Measurement of One-Way Internet Packet Delay
11
0
0
Full text
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5) !#"%$# &')(* +-,/.1032 ,547698;:<4*8>=?4A@B6>CD0FEHGI:J8>.1=?KL2M:<.1N?616>,/4FEHOQPH.1=?:/4RGS,5TU@B6>CD0L:/47PROV.>47@WOWX7YV=ZN[6>6>,/4 \^]1_5`baFcedgfh];ij];k;celml n*o5pjkbqD`9pjcBo r<s/tu`9];lmt r/kwv*cJcBi7cedgxyo5zBpjo*];]>{9p|o5z }ij];~<pjo*ze]Vo*tu`9p`9n5`9]McedFfh]1k>v5o*cBijcezes J -e% qD{9ijt~J{9cBo*q/r<]b5];o /ce{9nUa k;ceo*tu`wqDo<`9pjo5];tk;nU*_q`{9p|~Ha kbq{9i|ttceoUAqe/{9p|qeo7a _HcB_H];tk;n7q{9o*]Ba o5p|ijttceoAeM/`9vUa t] ;1D*B fSv*]_qe_H]>{m{9];_Hce{`9tWcBoq5];5pjkbqD`9];#lm]bqDtn5{9];lm];oJ` tus5tu`9]1ld[cD{/];i|q;s#lm];qetn5{9]> lm];oJ`9tpjo ¡{9cBn/`9]1{9t;F¢v*pjk>v3d?cBijijc¢tWt_H];k1pj£*kbqD`9pjceo*t%cDd `9v5]¤ x¥fI¦¨§M¦h©«ªe¬ e a3fSv*] tus/tu`9];ln*t];t Hce`9v_qDttp|®B]%qeo*qek1`9pj®]Vlm]bqetn/{9];lm];oJ`9t;a \^]b5pjkbq`9]bqe_5_*ijpjkbqD`9pjcBo/¯iZq;sJ]>{ tcedZ` SqD{9]¤p|t-n*t]bL`9c)ze];o*]>{wqD`9]W`{wqD°mkBagq{9]1`9c)`{wqD°mkWlmc</];ijt q{9]n5t]bL`9c)zB];o5]1{wqD`9] t];id?¯tpjlmpji|qD{%`{wq°mkpjo`9v5]¤ijpjo*~HaL}ce`9v3_*qekw~]1`-pjo<`9]>{ q{{9pj®BqDi`9pjlm];t qDo_*qekw~]1`-tp|±1];t qD{9]MlWqD`9kwv*pjo*zV{9]bqeiA`{wqD°mkMlmc<5];ijt;ay²¨_*qettpj®]^lm];qetn5{9]1lm];oJ`Itus/tu`9];l³pjt¢n*t]bmd[cD{M5qD`wq k;cei|ij];k>`9p|ceo3`9vqD`VpjtVqet];cBon5tp|o5z)t];®]1{wqDitcDk;qeijij]b´]bqetn/{9];lm];oJ`-cBpjoJ`9t;F]bqekwv3ced `9v*]1l ]bµJn*pj_*_H];¢p`9v \ ²·¶lmcBo5pj`9cD{9pjo*zMk;qD{w5t;aF¸Mqetv5p|o5zMpjtFn*t]bd[cD{y`9v5]Sp|5];oJ`9p£k;qD`9pjcBo qeo*lWq`9k>v5pjo*zWced_qekw~]1`9t;a-fSv5] k;cel *pjo*qD`9pjcBoced_qettpj®] lm]bqetn/{9];lm];oJ`9t^qDoqek1`9pj®] _5{9ce*pjo*z/B`9cezB]1`9v5]1{F¢pj`9v-n*tpjo*z `9v*]S\ ²·¶lmcBo*p`9cD{9p|o5zMtus/tu`9];l ezBpj®];tFn5t¥qDo n5o*p|µJn*]S_Hcetu tpj*pjijp` s`9c_H]1{d?ce{9l¹_/{9];k;pjt]%`{wqD°mk lm]bqetn/{9];lm];oJ`9tQqet^];ijiqDtQ`9v*] º*]1»/p|5pji|p`so*];]b/]b `9c k1cBlm_H];o5t9qD`9]^d[cD{¢`9v*]Qi|qekw~Wcedyqeo*qeis<`9pjkQtcBijn5`9pjcBo5t;a ¼ ½h¾¿yÀSÁ)ÂLÃRÄ·¿¥ÅÁW¾ ¥Æ ,HPA:Ç 4A@89ÈM,/.1K)CD:/T7:/CD=|81=Z@B6 :/.>@-ÉU@e=Z4AÊ PH@eNZ=?ÉU@e.1:<8>@eNZÇ ,JË/@e.>@e4AÊ/=?4A@e@D.1@eP=Z4R8>Ì7@-Í4*8>@e.>47@8Q6w,¤8>Ì7:<8 81ÌA@%T7:/C;K5@8MNZ,*6>6 .1:<8>@-=?6MË/@e.>Ç N?,JÈ :<47P8>ÌA@%@e47PÎ 8>,<Îu@D4UPÐÏÑ@ÒJ@BÓ PH@eN?:Ç =[6 Ô =?4A=?Ô=?ÕD@BPgX¢Ö,JÈM@DË5@D.BE Ê5=ZË5@D48>ÌA@VÌA@81@D.1,/Ê/@e4A@D=Z89ÇW,/×U81ÌA@4A@D89È ,5.>KW:/47P8>ÌA@^ׯ:5Cb8¢81Ì7:J8I81ÌA@,JË5@D.1@D4AÊ5=Z4A@e@D.1=Z47Ê-6>,/N?0H8>=?,/4=?6 47,<8:/PH,5TH8>@BP@eË/@D.1ÇÈQÌA@D.1@/E*@e6>Th@eC=[:<N?N?Ç)4A,<8QÉÇÉ7:5C;K*Éh,/47@8>@eNZ@e,/Th@D.;:J81,/.;6·=?4LPA@DË/@eNZ,5TA=?4AÊCD,/0A4AÎ 81.>=?@e6eE58>ÌA@ Ø507@e6w8>=?,/4:<.1=[6w@B6¢:/6S81,¤ÌA,JȨ8>Ì7@-PH@eN?:ÇTU@e.w×Ñ,5.>Ô):/47C@Q=?Ô T7:/C816¢,54@BÒ<@QTU@e.w×Ñ,5.>Ô):/47C@5X Æ^Ì7@D.1@ :/.>@%6w@eË/@e.1:/NU=?Ô TU,5.w8;:<4*8MTU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6¢81Ì7:J8QÔ):Ç)=ZÔ T7:5Cb8^,/4PH@DN[:Ç)Th@D.>×Ñ,/.1Ô :/47C@-=Z4R8>Ì7@ N?=?4AKEA@/X Ê7X?E8>.;:JÙC%6w@eN|×ÚÎ6>=ZÔ =?N?:/.>=Z89Ç/EH.1,/0H81=Z47ʤÛU:/T76Q:<4UPRN?=?4AK0H81=ZN?=ZÕB:J81=Z,54FX Ü @DË/@e.1:/NIT7:<Th@D.;6mÌ7:Ë5@ ÉU@e@D4ÝTA07ÉANZ=[6>ÌA@eP6>,ׯ:<.m81Ì7:J8.>@eTU,5.w8W,54@ÒJ@PA@DN[:ÇÐTU@e.w×Ñ,5.>Ô):/47C@5E :/47PmÉh,<81ÌÞQ,50A47PÎÆy.1=?TWÆ^=ZÔ @-ÏÞSÆQÆÓy:/47Pß-4A@DÎ àá:Ç Æ¥.;:<476>=|8SÆ^=ZÔ @ Ï ßà ÆQÆÓF:<.1@·CD,/476>=?PA@D.1@eP.
