THESIS
BUCK CONVERTER FOR ON-CHIP REFERENCE GENERATION
Submitted By Abhay K Rai
Electrical and Computer Engineering Department
In partial fulfillment of the requirement For the Degree of Masters of Science
Colorado State University Fort Collins, Colorado
Summer 2010
!
"## $ $ %%"& '()*($ % "'+
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, -%' (.&
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
$ %/%& %0&1
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, )/ 0"'2 %"'1% ". .&0
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
%3('$ #%&$ %()2 &$ 4"&5 (6%7 %80+
"0$#")%'& )(56430*0%(& "& 643/". $ (1%'%9%'%&6% (. 0"+&"8& (0(
:(&)1(3/". $ (1%'%9%'%&6%1%&%'($ "'$ "3'"/ )%(0$ (:. %'%9%'%&6% &)%3%&)%&$"93"8%' 0*33. 5/". $ (1%; < '33. %0(&)6"#3%&0($ %)9"'$ %#3%'($ *'%/('($"&0 4%& 3"8%' 0*33. 5 /". $ (1%)%6'%(0%0(0$ 4%3'"6%009%($ *'%0-%;1($ %. %&1$ 4< )%6'%(0%0 $ #3"0%0 64(. . %&1%0 & $ %'#0"94%()'""# (&) "$ 4%'9(6$ "'0$ " (64%/%(0$ (:. %:(&)1(3 /". $ (1%
'%9%'%&6% $(. 0" &%%)0$ " :% 06(. %) )"8& $ " = 9"'3'(6$6(.*0%0(&) 3'"/ )% ( 6"##"& #")% /". $ (1% "9 = 9"' "& 643 6'6*$ 0 40 $ 4%00 )06*00%0 ( :*6+
6"&/%'$ %' 8464 *0%0 (& (. $ %'&($/% $ " 3*. 0% 8 )$ 4 #")*. ($"& ; < 9"' 0$ (:. % '%9%'%&6% 1%&%'($"& (&) )'%6$ . 5 1%&%'($ %0( = '%9%'%&6% *0&1 ( &"/%. &)*6$ "' '33. %6*''%&$6(&6%. . ($"& $ %64& >*% 84646(&6%. 0 &)*6$ "''33. %6*''%&$(&)$ 4%'%9"'%
)"%0&"$'%>*'%(. ('1%6(3(6$ (&6%9"'9. $ %'&1 "9 &)*6$ "''33. % & (. $ %'&($/%$ "$ 4%
3*. 0%8 )$ 4#")*. ($"& ; < $ %64& >*% 03'"3"0%) 8464*0%06"##"& #")%:(0 (&)$ '(&06"&)*6$ (&6%;1 # < $ *& &1 $ "+%%3$ 4%'%9%'%&6%"*$ 3*$6"&0$ (&$9"'/('(:. %. "()0 (&)($ %#3%'($ *'%6"#3%&0($"& $ %64& >*% 0*0%)$ "# & # -%$ %#3%'($ *'%0%&0$/ $ 5
:4(5 *#(' ( . %6$ '6(.? "#3*$ %' &1 &%%'&1
". "'()" $ ($ % & /%'0$ 5
"'$ ". .&0 @ A
*##%'
/
$4(0:%%& ('%(.3'/ . %1%$ " :%(1'()*($ %0$ *)%&$ & $ 4% )%3('$ #%&$($
". "'()" $ ($ % & /%'0$ 5 "'$ ". .&0 5 %B3%'%&6% 4%'% 4(0 :%%& 9*. . "9
"33"'$ *& $%0 $ " . %('& 9'"# 9(6*. $ 5 (&) 0$ *)%&$ 0 8 $ 4 8 )% (&) )%%3 %B3%'$0% &
%&1 &%%'&1
8"*. ).+%$ "$ 4(&+#5()/ 0"' '"9 %"'1% ". .&0 9"'40 &/(. *(:. %1*)(&6%
$ 4'"*14"*$#5 7 "*'&%5 (0 ( 1'()*($ % 0$ *)%&$ & $ 4% )%3('$ #%&$ 0 #(&5 5%('0 "9
%B3%'%&6%8 $ 408 $ 64&1 '%1*. ($ "'0(&)3"8%'%. %6$ '"& 604(/%(. . "8%)4# $ "9"6*0"&
$ 4%6'$6(.(&) &$ %'%0$&1 00*%0"9(&53'":. %# $4(0:%%& (*& >*%3'/ . %1%$ ":% &
401'"*3
8"*. ) .+% $ " $ 4(&+ $ 4% #%#:%'0"9#5 $ 4%006"## $ $ %% 9"'$ 4%'/(. *(:. % 9%%):(6+ 8"*. ) .+% $ " $ 4(&+ '"9 $ %/%& %0&1 9"' 4%. 3&1 #% "& &*#%'"*0
"66(0"&0 1"$1'%($ . 5 :%&%9$ %) 9'"# 40 ($ 4 3'"1'(# 9"'"& 643 &)*6$ "' )%01& (&) 8(0(:. %$ " 0*66%009*. . 5 #3. %#%&$$ 4%04*&$3%(+&1 $ %64& >*%$ (*14$ &
@AC 0)%$ (. %) (&(. 500"9&"0% & 04%. 3%) #% & )(5$ ")(5 )%01&
(6$/ $%0(&)84. %8"'+&1 "& "*$ 3*$$ '(&06"&)*6$ (&6%(#3.9%'; < )%01& 9"'@ $ 4
"')%'%. .3$69. $ %'D E)%01& 3'"7 %6$9"'#5 $ (&9"') & /%'0$ 5 1&(.6"&)$"& &1 6. (00$ 4003'&1 8"*. ).+%$ "$ 4(&+ '"9 -%' (.& 9"'+&). 5(1'%%&1 $ ":% & #5 6"## $ $ %%(&)$ (+&1 $#%$ "'%()$ 40$ 4%00
8"*. ) .+% $ " $ 4(&+ '"9 %/ & %('9"'#(+&1 4#0%. 9(/(. (:. % $ " #%
64%%'9*. . 584%&%/%' &%%)%)40()/ 6%"& 8 )%/('%$ 5"9)%/ 6%345060'%. ($ %) 00*%0
/
8"*. ).+%$ "$ 4(&+#53('%&$ 0 4(#%. (&) '( ( 9"':%&1 (&%/%'%&)&1 0"*'6%"9&03'($"& (&)(0". %'%(0"& 9"'84" (# $ ")(5
8"*. ).+%$ "$ 4(&+#58 9% '3(&( ( 9"':%&1 #"0$3($%&$3%'0"& & #5.9%
(&) :%&1 (0"*'6% "9%&6"*'(1%#%&$ 8 $ 4"*$84"0% 84". %4%('$ %) 0*33"'$ $ 401"(.
