• No results found

Nonlinear gene activity- drug sensitivity relationship modelling for improved detection of genes that affect drug sensitivity

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Nonlinear gene activity- drug sensitivity relationship modelling for improved detection of genes that affect drug sensitivity"

Copied!
26
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)UPTEC X 05 021 APR 2005. ISSN 1401-2138. KARIN HOLMSTRÖM. Nonlinear gene activitydrug sensitivity relationship modelling for improved detection of genes that affect drug sensitivity. Master’s degree project.

(2) Molecular Biotechnology Programme Uppsala University School of Engineering Date of issue 2005-04. UPTEC X 05 021 Author. Karin Holmström Title (English). Nonlinear gene activity–drug sensitivity relationship modelling for improved detection of genes that affect drug sensitivity Abstract A novel approach for detection of genes whose products affect drug sensitivity was introduced. Two detectors, one based on nonlinear regression and the other on errors in variable modelling, have been tested on simulated data and was, using reciever operating characteristics graphs, compared to a linear state-of-the-art detection strategy, which is based on Pearson's correlation coefficient. On small and nonlinear datasets our modelling detector performed significantly better than the correlation coefficient detector. For example, a dataset size of five points gave under certain circumstances a rate of true positives of the modelling detector that was four times that of the correlation coefficient detector, both at 5% false positives. Our regression detector outperformed the correlation coefficient detector only on very small datasets. Keywords Relationship modelling, regression, drug sensitivity, correlation coefficient, detection. Supervisors. Mats Gustafsson Dept. of Engineering Sciences, Uppsala University Scientific reviewer. Anders Isaksson Dept. of Genetics and Pathology, Uppsala University Language. Security. English Classification. ISSN 1401-2138 Supplementary bibliographical information. Pages. 22 Biology Education Centre. Biomedical Center. Husargatan 3 Uppsala. Box 592 S-75124 Uppsala. Tel +46 (0)18 4710000. Fax +46 (0)18 555217.

(3)

(4) Nonlinear gene activity–drug sensitivity relationship modelling for improved detection of genes that affect drug sensitivity Karin Holmström. Sammanfattning Läkemedelskänslighet, d v s hur stark effekt ett läkemedel har, varierar från patient till patient. Detta är ett problem vid t ex kemoterapi i behandling av cancer. Men denna variation kan utnyttjas för att hitta gener som påverkar just läkemedelskänsligheten. Kännedom om patientens uttrycksnivåer av dessa gener kan användas vid individuell behandling och för att förutsäga behandlingens slagkraft. Dessa gener kan också ge information om hur olika läkemedel fungerar. Om man känner till patienters läkemedelskänslighet och uttrycksnivåer för olika gener kan man identifiera de intressanta generna på olika sätt. Tidigare har en korrelationskoefficient mellan genuttryck och läkemedelskänslighet använts som mått på hur mycket genen påverkar läkemedelskänsligheten. Denna metod vore smidig och bra om sambandet mellan genuttryck och läkemedelskänslighet vore linjärt. Emellertid är detta inte fallet och i detta projekt har data istället anpassats till en ickelinjär kurva på två olika sätt. Dessa metoder för att hitta gener har med hjälp av simulerade data testats och jämförts med korrelationskoefficientmetoden. Det visade sig att de nya metoderna generellt sett presterar bättre när man har små datamängder.. Examensarbete 20 p civilingenjörsprogrammet i molekylär bioteknik Uppsala universitet, april 2005.

(5)  .

(6) . . !#"$&%'")(+* "),#%-.* 0$132!465)798$:;<:&=>;<?'7A@B1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1 0$1G0IH9J8$:7AKMLON3J)P QSR;<TU:QSR;AN3=@V1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1 0$1 F X94DYZP'7AR\[)TU@C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1 0$1 W ^`_$[a:7ANMQ :J';bRKc6:;bRN3K3@d1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1. ] &2 e. /gfd%O*&h(+*. O/. iIjk*'h*&*&+a WU132nmoT):D7A:@<5)KM;A@p1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1 WU1G0Iq@A@<5)Q [$;<N3?\JU@RJU8rR[)[U7<?s_$N3Q R;<N3?\JU@V1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1 WU1 F t)5);<5)7A:Duv?'7<wx1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1E1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1C1D1E1D1C1D1D1C1D1C1D1C1D1D1E1D1C1D1C1D1. Ul 0\e 0\e 0)2. y!zd&{O| (%Oh}a%O~%O*. €. 2. / W. F.

(7) . `    . m ? 7A:Q :8)L ?\5)7oN3KMK

(8) :K3KM?u Q:JkN @ RQSR; ;A:7 ? ;<TU:DT):R\7 ; ?\7 Q ?$8$:7AJ @ ?$=N3:; L R\JU8k[)7<?URUKML TR\@::J ?\79R\KMK€@<?$=N3:;<N3:@ NMJBRK3K ;ANMQ :@1 Yv5)7AN3J)P N @ ? ;A:J R'==?\Q [)K3N3@<T):8 u NM;<T;<T):rRN 8 ? 7A:Q :8$N3:@ RJU8Q:&8$N =N3J):@1 H9J ?\7<;<5)JUR;<:KML ?'7 QSRJOL Q :8$N =N3J):@r;AT): 8$7A5)Px@<:J@ NM;<NON ; LR7AN3:@:; uv::J [R;<N3:J-;b@1 moT):V7A:R'@ ?'JU@ ?\7r;<T)N @R7AN3R\JU=: R7A:V=?\Q [)K3N3=R;<:&8 R\JU8 8$N a:7u NM;<T 8$7A5)P RJ8 8$N3@<:R'@ :)5$;E8$N:7A:J=:@9NMJ P':J): R'=>;<NON ;ANM:&@a:; u ::J N3JU8$NON38)5URK @R\7<:DRK3uoRsLO@a?\5UJU8r;<?S[)K RsLkR\J NMQ [a?\7<;AR\J'; 7A?\K3:\1!CJ)?u K3:8$P':6? hu T)N =bTrP\:JU:@#"-:_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\JdK3:$':K @oR%:=>;98$7A5)PS@<:JU@<N ;ANONM; L J)?\;o?'J)K3LS[)7<?%ON 8$:CR [U7<?'P\J)?-@ N @ ;<?O?\&K )5$;=R\JrR\K3@<?':D5@ :&8dN3J NMJU8)NON 8$5URKh8$7<5UP ;A7<:&R;AQ:J-; @<:K3:=;<N3?\J RJU8 @ ;<5U8)NM:&@o? Q:&=bTURJUN3@<QS@o? 8)7<5)P-@1 ( N ':J 8)R;bRd?'J 8)7<5)P @<:JU@<N ;AN ONM; L RJU8VP\:J)::_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\) J ?'7D8$N :7A:J-; =:KMK`K3N3J):@C?'7E[R;<N3:J-;b$@ ;AT):7A: N3@EJ)? ? *ON3?\5U@;<?O?\K ?\7 N 8$:J-;AN LON3J)P ;AT):DP\:J):@v? NMJ-;A:7A:@ ;, 1 +-;<58$NM:&@oTU-R \.: a::Jr7A:[a?\7<;<:8du T):7A:6;<T):D=:KMK @ou :7A:68$N ON38$:&8dN3Jk;<T):D=K R\@A@<:@o8$7A5)P 7<:&@ N @ ;ARJ-;?\7 8)7<5)P @ :JU@<N ;AN ' :  RJ88$N a:7<:J'; Q :;AT)?$8)@uv:7<: 5@ :&8 ;<0? /UJU8;<T):kP\:JU:@ u T)?'@<:dP':J):k:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\J [)7A? /KM:&@ 8$N a:7<:&8k@<NMP'J)N /=R\J';AKM'L a:; u ::J ;<TU:C=K3R'@<@<:.@ 1M32 24

(9) 1 -0 2561 F 2 1 4;AT):7 @ ;<5U8$N3:@ TU-R ':6=?\7A7<:K3R;<:8S;<T):C8$:P'7<::6 ? h8$7A5)P @<:J@ NM;<N ON ; L ;<? P':J): :_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J ;<? N 8$:J-;AN LVP\:JU:@E? NMJ-;<:7<:&@ ;&'1 7 8J 1 %W 2591 :-2 R\JU;8 1 <%2>= :&R7b@ ?'

(10) J " @6=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\JV=?O@: ? =N3:J-; A+@<:': a:K3?Cu B u R'@o5U@<:8k;<? Q :R'@ 5)7A:E;<T): 8):P\7A::E? `=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J1 c6R;AR ?\JSP\:J)::_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\JSRJU8S8)7<5)P @ :JU@ NM;<N ON ; LS=RDJ a:6@<5)[)[)K3NM:&'8 7A?\Q:\1 PU1 7A:RK);<N3Q:CX m E5=oY XZ?\7 =Gc F6q Q N =7A?'R\7<7bRsL P\:J): :_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J R\JURK3L$@ N @9R\JU8 8$7A5)Pd@<:JU@<N ;AN ONM; LrR'@<@ARsL$$@ U7<:&@ [a:=;<N \:K3L\1 7 J =RJU=:78)7<5)Pk@ :JU@ NM;<N ON ; L R\@A@ARsLO@ =RJU=:7=:K3K3@ R7A: ;A7<:&R;<:&8 u NM;<TR6=:7<;ARN3J 8$?-@ :v? );AT): 8$7A5)PU1moT)>: 7bR\=;<N3?\J ? UwONMK3K3:8 =:K3K3#@ =R\KMK3:8 @ :JU@ NM;<N ON ; LDN3JU8$:_ AH+*7IB@N3@ 8$:;<:7<Q N3J):8€1 moT):9@ARQ :98$?'@<:o? a;<T):98)7<5)PDN @`5U@<:8?'JR\KMKU@ARQ [)K3:#@ \R\JU8 ;<T)N @ 8$?-@ :oN @`[)7A@: :7bR UKML =bTU?'@<:J @ ?C;ATUR; @<?\Q :o[UR;ANM:J-;A#@ "\=R\JU=:7 =:KMK @u N3K3KhTU-R ': R +*7 ? e RJU8 ?;<TU:7b@ ? `;AT): QSR_$N3Q 5)J Q +*7 ?'79;<TR;E@<[a:=N /= 8$7<5UKP au T)N3=bT N @6J)?;JU:=:&@<@AR7AN3KMLV2\G1 +O?'Q : 8$7A5)P'@o?'798$?'@<:@o ? 8$7A5)P'@ =RJ)JU?; wONMK3K RK3K;<TU: =:K3K $@ $u T)N =bT 7<:JU8$:7A@oR QSR_$N3Q 5)L Q a:K3?u 2'1 moT)N @9[)7A? M :&=>#; " @9R\NMQ u R'@o;<?dNMQ [)K3:Q :J-N; U;A:@ ;6RJU8 /JURK3KMLr5U@<: ?\J =KMN3J)N =RK )N3?\K3?\P\N =R\K 8)R;ARSRSJ)%? ':K R\[)[)7A?'R'=bTd;A? 8$:;A:=>; P\:J):@ u T)?'@<:r:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\JR a:&=>;S8$7<5UPV@<:JU@<N ;AN ONM; L\O1 7 J;AT)N @ JU%? \:KoR[U[)7<?-R\=b

(11) T  J)?'J)K3NMJ):&R7 7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\JR\JU8 Q ?$8$:K3KMN3J)P N3@ 5U@<:8 ;A? P-5URJ-;<N Lr;<T):=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J a:; u ::J 8$7<5UPd@ :JU@<N ;AN ONM; LrR\JU8 P\:J): :_O[U7<:&@<@<NM?'J1 q@Q:J-;<N3?\J):&8 :R\7<K3NM:#7 Q= :R\7A@<?\

