1XPHULVNDYlUGHQ
'DWDEHVWlPGDDYEURDUVXWIRUPQLQJ
(JHQW\QJG
)DNWRUQνXWWU\FNHUUHODWLRQHQPHOODQODVWHIIHNWHUQDDYHJHQW\QJGRFKWnJODVW
(QOLJWHNYlU ν =* *
4
EP GP
+lUEHKDQGODVHQGDVWYHUWLNDODODVWHURFKGHWNDQGnYDUDULPOLJWDWWDQWDDWWODVW
HIIHNWHUQDVNXOOHYDUDQlUDOLNDYLGOLNDHJHQW\QJGRFKWnJODVWUlNQDWLN1P 'HWWDVNXOOHLQQHElUDDWWERFKGVlWWVOLND2PPDQERUWVHUIUnQGHQDOOUDPHVW ORNDOD LQYHUNDQ E|U YlUGHW Snν* YDUD WlPOLJHQ REHURHQGH DY EHODVWDG OlQJG
7nJODVWHQVQRPLQHOODYlUGHlUN1PRFKPHGHOYlUGHWP4 = λ4 VHQ NDQDQWDVYDUDQnJRWVW|UUHJHQRPDWWλDQWDVYDUDVH'HWWDLQQHElU DWWν =* P* (Q EHG|PQLQJ DY ULPOLJD YlUGHQ I|U P* I|U VWnOEURDU RFK EHWRQJEURDUJHUVRPJHQRPVQLWW
I|UVWnOEURDU ν*
I|UEHWRQJEURDU ν*
%lUI|UPnJD
%lUI|UPnJDQKDUEHVNULYLWVHQOLJWHNY
5 &DI=
)|UEHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQHUGnEHWRQJHQVKnOOIDVWKHWlUDYJ|UDQGHlURVlNHUKHWHQLGH JHRPHWULVND VWRUKHWHUQD D OLWHQ RFK I|UVXPPDV KlU 2VlNHUKHWHQ L GHQ QRPL
QHOODKnOOIDVWKHWHQEHVWlPGWH[JHQRPSURYQLQJDYNXEHUlUDYVWRUOHNVRUG
QLQJHQ03DYLONHWPHGPI∼03D.JHU9I 2VlNHUKHWHQLEH
UlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQ EUXNDU NXQQD EHVNULYDV JHQRP YDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ 9&∼
9IRFK9&JHUWLOOVDPPDQV95 = + +nOOIDVWKHWHQVND
UDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHVYDUDUXQJHIlUPRWIUDNWLOHQYLONHWPRWVYDUDUNI
RFK JHU YlUGHW IN =PI H[S
(
−N 9I I)
=P %HUlNQLQJVPRGHOOHQ lU RIWD VnI YDOGDWWGHQlUSnVlNUDVLGDQRFKVYDUDUXQJHIlUPRWHQIUDNWLOGYVN&RFK &N =P&H[S
(
−N 9& &)
=P&H[S(
− ⋅)
=P 9LGDUH VlWWV&$
N = D
D P 'HWWD JHU 5N =& D IN N N =P P& DPI =P P P& D I =P 5 0HGγ =I ⋅ = I|UVlNHUKHWVNODVVEOLUGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHW
= =
N
G 5 5
5 P
)|UVWnONRQVWUXNWLRQHUNDQI|OMDQGHYlUGHQDQVHVULPOLJD9I 9D 9&
YLONHWJHU95 +nOOIDVWKHWHQVNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHVYDUDUXQJHIlU PRWIUDNWLOHQGYVNI∼RFK IN =PI H[S
(
− ⋅)
=P 3nVDPPDIVlWW VRP RYDQ HUKnOOV &N =P&H[S
(
−N 9& &)
=P&H[S(
− ⋅)
=P &0HG DN OLND PHG PHGHOYlUGHW EOLU Gn 5N =P P& DPI =
