• No results found

VÄNNEN FORN

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "VÄNNEN FORN"

Copied!
9
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

1 Rimkus, T. In search of Lithuania coastal Mesolithic. Review of current data and the aims of an ongoing research project.

12 Røstad, I.M. I Åkerfunnets skygge. En fornem merovingertidskvinnes grav fra Åker i Hedmark. —Summary.

28 Neijman, T. & Mårtensson, M. Rustnings- handske 17 från Korsbetningen.

—Summary.

36 Welinder, S. The northern margin of cereal cultivation in Sweden during the Middle Ages.

korta meddelanden

43 Nord, A.G. Analys av bemålade brädor från två rivna träkyrkor — Hakarp i Småland och Bredsäter i Västergötland.

47 Apel, J., et al. Istidsjägare i Uppåkra.

recensioner

52 Clarke, H. & Lamm, K. Helgö revisited. A new look at the excavated evidence for Helgö, central Sweden. Anmälan av M.B.

Henriksen.

54 Simonsen, J. Daily life at the turn of the Neolithic. A comparative study of long- houses with sunken floors at Resengaard and nine other settlements in the Lim- fjord region, South Scandinavia.

Anmälan av M. Blank Bäcklund.

VÄNNEN FORN

FORNVÄNNEN2019/1

JOURNAL OF SWEDISH ANTIQUARIAN RESEARCH

2019/1

Innehåll

issn 0015-7813

Omslag 2019/1_Omslag 3/2004 (kopia) 2019-02-21 12:18 Sida 1

(2)

Utgiven av

Kungl. Vitterhets Historie och Antikvitets Akademien i samarbete med Historiska museet.

Fornvännen finns på webben i sin helhet från första årgången och publiceras löpande där med ett halvårs fördröjning: fornvannen.se

Ansvarig utgivare och huvudredaktör Mats Roslund

Vitterhetsakademien Box 5622, 114 86 Stockholm mats.roslund@ark.lu.se

Redaktionssekreterare och mottagare av manuskript Peter Carelli

Vitterhetsakademien Box 5622, 114 86 Stockholm fornvannen@vitterhetsakademien.se Redaktörer

Herman Bengtsson, herman.bengtsson@upplandsmuseet.se Christina Fredengren, christina.fredengren@shm.se Åsa M Larsson, asa.larsson@raa.se

Teknisk redaktör Kerstin Öström Grävlingsvägen 50 167 56 Bromma kerstin@vinghasten.se Prenumeration Vitterhetsakademien Box 5622, 114 86 Stockholm

e-post fornvannen@vitterhetsakademien.se Bankgiro 535-3552

Årsprenumeration i Sverige (4 häften) 200 kronor, lösnummer 60 kronor Journal of Swedish Antiquarian Research

published by The Royal Academy of Letters, History and Antiquities Subscription price outside Sweden (four issues) SEK 250:–

Box 5622, SE-114 86 Stockholm, Sweden

fornvännen började utges av Kungl. Vitterhets Historie och Antikvitets Akademien år 1906 och ersatte då Akademiens Månadsblad samt Svenska Fornminnesföreningens Tidskrift, som båda tillkommit under 1870-talets första år. Förutom i Sverige finns Fornvännen på drygt 350 bibliotek och vetenskapliga institutioner i mer än 40 länder.

Tidskriften är referentgranskad.

fornvännen (»The Antiquarian») has been published by the Royal Academy of Letters, His tory and Anti quities since 1906, when it replaced two older journals which had started in the early years of the 1870s.

Outside Sweden Fornvännen is held by more than 350 libraries and scientific institutions in over 40 countries.

The journal is peer-reviewed.

issn 0015-7813

Printed in Sweden by AMO-tryck AB, Solna, 2019

Till författaren

fornvännen välkomnar manuskript i nordisk arkeologi och äldre tiders konstvetenskap med an grän sande ämnen. Bidrag kan vara avfattade på de skandinaviska språken samt engelska, tyska och franska. Abstracts och sammanfattningar skall vara på engelska, bildtexter på uppsatsens språk och engelska. Hela Fornvännens inne- håll publiceras fortlöpande både på papper och på internet, det senare med ett halvårs fördröjning. Kontakta gärna redaktionen inför och under skrivandet om frågor uppstår.