(12) J " @ =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jk=?O$: ?S=NM:J-; Yv%? U1 VXWZY[2 2a Ra 2 RTS \ ] R7#1 V)2 ] R7N1 Y^2 W`_Db TU-R \b: a::Jr5@ :&8dN3J ?;<TU:79@ ;<5U8$N3:@ ;<? Q :R\@<5)7A:E;<T)N @ =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J1 7 J8$:[a:JU8):JU=[: :; uv::Jr; uv'? R7AN R )K3:@ N3Q[UKMN3:@ R'S e  u T):7A:R'@R =?\Q [)K3:;A:K30L " KMN3J):&R768):[a:JU8$:JU=: NMQ [)K3N3:@ RS _D26?'7 RS 2\1q6.@ +c7R\KM5):&@6R\KMuoRsL$@oKMN3: N3J ;AT): N3J-;<:d7 RK 1 e $2 24 Rk@<N3P\Q ?\N 8)RK Ae@ E @ TR[a:K8 B68$:[a:J8$:JU=: ?\J P':J)::_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J N3@CQ ?\7A: K3N3w\:K3L ;<TRJ R K3NMJ):&R7C?\JU:\f1 +ON3P\Q ?'N38)R\K8):[a:JU8$:JU=: N3@ =?\Q Q ?\J N3J JUR;<5)7A:VR\JU68 @<[:&=N /=R\KMK3 L 68$?'@<@: E 7<:&@ [a?\J@ : =5)Z7 ':@kR7A: wOJ)?u J ;<;? : @ N3P\Q ?'N38)R\Kg1 7 J +R\=#; E@ N3P\Q ?\N 8)R\K 8$:[a:J8$:JU=: TUR\h@ a::J@<::J N3J P':J): :_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'*J iO8$7A5)P@<:J@ NM;<N ON ; L 8UR;A*R j&1 thN3P\5U7<:C2o@ T)?u9@ RE@ N3P\Q ?'N38)R\KOP\:JU:v:_O[U7<:&@<@<NM?'*J i 8$7A5)P@<:J@ NM;<N ON ; L =?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J RJ8 RJk:_)RQ [)K3:6 ? J)?=?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\DJ a:; u ::Jk8$7A5)P @ :JU@<N ;AN ONM; L RJU8SP':J):E:_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J1moTU: 8$:;A:=;<?\7b#@ " ;bR\@<w N3@ ;<? 8$N @ ;ANMJ)P'5)N @ T ;AT):rP\:JU:@ u T)N3=bTx%R :=; 8$7A5)P @ :JU@ NM;<N ON ; L AthN3P\5U7<:V2 A+kR BIB^ 7<?'Q ;<T)?-@ :k;<TUR; 8)? J)?\; A+tN3P\5)7A: 2 AlmBIB1 465U^ 7 UR\@<N = N38$:& R n N @D;ATUR; J)?'J)K3NMJ):&R7 7A:P'7<:&@<@<N3?\JVR\JU8 Q ?O8):K3KMN3J)P ? v;AT):d8)R;AR R\==?'7A8$N3J)Pr;<?VR @ N3P\Q ?\N 8 =5)d7 \: u ?\5UK38xK3:R\8B;A?8$:;A:=>;A?\7b@ Q ?\7A: @ :JU@ NM;<N \: R\JU8ZR\==5)7bR;<:r;ATURJZ;AT): =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jx=?-$: ? =N3:J-;d8$:;A:=;<?\7&o1 7 JZ;AT)N3@ uv?'7<Uw 'uv:6TU-R \:=?\Q [UR\7<:&8 ;AT):[a:Z7 ?\7AQSRJU=:@ ? ?\5U7 7A:P\7A:@A@<NM?'J8$:;<:&=>;<?'#7 -?\5U7 Q ?$8$:K3KMN3J)P8$:;A:=>;A?\7 RJU8 ;AT):6=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?O@: ? =NM:J'; 8$:;A:=;<?\N7 u T)N =bT N3J [)7bR\=>;AN3=:v=?\7A7<:&@ [a?\JU86;A?K3NMJ):&R77<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J 1h465)7 7A:P'7<:&@<@<NM?'JD8$:;A:=>;A?\7[:I7 ?'7<QS@ 7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J R\==?\7b8$N3J)P ;<? Rd@ N3P\Q ?\N 8 =5)d7 \: R\JU8 ?\5U79Q ?O8):K3KMN3J)Pd8$:;<:&=>;<?'79Q ?$8$:K @ ;AT): 8)R;AR R'==?'7A8)NMJ)P;A?dRS@ N3P\Q ?'N38 =5)Z7 ' : )u TUN3=b

(13) T  R\@ ?\[)[a?'@<:8 ;<? ;<T):97A:P'7<:&@<@<N3?\J 8$:;A:=>;A?\7b@ ;<TR; ?'J)KMLR\==?\5UJ'>; ?\7 J)?'N3@<: N3J ;<T):6 ? U@<:d7 R;<N3?\J? 8$7A5)P @<:JU@<NM;<N -NM; L ORK @<?C;ARw': NMJ-;A? R\==?\5)J-; J)?'N3@<:CNMJk;<T):D? U@<:d7 sR;<N3?\Jr? P\:JU:E:_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\J1 pIqhr5sutvxwNyz3rH{|sd}4vxz3w|yr4z3{~hw-€NIrH‚ƒ„‚4su #‚H‚4z3w.sd}h†I‡#}hzuymˆhew-‰}HvxŠI‚hsuw-€b‹Ksd}HŒ-z3txz3uŽ@  †h‰‘@etxz3‡ e€[’@ŽG“[sd}4‚hˆ9 ˆh”-‚l}5sdy‚4‚Hz3w[sd}†I‡#}ZmzuyK•Qw-3vxw-eer4vxwNC–#ŠevxIwNŠIe‚I— ˜‡-‡-‚4sut™s˜wNv ‘@IrH‚4v }„Ž@—-~w-€-er4‚&ƒ„‚5su $‚4‚Hz3w[sd}h†he‡N}ZQzuymˆhew-‰}4vxŠe‚ suw-€.‹msd}HŒ-z3txz3uŽ@— ˜‡N‡-‚5sut™s9˜w-v ‘@er4‚Hv }„ŽGsuw-€[šUt™sue‚~w-€-er4‚H‚4z3w.sd}&}HŒ-!›*vxwNw-Isu”-‚hŠeew$}Hr4yz3r

(14) ’-vxz3vxwNyz3r4{|sd}HvxŠe‚Z—N˜‡-‡-‚4sut™s˜wNv ‘@IrH‚4v }„Ž@. 0.

(15) Drug sensitivity. Drug sensitivity. Gene expression. Gene expression. s –#vx3{z3vx€-sutc€-e‡ ew-€NIwNŠIzuyU€-rH”-|‚4ew-‚4v }Hv ‘#v }„Ž[z3w 3ew-,#‡-r4e‚4‚Hvxz3wk. ’ z €-e‡IwN€-ew-Šefzuy!€Nr4”-f‚4ew-‚4v }Hv ‘#v }„Žz3w3ew-  #‡-r4e‚4‚Hvxz3wk. tNMP'5)7<:d2 ^ _$R\Q [)KM:D ? RS@ N3P\Q ?\N 8)R\K =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Ja:; u ::J 8$7<5UP @ :JU@ NM;<NON ; LrRJU8 P':J):D:_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\JOA+RB9RJU8 R\Jr:_)RQ [)K3: ? `RU@<:J=:C? =?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\J:; uv::J 8$7A5)PS@ :JU@<N ;ANONM; LdRJU8kP\:J):C:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\J A mB1 . .

(16). |,.  

(17) .

(18). o . .  "!# $%'&. 7 J ;AT)N3@ou ?\7Aw N3@oP':J):E:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\JkRJU8 N3@+*7>1)moTU: q @ N3P\Q ?\N 8)R\K=5)d7 \:N @ 8$$: /UJ):8 OL ;<T):CN: P'5R;<N3?\J )T :N3P\T-; ? o;<T): A@ ;A:[ N @D:NP'5RK ;A? Rh;<T):k@ K3?\[a: N @ S 8$:j ;<:7AQ NMJU:8OOL j R\JU8 k8$:;<:7AQ NMJU:@Du T):7<:S?'J ;<T): _kE R_$N @C;<TU: 1 tU?\7 ;AT):DP\:J):@ ? u TUN3=bT 8$7A5)PS@ :JU@<N ;ANONM; LdN @ NMJ8$:[a:JU8):J-;# <@ ;<:[ SR[)[a:R\7A@#ca:=R\5U@<:Du T):J _ uv:DTUR-': ;<T):D7A:K R;ANM?'Ja:; u ::J P\:JU:E:_$[)7<:&@<@<S N3?\JkR\JU8r8$7<5UP @<:J@ S NM;<NOn N ; Lr=RJa: 8$:@A=7ANa:8ku NM;<T )(. <;. ;. * ,+"-/. 0 12. 043,576. >=. >=. C8. ED 1 D 3. F(. 98 A?B. @?. :(. *. ( H S G. W. u )T :7A: N3@RV=?\JU@ ;AR\J-; :; uv::Jxe RJ8 2\1 +ON3JU=:k;<T): 8)R;AR R\7<:k? U@<:7dR;ANM?'JU@$ u :dQ ?$8$:Kv;<TU:kQ :R'@ 5U7<:Q:J-; N3J ?\5U7 Q ?O8):K @$U@<?;<TUR; ;<T):DN3JU8$:[:JU8$:JU=:DQ ?$8$:K N3@ W A -2 B S RJU8k;AT): @ N3P\Q ?'N38)R\KQ?$8$:KN @ A0 B S 2 j jW u T):7A: rR\JU8 j R7A:dJU?\7AQ R\KMK3L8$N @ ;A7<N )5$;A:8BJ)?\N @<:ku NM;<Tx:_$[a:=>;bR;ANM?';J RK35): e RJU8B@ ;bRJU8)R\7A8B8$$: ON R;ANM?'J R\JU8 j  7<:&@ [a:=;<N \:KML 'N 1`:\1 A+e W -B RJ8 Ae W B, 1 F9?\;<:9;ATUR;oN3J Q ?O8):K S8$:[:JU8)@ ?\J !1 7 J 7A:R\KMNM; L S8$:[:JU8)@ ?\J )5$; u :dR'@<@<5)Q :S;<TR; ;AT):7A: N @ J)j? J)?\N @ :dNMJ j ;AT): ? U@ :Z7 R;<N3?\J ?  @ ? j;ATUR; S X1 F6R;A5)7AR\KMK3 L h;<TU:7A: N3@ J)?\N @<: NMJ ;<T): ? U@<:d7 sR;<N3?\JU@o ? `P\:JU: :_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\J R\@9uv:KMK 1 q8)8$N3J)PS;AT)N @9;A?S;<T): Q?$8$:K QSRw':@o;AT): 8$:;<:&=>;<?'79;AT):?'7<:;<N =RK3K3LdQ ?\7A: G. I. I. N B. <8. N. N BYXHZ. [UWB. N. XLZ. . K(. BJ. K( LGEMN B. O M<N M<PRQ D 1 Q D 32T S. I. [U. F. 8. (. K8. ]K8. 8. VUWB \(. U.

(19) [?u :7Z 5)K6)5);6RK @ ? =?'Q [)5$;AR;<N3?\JUR\KMK3L Q ?\7A:D8$:QSR\JU8$N3J)P)A+@<::D@ :&=>;ANM?'J 0)1 0B S. . +F  u T):7A: AeW BoR\JU8  AeW  B>1 H6@ N3J)PoRsL\:&@ N RJkNMJc :7<:JU=:$?\5)7 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7A@ =?\Q [UR\7<:6;<T):D[U7<?UR)N3K3N ; LS? h?\JU: ? ;AT):6; uv?@ N3P\Q ?\N 8)R\KUQ ?$8$:K @v;<? ;<T):ENMJ8$:[a:JU8):JU=:6Q ?$8$:K4OP\N\:Jd8)R;bR)1,+O[a:=N/=RK3KML-;<T):LS5U@ :;<T):EJUR;<5)7bRKaKM?'P'R\7<NM;<T)Q ? v;<T): 7bR;<N3? 

(20)

(21)  W  S 2WA0 ;<?r7AR\J)w P\:J):@CR\JU8V8):;<:&=>;C;<TU?'@<: ? vN3J';A:7A:@ ;1 N @E;<T):S8)R;AR€N 1 :'1 ;AT): ? U@<:7dR;ANM?'JU@ ? `P\:J): :_O[U7<:&@<@<NM?'J A+? `?\JU: P\:J):NBoR\JU8 8$7A5)P @ :JU@<N ;ANONM; L\1 moT): T)N3P\TU:7 ;AT):^RK35): ?    

(22)

(23)  W S 2WA0f ?\76R @ [a:=N /a= P\:J): $;AT):DQ ?\7A:6[U7<?UR)K3:E;<TUR; ;<T)N @ P':J):DR%:=;A@ 8$7A5)PS@<:JU@<N ;ANONM; L\1 tU7<?'Q J)?u ?'Jk?'5)798$:;<:=;<?'7o;<TUR;95U@ : B A *W B  AA j   B  u NMK3K

(24) a: =R\KMK3:8k;<TU: <7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\Jk8$:;A:=>;A?\7 )R\JU8 ;AT):D?\JU:C;<TUR;o5@ : K8. I. N T XLZ. U. XLZ. N. T. n. . 8 MN T. S j+"-. K(. A kB. MN * . 0R1. 0 3,5. [U. 1. 1. I I. ;. /=.  . u NMK3K

(25) a: =R\KMK3:8k;<TU: <Q ?O8):K3KMN3J)P 8$:;<:=;<?'7 U1 ;.  . [=. B. A I n  B A I B  B. AH:B. "!Y7$#&%('!()+*+, . - / *+, . ' !&. q@ @ ;AR;<:8kR a%? \: '?'5)7 8):;<:&=>;A?\7b@v5@ :6;<T):.RK35):E? 9A+WkB RJU80AH:B`;A? 7bRJ)wSR\JU8d8$:;<:&=>; P\:J):@1moTU:E8)R;ARKOcf)=?'JU@<N3@ ;A@v? F ? U@<:7dR;ANM?'JU@[A 10IW 0HB@W2 S 2 WA0W W -u TU:7A:bF#N3@ ?'7 :_)RQ [)K3:C;<T):DJO5)Qf:7 ? [UR;ANM:J-;A@oN3J RS@ ;<58$Ld?'7v;AT):DJO5)Q a:7? =:KMKK3N3J):@ :_)RQ NMJU:8€1`moT):D?U@ :7ZR;<N3?\JU@o=R\Ja:D[)5$;9N3J \:&=>;<?'7A@bA &3 W 3 B1 H@<NMJUP4oRsL':@#"-7A5)K3:C?\J A W*B3$u :DP\:; K8 RK(. Z. 666.  . 8K. A I j5 B A   I j B  A I j B S 7 6 A I B  B AB 6 | I n B j k $ B 9A   AA II Bj    S  B  A9  c. (K. A  B 6 8 A  I B-B  6. A I NB B. A+c6:7AN R;<N3?\JU@vR7A:9@ T)?u JS?'J)K3L '? 7 )5$;oR7A:o;<T):6@<R\Q: ?\7 1 q@A@<5)Q NMJ)P ;<TUR; RK3K)Q ?$8$:K @ R\7<::#P-5URK3K3L K3NMw':K3L P'N':J J)?;AT)N3J)PK)N 1`:\1  A j B S  A B3U?\J):CN @oKM: ;u N ;AT I. I. I. B. .  II. jB BNB. Al<kB. 6. ?u :$':7N;AT): Q ?O8):K @CP\N\: 5@CKMNM; ;AKM: N3J ?\7AQSR;<N3?\JVu N ;AT)?\5);E;AT):N37D[UR\7AR\Q:;<:7A@1<;:;E5U@D8):@/UJ):;AT):S@ :;A@E? [UR7bRQ :;A:7b@ ?\7 ;AT):DQ ?$8$:K @ R\@ = :. S?> G = j SB> ?B W? n SC> = ?B W ? j A   I W B. =. RJU8 J)?;A: ;<TR; 6 A  B N @6J)?;Ew-JU?u J

(26) mU5$; @ ;bR;A:Q :J-;9N @ P\:J):7bRKQ ?\79R\KMK;AT)7A::DQ ?$8$:K @1 I. EGF5H. moT):D7A:K R;<N3?\Jr? h;<T):DwOJ)?u J 6. A9  W I. =. W. B. W. A@. U. jW U. . U.  WO @. W W[U. D@. 6. O. T. A9. I. B. A9 I B N @ 6 =  = = SI A  I W B A  I B&J 6 6. I. RJ8 ;AT):D5)J)wOJ)?u J. W B@. 6. =. N3@1tU7<?'Q TU:7A:[ ?\7<;<T

(27) u T):J):$':7 ?'7 N @JU?;6N3JU8$:_$:86a;<TU:. W. W.

