Att hitta ingångar i formandet av programmeringskunskap

Full text

(1)Blekinge Tekniska Högskola Institutionen för programvaruteknik och datavetenskap. Att hitta ingångar i formandet av programmeringskunskap En diskussion kring möjligheter och svårigheter i grundläggande programmeringsundervisning inom högskolan.. Kandidatarbete i adb, 10 poäng för Informationsteknologiprogrammet 2001-05-22 Författare: Maria Alsbjer. Handledare: Lena Trojer.

(2) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 7DFN. 7LOODOODHUVRPSnROLNDVlWWELGUDJLWWLOOGHWWDDUEHWHJHQRPDWWGHOWDLLQWHUYMXHURFKVDPWDO VnYlO VRP GLVNXVVLRQHU NULQJ VMlOYD XWIRUPQLQJHQ YLOO MDJ ULNWD HWW VWRUW RFK KMlUWOLJW WDFN ,QJHQQlPQGRFKLQJHQJO|PG 0DULD$OVEMHU%URP|OOD. .

(3) $WWKLWWDLQJn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|JVNROD

(4) WKH SURJUDP RI ,QIRUPDWLRQ WHFKQRORJ\ ,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLSURJUDPPHW

(5) DQG WKH SURJUDP RI 0HGLD WHFKQRORJ\ 0HGLHWHNQLN SURJUDPPHW

(6) ,KDYHLQWHUYLHZHGVWXGHQWVDQGWHDFKHUVIURPERWKSURJUDPVDQG,KDYHDVNHG WKHP DERXW HDUOLHU H[SHULHQFHV RI FRPSXWHUV DQG SURJUDPPLQJ YLHZV RQ SURJUDPPLQJ GLIILFXOWLHV WKH\ KDYH H[SHULHQFHG ZKHQ OHDUQLQJ WR SURJUDP DQG SRVVLEOH FDXVHV RI WKHVH GLIILFXOWLHV 7KHUHVXOWVIURPWKHLQWHUYLHZVKDYHEHHQUHIOHFWHGWKURXJKDQXPEHURIWH[WVWKDWGHDOZLWK FRQFHSWLRQV DQG FRQGXFWV LQ WKH IRUPDWLRQ RI SURJUDPPLQJ NQRZOHGJH DV ZHOO DV PRUH JHQHUDOTXHVWLRQVDERXWWKHHSLVWHPRORJLFDOSRLQWVRIGHSDUWXUHLQWKHIRUPDWLRQRIDOONLQGV RINQRZOHGJHEXWZLWKIRFXVRQSURJUDPPLQJNQRZOHGJH0\PHWKRGRORJ\LVHVWDEOLVKHGLQ JHQGHUUHVHDUFKWKHRULHVGHDOLQJZLWKWKHVFLHQWLILFSURFHVVHVRINQRZOHGJHZKHUHTXHVWLRQV DERXW WKH FRQWHQWV RI PHWKRG DQG WKHRU\ DUH EHLQJ GLVFXVVHG 7KLV FRQQHFWLRQ KDV PDGH D FRQWH[WXDO DQDO\VLV SRVVLEOH LQ ZKLFK , KDYH WULHG WR HPSKDVLVH JHQHUDO DV ZHOO DV PRUH VSHFLILF WHQGHQFLHV 7KDW LV WHQGHQFLHV ZKLFK FDQ EH LGHQWLILHG LQ WKH UHVSHFWLYH HGXFDWLRQDO SURJUDPV , KDYH VWXGLHG DV ZHOO DV WHQGHQFLHV ZKLFK PD\ EH UHFRJQLVHG LQ DOO DFDGHPLF SURJUDPPLQJHGXFDWLRQ. ,Q WKH ILQDO GLVFXVVLRQ , KDYH HPSKDVLVHG WKRVH LVVXHV ZKLFK , FRQVLGHU WR EH WKH PRVW VLJQLILFDQWIRUWKHSRVVLELOLWLHVWRPDNHSURJUDPPLQJNQRZOHGJHDYDLODEOHWRDOOKDYLQJWKH LQWHUHVWWROHDUQ7KHVHLVVXHVGHDOZLWKWKHJHQHUDOYLHZRINQRZOHGJHLQZKLFKSURJUDPPLQJ HGXFDWLRQDOOWRRRIWHQLVEHLQJVKDSHG,WLVDYLHZRINQRZOHGJHZKLFKH[SUHVVHVDPRUHRU OHVV SURQRXQFHG YLHZ RI HGXFDWLRQ DV DFKLHYHPHQW 4XHVWLRQV DERXW ZKDW FRQVHTXHQFHV D XQLIRUP HGXFDWLRQ PLJKW KDYH RQ GLIIHUHQW LQGLYLGXDOV LV DOVR WDNHQ LQWR DFFRXQW 0HDQV RI KRZ WR FUHDWH PXOWLSOLFLW\ ZLWKLQ WKH HGXFDWLRQ LV EHLQJ GLVFXVVHGDV ZHOO DV WKH UROH RI WKH WHDFKHUVLQWKLVFRQWH[W :LWKWKLVZRUN,ZDQWWRFRQWULEXWHWREDVHVRINQRZOHGJHIRUGHYHORSPHQWRIDSHGDJRJLFDO ZRUN WKDWZLOO VKRXOG EHQHILW VWXGHQWV DQG WHDFKHUV DV ZHOO DV WKH VXEMHFW RI SURJUDPPLQJ LWVHOI. .

(7) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 6DPPDQIDWWQLQJ. $WWOlUDVLJSURJUDPPHUDSnQ\E|UMDUQLYnLQRPUDPHQI|UHQK|JVNROHXWELOGQLQJlUHQSURFHVV VRPI|UYLVVDVWXGHQWHUW\FNVKHOWRSUREOHPDWLVNPHGDQGHQI|UDQGUDWHUVLJ VPlUWVDPHOOHU UHQW DY R|YHUVWLJOLJ 9DUI|U lU GHW Vn RFK KXU NDQ PDQ KLWWD LQJnQJDU L IRUPDQGHW DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS VRP |SSQDU P|MOLJKHWHU I|U DOOD VRP YLOO OlUD VLJ" 0HG GHVVD IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDUVRPXWJnQJVSXQNWKDUMDJWLWWDWSnWYnROLNDXWELOGQLQJVSURJUDPYLG%OHNLQJH 7HNQLVND +|JVNROD %7+

(8) ,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLSURJUDPPHW UHVSHNWLYH 0HGLHWHNQLN SURJUDPPHW -DJKDU LQWHUYMXDW HWW XUYDO VWXGHQWHU RFK OlUDUH IUnQ GH EnGD SURJUDPPHQ RFK VWlOOW IUnJRU EO D NULQJ WLGLJDUH HUIDUHQKHWHU DY GDWRUHU RFK SURJUDPPHULQJ V\QHQ Sn SURJUDPPHULQJXSSOHYGDVYnULJKHWHUPHGDWWOlUDVLJSURJUDPPHUDRFKWlQNEDUDRUVDNHUWLOO GHVVDVYnULJKHWHU. 5HVXOWDWHQ IUnQ LQWHUYMXHUQD KDU UHIOHNWHUDWV JHQRP HWW DQWDO WH[WHU VRP EHKDQGODU I|UHVWlOOQLQJDU RFK I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW L IRUPDQGHW DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS VnYlO VRP PHU |YHUJULSDQGH IUnJRUNULQJHSLVWHPRORJLVNDXWJnQJVSXQNWHULIRUPDQGHWDYDOOVODJVNXQVNDS PHQ PHG IRNXV Sn SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0LQ PHWRGRORJL lU I|UDQNUDG L JHQXV IRUVNQLQJVWHRULHUNULQJGHYHWHQVNDSOLJDNXQVNDSVSURFHVVHUQDLQRPYLONDIUnJRUU|UDQGH EOD PHWRGRFKWHRULLQQHKnOOSUREOHPDWLVHUDV'HQQDI|UDQNULQJKDUP|MOLJJMRUWGHQNRQWH[WXHOOD DQDO\VLYLONHQMDJI|UV|NWO\IWDIUDPDOOPlQJLOWLJDVnYlOVRPVSHFLILNDWHQGHQVHUGYVEnGH IDNWRUHU VRP NDQ KlUU|UDV WLOO UHVSHNWLYH SURJUDP MDJ VWXGHUDW RFK IDNWRUHU VRP EHU|U SURJUDPPHULQJVXQGHUYLVQLQJLK|JVNROHPLOM|JHQHUHOOW , GHQ DYVOXWDQGH GLVNXVVLRQHQ KDU MDJ ODJW VlUVNLOG YLNW YLG GH IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU VRP MDJ XSSIDWWDU KDU GHQ PHVW VLJQLILNDQWD EHW\GHOVHQ I|U KXU P|MOLJKHWHU NDQ VNDSDV I|U DWW SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDSVNDXSSIDWWDVVRPWLOOJlQJOLJDYDOODVRPKDULQWUHVVHDYDWWOlUDVLJ SURJUDPPHUD 'HVVD IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU EHU|U MXVW GHQ |YHUJULSDQGH NXQVNDSVV\Q LQRP YLONHQ SURJUDPPHULQJVXQGHUYLVQLQJDOOWI|URIWDIRUPDVHQNXQVNDSVV\QVRPJHUXWWU\FNI|UHWWPHU HOOHU PLQGUH XWSUlJODW SUHVWDWLRQVWlQNDQGH )UnJHVWlOOQLQJDU NULQJ YLOND NRQVHNYHQVHU HQ OLNULNWDGXQGHUYLVQLQJNDQInI|UROLNDLQGLYLGHUWDVRFNVnXSSRFKP|MOLJKHWHUWLOOVNDSDQGHW DYPnQJIDOGLXQGHUYLVQLQJHQGLVNXWHUDVOLNVRPOlUDUQDVUROOLGHWWDVDPPDQKDQJ 0HG GHWWD DUEHWH YLOO MDJ ELGUDWLOO NXQVNDSVXQGHUODJ I|U HWW SHGDJRJLVNW XWYHFNOLQJVDUEHWH WLOOJDJQI|UVWXGHQWHURFKOlUDUHVnYlOVRPSURJUDPPHULQJVlPQHWLVLJ. .

(9) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. ,QQHKnOOVI|UWHFNQLQJ ,1/('1,1* . 352%/(0205c'( (//(5+85-$*)g//)g5b01(7 352%/(0$9*5b161,1* $77206b77$.b16/$1,(77.21.5(7352-(.7 )5c*(67b//1,1*$5(//(59$'9$5'(7(*(17/,*(1-$*9,//(+$69$53c " 0(72''(5('6.$3620-$*9$/'($77$5%(7$0(' 0(72'2/2*,87*c1*6381.7(5,6.$3$1'(7$9.816.$3 6<)7( 0c/*5833 5$33257(16833/b**1,1* . %$.*581' . %$.*581' ,1)250$7,2167(.12/2*,352*5$00(7 %$.*581' 0(',(7(.1,.352*5$00(7 352*5$00(5,1*6.856(51$6833/b**1,1* ,7352*5$00(7$//0b17 35$.7,6.$020(17)g5,7352*5$00(7 0(',(7(.1,.352*5$00(7$//0b17 35$.7,6.$020(170(',(7(.1,.352*5$00(7 -b0)g5$1'(.200(17$5(5 . *(120)g5$1'( . %(6.5,91,1*$9,17(59-8$5%(7(7 $1$/<60(72'2&+0(72'2/2*,6.$87*c1*6381.7(5 35(6(17$7,21$90$7(5,$/(7 8WELOGQLQJRFKI|UKnOODQGHWLOOPDWHPDWLNlPQHW 9DGLQQHElUGHWDWWNXQQDSURJUDPPHUDXUVWXGHQWSHUVSHNWLY" 9DGLQQHElUGHWDWWNXQQDSURJUDPPHUDXUOlUDUSHUVSHNWLY" 9LONDELOGHUKDUVWXGHQWHUQDDYOlUDUQDVV\QSnSURJUDPPHULQJ" 9DGlUGHWVRPlUVnVYnUW" 9DGYDUVYnUWLEDFNVSHJHOQ" 9DUI|UlUGHWVnVYnUW" bUGHWGnLQJHQWLQJVRPlUOlWW" 2OLNDI|UKnOOQLQJVVlWWLI|UYlUYDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 7LGLJDUHGDWRUYDQDRFKHUIDUHQKHWHUDYSURJUDPPHULQJ 9LONHQEHW\GHOVHKDUWLGLJDUHHUIDUHQKHWHUDYGDWRUHURFKSURJUDPPHULQJ" %HG|PQLQJDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS +XUVHUOlUDUUROOHQXW" 3HGDJRJLVNDI|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW 6$00$1)$771,1* . $1$/<6 . 6<1(13c.816.$3 .XQVNDSVSURFHVVHU 7YlUYHWHQVNDSOLJDDQVDWVHU *HQXVIRUVNQLQJLQRPGHWWHNQRYHWHQVNDSOLJDRPUnGHW 9LONDlUPLQDJODV|JRQ" .RQVHUYHUDQGHVWUXNWXUHU 6\QHQSnWHNQLNXUJHQXVSHUVSHNWLY )250$1'(7$9.816.$3 )RNXVHULQJSnWHRUHWLVNNXQVNDS 3UDNWLVNNXQVNDS )|UHVWlOOQLQJDUNULQJSURJUDPPHULQJ )|UKnOOQLQJVVlWWNULQJSURJUDPPHULQJVRPDNWLYLWHW 2OLNDLQOlUQLQJVVWLODU 9b*/('$5(,)250$1'(7$9.816.$3 .

(10) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB )|UPHGODUUROOHQ $WWJ|UDI|UPHGODUUROOHQV\QOLJ 3URMHNWDUEHWHRFKHJHWOlUDQGH 6$00$1)$771,1* . ',6.866,21 . $77g331$'(169$57$/c'$1 +85*(50$1875<00()g50c1*)$/',6.$3$1'(7$9.816.$3 " 6NDSDQGHWDYNROOHNWLYNXQVNDS /nQJVDPKHWHQVEHW\GHOVH '(+b/)7(16<1/,*$ +85)250$62&+)250$5 )g50('/$51$$9.816.$3" 6/8725' . 5()(5(16(5 %,/$*25 . %,/$*$ /,7(125'/,67$ %,/$*$ ,17(59-8)5c*257,//678'(17(51$ )g567$,17(59-820*c1*(1 %,/$*$ ,17(59-8)5c*257,///b5$51$ %,/$*$ ,17(59-8)5c*257,//678'(17(51$ $1'5$,17(59-820*c1*(1 . .