Tekniska och typografiska frågor

Manuskript skall vara kompletta och noga korrekturlästa. De levereras med all text i en enda fil i RTF-format eller annat vanligt ordbehandlingsformat. Filen skickas helst per e-post, annars på CD. Inget pappersmanu- skript behövs. Om invecklad typografi som tabeller, matematiska formler eller runtranskriptioner förekommer kan dock en utskrift eller PDF-fil vara bra.

Uppsatser

Tät och kortfattad framställning är en dygd. En uppsats får inte överstiga 16 trycksidor à 4500 ned slag inkl.

abstract, illustrationer och tabeller.

Uppsatser levereras med abstract (högst 1500 nedslag), summary (2000–4500 nedslag) och bildtexter, alla dessa på engelska.

Abstract inleds med författarnamn, årtal, uppsatsens titel med engelsk titel inom parentes och avslutas med författarens namn, institutionsadress och e-postadress.

Referenser

Dessa utformas enligt Harvardsystemet med författarnamn, tryckår och sida inom parentes i texten. Under rubriken Referenser förtecknas refererade eller citerade arbeten i bokstavsordning efter författarens efternamn följt av initialer, tryckår, titel, namn på eventuell tidskrift samt nummer, utgivande institution och förlagsort.

Titlar på monografier och tidskrifter kursiveras. Inga sidnummer anges i referenslistan. Se nedan.

Forsklund, F., 1954. Skäggmode under järnåldern. Esoteriska sällskapets årsskrift 26. Stockholm.

Gendergren, G., 1993. Medeltida suffragetter i Burgund. Lund.

Sviskonkvist, S., 1946. Priapos på Kullaberg. Adlerlöffel, X. & Ölkefjär, Y. (red.). Sydsvensk järnålderskult, ett symposium. Halmstad.

Illustrationer

Illustrationer skickas med minst 1500 pixlars bredd, per e-post, på CD eller i fysiskt original. Fornvännen pub- licerar endast illustrationer där rättighetsinnehavaren givit författaren tillstånd för publicering på internet.

Debatt och mötesreferat

Debattinlägg och mötesreferat saknar abstract och summary, får ha referenser och illustrationer, överskrider inte 5 trycksidor à 4500 nedslag inkl. illustrationer. Innan ett inlägg publiceras skickar redaktionen ofta slut- redigerad version till berörd part för inhämtande av svar.

Korta meddelanden

Korta meddelanden får ha referenser och illustrationer, överskrider inte 3 trycksidor à 4500 nedslag inkl.

illustrationer. Recensioner

Recensioner får inte ha illustrationer eller referenslista (kortfattade referenser läggs inom parentes i texten), omfattar högst 9000 nedslag inklusive mellanslag. Tonvikten skall ligga på vetenskaplig utvärde ring mer än på referat av böckernas innehåll.

Korrektur

Författaren får efter textredigeringen den nya textversionen per e-post för granskning. Illustrerade bidrag skickas därtill, efter slutförd typografering och ombrytning, per e-post i form av PDF-fil för granskning. Inga papperskorrektur förekommer.

Varje författare erhåller ett exemplar av det häfte i vilket bidraget blivit infört.

(3)

Fornvännen 114 (2019)

Farmers think of themselves as living at the cent- re of the world with everyone else on the periphery.

This is the subjective, inside view. From the out- side, for example as viewed by a scholar, centre and margin may be described or defined from more or less objective criteria.

In this paper I deal with two archaeologically excavated sites in Jämtland province, a – from an agricultural point of view – marginal area in north- ern Scandinavia (fig. 1). One was a farm, whose main crop was barley and which was deserted in the 14th or 15th century during the Late Medie- val agrarian crisis. The other was a summer farm (Sw. fäbod), which was established at about the same time. They both display flexibility in the subsistence economy of the area. I will emphasise change during the crisis.

Farms in middle Sweden, as in northern Scan- dinavia as a whole, were self-sufficient during the Medieval period. Nevertheless, the area was part

of World Systems in trading vital goods to the European continent, such as dried fish from the northern Norwegian Atlantic coast and elk hides and squirrel furs from the forested interior of midd- le and northern Sweden. This view challenges the concepts of the central and marginal.

Expansion

Agriculture was introduced into Jämtland in the early 3rd century AD (Eriksson et al. 2011). From that time on the number of farms increased more or less exponentially. A tentative graph showing the expansion (fig. 2) is based on the number of excavated and dated graves up to around AD 1050.