(28) =. u )T := 7A: 6 A  BoN @o;AT): @ ? =RK3KM:&8r[)7<N3?\7 [U7<?UR)N3K3N ; L ? h;AT): [UR\7AR\Q :;<:7A@1 moT):DJO5)Qf:79? [UR7bRQ :;<:7b@ NMJ ;AT):D[UR\7AR\Q:;<:7 @ :; 8$:;<:7<Q N3J):@;AT): JO5)Q a:7`? a8$N3Q :JU@<NM?'JU@ ? ;<T)N @`N3J-;<:P'7AR\K1m ?C:&@<=R[a:v;AT)N @`@ ?'Q:u TUR;`T)?'7<7AN L-N3J)PEQ 5)KM;<N 8$N3Q :JU@<NM?'JURK NMJ-;A:P\7bRKR\JrR\[)[)7A?s_$NMQSR;ANM?'Jk=RK3KM:&8 E   F

(29)    H    197<YG=RJa:D5U@ :&8€1!7 ;@ ;AR;A:@ ;ATUR; =  A  B A  W B_ J0  W A B 6 6 = u T):7A : F N @ ;<T): JO5)Q a:7 ?  ? U@<:d7 R;ANM?'= JU$@ `8BN3@ ;AT):kJO5)fQ :7 ? [UR\7AR\Q :;<:7A@ ? ;<T):r= Q ?O8):K RJU8 N @ ;AT):k;<T): qG= A !"#%$&'     B:@ ;<N3QSR;<: ? N 1U:'1v;AT): =?\cJ /P\5)7bR;ANM?'Jd;ATUR;QSR_ON3Q )N (:@ A  )W B^1 -2 1 H@<N3J)P 7<Y N3J AH<B3 6 uv:DP':; I. K. I. I. Z. K. I. =  A9  I j Bh_   A  I B-B*   A  I j W K j Bh_ J 0 j ]Z 6 6  = 6 J)?u :_)RQ N3J):Cu TUR; 6 A9  I W BoN @1-, :DJ)::&8 ;A?S:Qf)7AR'=:6;<T):b +R'=>; ;ATUR; = = . A  I W B S / A2K( 0IWR1K8 0  I W B 6 6 10 0 j 6 A I j  B A I B  B S.   ;:;95U@. RJU8 <7 :&=RK3K€;ATUR;ENMJ Q ?$8$:K @ ::E:NP-5UR;ANM?'J A 2NB3. B W K B-B M. J B @Z 0. 6. A +kB. J)?\N @ :DN3J VN3@J)?;CR\==?\5)J-;A:8 ?\7Nu TOL 0 S 0> ?\7;<T)?-@ : Q?$8$:K3@19t)?'7Q ?$8$:K A+Ke W NB3RJU8kT):J=: = = = A 0ZW 0  kW #B S?> 0`R\JU8 0 NMJ8$:[a:JU8)= :J-; @ S A 0  kW -B A 0  = W NB 6 R\JU8 6 @ S 6 A 104B 6 6 A 0  W NB S?> 0 N3JU8$:[:JU8$:J-; ? A+]kB 4 2 .   8 7 4 6 4 5 A 1 4 0 B S 2 0 3 6 ;:;95U@ K3:R-\: A 0 B9 ?\7 J)?u[$NM;9u N3KMK

(30) a: =K3:R\7 u TOL K3R;<:7 ?\J1`q==?'7A8$N3J)P'KML * ?\7 Q ?$8$:K j A+:#P-5UR;<N3?\J A0BIB u :ETR-\: 6 = = = 2 465 4:9 . <>= ; ? 4 A 0W 0 j W jB S A 0 0W j W jB A 0 j W jB S A 0B A 2ekB 6 6 6 6 j 2 0 3 t)?'7 Q?$8$:K = n ;AT): @ NM;<5R;<N3?\= JrN @9TR )N ;9Q ?'7<:D= =?'Q [)KM:_k@<NMJU=:Cuv:CTU-R ':EJU?\N @ :CN3J A@ ::C#: P-5UR;ANM?'J AF BZB I. I B 9 K( XLZ A G. B. 8. RK(. R\JU8. =.  A9  I 6 _. Uj R\@. I. W U>B-B@ I. B. 8. N BYX. B. K8. Z. 8. 8. U>B. K(. 8. 8. I. B. 8. 3. P Q. UWB. S Q. 1. I. B. B. B. K(. 8. K(. I. B. I. 8. I. K(. 2K(. 8. I. I. 8. 8. 3. P Q. U. I. S Q 3. 3. . 0R1 . 0 35. 8. AK8 0 4W K( 0  n W S I. I. n B S = 6 AK8 0  n W I n B 6 = A K( 0  K8 0 W n W AK8 0 W I W 8QB A 8 W I B&JR8 6  n n 6  n n. I. nB. I 6 T. A. K(. 0. =. nW. n W8UB 6 A 8. I. 2 2 4 I U 2 03 8 P Q 45 3 45  T S Q T  6 A 8QB&JR8 I U 2 03 8 P Q T T T  S > R\@A@ 5)Q :6;<TUR;9[&A _KBoN @ =?'JU@ ;ARJ-; @ B 2 2 4 3 S A 8QB I U 2 03 8 P Q 465 45  T S Q T  JR8 I U 2 03 8 P Q 6 T T T  2 3 4  TS Q T  4 Q J 8 S 2ED R SCB I U 2 03 8 P 465 5 T. S. T. S. B. B. 6. 8. 6. I. B. 6. A 8QB. I T. T. U. 2.  2 0 3 8 P. Q. 4 4 5 3 @4 9  S Q 3 <>= . 0 ; 12. 043,5 ? 8. 2. U. :. T.  0W K8. =. nW. I. . n B&JR8. 4 4 5 3 @4 9  S Q 3 <>= . 0 ; 1 . 0 3 5 ? 8 4 64 5 3 @4 9  S Q 3A<>= . 0R; 1 . 043 5 ? 8. 2 0 3 8. P Q. 465 3 45  T. Q TS. 6.  4 JR8 6. U. 2. U. T. 3 T T 4 J8 P Q 64 5 54  Q S  R 8 2 03. T. 2. 2 0 3 8. P Q. 45 45  T 3. Q TS.  4 JR8. 2\2. A -B.

(31) ,V:DR\7<:9JU?u. 7<:&R\8$L;<? @<::u TR;o#: P-5UR;ANM?'XJ A +kB 7A:@<5)KM;vN3J

(32) $u T)N =bT N @vN3J +R'=>;ou TUR; ?\5)7o8$:;<:=;<?'7A@9UR\@<:9;AT):N37 8$:=N3@<N3?\JU@v?\J1 t)?'7o;<T):D7A:P'7<:&@<@<NM?'JdQ ?$8$:K€:NP-5UR;ANM?'JU@[A W*B3&AA+B3A 2ekB RJU8 A+]kB P\N\:C5U@  . A I j5 B " A I B  B S. 0)0. 6 . j. _ S. A. Z. 10 0 .  .. A 8 ‰0 B. 6.  j. 6. KU. 6. 6. M.  KU j 2 0 3 . S _Z.  >KU B 2 0 3 Z. 2. 0. P Q. 2.  . =  A9  I B W K B B M J 0 B   Z 6 4 45 3 43:9  S Q 3A<= . 0  ;1 . 0  3 5 ? _ J 0 j  ]Z _. 4 5 3 14   S Q 7 S  4. Q P. 2. 

(33) KU j 2 03 _  WKU B 2 0 3 Z. 2. M. 0KU jn 010 j %K( 0 _ 2 2. 0 M. .. 0. 2. 010. KU B n. .. A K( 06_. j [A4: B3

(34) AA+B@&A NB. KU B n. GK. 010. .. A K( 06_. j O. O. M. Bn. GK. K. J B  0. 2'2 RJU8OA]B =. Z. M<PRQ D S 1 Q D S 3 T. MPRQ D S 1 Q D S 3 T. Bn. K. J B   0. M. n _. J j   0. n. _. J j  ]Z 0. A. I. K n W n B!_. Z. _. <. 2&0. A B. Z. Z. 6. .  A  I B W K B B M RJ 0 B  ]Z 6 6 . 4   A 8UB I KU 2 2 03 8 P Q 45 3 @4 9  S Q 3A<= . 0  ; 12. 04 35 ? 8 KU 2 2 03 8 P Q 4 5 3 45  T Q T S  4 J 8 S 010 j 6 T  T .  4. J 2 J. 3 .  M B ]Z _ n  Z _      A 8 50 B P Q 45  14 S Q 7 S 0 0 010 j 6 KU B 2 03 . 4  I KU 2 2 03 8 P Q 45 3 @4 9  S Q 3 <>= . 0  ; 1 . 0  3 5 ? 8 KU 2 2 03 8 P Q 453 54  T Q T S  4 JR8 S Z  A 8UB M 6 010 j T  T . J _ n  Z _AZ  A 8 0 B M Z ,  A KU B 2 03

(35) B M 0 2KU Bn A K( 0 _ G K B n M J 0 B ]  Z 0 6 )0 0 j SC> R'@<@<5)Q : A 8 0 B S A 8QB @ 6 6 . 4 2  I KU 2 03 8 P Q 45 3 @4 9  S Q 3 <>= . 0  ; 1 . 0  3 5 ? 8 KU 2 2 03 8 P Q 453 54  T Q T S  4 RJ 8 S 010 j T  T . J 2 J B  Z _ n  Z M Z ,AWKU B 2 03&B M A2K( 0U_ G K B n M 0 0 KU Bn 10 0 j 0 6. A I n  B    A I B  B. J n   0. JRB ]Z 0. M. .. 0 KU jn 0)0 j  K( 0

(36) _ 2 _. t)?'7o;<T):DQ ?$8$:K3K3NMJ)P 8):;<:&=>;A?\7N$uv:C5U@<:D:#P-5UR;<N3?\JU@ =. Z. 2 0 3. KU B. Z. A 8 ‰0 B. J j   0. j 2 3. A 8 50 B. A 8 0 hB _. . _]Z. M. . =. K j W j B_ I. 2F. A kB.

(37)   A . m ?Oa: R)K3:d;A? =RK =5)K R;A: A 2&0B R\JU8 A 2FkB u :kJU::8 ;<?0/UJU8 ;<TU:  qC=!E :@ ;<N3QSR;A:r? 9;<TU:r[R7bRQ :;A:7b@^ ?'7:&R\=bTBQ?$8$:K1 ,V: @<:R\7A=bT ?\7E;<T):'RK35):&@6? ;AT): [UR7bRQ :;A:7b@9;ATUR;D7A:JU8):7b@;AT):S@ N3P\Q ?'N38 ?\7E;<T):S=?\JU@ ;AR\J';E;<TR;DN3@.a:@ ;[/); ;A:8 ;<? ?\5U7 8)= R;bR)1dmoTU: 8$:7ANR;<N3?\J ? ;<T):  qC=!E :@ ;<N3QSR;A:N @C;AT):d@ARQ :T ?\7 R\KMK ;AT): Q ?$8$:K @DN u :SJ)?u 5@ : ;AT): P\:J):7bRK`8$:J)?;ANM?'J SC> j W W  @ ?\7o;<TU:D[UR7bRQ :;A:7 @<:;A@ ?'7o;<T): 8)N:7A:J-;9Q ?$8$:K @1 = = = = A9  W B A  B S R7AP QS R_ A  W B SC> oRsL\:&$@ "-7<5UKM: @ S R7AP QS R_  6 6 = = = 6 A  6 B SB> A  B NMJ8$:[a:JU8):J-;9? @ S R7AP QS R_ A  W B A  B 6 6 6 = = = = RS 7AP QS R_ 'A 6 A  W B 6 A  BIB S R\7<P QS R_ A  6 A  W B  6 A  BIB A 2*W B = . .   A 0ZW 0  W B  / A  0  B S R7AP QS R_   / 010 6 010 6 666. K. I. I. I. I. I. I. R7AP QS R_  010. S. j. j.  6. I. I. I. I. K8 4K(. .. I. =. AK8 0 WRK( 0  W.     . I. I. M. B M. I. M. 010.  j. j. 6. A. 0 I B. . =. J :#P-5UR;<N3?\J8A+]B@9A 2eBCR\JU88A 2'2NB;<T):d:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\JU@G ?'7 A 0 W 0 W B R7A: @ ;AR;<:&8€1kmh? /UJU8V;<TU:  qC=,E :&@ ;ANMQSR;<: ? o;<TU: [UR7bRQ :;<:7b@#\?\JU:9RK @ ?DJ)::8)@ ;<T):[)7<N3?\7 [)7<?URUNMK3N ;ANM:&@ ? a6 ;AT):9[UR\7A R\Q :;<:7A@# 6 A  0  B>1`moT):[)7<N3?\7b@`R7A:9@<5)[)[a?'@<:8;<? 7<:

(38) U:=; ?\5)7 $     N3Jc ?\7AQSR;ANM?'JdRa?\5$;v;<T):E[UR\7AR\Q:;<:7A@#\:'1`PU1 u T)N =bTRK35):@vuv:6;<TUNMJ)w R\7<:Q?'7<:6[)7A? UR )KM:;<TUR\J ?;AT):7b@1 moTU: [)7ANM?'7A@o ? ;<TU: @ ;bRJU8)R\7A8r8$#: -N R;ANM?'