(11) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. ,QOHGQLQJ 'HQ WH[W GX KDU IUDPI|U GLJ XWJ|U HWW H[DPHQVDUEHWH I|U ,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLSURJUDPPHW YLG %OHNLQJH 7HNQLVND +|JVNROD %7+

(12) bPQHW lU SURJUDPPHULQJVXQGHUYLVQLQJ Sn Q\E|UMDUQLYnLQRPK|JVNRODQP|MOLJKHWHURFKVYnULJKHWHU,GHWWDLQOHGDQGHDYVQLWWI|OMHUHQ EHVNULYQLQJDYEDNJUXQGHQWLOOlPQHVYDOHWVDPWHQI|UNODULQJWLOOYDOGDDUEHWVVlWW,VOXWHWDY LQOHGQLQJHQJ|UVHQNRUWIDWWDGJHQRPJnQJDYUDSSRUWHQVXSSOlJJQLQJ 3UREOHPRPUnGHHOOHUKXUMDJI|OOI|UlPQHW 1lU MDJ VMlOY OlUGH PLJ DWW SURJUDPPHUD L SURJUDPVSUnNHW MDYD

(13) YDU YL JDQVND PnQJD L NODVVHQ VRP XSSOHYGH SURJUDPPHULQJHQ VRP QnJRQWLQJ VYnUW RFK DEVWUDNW 'H IOHVWD KDGH K|JDI|UYlQWQLQJDUSnGHQLQOHGDQGHSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHQRFKW\FNWHGHWVNXOOHEOLRHUK|UW UROLJW 'H IOHVWD OD RFNVn QHU YlOGLJW P\FNHW DUEHWH Sn DWW I|UV|ND OlUD VLJ PHQ LQWH GHVWR PLQGUH EURWWDGHV YL VRP YDU Q\E|UMDUH PHG JDQVND VWRUD SUREOHP 1nJUD JDY WLOO VLVW XSS MDYDSURJUDPPHULQJHQRFKVnVPnQLQJRPRFNVnXWELOGQLQJHQ9LVRPLQWHJDYXSSXWDQWURWV DOOWJHQRPI|UGHODERUDWLRQHURFKWHQWDPLQDO\FNDGHVLDOOWI|UPnQJDIDOOGHVVYlUUHLQWHIULJ|UD RVV IUnQ GHQ JQDJDQGH NlQVODQ DY DWW HJHQWOLJHQ LQWH DOOV KD I|UVWnWW DY DWW LQWH KD KLWWDW G|UUHQWLOOLQJnQJHQ /lQJH JLFN MDJ RPNULQJ PHG I|UHVWlOOQLQJHQ DWW SUREOHPHW YDU VSHFLILNW I|U YnU NODVV 'HQ DOOHQDUnGDQGH I|UNODULQJHQ VNXOOH YDUD DWW YnUW SURJUDP YDU Q\WW RFK GlUI|U EURWWDGHV PHG EDUQVMXNGRPDU L IRUP DY EULVWIlOOLJ RUJDQLVDWLRQ RFK SODQHULQJ RFK LQWH PLQVW EULVWDQGH HUIDUHQKHWDYDWWXQGHUYLVDSnGLVWDQV6nVPnQLQJRPLQVnJMDJGRFNDWWlYHQRPYnUVLWXDWLRQ VRPSLRQMlUHUSnHWWQ\WWSURJUDPPHGI|UGHHQKHOGHOVYnULJKHWHUVnIDQQVGHWlYHQVWXGHQWHU Sn EHW\GOLJW PHU HWDEOHUDGH SURJUDP VRP NRQIURQWHUDWV PHG OLNQDQGH SUREOHP VRP YL YDG JlOOGHSURJUDPPHULQJHQ 3UREOHPDYJUlQVQLQJDWWRPVlWWDNlQVODQLHWWNRQNUHWSURMHNW +XURPVlWWHUPDQHQNlQVODLHWWNRQNUHWSURMHNW"'HWJlOOHUDWWILQQDHQUHDOLVWLVNEHJUlQVQLQJ L GH IUnJRU PDQ VWlOOHU RFK DY GH YHUNOLJKHWHU PDQ YlOMHU DWW XQGHUV|ND )|U PLJ YDU GHW QDWXUOLJWDWWYlOMDDWWWLWWDSnPLWWHJHWSURJUDPPHQHIWHUVRPMDJYLOOHVSHJODGHWPRWQnJRW JlOOGH GHWDWW KLWWD PLQVW\WWHUOLJDUH HWW SURJUDP PHG OLNDUWDGH I|UXWVlWWQLQJDU bYHQ RP MDJ DOGULJ KDUKDIW I|U DYVLNW DWW J|UD QnJRQ GLUHNW MlPI|UHOVH VnJ MDJ GHW VRP EHW\GHOVHIXOOW DWW SURJUDPPHQ JLFN DWW UHODWHUD WLOO YDUDQGUD $QOHGQLQJHQ YDU DWW MDJ GlULJHQRP YLOOH YLVD DWW SUREOHPHQ RFK P|MOLJKHWHUQD LQWH L I|UVWD KDQG OLJJHU Sn HQ QLYn VRP HQEDUW EHU|U GHQ HQVNLOGDXWELOGQLQJHQ6QDUDUHILQQVGHSnHQ|YHUJULSDQGHVWUXNWXUHOOQLYn6DPWLGLJWlUMDJ PHGYHWHQ RP DWW L GHQ |YHUJULSDQGH VWUXNWXUHQ U\PV HQVNLOGKHWHU VRP KDU EHW\GHOVH I|U XWIDOOHW'HWJHQHUHOODRFKGHWVSHFLILND JnUKDQGLKDQG'HWJnULQWHDWWERUWVH IUnQGHWHQD XWDQ DWW I|UORUD QnJRW YlVHQWOLJW L EHVNULYQLQJHQ 'lUI|U KDU MDJ I|UV|NW EHKnOOD EnGD SHUVSHNWLYHQ 'HWYnSURJUDPMDJWLOOVLVWYDOGHDWWDUEHWDPHGVRPXWJnQJVSXQNWI|UPLQDIUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU YDU ,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLSURJUDPPHW UHVSHNWLYH 0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHW %nGD lU UHODWLYW .

(14) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. Q\VWDUWDGH K|VWWHUPLQHQ UHVSHNWLYH

(15) 'H KDU VDPPD DQWDJQLQJVNUDY VWDQGDUG EHK|ULJKHW ' YLONHW LQQHElU PDWHPDWLN & UHVSHNWLYH VDPKlOOVNXQVNDS $

(16) 'H JUXQG OlJJDQGH SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHUQD JHV L VDPPD VSUnN MDYD

(17) 1lU MDJ LQOHGGH PLWW DUEHWH NXQGH XWELOGQLQJDUQD GHVVXWRP OHGD WLOO VDPPD VOXWH[DPHQ ILORVRILH NDQGLGDWH[DPHQ L GDWDYHWHQVNDS

(18) )UnQE|UMDQKDGHMDJWlQNWWDPHG\WWHUOLJDUHHWWSURJUDPPHQMDJLQVnJVQDUW DWWPHGGHQEHJUlQVDGHWLGMDJKDGHWLOOPLWWI|UIRJDQGHYDUGHWWDLQWHUHDOLVWLVNW)OHUDDYGH DQGUDSURJUDPPHQYLG%7+ILQQVWURWVDOOWUHSUHVHQWHUDGHLQGLUHNWJHQRPDOODGHLQIRUPHOOD VDPWDOMDJI|UWPHGROLNDVWXGHQWHURFKOlUDUHXQGHUDUEHWHWVJnQJ )UnJHVWlOOQLQJDUHOOHUYDGYDUGHWHJHQWOLJHQMDJYLOOHKDVYDUSn" %ODQG PLQD LQOHGDQGH IXQGHULQJDU LQI|U DUEHWHW IDQQV IUnJRU VRP EHU|UGH YDUI|U YLVVD Q\E|UMDUVWXGHQWHULSURJUDPPHULQJXSSOHYHUlPQHWVRPVnVYnUWRFKYDUI|UDQGUDLQWHJ|UGHW -DJIXQGHUDGHYLGDUH|YHURPGHWILQQVQnJRWLOlURSURFHVVHQVRPWLOOWDODUYLVVDPHQI|UYLUUDU DQGUDRFKRPXQGHUYLVQLQJHQP|MOLJHQLSUDNWLNHQlUXSSODJGXWLIUnQDWWVWXGHQWHUQDI|UYlQWDV KD HQ JDQVND EUHG GDWRUYDQD lYHQ RP GHWWD DOGULJ XWWDODV

(19) )|OMGIUnJDQ EOHY Gn RP GH VWXGHQWHUVRPVDNQDUGHQQDGDWRUYDQDNXQGHDQWDVKDVlPUHI|UXWVlWWQLQJDUYDGJlOOHUDWWOlUD VLJ SURJUDPPHULQJ 6OXWOLJHQ IXQGHUDGH MDJ |YHU RP GHW GlUXW|YHU JnU DWW VN|QMD QnJRQ N|QVPlVVLJVNLOOQDGRFKYLONDXWWU\FNGHQLVnIDOOWDUVLJ , GH XUVSUXQJOLJD IXQGHULQJDUQD XWJLFN MDJ KXYXGVDNOLJHQ IUnQ VWXGHQWHUQDV SHUVSHNWLY PHQ HIWHUVRP NXQVNDS HQOLJW PLQ XSSIDWWQLQJ lU QnJRW VRP L VWRU XWVWUlFNQLQJ IRUPDV L P|WHW PHOODQ OlUDUH RFK VWXGHQW HU

(20) VnJ MDJ GHW VRP YlVHQWOLJW DWW KD PHG EnGD GHVVD SHUVSHNWLY 'HVVD IXQGHULQJDU UHVXOWHUDGH L HWW DQWDO IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU VRP MDJ KRSSDVGHWWD DUEHWH O\FNDV EHO\VD.

(21) 9LONHQEHW\GHOVHKDUEDNJUXQGVIDNWRUHUVRPROLNDXWELOGQLQJVEDNJUXQGWLGLJDUHGDWRUYDQD LQNOXVLYHHYHQWXHOODHUIDUHQKHWHUDYSURJUDPPHULQJ

(22) N|QHWF I|USURJUDPPHULQJVLQOlU QLQJHQ"

(23) 9LONDI|UHVWlOOQLQJDURFKI|UKnOOQLQJVVlWWILQQVNULQJSURJUDPPHULQJ"

(24) 9DGPHUH[DNWlUGHWVRPGHVWXGHQWHUVRPXSSOHYHUVLJKDVYnULJKHWHUPHGLQOlUQLQJHQ XSSOHYHUVRPSUREOHPDWLVNW"

(25) +XUXSSOHYHUGHOlUDUHVRPXQGHUYLVDULSURJUDPPHULQJVLWXDWLRQHQ"

(26) +XUVHUGHQNRQWH[WGHWVDPPDQKDQJXWVRPXQGHUYLVQLQJHQRFKLQGLYLGHUQDIRUPDVLRFK KXUSnYHUNDUGHQOlURSURFHVVHQ" 0HWRGGHUHGVNDSVRPMDJYDOGHDWWDUEHWDPHG )|U DWW EHO\VD PLQD IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU EHVWlPGH MDJ PLJ Sn HWW WLGLJW VWDGLXP I|U DWW J|UD LQVSHODGHLQWHUYMXHUPHGVWXGHQWHURFKOlUDUH-DJKDGHWlQNWEHJUlQVDPLJWLOOPHOODQI\UDRFK VH[VWXGHQWHUUHVSHNWLYHWYnOlUDUHSHUSURJUDP8QGHUDUEHWHWVJnQJYDOGHMDJGRFNDWWXW|ND DQWDOHWLQWHUYMXHU. $QOHGQLQJHQ WLOO DWW MDJ YDOW DWW DUEHWD PHG LQWHUYMXHU VRP PHWRG lU DWW MDJ VnJ GHW VRP HQ P|MOLJKHW DWW In IUDP PHU JHQRPWlQNWD RFK Q\DQVHUDGH VYDU lQ YDG VRP EOLU IDOOHW YLG HQ HQNlWXQGHUV|NQLQJ(QLQWHUYMXJHUHQKHOWDQQDQP|MOLJKHWWLOOXSSI|OMQLQJDYVYDUJHQRPDWW. 6WXGHQWHUQDYLG07SURJUDPPHWNDQHQOLJWEHVOXWVRPIDWWDWVXQGHUYnUHQHUKnOODDQWLQJHQHQWHNQRORJLH NDQGLGDWH[DPHQHOOHUHQILORVRILHNDQGLGDWH[DPHQLKXYXGlPQHWPHGLHWHNQLN . .

(27) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. MDJVRP LQWHUYMXDUHNDQVWlOOD I|OMGIUnJRU VRP EHVWlPV DY LQWHUYMXVLWXDWLRQHQ 9DG JlOOHU GH LQWHUYMXDGHVWXGHQWHUQDVnJMDJGHWVRPYlVHQWOLJWDWWJ|UDHQXSSI|OMQLQJHIWHUDYVOXWDGNXUV 'HWYDUGnHQI|UGHODWWLYLVVPnQKDNXQQDWI|OMDLQIRUPDQWHQLGHQQHVLQOlUQLQJVSURFHVV. 'H LQIRUPHOOD VDPWDOHQ lU HWW DQQDW DY GH UHGVNDS MDJ DQYlQW PLJ DY L DUEHWHW PHG I|UHOLJJDQGHUDSSRUW,QOHGQLQJVYLVEHWUDNWDGHMDJLQWHGHVVDLQIRUPHOODVDPWDOVRPQnJRWVRP LQJLFNLPLQPHWRG6nVPnQLQJRPLQVnJMDJDWWGHLDOOUDK|JVWDJUDGXWJMRUGHHQGHO/LNDVn LQJnUGHWLOOIlOOHQGnMDJVXWWLWPHGRFKO\VVQDW JlOOHUIUDPI|UDOOW0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHW

(28) Sn OHNWLRQHU XWYlUGHULQJ RFK UHGRYLVQLQJVWLOOIlOOHQ 'HW IMlUGH UHGVNDSHW XWJ|UV DY GHQ OLWWHUDWXUMDJKDUOlVWLW\VWGLDORJPHGGHWUH|YULJDLQVWUXPHQWHQ 0HWRGRORJLXWJnQJVSXQNWHULVNDSDQGHWDYNXQVNDS 1lUMDJI|UVWE|UMDGHIXQGHUD|YHUKXUMDJVNXOOHQlUPDPLJPLWWlPQHXSSOHYGH MDJHQVWRU RVlNHUKHW,GHQJHQRPJnQJDYKXUHWWH[DPHQVDUEHWHE|UVNULYDVVRPMDJGHOWDJLWLYLG %7+ NRQFHQWUHUDGHVLJP\FNHWDYGLVNXVVLRQHQNULQJYLNWHQDYDWWIRUPXOHUDHQK\SRWHVGYVHWW DQWDJDQGHVRPDQWLQJHQNDQEHYLVDVHOOHUPRWEHYLVDV3UREOHPHWYDUDWWMDJLQWHYLVVWHYDGMDJ VNXOOH EHYLVD HOOHU PRWEHYLVD

(29) DWW SURJUDPPHULQJVXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ YDU GnOLJ" HOOHU DWW RP DOOD ILFN E|UMD PHG DWW OlUD VLJ SURJUDPPHUD JUDILVND DQYlQGDUJUlQVVQLWW VNXOOH DOOD VYnULJKHWHU I|UVYLQQD" HOOHU DWW PHG PLQGUH WHRUL RFK PHU KnUGNRGQLQJ VNXOOH YlUOGHQ EOL O\FNOLJDUH"6lNHUWlUDWWVDPWOLJDSnVWnHQGHQRYDQKDGHJnWWDWWEHYLVDVnYlOVRPPRWEHYLVD JHQRP DWW PHG RPVRUJ YlOMD UHIHUHQVHU RFK LQWHUYMXSHUVRQHU VRP SDVVDGH GHW UHVXOWDW MDJ |QVNDGHXSSQn,LQWHUYMXVLWXDWLRQHQVnYlOVRPLOLWWHUDWXUHQKDUMDJVW|WWSnI|UHVSUnNDUHVnYlO VRPPRWVSUnNDUHI|UDOODGHWUHSnVWnHQGHQD)|UHVSUnNDUHUHVSHNWLYHPRWVSUnNDUHVRPVlNHUW VNXOOHVWlOODXSSRFKVNULYDXQGHUSnDWWVnKlUlUGHW0HQYDGVNXOOHMDJLVnIDOOXSSQnPHG GHW"6NXOOHMDJKDEHYLVDWVDQQLQJHQ"9LONHQVDQQLQJLVnIDOORFKYHPV" 0LWW L GHVVD EU\GHULHU ILFN MDJ HWW HUEMXGDQGH RP DWW Jn HQ NXUV PHG UXEULNHQ 0HWRG PHWRGRORJLRFKHSLVWHPRORJLLIHPLQLVWLVNDIRUVNQLQJVSURFHVVHU EHQlPQVKlGDQHIWHUPHWRG PHWRGRORJLNXUVHQ

(30) 8QGHUDUEHWHWPHGGHQQDNXUVE|UMDGHMDJI|UVWnYDULPLWWGLOHPPDOnJ 'HIXQGHULQJDUMDJEDUSnERWWQDGHLHQHSLVWHPRORJLVNNXQVNDSVWHRUHWLVNNRQIOLNW'HWEOHY W\GOLJW I|U PLJ DWW MDJ L PLQ UROO VRP VWXGHQW YLG HQ WHNQLVN K|JVNROD EHIDQQ PLJ L HWW VDPPDQKDQJVRPSUlJODVDYHQSRVLWLYLVWLVNNXQVNDSVV\Q'HWlULQWHVnDWWMDJYLOOSnVWnDWW GHQQDSUlJOLQJNlQQHWHFNQDVDYHQWRWDOEOLQGKHWLQI|UGHQNULWLNPRWREMHNWLYNXQVNDSVRP lU QlVWDQ OLND JDPPDO VRP SRVLWLYLVPHQ VMlOY , GHQ NXUVOLWWHUDWXU I|U H[DPHQVDUEHWH VRP IOLWLJW DQYlQGV LQRP K|JVNRODQ EHVNULYV WYn YHWHQVNDSOLJD I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW YDUDY GHW HQD lU SRVLWLYLVPHQRFKGHWDQGUDlUKHUPHQHXWLNHQ 'HWVHQDUHI|UKnOOQLQJVVlWWHWEHVNULYVVRPGHW I|UUDV PRWVDWV L RFK PHG DWW GHW NlQQHWHFNQDV DY WRONQLQJ DY YHUNOLJKHWHQ VQDUDUH lQ EHVWlPQLQJDYGHQVDPPD3UREOHPHWlUDWWLSUDNWLNHQVWlOOVDOGULJGHQJUXQGOlJJDQGHIUnJDQ 9LONHQYHUNOLJKHWRFKYHPV" )|U DWW IRUPXOHUD PLQD HJQD XWJnQJVSXQNWHU KDU MDJ KDIW VWRU KMlOS DY GHQ OlVQLQJ RFK GH GLVNXVVLRQHU VRP I|UWV L PHWRG PHWRGRORJL NXUVHQ 7Yn DQGUD NXUVHU KDU RFNVn KDIW VWRU. .XUVHQ YDU HQ GRNWRUDQGNXUV VRP JDYV L VDPDUEHWH PHOODQ %7+ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ I|U $UEHWVYHWHQVNDS RFK 0HGLHWHNQLN IRUVNQLQJVHQKHWHQ I|U ,7 RFK JHQXVIRUVNQLQJ QXPHUD 7HNQRYHWHQVNDSOLJD VWXGLHU

(31) RFK /XOHn WHNQLVNDXQLYHUVLWHW,QVWLWXWLRQHQI|UDUEHWVYHWHQVNDSDYGHOQLQJHQJHQXVRFKWHNQLN.XUVHQYDUXSSGHODGLWUH DYVQLWW VRP YDU I|UODJGD WLOO ROLND WLGSXQNWHU XQGHU SHULRGHQ VHSWHPEHU IHEUXDUL 'HW DYVQLWW MDJ GLVNXWHUDUNULQJKlUXWJMRUGHGHWI|UVWDDYVQLWWHW -DJWlQNHUKlUIUDPI|UDOOWSn5XQD3DWHOVRFK%R'DYLGVRQV)RUVNQLQJVPHWRGLNHQVJUXQGHU . .

(32) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. EHW\GHOVHLPLQDHSLVWHPRORJLVNDIXQGHULQJDU'HQHQDlU,7VLGpKLVWRULDL JHQXVIRUVNQLQJV SHUVSHNWLY GHQ DQGUD lU <UNHVNXQQDQGH RFK 7HNQRORJL %nGD NXUVHUQD JDYV YLG %7+ ,QVWLWXWLRQHQ I|U $UEHWVYHWHQVNDS RFK 0HGLHWHNQLN IRUVNQLQJVHQKHWHQ I|U 7HNQRYHWHQ VNDSOLJDVWXGLHU,GHVVDEnGDNXUVHUKDUMDJInWWYLNWLJDUHGVNDSLIRUPDYWH[WHUHWDEOHUDGHL GHQ YHWHQVNDSOLJD YlUOGHQ G Y V WH[WHU VRP KDU JUDQVNDWV DY DQGUD IRUVNDUH RFK GlUPHG EHWUDNWDV VRP YHGHUKlIWLJD *HQRP GHQQD OlVQLQJ KDU MDJ InWW P|MOLJKHW DWW UHIOHNWHUD |YHU NXQVNDSHQ VRP EHJUHSS RFK YDG VRP XWJ|U PLQ HJHQ NXQVNDSVV\Q -DJ KDU RFNVn KDIW P|MOLJKHW DWW SU|YD HQ GHO DY PLQD WDQNHJnQJDU L VNULIWOLJD DQDO\VHU VnYlO VRP PXQWOLJD GLVNXVVLRQHUYLONDYDULWRHUK|UWYlUGHIXOODLPLQHJHQWDQNHSURFHVV 6\QHQSnNXQVNDSPLQHJHQRFKDQGUDVVSHODUVnOHGHVHQJUXQGOlJJDQGHUROOLGHWDUEHWHGX KDU IUDPI|UGLJ'HWlU GRFN YLNWLJWDWW NRPPD LKnJ DWW PLQ lPQHVPlVVLJD XWJnQJVSXQNW lU GDWDYHWHQVNDSDGE'HWlUWDFNYDUHGHQXWJnQJVSXQNWHQMDJNDQYlOMDGHSHUVSHNWLYMDJJ|UL IRUP DY IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU RFK WRONQLQJDU +DGH MDJ VDNQDW GHQQD lPQHVPlVVLJD I|UDQNULQJ KDGHSHUVSHNWLYHWEOLYLWHWWDQQDW 6\IWH PnOJUXSS 0LQPnOVlWWQLQJKDUYDULWDWWYLVDSnQnJUDDYGHVYnULJKHWHUPHQRFNVnP|MOLJKHWHUVRPNDQ XSSIDWWDV L IRUPDQGHW DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS Sn Q\E|UMDUQLYn *HQRP DWW VDPWDOD PHG VnYlOOlUDUHVRPVWXGHQWHUKDUMDJI|UV|NWW\GOLJJ|UDKXUVNDSDQGHWDYNXQVNDSlUQnJRWVRP VNHULP|WHWGHPHPHOODQ'HIUnJHVWlOOQLQJDUMDJEHVNULYHULDYVQLWWKDUXWJMRUWEDVHQI|U GHVVDVDPWDO)UDPI|UDOOWKDUMDJI|UV|NWV\QOLJJ|UDGHQNRQWH[WLQRPYLONHQXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ WLOOlPSDV 0LQ I|UKRSSQLQJ lU DWW DUEHWHW L I|UOlQJQLQJHQ NDQ JH LPSXOVHU WLOO Q\D YlJDU L I|UPHGODQGHW DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 6RP SRWHQWLHOOD OlVDUH VHU MDJ XWELOGQLQJV DQVYDULJD VWXGHQWHU RFK OlUDUH OLNVRP DQGUD VRP Sn ROLND VlWW lU LQYROYHUDGH L SURJUDP PHULQJVXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ 5DSSRUWHQ NDQ lYHQ YDUD LQWUHVVDQW I|U GHP VRP KDU HWW DOOPlQW LQWUHVVHDYDWWVWXGHUDKXUOlURSURFHVVHQIRUPDURFKIRUPDVDYGHGHOWDJDQGHSDUWHUQD 5DSSRUWHQVXSSOlJJQLQJ 5DSSRUWHQlULQGHODGLIHPNDSLWHO'HROLNDNDSLWOHQEHKDQGODULNRUWKHWI|OMDQGH.

(33) , LQOHGQLQJHQ EHVNULYHU MDJ PLWW lPQHVYDO RFK EDNJUXQGHQ WLOO GHW -DJ I|UNODUDU RFNVn YLOND PHWRGHU MDJ DQYlQW RFK GH PHWRGRORJLVND XWJnQJVSXQNWHUQD I|U PLWW DUEHWH 6OXWOLJHQEHVNULYHUMDJV\IWHWPHGUDSSRUWHQOLNVRPYHPGHQULNWDUVLJWLOO

(34) %DNJUXQGVNDSLWOHW XWJ|U HQ NRUW EHVNULYQLQJ DY GH EnGD XWELOGQLQJDU VRP LQJnWW L GHQ HPSLULVND GHOHQ DY XQGHUV|NQLQJHQ )UDPI|UDOOW LQQHKnOOHU GHW HQ LQJnHQGH UHGRJ|UHOVH I|UXWIRUPQLQJHQDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHUQDYLGGHUHVSHNWLYHSURJUDPPHQ

(35) .DSLWHO WUH WHFNQDU HQ ELOG DY UHVXOWDWHQ IUnQ GHQ HPSLULVND XQGHUV|NQLQJHQ 8QGHUUXEULNHUQD nWHUVSHJODU GH WHPDQ VRP IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDUQD NUHWVDW NULQJ ([HPSHO Sn GHVVD WHPDQ lU LQQHE|UGHU DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS ROLND I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW L I|UYlUYDQGHW DY SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS WLGLJDUH HUIDUHQKHWHU DY GDWRUHU RFK SURJUDPPHULQJPP (OLVDEHWK *XOEUDQGVHQ I|U L DUWLNHOQ 2EMHFWLYLW\" 5HIOH[LYLW\ $XWKRULW\" VRP LQJnU L KHQQHV OLFHQWLDW DYKDQGOLQJ HWW LQWUHVVDQW UHVRQHPDQJ RP KXU I|UHVWlOOQLQJDU RP DXNWRULWHW HOOHU EULVW Sn DXNWRULWHW L HQ WH[W IRUPDVLQRPGHQYHWHQVNDSOLJDYlUOGHQ,GHWWDVDPPDQKDQJYlOMHUMDJGRFNDWWEDUDQlPQDGLVNXVVLRQHQVRPHQ ILQJHUYLVQLQJRPDWWYHWHQVNDSRFKYHWHQVNDSOLJKHWVRPEHJUHSSLQWHlUKHOWRNRPSOLFHUDGH. .

(36) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB.

(37) $QDO\VNDSLWOHWlUHWWI|UV|NDWWnWHUVSHJODGHQIRUWJnHQGH GLDORJ PHOODQIlOWVWXGLHUQDRFK GHQ OLWWHUDWXU MDJ OlVW VRP YDULW XWPlUNDQGH I|U DUEHWVSURFHVVHQ , DQDO\VHQ KDU MDJ IRUPXOHUDWWUHNXQVNDSVWHPDQXQGHUYLONDROLNDDVSHNWHUDYNXQVNDSGLVNXWHUDV'HWI|UVWD WHPDW EHKDQGODU V\QHQ Sn NXQVNDS GHW DQGUD IRUPDQGHW DY NXQVNDS RFK GHW WUHGMH GLVNXWHUDUYlJOHGDUHLIRUPDQGHWDYNXQVNDS

(38) 'HW VLVWD NDSLWOHW XWJ|U HQ GLVNXVVLRQ NULQJ GH HQOLJW PLQ XSSIDWWQLQJ PHVW FHQWUDOD IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDUQDLDUEHWHW-DJUHGRJ|UKlUI|UGHNRQWH[WXHOODSUREOHPMDJLGHQWLILHUDUL DQDO\VHQVDPWI|UHWWUHVRQHPDQJNULQJP|MOLJDRUVDNHUWLOOGHP %LODJHGHOHQ LQQHKnOOHU HQ RUGOLVWD PHG SURJUDPPHULQJVUHODWHUDGH WHUPHU VRP I|UHNRPPHU L DUEHWHW'HQlUWlQNWDWWIXQJHUDVRPHWWVW|GYLGOlVQLQJHQI|UGHPVRPLQWHXPJnVPHGGHVVD WHUPHU GDJOLJHQ %ODQG ELODJRUQD ILQQV RFNVn GH IUnJHPDOODUMDJ XWJnWW LIUnQ L VDPEDQG PHG LQWHUYMXDUEHWHW. .