8"*. ) 4(/% :%%& &%('. 5 #3"00:. % 8"*. ) (. 0" .+% $ " $ 4(&+ #5 $ ")). %')(*14$ %' (04/ ( 9"'9. .&1 #%8 $ 4%&%'15(&)$ %(64&1 #%$ 4($.9% 0(&%/%'%&)&1 . %('& &1
%B3%'%&6%
(0$:*$&"$$ 4%. %(0$ 8"*. ) .+%$ " $ 4(&+ #5 %#3. "5%' /(1" %64&". "1 %0
&6 9"'03"&0"'&1 #51'()*($ %0$ *)%0(&):%&1 3($%&$$ 4'"*14"*$$ 4%)*'($"& "9#5
1'()*($ %0$ *)%0
! " # $
% & ' ( )
' * # +! &"* )
# # "* " ,- . '/# 0 " # 1
# " # 1 2
' * # ! "!" # &"* 3
# #+ + ! "!" # " "* *" # $
" 0 "* *" # ! * ! $
4 % & ' ' ( 5 -
6 7 ' 7
& - (
#!!* 8 # " & ! 2
+! " ! 4
' - 5 , . ' ( 49
5 * " " #1 : 5# ' ! 4$
5 * " " *"; * )
+!* # 1 0 #1 2
#" & * "1 " ' 2
5 * " #1 "* " # <
2 5 = % 24
(+ # 1 24
'* / " * *"!!# 1 /# 0# 1 " # 22
5# ' 0 + : 22
' 0 2$
++ + ;" #1 3
#* # ' * 3
3 ' > 33
? 5 - ' - - 39
? ' ' 9
99
5 ' $
0 # " # # +!* @# 1 " /# 0# 1 / 0"
* "1 " 0 ,5#1 . " +"# *@ ! # " ! /
!!*@/# 0" 8 ";* ! * "1 7 1 "*
0 " / /"@ " 0# 0 * "1 1 *" # :
* =# 0 *" # , = .: 0# # " 0# ;@ " @# 1 0 ! # , .
0 /# 0/0#* !# 1 0 /# 0# 1 ! # " 7 " 0 / # 5#1
@ @ * , . 0 " # 0 * 1 0 #+ /0# 0 0 /# 0
# ! 0 @ * ! # "**@ * ;@! * /# 0+ *" # # 0
! + 0 # " A @ ! " # * " !#+#B" # "
- #* " *#+# 0 #!!* # 0 ! * "1
* 5 A @ *" # , 5 .: 0 " # , . # ! "
" 0 /# 0# 1 ! # # " # " 0 / # 5#1 4 0 #1 0 -
#* # # # * # 0# "
'/# 0# 1
* +
! & * "1 ! & * "1
4
0 " 0 ;" # @! :
' ! / ,; .
' ! ! , . "
4 ' ! ! / ,; ; .
; ! / /# 0 + ! / !!*@ " "* ; "** " /# 0
+ 1 *" 0 ! ! *" # @ /# 0 + 1 *" # 0 # "# *@ 0#10
# # @" +!" #B '/# 0+ 1 *" " # !*" *# " * "1 1 *" " *" # *@0#10 ! 7 ; " *# " * "1 1 *" " # # # CD '# 0 ! / # # *# " 1 *" 0" # #!" " "# *@*" 1 "+
! / 7 0 @0" ; " A " *@ * 7 @!# "**@;@+ # 1 0 + 0 " # 7 /0# 0+" 0 1 *" ; * @" *" 1 "!!*# " # /0 #B " # # @"
# # "*7 *# " * "1 1 *" " ; CD 1 "*7 " @;" # /# 0 ! /
!!*@ # # " " +! 7 " 0 / # 5#1
!" #
2
! * /# 0+ *" # 1 **
" # /# 0
#
& "!" # "
& # " *"!!# 1 /# 0
* ;@! * /# 0+ *" # # " @ 1 *" # 1 0 ! # @ @ *
" ; " 8 ; "# 0 # * "1 ! 0 /# 0 # 0 0 " 0
/# 0 !!*@" # * 0 ! / !!*# 0 * " C4D # # #
" #* 0 #!!* 0# # ; " # !!
0" 1 # =0 0 0 10" # " 7 0 #
+"# "# 0 ;@" # 1 " "
"!" # # # " #* #!!* * "1 0 # # " /# 0
1 *" # "**@ " " " 0 # CD 0 ! ! 0# # #
# @7 ; # " # * / # 0 # # " 0" 0 # "*/"@ "
!" 0 0 * / # 0 # 0# # " ; !*" /# 0 "
*"!!# 1 '5 /# 0# *#+# " 0 # !
3
5#1 3 0 / 0 " * "1 /" + 0 10 0 # /0 /# 0 #
! " *
$% & % '
0# # # " ! " # # 0 0 / " " E!*"# ; * /
( " # ' !
) *)
(+ " # ' !
) *) ,
9
0 # # 7 /0 0 /# 0# * 7 0 /# 0 0 #
, - . " 0 / # 5#1 2" 0# * # " ! # # * "1 " 0 #
# 0 * "1 # 1 " 0" 0 ! * "1 0# * "1 " " *# "
# " # 0 # =0 0 # # 7 0 1@ # #
# " # 1 0 " /0 0 /# 0# * 7 0 # " A # 1@CD
& - F& # & ) , .
F , .
0 "!" # + 0 0 # G 0" 1 # " " ! * "1
* 7 0 "!" # # *" 1 10 0" 0 ! * "1 0" 1
#1 # # " *@ # 1 /# 0# 1 @ * 0# " 0 "!" # # 0" 1# 1 =0 0
/# 0# * 7 0 * + " @# 1 " 0 / # 5#1 2" '# 0 # #
;#" 7 # # 0 / # 0 !#
! =0 0 /# 0 # ! 7 0 # +"# "# 0 * " "
0 / # 5#1 2; 0 # G +"1 # # * " 7 0 0 10 0
# " *# " *@7 " +# ;@ 0 * "1 " 0 # " #
# "
& - 55 F & ) , 4.
