0LQ DYKDQGOLQJ KDQGODU RP DWW I|UVWn PlQQLVNDQV HYROXWLRQlUD KLVWRULD PHG KMlOS DY JHQHWLN 'HW ILQQV PnQJD YHWHQVNDSHU VRP VWXGHUDU PlQQLVNDQV KLV WRULD WLOO H[HPSHO DQWURSRORJL DUNHRORJL VSUnNYHWHQVNDS RFK SDOHRQWRORJL 2OLND RPUnGHQ ELGUDU PHG ROLND GHODU DY LQIRUPDWLRQ RFK lU DQYlQGEDUD I|U ROLND WLGVSHULRGHU 7LOO H[HPSHO lU VSUnNYHWHQVNDS LQIRUPDWLY I|U GH VHQDVWH nUHQ PHGDQ DUNHRORJL NDQ ELGUD PHG LQIRUPDWLRQ VRP VWUlFNHU VLJ IOHUD PLOMRQHU nU WLOOEDND
-DJ KDU DQYlQW HQ DQQDQ YHWHQVNDS I|U DWW VWXGHUD PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD QlP OLJHQ SRSXODWLRQVJHQHWLN HOOHU PROHN\OlU DQWURSRORJL 3RSXODWLRQVJHQHWLN VWXG HUDU KXU PXWDWLRQHU VSULGHU VLJ L SRSXODWLRQHU 9L lUYHU '1$ ± DUYVPDVVD GHW NHPLVND lPQHW VRP LQQHKnOOHU GHQ JHQHWLVND LQIRUPDWLRQHQ ± IUnQ YnUD ELROR JLVND I|UlOGUDU YLOND lUYGH GHUDV '1$ IUnQ GHUDV I|UlOGUDU RVY 3n GHW VlWWHW LQQHKnOOHU '1$ LQIRUPDWLRQ RP DOOD YnUD I|UIlGHU RFK YL NDQ DQYlQGD SRSX ODWLRQVJHQHWLVND SULQFLSHU I|U DWW I|UVWn KXU QXYDUDQGH JHQHWLVN YDULDWLRQ XSS VWnWW 9L NDQ VWXGHUD KXU SRSXODWLRQHU U|UW VLJ RFK I|UIO\WWDW VLJ |YHU YlUOGHQ PHQ RFNVn VWXGHUD YDULDWLRQHU L SRSXODWLRQHUV VWRUOHN 7LOO H[HPSHO RP DQWDOHW LQGLYLGHU L HQ SRSXODWLRQ KDU PLQVNDW VQDEEW RFK VHGDQ |NDW LJHQ OlPQDV HWW VlUVNLOW P|QVWHU L SRSXODWLRQV '1$ YDULDWLRQ HQ Vn NDOODG ³IODVNKDOVHIIHNW´ '1$ IUnQ QX OHYDQGH SRSXODWLRQHU lU LQIRUPDWLY I|U KlQGHOVHU VRP XSSVWRG I|U KXQGUDWXVHQ nU VHGDQ PHQ RFNVn I|U KlQGHOVHU VRP XSSVWRG I|U QnJUD GH FHQQLHU VHGDQ 0DQ NDQ RFNVn XQGHUV|ND '1$ IUnQ PlQQLVNRU VRP OHYGH I|U IOHUD WXVHQ nU VHGDQ DQFLHQW '1$ I|U DWW VWXGHUD PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD
'HW lU VlUVNLOW VSlQQDQGH DWW VWXGHUD HYROXWLRQVKLVWRULD L DIULNDQVND SRSX ODWLRQHU GlUI|U DWW PlQQLVNDQ +RPR VDSLHQV XWYHFNODGHV L $IULND ,GDJ YHW YL DWW GHQ PRGHUQD PlQQLVNDQ VSUHG VLJ YLD HQ HQVNLOG PLJUDWLRQVKlQGHOVH IUnQ $IULND WLOO UHVWHQ DY YlUOGHQ 'HQ PRGHUQD PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD L $IULND I|UH RFK HIWHU PLJUDWLRQHQ IUnQ $IULND lU PLQGUH VWXGHUDG EODQG DQQDW GlUI|U DWW GHW ILQQV PLQGUH SHQJDU WLOO IRUVNQLQJHQ L $IULND lQ L (XUDVLHQ RFK 1RUGDPHULND 9L YHW GlUHPRW DWW +RPR VDSLHQV XWYHFNODGHV I|U FLUND nU VHGDQ I|UPRGOLJHQ L ROLND GHODU DY $IULND +XU PnQJD SRSXODWLRQHU GHW IDQQV Gn KXU GH YDU UHODWHUDGH WLOO YDUDQGUD RFK WLOO SRSXODWLRQHQ HOOHU SRSXODWLRQHU VRP YDQGUDGH XW XU $IULND VDPW WLOO SRSXODWLRQHU VRP OHYHU LGDJ lU YLNWLJD IUnJRU VRP YL YLOO EHVYDUD
7LGLJDUH VWXGLHU KDU YLVDW DWW QnJUD DIULNDQVND SRSXODWLRQHU lU VlUVNLOW LQ WUHVVDQWD I|U DWW I|UVWn PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD I|UH MRUGEUXNHW VRP I|UlQGUDGH GHW JHQHWLVND ODQGVNDSHW I|U FLUND nU VHGDQ V|GHU RP 6DKDUD 'HVVD SRS XODWLRQHUQD lU .KRH6DQ IUnQ V|GUD $IULND MlJDUHVDPODUH IUnQ UHJQVNRJHQ L
FHQWUDO $IULND MlJDUHVDPODUH IUnQ |VW $IULND RFK QnJUD SRSXODWLRQHU VRP lU PLQGUH YlO NlQGD
-DJ KDU L PLQ DYKDQGOLQJ DQYlQW PLJ DY JHQHWLVND DQDO\VPHWRGHU I|U DWW VWXGHUD QnJUD DY GHVVD SRSXODWLRQHU 7HNQLNHU I|U DWW VNDIID JHQHWLVN LQIRU PDWLRQ KDU XWYHFNODWV P\FNHW GH VHQDVWH GHFHQQLHUQD (WW VlWW lU DWW DQDO\VHUD I|UXWEHVWlPGD SRVLWLRQHU L JHQRPHW SRVLWLRQHU GlU YL UHGDQ YHW DWW GHW ILQQV JHQHWLVND YDULDQWHU Vn NDOODGH 613DU KRV PlQQLVNDQ 'HW lU VDPPD WHNQLN VRP DQYlQGV L NRPPHUVLHOOD JHQHWLVND WHVWHU VRP YLVDU RP PDQ lU PHU VOlNW PHG PlQQLVNRU IUnQ HWW HOOHU HWW DQQDW ODQG 'HW lU HQ UHODWLYW ELOOLJ WHNQLN VRP DQYlQGV QlU PDQ YLOO In HQ I|UVWD JHQHWLVN |YHUEOLFN DY HQ SRSXODWLRQ HOOHU QlU PDQ YLOO WLWWD Sn PnQJD PlQQLVNRU (WW DQQDW VlWW lU DWW DQDO\VHUD QlVWDQ DOOD SRVLWLRQHU L JHQRPHW GYV DWW VHNYHQVHUD '1$W 'HW NRVWDU PHU lQ 613DQDO\V RFK GHW WDU OlQJUH WLG RFK PHU UHVXUVHU I|U DWW I|UEHUHGD GDWD RFK JHQRPI|UD DQDO\VHU 0HQ PDQ InU P\FNHW PHU LQIRUPDWLRQ IUnQ KHOD JHQRPVHNYHQVHU