(39) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. %DNJUXQG , GHWWD NDSLWHO JHU MDJ HQ NRUWIDWWDG EHVNULYQLQJ DY GH WYn XWELOGQLQJDU VRP LQJnU L XQGHUV|NQLQJHQ-DJUHGRJ|URFNVnI|UXSSOlJJQLQJHQDYRFKLQQHKnOOHWLGHUHVSHNWLYHXWELOG QLQJDUQDVLQOHGDQGH SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUV $YVOXWQLQJVYLV J|U MDJ HQ MlPI|UDQGH NRPPHQWDU NULQJNXUVHUQDVXWIRUPQLQJ %DNJUXQG,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLSURJUDPPHW. ,QIRUPDWLRQVWHNQRORJLXWELOGQLQJHQ HOOHU ,7SURJUDPPHW VRP GHQ NDOODV LQWHUQW JHV YLG ,QVWLWXWLRQHQI|USURJUDPYDUXWHNQLNRFKGDWDYHWHQVNDS LSG

(40) 'HQlUHQGLVWDQVXWELOGQLQJGlU VWXGHQWHUQD KDU WYn DOWHUQDWLY 'HW HQD LQQHElU DWW WYn nU OlVHV KHOW Sn GLVWDQV YDUHIWHU HQ K|JVNROHH[DPHQ L DGE HUKnOOHV 'HW DQGUD DOWHUQDWLYHW LQQHElU DWW GHW I|UVWD nUHW OlVHV Sn GLVWDQVWLOOVDPPDQVPHGGHPVRPOlVHUWLOOHQK|JVNROHH[DPHQRFKDWWGHWYnVLVWDnUHQOlVHV Sn %7+ L 5RQQHE\ $YVOXWDG XWELOGQLQJ OHGHU WLOO HQ ILORVRILH NDQGLGDWH[DPHQ L DGEGDWDYHWHQVNDS2DYVHWWRPVWXGHQWHQOlVHUWYnHOOHUWUHnUKDUXWELOGQLQJHQVRPV\IWHDWW JH HQ JUXQGOlJJDQGH GDWRUNRPSHWHQV RFK YDQD YDG JlOOHU DWW DUEHWD PHG ROLND W\SHU DY WLOOlPSQLQJDUVnYlOVRPYLGDWWXWIRUPDUXWLQHURFKYHUNW\JWLOOVW|GI|UGHWHJQDDUEHWHW 8WELOGQLQJHQ VlJV I|UEHUHGD VWXGHQWHQ I|U NYDOLILFHUDGH XSSJLIWHU LQRP V\VWHPXWYHFNOLQJ SURJUDPPHULQJRFKXSSKDQGOLQJDYGDWRULVHUDGHLQIRUPDWLRQVV \VWHP 8QGHU GLVWDQVGHOHQ DY XWELOGQLQJHQ DQRUGQDV I|UHOlVQLQJDU RFK ODERUDWLRQHU Sn K|JVNRODQ L 5RQQHE\ YDU IMRUWRQGH GDJ 'HVVD WUlIIDU lU LQWH REOLJDWRULVND PHQ UHNRPPHQGHUDV IUnQ SURJUDPOHGQLQJHQV VLGD 6WXGHQWHUQD XSSPDQDV lYHQ DWW ELOGD ORNDOD VWXGLHJUXSSHU $GUHVVXSSJLIWHURFKWHOHIRQQXPPHUGLVWULEXHUDVGlUI|UWLOODOODUHJLVWUHUDGHVWXGHQWHULE|UMDQ DYWHUPLQHQ 1lU ,7SURJUDPPHWVIMlUGH nUVNXOO DY VWXGHQWHU E|UMDGH K|VWWHUPLQHQ UHJLVWUHUDGHV VWXGHQWHUYDUDYNYLQQRU9LGYnUWHUPLQHQVE|UMDQGYV LPLWWHQDYMDQXDULVWRG DYGHVVDYDUDYNYLQQRUIRUWIDUDQGHVRPUHJLVWUHUDGHYLGSURJUDPPHW %DNJUXQG0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHW 0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHW 07SURJUDPPHW

(41) JHV YLG LQVWLWXWLRQHQ I|U $UEHWVYHWHQVNDS RFK 0HGLHWHNQLN LDP

(42) IRUVNQLQJVHQKHWHQI|U7HNQRYHWHQVNDSOLJDVWXGLHU3URJUDPPHWlUQ\WWI|U K|VWWHUPLQHQRFKSURJUDPPHWVI\VLVNDSODFHULQJlUL.DUOVKDPQVWXGHQWHUYDUDY NYLQQRU VWRG VRP UHJLVWUHUDGH YLG K|VWWHUPLQHQV E|UMDQ 'n YnUWHUPLQHQ LQOHGGHV KDGH HQ NYLQQOLJ

(43) VWXGHQW KRSSDW DY 8WELOGQLQJHQ lU WUHnULJ RFK OHGHU EHURHQGH Sn LQULNWQLQJ WLOO DQWLQJHQHQWHNQRORJLHNDQGLGDWH[DPHQHOOHUHQILORVRILHNDQGLGDWH[DPHQLPHGLHWHNQLN. 6\IWHW PHG XWELOGQLQJHQ lU DWW PHG XWJnQJVSXQNW IUnQ PHGLHEUDQVFKHQV EHKRY DY \UNHVVNLFNOLJD PlQQLVNRU VRP NDQ KDQWHUD GLJLWDOD WHNQLN DUEHWV RFK GLVWULEXWLRQVIO|GHQ 9LONHWDYlPQHQDVRPXWJ|UKXYXGlPQHLH[DPHQEHVWlPVDYYLONHQLQULNWQLQJGHQHQVNLOGHVWXGHQWHQYlOMHU 'HVRPYlOMHUGDWDYHWHQVNDSOLJLQULNWQLQJKDUP|MOLJKHWDWWE\JJDSnXWELOGQLQJHQPHGHWWIMlUGHPDJLVWHUnU (QOLJWGHQXWELOGQLQJVEHVNULYQLQJVRPIRUPXOHUDGHVLQI|UDQWDJQLQJHQWLOOK|VWWHUPLQHQ ,ELG . .

(44) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. >@XWELOGDGLJLWDODKDQWYHUNDUHVRPNDQWLOOlPSDVLQDNXQVNDSHURFKHUIDUHQKHWHULPnQJD ROLNDGLJLWDODPHGLHU. 'H VWXGHUDQGH YLG SURJUDPPHW XWUXVWDV YDU RFK HQ PHG HQ ElUEDU GDWRU VRP GH InU EHKnOOD XQGHUKHODXWELOGQLQJHQ(QDYWDQNDUQDEDNRPGHWWDlUDWWVWXGHQWHUQDLQWHVNDYDUDEXQGQD DY DWW EHILQQD VLJ Sn HQ EHVWlPG SODWV L VWXGLHDUEHWHW 6WXGHQWHUQD EOLU PHU PRELOD RFK NDQ GlUPHG OlWWDUH WLOOYDUDWD GHQ SRWHQWLHOOD NUHDWLYLWHW GHW LQQHElU DWW PnQJD LQGLYLGHU RFK VDPPDQKDQJ P|WV 6WXGHQWHUQD XSSPXQWUDV RFNVn DWW WD HWW VWRUW HJHW DQVYDU I|U GHQ HJQD OlURSURFHVVHQ,GHWWDDQVYDULQJnUDWWIRUPXOHUDGHQHJQDPnOVlWWQLQJHQPHGXWELOGQLQJHQRFK P|MOLJDYlJDUI|UDWWQnGHQQDPnOVlWWQLQJ6WXGHQWHUQDInUWH[UHGDQLQI|UDQGUDnUHWYlOMDGH RPUnGHQ LQRP YLOND GH lU LQWUHVVHUDGH DY DWW I|UGMXSD VLQD NXQVNDSHU /HNWLRQVQlUYDURQ lU IULYLOOLJ'HQHQGD JnQJHQPDQIUnQK|JVNRODQVVLGDI|UXWVlWWHUDWWDOOD lU QlUYDUDQGH lU YLG GHQnWHUNRPPDQGHYHFNRVDPOLQJHQVRPKnOOVYDUMHIUHGDJVI|UPLGGDJ. 9LG XWELOGQLQJHQ I|UV HQ SnJnHQGH GLVNXVVLRQ NULQJ EHW\GHOVHQ DY DYOlUQLQJ G Y V DWW YL VRP GHOWDJDUH L HWW XWELOGQLQJVVDPPDQKDQJ PnVWH DUEHWD PHG DWW OlUD ERUW LQDUEHWDGH I|UHVWlOOQLQJDU VRP YDULW GRPLQHUDQGH LQRP WUDGLWLRQHOOW VYHQVNW XWELOGQLQJVYlVHQGH I|UHVWlOOQLQJDU RFK YlUGHULQJDU VRP E\JJHU Sn §NRQNXUUHQVWlQNDQGH OlUDUDXNWRULWHW RFK ©NlQGD VYDU Sn NlQGD IUnJRU© ,VWlOOHW YLOO GH DQVYDULJD I|U XWELOGQLQJHQ WLOOYDUDWD EnGH OlURSURFHVVHU RFK UHVXOWDW $PELWLRQHQ lU DWW VNDSD I|UXWVlWWQLQJDU I|U DWW GHQ HQVNLOGHV VRFLDOD RFK SHUVRQOLJD NRPSHWHQV >VND NXQQD@ Yl[D YDG JlOOHU W H[ DQVYDU VDPDUEHWH RPG|PH RFK HWW NULWLVNW I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW )|U DWW J|UD GHW P|MOLJW DWW VNDSD GHVVD I|UXWVlWWQLQJDU lU GHW EHW\GHOVHIXOOW DWW EHWUDNWD GHOWDJDUQDV OlURSURFHVVHU L HWW WUHnUV SHUVSHNWLY. , SURJUDPEHVNULYQLQJHQ I|UNODUDV GH I|UKnOOQLQJVVlWW GH DQVYDULJD YLOO XWJn IUnQ L XWELOGQLQJVVLWXDWLRQHQ , NRUWKHW EHWRQDV KlU YLNWHQ DY DWW EnGH WLOOYDUDWD WUDGLWLRQHOOD XQGHUYLVQLQJVIRUPHUWH[LIRUPDYI|UHOlVQLQJDURFKVHPLQDULHUVRPDWWI|UV|NDILQQDQ\DEO D JHQRP LQWHJUHUDGH NXUVHU RFKDQGUD WYlUYHWHQVNDSOLJD |SSQLQJDU (WW VlWW DWW nVWDGNRPPD GHWWD lU JHQRP DWW OlPQD XWU\PPH I|U I|UXWVlWWQLQJVO|VD LGpVDPWDO PHOODQ VWXGHQWHU OlUDUH RFKH[WHUQDLQWUHVVHQWHU'HWUHGHODUSURJUDPPHWYLOOLQWHJUHUDlU

(45) 'DWDYHWHQVNDS PHGLHWHNQLN RFK JHVWDOWQLQJ LQQHIDWWDU JUXQGWHNQLNHU LQRP GH ROLND KXYXGlPQHQD

(46) 5HIOHNWLRQ RPIDWWDUEODSURMHNWOHGQLQJPlQQLVNDRFKGDWRULQWHUDNWLRQF\ERUJWHRULHU ,7VLGpKLVWRULDPP

(47) 3URMHNW LQQHElUDWWNXUVHUQDLJUXQGWHNQLNRFKUHIOHNWLRQVNDWLOOlPSDVLROLNDGLJLWDOD PHGLHU JHQRP SURMHNW VRP E\JJHU Sn LGpVNDSDQGH SODQHULQJ RFK ILQDQVLHULQJ JHQRPI|UDQGHVDPWUHIOHNWLRQ. 'HWWD FLWDW OLNVRP |YULJ LQIRUPDWLRQ L PLQ EHVNULYQLQJ DY 07SURJUDPPHW L GHWWD DYVQLWW

(48) lU Gn LQJHW DQQDW DQJHV KlPWDG IUnQ 3URJUDPEHVNULYQLQJ YHUVLRQ I|UIDWWDG DY 3HWHU (NGDKO $WW MDJ YDOW DQYlQGD GHWWDVRP NlOOD LVWlOOHW I|U GHQRIILFLHOOD XWELOGQLQJVEHVNULYQLQJ VRP SXEOLFHUDGHV L VDPPD VHULH PHG LQIRUPDWLRQVEODGVRP,7SURJUDPPHWVXWELOGQLQJVEHVNULYQLQJKlUU|UIUnQEHURUSnDWWMDJVnJGHWVRPYLNWLJWDWW DQYlQGD GHQ NlOOD VRP GH VWXGHQWHU VRP V|NW WLOO SURJUDPPHW VHQDVW NDQ KD NRPPLW L NRQWDNW PHG 'HQQD EHVNULYQLQJ VNLOMHU VLJ QlPOLJHQ Sn YLVVD YlVHQWOLJD SXQNWHU IUnQ GHQ XUVSUXQJOLJD RIILFLHOOD XWELOGQLQJV EHVNULYQLQJHQ 'lUHPRW VWlPPHU GHQ YlO |YHUHQV PHG GHQ SUHVHQWDWLRQ DY SURJUDPPHW VRP J|UV L %7+V XWELOGQLQJVNDWDORJI|U %HW\GHOVHQDYDWWEHWUDNWDGHOWDJDUQDVOlURSURFHVVHULHWWWUHnUVSHUVSHNWLYLVWlOOHWI|U§WHUPLQI|UWHUPLQ§KDU VlUVNLOWEHWRQDWVLGHnWHUNRPPDQGHVDPWDOMDJKDUKDIWPHGGHDQVYDULJDI|UXWELOGQLQJHQ . .

