1ECHNICKA UNTVERZ]TA V UBERCI Fakulta me(hatronrky,tnfo.matrky a mezroborovv(h
itudri I
DIPLOMA THESIS EVALUATION
OPPONENT B/ALUATION Aulhor name: Bc. Pavel Veder
Thcls Ufe: Modeling and real time optimization of a smart microgrid
Opponem Ing. Nikita Zemtsov, PhD
Opponent wortplace3 Eaton European Innovation Center (EEIC) A
Abstracl quality, kel rvordsmatching . . . .
Excellent (1)B. Researdr scop6 and
processing
Excellent (1)C. Level of theorotical
part . ....
Excellent minus(1)
D. Approprialoness of the
m€thods
Excellent(l)
E. Results olaboration and
discussion . . . .
Excellent minus (1-)F. Studsnts own contribution Excellent (1)
G. Th€ conclusion
siatement ...
Excellent minus (1-)H. Fulfillment of Thesis tasks
(goals) ...
Fulfiledl.
Struclure, conoctness and fulness otrofsrences ....
Excellent (1)J. Typographical and tanguage
l€v€l
Very good (2)K. Fomal
quality . . . .
Very good (2)(text structurs, chapters order, darity of illustrations) Comments, remarks
.,.aont on page 2
TECHNfCIL UNNGRSITY OF UBEREC FMIMS StudentskS 1402t2 46117 Libetecl
tel.r +420 485 353 429 I www.fm.lul.cz DIC: CZ 467 47 885
!:!r
r:t w
TTCHNICKA UNNGRZ]TA V UBERCI Fakrrlta mechatroniky, rnformatrky a mezrooorovy<hiludrt I
Overall asssssmenl:
Rapidly inqeasing share of renewable (uncontrollable) energry sources motivates research in the area of modering and rear-time optimization of energy (smart) grids, microgrids, and its components, thus motivating this work.
The author demonstrates good underslanding of the topic including both mode ing and optimization parts, which is evidenl from the theoretical part and high number of cited literature.
The main benefit of the work is the proposed Economic Model predidive controller that performs real-time optimization
ofa
sm€rt microgrid. verification of the optimalcontrol strategy is ierformed via simulations in Matlab simulink. The controller provides optimal regimes forcontroll;|le
components and reduses the operalional cost of the microgrid.oespite good overall assessment, some parts
oflhe
work are sligh y unclear and require more delailed explanation. E.g. praciical reasoning for the micrtogrid structure, infl;ence of simplifying assumptions on the model accuracy (miqogrid model verification), and/or comparison of the investmeni cosrs to the achieved savings.Questions for the dofonse:
l
Vvhat could be another potential source of increasing the savings without signiticant investments in residenlial domain that could be included into the optimization Drobtem?2'
Wlat
will/can happen to the consumption profile if the real-time eleclricity pricing is introduced in the grid? How it will influence the @nsumption prediciive model?@erall dasslMion:
work meets the Masler degree requirements and thgrefore r re@mmend it for defense I
suggest to classifo this work by grade Excellent minus (1,
In
Praguedats
13.05.2019By signing
Icertiry that
Iam not in any personal relationship with the author of the thesis
Opponent signature
IECHNICIL UNNGRS|TY of UBEREC , FtvtMS Studenlska t4o2l2 t461 i7 Liberec 1
rel.:+420 485 353 429 www.fm.l ut.cz DIC: CZ 467 4Z SS5