(6) ÒHE AE HE u
(7) X @D4A@e.1:/NZN?Ç/EÞSÆQÆÔ @e:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8;6·:<.1@-6>=?ÔT7NZ@e. ÉA0A8 81ÌA@ :/47:<N?ÇH6w=[6 =?6 Ô ,/.1@-C,5ÔÎ T7NZ@ PH07@W8>,TA.>,5ÉAN?@DÔ)6Q.1@DN[:J8>@BPL8>,CDNZ,HC;KL6wÇ47C;ÌA.1,/47=ZÕB:J8>=?,/4yEAT7:/C;K5@8Q81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô TA=Z47Ê7EhTA.>,/8>,HC,5N CD,/Ô TAN? @ H=Z89Ç/E:/6>Ç*Ô Ô @81.>=?@e6V=Z4PH=?.>@BCb8 :/47P.1@8>07.>4ÐTU:J8>ÌU6-:56ÈM@DN?N:56VT7:<8>ÌÐËJ:/.>=[:J81=Z,5476DX%ßV8>ÌA@e. T7.>,5ÉANZ@eÔ)6S.>@eN?:<8>@eP¤8>,WPA=|ÙC07N|81=Z@B6I=Z4 Ô @e:56w07.>=?4AÊ%Ø507@D0A@e=Z4AÊmPH@eN?:ÇH6S=?4 ,/Th@D.;:J8>=?,/4U:<N.>,50H8>@e.16S:/47P 6>ÈQ=Z81C;ÌA@B6M×Ñ0A.w81ÌA@D.-C,/Ô TAN?=[CD:J81@e6 8>Ì7@mTA=?C8>0A.1@/X ß-07.IT7:<Th@D.I=[6¢:%C,54581.>=?ÉA0H81=Z,548>,JÈ^:<.;PA6S:-Éh@8>8>@e.¢0A47PH@e.16w81:/47PH=?4AÊ%,<×h8>.;:JÙC^Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6 :56>6>,HC=[:J81@ePÈQ=Z8>Ì¡@BÒ<@LPH@eN?:ÇH6,HCDC07.>.1=Z47Ê=?4¨Éh@e6w8wÎu @ ,/.>847@89ÈM,/.1K6eXà@PA@e61C.1=ZÉh@RT7.>,5ÉANZ@eÔ)6 :/47P6w,5NZ0A8>=?,/476:56>6>,HC=[:J81@ePRÈQ=|81Ì#ßQà ÆQÆ PH@DN[:ÇÔ @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*816eEA:<47PLÊ/=?Ë/@m@ A:<Ô TAN?@e6^,<×¢6>07C;Ì Ô @B:/6>0A.>@eÔ @D4*816eX-O PH@ePA=?Ce:J8>@BP3Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458 6wÇH6w8>@DÔ =[6 .>@eTU,5.w81@ePL×Ñ,/.%PH@eN?:ÇÔ @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6 =?4ÍG .1,/0H81@D.;6DE¥ÈQÌA=[C;Ìá×Ñ,/N?NZ,JÈ66wTh@eCD= UCe:J81=Z,5476m,<×^81ÌA@Í ·Æ ³Þ S2 Ò AXÆ^ÌA@6>Ç6w8>@eÔ 0U6w@B6 Éh,<81ÌT7:/616w=?Ë/@ Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6Q:<47PL:/C8>=?Ë/@%TA.1,/ÉA=?4AÊUX Æ^Ì7@.1@e6w8W,<× 8>ÌA@)TU:<Th@D.W=[6%,/.1Ê5:/4A=ZÕe@eP#:/6 ×Ñ,/N?N?,JÈ6DX Í4 Ü @eC8>=?,/4ÝÒRÈ @PA@e61C.1=ZÉh@8>ÌA@PH@eN?:Ç CD,/Ô Th,/4A@e458;6S:/616w,HC=[:J81@ePmÈQ=Z8>Ìß-4A@DÎ àá:ÇWÆy.;:<4U6w=Z8SÆ^=?Ô @^Ô@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*816eX Ü @BCb81=Z,5 4 PH@e61C.1=?ÉU@B6 81ÌA@VÔ @B:/6>0A.>@eÔ @D4*8 6>Ç6w8>@eÔ¹:<47P 81ÌA@81@eC;ÌA47,/N?,/Ê/Ç076>@eP ×Ñ,5.¢8>.;:JÙC-C,/N?N?@eCb81=Z,54:/6·È @eNZN:/6¢8>.;:JÙC Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>=?,/4:<47PT7:/C;K5@8S=?PA@D4*8> = UCD:<8>=?,/4FX¥Í4 Ü @eC8>=?,/ 4 -ÈM@QPH@e61C.1=ZÉh@Q6w@eË/@e.1:/N5@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*816IPH,54A@ :/47P8>ÌA@m:/616>,CD=?:<8>@BPPH@D81:<=?N[6DX Ü @BCb8>=?,/! 4 ¤=?6QPH@BPH=[CD:J81@eP8>, .1@DTh,/.>8>=?4AÊ6>@DË5@D.;:<Nh.>@B6w0ANZ816^,5ÉH81:/=Z47@eP ,54R,54A@ÎuÈ^:ÇPH@DN[:ÇTh@D.