(39) J $N 1`:\1  R\JU8 R\7<:C@<T)?u JkN3J tNMP'5)7<: 0)1 7. I. 2K8 RK(. I. %U. G. O. 1. 1. 0.9. 0.8. 0.8 0.7. 0.6. 0.6 0.5. 0.4. 0.4 0.3. 0.2. 0.2. 0.1. 0. 0. 5. 10. 15. 20. 25. 30. s6‹Qr4vxz3r6‡Nr4z3’%su’-vxtxv }„Ž|yz3r. 35. 0. 40. LB. UB. ’ &‹QrHvxz3r

(40) ‡-r4z3’%su’Nvxtxv }„Ž.yz3r|suw-€K

(41) Œ-,txz6erhsuw-€ ”-‡-‡erQ’z3”-w-€-sur4vxe‚ ›suw-€˜7K€-v  erKyz3r>suw-€. tN3P\5)7A: 0 moT):D[U7<N3?\7o[)7A? UR )N3KMNM;<N3:@o? ;<TU:D[UR7bRQ :;A:7b@. UUW. . O. R\JU8 1 G. moT): [)7ANM?'7? ;AT): @ ;bRJU8)R\7A8B8$:$ON R;ANM?'JU@ @ T)?'5)K 8 a: J)?\JcE6(:7<?V?\J)K3L ?'7  e RJU8B@ QSRK3K3:7'RK35):@ ? @<T)?'5)K38 : Q ?\7A: [)7A? UR )KM: ;ATURJ UNMP'P\:7 ?\J):&@1 q 8$N @<=?\J-;<N3JO5)NM; LVN3J S eKhK3N3w\:AeB S e )5$;KMN3Q!#" < A

(42) B S%$ hu ?\5)K 8 J)?\; : 8$:&@ N37AR )K3: UTU?uv:#\:7NR'@ ;AT)N3@6u ?\5)K 8 QSRw': N ;ETUR7b8$:79;<?/UJU8 ;AT):Q R_$NMQ 5)Q 1cN @A=?\J-;ANMJO5)NM;<N3:@6NMJ ;<T):[)7ANM?'7A@98)?dJ)?\; 9U. <U. U. . B. U.

(43) uoR7AJ u T):J L'?\5 R\[)[)7A?'R\=bOT ?'Z7 UN38)8):J RK35):&@ ? R [R7bRQ :;A:7Nu TUN3=bTBQ RsL 7A:@<5)KM; N3J ?\JU:dP\:; ;ANMJ)P @ ;<5U=bw R;;<TU:@<: $8 N @<=?\J-;<N3JO5)N ;ANM:&@1 moTU:7A:@ ?\7A:Euv:Euv?'5)K 8d[)7A:@ :79R @ ;<::[ @<KM?'[:E5)[Ou R\7A8U@> ?'79@ QSR\KMK xeU1`m ?T/);o;<TU:@<:C=7<NM;<:7<N RO;AT):C[)7ANM?'7 ? ;AT):D@ ;bRJU8UR7b8 8$:$ON R;ANM?'J u R'@v=bTU?'@<:JdR'@A

(44) B S 4  4 Ou T):7<:ETkRa:&=>;b@.A+NMJrR JU?;o5)JU=?'Q [)KMN =R;<:&8 uoRsLcB R;ou T)N =bT ;<T):D[a:R\wkR\[)[:&R7b@$$@<::DtNMP'5)7A:D0KA+RkB>1 q ;A:79:Q [)7<N37AN3=RK;<:&@ ;ANMJUPK S  j uoR\@o8$:&=N 8$:8r?\J 1 moT):9[)7AN3?\7b@ ? R\JU8 R\7<: a?;AT RK3Q?-@ ; 5UJ)N ?'7< Q )5$;v@<NMJ=:9u : u R\J-;`;<? R-\?'N388$N @<=?\J-;<N3JO5)NM;<N3:@#;<TU:@ Q ?O?;AT):7 5UJU=>;ANM?'J ;. >=. U. U. :U. +. B[B. G. O. A O. A _fBen B S A _ O  fB n M  n. A

(45) _ TBen A  _fBIn _ O A  _ TB n M  n A  _  fB n M  n. M. u R'@ =bT)?'@<:JOA :NP-5UR;ANM?'Jr@<T)?u J ?\7 c)5$;9N @o;<TU: @<R\Q:. ?'7 B@U@<:: tNMP'5)7A:D0KA mB1;/ N @ ;<TU:DKM?u :7a?\5)JU8UR7ALdRJU8rH  N3@ ;<T): 5)[)[a:7NaR\JU8r;<TU:^RK35):@? ;<T):&@ :R7A:C;<T): ?\J)K3Lr8)N:7A:JU=:^a:; u ::J ;<T): [U7<N3?\79? R\JU8 1 : :7<: TV8$:;A:7AQN3J):&@ ;<TU: @ ;A::[)J):@A@ R; ;<TU:|?'5)JU8)R\7<N3:@#'R\JU8u R'@ R% ;A:7v:Q [)N37<N =R\K$;<:&@ ;ANMJ)P @ :; ;<? n   1`q@ ;<T):.+*7sR\KM5U:@ =RJ ?\JUKML7AR\J)P\: 7A?\Q e ;A?V 2 A+R\K ;AT)?\5UP\T JU?\N @ : =R\J 7A:@<5)K ;CN3XJ RK35):@E?'5$;A@<N38): ;AT)N3@CN3J-;<:7ZRK„B3 ;  RJU8VH  ?'7 uv:7<:ekR\JU82€7<:&@ [a:=;<N\:KML'1 moT):[UR7bRQ :;A:7 @ :;A@6;<T):T):NMP'T';C? `;AT): @ N3P\Q ?\N 8 @ ;<:

(46) [ €R\@E8$:@A=7AN:&8 :R\7<K3N3:7NaR\JU8 ;AT)N3@EN @JU?;DRK3u RsL$@ 2'1DmoT):7A:@ ?'7<: ;/ RJU8r H o ?\7 u :7A:Ce)x1 : R\JU8V 2 )7A:@<[:&=>;AN ':K3L\1 moT)= :7A: N @ J)? J)::&8 ;<? JU?\7AQ R\KM1N (: ;AT):d[U7<N3?\7b$@ R\@ =?\J@ ;bRJ-;A@ 8)? J)?;=bTURJ)P': ;<T):k[?-@ NM;<N3?\J ? o;<T):kP\K3 ? UR\K QSR_$NMQ 5)Q ? A )W B u TUN3=bT u :6@<:R\7A=b T ?\7&1moT):E[UR\7AR\Q:;<:7A@ CRJ8 T-R \:5UJ)N ?'7<Q [)7AN3?\7b@ 7bRJ)P'NMJ)P 7<?'Q _ $ ;A? $ RJU8kR7A: 6;<TO5U@  =?\JU@ ;AR\J-#;  R\JU8 JU::8V;AT):7A@: ?'7<:J)?[; a: ;AR\w\:J N3J';A?r;<T)': j 5)J=>;<N3?\J ;A ? a:SQSR_$N3Q1N (:&8€1SmoT): P\7A?\5)J8)G@ ?\7 =bT)?O?'@<N3J)P ;<T):&@ :6[)7ANM?'7A@ R\7<:6R\!@ ?'KMK3?u9@1hmoT):E@ K3?\[a :  j -? ;<TU:6I@ E @<TUR[a:9N3JS;<TU:6@<NMP'Q?'N38S=?\5)K 8 TU-R ':9RJOfL R\KM5): -R J):P-R;<N \:6@ N3P\Q ?\N 8 RK @ ? NMQ [)K3N3:b@ A J):P'R;<N \N: Bv=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'DJ :; uv::JkP\:JU::_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J RJU8k8$7<5UP @<:JU@<N ;AN ONM; L\1`moT):C@ [a:=N /a=N3JU@ ;ARJ=:E? e uv?'5)K 8k7A:@<5)KM;9NMJ R =?\JU@ ;AR\J'; 5UJU=>;ANM?'

(47) J Uu T)N =bT Q :RJ@o;<TUR; ;<T)N @@<N3P\Q ?\N 8du ?\5UK38 /);u :K3K€;A? 8)R;bR ;ATUR;ER\=>;A5URK3K3L a:jK3?\S J)P-@ ;<? \1 : ?uv#: \:#7 \;<T): 7<YxR[)[U7<?s_$N3Q R;<N3?\XJ A+#: P-5UR;<N3?\XJ A6BIB@$[)5)J)N @<T):@o=?'Q [)KM:_ Q ?O8):K @ R'@ ;AT):@<:ETU-R \:6K3R\7<P':>7 R\KM5):&@ ? 8€16moTU: [UR\7AR\Q :;<:78$:;<:7AQ NMJU:@9u TU:7A: ?\J ;AT): *_ E R_$N3@9;<T):@ ;A:[ N @6@<NM;<:8C1 F9:N ;AT):G7 ?\7;<T)N @[R7bRQ :;A:79N @ ;AT):7A: R\J-L 7<:&R\@<?\Jd;<? ;<TUNMJ)wd;<TUR;@ ?'Q .: R\KM5):&@ @ TU?\5)K 8 a:DQ ?\7A:C[)7<? UR UKM:E;<TRJ ?;AT):7b@1 O. O. G. O. G. O. Q B[B. G. O. O. I. ? B. E?. 4?. "?. I. B. ?B. E. . ,V:. E   A . R\7<:vJ)?u7A:R\8)L6;A?C/J)N3@<T ;AT): 8$:7ANsR;<N3?\J ? );AT):  Cq =!E :@ ;<N3QSR;A:\1;:; 5U@[)N =bwD5)[u T):7A: u :vK3:@ ;`? hR; :NP-5UR;ANM?'JA 2WkB3 )5$; K3:; 5U@D:_)R\QN3J):;<TU: Q ?O8):K @DNMJ8$NON 8$5UR\KMK3L 7A?\Q UJ ?u ?'J1dmoT):' 5)J=>;<N3?\J ;ATUR; @<T)?'5)K38 a:SQ NMJ)N3Q N)(:8 ;A? /UJU8 ;<TU:  qC=,E :&@ ;ANMQSR;<:D? h;<T):D[R7bRQ :;A:7b@v? Q ?$8$:K DN3@ = =. . .  A %B S _  A 10dW 0  kW #B!_  A  0  NB S _   A 104B 2 2 0 3 45 4   7  4 010 j 6 010 j 6 0)0 j 6. A _ e BIn A _xN2 BIn A 2 _ e BIn _  _ A _ ke B n e e\ke : n A _Z-2 B n e e\e : n A  2 _ ke B n e e\ke : n _  n e e\e'0 : n .    6 A 0 B 2 2 0 3 _ 0 2 n A 0 _ B n _   n e n e\ke : n A _BA -2 B n _xN2 BIe n e\ke : n _ 2 e 2 e\ke : n S _ 010 j. _  n e e'e'0 : n = = +ON3JU=: 2 0 3 RJ8 A 0 B N @ J)?;8):[a:JU8$:J-;9?\J $;AT)N3@ =R J a: @ N3Q [)KMN /U:&8rR\JU8  A B 7A:8$$: /UJ):8 R'@ 6 = 2 . A 0 _ Bn  A B S  0 n 0)0 j A N2 :B. n A _B-2 Ben 2 _   _ _   n e e'e' 0 : n n e e'e : n A _xN2 B n e e'e : n 2 e e'e : n B. I. B. K8. K(. G. G. I. B. B. 8. G. 6. M. M. 6. K(. U B. UWB. B. S Q. 1. U B M. 6. G. G. G. M. 6. M. G. G. 6. M. M. 6. 6. 6. 6. 8. B. UWB. U B. UWB. U B M. 3. P Q. G. M. M. 8. I. B. B. Z. B. ]U B M. K(. U B G. G. M. B. 6. M. B. G. UWB. G. G. M. +. 6. M. 6. U B M. 6. 6.