P P P& D I =P 0HG5 γ =I ⋅ = EOLUGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHW
= =
N
G 5 5
5 P
%lUI|UPnJHYlUGHQDlUVDPPDQVWlOOGDL7DEHOO
7DEHOO'DWDI|UElUI|UPnJDQ5
$YJ|UDQGHPDWHULDO 95 5 PG 5
%HWRQJ
6WnO
2P DUPHULQJHQ L EHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQHU lU DYJ|UDQGH EOLU I|UKnOODQGHQD QlUD OLNDGHPVRPJlOOHUI|UVWnONRQVWUXNWLRQHU
%HODVWDGOlQJG
7UHROLNDYlUGHQSnDQWDJHQEHODVWDGOlQJG/WDVPHGLEHUlNQLQJDUQD'HVVDlU NQXWQDWLOOWnJHQVHQKHWHUSnI|OMDQGHVlWWVHDYVQLWW
/ P%HODVWQLQJIUnQHQERJJLH / P%HODVWQLQJIUnQHQYDJQ / P%HODVWQLQJIUnQIHPYDJQDU
$
'DWDEHVWlPGDDYWnJODVWHQ
$OOPlQQDGDWD
'HXSSJLIWHUMDJHUKnOOLWRPD[HOWU\FNHQRFKD[ODUQDVSODFHULQJI|UHQYDJQnWHU
JHVL)LJ
(QYDJQ PHWHU
N1 N1 N1 N1
)LJ$[HOWU\FNRFKD[HODYVWnQGI|UHQYDJQ
(WWWnJEHVWnU QRUPDOW DYORN RFK YDJQDU0DQSODQHUDU DWW N|UD WnJ SHU G\JQ7nJHQVKDVWLJKHWNDQXSSJnWLOONPKPV9DUMHYDJQDYVHVYlJDV LQQDQGHQInUJnXWSnVSnUHWI|UNRQWUROODYDWWODVWHQLQNOXVLYHW\QJGHQDYYDJ
QHQLQWH|YHUVWLJHU×N1'HQQDODVWEHQlPQVLGHWI|OMDQGHQRPLQHOOODVW RFKEHWHFNQDV4Q7RWDOQRPLQHOOODVWEOLUVnOHGHVI|UGHROLNDEHODVWDGHOlQJGHU
QDHQOLJW
/ P4Q N1 / P4Q N1 / P4Q N1
([FHQWULFLWHWDYVSnUHWRFKVQHGEHODVWDGHYDJQDUDQVHVNXQQDJH HQ |NQLQJ DY ODVWHIIHNWHUQDPHG'HWWDEHDNWDVJHQRPNRHIILFLHQWHQλ
6WDWLVWLVNDGDWD
'HYlUGHQSnVlNHUKHWVLQGH[βVRPDQJHVL%.5JlOOHUI|UUHIHUHQVWLGHQHWWnU
2PGHVVDYlUGHQVNDOOWLOOlPSDVLQQHElUGHWWDDWWGHVWDWLVWLVNDGDWDVRPVNDOODQ
YlQGDVVNDOOJlOODWnJODVWHQVPD[LPDODYlUGHXQGHUHWWnU
2PWnJODVWHQVVWRUOHNKDUHQ|YUHJUlQVEOLUGHQPD[LPDODWnJODVWHQXQGHUHWWnU P\FNHWQlUDHWWGHWHUPLQLVWLVNWYlUGHOLNDPHGGHQ|YUHJUlQVHQ'HWWDNDQEH
O\VDVHQOLJWI|OMDQGHH[HPSHO
0HGGHI|UXWVlWWQLQJDUVRPDQJHWWVLDYVQLWWNRPPHUHQEURDWWSDVVHUDVDY
⋅ WnJSHUnUYLONHWPRWVYDUDU⋅ VHWRPIHPYDJ
QDU'HVVDVHWNDQDQVHVXWJ|UDVWDWLVWLVNWREHURHQGHKlQGHOVHU'HQVWD
WLVWLVNDI|UGHOQLQJHQI|UODVWHQ4YLGHWWHQVWDNDODVWWLOOIlOOHDQWDVYDUDHQWUXQNH
UDG QRUPDOI|UGHOQLQJ )4[ PHG HQ IUHNYHQVNXUYD I4[ HQOLJW )LJ D
$
( )
= − 4 4