The number of tax-paying farms in 1568 was about 900, calculated from the tax lists drawn up by the Swedish Crown administration during its brief occupation of the area in the 1560s. Other- wise Jämtland belonged to the Danish-Norwe- gian kingdom up to 1645.

The northern margin of cereal cultivation in Sweden during the Middle Ages

By Stig Welinder

Welinder, S., 2019. The northern margin of cereal cultivation in Sweden during the Middle Ages. Fornvännen 114. Stockholm.

One Medieval farm and one coeval summer farm in the Swedish province of Jämt- land are discussed in the framework of a demographic and economic expansion from the regional introduction of agriculture in the early 3rd century until the agrarian crisis in the 14th and 15th centuries. The farm was deserted, while neigh- bouring farms specialising in iron production were not. The summer farm, on the other hand, was first used around the time of the crisis.

Households in Jämtland had a diversified economy including outland-produc- tion of goods for the European market, for example, squirrel and beaver furs, elk hides and iron bars. This provided flexibility for the households, allowing them to subsist on barley cropping in a marginal agricultural area, and thus surviving the Late Medieval agrarian crisis. They even increased their outland production of export commodities.

Stig Welinder, Department of Humanities, Mid Sweden University, SE–851 70 Sundsvall stig.welinder@mium.se

Art. Welinder 36-42 _Layout 1 2019-02-21 11:48 Sida 36

(4)

Fig. 1. The farm Eisåsen and the summer farm Munkbo- vallen in the province of Jämt- land in middle Sweden.

Drawing Marianne Ling.

Fig. 2. The tentative increase in the number of graves, and accordingly in population, in Jämtland during the Iron Age. Shaded area = Sami burials. After Magnus- son 1986 and the archives of Jämtland County Museum, Östersund.

(5)

38 Stig Welinder

Fornvännen 114 (2019)

The estimated number of farms in the early part of the 14th century, already around 900 farms judging from taxation lists, seems to be too low in comparison with the estimated number of deserted Medieval farms, numbering at a mini- mum of 600 farms, most of them actually record- ed in the field. The dip in the graph in the 7th cen- tury may reflect a demographic disaster caused by cold climate due to the notorious AD 536 vol- canic eruption and the Plague of Justinian.

In a detailed study of the parishes of Häggen- ås, Kyrkås and Lit (Olofsson 1997), the number of farms has been tentatively established from archaeological data:

6th century 4 11th century 11 14th century 49

The exponential increase is obvious, as it is from the number of radiocarbon-dated cultivation lynchets in all of Jämtland (Hansson et al. 2005).

There are eight in the period 200–1200 cal AD, rising to 14 for the period 1200–1400.

Agrarian crisis

The immense settlement expansion towards the 14th century brought society into a state of stress.

It became sensitive to change. The Black Death in the year 1350 caused catastrophic change and chaos (Myrdal 2003). There is no unambiguous written document stating that the plague actually hit Jämtland, but there is no reason to doubt it.

One eloquent indicator is the subsequent merg- ing of parishes due to a lack of both priests and parishioners (Ahnlund 1948). From an archaeolo- gical point of view the main indication is the im- pressive number of deserted farms, about 600–

800, comprising about 50–60% of the number around 1300.

Dendrochronologically dated timber build- ings offer quite an amazing insight into the agra- rian crisis (Landström & Bartholin 1987; Raihle 1990). Most obvious in the adjoining province of Dalecarlia, but also hinted at in Jämtland, is the fact that structures were raised regularly during the first half of the 14th century. Then construc- tion ceased entirely during the 1350s, after which nothing was built until about the 1460s. There

was simply no need for new buildings, nor the manpower to build them. However, many farms in Jämtland seem to have remained inhabited un- til after 1400 (Ahnlund 1948). A suggested expla- nation for this late date of desertion is that the first waves of the plague were not as severe in Jämtland as the later ones. Olof Holm (2011) has challenged the established view and suggested that the main desertion wave began already in the 14th century.

In the study of three parishes referred to above, 37% of the 49 farms were deserted, which is less than in most of Jämtland. In the highland part of the area, the percentage is 44%, and in the valley partly along a river, it is only 26%. This differ- ence seems reasonable, but it is not typical for all of Jämtland.

Out of the total number of deserted farms, 72% were less than 1.5 km from a farm that sur- vived the crisis; 40% shared fences with a surviv- ing farm (Hansson et al. 2005). Thus, farms in good farming areas were deserted as often as farms in poor areas.