>×Ñ,/.1Ô :/47C@5"X =?47:<N?N?Ç/E Ü @BCb81=Z,5# 4 )CD,/47CDNZ07PA@e6 8>ÌA=[6QT7:/TU@e.eX Á/.10#ÁW¾#&Q¾¿32 ß-47@Îuà:ÇÝÆ¥.1:/476>=|8Æ^=?Ô@ÏußQà ÆQÆÓ=[6)Ô @e:/6>0A.1@eP É*ÇÝ8>=?Ô@B698;:<Ô TA=?4AÊ:á6wTh@eCD=UCLT7:5C;K/@D8 :<8 81ÌA@6>@D47PH@e.eEF6>@D4UPH=Z47ÊR81ÌA@ T7:/C;K5@8%=Z4*81,R81ÌA@)4A@D89È ,5.>KEF:<4UPC,5Ô T7:<.1=Z47Ê81ÌA@8>=?Ô@B698;:<Ô TáÈQ=|81Ì 81ÌA@W81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô TÐÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81@eP:J8-8>ÌA@.>@BC@e=ZË5@D.BXMGI:5C;K/@8Q81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô TA=?4AÊRCe:<43Éh@PH,54A@W@D=Z8>Ì7@D. É*Ç 6>,<×Ú89È^:<.1@)ÏÚ×Ñ,5.8>Ì7@¤CD:56w@m,/×IPA@DN[:ÇRÔ @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*816Q:J8V8>ÌA@:<TATAN?=[CD:J81=Z,54NZ@eË/@DNÚÓ^,5.ÉÇÌ7:/.1PHÈ^:<.1@ ÏÑ×Ñ,/.¥8>ÌA@^CD:56w@ ,<×7PH@eN?:Ç%Ô @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*816F=?4W81ÌA@M4A@89ÈM,/.1KAÓbEJ:<47PW=Z4¤8>ÌA=[6¥Ce:/6>@ 6>TU@BC=[:<N*Ì7:<.;PHÈ^:<.1@I=?6 0U6w@BPgXI2 N?,HC;Km6wÇ47C;ÌA.1,/47=ZÕB:J8>=?,/4mÉh@89ÈM@D@e4¤81ÌA@^6w@e47PH@D.I:/47Pm81ÌA@ .1@eCD@D=?Ë/@e.¥4A,HPH@B6=?6=?ÔTh,/.>81:/4*8¥×Ñ,5. 81ÌA@mTA.1@eCD=?6>=Z,54R,/×¥,54A@ÎuÈM:ÇPA@DN[:Ç)Ô@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*816 4 uX ß-4L8>,/TL,<×8>ÌU:J8eEUPH@DN[:ÇÔ @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6 :<88>Ì7@¤:<TAT7NZ=[CD:<8>=?,/4NZ@eË/@eNy:<.1@W6w@e476>=|81=ZË5@%8>,)Th,5616w=?ÉAN?@W0A47CD@D.>81:<=?4*8>=?@e6Q.1@DN[:J81@ePR8>, 81ÌA@¤PH = @D.1@D47CD@ Éh@89ÈM@D@e4L8>ÌA6 @ 5ÈQ=Z.1@V81=ZÔ @ 5%:<47P8>ÌA6 @ 5ÌA,56w8^8>=?Ô @ 5 :/6^ÈM@DN?NX ßà ÆQÆ ÌU:/6Q6>@DË/@e.1:/NgC,/Ô Th,/4A@e4*81687 $. %'&( )+*-,. Dn,i. Ï9Ó. Dn,i = Dtr,i + Dproc,i + Dq,i. ÏÒ5Ó. OW T T = Dprop +. ÈQÌ7@D.1@-81ÌA@WPH@eN?:Ç)Th@D.47,PA@ i E. N X. i=0 [ = ^ 6 / Ê ? = / Ë e @ R 4 É 7 Ç Dn,i. Æ^Ì7@%PA=@D.1@D4*8VC,5Ô TU,54A@D4*816^=?4Ï9Ó :/47PáÏÒ5Ó^CD:<4LÉh@W6w0AÔ Ô):<.1=?ÕD@ePR:/6M×Ñ,5NZN?,JÈ67 =?6 81ÌA@ 8>,/81:/NITA.>,5T7:<Ê*:J81=Z,54PH@DN[:Ç:/NZ,54AÊ81ÌA@ TAÌÇH6w=[CD:/NINZ=?4AKH6 8>Ì7:<8WÔ):<K/@0AT8>Ì7@ • Dprop Í4*8>@e.>4A@D8IT7:J81ÌÉh@89ÈM@D@e4¤81ÌA@Q6w@e47PH@D.¢:/47P¤8>ÌA@^.1@eC@e=ZË5@D.BXyÆ^ÌA=[68>=?Ô @Q=?6I6>,/N?@DN?ÇWPH@81@D.1Ô =Z4A@BP ÉÇ8>ÌA@TA.1,/Th@D.>8>=?@e6,<×81ÌA@C,/Ô Ô0A4A=[CD:J81=Z,54¨C;Ì7:/4A4A@eNM:56¤ÈM@DN?NQ:/68>ÌA@PH=[698;:<47CD@/XÍu8 =?6 =?47PH@DTh@D4UPH@D4*8,<×8>.;:JÙC%C,547PH=Z8>=?,/476^,5481ÌA@mN?=Z4AKH6eX =?6^81ÌA@%40AÔ¤Éh@D.,/×¥4A,HPH@B6QÉh@89ÈM@D@D4R8>Ì7@W6w@e47PH@D.:/47P8>ÌA@m.1@eCD@D=?Ë/@D.BX • N.