[ 4 P V GlUV4lUVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHQV4 =P 9 )|UGHOQLQJHQDQWDV4 4 WUXQNHUDG YLG[= ± GYV YLG4 P= 4 ±V )|UGHOQLQJVIXQNWLRQHQ I|U GHW4
0RWVYDUDQGHIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQIPD[4[YLVDVI|UQ L)LJE
D I4[
[
gYUHJUlQV
E IPD[4[
)LJ)UHNYHQVNXUYRUI|UDI4[RFKEIPD[4[
,GHWWDH[HPSHOEOLUPD[4QlUDHWWGHWHUPLQLVWLVNWYlUGH4 P= 4+V 4
+HOWQDWXUOLJWPnVWHGHWH[LVWHUDHQ|YUHJUlQVI|UVWRUOHNHQDYODVWHQDYHQYDJQ
2PDOODYDJQDUYlJVJHVP|MOLJKHWDWWYlOMDHQ|YUHJUlQVI|UODVWHQVVWRUOHNRFK DWWNRQWUROOHUDDWWGHQLQWH|YHUVNULGV+lUDQWDVDWWHQVnGDQJUlQVKDUYDOWVRFK DWWGHQlUNQXWHQWLOOGHQQRPLQHOODODVWHQ4QHQOLJWVDPEDQGHW
* = η Q
4 4
'HWWDLQQHElUDWWLGHI|OMDQGHEHUlNQLQJDUQDVlWWVP4 = ηλ4 RFK9η 4 , IRUPOHUQDHUVlWWVDOOWVnλPHGηλ%HUlNQLQJDUQDJHQRPI|UVI|UROLNDYlUGHQSn η9LGWLOOlPSQLQJDYSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQVlWWV4N 4Q
'\QDPLVNWWLOOVNRWW
'HQG\QDPLVNDGHOHQDYWnJODVWHQKDUHQOLJWHNYVNULYLWV
= ϕ
G\Q Q
4 4
9LGWLOOlPSQLQJDYSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQlUGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHW
$
= γ ϕ
G\Q G Q 4 Q
4 4
GlU γ4lUVDPPDSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWVRPI|UWnJODVWHQL|YULJW ϕQlUGHWYlUGHSnGHWG\QDPLVNDWLOOVNRWWHWVRPJHVLQRUPHQ
9lUGHQSnϕQI|UGHROLNDEHODVWDGHOlQJGHUQDKDUEHUlNQDWVLELODJD)|OMDQGH YlUGHQKDUHUKnOOLWV
/ P P P
ϕQ
9LGWLOOlPSQLQJDYHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGEHWUDNWDVϕHQOLJWDYVQLWW
VRPHQVWRNDVWLVNYDULDEHOPHGPHGHOYlUGHPϕRFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW9ϕ 'HG\QDPLVNDODVWHUQDNDQDQWDVYDUDEHKlIWDGHPHGVWRUDRVlNHUKHWHU9lUGHWSn 9ϕlUI|UPLJRNlQW(WWYlUGH9ϕ NDQYDUDHQULPOLJJLVVQLQJ
0DQNDQI|UPRGDDWWXWWU\FNHQI|UEHUlNQLQJDYϕQHQOLJWELODJDEHVWlPWVJH
QRPQnJRQIRUPDYREVHUYDWLRQHUSnEURDU0DQNDQRFNVnI|UPRGDDWWVnGDQD REVHUYDWLRQHUXWYlUGHUDWVVnDWWEHUlNQLQJVUHJOHUQDlUSnVlNUDVLGDQGYVDWWEH