Jämtland recovered later from the crisis than most parts of Scandinavia (Salvesen 1979). The reason was that the farmers of the province pre- ferred to use the land of the deserted farms for grazing and hay making, not for reestablishing the deserted farms for daughters or sons. Some deserted farms became summer farms.

The deserted farm Eisåsen is typical of the pattern outlined above, although it deviates some- what in being 2.5 km from a surviving farm (fig.

3).

The deserted farm Eisåsen

Eisåsen is in Berg parish, some kilometres to the south of Lake Storsjön and the good farming land on its shores (Hansson et al. 2005). The farm site is close to a small lake, well suited for pollen analysis, at an elevation of 480–500 m above sea level (figs 1, 3).

1st millennium farming settlements are indi- cated by burial mounds and stray finds around Lake Storsjön. Slag indicates bloomery iron pro- duction (fig. 3). The birth date of this settlement area is unknown, but it certainly predates the 11th century, when Christianity became established in Jämtland. At the same time the area around Eis- Art. Welinder 36-42 _Layout 1 2019-02-21 11:48 Sida 38

(6)

åsen was used for cattle grazing in a mainly forest- ed environment. Land use intensified around the 9th century (tab. 1). Meadows were created, and arable land was cleared from stones and plough- ed. No house foundations are as yet known from this time. The land was used as outland by the farms at Lake Storsjön.

During the expansion stage described above, farms and villages were created, thus turning the former outland partly into infields. Eisåsen was one of the farms established in the 13th century.

A house with two rooms has been excavated. Oth- er buildings, including a cowshed, are not visible above ground. Barley was grown at the farm. A stock of cows produced milk; calves were slaugh- tered regularly at an age of less than three years, most often two years or less.

The farm owned a pitfall system for hunting, or at least a share in one. A spearhead typical for pitfalls was found in the waste around the house.

Elk bones, however, make up only about 10% of the mammal bones in the garbage of the Eisåsen household. Bones of beaver and squirrel indicate trapping for furs. The farm was linked into the above-mentioned long-distance trading system.

A further indication is the presence of a sherd of Siegburg stoneware at another deserted farm in Jämtland, also at a distance from the farming area around Lake Storsjön (Gauffin 1981). Fishing and fowling, indicated by a few bones each, were more likely part of the self-sufficient subsistence eco- nomy.

The Eisåsen farm was, according to radiocar- bon, deserted in the 15th century, that is, during one of the recurring plague waves following the Black Death or during the chaos created by that first catastrophic pandemic. In the area shown in fig. 3, there were eleven farms or small villages during the 13th century. Out of these, six were deserted, or 55%, a percentage which may be typi- cal of Jämtland as a whole.

Note that the farms that survived the crisis were all engaged in iron production, while the de- serted ones were not (fig. 3). This small-scale iron production was obviously profitable, although large-scale production in blast furnaces was well under way in the iron producing district of Bergs- lagen further to the south (Magnusson 1984;

2001).

Fig. 3. The landscape with the Eisåsen farm to the south of Lake Storsjön, the central lake in Jämtland surrounded by farming land. Black squares = burial mounds and other sites from the 1st millennium.

Black triangles = iron production sites, mostly finds of slag. Open squares = Medieval farms or villages.

Open circles = deserted Medieval farms. After Hans- son et al. 2005.

(7)

40 Stig Welinder

Fornvännen 114 (2019)

In the wake of the crisis, Eisåsen was turned into meadows and hay producing land and used by the farmers in the surviving small village of Bingsta (fig. 3). Eventually it was turned into a summer farm called Eisåsvallen, which in turn was abandoned around 1875 when the cows decided to go home to the village instead of to the cowshed at the summer farm.

The summer farm Munkbovallen

At the time of its abandonment in the mid-19th century, Munkbovallen consisted of four small cottages with large fireplaces for making whey cheese (Sw. mese), five cellars and at least one cowshed. The summer farm had looked like this since the 17th century, when its owners began to grow barley (Olofsson et al. 2007; Eriksson et al.

2011). This is a typical central Swedish fäbod, where butter, cheese, and whey cheese were made dur- ing the summer months (Larsson 2009). From the

18th century on the butter may have been eaten at five o’clock tea in England.