(49) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 8WELOGQLQJHQ lU XSSE\JJG NULQJ ROLND SURMHNW

(50) HWW I|U YDUMH WHUPLQ )|U DWW UHDOLVHUD GH ROLNDSURMHNWHQSODQHUDVUHOHYDQWDNXUVHULQVRPNDQJHNXQVNDSHURPGHI|UVDPPDQKDQJHW Q|GYlQGLJD JUXQGWHNQLNHUQD

(51) ,QRP GH ROLND SURMHNWHQ YLOO GH DQVYDULJD DWW HWW NRQWLQXHUOLJW XWU\PPH I|U UHIOHNWLRQ VNDSDV JHQRP DWW VWXGHQWHUQDV HUIDUHQKHWHU RFK NXQVNDSHUWDVWLOOYDUD(WWDYPHGOHQI|UDWWVNDSDGHWWDXWU\PPHlUGHLQSODQHUDGHNXUVHUVRP WLOO VLWW LQQHKnOO SUREOHPDWLVHUDU UHODWLRQHQ HUQD

(52) PlQQLVND ¤ GDWRU GLVNXWHUDU LGpKLVWRULVND SHUVSHNWLYDY,7NRQNUHWLVHUDUIUnJHVWlOOQLQJDUNULQJSURMHNWOHGQLQJRVY

(53) 3URJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHUQDVXSSOlJJQLQJ ,7352*5$00(7$//0b17. ,7SURJUDPPHWVSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVGGYlUHQSRlQJVNXUVVRPEHVWnUDYYDGVRP WLGLJDUH YDULW WYn VHSDUDWD SRlQJVNXUVHU *UXQGOlJJDQGH ,7 GDE UHVSHNWLYH 3URJUDPPHULQJ L MDYD GGY OlVWHV WLGLJDUH XQGHU YDUVLQ OlVSHULRG SRlQJ I|UHWDJVHNRQRPL OlVHV VRP SDUDOOHOO NXUV XWGUDJHQ |YHU GHQ I|UVWD WHUPLQHQV EnGD OlVSHULRGHU*HQRPDWWVOnVDPPDQGHEnGDLQOHGDQGHNXUVHUQDLGDWDYHWHQVNDSRFKOnWDGHQ KRSVODJQDNXUVHQO|SDSnKDOYIDUWXQGHUYHFNRUKRSSDVSURJUDPOHGQLQJHQXSSQnSRVLWLYD HIIHNWHU I|U MDYDLQOlUQLQJHQ L RFK PHG DWW EHDUEHWQLQJVSHULRGHQ EOLU OlQJUH 7LGLJDUH nUV VWXGHQWHU KDU L NXUVXWYlUGHULQJDU IUDPI|UW DWW LQOlUQLQJHQ EOLYLW DOOWI|U NRPSULPHUDG Gn PDQ OlVWSRlQJMDYDSnKDOYIDUWXQGHUYHFNRU ,7SURJUDPPHWV LQOHGDQGH nU VND HQOLJW SURJUDPI|UNODULQJHQ NXQQD JHQRPI|UDV KHOW Sn GLVWDQV &LUND YDU IMRUWRQGH GDJ DQRUGQDV GRFN I|UOlVQLQJDU RFK HOOHU ODERUDWLRQHU I|U GHP VRP YLOO RFK KDU P|MOLJKHW DWW UHVD WLOO 5RQQHE\ , nU IDQQV GHVVXWRP HQ VWXGLHJUXSS L +|JDQlV PHG HJHQ KDQGOHGDUH 'HQQD VWXGLHJUXSS KDGH WLOOJnQJ WLOO HQ GDWDVDO VRP WLOOVDPPDQVPHGKDQGOHGDUHQVO|QILQDQVLHUDGHVDY+|JDQlVNRPPXQ'HWYDURFNVnGHVRP WDJLWLQLWLDWLYHWWLOOGHQQDO|VQLQJ0RPHQWHQLMDYDKDUSUHVHQWHUDWVJHQRPIHPI|UHOlVQLQJDU RFK VMX KDQGOHGGD ODERUDWLRQVWLOOIlOOHQ 8QGHU WHUPLQHQ EOHY HQ I|UHOlVQLQJ RFK HWW ODERUDWLRQVWLOOIlOOHL5RQQHE\LQVWlOOGD'HPRPHQWVRPPDQVNXOOHKDJnWWLJHQRPYLGGHVVD WLOOIlOOHQ ILFN VWXGHQWHUQD OlVD LQ Sn HJHQ KDQG $OO |YULJ KDQGOHGQLQJ XWI|UGHV YLD HSRVW DQWLQJHQ JHQRP NRPPXQLNDWLRQ L GHQQ\KHWVJUXSSVRP YDUNRSSODGWLOO NXUVHQHOOHU JHQRP DWW VWXGHQWHU RFK KDQGOHGDUH NRPPXQLFHUDGH GLUHNW PHG YDUDQGUD )UnQ K|JVNRODQV VLGD XSSPXQWUDGHVDQYlQGQLQJHQDYQ\KHWVJUXSSHQGHWYLUWXHOODNODVVUXPPHWI|UDWWDOODVNXOOH NXQQDInWDGHODYIUnJRURFKVYDU+DQGOHGDUQDODRFNVnXWIUnJRUDYDOOPlQWLQWUHVVH 'HSHUVRQHUVRPKDUYDULWLQYROYHUDGHLNXUVHQYDUHQH[WHUQI|UOlVDUHWLGLJDUHVWXGHQWYLG VNRODQV 'DWDLQJHQM|UVSURJUDP RFK QXPHUD GHOlJDUH L HWW XWELOGQLQJVI|UHWDJ VDPW I\UD ,7 VWXGHQWHU WYn WUHGMHnUV RFK WYn IMlUGHnUV

(54) DQVWlOOGD VRP DPDQXHQVHU , DPDQXHQVUROOHQ LQJLFN XUVSUXQJOLJHQ HQEDUW DWW GH VNXOOH IXQJHUD VRP ODEEKDQGOHGDUH , KDQGOHGDUXSSGUDJHW LQJnU EO D YlJOHGQLQJ YLG ODERUDWLRQHUQDV JHQRPI|UDQGH VDPW UlWWQLQJ DY GHVDPPD RFK DVVLVWDQVYLGWHQWDPHQVUlWWQLQJ9LGWHUPLQHQVE|UMDQXW|NDGHVXSSGUDJHWWLOODWWlYHQRPIDWWD XWIRUPQLQJHQ DY ODERUDWLRQHUQD VDPW YHFNR RFK NRQWUROOXSSJLIWHU RFK DOO UlWWQLQJ DY WHQWDPLQD6RPIRUPHOOWNXUVDQVYDULJKDU,7SURJUDPPHWVSURJUDPDQVYDULJHIXQJHUDW. ''9 *UXQGOlJJDQGH ,7 RFK SURJUDPPHULQJ L MDYD lU GHQ RIILFLHOOD NXUVNRGHQ I|U ,7SURJUDPPHWV LQOHGDQGHSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUV . .

(55) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 35$.7,6.$020(17)g5,7352*5$00(7. 'H VWXGHUDQGH YLG ,7SURJUDPPHW VNXOOH XQGHU K|VWWHUPLQHQ JHQRPI|UD I\UD REOLJDWRULVND ODERUDWLRQHU6WRSSGDWXPI|ULQOlPQLQJYDULHUDGHSnPHOODQWYnRFKIHPYHFNRUEHURHQGHSn ODERUDWLRQHQV RPIDWWQLQJ 'HVVXWRP JMRUGH GH DQVYDULJD KDQGOHGDUQD NRQWUROOIUnJRU WLOO GH WYn I|UVWD ODERUDWLRQHUQD VRP DYVnJ WlFND LQ GH EHJUHSS VWXGHQWHUQD ERUGH KD OlUW VLJ HIWHU JHQRPJnQJHQ ODERUDWLRQ .RQWUROOIUnJRUQD I\OOGH IXQNWLRQHQ DY VMlOYWHVW G Y V VWXGHQWHUQD NXQGHWHVWDVLQDNXQVNDSHUGLVNXWHUDGHPLGHWYLUWXHOODNODVVUXPPHWRFKILFNHIWHUHQYHFND VYDUHQ WLOO IUnJRUQD /DEEKDQGOHGDUQD OD lYHQ XW V N YHFNRXSSJLIWHU YLOND RFNVn KDGH IXQNWLRQHQDYVMlOYWHVWRFKGlUGLVNXVVLRQLGHWYLUWXHOODNODVVUXPPHWXSSPXQWUDGHV,VOXWHW DY QRYHPEHU VOXWDGH ODEEKDQGOHGDUQD DWW OlJJD XW YHFNRXSSJLIWHU PHG KlQYLVQLQJ WLOO DWW NXUVDQVYDULJEHVOXWDWDWWVWXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHJHVP|MOLJKHWDWWVNUDSDLKRSERQXVSRlQJWLOOGHQ NRPPDQGHWHQWDPHQJHQRPDWWXWI|UDWHVWHULHWWZHEEDVHUDWWHVWV\VWHP 6WXGHQWHUQDNXQGH HUKnOOD ERQXVSRlQJ JHQRP DWW JHQRPI|UD GH HOYD I|UVWD WHVWHUQD L V\VWHPHWPHG PLQVW UlWWSnYDUMHWHVW9DUMHJHQRPI|UWWHVWPHGPLQVWUlWWJHQHUHUDGHSnWHQWDQ6\VWHPHW YDUXSSE\JJWVnDWWQ\DIUnJRUVOXPSDGHVIUDPYDUMHJnQJHQSHUVRQJHQRPI|UWHWWWHVWYLONHW PHGI|UGHP|MOLJKHWHQDWWWHVWDVLJIOHUDJnQJHU )|U DWW VWXGHQWHUQD VNXOOH NXQQD JHQRPI|UD ODERUDWLRQHU L MDYD NUlYGHV GHW DWW GH LQVWDOOHUDW -'. -DYD'HYHORSPHQW.LW

(56) SnVLQDUHVSHNWLYHGDWRURUHU-'.YDUGHQXWYHFNOLQJVPLOM|VRP DQYlQGHVYLGXWYHFNODQGHWDYMDYDSURJUDP6RPLQOHGDQGH|YQLQJIDQQVGlUI|UHQODERUDWLRQ VRPQRJJUDQWEHVNUHYYDUPDQNDQInWDJSn-'.RFKKXUGHWLQVWDOOHUDV9LGDUHLQJLFNHQ EHVNULYQLQJ DY KXU PDQ NXQGH VNULYD HWW HQNHOW SURJUDP VDPW KXU NRGHQ NRPSLOHUDV UHVSHNWLYH H[HNYHUDV 6OXWOLJHQ IDQQV RFNVn HQ EHVNULYQLQJ DY HQ QRUPDO DUEHWVJnQJ YLG VNDSDQGHW DY SURJUDP VDPW I|UVODJ Sn ROLND HGLWRUHU VRP NXQGH DQYlQGDV YDUDY YLVVD LQQHK|OOVW|GIXQNWLRQHUVRPWH[UDGQXPUHULQJRFKIlUJODJGNRG. 'H I\UD ODERUDWLRQHU VRP VWXGHQWHUQD KDGH L XSSJLIW DWW UHGRYLVD YDU XSSE\JJGD HIWHU HWW JHPHQVDPW WHPD $YVLNWHQ YDU DWW ODERUDWLRQHUQD VNXOOH E\JJD Sn YDUDQGUD , GHQ I|UVWD ODERUDWLRQHQ YDU GHW KXYXGVDNOLJD V\IWHW DWW VWXGHQWHUQD VWLIWDGH EHNDQWVNDS PHG GH I|U REMHNWRULHQWHUDG SURJUDPPHULQJ JUXQGOlJJDQGH EHJUHSSHQ REMHNW RFK NODVV 'HW YDU GRFN IOHU EHJUHSS NRQFHSW VRP WUlQDGHV JHQRP ODERUDWLRQHQ VRP EHVWRG L DWW YDU RFK HQ DY VWXGHQWHUQDI|UYlQWDGHVVNDSDHQNODVVVRPUHSUHVHQWHUDUHQ &'VNLYDPHGGHVVW\SLVNDGDWD VRP WLWHO DUWLVW XWJLYQLQJVnU OlQJG Sn VNLYDQ PP 0HWRGHU VNXOOH VNDSDV I|U DWW YLVD UHWXUQHUD

(57) VnYlO VRP lQGUD GHVVD GDWD )|U DWW WHVWD PHWRGHUQD L &'NODVVHQ PnVWH VWXGHQWHUQD lYHQ VNDSD HQ WHVWNODVV (IWHU JHQRPI|UG ODERUDWLRQ I|UYlQWDGHV VWXGHQWHQ I|UXWRP DWW KD InWW I|UVWnHOVH I|U EHJUHSSHQ NODVV RFK REMHNW RFNVn I|UVWn LQQHE|UGHQ DY SURJUDPPHULQJVWHNQLVND EHJUHSS VRP YDULDEHO DWWULEXW

(58) PHWRG NRQVWUXNWRU WLOOJlQJOLJKHW SXEOLF UHVSHNWLYH SULYDWH

(59) VWUlQJDU KHOWDO IO\WWDO WLOOGHOQLQJ PDLQPHWRGHQ LQVWDQVLHULQJ SDUDPHWHU ,GHQDQGUDODERUDWLRQHQYDUV\IWHWDWWVWXGHQWHUQDOlUGHVLJDWWI|UVWnRFKDQYlQGDEHJUHSSHW DUY 8SSJLIWHQ EHVWRG DY DWW VWXGHQWHQ VNXOOH VNDSD HWW PHGLDDUNLY L IRUP DY HQ JHQHUHOO EDVNODVVHOOHUPHUNRUUHNWHQDEVWUDNWVXSHUNODVV

(60) PHGWUHVNVXENODVVHUI|UDWWUHSUHVHQWHUD ROLNDW\SHUDYPHGLDYLGHRFGRFKERNVRPVNXOOHlUYDJHPHQVDPPDGDWDRFKIXQNWLRQDOLWHW. 6HQDUHLQOlPQLQJDU JRGWRJVRFNVnPHQ UlWWQLQJHQDYGHVVDODERUDWLRQHUSULRULWHUDGHVLQWHRFKDOODVWXGHQWHU XSSPDQDGHVDWWI|UV|NDKnOODLQOlPQLQJVWLGHUQDI|UVLQHJHQVNXOOVnDWWGHVNXOOHVOLSSDKDONDHIWHU 7HVWV\VWHPHWnWHUILQQVSnDGUHVVKWWSFZSUHQKDOOFRPVDYLWFK QHUODGGDG

(61) 3URJUDPH[HPSOHW YDU GHW L SURJUDPPHULQJVVDPPDQKDQJ NODVVLVND +HOOR :RUOG VRP VNULYHU XW MXVW +HOOR :RUOGSnVNlUPHQ . .