UlNQDGH G\QDPLVND ODVWHU NDQ I|UYlQWDV |YHUVNULGDV HQGDVW L HQ OLWHQ DQGHO DY EHUlNQDGH IDOO 'HWWD NDQ LOOXVWUHUDV L )LJ VRP YLVDU HQ IUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQ QRUPDOI|UGHODG I|U GHQ G\QDPLVND ODVWHQ 4Qϕ YDUYLG YDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ DQWDJLWVYDUD94Qϕ =9ϕ ='LPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHWYLGWLOOlPSQLQJDYSDUWL
DONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQGYV4G\QG =4Q 4 Qγ ϕ KDUDQWDJLWVPRWVYDUDHWWYlUGHOLND PHGPHGHOYlUGHWHQVWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHYLONHWJHU
$
(NY JHU Pϕ = γ ϕ4 Q
(
+9 0HGϕ)
γ4 RFK 9ϕ EOLUϕ =ϕQ
P
9LGWLOOlPSQLQJDYHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGDQYlQGVVnOHGHVI|OMDQGHYlU
GHQ
/ P P P
Pϕ
9ϕ
$FFHSWDEHOIRUPHOOEURWWVDQQROLNKHWβYlUGH
,%.5DQJHVLDYVQLWWYlUGHWβ≥I|UVlNHUKHWVNODVVRFKI|UUHIHUHQV
WLGHQHWWnUβ DQYlQGVLEHUlNQLQJDUQDLGHWI|OMDQGH
$
%HUlNQLQJDUQDVJHQRPI|UDQGHRFKUHVXOWDW
%HUlNQLQJDUQDVJHQRPI|UDQGH
9DGEHWUlIIDUEURDUQDVXWIRUPQLQJKDUEHUlNQLQJDUQDJHQRPI|UWVI|UIDOOVWnO
NRQVWUXNWLRQRFKEHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQRFKI|UYDUGHUDWUHEHODVWDGHOlQJGHU/
P/ PRFK/ PHQOLJWDYVQLWW)|U|YULJDGDWDKDUGHYlUGHQ VRPDQJHVLNDSDQYlQWV'HVVDYlUGHQKDULQWHYDULHUDWVPHGXQGDQWDJI|Uη VDPWI|UβRFKν*VRPI|UVWnONRQVWUXNWLRQlYHQVDWWVWLOOβ RFKν* I|U / P
(WWYlUGHKDUYDOWVSnηGYVI|UKnOODQGHWPHOODQWnJODVWHQV|YUHJUlQVRFKGHW QRPLQHOODYlUGHW)|UGHWWDYlUGHSnηKDUHUIRUGHUOLJWYlUGHSn] P G4= 5 Q EHUlNQDWVHQOLJW HNY 0HG YlUGHW Sn] NlQW EHUlNQDV HUIRUGHUOLJWγ4 XU HNY
%HUlNQLQJDUQDVUHVXOWDW
%HUlNQLQJDUQDVUHVXOWDWYLVDVL)LJDII|UGHIDOOHQVRPQlPQWV L DYVQLWW
(UIRUGHUOLJWYlUGHSnγ4DQJHVVRPIXQNWLRQDYηI|UYlUGHQSnηVRPJHU γ4≤
$
6WnONRQVWUXNWLRQHU %HWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQHU
)LJγ4VRPIXQNWLRQDYηI|UROLNDIDOO
$
.RPPHQWDUHU
$Y )LJ IUDPJnU DWW EHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQHU lU J\QQVDPPDUH GYV JHU OlJUH YlUGHSnγ4YLGJLYHWYlUGHSnηlQVWnONRQVWUXNWLRQHU'HWWDEHURUI|UPRGOLJHQ WLOOVWRU GHO Sn DWW EURQV HJHQW\QJGXWJ|UVW|UUH DQGHODYGHQ WRWDOD ODVWHQ YLG EHWRQJNRQVWUXNWLRQHU