55 F, . , .
'# 0 " "1 * "1 " 0 # # B # " @ " 7 # 1 0 *
;"*" A " #
& - H& - 55 55 F) , 2.
C& 1 & ) D H, & ) . , . F)
& 1 I & ) I & ) H& ) F)
$
& ) F &1 ," +# 1 # "* +! . , 3.
0 # +"# "# * / ;@ # 1 # * "1 /0 0 "!!*# * "1 #
+ 0 # " " " * "1 ** /# 0 ! # " !" 0 0 #
=0 0 /# 0# ! 7 0 # * / 0 10 0 # C2D
" # ! $
0" / # # + ! " # : # #
+ , . " # # # + , . 0 ;
" # * " #1 ;" ; 0+ ! " #
- ' ,
0 # # + 7 0 # * / # *@ 0" # 7
# # "*/"@ 1 " 0 B # 1 0 55 ! # 7 " 0 / # 5#1 9;
0 * "1 ! " # *# " *@/# 0 0 @ @ * 0 /# 0 " 1#
* "1 # ! ! 0 # # !" "+ , 1 # " "!" #
"* . C3D
<
& ) J& 1 F J F @ @ *
0 # 0 # # + , .7 0 ! * "1 " ;
** ;@ **# 1 0 @ @ * " " 1 )
0 # # # + , . C4D7 0 # # # #
" ; # 5#1 9" 0" # # # # # "* " + #+ , - F ).
/0# 0 " 0 " "1 # " * 0" 0"* 0 #
#!!* CD 0 55 ! # 7 0 ! / 0 * " # " # !!*# ;@ 0
"!" # " "* 0 # 0 # # # + 7 0 ! * "1 #
! 0 # # +! "* " 0 @ @ * 0 /# 0C3D
)
% & ' (
0 * "1 ! # ** ;@ # 1 " 0#10 A @ ! * /# 0+ *"
* , = . #1 "* # 0 /# 0# 1 * + , " # /# 0. @!# "**@ 0
A @ 0 ! * /# 0+ *" * #1 "* # # 0 " 1 0
% B 0 " / ; # : 5# 7 " A @ # " 7 +! ; +
+"** 7 *#10 " 0 "! CD 0 ; # # 0" 0 *"@ + # ! !
" ;@ 0 /# 0# 1 #+ # * /
@!# "**@7 # # ++ 0" 0 ; # # + , .
E! * " ** /# 1 "
0 1"# # ";* # + 7 0 ! & * "1 ,& ) . # "!! E#+" *@
;@ # ! * "1 ,& 1 . " 0 @ @ * *@7 1" * * " 0
+! "* # # + 7 & ) ! & 1 7 @ @ * 7 #
"* 7 * " " A @
5 # " # # + 7 0 A @ ! " #
0 " # ! # # + " ; # 0" # # #
+
4 # + ! " # ! +"** #!!* # ! & * "1 &
" # CD
# 1 +! * # 7 " 0 +! G "* # * ;" "# # #
!" "+
" # ) ' + ,
'# 0 "* 0 # +# 0 ! " # 1 + 0 ; C4D7
# #1 !*"@ " #+! " * # ; #1 0 # #
;@ + # 1 1@ + 0 * # "* # # 7 # 1 # # " +"1 # # * "
; A *@ # 1 0 1@ 0 # # C9D
=0 0 # # # 0" 1# 1 CD:
& - F & ) F- # - J , .
# - J F & ) J- , .
K# - F & ) J- LCK D
K# - F & ) J- LC D , 4.
=0 # # 0" 1# 1:
& - F& 1 I& ) F- # - J
& 1
# - J FC& 1 I& ) DJ- K# - F,& 1 & ) J- .LCK D
K# - FC& 1 & ) J- DL , .
5#1 0 / 0 0 10" * "1 " 0 #
- F - I MK# - MJ F& ) J , .& ) J -5 F& CJ , .J -5D , 2.
- ? F - HMK# - MJ F& ) J H, .& ) J -5 F& ) CJ H, .J -5D , 3.
% &
$ $ )* +
0 # # "* " # 0 +# #+ + # " " /0# 0 0 # " 0
; " @ # + @ # " "* * / 0" 0 # # "* # "
" 0 ; ! " # 0 # # # + 0
# " "* # # # "* +"# "# # 1 0 * " /0#* 0 /# 0# #
" @ +# 0 +# #+ + # " " @ !! 0 A # !
4
0 0" 0 * " # !! / " # #
! * "1 " # ! CD
+# 0 # # "* # " 7 0 +"E#+ + # #!!* K# -
+# #+ + ! "1 * " A # + # ! # # - F) F - I CMK# - MJ D F& ) CJ , .J -5D
- F, ? . ? J 5 , 9.
? F& ) J , $.
? F @ @ * "* *" " +# #+ + # ! * "1
5F5 A @
% . .
" 0 10 0 # +# 0 # N A # " " #
" # 17 /0# 0# # " 0 "!! E#+" !0@ # "* #B 0 # '" " # 1 0
# " 0 # # @7 /0#* # " # 1 0 +! " 0
# 7 0 '5 " 0 # CD 0 ! " " # 1 0 # #
+# /# 0 0 +"E#+ + # 0 / " +# #+ + #
" +"E#+ + * "
$ ,
" # #1 " # /# 0# 1 ! / !!*# + 0" " /# 0# 1 #+
" 0 * ; ";* /# 0 " 0 * "1 !# ! ;@ 0 # & * "1
" # 1: 5 " # "* /# 07 0 +"E#+ + /# 0 * "1 ,& /# 0O+"E . # 0 +"E#+ +
* "1 # ! CD " # "* /# 07 & /# 0O+"E F & # +"E H & 5 /0 & 5 # 0 +"E#+ + /" ! " 0 /# 0 , /" # !. " +"E#+ + * "
'/# 0 " # 1 # "* *" ;" 0 " "1 "* /# 0 # 1
7 0 # # A "* /# 0 # 1 /# 0 # A "*
B
/# 0 F,# -+# H# -+"E . L J , $.
/# 0 FC,# -+"E K# - .H# -+"E D L J FC# -+"E K# - D L J
/# 0 FC# -+"E K# - J D L F# - L
/# 0 P# - L +"E , <.