(62) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. IUnQ VXSHUNODVVHQ PHGLD 'H NRQFHSW EHJUHSS VRP VWXGHQWHQ I|UKRSSQLQJVYLV KDGH InWW I|UVWnHOVHI|UHIWHUJHQRPI|UGODERUDWLRQYDUDUYVXENODVVVXSHUNODVVDEVWUDNWNODVVDEVWUDNW PHWRGSRO\PRUILVPUHWXUYlUGHH[WHQGVWLOOJlQJOLJKHW SURWHFWHG

(63) . 'HQ WUHGMH ODERUDWLRQHQ KDGH VRP KXYXGV\IWH DWW JH I|UVWnHOVH I|U EHJUHSS UHODWHUDGH WLOO GDWDVWUXNWXUHU YHNWRUHU PlQJGHU

(64) RFK DUY VXSHUNODVV VXENODVVHU LQNDSVOLQJ JHQRP DQYlQGDQGH DY SXEOLF SULYDWHSURWHFWHG RFK VXSHU

(65) 8SSJLIWHQ EHVWRG L DWW XWYHFNOD GHW SnE|UMDGH PHGLDDUNLYHW WLOO HWW HIIHNWLYW UHJLVWHUSURJUDP 5HJLVWUHW PHGLDUNLYHW

(66) VNXOOH I|UlQGUDV Vn DWW GHW LQQHK|OO YLVVD DWWULEXW YDULDEOHU

(67) RFK PHWRGHU YDUDY HQ GHO NXQGH nWHUDQYlQGDVIUnQI|UHJnHQGHODERUDWLRQ'HIXQNWLRQHOODNUDYHQEHVWRGDYNRQVWUXHUDQGHWDY PHWRGHU I|U VNDSDQGH DY Q\ SRVW W H[ LQOlJJQLQJ DY HQ Q\ VNLYWLWHO

(68) lQGULQJ DY EHILQWOLJ SRVWERUWWDJDQGHDYSRVWV|NQLQJOLVWQLQJVDPWIHOKDQWHULQJ6WXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHlYHQVNDSD HWWPHQ\V\VWHPVnDWWDQYlQGDUHQOlWWVNXOOHNXQQDNRPPDnWGHVVDIXQNWLRQHU , GHQ IMlUGH RFK VLVWD ODERUDWLRQHQ YDU KXYXGV\IWHW DWW VNDSD I|UVWnHOVH I|U KXU MDYD NDQ DQYlQGDVWLOODWWSURJUDPPHUDJUDILVNDJUlQVVQLWWVDPWKXUPDQVSDUDUWLOOILO8SSJLIWHQYDUDWW VNDSD HWW JUDILVNW DQYlQGDUJUlQVVQLWW WLOO UHJLVWHUSURJUDPPHW VRP JMRUGHV L GHQ I|UHJnHQGH ODERUDWLRQHQ 'HVVXWRP VNXOOH GH Q\D XSSJLIWHU VRP HQ DQYlQGDUH YLOO OlJJD LQ L V\VWHPHW NXQQDVSDUDVWLOOILO'HIXQNWLRQHOODNUDYHQL|YULJWYDULVWRUWVHWWGHVDPPDVRPLI|UHJnHQGH ODERUDWLRQ 0(',(7(.1,.352*5$00(7$//0b17 0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHWV LQOHGDQGH SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUV KDU GHQ RIILFLHOOD NXUVNRGHQ GSW 2EMHNWRULHQWHUDGSURJUDPPHULQJ LMDYD 'HWWDlUHQIHPSRlQJVNXUVVRPQRUPDOWOlVHV SnKDOYIDUWXQGHUWLRYHFNRU$QVYDULJDYLG0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHWKDUSUHFLVVRPDQVYDULJD YLG ,7SURJUDPPHW KDIW DPELWLRQHQ DWW JH VWXGHQWHUQD HQ OlQJUH EHDUEHWQLQJVWLG I|U SURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDSHUQDlQYDGVRPQRUPDOWlUIDOOHWYLG %7+VSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHU )|UDWWnVWDGNRPPDGHWWDKDUPDQYLG07SURJUDPPHWYDOWDWWOnWDGHQLQOHGDQGHMDYDNXUVHQ O|SD |YHU KHOD WHUPLQHQ PHG HQ OHNWLRQ L YHFNDQ 'H NXUVHU VWXGHQWHUQD OlVW SDUDOOHOOW lU ZHEESURGXNWLRQSRlQJ RFNVn|YHUKHODWHUPLQHQ

(69) GDWDEDVHUSRlQJVDPWGDWRUWHNQLNRFK RSHUDWLYV\VWHPSRlQJ 8QGHUYLVQLQJHQKDUYDULWEDVHUDGSnOHNWLRQHUVRPKDUJHWWVHQJnQJLYHFNDQLJUXSSHURPFD SHUVRQHU /HNWLRQHUQD KDU LEODQG YDULW DY I|UHOlVQLQJVNDUDNWlU RFK LEODQG PHU DY VHPLQDULHNDUDNWlU GlUPDQL JUXSSHQ KDU GLVNXWHUDW ROLND SURJUDPPHULQJVEHJUHSS RFK HOOHU O|VQLQJDU(IWHUVRPDOODVWXGHQWHUYLG07SURJUDPPHWKDUXWUXVWDWVPHGHQElUEDUGDWRUKDU OlUDUQD KDIW P|MOLJKHW DWW Jn LJHQRP H[HPSHO VRP VWXGHQWHUQD GLUHNW KDU NXQQDW WHVWD HQ P|MOLJKHWVRPGHNXUVDQVYDULJDRFNVnDNWLYWDQYlQWVLJDY. 'H NXUVDQVYDULJD YLG 07SURJUDPPHW UHNU\WHUDGHV WLOO DWW E|UMD PHG I|U DWW XWIRUPD Q\D ODERUDWLRQHU 6NlOHW YDU DWW SURJUDPOHGQLQJHQ YLOOH In IUDP Q\D LGpHU NULQJ ODERUDWLRQHUQDV XWIRUPQLQJLHWWI|UV|NDWWVNDSDHQQ\NXOWXUNULQJSURJUDPPHULQJHQ'HWYnVWXGHQWHUVRP UHNU\WHUDGHV I|U XSSGUDJHW EOHY UHNRPPHQGHUDGH DY 0'$SURJUDPPHWV SURJUDPDQVYDULJH 'H HQJDJHUDGH VWXGHQWHUQD OlVHU VLVWD nUHW YLG 0'$SURJUDPPHW RFK lU EnGD P\FNHW LQWUHVVHUDGH DY RFK GXNWLJD Sn DWW SURJUDPPHUD 'H lU IUDPI|UDOOW LQWUHVVHUDGH DY VSHOSURJUDPPHULQJ RFK lJQDU HQ VWRU GHO DY VLQ IULWLG nW GHWWD 8SSGUDJHW I|U GHUDV GHO XW|NDGHVWLOODWWYDUDODEEKDQGOHGDUHI|UDWWWLOOVLVWRFNVnRPIDWWDUROOHQVRPNXUVDQVYDULJD. .

(70) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 35$.7,6.$020(170(',(7(.1,.352*5$00(7. , NXUVHQ LQJLFN WUH ODERUDWLRQHU VDPW HWW DQWDO |YQLQJDU 6RP DYVOXWQLQJ ILFN DOOD VWXGHQWHU DUEHWDPHGHWWYDOIULWWSURJUDPPHULQJVSURMHNWLJUXSSHURPSHUVRQHU 6RPH[DPLQDWLRQ JHQRPI|UGHVHQVNFRGHUHYLHZ NRGJHQRPJnQJ

(71) GlUGHROLNDLQGLYLGHUQDLSURMHNWJUXSSHUQD GHODGHV LQ L ROLND UHGRYLVQLQJVJUXSSHU 9DU RFK HQ VNXOOH VHGDQ SUHVHQWHUD NRGHQ I|U VLQ SURMHNWJUXSSV SURJUDP XQGHU PLQXWHU RFK VHGDQ DNWLYW GHOWD L GH DQGUD VWXGHQWHUQDV UHGRYLVQLQJDU JHQRP DWW VWlOOD IUnJRU NULQJ GHW SURJUDPPHULQJVWHNQLVND XWI|UDQGHW 9DUMH LQGLYLG PnVWH VnOHGHV IRUPXOHUD VLQ HJHQ I|UVWnHOVH DY VnYlO GHW SURMHNW KRQ KDQ GHOWDJLW L VRPDYGHDQGUDVWXGHQWHUQDVSURMHNW/DERUDWLRQHUQDYDUWLOOHQE|UMDQREOLJDWRULVNDPHQGH NXUVDQVYDULJDEHVWlPGHVLJ JDQVND VQDUW I|U DWW GH LQWH VNXOOH YDUD GHW 9LG WYHNVDPPD IDOO YLG EHG|PQLQJHQ DY GHQ VOXWJLOWLJD H[DPLQDWLRQHQ NXQGH GRFN JHQRPI|UDQGHW DY ODERUDWLRQHUQDYDUDXWVODJVJLYDQGH 9LG XWIRUPQLQJHQ DY ODERUDWLRQHUQD KDGH GH NXUVDQVYDULJD LQWH QnJRQ XWWDODG DPELWLRQ DWW GHVVD VNXOOH I|OMD QnJRQ U|G WUnG 0DQ YLOOH KHOOUH IRNXVHUD Sn DWW WUlQD ROLND EHJUHSS NRQFHSW VDPW Sn DWW VNDSD ODERUDWLRQHU VRP VNXOOH NlQQDV JUDILVNW WLOOWDODQGH 'HWWD JMRUGH PDQ L I|UKRSSQLQJHQ RP DWW VWXGHQWHUQD VNXOOH NlQQD VLJ PHU PRWLYHUDGH RFK W\FND DWW GHW NlQGHVUROLJDUHRPGHWKlQGHQnJRWSnVNlUPHQ 'HNXUVDQVYDULJDKDGHRFNVnLnWDQNHGH VWXGHQWHUVRPUHGDQNXQGHHQGHOSURJUDPPHULQJYLONDPDQKRSSDGHVVNXOOHEOLVWLPXOHUDGH DYGHVVDJDQVNDRNRQYHQWLRQHOODODERUDWLRQHU)|UDWWNRPELQHUDNlQVODQDYDWWQnJRWKlQGHU Sn VNlUPHQ PHGGHQ YHUNOLJKHW GHW LQQHElUDWW XQGHUYLVD Q\E|UMDUH L SURJUDPPHULQJ YDOGH OlUDUQD DWW JH VWXGHQWHUQD P\FNHW IlUGLJ NRG L YLONHQ HQEDUW PLQGUH I|UlQGULQJDU EHK|YGH XWI|UDV(Q\WWHUOLJDUHPnOVlWWQLQJPHGGHWWDYDUDWWVWXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHOlUDVLJJHQRPDWWOlVD NRG. 6RP LQOHGQLQJ WLOO GH ODERUDWLRQHU VWXGHQWHUQD VNXOOH XWI|UD Sn HJHQ KDQG VDPDUEHWH YDU WLOOnWHW

(72) XWI|UGHVHQ|YQLQJEHQlPQGODERUDWLRQXQGHUOHNWLRQVWLG'HQQD|YQLQJJLFNXWSn DWWVWXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHEHNDQWDVLJPHGSURJUDPPHULQJVVSUnNHWMDYDJHQRPDWWlQGUDSnQnJUD YDULDEOHUV YlUGH L HWW IlUGLJW SURJUDP 3URJUDPPHW YDU HQ DSSOHW VRP YLVDGH HQ WH[W VRP UXOODGH |YHU HQ IlUJDG EDNJUXQG *HQRP |YQLQJHQ WUlQDGH VWXGHQWHUQD VLJ L DWW DQYlQGD SURJUDPPHW8OWUD(GLWVRPYDUGHQWH[WHGLWRUVRPUHNRPPHQGHUDGHVI|UVNULYDQGHWDYNRG VDPWSnDWWNRPSLOHUD1|GYlQGLJSURJUDPYDUD -'.UHVSHNWLYH8OWUD(GLW

(73) KDGHGHVVI|ULQQDQ ODGGDWVQHURFKLQVWDOOHUDWVDYVWXGHQWHUQDSnGHQHJQDGDWRUQ ,QI|UYDUMHODERUDWLRQK|OOGHNXUVDQVYDULJDHQOHNWLRQGlUPnOVlWWQLQJHQYDUDWWJnLJHQRPGH YLNWLJDVWH EHJUHSSHQ VRP EHU|UGH GHQ DNWXHOOD ODERUDWLRQHQ 0DQ JMRUGH lYHQ VNULIWOLJD EHVNULYQLQJDU VRP GHOYLV |YHUODSSDGH GH PXQWOLJD 6DPWOLJD ODERUDWLRQHU KDGH VWRSSGDWXP PHQGHVVDYDULQWHDEVROXWD'HNXUVDQVYDULJDI|UV|NWHGRFNXSSPXQWUDWLOODWWODERUDWLRQHUQD VNLFNDGHVLQI|UHLQWURGXNWLRQHQDYHQQ\ODERUDWLRQ6DPWOLJDODERUDWLRQHUJLFNVLJHQRPI|UH PLWWHQ DY RNWREHU 'HWWD LQQHEDU DWW L SULQFLS HQ Q\ ODERUDWLRQ SHU YHFND SUHVHQWHUDGHV 7DQNDUQDPHGDWWJnLJHQRPODERUDWLRQHUQDLGHWWDVQDEEDWHPSRYDUIOHUD'HWKDQGODGHGHOV RP DWW In LJnQJ VWXGHQWHUQD JHQRP DWW FKRFND GHP OLWH PHQ RFNVn RP DWW GH VRP UHGDQ lJQDW VLJ HQ GHO nW SURJUDPPHULQJ LQWH VNXOOH WDSSD VXJHQ UHGDQ IUnQ E|UMDQ S J D GHW OnQJVDPPD WHPSRW 'HOYLV RFK NDQVNH IUDPI|UDOOW KDQGODGH GHW RP DWW OlPQD UHVWHQ DY WHUPLQHQ|SSHQI|UHWWPHULQGLYLGXHOOWWHPSR'HVRPNlQGHEHKRYDYDWWUHSHWHUDVNXOOHIn WLGWLOOGHWWDLQQDQGHWYDUGDJVDWWI|UGMXSDVLJLGHWDYVOXWDQGHSURMHNWDUEHWHW'HVRPW\FNWH VLJEHKlUVNDGHJUXQGOlJJDQGHELWDUQDLSURJUDPPHULQJVNXOOHLVWlOOHWNXQQDlJQDPHUWLGnW . . 1nJUDKDUYDOWDWWDUEHWDSnHJHQKDQGRFKLQnJRWIDOOKDUJUXSSHQEHVWnWWDYIOHUlQWUHSHUVRQHU 7UDGLWLRQHOOWOlUVLJQ\E|UMDUVWXGHQWHUDWWVNDSDSURJUDPVRPlUKHOWWH[WEDVHUDGHVRPL,7SURJUDPPHWVIDOO .

