGPSSFQPSUJOHPOMZXIFOBTIJQNFOUJTOPUNPWJOHBDDPSEJOH UPQMBOăFJOUFSWJFXTBMTPQSPWJEFSFTVMUTPOIPXJOGPSNBUJPOTIPVMECFEFMJWFSFEUP TIJQQFSTăFQSFGFSSFENPEFMGPSQSPWJEJOHSFBMUJNFUSBOTJUJOGPSNBUJPOJTFMFDUSPOJDEBUB JOUFSDIBOHF &%* XIJDIXBTNFOUJPOFECZQFSDFOUPGUIFTIJQQFST0UIFSTXBOUFE JOGPSNBUJPOUPCFQSPWJEFEWJBBDFOUSBM*OUFSOFUCBTFEQPSUBM QFSDFOU FNBJM  QFSDFOU PSUFMFQIPOF QFSDFOU 4IBXEPO JCJE GVSUIFSTUBUFTUIBUUIFSFTBHFOFSBM BDDFQUBODFUIBUUIFJOEVTUSZXJMMIBWFUPMFBSOUPMJWFXJUINPSFCVSFBVDSBDZ DPNQMJBODF  BOEQBQFSXPSLEVFUPUIFSFHVMBUPSZBOETFDVSJUZFOWJSPONFOU "DDFTT UP JOGSBTUSVDUVSF BOE USBċD JOGPSNBUJPO JT WJUBM GPS UIF USBOTQPSU NBOBHFNFOU GPS QMBOOJOH BOE QSPEVDUJPO PG USBOTQPSU DIBJOT 3FTFBSDI DBSSJFE PVU JO .JDIJHBO  64 4FPOHNPPO  JOEJDBUFEUIBUJOUFHSBUJPOPGSFBMUJNFSPBEUSBċDDPOHFTUJPO JOGPSNBUJPOXJUIWFIJDMFSPVUJOHMFBETUPDPTUTBWJOHTBOEEFDSFBTFJOVTBHFUJNF GPSUIFUSVDLJOHJOEVTUSZXIFOVTFEJOBDPOHFTUFEUSBċDFOWJSPONFOU 5ÕSORVJTU FU BM  EJTDVTTFT JOUFSBDUJPO CFUXFFO USBOTQPSU NBOBHFNFOU BOE USBċD BOE JOGSBTUSVDUVSFNBOBHFNFOUXJUIJOUIFSBJMTFDUPS5SBċDBOEJOGSBTUSVDUVSFNBOBHFNFOU QMBZBOJNQPSUBOUSPMFJOUIFUSBOTQPSUDIBJO SFTQPOTJCMFGPSQSPWJEJOHJOGPSNBUJPOGPS QMBOOJOH JOGPSNBUJPOPOTUBUVTBOEEJTUVSCBODFTBTXFMMBTDPOUSJCVUJOHUPUIFSFEVDUJPO PGUIFDPOTFRVFODFTPGEJTUVSCBODFT 5ÕSORVJTUFUBM   4FJU[TUSFTTFTUIBUUPNBLFJOUFSNPEBMUSBOTQPSUBTBUUSBDUJWFBTUSVDLUSBOTQPSU JOUFHSBUJPO CFUXFFOUSBċDBOEUSBOTQPSUNBOBHFNFOUJTOFDFTTBSZ)FDBMMTPVUGPSUIFQPTTJCJMJUZUP VTFSFBMUJNFUSBċDJOGPSNBUJPOGPSMPHJTUJDTQMBOOJOHBOENPOJUPSJOH 4FJU[   ăFUIFNBUJDOFUXPSL5)&.*4GVOEFECZUIF&VSPQFBO$PNNJTTJPO FYBNJOFEUIF TUBUVTPGUIFJOUFSBDUJPOCFUXFFOUSBċDNBOBHFNFOUTZTUFNTBOEGSFJHIUUSBOTQPSUBUJPO NBOBHFNFOU TZTUFNT BOE DPODMVEFE UIBU BU UIJT NPNFOU  UIF JOUFHSBUJPO PG USBċD JOGPSNBUJPO XJUI UIF GSFJHIU USBOTQPSUBUJPO NBOBHFNFOU UBTLT JT TUJMM JO JUT JOGBODZ )PXFWFS BXBSFOFTTJTHSPXJOH CVUSFBMBQQMJDBUJPOTBOETFSWJDFQSPWJEFSTBSFTUJMMJOUIF đSTUTUBHFPGEFWFMPQNFOU  (JBOOPQPMPVT  ăFRVFTUJPOJTIPXKPJOUTPMVUJPOTBOE DPPQFSBUJPOTIPVMECFTVQQPSUFEXIFOUIFSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFTBOECFOFđUTBSFCMVSSFEBOE XIPPSXIBUTIPVMEUBLFPOUIFSPMFPGBGBDJMJUBUPS 0z4VMMJWBOFUBM TIPXUIBUUIFMBDLPGJOUFHSBUJPOXJUIJOUSBOTQPSUNPEFTBTXFMMBTBDSPTT USBOTQPSUNPEFTHFOFSBUFTFYUFSOBMJUJFTUIBUJT BEEJUJPOBMDPTUTUPUIFVTFSTPGUIFTZTUFN ăFZBSHVFUIBUJUJTUIFUBTLPGUIFBVUIPSJUJFTUPQSPNPUFFċDJFOUJOUFHSBUFEUSBOTQPSU OFUXPSL PĈFSJOH UIF DVTUPNFST PQUJNBM MFWFM PG JOUFSDPOOFDUJPOT BOE JOUFSUJDLFUJOH .

References

Related documents

Inputs to our sensor fusion algorithms are ego-vehicle measurements and either tracked objects from both the vision and radar system designed by Autoliv, or classifications with

The previous steps creates the Terraform configuration file, while the last step is to execute it. The command terraform apply is used to execute a Terraform config- uration

N UMERICAL R ESULTS Next, we numerically evaluate the impact of the shortterm average power constraint given by 9 on the achievable downlink rate, coherent beamforming gain,

The following part of this chapter addresses a more detailed discussion about how the general descriptions and conclusions above depend on whether we treat social co- herence

Syfte: Studiens syfte är att skapa en tydligare förståelse för vilka förutsättningar start-up företag har att arbeta miljöfokuserat genom att identifiera

Det finns även en del företag som utvecklar och jobbar med teknik för att i framtiden kunna stänga det textila kretsloppet och göra alla kläder i 100%

Even the simplest gestures are often not simple enough, for example a simple swipe gesture, where the user moves their finger across the screen in one direction, is more complex

He made sure that the robot was near a location before presenting it and did not made any hand gestures, however for a person he presented the locations and pointed at them