2
! ) ' % . + % * %/ 0 % %1 2
$ ,
# " @ 0" 0 # 0 * ; ";* *" # *@ " # / "
" @ # " # 0 "!!*# " # 0 # G " "1 #
A "* 0 * " #+ 0 ! # 0 #+ 0 # # # 1 "
3
0 / # 5#1 2 0 # N /" ! # # " # + + E 0
+"E#+ + ! CD
# F,# -+# H# -+"E . L J , ).
# FC,# -+"E K# - .H# -+"E D L, . J FC# -+"E K# - D L, . J
# FC# -+"E K# - J D L, . F# - L, .
# P# - L, +# . , .
( ) '
0 +"E#+ + * "1 " 0 # # 0 +"E#+ + # ! * "1 0
* "1 " # 1 " * / 10 0" " +"** ' 0 @ # " " @
# * ; 0# "!!*# " #
/ # #!" # # 0 *#+# # 1 " /0 0 # 1 " # 0 / " " "1
! / " ; "* *" " ** / :
# F, +# . L# - L& , .
/0 & # 0 * "1 !" 0 # " 0 1# ! ?
# ! $!$ '$
0 "!" # * "1 0 * /# 0 " 0 +"E#+ + ! * "1 "**@
9
& +"E F& ) HK& ) J , 4.
=0 K& ) F #!!* * "1
& ) F ! * "1
0 ! "!" # " # 0 +# #+#B 0 * "1 0 " #!!* " 0
! " ; '# /# 0 ! / 1 *" " "**@ # 0#10
7 0#10! +" ! / !!*# 7 0 "!" # 0 * ; 0 +# #+ +
* - # " "!" # ; " # # "* # # " " # "
"!" # /# 0 # # " 0 0 ;" # # # # "
, ' . 5 @ 0#10 ! +" ! / !!*# 7 + #+ # # " @ !
"!" # # !" "** * 1 " * / 10 # # # " 0 +"E#+ +
"** / ! * "1 0 " #!!* " + #+ ! # # " 0 #+
#1 0 7 + 0 #!!* ! # # " # " ; # # 7 " !
"!" # /# 0"+!* "!" # " " * / ' # A #
0 ! * "1 #!!* * ; ;@
• # 1 0 ' ;@ +;# # 1 "!" # # !" "** * # 1 "!" # /# 0
* / '
• 0 #!!* # ;@# " # 1 0 # # # " # " # 1 0
/# 0# 1 5 A @
#!!* # 0 # * / 0 10 0 "!" # * " # 1 0 " "1
* /# 1 0 10 0 * " C$D
$
$ , ) '
" - - ! $!$ $ $ $ ./0
Q FR , J .,K# - J . FK# - J$5 FC,& ) J - ., . D J $5 F, .& ) J$-5 QF LK& )
FQJK& ) FC, . & ) D1K& ) $-5 F,4 . & ) JK& ) F , .
S&J& ) F, +# .J$- 5 , 2.
K& ) F #!!* & * "1
K& ) J& ) F! "1 #!!*
"$ $ $ # ! !
+! "* ! * !; / "* *" # 1 " 0 4 "
#+ *" # 1 " '! 2
I +#
,S&J& ) .L$-5
<
1 " " 7 " " /# 0 # " 7 ' " # !7 /# 0
# " " 0 *"!!# 1 /# 07 # " "* /" 0 " + 7 /0# 0# 2 9 #+ 0 # # "* # " "*
"E#+ + ! & * "1 &# +"E := ) & ⋅
# #+ + ! & * "1 &# +# := 3 & ⋅
! & * "1 &) := ) < & ⋅
'/# 0# 1 5 A @ := 492 % B ⋅
"E - " *+"E := $+
*+# := 4+
# #+ + - "
*+"E &)
:= *+# *+"E 4)) = Ω
"E#+ + - " # "
# #+ + - " # " *+# &)
*+"E
:= *+# = 2 Ω
#+ #
:= = 339 × ) − 3
# #+ + @ @ * +# &)
&# +"E
:= +# = ) 2
+"E &)
&# +#
:= +"E = ) 234
"E#+ + @ @ *
- , − +"E . ⋅ *+"E
:= ⋅ - = 92 × ) − F *
" - - 2 $
)
-" # *
3 ) , ,
" # #+ *" # /" !" !" "+ # / !/" ! + # 1 &# 7 - "
@ @ * " " #";* 7 " 0 / # 5#1 $ 5#1 9 0 / 0 ;" # ! * ! ; 0 +" # /# 0 #!!* " **" # #* "!" # '/ " '/
" 7 *"!!# 1 * 1 " ;@" *"!!# 1 * 1 "
*"!! # " ; ! 1 "++
4%
56 ,,
5#1 < 0 / 0" 0 ; # ! " # 1 # # # + "
5#1 ) 0 / 0 #!!* 5#1 0 / #!!* * "1 /# 0 0 #!!*
" **" # 0 #A " #* "!" # 0 +"E#+ + "* #!!*
* "1 # )2 +&
4 6 ,, &
5#1 9 I 0 / 0" ! #!!* * "1 " " "1 ! * "1 !
# ! * "1 7 @ @ * 7 # " "!" # "* " 0 # ' 0# * "1 #
# *@ " " 0#! 7 # /#** * " " ! ! / !!*@ 8 # " # , ' . ! +" " "* # /#** * # " ! # " @ # #"*
# # ++ + " #" # /0# 0/#** ; "+!*# # ;@" ; A "1 "
0 # /#** ; + !" #1 "* * # 1 # @! ! +"
5 0# ! * "1 ; " " 0#! ! # " " "* " #
;" 1"! 7 A # " # # *#+# " #!!* ! * "1 "
" 0# # # # # # +! " #" # " & 1
3 & ' "
( 4 *
5 6 "
" 6
' * (
" # #"* # # A # # 1 " ++ + !!*# ;@" 0#! 7 " @
++ + " #" # /#** * " " ! /0# 0; + !" 0
#1 "* " # "+!*# # ;@ ; A "1 0# # #"* "1 # !" " " "* 1
7 # /#** * # ! +" 1 " " # " 0 +"@; +
# ";* 0 "!!*# " # 0# A # " 0#! ! # " "
* "1 #!!*
" # "* ; 7 ! * "1 " #" # # +# #+#B ;@ # 1 0
* =# 0 *" # , = . 0 * 5 A @ *" # , 5 . 0 #A
/0# 0+# #+#B ! * "1 " #" # 0" 1 # * " & 1 0# 0 #A
*@ A # " *@ = !0" * * !, --.7 ; 0 A # +"@1
"*#" # ;" ;" 7 1 " # 1 #1 "* # " # ,' . ! +" 0 "**
@ +
+"@ "* "* A # ; 1 " 0#! /0# 0 +"@ ; "
# ";* * # " * / ! / 0#! + ;#* "!!*# " #
# "* #!!* 8 # 0 #A A # " "!" # /0# 0 " # " #
# " 0 " "1 * / 0 10 0 * "
/ " "!" # +"@ ; " #";* * # + ;#* "!!*# " # "
"* # A # " E " !#
2
! ! * # #; ; * / " " " # 1 + 0" # + "* 1
/# 0" ++ + ;" 0 #A " 0# !" "+ # !