(8) =[681ÌA@8>.;:<476>Ô =?616w=?,/4Ð8>=?Ô@×Ñ,/. 4A,HPH@ X%Æ^Ì7=?6-=?6-81ÌA@¤81=ZÔ @=|8 81:/K/@B6×Ñ,5.V81ÌA@47,PA@ 18 ,ÐC,5T*Ç8>ÌA@)TU:/C;K/@D8W=Z4*81,8>ÌA@ U.16w8WÉA0 @Di.:/6%ÈM@DN?N :/6 81,6>@D.1=?:/NZ=?ÕD@8>Ì7@T7:/C;K5@8m,JË/@e. 8>Ì7@#C,5Ô Ô¤0A4A=[CD:<8>=?,/4 N?=Z4AKX Íu8PH@DTh@D4UPA6,54 8>ÌA@#T7:/C;K5@8N?@D47Ê<8>Ì :/47P=Z8R=[6=?4Ë/@D.;6>@DN?Ç TA.1,/Th,/.>8>=?,/47:/N781, 8>ÌA@mN?=?4AK6>TU@e@ePgX =?6Q8>ÌA@WT7.>,HC@B6>6>=?4AÊ)PH@DN[:ÇR:<8Q8>ÌA@W47,PA@ X^Æ^ÌA=[6Q=[6Q8>Ì7@m8>=?Ô @W4A@D@BPH@ePR81,TA.1,CD@e616 • Dproc,i :<4R=Z4UC,/Ô =?4AÊT7:/C;K5@8mÏÑ@/X Ê7X?E8>, PH@BC,HPH@ 8>ÌA@%T7:5C;iK/@D8 ÌA@B:/PH@e.eE*8>,)C;ÌA@BC;K×Ñ,/.QÉA=Z8Q@D.1.>,5.16eE<81, N?,*,5K0AT.1,/0A8>@e6¢=Z4):%.1,/0H81=Z4AÊ 8;:<ÉAN?@BÓI:56SÈ @eNZNU:/68>Ì7@Q8>=?Ô @4A@D@BPH@eP81,mTA.>@eT7:<.1@M8>ÌA@QTU:/C;K/@D8 ×Ñ,/.×Ñ0A.w81ÌA@D.8>.;:<476>Ô =?616>=Z,54FE ,54 :<4A,/8>ÌA@e.N?=Z4AKX Æ^ÌA=[6PH@eN?:Ç¡PH@DTh@D4UPA6,54T7:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6 N?=ZK5@4A@89ÈM,/.1KT7.>,/8>,HC,5NEIC,5Ô TA0H81:<8>=?,/47:/N·Th,JÈ @e.¤:J84A,HPH@/E¢:/47Pá@ÙCD=Z@e47CÇá,<×47@89ÈM,/.1K =?4581@D.>ׯ:/CD@ Ce:<.;PA6DX =?6V8>Ì7@Ø*0A@e0A@D=?4AÊPH@DN[:ÇR=?4Ð81ÌA@4A,HPH@ XmÆ^ÌA=[6-PA@DN[:ÇL.1@×Ñ@e.16V8>,8>ÌA@È^:<=Z8>=?4AÊ81=ZÔ @e6 • Dq,i =?4¡É70 h@e.16eE:<4UP¡PA@DTh@D47PA60ATh,/4 8>.;:JÙCC;Ì7i :/.1:5Cb8>@e.>=[6w8>=[CD6eE·N?=Z4AK C,547PH=Z8>=?,/476ÏÑ@/X Ê7X?E^NZ=?4AK 0H81=ZN?=ZÕB:J81=Z,54 ρ E/=Z4*8>@e.w×Ñ@e.>@e47C@ ÈQ=|81̤,/8>ÌA@e.¥ÍG#T7:/C;K5@816;ÓF:56yÈM@DN?NH:/6¥=ZÔ TAN?@DÔ @D4*8;:J8>=?,/4PH@8;:<=?N?6 ,<×¥8>ÌA@m47,PA@/X Ü @DË/@e.1:/N¥6w81:<8>=[6981=?Ce6DE@/X Ê7X?EhÔ@B:<4FEÔ @ePA=?:/4FEgÔ): H=ZÔ0AÔEÔ=?4A=?Ô¤0AÔEËJ:<.1=?:/47C@5EUTh@e:/K/@BPH4A@e616eE :/47PÐT7.>,5É7:<ÉA=?N?=|89Ç3PH=[6981.>=?ÉA0H81=Z,54Ð×Ñ0A4UCb8>=?,/4yEy:<.1@¤076>07:/NZN?Ç3076>@ePÐ=?4Ð81ÌA@)PH@e61C.1=?TH8>=?,/4Ð,/×MPH@eN?:ÇL×Ñ,5. 47,/4HÎC,5.>.10ATH81@ePÐTU:/C;K/@D816eXÆ ÇTA=?Ce:<NIËJ:<N?0A@B6%,/ÉH8;:<=?4A@ePÐ×Ñ,/.ßà ÆQÆ .;:<4AÊ5@¤×Ñ.1,/Ô 81@D476%,/× µ6 81, Ì0A4UPH.>@BPA6^,<×SÔ)6 X 7,/.¢:%Ê5@D4A@e.1:/NAPH=?61C0U6>6>=Z,54FE<81ÌA@ ßà ÆQƨPA@DN[:ǤCD:/4Éh@T7:/.w81=|81=Z,54A@eP=?4*8>,%89ÈM,WC,/Ô Th,/4A@e4*816eE : PH@D8>@e.>Ô =?4A=?6w8>=[CmPH@eN?:Ç Dd :/47PL:6w8>,HC;Ì7:56981=?C%PH@eN?:Ç Ds 7 Ï *Ó OW T T = Dd + Ds E :/47P ÏÑT7:/.w81NZÇAÓ :/.>@C,54*8>.1=ZÉA0A8>=?4AÊ¡8>, 8>Ì7@ÝPH@81@D.1Ô=?4A=[6981=?C PH@DN[:Ç Dd E ÈQÌ7@DD.1@eprop :/6W8>ÌAD@tr6w8>,HC;Ì7:/6w8>=[CPA@DN[:Ç DDproc [ = 6 D C .>@B:J81@ePÉÇ Dq :<4UPgE·:J8 6w,5Ô @ @ 81@D4*8eE Dproc XÆ^Ì7@ 6w8>,HC;Ì7:56981=?C-T7:/.w8^,<×¥8>ÌA@%.1,/0H81@D.MTA.>,HsCD@e616w=?4AÊPA@DN[:ÇCD:<4R ÉU@%,5É76w@e.>Ë5@eP@e6>TU@BC=[:<N?NZÇ)=?481ÌA@mCD:56w@-,<× N?,JÈ :/47PRË/@D.1ÇN?,JÈ N?=Z47K0H8>=?N?