(48) Lk@<NMQ N3K3R\798$:7ANR;<N3?\JU@#Ouv:DP':; . =.  j A j B S.  Z. j. 2. 0 U jn 010 j  K( 0 _ 2. M. e. O. =.  n A n B S _.  . _.  010 j I. e. A _ : Ben A _ O : B n M 6 : n. e. O. e e'e. 6. M. 6. U. _.  2 0 3 8. U T. P. e. O. M<PRQ D 1 Q D 3 T S. e e'e. 6. M. 6. B2. A _ -Ben _ A _ -O B n M k: n. B2. e e\e. n.  _. B2. O. e. U. :n. e M. : n. e e'e: n. 6. 6. P Q. 2 0 3 8. T. e e\e. 2. 64 5 3 45  T. 6. M. 6.  . U. _. e e\e'0: n. T. n T M. U. 2. A #<kB. 6.  4 JR8. Q TS. j. M. 6.  . _. U. e \e e-0 : n e :n e : n e e'e: n jn. U. A _ NBIn _ A _ -O B n M k: n. 4 4 5 3 @4 9  S Q 3A<= . 0 ; 1. 043,5 ? 8. Q. x2. U. n. U M. . e e'e'0 : n. 6. 2. A ' B. 4  _   2 0 3 I 465 @4 9  = ; ? 45 4   4 J _   n e  e'e'0 : n 010 j  . A _ e : Ben A _B2-Ben e : n   A _ e : B n e e'e: n A _B2-B n e e\ek: n _ e : n e e'e: n _   n e e\e'0: n .. S. 2. .. .. A _ : Ben A _ O : B n M 6 : n.   _. RJU8. U. U. O. O. 6. T. P. M. T. 6. O. 3. Q. S Q. M. 6. 6. . 0 1 . 0 3 5. O. O. Q. M. 3. 5. 6. 6. T Q TS. 6. 6. 8. M. 6. U. U. M. 6. U. 6. 6. U. T M. T. 6. m ? @<5)Q 5)[r;<T): [)7<?$=:8$5)7A: $P'N':J P\:J):D:_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'Jk8)R;AR ? `R P\:J): RJ8r=?\7A7<:&@ [a?\J8$NMJUP'+*7RK35):&@o;<T):% qC=!E :@ ;<N3QSR;A: ? `;A= T): [UR\7AR\Q:= ;<:7A@ ? `Q?$8$:= K j ?'7 n a8$:[:JU8$N3J)P ?'J u T)N3=bT 8):;<:&=>;A?\7N @95@ :&86aR\JU8 R\7<:b ?'5)JU8)OLrQ NMJ)N3Q N)(NMJUP  j A j BD?\7  n A n B RJ8  kA %B3 7A:@<[:&=>;AN':K3L\1 CJ)?u NMJUPk;AT):  qG=!E :@ ;<N3QSR;<:&@$h;<TU:d:_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'JVN3J :#P-5UR;<N3?\JA 2s0 BDR\JU8 A 2&F B =RJ;: =RK =5)K R;A:8R\JU8 RV7AR\J)wONMJUPXRK35): R\==?\7b8$N3J)P ;<?V;<TU:k7A:P'7<:&@<@<NM?'J8$:;A:=;<?\7SR\JU8 ;AT):kQ ?$8$:KMK3NMJUP 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7# 7<:&@ [a:=;<N \:KML $N3@98):;<:7<Q N3J):8 ?'7o;<T)N @ P\:J):\1 I. B. . . I. I. B. B. )%., -Y& . c7bRsu N3J)PVX94DY P\7bR[)T@ N @R u RsL ? |ON @ 5RK3N3@<NMJUP ;<T):r[a:7Z ?\7AQ R\JU=:d? =K R\@A@<N/U:7A@1VmoTU:kRK)7<:#ON3R;<N3?\J 7A:R\8U@   ' $E  H &       1E^,\:7<Lr=K R\@A@ N/U:79TUR\@6R' +RK @<: [?-@ NM;<N\: 7AR;<: at=,7bR;<:R\JU8 R ;<7A5): [a?'@<NM;<N\: 7bR;A: m= 7AR;<:'1 moT)^: +R\K3@<: [a?'@<N ;AN': 7bR;<:DN @   . u T):7<: N3@9;<7A5): J):P'R;AN':@1 moT):D;<7A5): [a?'@<NM;<N\: 7bR;A: N3@   . u TU:7A: N3@ +RK @ :6J):P-R;AN':@1 : :JU=: Oth=BRJU8dm= 7AR;<:&@ 7bRJ)P': 7<?'Qe ;<?k2\1 q,[a:7Z :=>; =K R\@A@<N/U:7`;<TR;oQ R\w\:&@`J)? Q N @ ;bRw':@ u N3K3KTUR-': RSm =x7AR;<:C? 2CR\JU8 R th=x7bR;A:E? eU1 q =K R\@A@ N /U:7h5U@<5UR\KMK3LDQSRw\:&@N ;b@`8$:=N3@<NM?'J UR'@ :&8 ?'J u T):;<T):7 R6@<[:&=N /= RK35):oN3@T)N3P\T):7 ?\7 KM?u :7h;<TRJ R6=:7<;ARN3J ;AT)7A:@<T)?\K 8 RK35):\1#tU?\7 N3JU@ ;ARJ= :  ?'5)7 7A:P'7<:&@<@<NM?'Jx8):;<:&=>;A?\7 5U@<:@ ;<T)X : sR\KM5U: ? <(

(49)  ;<?B=K R\@A@ N L P':J):&@ R\@k%R :=>;ANMJUP 8$7A5)P @ :JU@<N ;AN ONM; Lx?'7 J)?\;1 c6N :7A:J-;k;<T)7A:@<T)?\K 8 RK35):&@ u N3KMKE7<:&@ 5UK ;dN3J 8$N :7A:J- ;r t

(50) =  R\JU8 m = 7bR;A:@1 , T):J =?\JU@ ;<7A5U=;<N3J)P ;<T):SX94DY P'7AR\[)T ?'7CRr=K R\@A@<N /U:76L'?\5 @ 5U==:&@<@<N ':K3L NMJU=7<:&R\@<: ;AT):;<T)7A:@<T)?\K 8 R\KM5)T: 7A?\Q @<?kK3?u ;ATUR; RK3K NMJ@ ;bRJU=:@CR7A: =K R\@A@ N /U:&8 R'@C[?-@ NM;<N \:&$@ hu T)N =bT LON3:K 8)@C;AT):S[?'NMJ-; A 2 3N2 B@;<? @<? T)N3P\T ;<TUR; J)? N3JU@ ;bRJU=:SN3@ =K R\@A@ N /U:8 R\@ [?-@ NM;<N \:  u T)N =bT LONM:K38)@ ;<T):D[a?\N3J-; A+e  e B@$?\7o;AT):D?;AT):7 uoRsL 7A?\5)JU8 1 +%2 1 q =K R\@A@ N /U:7 ;ATUR;9P'5):@A@ =K R\@A@ R; 7bRJU8$?'Q ?\7 :&R\=bTrNMJ@ ;bRJU= : )u N3KMK ;<T):?\7A:;AN3=RK3KML [U7<?$8$5U=:R X94DY P'7AR\[)T ;ATUR;DN @DR @ ;A7AR\NMP'T';CK3NMJ)': 7A?\Q Ae  e B;<? A 2 3N2 B>1dYvK R\@A@ N /U:7A@6;<TR; R7Af: a:;<;<:7D;<TUR\J Rd7bRJ8$?\Q P'5):@A@ N3J)Pk?\J):u NMK3K P\N \: RkX94DY P'7AR\[)T u T):7<: ;<T): K3NMJU:Q %? ':C@ 7<?'Q A+e  e B9;<O? A 2 M-2 B9JU?;D@ ;A7AR\NMP'T'.; )5$[; a:J-#;  =K3?'@<NMJUP N3Jk?'Jd;AT)D: A+Ke M-2 B =?\7AJ):7&1moTU:CX94DYxP'7AR\[)Td ? R [:I7 :&=>;9=K R\@A@<N /U:7vN @ R@ ;A7AR\NMP'T';oK3NMJ).: 7A?\Q Ae  e B ;< ? A+Ke M-2 BvR\JU8 ?'J ;<? A 2 3N2 B>1. .

(51). . . +. YZ. . ]. 1. 3. . +. . JZ.

(52) . . $'* / ! D ,#. J7. L7. ,' #&. moT): [a:7Z ?\7AQSRJU=:@o? ?'5)768):;<:&=>;A?\7b@ TUR-\:[a::J =?'Q [UR7A:8d;<?S;AT): R U@<?\K35$;<:[RK35): ? =?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\J =?O:$?S=NM:J-;68$:;A:=;<?\7 ?\J @ N3Q 5UK3R;<:8V8)R;bR)1465U7C8):;<:&=>;A?\7b@6TR-\: JU?;[::J 5U@<:8 ?'J0UNM?'KM?'P\N =RK 8)R;AR6a:=R5U@<: ;<T):;<N3Q : ? ;AT)N3@C[U7<? M :=>;C7A5)J ?\5$;&1 moT):9P':J):o:_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'JfRK35):&@ ? a;<T):9@<NMQ 5)K R;<:&8 8)R;bRCuv:7<:o5)J)N ?\7AQ KML8$N @ ;A7<N)5$;A:8NMJ;AT):9N3J';A:7dRK

(53) 1 e 2e\e'e%25u T)N =bT =?\7A7<:$E @ [a?\J8)@o;<? Rr2&e\e\e EH ?'K38k8$N a:7<:JU=:DN3J P\:JU:D:_$[)7A:@A@ N3?\J :; uv::Jr;<T):C; u ? NMJ8$N ON 8$5UR\K3@ u NM;<T Q ?'@ ;9:_O;A7<:Q:D:_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\JU@1 moT):E[:I7 ?'7<QSRJ=:@ ? ;AT):C8$:;A:=>;A?\7bG@ A+NMJ=K35U8$N3J)P ;AT):C=?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\JS=?-$: ? =N3:J-;o8):;<:&=>;A?\37 B R7A:N3J

(54) U5U:JU=:8 OL;<TU:E@ ;AR\JU8)R7b8 8$$: ON R;ANM?'Jk ? h;AT):CJ)?\N @ :CN3Jr;<T): 8)R;AKR O;<T): @<)N (:C? ;AT): 8)R;AR\@<:^; A+N1`:',1 F^$JO5)Q a:7? h? U@<:d7 sR;<N3?\JUu@ BvRJU8d;<T): @ ;<::[)JU:@A@o? ;<T):D@<NMP'Q ?\N 8d@<KM?'[: -u TUN3=bTr=RJ :D@<::JkR\@oR Q :R\@<5)7A: ? J)?\JUKMN3J):R\7<NM; L\1`moT):7<$: ?\7A:9;AT):@<:6[R7bRQ :;A:7b@ TU-R 'C: a::J R7AN3:8 u T):J [U7<?$8$5U=NMJUP @ N3Q 5)K R;A:8 8)R;AR)1vmoT):D[UR7bRQ :;<:7 8$?O:@ JU?;6R a:&=>; ;<TU: [:I7 ?'7<QSR\JU=:C? ;<TU: =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jk=?O$: ?S=NM:J-; 8$:;A:=;<?\7@ N3P\JUN /=RJ-;<K3L N |R7AN3:O8 a:; u ::JeU1 : RJU8ZX2 A8)R;bR J)?\; @ TU?u mJ B>)1 7 ; =?\5UK38 T)?u $: ':7 R a:&=>; ;AT):d[a:Z7 ?\7AQSRJU=: ? ?'5)7 8$:;A:=>;A?\7b$@ !U5$;S[)7<? UR UKML J)?;;<? R P'7<:&R; :_O;<:J-;&1moT):7A@: ?'7<:  uoR\@ w\:[$;R; ;AT): =?\J@ ;bRJ-f ; RK35): e)1 + u T):J [)7A?O8)5U=N3J)PS@ N3Q 5UK3R;<:8 8)R;ARU1 moT)D: RK35):@C ? hu T)N =bT 8$:;<:7<Q N3J):@E;AT):S@ ;A::[UJ):@A@C? v;<T): @<NMP'Q ?\N 8 @<KM?'[: uv:7<:SeU1 eU 2 e)132 RJU8 e)1 F\FU1 moT):&@ ': RK35):@ NMQ [)K3N3:8r;<TR; ;<TU: j u N38$;<T ? ;<T):D7A:P'NM?'Jk ? h;AT): @<NMP'Q?'N38ru NM;<T +*7RK35):@o;ATUR;R\7<:CJ)?\;e ?\7 $;AT): R\=;<5UR\K@9@ ? ;A?S@ [a:R\Qw  uv:7<:E2e'e\Ke -2&e\eERJU8 F\e6P\:J):v:_$[)7<:&@<@<?\J 5)J)NM;A@ u N 8$ : '7<:&@ [a:=;<N \:K3L\1`46J)K3L @ N3P\Q ?\N 8)@u NM;<T[?-@ NM;<N \:o@ K3?\[a:@u :7A:v[U7<?$8$5U=:68  :&=R\5U@ :9;<T):E@ N3P\JS ? a;AT):6@<K3?\[a:@ TU?\5)K 8 J)?; %R :=>;v;<T):[:I7 ?'7<QSRJ=:9 ? €R\JOL ? a;AT):68):;<:&=>;A?\7b@! 1 +ON3JU=: ;AT):68UR;AR [?'NMJ-;A@vR7A: 5)J)N ?\7AQ KML 8)N3@ ;<7AN U5$;<:&8 RK3?\JUP ;<TU:P':J)::_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'J R_$N3#@ ;<TU:@ ;<::[a:7E;<T):S@<KM?'[: ;<TUf: :uv:7E8UR;AR\[?'NMJ-;b@6u N3K3hK a: NMJV;<TU: e@ E @<TUR[a:97A:P\N3?\J 1 +O[a:=N /a=RK3K3 L -NMJS;AT):6=R\@<:9? : :&=R5@ :;<T):E@ K3?\[a:9N @v@<? S e e)29R\KMK8)R;bR[a?\N3J-;A@ R\7<: u NM;<TUNMJd;<T):Ee@ E @ TR[a