(74) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. SURMHNWDUEHWHWJHQRPDWWJnGLUHNWLQLGHWWD9DUMHJUXSS VRPVNDSDGHVDYVWXGHQWHUQDVMlOYD

(75) ILFNYlOMDlPQHRFKQLYnI|UVLWWSURMHNW7DQNHQYDUDWWDOODGlULJHQRPVNXOOHJHVP|MOLJKHW DWW DUEHWD XWLIUnQ VLQ NXQVNDSVQLYn RFK VLQD I|UXWVlWWQLQJDU 'HW HQGD NUDYHW YDU DWW YDUMH JUXSSVNDSDGHHWWHJHWSURJUDP. ,GHQI|UVWDODERUDWLRQHQILFNVWXGHQWHUQD NRGHQWLOO HWW KDOYIlUGLJWELOVSHO JMRUW VRP DSSOHW 'HW VRP VDNQDGHV YDU VMlOYD ELOHQ RFK XSSJLIWHQ EHVWRG L DWW VNDSD GHQQD ELO VDPW VNDSD PHWRGHUI|UELOHQVU|UHOVHUIUDPnWEDNnWRFKnWVLGRUQD6\IWHWPHGODERUDWLRQHQYDUDWWJHHQ I|UVWD LQVLNW L YDG NODVVHU REMHNW PHWRGHU RFK YDULDEOHU lU VDPW KXU REMHNW NRPPXQLFHUDU PHG YDUDQGUD )|UVWnHOVH VNXOOH lYHQ JHV I|U SURJUDPPHULQJVWHNQLVND EHJUHSS VRP NRQVWUXNWRUUHVSHNWLYHnWNRPVW. bYHQ L GHQ DQGUD ODERUDWLRQHQ ILFN VWXGHQWHUQD HWW KDOYIlUGLJW SURJUDP VRP GH VNXOOH IlUGLJVWlOOD8SSJLIWHQEHVWRGDYDWWNRPSOHWWHUDHWWGHOYLVXSSE\JJWUHJLVWHUI|UROLNDPHGLD 'HQIlUGLJDNRGVRPVWXGHQWHUQDKDGHWLOOJnQJWLOOEHVWRGDY i *8,NODVV I|UDWWKDQWHUDGHWJUDILVNDJUlQVVQLWWHW NQDSSDUWH[WIlOWOLVWRUPP

(76) i .QDSSO\VVQDUNODVV %XWWRQ/LVWHQHU

(77) VRP NRQWUROOHUDU RP QnJRQ NQDSS L *8,W KDU EOLYLWQHGWU\FNW HOOHUNOLFNDGSn

(78) i 0HGLD6WRUDJHNODVV VRPIXQJHUDUVRPHQODJULQJVSODWVI|UDOODPHGLHU i 0HGLDNODVV VRP XWJ|U EDVNODVV VXSHUNODVV

(79) WLOO |YULJD PHGLHU RFK VRP LQQHKnOOHU JHQHUHOODHJHQVNDSHUJLOWLJDI|UDOODIRUPHUDYPHGLD i 6WDUWNODVV LYLONHQILQQVPHWRGHU HJPDLQPHWRGHQ

(80) I|UDWWVWDUWDSURJUDPPHW 'HW VRP nWHUVWRG I|U VWXGHQWHUQD DWW J|UD YDU DWW VNDSD NODVVHU VRP UHSUHVHQWHUDU GH ROLND PHGLDW\SHUQD ERN FG RFK YLGHRILOP VDPW DWW VH WLOO DWW DUYVVWUXNWXUHQ IXQJHUDGH YLONHW EO D NUlYGH I|UVWnHOVH DY DEVWUDNWD NODVVHU UHVSHNWLYH PHWRGHU RFK KXU GHVVD IXQJHUDU VDPW SULQFLSHQI|USRO\PRUILVPlYHQRPWHUPHQDOGULJDQYlQGHV

(81) 6WXGHQWHUQDPnVWHRFNVnNXQQD VNDSDQ\DREMHNWDYGHROLNDPHGLDW\SHUQDRFKVlNHUVWlOODDWWGHVVDODJUDGHVL 0HGLD6WRUDJH 6WXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHlYHQNRPPHQWHUDNODVVHQ0HGLD6WRUDJHGYVEHVNULYDYDGGHQJ|U , GHQ WUHGMH RFK VLVWD ODERUDWLRQHQ VNXOOH VWXGHQWHUQD IlUGLJVWlOOD NRGHQ WLOO HWW V N KlQJD JXEEH VSHO VRP lU HQ W\S DY RUGVSHO 0nOVlWWQLQJHQ PHG ODERUDWLRQHQ YDU DWW VNDSD HQ GMXSDUH I|UVWnHOVH I|U NRPPXQLNDWLRQHQ PHOODQ REMHNW VNLOOQDGHQ PHOODQ NODVV RFK REMHNW YDULDEHORFKDWWULEXW6WXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHlYHQInLQVLNWLDQYlQGQLQJHQDYODJULQJVVWUXNWXUHUL IRUPDYIlOWVDPWVW\UIXQNWLRQHU LIVDWVHU

(82) RFKORRSDU IRURFKZKLOH

(83) . 'HQ IlUGLJD NRGHQ EHVWRG DY HQ 6WDUWNODVV HQ *8,NODVV LQQHKnOODQGH VSHOHWV JUDILN

(84) HQ .H\ERDUG/LVWHQHUNODVV O\VVQDUHIWHU WDQJHQWHU VRP WU\FNV QHG G Y V L GHW KlU IDOOHW YLOND ERNVWlYHUVRPYlOMV

(85) HQ %XWWRQ/LVWHQHUNODVVRFKHQ NODVVI|U *DPH5XOHV G Y V GHQ NODVV VRPLQQHKnOOHUVSHOHWVUHJOHU'HQSULPlUDXSSJLIWHQI|UVWXGHQWHUQDEHVWRGLDWWIlUGLJVWlOOD GHQVLVWQlPQGDNODVVHQ)|UXWRPDWWKLWWDSnRUGRFKOlJJDLQGHVVDLHWW I|UNRQVWUXHUDWIlOW PnVWH VWXGHQWHUQD NXQQD KDQWHUD GH LQPDWQLQJDU VRP J|UV YLD WDQJHQWERUGHW Vn DWW *8, NODVVHQInULQIRUPDWLRQRPKXUXYLGDGHQVNDVNULYDXWERNVWlYHUHOOHUULWD GHODUDY

(86) HQKlQJG JXEEH 9DUMH ERNVWDYVRP VSHODUHQ DQYlQW VLJ DY VNXOOH RFNVn VNULYDV XW Sn VNlUPHQ Vn DWW VSHODUHQ VOLSSHU KnOOD GHVVD L KXYXGHW .XUVDQVYDULJD KDGH XWIRUPDW V N SVHXGRNRG I|U HQ PHWRG VRP NDQ NRQWUROOHUD RP HQ ERNVWDY ILQQV L HWW RUG 'HQ VOXWJLOWLJD NRGHQ ILFN GRFN VWXGHQWHUQDVNULYDVMlOYD'HVNXOOHRFNVnEHVNULYD KXUSURJUDPPHWKRSSDULNRGHQHIWHUDWW HQVSHODUHWU\FNWQHGHQWDQJHQWI|UDWWJLVVDSnHQERNVWDY6WXGHQWHUQDVNXOOHPDREHVNULYD GHPHWRGHUSURJUDPPHWJnULQLLYLONHQRUGQLQJRFKYDUI|U. .

(87) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. -lPI|UDQGHNRPPHQWDUHU. $YJHQRPJnQJHQRYDQIUDPJnUW\GOLJWDWWSHGDJRJLNHQLSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHUQDSnGHEnGD SURJUDPPHQVNLOMHUVLJHQGHOnW1HGDQI|UV|NHUMDJEHO\VDGHVVDVNLOOQDGHU(QI|UVWnHOVHDY GHROLNDVlWWHQDWWI|UPHGODSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDSlUYLNWLJI|UI|UVWnHOVHQDYGHQIRUWVDWWD GLVNXVVLRQHQ -DJ YLOO GRFN EHWRQD DWW GHW LQWH KDQGODU RP DWW GLNRWRPLVHUD G Y V VNDSD HWW DQWLQJHQHOOHUSHUVSHNWLYGlUGHWHQDVlWWHWIUDPKnOOVVRPElWWUHHOOHUVlPUHlQGHWDQGUD'H UHVSHNWLYHSURJUDPPHQKDUVLQDROLNDI|UXWVlWWQLQJDUGHWMDJVHUVRPHWWJHPHQVDPWGUDJlU DPELWLRQHQ DWW VNDSD SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHU DQSDVVDGH WLOO GH HJQD YLOONRUHQ RFK WLOO PnOHQ PHGSURJUDPPHWLVLQKHOKHW. ,,7SURJUDPPHWVIDOOKDUPDQYDOWDWWDUEHWDXWLIUnQHQPRGHOOGlUVWRUYLNWOlJJVYLGDWWVNDSD I|UVWnHOVH I|U ROLND SURJUDPPHULQJVWHNQLVND EHJUHSS , GH ODERUDWLRQVEHVNULYQLQJDU VWXGHQWHUQDInUEHWRQDVYLONDEHJUHSSNRQFHSWGHE|U KDOlUWVLJ HIWHUUHVSHNWLYHODERUDWLRQ 'HWWDlULVLJHQILQJHUYLVQLQJRPYDGGHE|UOlVDLQVLJSn,HQNXUVVRPGULYVSnGLVWDQVKDU GHWDQVHWWVQDWXUOLJWDWWEHWRQDYLNWHQDY DWWVWXGHQWHUQDOlUVLJ DWWVMlOYDLQKlPWDQ|GYlQGLJ NXQVNDS YLD E|FNHU WLGVNULIWHU ,QWHUQHW

(88) bYHQ GHOWDJDQGH L LQWHUQD RFK H[WHUQD Q\KHWV GLVNXVVLRQVJUXSSHU XSSPXQWUDV )|U DWW NXQQD DQYlQGD GHVVD UHGVNDS NUlYV DWW VWXGHQWHUQD EHKlUVNDUYLVVDEHJUHSSNRQFHSW'HWlUWH[VYnUWDWWVOnXSSQnJRWLHQERNRPPDQLQWHYHW YDGPDQVNDOHWDHIWHU6DPPDVDNJlOOHUYLGGHOWDJDQGHLlPQHVEDVHUDGHGLVNXVVLRQVJUXSSHU 'HWlUOlWWDUHDWWIUnJDRFKInVYDURPDOODDQYlQGHUHQJHPHQVDPWHUPLQRORJL. ,7SURJUDPPHWLQOHGDQGHSURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVKDUDYPnQJDDYVWXGHQWHUQDDQVHWWVVRPVYnU WURWV I|UV|N WLOO I|UlQGULQJDU DOOW VHGDQ GHQ I|UVWD NXUVHQ JDYV 'HWWD KDU PlUNWV L WHQWDPHQVUHVXOWDWXWHOlPQDGHODERUDWLRQVLQOlPQLQJDUVDPWDYGHXWYlUGHULQJDUVRPJMRUWVYLG NXUVVOXW ,7SURJUDPPHW KDU RFNVn KDIW HWW VWRUW DQWDO VWXGHQWHU VRP VOXWDW L I|UWLG YDUDY IOHUWDOHWUHGDQXQGHUI|UVWDnUHW .XUVDQVYDULJI|UMDYDNXUVHQWLOOLNDSURJUDPDQVYDULJJLFNL PLWWHQDYK|VWWHUPLQHQXWPHGHWWULNWDWEUHYWLOOGHVWXGHQWHUVRPLQWHYLVDWQnJRQDNWLYLWHWL MDYDNXUVHQ G Y V VRP LQWH VNLFNDW LQ QnJUD ODERUDWLRQHU

(89) 6\IWHW YDU DWW I|UV|ND PRWYHUND DQWDOHW DYKRSS VRP SURJUDPOHGQLQJHQ PLVVWlQNHU EHURU EO D Sn VYnULJKHWHU PHG DWW OlVD SURJUDPPHULQJSnGLVWDQV,QQDQGHWWDEUHYVNLFNDGHVXWKDGHDOOPlQLQIRUPDWLRQJnWWXWWLOO VDPWOLJDVWXGHQWHUYLDGHQLQWHUQDGLVNXVVLRQVJUXSSHQRPYLNWHQDYDWWDUEHWDPHGMDYDNXUVHQ RFKRPEUHYHWVRPVNXOOHVNLFNDVWLOOEHU|UGDVWXGHQWHU'HWVRPVDGHVLEUHYHWYDULNRUWKHW DWWPDQIUnQK|JVNRODQVVLGDNRQVWDWHUDWDWWPRWWDJDUHQDYEUHYHWLQWHYDULWDNWLYLMDYDNXUVHQ 0DQYLOOHGlUI|UDWWYHGHUE|UDQGHVNXOOHWDNRQWDNWDQWLQJHQPHGNXUVSURJUDPDQVYDULJHOOHU PHGLQVWLWXWLRQVVHNUHWHUDUHQRFKHYHQWXHOOWWDHQGLVNXVVLRQPHGQnJRQDYVWXGLHYlJOHGDUQD 0RWWDJDUHQDYEUHYHWILFNRFNVnDUJXPHQWWLOOYDUI|UPDQIUnQK|JVNRODQVVLGDDQVnJDWWKRQ KDQVNXOOHVDWVDSnMDYDNXUVHQ%ODIUDPK|OOVDWWGHYHUNW\JVRPMDYDNXUVHQWLOOKDQGDKnOOHU EHK|YVI|UDWWNODUDHIWHUI|OMDQGHNXUVHURFKDWWGlUI|UMDYDNXUVHQlUVSHFLHOOWROlPSOLJDWWKD VOlSDQGH HIWHU VLJ 'HVVXWRP SnSHNDGHV GHW IDNWXP DWW WLOOJnQJHQ WLOO KDQGOHGDUH VRP NDQ EHVYDUDIUnJRUlUEHJUlQVDGWLOOGHQWLGVRPNXUVHQJHV %ODQG GH VWXGHQWHU VRP WRJ NRQWDNW PHG K|JVNRODQ HIWHU DWW KD PRWWDJLW EUHYHW IUnQ SURJUDPOHGQLQJHQYLVDGHGHWVLJDWWHQVWRUDQGHOKDGHDUEHWHYLGVLGDQDYVWXGLHUQDRFKDWW GHWWDYDUHQYLNWLJRUVDNWLOODWWGHDQVnJVLJKDVYnUWDWWKLQQDPHG9LGGHQNXUVXWYlUGHULQJ VRPJMRUGHVLQJLFNGlUI|UHQIUnJDLYLONHQRPIDWWQLQJGHQVWXGHUDQGHHYHQWXHOOWDUEHWDGHYLG. 'LVWDQVXWELOGQLQJDU KDU JHQHUHOOW HQ OlJUH JHQRPVWU|PQLQJ lQ DQGUD XWELOGQLQJDU HQOLJW FLYLOLQJHQM|U &KULVWLQD%M|UNPDQVRP lUYHUNVDPLQRPGDWDYHWHQVNDSYLGEOD8SSVDOD8QLYHUVLWHWRFKVRP lYHQWMlQVWJMRUW VRPVWXGLHYlJOHGDUHLQRPlPQHVRPUnGHW(QGLVNXVVLRQNULQJRUVDNHUQDWLOOGHWWDOLJJHUGRFNXWDQI|UUDPHQI|U GHWWDDUEHWH . .