9LGDUH lU Sn VDPPD VlWW I|UKnOODQGHQD J\QQVDPPDUH MX VW|UUH GHQ EHODVWDGH OlQJGHQlU'HWWDWRUGHWLOOVWRUGHOEHURSnDWWGHG\QDPLVNDHIIHNWHUQDPLQVNDU
UHODWLYWVHWWYLG|NDQGHEHODVWDGOlQJG
+lUE|USnSHNDVDWWGHWlPOLJHQJ\QQVDPPDI|UKnOODQGHQDVRPIUDPJnUDY)LJ
KDUVRPI|UXWVlWWQLQJDWWODVWHQKDUHQ|YUHJUlQVVRPNDQEHVWlPPDVRFK NRQWUROOHUDV9lJQLQJDYYDJQDUQDNDQRFNVnPHGI|UDDWWVSULGQLQJHQLODVWYlU
GHQD YDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ94PLQVNDU-DJJHQRPI|UGHLGHWWDVDPPDQ
KDQJHQDQQDQEHUlNQLQJVRPLQWHUHGRYLVDVHIWHUVRPGHQLQWHJDYQnJRWSnWDJ
OLJWUHVXOWDW,GHQQDEHUlNQLQJDQWRJVDWWWnJODVWHQVDNQDGH|YUHJUlQVPHQDWW YlJQLQJHQPHGI|UGHDWWVSULGQLQJHQKRVODVWHQ94PLQVNDGHDYVHYlUWXQJHIlU WLOOKlOIWHQ0HGULPOLJDYlUGHQSn94RFKL|YULJWVDPPDI|UXWVlWWQLQJDUVRP UHGRYLVDWVLNDSYLVDGHGHWVLJDWWGHQQDPLQVNQLQJDY94KDGHP\FNHWOLWHQ LQYHUNDQSnYlUGHWSnγ4
)OHUDDYGHI|UXWVlWWQLQJDUVRPUHGRYLVDWVLNDSlURVlNHUWEHVWlPGDQnJUDlU KHOWRFKKnOOHWJLVVDGH0HGKlQV\QWLOOGHWWDNDQGHWNDQVNHDQVHVPRWLYHUDWDWW JHQRPI|UDEHUlNQLQJDUQDI|UROLNDYlUGHQSnGHLQJnHQGHVWRUKHWHUQDWH[I|U GHG\QDPLVNDHIIHNWHUQD'HWWDVNXOOHLQQHElUDHQQnJRWXWYLGJDGVWXGLHYLONHW JLYHWYLVlUKHOWP|MOLJWDWWJHQRPI|UD'HQQDVWXGLHKDUEHJUlQVDWVLGHWWDDYVH
HQGHLDYVLNWDWWSnQnJRUOXQGDNRUWWLGJHQnJUDUHVXOWDW
$
(WWYlUGH α ϕQHJDWLYWDQWDV
ϕ ϕ
1 EHUlNQDV2Pα − αϕ ϕ′ lUVW|UUHlQDFFHSWDEHOWYlOMVHWWQ\WW
ϕ′
α RFKUHSHWHUDV
$
1lUα ≈ αϕ EHUlNQDVϕ α = −* ν λ* 9* α = −4 λ94 α =5 ψ95
1 1 1
)|UDQYlQGQLQJYLGSDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQEHUlNQDV
= 5 = ψH[Sα β5 5
Q
] P 9
G4
$
Q / |YUHJUlQV
/ EHODVWDGOlQJG/ RFKPHWHU Y KDVWLJKHWY PV
'HWWDJHU
%
%,/$*$%
'HQQDELODJDlUHQDYVNULIWDYGHODUDY$YVQLWWL$.$OOPlQQDUHJOHUI|U ElUDQGHNRQVWUXNWLRQHU3ULQFLSHUUHNRPPHQGDWLRQHURFKNRPPHQWDUHUVDPWH[HPSHOSn WLOOlPSQLQJ 6WRFNKROP 6WDWHQV 3ODQYHUN 5DSSRUW QU $YVQLWW
3ULQFLSHUI|UHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRGRFKI|USDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQ
,DYVNULIWHQKDUI|OMDQGHEHWHFNQLQJDUlQGUDWVI|UDWWVWlPPD|YHUHQVPHG|YULJD GHODULUDSSRUWHQ
0HGHOYlUGH 6P⇒P6
5P⇒P5 ξP⇒Pξ
ηP⇒Pη