=ZÕB:J8>=?,/4yEA=X @/X?EAÈQÌA@e481ÌA@WØ*0A@D07@D=?4AÊ)PH@DN[:ÇH6Q:<.1@ Ô =?4A,/.BX • Dtr,i i. . . yÃRÀ"&. &Q¾¿32 O³PH@BPH=[CD:J81@ePRÔ @e:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8Q6wÇH6w8>@eÔ¹Ì7:/6MÉh@D@D4PH@eË/@DN?,/Th@eP8>,)PH, PH@DN[:Ç)Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6M=Z4LÍG .1,/0A8>@D.;6eE*ÈQÌ7=?C;ÌL×Ñ,/N?N?,JÈ6M6>Th@eC = UCe:J8>=?,/4U6^,<×y81ÌA@mÍ ·Æ ¨Þ 2 Ò 4 uX¢Æ^ÌA@W6>ÇH6981@DÔ 076>@e6^Éh,<81Ì TU:/616w=?Ë/@^Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458;6¢:<4UP):/Cb81=ZË5@^TA.>,5ÉA=?4AÊ7XS+V@BPH=[CD:J81@eP):/TATAN?=?Ce:J8>=?,/4AÎ N[:Ç/@e.S6>,<×Ú89È^:<.1@^=?6¢076w@BP 81,#Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@ -+VG 8>.;:JÙCÈQ=|81̨ÆV2 GIÎuNZ=?K/@C;Ì7:/.1:5Cb8>@e.>=[6w8>=[CD6eX#Æ^ÌA@RÈ @eNZNZÎ K4A,JÈQ4 =Z4*8>@e.1:5Cb81=Z,5476 Éh@89ÈM@D@e4ÆV2 G 6>,/0A.;C@B6¢:<47P 47@89ÈM,/.1K:<.1@Q81Ì*0U6·:Ë/,5=?PA@ePgX V+-G =[6¢4A,/8M:È^:<.1@M,/×F:<4Ç47@89ÈM,/.1K CD,/4AÊ5@e6w8>=?,/4FE:<4UP 8>ÌA=[6MÊ/=?Ë/@B6·076·8>Ì7@ C;ÌA,5=?CD@V,/×¥PH,/=?4AÊ @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816 ÈQÌA@e.>@V8>ÌA@-×Ñ,HC076M=[6 ,54)8>Ì7@ 47@89ÈM,/.1KR,54ANZÇ5XWÆ^ÌA@ 6w,/×Ú89ÈM:/.>@¤CD,/476>=[698;6V,/× :CDNZ=?@D4*8m:<47P#:6>@D.1Ë/@D.-.>074A4A=?4AÊR,54389ÈM,RPH = h@e.>@e4*8 Ì7,56w816eE·ÈQÌA=[C;Ì:<.1@L6>@DT7:/.1:<8>@BPÝÉÇ :40AÔ¤Éh@D.),/× .1,/0H81@D.;6DX¡GI:<.1@81,81.1:<Ù)CLÔ ,HPH@DN[6):<.1@L076w@BP 81,RÊ5@D4A@e.1:<8>@6w@eN|×ÚÎ6w=?Ô =ZN[:<.-8>.;:JÙC=Z48>ÌA@N?=Z4AKX M,/8>ÌTU:/C;K/@D8-=?4*8>@D.>Î:<.1.>=?ËJ:<NF81=ZÔ @B6 :/47PÐTU:/C;K/@D8 6>=?ÕD@e6Q:/.>@%Ô):J8;C;ÌA=?4AÊ .>@B:<Nh8>.;:JÙC Ô ,PA@DN[6DX¢O³T7:56>6>=?Ë/@ Ô@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*86wÇH6w8>@eÔ =?6^0U6w@BP×Ñ,5.PA:J8;: CD,/N?NZ@BCb81=Z,548>ÌU:J8Q=?6^ÉU:/6>@eP,54076>=?4AÊ)6w@eË/@D.;:<N6>,<ÎCD:<N?N?@eP 3@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8 GS,5=Z4*816mÏ 3G·6;Ó EH@B:/C;Ì ,/×¥81ÌA@DÔ @eØ*0A=?TATh@ePLÈQ=|81Ì3+O Ô ,54A=|81,/.1=Z47ÊCe:<.;PA6 X Æ¥,Ý@B6981=ZÔ):J81@Ð81ÌA@PA@DN[:Ç 81Ì7:J8:ÝT7:5C;K/@8R @ HTU@e.>=?@D4UC@e6,/4A@#4A@D@BPA68>, U.16w8=[PH@D4*8>=Z×ÑÇ 8>Ì7@ TU:/C;K/@D816I:568>ÌA@eǤT7:56>681ÌA@ 3G·6¢,/48>ÌA@e=Z.·ÈM:Çm81ÌA.1,/0AÊ5̤81ÌA@Q.>,50H8>@e.16eX¥Ö-:/6>ÌA=?4AÊm=?6S0U6w@BP¤×Ñ,5.I8>Ì7@ %'&( )+*. &) 2. . . .
(9) . .
(10) =[PH@e4581=hCD:J81=Z,54L:/47PRÔ :<81C;ÌA=?4AÊ,<×T7:/C;K5@816eXIÆ^ÌA@%Ì7:/6>ÌA=?4AÊ×Ñ0A47Cb81=Z,54=?6^=?Ô TANZ@eÔ @D4*8>@BPÈQ=Z8>ÌL8>Ì7@ Ü ÖVOQÎ Ü @eC07.>@¤Ö-:/6>ÌON?Ê/,5.>=Z8>Ì7Ô BÒ uX-OVNZNICe:<TH810A.>@BPT7:/C;K5@8;6V:<.1@WÔ):/6>K/@BPLÉU@D×Ñ,/.1@¤Ì7:56wÌA=?4AÊUX Æ^Ì7@)=?PH@e4*8> = UCD:<8>=?,/4:<47PÔ):J8;C;ÌA=?4AÊÐ6w,/×Ú89ÈM:/.>@TA.1,JË=?PH@B6 8>=?Ô @e6w81:<Ô Tá.1@e:/PA=Z4AÊ*6 ×Ñ,/.m@eË/@D.1Ç389ÈM, :5P w:/CD@D4*8 3G·6eX. .