(90) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. VLGDQDY5HVXOWDWHWIUnQXWYlUGHULQJHQYLVDGHDWWDYGHVWXGHQWHUVRPGHOWRJYLGGHWI|UVWD WHQWDPHQVWLOOIlOOHWDUEHWDGHDYGHPKHOHOOHUGHOWLG PDMRULWHWHQDUEHWDGHGHOWLG

(91) (IWHUVRP PDQ IUnQ K|JVNRODQV VLGD KDGH DQOHGQLQJ DWW WUR DWW GHW IDQQV lQQX IOHU VRP DUEHWDGH EODQG GHP VRP LQWH I|UV|NW J|UD WHQWDPHQ VNLFNDGHV HWW LQIRUPDWLRQVEUHY XW YLD Q\KHWVJUXSSHQ , GHWWD WRJ SURJUDPOHGQLQJHQ XSS DWW PDQ VnJ GHW VRP HWW EHN\PPHU DWW DOOWIOHU VWXGHQWHU W\FNWHV KDPQD Sn HIWHUNlONHQ PHG VLQD VWXGLHU S J D DWW GH DUEHWDGH YLG VLGDQ DY .RQVHNYHQVHUQD PDQO\IWHIUDP YDUGHOV DWW GHQLQGLYLGXHOOD VWXGLHJnQJ VRP Gn VNXOOH YDUD DOWHUQDWLYHW NDQ EOL NRPSOLFHUDG HIWHUVRP PnQJD NXUVHU lU EHURHQGH DY YDUDQGUD GHOV DWW K|JVNRODQInUSUREOHPDWWKnOODSODWVHUWLOOHIWHUNRPPDQGHNXUVWLOOIlOOHQSJD DWWVnInDY,7 VWXGHQWHUQDOlVHUSnKHOWLG. 9LG0HGLHWHNQLNSURJUDPPHWKDUNXUVDQVYDULJDPHGYHWHWYDOWDWWLQWHIRNXVHUDVnP\FNHWSn ROLND SURJUDPPHULQJVWHNQLVND EHJUHSS NRQFHSW XWDQ HQEDUW WDJLW XSS GH DOOUD PHVW JUXQGOlJJDQGHVnVRPEHVNULYVRYDQ$YVLNWHQPHGGHWWDKDUYDULWDWWVWXGHQWHUQDVNDOlUDVLJ SURJUDPPHUD JHQRP DWWSUDNWLVHUDSURJUDPPHULQJ7HUPLQRORJLQKDUPDQPHQDWlU L UHJHO OlWWDUH DWW WD WLOO VLJ QlU VWXGHQWHQ NRPPLW LQ OLWH PHU L GHW SUDNWLVND WLOOYlJDJnQJVVlWWHW 6DPWLGLJW KDU OlUDUQD YDULW YlO PHGYHWQD RP DWW GHW KHOD lU HQ EDODQVJnQJ 0HGLH WHNQLNSURJUDPPHWVSHGDJRJLNE\JJHUWLOOVWRUGHOSnDWWPDQOlUVLJ ElVW JHQRPDWWKLWWDVLQ HJHQ LQOlUQLQJVSURFHVV YLONHW I|UXWVlWWHU HWW DNWLYW DUEHWH IUnQ GHQ HQVNLOGH VWXGHQWHQ YDG JlOOHU DWW V|ND LQIRUPDWLRQ 'H NXUVDQVYDULJD I|U SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUVHQ KDU GHILQLWLYW LQWH VDNQDWLQVLNWLDWWGHWNDQRUVDNDSUREOHPLNXQVNDSVV|NDQGHWRPVWXGHQWHQVDNQDUI|UPnJD HOOHUYHUNW\JDWWIRUPXOHUDYDGGHWlUKRQKDQOHWDUHIWHUcDQGUDVLGDQKDU07SURJUDPPHWV VWXGHQWHU KDIW KHOW DQGUD P|MOLJKHWHU lQ ,7SURJUDPPHWV WLOO NRQWLQXHUOLJ KDQGOHGQLQJ 9LVVHUOLJHQVlJVGHWLSURJUDPI|UNODULQJHQDWWYLlUPRELODWDFNYDUHGHElUEDUDGDWRUHUVRP VWXGHQWHUQDXWUXVWDVPHGYLONHWLQQHElUDWWGXNDQEHILQQDGLJYDUVRPKHOVWLYlUOGHQRFK lQGn NlQQD GLJ KHPPD 'HQQD P|MOLJKHW WLOO U|UOLJKHW DQYlQGV DY PnQJD VWXGHQWHU VnWLOOYLGD DWW GH LQWH DOOWLG EHILQQHU VLJ Sn K|JVNRODQ XWDQ LVWlOOHW YlOMHU DWW DUEHWD QnJRQ DQQDQVWDQV'HWIDNWXPDWWGHNDQnNDWLOOK|JVNRODQQlUGHYLOORFKGlUInKMlOSDQWLQJHQDY NODVVNDPUDWHU HOOHU DY KDQGOHGDUH XWJ|U GRFN HQ YlVHQWOLJ VNLOOQDG PRW GHQ GLVWDQVXQGHUYLVQLQJVRPNlQQHWHFNQDU,7SURJUDPPHW 1lU GHW JlOOHU DUEHWH YLG VLGDQ DY VWXGLHUQD Vn I|UHNRPPHU GHWWD lYHQ YLG 07SURJUDPPHW RP lQ LQWH L VDPPD XWVWUlFNQLQJ VRP YLG ,7SURJUDPPHW 'H VWXGHQWHU VRP DUEHWDU W\FNV KHOOHU LQWH KD KDIW QnJUD SUREOHP DWW KLQQD PHG NXUVHUQD YLONHW GHOYLV NDQ EHUR Sn DWW GH EHVLWWHU I|UNXQVNDSHU LQRP EHU|UGD RPUnGHQ 1nJUD KDU GDWDWHNQLVND VWXGLHU PHG VLJ L EDJDJHW DQGUD DUEHWDU LQRP RPUnGHQ VRP UHODWHUDU WLOO GH VRP VWXGHUDV 'HVVXWRP NRPPHU 07VWXGHQWHUQDLQI|UDQGUDRFKWUHGMHnUHWDWWInYlOMDYLONDYLONHQW\SDYNXUVHUGHYLOOJn 'HWLQQHElUDWWGHWLQGLYLGXHOODYDOHWVNHUEHW\GOLJWWLGLJDUHlQYLG,7SURJUDPPHWGlUPDQL SULQFLSLQWHNDQYlOMDNXUVHUI|UUlQLQI|UGHWVLVWDnUHW. 8U YlONRPVWEUHY WLOO GH VWXGHQWHU VRP V|NWH XWELOGQLQJHQ LQI|U K|VWWHUPLQHQ )UDPJnU lYHQ DY XWELOGQLQJVNDWDORJHQI|UK|VWWHUPLQHQ . .

(92) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. *HQRPI|UDQGH. 'HWHPSLULVNDPDWHULDOHWXWJ|UEDVHQI|UPLWWDUEHWH,QHGDQVWnHQGHNDSLWHOUHGRJ|UMDJGHOV I|UKXUPDWHULDOLQVDPOLQJHQJnWWWLOOGHOVI|UPLQEHDUEHWQLQJDYGHW %HVNULYQLQJDYLQWHUYMXDUEHWHW -DJ KDU LQWHUYMXDW nWWD VWXGHQWHU IUnQ 07SURJUDPPHW RFK VMX IUnQ ,7SURJUDPPHW $Y GH LQWHUYMXHUVRPJMRUGHVPHGVWXGHQWHUIUnQ,7SURJUDPPHWJHQRPI|UGHVVH[PXQWOLJHQRFKHQ VNULIWOLJHQ)|UGHOQLQJHQPHOODQPlQRFKNYLQQRUEODQGGHLQWHUYMXDGH VWXGHQWHUQDlULVWRUW VHWW MlPQ cOGHUVI|UGHOQLQJHQ lU RFNVn UHODWLYW MlPQ PHQ PHG HQ YLVV VODJVLGD PRW QnJRW lOGUH VWXGHQWHUYDGEHWUlIIDU 07SURJUDPPHW%ODQGLQEODQGDGHOlUDUHKDU MDJLQWHUYMXDW I\UD DY IHP IUnQ ,7SURJUDPPHW RFK EnGD GH OlUDUH VRP DQVYDUDGH I|U 07SURJUDPPHWV SURJUDPPHULQJVNXUV VDPW HQ OlUDUH VRP JMRUGH HWW SDU LQKRSS VRP I|UHOlVDUH L SURJUDP PHULQJVNXUVHQ 'lUXW|YHU KDU MDJ LQWHUYMXDW HQ DY SURJUDPPHULQJVOlUDUQD YLG 0'$ SURJUDPPHW L5RQQHE\,PDWHULDOHWDQYlQGHUMDJRIWDOlUDUHRFKKDQGOHGDUH V\QRQ\PWRP MDJ LQWH ILQQHU GHW EHIRJDW DWW EHWRQD VNLOOQDGHQ 6NlOHW WLOO GHWWD lU MDJ Sn Vn VlWW OlWWDUH EHYDUDUGHLEODQGDGHVDQRQ\PLWHW'HVVXWRPW\FNVVNLOOQDGHQXUVWXGHQWHUQDVV\QYLQNHOKDHQ PDUJLQHOOEHW\GHOVH. 'H IUnJRU MDJ VWlOOGH WLOO GH LQGLYLGHU VRP VWlOOGH XSS RFK OlW VLJ LQWHUYMXDV XWJLFN IUnQ JHPHQVDPPDPDOODUHQPHGIUnJRUWLOOVWXGHQWHUQDRFKHQPHGIUnJRUWLOOOlUDUQD-DJI|OMGH GRFNLQWHGHVVDPDOODUVODYLVNWXWDQOlWLQWHUYMXHUQDXWYHFNODVRFKIRUPDVXWLIUnQVDPPDQKDQJ RFK SHUVRQ 0DOODUQD I\OOGH GRFN HQ YLNWLJ IXQNWLRQ YDG JlOOGH DWW Sn HWW NRUWIDWWDW VlWW I|UEHUHGDGHPMDJVNXOOHLQWHUYMXDRPNDUDNWlUHQSnIUnJRUQD)UnJRUQDLPDOODUQDKDUXWIRUP DWVPHGXWJnQJVSXQNW IUnQGH |YHUJULSDQGH IUnJHVWlOOQLQJDU MDJ IRUPXOHUDGH L SUREOHPIRUP XOHULQJVIDVHQ'HKDUUHIOHNWHUDWVJHQRPGHODUDYGHQOLWWHUDWXUMDJOlVWH L GHQQD IDV 'H KDU RFNVn GLVNXWHUDWV PHG ROLND UHIHUHQVSHUVRQHU VRP XWJMRUW HWW YLNWLJW VW|G I|U GHWWD DUEHWHV IUDPYl[W -DJ JHQRPI|UGH WYn LQWHUYMXRPJnQJDU PHG VWXGHQWHUQD 'HQ I|UVWD LQWHUYMXRPJnQJHQ JHQRPI|UGHV XQGHU RNWREHU PnQDG YLONHW LQQHEDU DWW VWXGHQWHUQD KDGH E|UMDW NRPPD LQ L SURJUDPPHULQJHQPHQIRUWIDUDQGHEURWWDGHVPHGHQKHOGHOVYnULJKHWHUDYQ\E|UMDUNDUDNWlU 'HQ DQGUD LQWHUYMXRPJnQJHQ JHQRPI|UGHV VRP HQ XSSI|OMQLQJ HIWHU DWW SURJUDPPHULQJV NXUVHQ DYVOXWDWV L PLWWHQ DY MDQXDUL ,7VWXGHQWHUQD KDGH Gn LQOHWW WYn Q\D NXUVHU HQ SRlQJVNXUV L GLVNUHW PDWHPDWLN VRP O|SHU |YHU KHOD WHUPLQHQ RFK HQ SRlQJVNXUV L V\VWHPXWYHFNOLQJ VRP OlVHV XQGHU KDOYD WHUPLQHQ 6WXGHQWHUQD YLG 07SURJUDPPHW KDGH E|UMDWOlVDWYnKHOWHUPLQVNXUVHUSnSRlQJHQLYLGHRSURGXNWLRQRFKHQLGDWDVWUXNWXUHURFK DOJRULWPHU'lUXW|YHUKDGHGHE|UMDWOlVDHQKDOYWHUPLQVNXUVSnSRlQJLYLGHRWHNQLN,QnJUD DYGHXSSI|OMDQGHLQWHUYMXHUQDnWHUVSHJODVGHI|UVWDLQWU\FNHQDYGHVVDNXUVHULI|UKnOODQGHWLOO GH VRP JHQRPI|UGHV XQGHU K|VWWHUPLQHQ 7Yn VWXGHQWHU GHOWRJ LQWH L GHQ XSSI|OMDQGH LQWHUYMXQHQIUnQYDUGHUDSURJUDPPHW. bOGUHLI|UKnOODQGHWLOOJHQRPVQLWWVnOGHUQKRVNXUVGHOWDJDUQD 7RWDOWYDUVH[OlUDUHLQEODQGDGH RPPDQUlNQDUNXUVDQVYDULJVRPGRFNLQWHGHOWRJLXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ 0'$VWnUI|U0lQQLVNRU'DWDWHNQLN$UEHWVOLY 'HQHQDDYVWXGHQWHUQDKDGHEHVWlPWVLJI|UDWWDYVOXWDXWELOGQLQJHQRFKELGURJlQGnWLOOPDWHULDOHWJHQRPDWW I|UNODUDRUVDNHUQDWLOODYKRSSHWLHWWHSRVWPHGGHODQGH . .

(93) $WWKLWWDLQJnQJDULIRUPDQGHWDYSURJUDPPHULQJVNXQVNDS 0DULD$OVEMHU,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB. 6DPWOLJD LQWHUYMXHU KDU EHDUEHWDWV JHQRP DWW MDJ O\VVQDW LJHQRP GH LQVSHODGH EDQGHQ RFK ORJJDW PDWHULDOHW L HQOLJKHW PHG GHQ PHWRG 6KDUDQ % 0HUULDP

(94) UHNRPPHQGHUDU 0HWRGHQ LQQHElU DWW PDQ J|U NRUWDUH HM RUGDJUDQQD

(95) DQWHFNQLQJDU DY GHQ LQWHUYMXDGHV VYDU RFK NRPPHQWDUHU RFK NRPSOHWWHUDU GHVVD PHG HJQD UHIOHNWLRQHU 8WVNULIWHQ DY ORJJDQWHFNQLQJDUQD KDU JMRUWV L GLUHNW DQVOXWQLQJ WLOO JHQRPO\VVQLQJHQ RFK lU I\OOLJDUH lQ DQWHFNQLQJDUQD L VLJ -DJ KDU DOOWVn I\OOW XW WH[WHQ PHG ELQGHRUG RFK VDPPDQKDQJ VRP LQWHUYMXORJJDUQDJHUHQDQW\GDQRP XQJHIlUVRPVW|GDQWHFNQLQJDUIUnQHQI|UHOlVQLQJYlFNHU VDPPDQKDQJHWWLOOOLYI|UGHQVRPVNULYLWDQWHFNQLQJDUQD

No results found