(55) RN; 'u TUN3=bT P\N \:&@;<T):68)R;bRDRCJ):R\7<K3L K3NMJU:R7 =?\7A7<j :K3R;<N3?\J1moT): [UR\7AR\Q :;<:#7 u TUN3=bT 8$:;<:7<Q N3J):@ ;AT):@<N ;A: ? ;<TU:e@ E @<TUR[a: ?\JV;<T):*_ E R_$N3#@ €uoR\@6[)N3=bw':8 7AR\JU8$?\Q K3 L 7<?'Q ;<T):S5UJ)N ?'7<Q 8)N3@ ;<7AN U5$;<N3?\J u T)?'@<T: ?'5)JU8)R\7<N3:@Eu :7A:@<:K3:=;<:8V@ ?r;ATUR;C;<TU: :J-;<N37A: I@ E @<TUR[a: ? `;<T): @ N3P\Q ?'N38 uoR\@u N ;AT)NMJ ;<T) : 1 e 2e'e\%e 2NMJ-;A:d7 sR\K1EmoT)N @5)JUN ?'7<Q 8$N @ ;A7<N )5$;ANM?'J uoR\@ 1 Eb2e\e'e j : Ee:-25 u T)N =bT J)::&8)@9@<?\Q :D:_$[)K RJUR;<N3?\J1v^ Q [)N37<N =R\K;<:@ ;<N3J)P @<T)?u :8k;<TUR; ;<T): :JU8)@9? ;<T): I@ E @ TUR\[: R\7<:CK3?$=R;A:8 R^; _ _ u T):J N3@6[?-@ NM;<N \: u TUN3=bT N @ ;AT): =R\@<: T):7<:'G1 +ON3JU=: ;<T)::JU8U@9? `;AT): I@ E @ TUR\[: @ T)?'5)K )8 : u N ;AT)N3J ;<TU: RJU8 _ NMJ-;A:d7 sR\,K 1 e 2&e\e'%e 25-u :CTU-R \j : ea _ _ : T O. O. ?. O. 7?. 6. ? B. ?. D 1 M D 3. . D 3. M. D 1. D 3. ?. . D 3. ? B ?. ?B ?. j. RJU8 ? B. _ : ?. ?. D2&e\e'j e. j. _. M. a _. ?. _C:. :. 2e\e'e a. B2&e\e\efa _. ?. j. M. ?. ?B[a. j. :fa. ?. j. :. j. j. ? B ? ? B. j. RJU8rT):JU=: 1 Eb2e'e\e j : Ee:-2 1 moT):9@ ;ARJ8)R7b8 8$:#ON3R;<N3?\J5U@ :&8 uoR\@ R'8-M 5U@ ;<:8 ;<?E;AT): 7AR\J)P\: ? ;<T): 8)R;ARU1^ _O[U7<:&@<@<:8 NMJ[:7A=:J-; ;<T): @ ;AR\JU8)R7b88$:$ON R;<N3?\J@ uv:7<: : v-2 : R\JU8 0 : d1rmoT)N3@ Q:&RJU@D;<TUR; R\@C;AT): 7bRJ)P': P\:JU::_$[)7<:&@<@<N3?\J sR\KM5U:@DN @ R\KMuoRsL$@ 2&e\e'ek5UJ)N ;b@Du N 8$: ;<TU: @ ;bRJU8UR7b8k8$#: ON3R;<N3?\J NMJ P':J):C:_$[)7A:@A@<NM?'JduoR\@|:eK€2N:\eR\JU8 0 :e5)JUN ;b@$)7A:@<[a:=>;AN':K3L\1>+ON3JU=: e + N3Jr;<T): @ N3Q 5)K R;ANM?'JU@# ;<T)^: +*7v7AR\J)P\:6u R'@oe)1 + 5)JUN ;b$@ $u T)N =bTrQ:&RJU@v;ATUR;o;<TU:C@ ;AR\JU8)R\7A8 8):$ON3R;<N3?\JU@ N3J +c7>RK35):@ u :7A:6S eU1 e\WK$e)132&0 RJU8re)1G0D5)JUN ;b@$ W? B.

(56) . . ?. M. . O. 2&e. 6.

(57) . 7<:&@ [a:=;<N\:KML'1 m ? P\:; R @ :JU@ : ? v;AT):SQ :RJUNMJ)P ? v;AT):@<:DRK35):@# =?'J-;<:Q [)K R;A:;<TUR; <\] ? oNMJc/J)N ;A:K3L QSRJOL <@ R\Q[UKM:&@ 7<?'Q R JU?\7AQ R\K8$N @ ;A7<N)5$;ANM?'J u NMK3KK3NM: u NM;<TUNMJ ?'J): @ ;bRJU8UR7b8k8$:#ON3R;<N3?\J 7<?'Q ;AT): :_$[a:=;AR;ANM?'J sR\KM5U: R\JU8 ] < ? ;<TU:Q u N ;AT)N3J ; uv?S@ ;ARJ8)R7b8d8$:#ON3R;<N3?\JU@1,+O:: R\K3@<?tN3P\5)7A:DF)1 moT): 8)R;AR\@<:;9@<)N (:@o5U@<:8ru :7Ab: :N2 :$F\eK:\e RJU8:)1h7 J tN3P\5)7A:DF ?'5)7 :_)R\Q[UKM:&@o? `8)R;bR\@<:;A@ R\7<:C@<T)?u J1

(58) . s D†sd}4su‚4‰}zuy  ‡ z3vxw@}H‚Z—[‚l}4ee‡I‚l}‚Htxz3‡suw-€ ‚H{|sutxtxe‚H}6‚l}5suw-€-sur4€b€-‰‘#v™sd}4vxz3w. ’ 6†sd}4su‚4‰}hzuy  ‡ z3vxw@}H‚ &v }HŒG{e€-vx”-{‚Htxz3‡ ,suwN€  ‚H{|sutxtxI‚l}6‚H}4suw-€%surH€b€-‰‘#v™sd}4vxz3wk. Š !†sd}5su‚H‰}zu y   ‡ z3vxw@}H‚ &v }HŒsd}l}HI‚l}‚Htxz3‡|suw-€ t™surH3e‚H}&‚H}4suw-€%surH€.€-‰‘#v™sd}4vxz3wk. € )†sd}4su‚4‰}Xzuy  ‡z3vxw@}4‚I—D{e€-vx”-{ ‚4txz3‡ suwN€  {e€-vx”-{ ‚H}4suw-€%surH€.€-‰‘#v™sd}4vxz3w. tNMP'5)7<:DF tU?\5)7 :_)RQ [)K3:@o? `@<NMQ 5)K3R;<:&8k8)R;AR'@ :;A@1 >. Yv?\JU@<:#P-5):J-;<K3L hR'@Du :TR\8V;<T)7A:: 8)N:7A:J-; @<KM?'[:&@$ ;<T)7A:: @ ;AR\JU8)R7b8 8$:$ON R;<N3?\J@DRJU80/K': 8)R;bR\@<:; @ N1(:&@$F F : W*: =?'Q )N3JUR;ANM?'JU@ ? [R7bRQ :;A:7@<:;<;<N3J)P'@uv:7<:D5U@<:81otU?\79:&R\=bT [UR\7AR\Q :;<:79@ :; ;ANMJ)Pr0e\eS@<N3P\Q ?\N 8 8)R;bR\@<:;A@fA ;AT): 8 [a?'8 @<N ;AS N':@uB RJU8 0\e\eC8)R;AR\@<:;b@`? Q ?$8$:K A ;AT):J):P'R;<N\:@uBhuv:7<: [U7<?$8$5U=:8€1 moT): 8)R;bR\@<:;A@ TUR\8 ;<TU:@<R\Q :9@ ;bRJU8)R\7A88$:#-N R;ANM?'J R\@o;AT): =?'7<7A:@<[a?\JU8$N3J)P @ N3P\Q ?'N38r8)R;bR\@<:;b@$)u TU:7A:R\@ uoR\@o7bRJU8$?'Q KML [UN3=bw':8 7<?'Q ;<TU:D5)J)N ?\7AQ 8$N @ ;A7<N)5$;ANM?'J 1 e 2$2 1 qKMK I. I. B. G. 2'2. B.

(59) 8)R;bR\@<:;b@ u :7A:S7AR\J)w\:&8OOLV;AT): ;AT)7A::k8):;<:&=>;A?\7b@$`RJ8 R X94DY P\7bR[)ToA@ ::k@<:=>;ANM?'J 0$1 FBCuoR\@ =?'JU@ ;A7<5=>;<:&8O ?\7 :R'=bT ? ;<T):Q 1 moT): X94DY P\7bR[UTU@=?\JU@<N3@ ;6? R;CQ ?'@ ;6W'e'eS[a?\N3J';b@$a;AT): :#\:J';E? v@<:$':7bRK 8UR;AR'@ :;A@6TUR-ONMJUPS;<T): @ARQ : 7bRJ)w u N3KMK KM?u :7 ;AT):CJ-5UQ a:7 ? [?'NMJ-;b@1`t)?'79=?'Q[R7AN3@<?\J ? ;AT):D8$:;A:=>;A?\7b@v;<T): m=B7AR;<:C=?'7<7A:@<[?'JU8$N3J)P ;A?SRt=B7AR;<:E? !: R\JU8 2e uv:7<:D@ ;<5U8)NM:&8€1 q9J :_)R\Q[UKM:D? X94DY =5)7Z':@ ? ;<TU:C;<T)7A::D8$:;<:=;<?'7A@oN @9@<T)?u JkN3J thN3P\5U7<:CWU1 . 1. 0.9. 0.8. 0.7. TP rate. 0.6. 0.5. 0.4. 0.3. 0.2. 0.1. 0. Modelling detector Regression detector Correlation coefficient 0. 0.1. 0.2. 0.3. 0.4. 0.5 FP rate. 0.6. 0.7. 0.8. 0.9. 1. thN3P\5U7<:CW `qJr:_)RQ [)K3:E? X94DY,=5)7d\:&@v? h;AT):C;<TU7<::C8):;<:&=>;A?\7b@1`tUR\K3@<:C[?-@ NM;<N\:D7bR;A:^: R\JU8 2&e R\7<:CQSR7Aw\:&8€1 >. .

(60) . q@o; u ?'RK35):@ u :7A:E[)N3=bw':8 7<?'Q :&R\=bTr?\J):C? ;<TU:DWk:X94DY =5U7Z':@#)R ;A?;bRK€? `]\eTRK35):&@ouv:7<:C:_)R\QN3J):&8€1 moT):D5)[)[a:7 RJU8 KM?u :7!a?\5)J8)R7AL ? ;<T):E]:   E  $E 6   E      1 ]24 7<?'Q JU?ux?'J 8$:JU?;<:&8   RJU8  -? €;<TU: m= 7bR;A:uoR\@ =R\K3=5)K3R;<:&8' ?\7 :R'=bTdRJU8d:$':7AL?'J):? ;<TU:@<:GRK35):&@1`moT):&@ :E=7A:8$N)N3KMNM; LSNMJ-;A:7dsR\K3@ ;<:KMK5U@ ?'5)7v5UJU=:7 ;bRN3J'; L Ra?\5$; ;AT):D;A7<5):Dm =Z7bR;A.: R\KM5):'1,75 `RJ)?\;<T):70e\e[a?'@<N ;AN':D8)R;b@ :;A@ u :7A:C[)7<?$8$5=:8ru NM;<Tr;<TU: @<R\Q:D[R7bRQ :;A:7 @ :; ;ANMJ)P-@$ uv:DQ N3P\T-; P\:;RJ)?\;<T):7om =x7bR;A:CR;t=B7bR;A:^: g ?'7o;<T): @ARQ :D8$:;A:=;<?\7&1 moT): [)7A?\P'7AR\QQ N3J)P:*J -N37A?\J)Q :J--;  q`2m ; q oA  R;<TOu ?\7Aw$@ 7 J=1 \GH +$.q Bh\:7A@<NM?'fJ <U1 :)1 e6u R'@NMQ [)K3?L\:&[8 ?\7 R\KMK)=RK =5)K R;ANM?'JU@1  q`2m ; q xu R'@`7<5UJ ?\J R @<:d7 \:7`? €:N3P\T-;v]'e\e  : (G<\W E5)N ; [U7<?$=:&@<@<?\7b@`@<TUR7ANMJUP RD[)7ANMQSR7AL Q :Q?'7<L? `N2 < ( 61OX 5)JUJ)NMJUP @ #: \:7AR\K  q`2m ;h q o@ N3Jd[R7bRK3KM:KM4K 'R\[)[)7A?s_ON3QSR;A:K3L ;AT)7<:: ? €;<T):&@ :6[)7<?$=:@A@ ?'7A@`u :7A:R;vQ LS8$N @<[?-@<R\HK -u TOL ;AT):C=RK =5UK3R;<N3?\J ;<N3Q :D;<? [)7A?$8$5U=:E;AT):@<:D7<:&@ 5UK ;b@ou R'@ R ?'5$;Ruv::wdR\JU8 RTURK 1 = =  q`= 2m ; q ." |@ 5)JU=>;ANM?' J QN3JU@<:R\7A=bTru R'@o5U@<:8k;<? @<:R\7A=bT ?\7 ;AT):DP\K3 ? UR\K€Q NMJ)N3Q 5UQ ? ;<TU[: 5)JU=;<N3?\JU@  A B3W  j A j BoR\JU8  A B1,moT): Q NMJ)N3Q )N (:D 7 Q N3JU=?'J RJU8 Q NMJO5)JU= uoR\@;A7<N3:8B?\5);dR\@ u :K3HK 9)5$; uoR\@SR RJU8$?'J):;8 a:=R\5U@<: Q N3JU@<:R7b=bT u n R'@Q n ?-@ ;E@: ? =N3:J-;6u TU:J ;A:@ ;<:;8 A+8)R;ARdJ)?;C@ T)?u QJ B9RJ8 ;<T):?\7A:;AN3=RK3KMLrQ ?'@ ;67A ? )5U@ ;1Eq9JV:J)TUR\JU=:&8 @ ;<::[:&@ ;C8$:@A=:J-; Q NMJ)N3Q )N (:7ouoR\@ N3Q [)K3:Q :J-;<:&68 c)5$; ;<TUN3@v?\J): -;<?OK? OuoR\@ R URJ8$?\J):&8€1 moT):7A:u :7A:[)7A ? UKM:Q @ u N ;AT (NMP (RP :TU-R ONM?'5)7vR\JU8 5)7<;<T):78$#: \:KM?'[)Q :J-; u R'@ =?'JU@<N38$:7<:&8 ;< ? a:dR uoR\@ ;<:S ? ;<N3Q :\1 q^@ Q NMJU@<:R\7A=bOT /JU8)@ K3?$=R\K Q NMJUNMQSR ;AT)7<::d8$N a:7<:= J-; @ ;bR7<;P\5U:@A@ :&@ uv:7<:DP'N ':J ;AD? Q NMJU@<:R\7A=b&T RJ8r;<T)f: :&@ ;7A:@<5)KMf; A N 1a:\1o;<TU: K3?O=RKQ N3J)N3Q 5)Q u NM;<T K3?uv:&@ |; R\KM5): ?  A BIB u R'@ =bT)?-@ :J1hmoTU:6@ ;AR7<; P\5U:@A@ :&@`uv:7<: 7bRJ8$?\Q K3L [)N =bw\:&8 NMJ ;AT):9[UR\7AR\Q:;<:7 7<?O?'Q 8$$: /UJ):8 -L ;<TU:95)J)N ?\7AQ8)N3@ ;<7AN U5$;<N3?\JU@ 1 e $2 2 1 eSeU1 +2 1 e)1 < @2 2 j 1 E eU1 FSeU1 F 2 RJU8 1 EuA 2e'e\e E‰:B E‰:%2 N uoR\@ [a?'@<NM;<N \: A+@<:: 8$:7AN R;<N3?\J R a%? \-: Bo?\7 1 : 2&e\e'e  j5 Ee:-2N j uoR\@9J):P-R;<N \ : A+@<NMQ N3K3R\768$:7<N R;< N3?\Jrj  ;A? ;<TU: =R'@ : u j NM;<T [?-@ NM;<N \: j B>1moT):7<: u R'@ RK @ ?d;<T):S=?\JU@ ;<7bRN3J-;;<TR;DRdJ):u @ ;AR7<;CP\5):&@<@6u R'@6R'==:[$;A:8 ?'J)K3L N ;AT): :5)wOK3N38)N3R\JV8$N @ ;bRJU=: ;A?d;AT):[)7<#: ONM?'5U@?'J):u R'@ .