" ,,
5#1 4 0 / " ! * ! ; /# 0 " ;" # #!!* " **" #
0 + 9 # " # "* ! " # "* " " +!*# # , . /0# 0
* "1 " # /# 0" " 1"# " 1 +
5#1 4 " 0 / ! ;@# " 5#1 4 ; 0 / 0 /
" !0"
3
% ,, 7 + 1/8 ,,
' )
9
" " 2 +' # A # 1 " " +" 0# 1 !0" +
7 0 / 7 # 0 / " " 7 0 @/#** E" *@ " * " 0 0 "
0 /#** * # B * "
" # 0# 7 ! " H !0" #!!* ; 7 #
*@ ! " #!!* /0# 0# !0" /# 0# #!!*
/# 0" B 0# ;8 # ; " 0# 7 ;
;#" " " # ++ + * "1 <)) +& " 0 / # 5#1 4
!% 1/8
$
( % ,, 7 + 1/8 ,,
$9 ) ' (
<
0# 0 #A " * # #!!* " ! " * " !" "+ #
/ ! /" ! # @ 0# ;" # ! !" "+ " #" # *#
" " 1+7 * " # " -7 @ @ * " # ! * "1 &
-% ' ,, :
4)
31 , ' ,, :
41 , ,, / , , , , ' ; <
4
51 , ,, + , ' ; < 55
5#1 4 9 I 4 ) 0 / 0 * " " * "1 " #!!* 8 # 0 ** /# 1
* # " "/ + 0 #+ *" #
5#1 4 < 0 / 0" " # "* #!!* $ T& /" " 0# /0 ( + /"
5#1 4 < " 4 ) + " 0" # " ( + # 1 + 0" # + # "!!*# 7 #!!*
* "1 " ; **
4
1 , ' ,
5#1 4 0 / ! * "1 /0 & # / ! + 3& )& /0# 0# HJ )U
+# "* !!*@ * "1 0# & # ! /" " 0# ;@ ++ + ;#" # 1
'5 "# # #; "
F J T ? =J- ,& (' I & . ,4 .
=0
T# + ;#*# @ " 0" 1 " # , * J0 * # 'J '.
& (' # "# * "1
? # E# "!" # "
= # 0" * /# 0
44 - # 0" * * 1 0
& (' # 1" * "1
& # 0 0 * * "1
V JV& (' FT ? =J- ,& (' I & . F1 + ,4 .
;#*# @,T. " 0 0 * * "1 ,& . " '5 " +! " ! C$D
" " ; #; ;@ A ,4 4. " ,4 .
T W 4J ,4 4.
& W ,4 .
A ,4 4. " ,4 . 0 / 0" 0" 1# 1 T " * "1 & & ,F & (' I & .
0" 1 # +! " +! " " 0 0 ! "# E 7 0 / #
" ; +! " # 1 ( + # 1 + 0" # + / " ; # # C)D #
+! " +! " # 7 # " *@# 1 " ( + # 1 + 0" # +
4
8 / , ,
+! " # # # ;#" 1 " 0 / "; # 5#1 4 # ;" 0
# +! " ! # 0 0 * * "1 ' " ' * /
+! " # * "1 " ; ; "# C D ;@ + "**@ +! " # 1 0 +! " # & " & "1 # & " & " *# " *@
/# 0 +! " " " ; + * " :
& , . F& , ) . I X & , I ) . ,4 2.
M& , .M FM& , ) .M X & , I ) . ,4 3.
42
=0 ) # 0 +! " /0 0 #1 ; ,1 "**@
9Y .7 " X & " X & " 0 +! " # # 0 0 0 * * "1
' " ' " # 7 ! # *@
5# "* * "1 # ; "# ;@ ; " # 1 M& M + " "* &
* / * "1 ;#" # # # + ;@ " " ! # # + ;@
' '4 # +; #" # # @# !!*# ;@ 2
# # @ # + ;@ 7 7 " # 0" 0 ; *
* "1 ,& ' . # B *#+# " 0 ;" 1" ;#" " #+!
! / !!*@ 8 # " # , ' . * "1 # :
& 5 F, H J .& (' I M& (' M ,4 9.
+! " ! & " ; ; "# ;@ # #" # 1 A 4 9 /# 0 !
" 1# ;@ A 4 $
,4 $.
0# +! " ! # 1 ;@ " *# " + " " *# " +
; "# ,V& 5 JV .M F F) /0 # + +! " 7 0 *# " + # B ;@
" # " # 7 /0# 0# 1# ;@:
J FX & J X & I ,4 <.
7 0 *# " + # B " F ;@ 0 " # #B# 1 " # 7 1# ;@:
43
,4 ).