, GHW DQGUD SURMHNWHW L PLQ DYKDQGOLQJ YLVDGH MDJ KXU PDQ I|UEHUHGHU KHOD JHQRPVHNYHQVHU I|U DQDO\VHU 1lU PDQ VWXGHUDU JHQHWLVN YDULDWLRQ L DIULNDQ VND SRSXODWLRQHU EHK|YHU PDQ YDUD H[WUD I|UVLNWLJ Gn GH KDU VW|UUH JHQHWLVN YDULDWLRQ lQ LFNHDIULNDQVND SRSXODWLRQHU RFK GHVVXWRP lU DIULNDQVN YDULDWLRQ XQGHUUHSUHVHQWHUDGH L JHQHWLVND GDWDEDVHU -DJ YLVDGH DWW YL NDQ I|UEHUHGD VHNYHQVHU IUnQ DIULNDQVND SRSXODWLRQHU Sn VDPPD VlWW VRP VHNYHQVHU IUnQ LFNH DIULNDQVND SRSXODWLRQHU PHQ RFNVn DWW NYDOLWHQ Sn GDWDW EHURU Sn KXU PnQJD JnQJHU YDUMH SRVLWLRQ L JHQRPHW KDU EOLYLW VHNYHQVHUDG
0RGHUQD PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD EUXNDU UHSUHVHQWHUDV VRP HWW WUlG RFK .KRH 6DQ RFK VLQD I|UIlGHU UHSUHVHQWHUDU I|UVWD JUHQHQ L WUlGHWQ , GHW I|UVWD SURMHNWHW L DYKDQGOLQJHQ JHQHUHUDGH RFK DQDO\VHUDGH MDJ JHQRPVHNYHQVHU I|U .KRH 6DQ LQGLYLGHU 7LGLJDUH VWXGLHU KDU XSSVNDWWDW DWW .KRH6DQ I|UIlGHU VNLOMHU VLJ IUnQ I|UIlGHU DY GHQ PRGHUQD PlQQLVNDQ I|U FLUND nUHQ VHGDQ , GHQQD VWXGLH XSSVNDWWDGH YL WLGHQ DY GHQQD KlQGHOVH LJHQ RFK ILFN OLNQDQGH UHVXOWDW 9L YLVDGH RFNVn DWW GHQ K|JD JHQHWLVND YDULDWLRQHQ KRV .KRH6DQ LQ GLYLGHU EHURU GHOYLV Sn JHQHIO|GH IUnQ SRSXODWLRQHU VRP NRP WLOO V|GUD $IULND XQGHU GH VHQDVWH nUHQ RFK I|UGH PHG VLJ KXVGMXUVVN|WVHO RFK Yl[WRGOLQJ 9L DQYlQGH PHWRGHU VRP EHUlNQDU KXU VWRUOHNHQ L HQ EHIRONQLQJ I|UlQGUDU VLJ PHG WLGHQ RFK YLVDU DWW VWRUOHNHQ KRV .KRH6DQ SRSXODWLRQHU E|UMDU PLQVND I|U FLUND nU VHGDQ 'HW VHU PDQ L DOOD EHIRONQLQJDU L YlUOGHQ RFK HQ I|UN ODULQJ WLOO GHW NDQ YDUD DWW NOLPDWHW I|UlQGUDGHV YLG GHQQD WLGSXQNW -DJ JHQRP I|UGH VLPXODWLRQHU DY GHQ Vn NDOODGH IODVNKDOVHIIHNWHQ I|U DWW VH KXU PHWRGHU VRP EHUlNQDU EHIRONQLQJVVWRUOHN I|UKnOOHU VLJ WLOO VnGDQD I|UlQGULQJDU 5H VXOWDWHQ I|UVWlUNWH YnUD WRONQLQJDU DY RUVDNHQ WLOO GH REVHUYHUDGH P|QVWUHQD L GDWDW 9L OHWDGH RFNVn HIWHU JHQHU VRP KDU SnYHUNDWV DY VHOHNWLRQ RFK YLVDGH DWW VnGDQD JHQHU RIWD lU LQYROYHUDGH L LPPXQI|UVYDUHW VDPW VSHUPLHU KMlUQDQ PHWDEROLVP RFK PXVNOHUQD