(11) . =?Ê/0A.1 @ M6wÌA,JÈ6g8>ÌA@ Ô@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8¥6>@810ATW076>@eP%×Ñ,5.y,50A.y@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*816eX¥Æ^ÌA@ K/@DÇ%C,5Ô TU,54A@D4*8y=?4 81ÌA@^6wÇH6w8>@DÔ«=[6F81ÌA@ ÐGEB81ÌA@ PH@eË=?CD@¢8>ÌU:J8PA,*@B6F81ÌA@^:/Cb8107:<N5T7:/C;K5@8¥Ce:<TH810A.1=Z4AÊUX¥Æ^ÌA@MCD:/T7:<ÉA=?N?=|81=Z@B6 ,/×S:/4 ÐG :/.>@%PH@BC=[PH@ePLÉÇ)8>Ì7@WCD:<TA8>0A.1@%Ì7:<.;PHÈ^:<.1@8>ÌU:J8=[6Q=Z4U698;:<N?NZ@BP=?4L8>ÌA@ 3GSE7:/47PR=Z4,/07. @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816^ÈM@-0U6w@ 8>Ì7@W+O 7X ¨4A@D89È ,5.>K)Ô ,54A=|81,/.1=Z47ÊCe:<.;P 8 X¢Æ^Ì7@ 3G·6Q:<.1@%CD:<TU:<ÉAN?@ ,/× CD,/N?NZ@BCb8>=?4AÊ:<4UPÝ81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô TA=Z47Êá×Ñ.1:/Ô@B6ÈQ=|81Ì :/4¡:5CDCD0A.1:5CÇ,/×-N?@e6168>Ì7:/4 #476DX + :J8;: :/47:<N?ÇH6w=[6M=?6TU@e.w×Ñ,5.>Ô @ePR, hÎuNZ=?4A@/X. . L1 wiretap. A. DAG3.5E. L2. L3 DAG3.5E. DAG3.5E. R1. R3. R2. E. DAG3.5E wiretap. MP03. MP04. MP05. B. MP06. C. D. =?Ê/0A.1@ 7 3@e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*8Q6>@810AT Æ^Ì7@W6wÇH6w8>@DÔ C,/N?N?@eCb8;6:<4UP81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô T76^8>.;:/CD@e6QCD,/476>=?6w8>=?4AÊ ,<×8>Ì7@ 7.16w8+ÉÇ*8>@B6Q,<×S@DË5@D.1Ç ×Ñ.;:<Ô @VCe:<TH810A.1@eP ,/46I8>ÌA@e.>47@8 N?=?4AKH6V9Ï ^:/6>@ÎÆÓbX5Æ^ÌA+@ I81ÌA@D.14A@D8eE*ÍG¨:<4UP8>.;:<476>TU,5.w8¢Ì7@e:/PA@D.;6 :/.>@ 81Ì076¤CD,/N?NZ@BCb8>@BPá:/6mÈM@DN?N·:/6WT7:<.>8¤,<×M8>Ì7@T7:ÇNZ,*:/PgXRGI:/C;K/@D816W6>Ô):<N?NZ@e.%8>Ì7:/4 ÉÇ*8>@B6W:<.1@ Õe@D.1,<ÎuT7:/P7PH@ePgXÆ^ÌA@VCDNZ,HC;KH6I,<×81ÌA@-+O «Ce:<.;PA6DE5ÈQÌA=[C;Ì)Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>@^81ÌA@Q81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô T76DE:<.1@QN?,Ce:<N?NZÇ 6>Ç47C;ÌA.1,/4A=[6>@eP¨=Z4 81ÌA@6>@D476>@8>Ì7:<8R:<N?NVCDNZ,HC;KH6:<.1@36wÇ47C;Ì7.>,54A=?6>@eP 8>, ,/4A@ 3G 6R+O CN?,C;K ÈQÌ7=?C;ÌFE=?4810A.>4yE*=[6^6wÇ47C;Ì7.>,54A=?6>@eP81,:YVÆ^G 6w@e.>Ë5@D.BX¥O ÌA=?Ê/ÌR:5CDCD0A.1:5CÇ,<×g81ÌA@ 8>=?Ô@B698;:<Ô T76 =?6 81Ì076·,5ÉH81:/=Z47@ePϯNZ@B6>6·8>ÌU:<4 m476;ÓbEH:56 CD,/Ô T7:<.1@eP ÈQ=Z8>Ì8>ÌA@%C,5Ô TA0H8>@e.·81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô T76 ,<×y:<Éh,/0A8 6eXÆ^Ì7=?6, @D.;6¥8>ÌA@^:/PAË:/4*81:<Ê5@·,/×Aׯ:<=?.>N?Çm:/CeC0A.;:J81@ PH@eN?:ÇmÔ @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*816y8>Ì7:<8S:/.>@M6w0A=Z81:/ÉAN?@ ×Ñ,5.Qµ,/0A.Q@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816eX Æ^Ì7@¤4A@D89È ,5.>KH6^81Ì7:J8%È @:<.1@WÔ @e:/6>0A.1=Z47Ê:<.1@ 8 3ÉAT76-×Ñ0AN?NPA0ATAN? @ I81ÌA@D.14A@8;6DXWß-4Ð: ÐÉAT76 ¢8>ÌA@e.>4A@D8W8>Ì7@)Ô : H=ZÔ0AÔ ×Ñ.;:<Ô @).;:J8>@)=[6 8 !" ¤×Ñ.;:<Ô @B$6 #<6DEy:/47P8>Ì7=?6m@BØ*07:<N[6W:L×Ñ.;:<Ô @ =?4*8>@e.wÎ:<.1.>=?ËJ:<NQ81=ZÔ @,</× XÒ µ6eX Æ^ÌA=[68>=?Ô@=[6L6>=?Ê/4A = UCD:/4*8>N?ǨN[:<.1Ê/@e.8>ÌU:<481ÌA@81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô T :5CDCD0A.1:5CÇ),/×y8>Ì7@ 3GSX Æ^Ì7@ .1,/0A8>@D.;6MÞ /EAÞVÒ:<4UPRÞ :/.>@%:<N?N,<×y81ÌA@m6>:/Ô @-89ÇTh@)Ï 2 =[6>CD , 5Ò *ÓbXSÆ^ÌA@m6w,50A.;C@ ÌA,56w8 O¤EJ8>Ì7@V6w=?4AKÌA,56w8 Ý:<47P8>Ì7@QÌA,56w816S81Ì7:J8¢Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@QC.1,5616¥8>.;:JÙC E*2-E5:/47P+ :<.1@Q:<N?NA=?PA@D4*8>=[CD:/N ÈQ=Z8>Ì.1@DÊ*:<.;PA6 8>, Ì7:<.;PHÈ^:<.1@-:/47P6w,/×Ú89ÈM:/.>@%C,54 7Ê/07.1:<8>=?,/4FX . . . &%. '( *),+.-/ *0213. . . Æ^Ì7@Ð,/4É 9@BCb81=ZË5@L=[6)81,Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81@P7:J81::<88>Ì7@:<TAT7NZ=[CD:<8>=?,/4 N?:Ç5@D. ÈQÌA=?NZ@076w=?4AÊ -+VG :56 8>Ì7@ 81.1:/476>TU,5.w8TA.>,/8>,HC,5NX¥+-:<81:N?@D47Ê<8>ÌU6:/.>@ 6w@eNZ@BCb8>@BPm×Ñ.1,/Ô :Q81.>0747CD:<8>@eP¤GI:<.1@8>,-PH=?6w8>.1=?ÉA0H8>=?,/4ÈQ=|81Ì.