(61).

(62). . . . G. B. 'U ?B. O. ?. >? %?. C?B. ?. ?. ?. 2s0. B.

(63) Ra?%\:DR =:7 ;bRN3Jd;AT)7<:&@ TU?\K 8RK35):'1 moT): NMJ-;A:P\7bRKoN3JBN: P-5UR;ANM?'J A 2 B4 RJ8 A 2&FB uoR\@ =R\K3=5)K3R;<:&8JO5)Q :7AN3=RK3KMLO 7A?\Q 10>_o: ;<? 0 : 1 465);A@<N38$:r;AT)N3@ NMJ-;A:d7 sR\HK ;AT): j n 465 4   [UR\7 ; ? ;<TU:dN3J';A:P'7AR\JU8 u R'@ R\@A@<5)Q :8V;<?0:r@ 5c? =NM:J';AKML =K3?'@<:S;A? e ;<?V7<:JU8$:7 ;<TU: :J-;<N37A:EN3J-;<:P\7bRJU8 R\[)[)7A?s_$NMQSR;A:K3LSe)1`q ;A:79:Q[UNM7AN3=RKa;<:&@ ;ANMJUPK)8$NON3@<NM?'Jd? ;<TU:EN3J-;<:P\7bR;<N3?\JdNMJ-;<:7ZR\KaN3J-;<?+\e'e [UR\7 ;b@ u R'@ 8$:=N38):8k;<D? a: RP\?O?$8d:J)?\5)P'TrR\[)[)7A?s_$NMQSR;ANM?'J1 moT):5UK ;ANMQSR;A:K3L 5U@ :&8 =?$8$:6=?\J@ N @ ;b@ ? R[)[)7A?s_$NMQSR;<:K3Ld2&F\e'eCKMN3J):@1  5U=bT Q ?\7A:9TU-R ': ::Jku 7<NM; ;A:JSN3JS;<?\;AR4K -? =?'5)7b@ :'1 q8)8)N ;ANM?'JURK=?$8$:DTUR'@ ::J 5U@<:8 ?\79R\KMK w-N3JU8)@9? ;<:@ ;<N3J)P R'@ouv:KMK R'@ R7ANM?'5U@ 8$:;A?\5)7b@1 q9K3KN3J RK3HK UR\[)[)7A?s_$NMQSR;A:K3LSW'e'e\e KMN3J):&@ ? `=?$8$:CTUR'@ ::J u 7<NM; ;A:J1 K8. 5. . . P Q. 3. 5. T Q TS. U. T. K8. M. U. T. 9  . om T):Dm=x7AR;<:@ N3JU=K35U8$N3J)P;<TU:N37   RJU8    UR\@o8$N @A=5U@A@ :&8 N3J @ :&=>;<N3?\J 0$1 WK$R7A:E[)7<:&@ :J-;<:8kN3JrmR)K3:2CR\JU8rmhR )KM:D0$1 46J):8$:;<:&=>;<?'7`N3@, 7<?'Q J)?ux?\JS@ARN 8 ;<?[a:|:; ;A:7 ;ATURJSR\J)?;AT):7N\R; RD@ [a:=N/=o[R7bRQ :;A:7 @<:; ;ANMJUPK\N €N ;b@   ? ;<TU:9m= 7AR;<: uoR\@9T)NMP'T):76?\79:NP-5URK ;<?S;AT): ?\;<T):78$:;A:=;<?\7N" @  1( ?\K 8 sR\KM5U:@9N3J =?'KM5UQJ@60SR\JU8: Q :R\J ;<TUR;;<TU: 8$:;A:=;<?\7 ? 9;ATUR; =?\K35)Q J uoR\f@ :; ;<:7;<TUR\J ;AT):r=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J=?-:$? =N3:J-; 8):;<:&=>;A?\7&1 v?'K38 RK35):@ NMJZ=?'KM5UQJ + Q :R\J;ATUR; ;<TU: =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'JV=?O$: ?S=NM:J-; 8$:;A:=>;A?\7D[a:7Z ?\7AQ :8 :; ;A:7D;ATURJ ;<TU:SQ?$8$:KMK3N3J)P 8$:;A:=;<?\7Nu T):7<:&R\@CNM;AR\KMN ='RK35):@CQ :R\J ;<TUR; ;<T):S7A:P'7<:&@<@<N3?\J 8$:;<:=;<?'7EuoR\@C8$$: :R;<:X8 OL ;<T):S=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?-:$? =N3:J-;C8):;<:&=>;A?\7&1  ?\K 8 NM;AR\KMN =@.RK35):@C7A:[U7<:&@ :J';C=R'@ :&@ u T):7A:C;<TU: =?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\Jk=?O@: ? =N3:J-;8$:;<:&=>;<?'7 [:I7 ?'7<Q :&8 a:;<;<:79;<TUR\Ja?;ATr? ?'5)798$:;<:=;<?'7A@1 moT): 7A:@<5)KM;A@9 ? t = 7bR;A: : RJU8 2&e 8)N :7A: 8 ':7ALdK3N ;<;<K3 : Uu TOLr?\J)K3L ;AT): 7A:@<5)KM;A@9 ? t = 7bR;A: : 7<?'Q T):7<:b ?'7 ;AT R7A: @ ;A5U8$N3:8€1vmoT):7A@: ?'7<: OR\KMK P\N \:Jrm =x7AR;<:@ R\7<:DR; t =Z7bR;Ab: : 5)J)K3:@A@o?;AT):7Au N @ :D@ ;AR;A:8€1 ] N @ 5RK3N3@AR;ANM?'JU@? a;<T):  m = 7AR;<:&@=RfJ :9@<::J N3JtN3P\5)7A|: :E tN3P\5)7A: *u T):7<: m = 7bR;<:&@ ?\7;<T):o;AT)7A:: 8$:;A:=;<?\7b@u N ;ATS] : T)N3P\T):&@ ;o[?-@ ;A:7ANM?'7v8$:JU@<N ; 'L a?\5)JU8UR7ANM:&,@ UR\7A@vR7A:6@<T)?u 'J ?\7oRK3KJUNMJ):C=?'Q )N3JUR;<N3?\JU@ ? @<KM?'[:&@vR\JU8 @ ;ARJ8)R7b8 8$#: -N R;ANM?'JU@1 . . . . .

(64) . .

(65) . .  6$&  *1 $&. rJ tN3P\5)7A:.: u :6@<::6;<TUR; ?'5)7oQ?$8$:KMK3N3J)P8):;<:&=>;A?\7 [:7I ?'7<Q :8d:_O;<7A:Q :KML u :K3Km ?'7 RK3Ka8)R;AR'@ :;o@<N)(:@vu T):Jd;<T):D@ ;AR\JU8)R7b8 8$:$ON R;ANM?'J uoR\@ ;AT):S@ QSR\KMK3:@ ;ER\JU8':7ALku :K3K`R;;AT):Q:&8$N35)Q @ ;ARJ8)R7b8 8$:#-N R;ANM?'J1Ct)5)7<;<T):7<Q ?'7<:aNM;Cu R'@Q 5U=bTXa:;<;<:7 ;<TUR\J ;AT): =?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\J =?O:@? =N3:J-;C?\J @<QSRK3K 8UR;AR'@ :;E@<N)(:@1Dt)?\7CN3JU@ ;ARJ=: u :@<::N3JVtNMP'5)7A:T:AlmB9;<TUR;Eu NM;<T Rd8)R;AR'@ :; @ 1N (: ? 9/K': [a?\N3J-;A#@ ;AT):S=?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\J =?O:@? =NM:J'; 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7DRJU8VQ ?O8):K3KMN3J)P 8$:;<:=;<?'7ETR\8 Rrm= 7bR;A:? R\[)[)7A?s_ON3QSR;A:K3L e)1G0$2 R\JU8 e)1 +:c 7<:&@ [a:=;<N\:K3L\1rt)?'7D;<T):dK3R\7<P':@ ;D@ ;AR\JU8)R\7A8 8$:$ON R;ANM?'J ?'5)7 Q ?$8$:K3K3NMJ)P 8):;<:&=>;A?\7 uoR\@ba:;<;<:7 ?\J)K3LVR; ;<TU: @ QSR\KMK3:@ ;8)R;bR\@<:;9@<)N (:\1 465)7E7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J 8$:;<:&=>;<?'76uoR\C@ :; ;A:7E;<TUR\J ;AT):=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?O$: ?S=NM:J-G; ?'7;AT):@<QSRK3KM:&@ ;C8)R;bR\@<:;C@ 1N (:R;DRK3K@ ;AR\JU8)R7b8 8$$: ON R;ANM?'JU@1 : ?uv#: \:#7  ;<T):d=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?O$: ?S=NM:J-; u R'[@ a:; ;A:7 R; ;AT):dK R7AP\:&@ ; 8UR;AR'@ :; @ 1N (:&$@  u T):7<:&R\@C;AT):7A: uoR\@DJU? @ N3P\JUN /=RJ-;98$N a:7<:JU=:DN3J [:I7 ?'7<QSRJ=:@oR; ;AT):DQ :8$N35)Q 8)R;bR\@<:;9@<)N (:@1 . 7.  " 1 $&. 9q P-RN3J

(66) O;<T):DQ ?$8$:KMK3NMJUP 8):;<:&=>;A?\7 [a:7Z ?\7AQ:&8':7ALSuv:KMKU ?'7o;<T): @<QSRK3KR\JU8kQ:&8$N35)Q @ ;AR\JU8)R7b8d8):$ON3R;<N3?\JU@#)@<::DtNMP'5)7<:b< RJU8 N3JU8$::8NM; u R'@h +R7 @<5)[a:7ANM?'7 ;<?C;AT):=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J =?-:$? =N3:J-; 8$:;A:=;<?\7, ?\7`;AT):9@ QSR\KMK3:@ ; 8)R;bR\@<:; @<N)(:9RJU8 @<NMP'J)N/=R\J';AKML :; ;A:7 R;S;<TU: @ :&=?'JU8 @ QSR\KMK3:@ ;d8)R;bR\@<:;d@<N)(:\1 t)?'7S;<T): K3R\7<P':@ ;d@ ;bRJU8)R\7A8Z8$:#ON3R;<N3?\J

(67)  ;<TU:7A: u R'@S?\J)K3LBR @ N3P\J)N/=RJ-; 8$N a:7<:JU=: NMJ ;<T):V[:I7 ?'7<QSR\JU=:&@ ? ;<T):&@ : ; uv?x8$:;A:=>;A?\7b@ ?'7d;AT):V@<QSRK3KM:&@ ; 8)R;bR\@<:; @ N1(:C)5$; T):7<:VJ):NM;<T):7k? ;<TU: 8$:;A:=;<?\7[:I7 ?'7<Q :8r@AR;<N I@ +R\=>;A?\7AL\1 2&F.