A 4 < " 4 ) 0 / 0" +! " # # " ; !#+#B ;@ # #
!" "+
/ , ,
5#1 4 4 0 / 0 ! +! " +! " " #" # "* 0 / 0
/ ! " 9Y
49
7
" * 4 ) + (
@ "* ! #;* " 0# 7 # * # 1 * !# 7 / "1 " "
#+!* # #"* !"# /# 0 " !* 7 " **# 1 * " /" ! + 7 0 / # " "* 1 #1 # " + * # #+ # !#+#B" # ! ;* + C D7 "
" * # " # " "* " # "** !" "+ 7 * " ! * 1@ /"
0 /" +# 0" 0 * " / * ! # 0 "!";#*# @
+"E#+#B# 1 0 * "1 /# 1 " 0 ! /0#* #** + # 1 0 1"# 7 ;" /# 0"
# A # + #+! ;@ 0 "!!*# " # " ! # # " # 0 # #"* !"#
/# 0 !* * " C2D /" 0 10 ; # #* 0 " +# +" 0
# 0 1 + 0 * " " # /" # "*# # +# +" 0 # # #
! # 7 0# # # / * 0" + 0 1"# A # + 0 * !#
! * 1@7 /0#* # 1 + #+! + # # 7 1"# " ;" /# 0 0 *
" 7 #+! #1 # # " *#+# " # ! * "1 /# 1 / "1 "+!*# #
* " #*@ + "** ! # # " # 7 ; / * *# *@ ; * ! / # # 0" 0 * "
0 #1 /" +!* #*#B# 1 " Z # # " A [ "!! " 0 "**
"# / +# " #1 A " # / # " 0 7 " " *";
#! /" * ! ;" 0 #1 A " # 0# #! /" " 0 0
#1 !" " # # 0" / * + "** ! # # " # /0#* +# #+#B# 1 ! / +!# 0 # "* # # /" #1 !;@ !7 " # 1 /# 0 " +" @ # "*
+! " ! #;* 7 " # 1 /# 0" +!* !" # "* # # 7 E ! " # "*
++ + ;" , 5 . ; # # 0 5 # # /" #
4$
"** /# 0# 0 ! 0# #1
! ) % ,
0 # # #"* #1 /" + * /# 0 *@ " # 5 # ! "1 /"
* ; # ! +" " +!" /# 0" 5 # ! 5 0 "+
1 + 7 " 5 /#** A # " *" 1 " " 0 *" 1 "!" # " /#** * " " * / J
0# "1 J # " +# # 1 " # # # * " 0 #+! "
#1 !" "+ ; " /# 0 0#
0 # #1 !" "+ 0" /" # /" 0 * * ! 1"# 5 0#
#+!* # # 7 0 * * !1"# # :
/ ) = β + , .
=0 7 1 + 7 1 + " " " " " 1 " 1 " 0 # !
" X # 0 ;" "
4<
# / 0" 0 ! * !1"# A # + /# 0" +"** +" 1# # 0
)7 " 0" β # 0 J4 ' * * !1"# A # + # 0
)
0# / 0 # 1"# A " # 7 0 A # + 0 # # # 1"# "
/ * ; "!! E#+" *@ ) 7 0 / 0 A " # 0 +!* * "
1"# # :
/ ) = β +
4
+ + 2
+
, .
0 " # # "* + # 0 +# " /#** * / 0 1"# + /0" 7 0 / 7 Z;"
0 * ! [ "* *" # ;" !" # "* 1 + " 1 "* # # " 0" "
# # # 1"# ) "** " # /#** # 5 0 + 7 !" # "* "*
1 + J 7 # 0 0 ) $ µ+ 0 * 1@7 " ) $ µ+ * 1 0/#** ! # 0 1"#
"** " # 0# # # " ; # # *" # 0 #1 ! # 0
"* *" # # # " 0" # ; # "
" # 1 0 * " #1 0 E * * +!* E# @7 0 "
7 # # 1 / " # " 0 # 0 # #"* !"# 7 " # #
!*" 0 ! # 0 #10 # 0 ! # 1 # # 0
" # # "* " # 0" "* " @; # A , . 0# ! # 7 0 *@
" # 0" " +# " 0 0 " 0 # ! "1 7 0 "#*
0 ! "1 7 " 0 * "1 ;#" "** "1 0 0 " # 0
# ! "1 # " 0 " " 0 "#* # 0 ! "1 " "#* 0
* "1 ;#" " "* ! # "* " 0# ! # 7 # *@ !" " +# 1 & 1
)
,& H& & . "** " # # 32) +& % !# 1 0 " * "1 # "*
+ 0 0 #1 ! /#** #+!*# @ " 0# 1 0 #1 !" "
1 * #
+ # # *@ # #1" #1 " 7 " " *"; + * 0
"+!*# # /" * ! 0 " *"; # ! # # !! #E
0 # "* *" # # 0 " *"; + * *" 0 " # , # @ 1"# . A @ ω !E F1 + J ? 7 /0 ? # " #+" 0 * " "!" # "
0 #1 A " # 0 !0" +" 1# " # "!! E#+" *" # 0#!/# 0 0 " #
A @ " :
≈ " − ω ,=
ω ω ,= ≈ ω / J 4 , 4.
" 0 / *" # 0#! 7 0 " # A @ " ; +#
+ 0 0 # 92 ° " 1 /" * +"E#+#B ;" /# 0"
+# #+#B *# 1 #+ 0 /# 0 "!" # "!!*# " # 0
0 #1 #! # * 0 #1 Z ; [7 " ** / :
+ ' 7
.
7
.
! 1, 9 ' ) % > % >
0 "* "!" # " " 0 * " # "* *" ;" :
.7 = . + + + , − β . ' , .
1 + # "* *" ;" 0 ;" /# 0 A # + # 1 0 "!! E#+" # :
ω ≈ β
.7
, 2.
1 + # "* *" ;" 0 ! # *@ "* *" " # A @ "
0 #1 ; =# 0 0 !" "+ # !*" 7 0 +"# 0 #1
#! # * # 1 ! 1 + J " 7 "* *" # 1 0 7 * # 1 !
J=7 "* *" # 1 0 /# 0 7 " # # 1 0 " " ;" "** 0 0
!" "+ "** 0 " # # 0 # #
0 " #*# @ 0# #1 #! /" # # ! #;* # 0 ! 1# 1
" "** * # 0 # # 0 #1 !" /" " 0 /# 0 "* !" "+
# #1" /0 0 0 " # * 1 0 " ! / +!# " 0"
0 /" +"** '# 0 +# #+"* * 1 0 / "* # + " # #
+ 0 1"# A # + 0 # # 7 /" ";* # 0 + " #E " +
+@ 0 #1 " #";* / +@ /"@ 0 10 0 # 1 " 0 0
!" "+ 7 /" "# ;@ 0 !" # "* *#+# 0 ) $ µ+ 0 * 1@
0 ** /# 1 A " # 7 # ;@> ( C)D7 /" 1"# # #10 # 0 #
! +" 0 # # :
4
) = β
#/
.
γ , + γ
γ ,
ω ω ,?