6WDQGDUGDYYLNHOVH σ⇒V
9DULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQW δ5⇒95
'HWHUPLQLVWLVNDNRHIILFLHQWHU P⇒E Q⇒G
%URWWVDQQROLNKHW ε⇒SI
%
3ULQFLSHU I|U HQ VDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVN PHWRG RFK I|U SDUWLDONRHIILFL
HQWPHWRGHQ
$OOPlQW
'HWI|OMDQGHDYVQLWWHWLQQHKnOOHULI|UHQNODGIRUPGHQWHRUHWLVNDEDNJUXQGHQWLOO GHQWLGLJDUHEHVNULYQDVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQ
0HWRGHQVIRUPHOODXWIRUPQLQJlUQnJRWDQQRUOXQGDlQGHQVRPEHVNULYLWVWLGL
JDUHPHQLVDNlUPHWRGHUQD GHVDPPD6NlOHWWLOO GHWWDlU DWW PDQ GlULJHQRP NDQInHQI|UNODULQJWLOOPHWRGHQ9DGVRPVNULYVLGHWWDDYVQLWWVNDOOGRFNLQWH EHWUDNWDVVRPQnJRWEHYLVI|UPHWRGHQVULNWLJKHW
'HQKlUEHVNULYQDPHWRGHQNDQDQVHVKDHQIUnQVDQQROLNKHWVV\QSXQNWPHUDOR
JLVNXSSE\JJQDGlQGHIOHVWDDQGUDPHWRGHU'HWWDEHK|YHUHPHOOHUWLGLQWHEH
W\GDDWWGHQJHUULNWLJDUHUHVXOWDWlQDQGUDPHWRGHU'HQEHWUDNWDVI|UQlUYDUDQ
GH DOOPlQW VRP PHUD NRPSOLFHUDG lQ W H[ SDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQ 'HW lU GRFNP|MOLJWDWWGHQRPGHQLHQIUDPWLGKDUXWYHFNODWVPHUDNRPPHUDWWEH
WUDNWDVVRPHQNODUHlQ|YULJDPHWRGHUMXVWSnJUXQGDYDWWGHQlUPHUORJLVN
NRQVHNYHQWRFKUHQRGODG'HVVDHJHQVNDSHUNDQUHGDQLGDJPHGI|UDDWWGHQlU GHQOlPSOLJDVWHPHWRGHQI|UYLVVDW\SHU DY GLPHQVLRQHULQJVSUREOHP 0DQ E|U RFNVnREVHUYHUDDWWGHQVRPGLPHQVLRQHULQJVPHWRGVNDOOEHWUDNWDVVRPHQPH
(QVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNPHWRG
)|UHQNHOKHWVVNXOODQWDVDWWSUREOHPHWLQQHKnOOHUHQGDVWI|OMDQGHWYnYDULDEOHU
− ODVWHIIHNWHQ6VRPKlUDQWDVYDUDQRUPDOI|UGHODGRFKKDPHGHOYlUGHWP6RFK VWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHQV6
− ElUI|UPnJDQ 5 VRP DQWDV YDUD ORJDULWPLVNW QRUPDOI|UGHODG RFK KD PHGHO
YlUGHWP5RFKYDULDWLRQVNRHIILFLHQWHQ95
'HQVWDWLVWLVNDIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQI65I|UYDULDEOHUQD6RFK5NDQLHWWNRRUGL
QDWV\VWHP65InVNnGOLJJ|UDVJHQRPHQ\WDLU\PGHQVRPL65SODQHWEHVNULYV JHQRPQLYnOLQMHUVRPYDURFKHQDQJHUHWWNRQVWDQWYlUGHSnI65HQOLJWILJXU