Munkbovallen is at an elevation of 600–700 m above sea level (fig. 4), close to a small bog in the Oviken mountains. The evidence for cereal cultivation at this altitude during the Little Ice Age is remarkable. Seasonal grazing of cows and goats, however, began already in the 14th century (tab. 1). The date based on the radiocarbon dates of a pollen diagram is somewhat uncertain. The contemporaneity with the abandonment of many farms in Jämtland is, however, remarkable.

The closest summer farm to Munkbovallen is Västnorbodarna, half an hour’s walk away. The landscape history around that fäbod is quite dif- ferent (Eriksson et al. 2011). Some forest clear- ance and grazing began already in the 3rd centu- ry, at the time when agriculture was introduced into Jämtland. Activity intensified in the 10th century, including some barley cultivation. The

Munkbovallen Eisåsen

2000

Abandoned c. 1850 Abandoned c. 1875 1900

1800

Summer farm (1) with arable land Summer farm (1) 1700

Pasture, barley cultivation Pasture, hay making, possibly 1600

barley cultivation 1500

Summer farm with an eldhus (2) 1400

Forest clearance, pasture Tax-paying farm c. 1250–1450 1300

1200 1100 Pasture, hay-making, barley cultivation 1000

Forest clearance 900

800 700 600 500 400

Forest grazing 300

200 100 BC/AD

Tab. 1. Long-term landscape change at the deserted farm Eisåsen and the summer farm Munkbovallen.

After Hansson et al. 2005; Eriksson et al. 2011. 1) Sw. fäbod; used for the cattle and for dairy production in the outland during the summer season. 2) A small cottage with a central fireplace below a hole in the roof.

Art. Welinder 36-42 _Layout 1 2019-02-21 11:48 Sida 40

(8)

site was turned into a regular summer farm with arable land in the 18th century, somewhat later than Munkbovallen. The site was in continuous use throughout the agrarian crisis.

Thus, the agrarian crisis is visible, or not, in quite different ways at the summer farm area in the Oviken high mountains from the farming area around the Eisåsen farm. No abandonment took place; rather, the opposite.

Conclusions

During the Early Modern Period Jämtland’s for- bönder (travelling trader-farmers, fig. 5) were well known. In the winters they went by horse and sleigh to markets on the Norwegian coast or south to markets in Falun and Uppsala, to name a few places (Brink 1995). They transported and sold butter, hides, iron bars, furs, and handicraft pro- ducts like barrels and caskets. Finds at the desert- ed farm sites indicate a similar economy for the Medieval period and indeed from the later 1st mil- lennium. Sleighs, scales, and exotic trading goods have been found in burial mounds from the 10th and 11th centuries (Kjellmark 1904; 1910–13).

The products traded by Jämtland’s forbönder

came mainly from the outland in the forest and mountain areas. Diversity in the subsistence eco- nomy paid off, not least during the Late Medie- val crisis as demonstrated by the farms in the Eis- åsen area (fig. 3). In the outland, the crisis meant change, not decline (Berglund et al. 2009). This is demonstrated in the Munkbovallen area, where an increase in cattle breeding is visible (tab. 1).

Trade went on as usual. The farmers of Jämtland were agents in the northern European trading systems both during and after the crisis of the 14th and 15th centuries.

Cereal cultivation, specifically barley, was a minor part of the subsistence economy in this northerly area at high altitudes. Possibly the for- bönder even brought barley home from their trade expeditions to have some left for brewing Christmas beer. Seen from this agricultural per- spective, Jämtland, and indeed all of northern Scandinavia, were marginal areas.

Jämtland’s households survived on the edge, where agriculture was almost impossible, thanks to a diversified economy emphasising outland production – and merging the northern Euro- pean trading systems. The flexibility of this eco- Fig. 4. The landscape view from the Munkbovallen summer farm in Berg parish, in the province of Jämtland, Sweden. Photo: PG. Bengtsson.

(9)

nomy allowed some of these households on the European margin for barley cultivation to sur- vive crises. The outland shows no signs of aban- donment or decline during the Late Medieval crisis, rather the opposite (Berglund et al. 2009).

English corrected by Carole Gillis.

References

Ahnlund, N., 1948. Jämtlands och Härjedalens historia.

Första delen intill 1537. Stockholm.

Berglund, B., Eriksson, K., Holm, I., Karlsson, H., Karls- son, J., Petersson, S., Sundberg, A., Ulfhjelm, B. &

Welinder, S., 2009. The archaeology of the medie- val crisis in Scandinavia. Current Swedish Archaeology 17. Stockholm.