+ γ γ ,
4 + ω
ω ,@ + ω ω ,@
+ 2 + ω
ω ,@
, 3.
0# A " # # # " 0" !# 1 0 0 " " # 0 # # +"** "
+!" 1 + / * # '# ; 01 + " 1 + " "# ;@ 0
#1 # # 7 / # #1" 0 ! / +!# " !" # "* #+!*# " # +# #+#B# 1 1 +4 7 1 + " 1 +2 7 " # " 0" !# 1 0 +"** #+! 0
! / ! +" " / ** " 0 # ! +" = 0" /# 0# 0 !" # "*
*#+# 0 0 * 1@7 ) 4 /" " " ";* 0 # 1 +4 J1 + " ) / * ;
" ";* 1 + J1 + " 1 +2 J1 +
+"# # 1 #1 ; 7 "1"# 7 ;@ # 1 0 " *"; #1 # +
" 0 0 + * # " #";* #1 !" 0" / 0" # 7 11 J -7 /"
+# ; "!! E#+" *@ J ))) +# #+#B ! / =# 0"** 0 * #
# 0" 7 / !* 0 0 10 4 " " #
+ ' . 7
* # 1 # 5#1 4 ; * /:
! + , ' ' + ,
0 " *"; ! 1 "+ 0" 1 " 0# !* /" ! * " ;*" " @ ** # 0
#1 !" 0" /" #+!" # "* + 0 " ! # 0" 1 + J /" "*#B";* " @
0 * # 1 # / * ; #+! #;* #+!" # "* " @ 0 " 5
E"+!* 7 / 0 # "** / # /# 0 1 " 0" 4)) µ+ 5 0# " 7 / 0 0" " # # ; /* 0"! 7 ; " 0"! 0" 0" " +# #+ + "* 1 0
11 J -7 "E# 7 ; "** #+!" # "* "* "* 1 0 11 J, H . "E# 0 #!
"* " +" # "**@! " # "** 1 " 0 * / ! / !" # "* #1 :
C+ 7 + 7 +47 + 7 +2D F O /,) 297 ) )4 27 ) )) 7 ) $ )37 ) $ )37 ) 47 ) 7 ) 7 0.
0 # "* "* + 0# ! " , / #1 # # " #1# .:
2
= F )) µ+
= F4$ µ+
=4 F2) µ+
= F4) µ+
=2 F4) µ+
0 " F$)) µ
"#* F ) µ
0# ! # 7 0 # # # 5#1 3 /" #+ *" " +# 0" #1 #! /"
# +# 1 ! /# 0 " ";* "* 0 1"# /" 7 " 0 !" ;"
! +" + ! # # " # 0 # /" E + *@* /7 * " # 1 !* @ + #
0 # ; 1 0 ;#" # # @
0 !;" " " # ! # # " # /" + 7 +# 1 ; "!! E#+" *@44
# " 42 ! 0 # #1" # 7 # /" 0" 0 !0" +" 1# /"
) °7 0 " 1 92 ° / 7 # 4 /" @ # 0 # # 7 " 0 "#
"!" # " 4 / * 0" 0 " # 1 0 !0" +" 1# 7 /
8 1+ 0# #* 0 # # /" +!*
$ ' $, $
* "1 # # # ;#" # # /" #1 1 " & H& & /0 & # ) 2
& ' " ' # # ' ) $ T+ +#E #1 "* ! 0 * 1@
, ) $+ . " & & /" 0 ; 2) +& " ' # A # " & (' ,F
3
& H& & . 2 & " <)) +& " ' # 32) +& " $)) +&
0#! 0 " J ) /" 1 " " & # 1 0
#1 " # # 5#1 ;#" 0 " # 7 " " # # ;@ "
# 0# 0 + ! # " 0#10 /# 1 " ;#" CD # 5#1
# # " " # " ! " # 0 # 1# 0 #B 0 +! #
+;# " # +# 0 * "1 7 & (' 7 /0# 0 # ;#" ; A
"1 5#1 2 0 / 0 " "* ;#" # 1 ;* 7 /0# 0 1 " " ;#" "
+#
=J -
!!"
9
!( + + #
$
!$ '
<
4 $ , $ $
0 " # ! * " " " ) +& !# 0 / # 5#1 9
0 ! ; 1# " )) " " "+!*# 1 ! # # \< 32 0# " 7 ) U
@ "+# *# 1 # # + = "* " "* 0 " # #+ *" # 5
*" 1 ! 7 0 *# 1 " 1 ; @ ) U7 ; # 1 " 0" ) 2 )U
0 ! # # "!!*# " # 0" "+ #1 # 1 7 0" ! 1 " 0" ) +& # !" # # ! #1 "* # 0 !" ;"
!- , , ' ' 1/8
5 5#1 , $.7 " # ! #1 "* /" 0 0" # # "**@ *#! " 0 ! 0#
* " *@ 0 / 0 1 " 1 0 0 * " 0 +"E#+ + !
2)
/# 1 # /# 0# * 0" 2 +& 0 !!*@ "#* 0# #1 "* 0 / + " # "
# # " 0#10 # * * 7 " 0" ; ! # *@ #
5#1 $ = 1 , *)
* * ! !* 0 # + #" # # 0 / # !4 0 *
* !1"# " ;" /# 0"1 ! *@/# 0 0 * 0 #1 ! # 1 0
" *"; + * 0 !0" +" 1# # ) ° 0# # #10 " 1 " 0# " 92 ° !0"
+" 1# 0 # "* "#* " !*" /# 0 4" " 4;7 /0# 0/#** #
" "# "!" # " 0" /#** " !0" +" 1#
2
5#1 < . , 6 , ' % &
5#1 ) # 0 * * ! ! 47 +!* /# 0 0 ;#" # # @ 0#
#+ *" # # # " " ! ;* + /# 0 0 1"# 0" /" ! #* 0 ;#" # # /" # 0# !* " "**@ 0 / " # " # 0 !0" +" 1# 7 /0 /
0 * ; # 1 " " + ) ° "!! E#+" *@92° / 7 0 0"! 0 +"1 # !* # # " 0 ;" /# 0 0" + 0" / " * # 1 # #
! 0 ! ;* + # /# 01"# 7 " 0# ! ;* + # " ;@ 0 0# / #E 7 0 1"# +" 1# / * ;
0 # # !" "+ * 0 10 " * + *# 1 " # 1 " *"; " 0 0
+ * # " #";* #1 !" * " #1 0" + "** 0 ! # # " # ! *@
2
! 5 , , ' , 1/8
24
8 4 9 &
! "
5#1 3 0 / 0 +!* /0# 0 ;#" 1 + # 1 / "
; 0 #A * ; +;# " # " * " " /# 0 0 ** /# 1
" " 1 + " 0 # "1
( ' 1/8'
0 # " 0 # "* # # 5#1 2 "+ + ; "!!# 1 " " **" # 5#1 2 0 / 0" # *" 1 # "* " ; " 0 0 @ " @# * " *
;#" # # 0# ! * 1@ * # " # "* , . 1 ; / 0 1" /0# 0
0 * # /# 0 ! # " + # 0 # 0
F1 + , MM ) . ,2 .