(68) 465)7E7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J 8$:;<:&=>;<?'76uoR\@C:; ;A:7E;<TUR\J ;AT):=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?O:$?S=NM:J-;G ?'7;AT):@<QSRK3KM:&@ ;C8)R;bR\@<:;C@ N1(:R;DRK3K@ ;AR\JU8)R7b8 8$:$ON R;ANM?'JU@1 : ?uv:#\:7# ;<T):d=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\J =?O:$?S=NM:J-; u R'@[a:; ;A:7 R; ;AT):dK R7AP\:&@ ; 8UR;AR'@ :; @ N1(:&@$ u T):7<:&R\@C;AT):7A: uoR\@DJU? @ N3P\JUN /=RJ-;98$Na:7<:JU=:DN3J [:7I ?'7<QSRJ=:@oR; ;AT):DQ :8$N35)Q 8)R;bR\@<:;9@<N)(:@1 )6 * ) $E. tNMP'5)7<:%D;<:K3K @o5U@v;<TUR; ?'7 ;<T):D@<Q R\KMK3:@ ; @ ;bRJU8)R\7A8d8$:$ON R;<N3?\Jd;<T):7<:EuoR\@ J)? @ N3P\J)N/=RJ-; 8$N:7A:JU=:EN3J ;AT):C[:7I ?'7<QSR\JU=:&@ ? v;<T): Q ?$8$:K3KMN3J)P RJU8 =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J =?O:@? =NM:J'; 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7A@#U?\;<T ? v;<T):Q [:7I ?'7<Q :&8 :_O;A7<:Q:KML u :K3K 1 t)?'76;AT): K3R\7<P':@ ; @ ;bRJU8UR7b8d8$#: -N R;ANM?'

(69) J O;<TU:C=?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\Jd=?O:@? =N3:J-;98$:;A:=;<?\7ouoR\@a:; ;A:7o;ATURJk;<T):CQ ?$8$:K3K3NMJ)PS8$:;<:&=>;<?'7 ?\7 @<Q R\KMK€8)R;AR'@ :; @ 1N (:&@1 : ?u $: ':N7 6 ?\7 ;<T): Q :&8$NM5UQ @ ;AR\JU8)R\7A8 8$:$ON R;ANM?'J

(70) h?'5)7 Q ?$8$:K3K3NMJ)PV8$:;A:=>;A?\7 [a:7Z ?\7AQ :8 a:; ;A:7 ?\J ;<T):k@ QSRK3K3:@ ; 8)R;bR\@<:;&1 t)?'7€;<T):v@ QSRK3K3:@ ;h@ ;bRJU8UR7b868$#: ON3R;<N3?\bJ ?\;<TD?'5)77A:P\7A:@A@<NM?'JE8$:;<:&=>;<?'7 RJ8;AT): =?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\JC=?O@: ? =N3:J-; 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7[a:7Z ?\7AQ:&8 \:7<LBuv:KM4K  RKM;<T)?'5)P\Tx;<TU: =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'JB=?O$: ?S=NM:J-; u R'@SP\:J):7bRK3KML :; ;<:71 t)?'7S;<TU: K3R\7<P':7S@ ;ARJ8)R7b8Z8$$: ON R;<N3?\J$@  ;<TU: 7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7kuoR\@dP\:J):7bRK3KM;L :; ;A:7 R;k;<T): @ QSRK3K3:@ ;r8)R;AR\@<:;r@ 1N (:Vu T):7A:R'@S;<TU:V=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J =?O@: ? =N3:J-;ru R'@ )7A?'R\8)KMLd@<[a:RwON3J)P;<T):Du N3J)J):79R;o;<TU:D?;<TU:798)R;AR\@<:;9@<)N (:@1 . "!  . )t ?'7 @<QSRK3Ka8)R;AR'@ :; @<N)(:@ RJU8SJU?; ;A?O?

(71) R; @<KM?'[:&@ ?'5)7vQ ?$8$:KMK3NMJUP 8$:;<:=;<?'7vuoR\@ Q 5U=bTa:;<;<:7#ON 1`:\1 N ; TUR\8dR T)N3P\T):7 ;A7<5U: [?-@ NM;<N\:E7bR;<:\;ATURJd;<T):C=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J =?O:@? =NM:J'; 8$:;<:=;<?'71 46J K R7AP\:7v8)R;AR\@<:;o@ N1(:&@ ;AT):@<:C8$:;A:=>;A?\7b@ [a:7Z ?\7AQ :86Ou NM;<TrR :u :_)=:[$;ANM?'JU@$$:NP-5URK3KMLkuv:KMK 1 moT):D?'J)K3Ld=N37A=5)QS@ ;bRJU=:@oN3J u T)N =bTk;AT): =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jk=?-:$? =N3:J-;9[:7I ?'7<Q :&8a:;<;<:7;<TUR\J ;<T):EQ ?$8$:K3KMN3J)P8$:;A:=>;A?\7 u R'@ u T):JS;<TU:6@<KM?'[:6u R'@`;<TU:

(72) R; ;A:@ ; RJ8 ;<T):C@ ;ARJ8)R7b8S8$:$ON R;ANM?'JSu R'@ K R7AP\:9?'7 Q :8$N35)Q R\JU8 ;<T): 8UR;AR'@ :;9@ 1N (:&@ uv:7<:C@<Q R\KMK 1 465)7 7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\J 8$:;<:&=>;<?'7 =?\5UK38 ?'J)K3L,8$@: :&R;r;<T): =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J,=?O@: ? =N3:J-; R;r;<T): @<Q R\KMK3:@ ; 8)R;bR\@<:;r@<1N ( : 6u T)N3KM: ;<TU: =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jk=?O$: ?S=NM:J-;ouoR\@ a:;<;<:7R;o;<TU:DK3R\7<P':@ ;o8)R;AR'@ :; @<1N (:@1`t)?'7o;<T):DQ :8)NM5)Q 8)R;bR\@<:;9@<)N (:#@ O;<T):7<:CuoR\@ P\:J):7bRK3KML J)? @<NMP'J)N /a=RJ-;98$N a:7<:JU=:CN3Jr;<T):D[a:Z7 ?\7AQSRJU=:@ ? ?\5)7 7A:P'7<:&@<@<N3?\Jd8$:;<:&=>;<?'79RJU8d;<TU: =?\7A7A:K R;<N3?\Jr=?O@: ? =NM:J';98$:;<:&=>;<?'71 . 2W.

(73) 

(74) ‹r5sd}He‚hsd}‹r4sd}4 ‹msur4su{‰}4er

(75) ‚4‰}l}4vxw-3‚  p     h€-‚  ‚H}H€    €-‚  ‚H}H€      p     h  p   h€-‚  ‚H}H€   (  €-‚   ‚l}4€.     p     h  p   h€-‚   ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚   ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.   (  €-‚:  ‚l}4€     p    0  p  0€-‚:  ‚l}4€      p    0€-‚:  ‚l}4€   (  €-‚:   ‚H}H€     p    0  p  0€-‚:   ‚H}H€      p    0€-‚:   ‚H}H€   (  €-‚:%  ‚H}H€     p    0  p  0€-‚:%  ‚H}H€      p    0€-‚:%  ‚H}H€   (  €-‚:  ‚H}H€     p    0 €-‚:  ‚H}H€      p    0  p  0€-‚:  ‚H}H€   (   p    0€-‚:9&  ‚H}H€    €-‚:9&  ‚H}H€      p    0  p  0€-‚:9&  ‚H}H€   (   p    %%>€-‚  ‚H}H€    €-‚  ‚H}H€      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚  ‚H}H€   (   p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.     p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.      p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.     p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.      p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚  ‚l}4€.    €-‚  ‚l}4€.      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚  ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.    €-‚9&  ‚l}4€.      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.   (  = = S. “bz$€-etxtxvxw-€Ne}I  

(76) Qsutx”-       ! "$#         ) 3       %        &  3     3           3     3       &    3     3     3      & ! #$# ! "$<   && ! <$"  %  ; $    ! #*          3             &>    3     3           3     3           ; $    ! "BA   & !-A   % ; $    ! #B,   &   (    ; $    ! #$"          3     3           3     3       %   . .      %  (  3        3  3    ( 3  3  3  3  3  3  3    &    3    &   &( 3        3  3    & 3  3     3       & 3        3        3  3     3  3    .    . 

(77) I3rHe‚4‚4vxz3wG€-‰}Z 

(78) Qsutx”-   .          !''  &    ( ! **   %&      %   &         %     &          %   &                  &    3    &                  (      %   &      %   &            &  &  !-"!;    !'.=  &    ( !-<"  %             &  &             &(   &&   %   &            &     &    &&      &         (     &          %   &         %      &       !-"$,   &   & !-=.*   &  &  ! *B,  %          (     &                (      (               &   &>   &   (               (      &      (               &   &(   &   %. š6z3rHrZŠez$ m€-‰}Z  

(79) Usutx”-          & +-,."   (( /01    2436545    54367.8   % /01    3     2436545    3     3     /01    /01    /01    /01     (  %    )   (               &&   %   %  &  /01      %      &   ( 3     ?          /01    /01    @            )   ((      )(            &            %         &&   % 3       (          /01          D   .  . 3       % 3  3     3  3  3  3  3  3  3  3  3    %&  %    )%   &      & 3       & 3       % 3  3    &      (   C&   (            %   & 3        3       . mhR )K3: 2 m 7bR;<:&@ R;vt 7AR;<: e)1 e:)1  ?'K38'RK35):&@ N3J =?\K35)Q JU@ 0DRJU8:EQ:&RJS;ATUR; ;<T):E8$:;A:=>;A?\7v? ;<TUR; =?\K35)Q JSu R'@ :; ;A:79;ATURJr;AT): =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'Jk=?-:$? =N3:J-;1G ?'K38RK35):@oN3J =?'KM5UQJ+ Q :R\Jd;ATUR;;<T): =?\7A7<:K3R;<N3?\Jk=?O:@? =N3:J-;9[a:7Z ?\7AQ:&8 :; ;A:7 ;ATURJk;<T):DQ ?$8$:KMK3NMJUP 8):;<:&=>;A?\7N$u T):7A:R'@vNM;AR\KMN =.RK35):@oQ :R\Jd;ATUR; ;AT):C7<:P\7A:@A@ N3?\Jk8$:;A:=>;A?\7 uoR\@o8$:$ :R;A:8OLS;<TU: =?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J =?O:@? =N3:J-;1 ?\K 8 NM;ARK3N =@,R\KM5):&@ 7A:[)7A:@<:J-;v=R\@<:@`u TU:7A: ;<T):E=?'7<7A:K R;ANM?'J=?-:$? =N3:J-;v[a:7Z ?\7AQ :8'a:; ;A:7v;<TUR\J ?\;<T ? ?\5U798$:;A:=>;A?\7b@1 . . 2-:.

(80) 

(81) ‹r5sd}He‚hsd}‹r4sd}4 ‹msur4su{‰}4er

(82) ‚4‰}l}4vxw-3‚  p     h€-‚  ‚H}H€    €-‚  ‚H}H€      p     h  p   h€-‚  ‚H}H€   (  €-‚   ‚l}4€.     p     h  p   h€-‚   ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚   ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚%  ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚  ‚l}4€.   (   p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.     p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.      p     h€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.   (  €-‚:  ‚l}4€     p    0  p  0€-‚:  ‚l}4€      p    0€-‚:  ‚l}4€   (  €-‚:   ‚H}H€     p    0  p  0€-‚:   ‚H}H€      p    0€-‚:   ‚H}H€   (  €-‚:%  ‚H}H€     p    0  p  0€-‚:%  ‚H}H€      p    0€-‚:%  ‚H}H€   (  €-‚:  ‚H}H€     p    0 €-‚:  ‚H}H€      p    0  p  0€-‚:  ‚H}H€   (   p    0€-‚:9&  ‚H}H€    €-‚:9&  ‚H}H€      p    0  p  0€-‚:9&  ‚H}H€   (   p    %%>€-‚  ‚H}H€    €-‚  ‚H}H€      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚  ‚H}H€   (   p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.     p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.      p    %%>€-‚   ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.     p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.      p    %%>€-‚%  ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚  ‚l}4€.    €-‚  ‚l}4€.      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚  ‚l}4€.   (   p    %%>€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.    €-‚9&  ‚l}4€.      p    %%%>  p  %>€-‚9&  ‚l}4€.   (  = = S. “bz$€-etxtxvxw-€Ne}I  

(83) Qsutx”-       ! #$<          3       %   &  &     3     3          % 3     3     3     3     3     3      & ! #$# ! #$    ! =B,    3                & 3             &&   % 3     3       %   & 3     3           ; $    ! "$"   ( !-A#   ( ; $    ! #B,         ( ; $            (   & 3     3           3     3       %   . .         & 3        3  3     3  3  3  3  3  3  3    %    3    &   &% 3       & 3  3     3  3     3    (    3        3        3  3     3  3    .   . 

(84) I3rHe‚4‚4vxz3wG€-‰}Z 

(85) Qsutx”-   .      %      &   (   &   %      &   %   &      (                  %   &                     ( 3    &                  %      %   &      %   &            &  && !-"<    !'.#   &%    ! *B'               &   &            &      %   &            &  &    &&   (      &         %      &   (   &   %   &         %             !-"$'   (    !' ;      && !A.<            %      &&   %   &         &(      (      &        &    &&   (   (               %  &          (         (         &>      . š6z3rHrZŠez$ m€-‰}Z  

References

Related documents

Values of in vitro resistance for 39 drugs were collected with FMCA (fluorometric microculture cytotoxicity assay), gene copy number and gene expression for 11246 genes

IM 1 drive behaviour from motor mode to generator mode (ramp of 500 rpm/s, 100% of the rated load, experimental): (a) reference speed, (b) estimated speed, (c) actual

hSOX9, naturally expressed by the human cell line, increased significantly in both MB002 and MB002/S9wt cells after treatment with high concentrations of Doxycycline or

17 Other findings where LightCycler FastStart DNA Master SYBR Green I kit (Roche Diagnostics) showed higher sensitivity than Mastermix 16S Basic Kit (Molzym) included higher

This study aimed to examine whether response bias (beta) and sensitivity index (d´) for odor detection correlate with self- rated health, CI, stress and distress.. The

Carina Claesson Staph ylococci and Enter ococci Link

that wind tunnel cells are removed from the body over- set region, as it happens for the body cells inside the other different regions.. The interface between the wind tunnel and

To display our setup’s increased collection efficiency, we trap 3.1 µm polystyrene beads in MQ water and measure their Raman spectra with the condenser and objective parfocal to