Brink, S., 1995. Marknader och forbönder. Sporrong, U. (red.). Perspektiv på Härjedalen. Sveg.

Eriksson, K., Gustafson, G. & Welinder, S., 2011. Fä- bodar som förändring. Håkansson, A. & Rosén, Ch. (red.), Landskaparna. Halmstad.

Gauffin, S., 1981. Ödesbölet Svedäng, Alsens socken.

Rapport från en arkeologisk undersökning. Jämtlands läns museum. Östersund.

Hansson, A., Olson, C., Storå, J., Welinder, S. & Zetter- ström, Å., 2005. Agrarkris och ödegårdar i Jämtland.

Östersund.

Holm, O. 2011. Digerdödens följder för jordägandet.

Exemplet Jämtland. Historisk tidsskrift 2011. Oslo.

Kjellmark, K., 1904. Vikingagrafvarna på Röstaham- maren. Folkhögskolans offentliga föreläsningar 1904/

1905:1. Östersund.

1910–13. Järnåldersgrafvar i Jämtland undersökta 1909. Jämtlands fornminnesförenings tidskrift 5. Öster- sund.

Landström, K.-H. & Bartholin, Th.S., 1987. De äldsta timmerhusen. Byggnadskultur. Meddelande från svenska föreningen för byggnadsvård 3. Stockholm.

Larsson, J., 2009. Fäbodväsendet 1550–1920. Ett centralt element i Nordsveriges jordbrukssystem. Uppsala.

Magnusson, G., 1984. Lapphyttan. En medeltida mas- ugn i Karbenning socken. Karbenning. En bergs- lagssocken. Norberg.

– 1986. Lågteknisk järnhantering i Jämtlands län. Stock- holm.

– 2001. Medeltidens industriutveckling – fanns den?. Andrén, A., Ersgård, L. & Wienberg, J.

(red.). Från stad till land. En medeltidsarkeologisk resa tillägnad Hans Andersson. Stockholm.

Myrdal, J., 2003. Digerdöden, pestvågor och ödeläggelse.

Stockholm.

Olofsson, K.-J., 1997. Kolonisation och bebyggelseutveck- ling i tre jämtländska socknar – från järnålder till tidig medeltid. Unpublished seminar paper. Östersund.

Olofsson, C., Stenbäck Lönnquist, U., Welinder, S., 2007. Munkbovallen. Oviks- och Myssjöbygden 2007.

Oviken.

Raihle, J., 1990. Datering av profana timmerhus från medeltiden i Jämtland och Härjedalen. Bebyggelse- historisk tidskrift 20. Uppsala.

Salvesen, H., 1979. Jord i Jemtland. Bosetningshistoriske og økonomiske studier i grenseland, ca. 1200–1650. Öster- sund.

42 Stig Welinder

Fornvännen 114 (2019)

Fig. 5. A live recon- struction of Jämt- landic forbönder (travelling trading- farmers) passing through a village in the province of Dalarna. Photo: Joa Silver.

Art. Welinder 36-42 _Layout 1 2019-02-21 11:48 Sida 42

References

Related documents

Key questions such a review might ask include: is the objective to promote a number of growth com- panies or the long-term development of regional risk capital markets?; Is the

För att uppskatta den totala effekten av reformerna måste dock hänsyn tas till såväl samt- liga priseffekter som sammansättningseffekter, till följd av ökad försäljningsandel

Inom ramen för uppdraget att utforma ett utvärderingsupplägg har Tillväxtanalys också gett HUI Research i uppdrag att genomföra en kartläggning av vilka

The increasing availability of data and attention to services has increased the understanding of the contribution of services to innovation and productivity in

Syftet eller förväntan med denna rapport är inte heller att kunna ”mäta” effekter kvantita- tivt, utan att med huvudsakligt fokus på output och resultat i eller från

Regioner med en omfattande varuproduktion hade också en tydlig tendens att ha den starkaste nedgången i bruttoregionproduktionen (BRP) under krisåret 2009. De

Generella styrmedel kan ha varit mindre verksamma än man har trott De generella styrmedlen, till skillnad från de specifika styrmedlen, har kommit att användas i större

Närmare 90 procent av de statliga medlen (intäkter och utgifter) för näringslivets klimatomställning går till generella styrmedel, det vill säga styrmedel som påverkar