2
# # #*#B# 1 " * ;#" *# # 5#1 2 /#** " " ++ + ;"
" **" # 0 1"# 0# #1 " # # + " *@0#10
( 8
+ 1"# " ; ; "# ;@ " **" # 5 0# ! ! 7 /
# #"* # '5 / 0 + ! # " # #"* +"** #1 "*
# " J1 + !*# 1 0 + " " ! # # ;" "+!*# # /# 0 /
"1 " * 7 0 # #"* # " ; + 1" # ] J1 + 0# 1" #
# " # " #*@ ** 0 10 0 0# # # #**" 7 5
* "1 ** #**" " # /# ;" "+!*# #
22
# 1 " ! # # # # " /# 0 1" # "** / "*#B" #
" @ # " ; / J1 + " ^ @ 0 # 1 # #B ; "+ " *
# 0 # # 7 /0# 0 * # @0#10 # #"* ! ,# # # /# 0 ))U
+" 0# 1. 0# * " # 0 " # "* * " " # #"* # # 0
" " "1 0# # # # # 0" # 0 # " " **" # 7 #
! " @ ! * 0 # # " 0 / # #"* "1 " ; # *@
!* /# 0 +! " # 0 # "* # # # 0 / # 5#1 2
- " # ; +" 0 " # " +# +" 0 # " 1 "* ! ! 7 0 / 0# # "!!*# " # 7 0" 1# 1 0 #B * " # 0" 1 0 * "
#+! " " 0 0" 1 0 "** ( +
# ! # "
; " ; +" " 1@ # "!!*# /0# 0 * # *"!!# 1 *
1 " # / 7 *"!!# 1 * 0" " #E "+ *"@/0# 0"
0 G # # @ # 1 0 * / " 0 #A C4D #; ; * /7
/# 0# 1 " # " ; +" " " " 0 /# 0# 1 " # " ; +" * /
/ 0 + " ! ! ; " # **";#*# @ * / # " 0#10
# /# 0
# 0 + ," *# # 5#1 2 .7/0 1 0#107 " ! * 1 " 1 " "
0#10! * /# 0" 0#10 " # * ! # 7 /0# 0 0 )))) "
0 /# 0'= /0# 0 & 0 1" ' E
* 7 " " " 0 ! /# 0 / /0# 0
23
) < & ' 1" " ;@ # /0# 0# *#10*@ 0 '
0 E !7 0 " " 0 E " '= 0# !
# #* 0 " 0 # *" 7 # 1 0 *" '= 7 /0# 0
) & 0 ' 1" 7 /0# 0 0" ' # **@
(!* ) %
0# + 0 ** 0#10 # /# 0 ;@ **# 1 # 1" * "1
# "* # ! /0# 0 * 0 , . ;@ # /0# 0# # *@ *
0 * / # " @;#1 ' # !! 0 *" 1 "+
" "* ; *"@ ;@ 0# + 0 7 /0# 0 0 *! ! 0 /# 0# 1
" # 1 " 0 /# 0# 1 0 ! / !!*@
' :;/'
:;<'
:;='
:;>'
'=
&O(
- -& O
& O '=
'=
'=4 '=
'=$
'=< O
0 '=)
'=
) 0#!* "
/
-%
29
'/# 0# 1 0 ! / !!*@ * # " 0#10! / , . #1 "* 1 "
;@ ;* #1 "* # /# 0 G * 0 ! * /
#1 "* " 0#10 #1 "* " 0 ! )))) * 0 !/"
# 1 0 =0 # 0#107 0 # # + ;@ /# 0
@ * 1 =0 0 ! " 0 ) ) # ! 7 " "@ " ) )
#* # 0#10
0 ! # 0 0 /0# 0# ! #;* # 1 "
!" # *" /# 0 " # 1 0 0 # 1 " !" # *" /# 0 "
!" # *" * "1 0 1" 0 0#10 # /# 0
0 0#10 # /# 0 ; /0#* 0 #1 "* # 0#10" # /#** ; /0
F ) =0 #1 "* # " , F ).7 # 0 ! 7 /0# 0 0
" * "* ))))
0 # # / 0 * 5#1 2 # 1 " # 1 ;
"!!*# 1" **# 1 0 0 0#10 # /# 0 "
"* ; 1 " + " " * "1 " " # " ! #"* # #
" " 1 +
1 " " ; *# " ;@ 0" # 1 +"** ! #"* ! # ; 1# # 1
" *" 1 ! #"* ! *"
! / !7 ;* 1 " " 0#10! * /0# 0 0 ! ))))
0 '=) " '= '= ) /0# 0 & * "1 1"
0#10 # /# 0 # 1 0" # /#** ; **@ =0 1 0#10 #
" 0 " " ! # 1 /# 0 @ # # 1 * 1
2$
! ))) 0" 0 /#** '= " 0 /# 0
/0# 0/#** ) & 1" ' 0# ! /#** " # + "*
0#10 # /# 0 =0 " 0 " "* ) ) # /#** '= ) "
0 0 /# 0 # 1 /# 0 '= ) /#** ( 0 1" 7
# 1 0" /# 0# **@ 0 /#** ! # 1 " " 0# 1 "
"* ) ) #* # 0#107 /0# 0 0" #* # 0#107 #
* / /#** 0 7 " 0 /0 * ! /#** " "1"#
*"@ 0 " 1 " "* 7 " / * @ * & " ;
' /0# 0/#** 0" /#** +"# ; /# 0
((* ) 6 ) '
-%
'=) '= '= '=4 '=< '= ) '= ) '= ) '= ) '= ) '=)