'HQ YRO\P VRP ILQQV XQGHU \WDQ RFK LQRP HWW RPUnGH$ L 65SODQHW DQJHU VDQQROLNKHWHQI|UDWWPDQVNDOOInHQNRPELQDWLRQDY6RFK5VRPIDOOHULQRP GHWWDRPUnGHVHILJXU'HQWRWDODYRO\PHQXQGHU\WDQlUOLNDPHG
%
)LJXU )UHNYHQVIXQNWLRQ I65 RFK OLQMHQ $ VRP UHSUHVHQWHUDU EURWWYLOONRUHW
)LJXU 2PUnGHW $ RFK PRWVYD
UDQGHYRO\PXQGHU\WDQI65
2P6RFK5lUVWDWLVWLVNWVHWWREHURHQGHYLONHWDQWDVKlUNDQI65GHODVXSSVn DWW
65 = 6 5
I I I
GlU
I6lUIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQI|U6HQEDUW
I5lUIUHNYHQVIXQNWLRQHQI|U5HQEDUW
9LOONRUHWI|UDWWEURWWLQWHVNDOOLQWUlIIDVNULYHVJHQHUHOOW
(
6 5)
Θ ≥
YLONHWVDPEDQGNDQnVNnGOLJJ|UDVL65SODQHWPHGHQNXUYD$HQOLJWILJXU
)|UYlUGHNRPELQDWLRQHUI|U6RFK5VRPPRWVYDUDUHQSXQNWSnHQDVLGDQRP NXUYDQLQWUlIIDUEURWWRFKI|UNRELQDWLRQHUVRPPRWVYDUDUHQ SXQNW Sn DQGUD VLGDQLQWUlIIDU LFNH EURWW %URWWVDQQROLNKHWHQEOLUVnOHGHV GHQ YRO\P VRP ILQQV XQGHU\WDQI|UI65RFKVRPOLJJHUSnVLGDQEURWWRPOLQMHQ$GYVYRO\
PHQVRPPRWVYDUDUGHQVWUHFNDGH\WDQLILJXU
%
GlU5lUHWWJRGW\FNOLJWYDOWYlUGHVRPJ|U55GLPHQVLRQVO|VW0HGHOYlUGHQD EOLU
,ξηSODQHWNDQQX\WDQIξηnVNnGOLJJ|UDVDYQLYnOLQMHUVRPEOLUFLUNODUHQOLJW ILJXU9LOONRUHWNDQVNULYDVVRPIXQNWLRQDYξRFKη
[
6 5]
Θ ξ η ≥
VRPUHSUHVHQWHUDVDYNXUYDQ%LILJXU8WWU\FNHWVHULHXWYHFNODVLRP
JLYQLQJHQDYHQWLOOVYLGDUHREHVWlPGSXQNWξ η VRPOLJJHUSnNXUYDQRFKVRP PRWVYDUDU5 5 RFK6 6 6HILJXU
0
)LJXU)UHNYHQVIXQNWLRQIξηRFKOLQMHQ
%VRPUHSUHVHQWHUDUEURWWYLOONRUHW
)LJXU'HWDOMDYILJXU
%
7HUPHUDYK|JUHJUDGlQGHQI|UVWDLξξ RFKηη I|UVXPPDVYLONHWPHGI|U DWWHNY EOLU HNYDWLRQHQ I|U WDQJHQWHQWLOO NXUYDQ% L SXQNWHQξ η 7DQJHQWHQKDUOXWQLQJHQPRWξD[HOQ
3XQNWHQξ η YlOMHVQXVnDWWWDQJHQWHQInUNRUWDVWP|MOLJDYLQNHOUlWDDYVWnQGβ WLOOSXQNWHQ0ILJXUYLONHWJHUVW|UVWDP|MOLJDYlUGHSnEURWWVDQQROLNKHWHQSI (IWHUVRP IUHNYHQVNXUYDQ L YDUMH ULNWQLQJ EHVNULYHU HQ QRUPDOI|UGHOQLQJ PHG VWDQGDUGDYYLNHOVHQ EOLU
= Φ −β
SI
GlUΦ⋅lUQRUPDOI|UGHOQLQJVIXQNWLRQHQ
8UILJXUHUKnOOVPHGKMlOSDY
3XQNWHQξ η OLJJHUSnNXUYDQVRPEHVNULYVDYΘ RFKYlUGHQDξ RFKη NDQ YlOMDV VRP GLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQ 0HG nWHUJnQJ WLOO YDULDEOHUQD 6 RFK 5 HUKnOOHVVnOHGHVGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQD
= 6 + βα6 6
6 P V
%
GlUSIlUIRUPHOODFFHSWDEHOEURWWVDQQROLNKHW
'LPHQVLRQHULQJVYLOONRUHWEOLU
6 5
Θ =
(NYDWLRQHUQD W R P lU WLOOUlFNOLJD I|U DWW O|VD GLPHQVLRQHULQJVSUR
EOHPHWYDUYLGI|UXWVlWWHVDWWβlUJLYHQSnI|UKDQGDWWPDQNlQQHUP6V695 RFKIXQNWLRQHQΘP5VNDOOEHUlNQDV
3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQ
3ULQFLSHUQDI|USDUWLDONRHIILFLHQWPHWRGHQlULQWHOLNDUHQRGODGHRFKVWULNWDVRP SULQFLSHUQD I|U GHQ VDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVND PHWRGHQ 'HW lU GRFN P|MOLJW DWW IUDPVWlOODSULQFLSHUQDSnOLNDUWDWVlWWVRPLDYVQLWW
3nVDPPDVlWWVRPLDYVQLWWDQWDVDWWSUREOHPHWLQQHKnOOHUHQGDVWWYnYDULDEOHU 6RFK5,ILJXUYLVDVNRRUGLQDWV\VWHPHW65PHGPHGHOYlUGHQDP6RFKP5 UHSUHVHQWHUDGHDYSXQNWHQ0SnVDPPDVlWWVRPLILJXUVDPWNXUYDQ$
VRPXWJ|UJUlQVHQPHOODQIDOOHQLFNHEURWWRFKEURWW,ILJXUYLVDVHPHOOHUWLG IUHNYHQVNXUYRUQDI6RFKI5YDUI|UVLJ*HQRPI|UKDQGVEHVWlPGDVDQQROLNKHWV
YlUGHQS6RFKS5I|UXQGHUVNULGDQGHEHVWlPPHVIUDNWLOYlUGHQD6NRFK5NVRPlU GHNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHQDRFKUHSUHVHQWHUDVDYSXQNW.LILJXU
1lU GHW JlOOHU EURWW lU PHG GH YlUGHQ Sn6N RFK 5N VRP YDQOLJHQ DQYlQGV
SXQNWHQ . LQWH WLOOUlFNOLJW DYOlJVHQ IUnQ SXQNWHQ 0 I|U DWW VlNHUKHWHQ VNDOO YDUDWLOOIUHGVVWlOODQGHRPSXQNWHQ.OlJJVSnJUlQVNXUYDQΘ
%
)LJXU0HGHOYlUGHQNDUDNWHULVWLVNDYlUGHQRFKGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQVDPWOLQMHQ
$VRPUHSUHVHQWHUDUEURWWYLOONRUHW
3XQNWHQ'SnNXUYDQ$VRPUHSUHVHQWHUDUGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYlUGHQD6GRFK 5GVNDOOVnOHGHVDYOlJVQDV\WWHUOLJDUHIUnQ0YLONHWVNHUJHQRPDWW6NPXOWLSOLFHUDV PHGγ6!3XQNWHQ'VNDOOOLJJDSnJUlQVNXUYDQΘ HOOHUSnVLGDQLFNH EURWWYLONHWLQQHElUDWWGLPHQVLRQHULQJVYLOONRUHWEOLU
6 5G G
Θ ≥
3DUWLDONRHIILFLHQWHUQDγ6 RFKγ5 lU EHURHQGH Sn DUWHQ DY YDULDEOHUQD 6 RFK 5 PHQ lURIWDVW REHURHQGH DY IXQNWLRQHQΘ'HWWD LQQHElU L PRWVDWVHQ WLOO YDG VRPJlOOHUI|UGHQVDQQROLNKHWVWHRUHWLVNDPHWRGHQHQOLJWNDSLWHODWWULNWQLQJHQ SnVWHJHQ0→.RFK.→'VHILJXULQWHJ|UVEHURHQGHDYNXUYDQ$