(12) TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6I8>ÌU:J8^Ô :<81C;Ì)81.1:<ÙCÔ ,HPH@DN[6M,/É76>@D.1Ë/@BP =Z4R.>@B:<Nh4A@89ÈM,/.1KH6DXÆy.10A47Ce:J8>=?,/4=?6^PH,54A@V=?4 6>07C;Ì:VÈ^:Ç 8>Ì7:<8¥81ÌA@^Ô : H=ZÔ0AÔ :<N?NZ,JÈM@ePmÍGT7:ÇN?,5:/P%=[6S4A,/8Ë=?,/N[:J8>@BPgE=X @/X?E ^ÉÇ*8>@e6eX¥Æ^Ì7@ =?4*8>@e.wÎuT7:/C;K5@8%8>=?Ô @e6:<.1@6w@eNZ@BCb8>@BP×Ñ.>,5Ô :/4@ HTU,54A@D4*8>=[:<NMPH=[6981.>=?ÉA0H81=Z,54F# X 70A.>8>ÌA@e.>Ô ,/.1@/ES6>=Z47CD@ 81ÌA@ÐßQà ÆQÆ @B6981=ZÔ):J81=Z,54 6>,<×Ú89È^:<.1@076>@e6T7:<.>816,<×81ÌA@LÍGT7:ÇN?,5:/P U@DN[Pá×Ñ,/.=?PA@D4*8> = UCD:<8>=?,/4FE : 6wTh@eCD= UC#PA:J8;:Ý6w8>.107Cb810A.>@3=[6R076w@BP¡8>, CD.>@B:J81@Ð0A4A=[Ø*0A@T7:ÇN?,5:5PA6×Ñ,/.8>ÌA@#Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>@BP V+-G TU:/C;K/@D816eX ·:/C;̨T7:ÇNZ,*:/PÝCD,/4*81:/=Z476:#T7:/C;K5@8=[PH@e4581= hCD:J81=Z,54 40AÔÉU@e.eE·:Ð8>=?Ô @e6w81:<Ô T :<47P¨: É7NZ,HC;K ,<פO Ü 2 ÍwÍP7:J81:7X MÇ 076>=Z47ÊÝ8>Ì7=?66>TU@BC = UCPA:<81:¨6981.>07C8>0A.1@#:/47P 81ÌA@#È^:Ǩ8>ÌA @ ×Ñ0747Cb81=Z,54L=[6Q=?Ô TANZ@eÔ @D4*8>@BPgEA,/47@%Ce:<4L@e:56w=?NZÇ8>.;:<476>Ô =|8QT7:ÇN?,5:/P76 ÈQ=Z8>Ì3PH = @D.1@D4*8V6w=?ÕD@B6^ÈQ=|81Ì4A, 47@D@ePR81,Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@ 4A@DȳPA:<81:AX Æ¥ÈM,LÊ5@D4A@e.1:<8>,5.16 :<.1@ 076w@BPÐ×Ñ,5.%8>ÌA@8>.;:JÙCÊ/@D47@D.;:J8>=?,/4yXÆ^ÌA@ U.16w8WÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81,/. =?6m0U6w@BPÐ81, @eÔ¤0AN[:J81@V:W6>=Z47Ê/N?@Q8>.;:JÙC6>,/0A.;C@VÈQÌA=ZN?@Q81ÌA@-6>@eCD,/47P):/=ZÔ)6·:<8 @eÔ¤0AN[:J81=Z4AÊ:<4:<.1ÉA=Z8>.;:<.1Ǥ40AÔÉU@e. ,/×y81.1:<Ù)C%6>,/0A.;C@B6DX 70A.w81ÌA@D.BE8>Ì7@mÊ/@D47@D.;:J8>=?4AÊ 6w,/×Ú89ÈM:/.>@-Ì7:/6M81ÌA.1@D@m,/Th@D.;:J81=Z47ÊÔ ,HPH@e86 7
(13) E :/47 P uXLÍ4á81ÌA @
(14) WÔ ,HPH@/E¥8>Ì7@6w,/×Ú89ÈM:/.>@ Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@e6¤# : H@ePá40AÔ¤Éh@D.¤,<× TU:/C;K/@D816¢:/47P8>@e.>Ô =?47:J81@e6eX¥Í48>ÌA @ VÔ ,HPH@5E/81ÌA@Q8>.;:JÙCQ=[6¢Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BP,JË5@D.¢: U4A=|81@-:/Ô,50A4*8 ,/×¥81=ZÔ @5X =?47:<N?NZÇ5E7=?48>ÌA@ !"#WÔ ,PA@m8>ÌA@%81.1:<ÙC%Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>=?,/4R8>@e.>Ô =?47:J81@e6QÈQÌ7@D4#2MÆQ%Þ $FÎ92 =[6^TA.1@e616w@BPgXÍ4L:5PAPH=Z8>=?,/4R8>,8>ÌA@m,5TU@e.1:<8>=?4AÊ¤Ô ,HPH@e6eE8>Ì7@%6>,<×Ú89È^:<.1@-:/N?6>, C,/4U6w=[PH@D.;6 T7:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6 81Ì7:J8)PH@D8>@D.1Ô =Z47@8>.;:JÙCC;ÌU:<.;:/Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6W=Z4¨NZ=?4AKEI@/X Ê7X?ES8>ÌA@RNZ=?4AK0H81=ZN?=?Õe:J81=Z,54 :<4UPá8>ÌA@LÖ0A.;6w8 TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.BX Æ^Ì7@·81.1:<Ù)C Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81@eP¤ÉU@D89È @e@D4W81ÌA@Q6w,50A.;C@^O¡:/47Pm81ÌA@Q6w=?4AK #×Ñ,/N?N?,JÈ6:-GI:<.1@81, PH=[6w8>.1=ZÉA0AÎ 81=Z,54×Ñ,/.S8>Ì7@QT7:/C;K5@8INZ@e4AÊ<81ÌÈQ=Z8>Ì 81ÌA@6>Ì7:<Th@^T7:<.;:<Ô @81@D. α ϯÈQÌA=[C;ÌPH@D8>@e.>Ô =?4A@e6S81ÌA@QÔ @e:/4:/47P 81ÌA@ËJ:/.>=[:<47CD@BÓ%:/47P8>ÌA@RNZ,HCe:J8>=?,/4TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D. β ϯÈQÌA=[C;ÌÝPH@81@D.1Ô=?4A@B6m8>Ì7@Ô =Z47=ZÔ0AÔË:/NZ07@BÓbX OV4 @ HTh,/4A@e4581=?:/N¢PH=[6981.>=?ÉA0H81=Z,54ÈQ=Z8>ÌTU:<.;:<Ô @81@D. λ =[6m076>@eP×Ñ,5.m=Z4*8>@e.wÎuT7:5C;K/@8%81=ZÔ @e6¤:<47P#8>Ì7@ Ï¯Ô @e:/6>0A.1@eP7Ó-N?