, GHW WUHGMH SURMHNWHW VWXGHUDGHV KHOD JHQRPVHNYHQVHU IUnQ MlJDUHVDPODUH IUnQ UHJQVNRJHQ L FHQWUDOD $IULND VRP MlPI|UGHV PHG VHNYHQVHU IUnQ DQGUD SRSXODWLRQHU -DJ E\JJGH PRGHOOHU VRP EHVNULYHU PlQQLVNDQV KLVWRULD L
$IULND IUnQ HQ HQGD XUVSUXQJOLJ SRSXODWLRQ WLOO IHP QXWLGD SRSXODWLRQHU RFK DQYlQGH VLPXOHUDW RFK REVHUYHUDW GDWD I|U DWW LGHQWLILHUD GHQ PHVW VDQQROLND PRGHOOHQ 9L VHU DWW GHW lU YLNWLJW DWW KD PRGHOOHU PHG P|MOLJKHW I|U JHQIO|GH 5HVXOWDWHQ IUnQ PRGHOOHUQD YLVDU DWW GHW lU PHU VDQQROLNW DWW .KRH6DQJUHQHQ VRP I|UVW NQRSSDV DY IUnQ GHQ XUVSUXQJOLJD SRSXODWLRQHQ VDPW DWW GHQ LQWHUQD XSSGHOQLQJHQ DY MlJDUHVDPODUH IUnQ UHJQVNRJHQ KDU LQWUlIIDW PHU Q\OLJHQ lQ GHQ LQWHUQD XSSGHOQLQJHQ DY .KRH6DQ OLQMHQ 'HQ ElVWD PRGHOOHQ YDOGHV XW RFK DQGUD SDUDPHWUDU XSSVNDWWDGHV VRP WH[ WLGHQ I|U QlU ROLND SRSXODWLRQHU VSOLWWUDWVVHSDUHUDWV
'HW IMlUGH SURMHNWHW KDQGODU RP SRSXODWLRQHU IUnQ =DPELD VRP NDOODV %D7ZD RFK VRP LGDJ OHYHU VRP ILVNDUH )OHUD VSnU WLOO H[HPSHO IUnQ DUNHRORJL W\GHU Sn DWW %D7ZDV I|UIlGHU NXQGH YDUD MlJDUHVDPODUH VRP OHYGH L UHJLRQHQ I|UUH MRUGEUXNDUH NRP WLOO GDJHQV =DPELD 9L JHQRW\SDGH PHU lQ HQ PLOMRQ 613DU I|U WYn %D7ZD SRSXODWLRQHU RFK MDJ MlPI|UGH GHWWD GDWDVHW PHG OLNQDQGH GDWD IUnQ DQGUD SRSXODWLRQHU 5HVXOWDWHW YLVDU DWW %D7ZD KDU HQ JHQHWLVN NRPSRQHQW VRP OLNQDU PHQ lU HM LGHQWLVN PHG QXYDUDQGH MlJDUHVDPODUH VlUVNLOW .KRH 6DQ 'H KDU RFNVn HQ VW|UUH JHQHWLVN NRPSRQHQW VRP OLNQDU SRSXODWLRQHU VRP PHGI|UGH MRUGEUXNHW WLOO V|GHUFHQWUDO $IULND
'H ROLND SURMHNWHQ L PLQ DYKDQGOLQJ ELGUDU PHG Q\ LQIRUPDWLRQ WLOO WLGLJDUH VWXGLHU DY +RPR VDSLHQV XWYHFNOLQJVKLVWRULD L $IULND VlUVNLOW I|U KlQGHOVHU I|UH VSULGQLQJHQ DY MRUGEUXNHW 'H EHNUlIWDU DWW GHW lU YlUGHIXOOW DWW VWXGHUD lYHQ PLQGUH RFK RNlQGD SRSXODWLRQHU -DJ DQYlQGH ROLND PHWRGHU RFK XWYlUGHUDGH KXU GH IXQJHUDU 5HVXOWDWHQ EHNUlIWDU DWW +RPR VDSLHQV KLVWRULD lU LQYHFNODG RFK DWW YL EHK|YHU WHVWD IOHUD PRGHOOHU I|U DWW I|UVWn GHQ lQQX ElWWUH