=Z47K0H81=ZN?=ZÕB:J81=Z,54 PA@DTh@D47PA6W,/4 :/6%ÈM@DN?N¢:/6 :/47P XÆ^ÌA=[6%Ô ,PA@DN¢Ô):J8;C;ÌA@e6 81.1:<ÙCmÔ ,PA@DN[6,/ÉU6w@e.>Ë5@ePR×Ñ,/.V8>ρÌA@à#,5.>N[Pà=?PAλ@¤à@DÉFEÈQÌA=[C;Ì3α =?6-,/47@Wβ ,<×S8>Ì7@¤Ô ,56w8-=?Ô TU,5.w8;:<4*8 CD,/4*8>.1=?ÉA0H8>,5.16M81, 8>ÌA@%81.1:<ÙC%=Z4Í4*8>@e.>4A@D8 XMÖ=?Ê/ÌL8>.;:JÙC =?4581@D476>=Z8>=?@e6:/.>@WCD,/476>=?PA@D.1@ePR=Z4,/07. @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816:56 È @eNZN EMÈQ=|81Ì 8>ÌA@ÐCD,/476>@eØ*0A@e47C@,<×%ÌA=?Ê/ÌA@e.)NZ,*:/PA6 ,54 .>,50H8>@e.16eE :/47P¨8>Ì076)ÈM@ ,5ÉH81:/=Z4LÉh@8w81@D.VPA@DN[:ÇÔ ,PA@DN[6DX Æ^Ì7@C.1,5616V81.1:<ÙCÊ5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BPÉÇÐ81ÌA@ 8>.;:JÙCÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81,/.;6 -ES2-Ey+¹Ì7:56W:R×Ñ,/.1Ô 8>ÌU:J8¤:<TAÎ T7.>,*:/C;ÌA@B6×Ñ.;:/C8>=?,/47:/N .1,JÈQ4A=[:<4 Ô,/8>=?,/4 ÏÚ× MÔÓR8>.;:JÙCÈQ=|81Ì 6w@eN|×ÚÎ6w=?Ô =ZN[:<.ÐC;ÌU:<.;:/Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6eE ÈQÌ7=?C;ÌL=?6M89ÇTA=[CD:/N×Ñ,/. I81ÌA@D.14A@8 uX¢Æ^ÌA=[6M8>.;:JÙC =?6^Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@eP=Z4: 6w=?Ô =ZN[:<.^È^:Ç/E= X @5XZEHGI:<.1@81, PA=?6w8>.1=ZÉ70H8>=?,/4#×Ñ,/.%T7:5C;K/@8%6w=?ÕD@B6%:<47P# @ HTh,/4A@e4581=?:/NIPH=?6w8>.1=?ÉA0H8>=?,/4×Ñ,/.%=?4581@D.>Î TU:/C;K/@D8V81=ZÔ @e6eXÆ^Ì7@ PA= @D.1@D47CD@VÌA,JÈM@DË5@D. =?6·8>Ì7:<8^:¤N?:/.>Ê5@40AÔ¤Éh@D.M,<×FT7.>,HC@B6>6>@e6 :<.1@V076>@eP=Z48>ÌA=[6^CD:/6>@Q81,Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@ : N[:<.1Ê/@ 4*07Ô¤Éh@D.S,<×hGS:/.>@D8>,-8>.;:JÙC·Û7,JÈ6=Z4@DË5@D.1Ç%8>.;:JÙC·Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>,5.eXyÆ^Ì7=?6SÊ5=ZË5@e6¥0768>ÌA@QC;ÌA,5=?CD@ ,/×¥PH,5=Z4AÊ @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6·ÈQÌA@e.>@-È @ CD:/4C,54581.>,5NhPA=ZË5@D.;6w@TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6¢,<×g81ÌA@-8>.;:JÙCÔ = *810A.1@-=?4 81ÌA@mN?=Z4AKEA@B6wTh@eCD=?:/NZN?Ç)81ÌA@WÖ0A.;6w8^TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D. H :<47P8>ÌA@mN?=?4AK0H81=ZN?=?Õe:J81=Z,54 ρ X. . . . &. . . & + '3 )( *0+. + *021. O Ô @e:/4A=Z47Ê<×Ñ0AN:<47:/NZÇH6>=?6·,<×¥PA@DN[:ÇÔ @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*816¢.1@eØ*0A=?.1@e6¢=[PH@e4581= hCD:J81=Z,54,/×FT7:/C;K5@816·TA.1@e6>@D4*8 5, 4Ô¤0ANZ8>=?TAN?@m8>.;:JÙC-8>.;:/CD@e6eX·ÖV:56wÌA=?4AÊ)=[6Q076>@ePR8>,)074A=?Ø*0A@eNZÇR.>@eTA.1@e6>@D4*8Q@e:/C;Ì3Ce:<TH810A.>@BPTU:/C;K/@D8 ×Ñ.1,/Ô 8>ÌA@m81.1:<ÙCV81.1:5C@B6DX M@×Ñ,5.>@%Ì7:56wÌA=?4AÊUEH@e:/C;ÌLT7:5C;K/@8^=[6QÉA=Z8wÎuÔ :56wK5@ePÏÑÉA=Z89ÈQ=[6w@WO-YV+%Ó^ÈQ=|81Ì :Ô):/6>KTA.1@DË=?,/076>N?ÇPH@ 747@eP X O-6W:<4áÍG T7:5C;K/@D8 81.1:Ë5@DN[6-8>ÌA.1,/0AÊ5Ì8>ÌA@.1,/0A8>@D.;6-8>ÌA@T7:ÇNZ,*:/P#.>@eÔ :/=Z4U6%0A47C;Ì7:/4AÊ/@BP#:/47P 6>,/Ô +@ 7@DN[PA6 =Z48>ÌA@-ÍG ÌA@B:/PH@e. ϯ=X @/X?EHÆQ,Æ $¢EÖ@e:5PH@D.2 ÌA@BC;K6>0AÔÓ¢:/.>@-C;Ì7:<4AÊ5@ePgXSÆ^ÌA@e.>@D×Ñ,/.1@/E*É*Ç Ô):56wK=?4AÊ 8>ÌA@B6w@ U@DN[PA6¢:mC,5.>.1@eC8¢:<47P 0A47=?Ø*0A@Q=[PH@D4*81= UCe:J81=Z,54,/×g@e:/C;ÌT7:5C;K/@8·Ce:<4 Éh@,/ÉH8;:<=?4A@ePFX 70A.>8>ÌA@e.>Ô ,/.1@/E<:56S,/4AN?ÇW0A4UC,/.1.10ATH8>@BPWÍGáT7:5C;K/@8;6SCD:<.1.1Ç*=?4AÊ V+-GT7:ÇNZ,*:/P¤:/.>@MTA.1,HC@e616>@ePgE<:/4*Ç. . .
(15) . ,/8>ÌA@e.·81.1:<ÙCQ8>ÌU:J8^Ô :Ç):/TATU@B:<. =Z4L:¤C,5NZN?@eC8>@BP 8>.;:JÙCQ81.1:5C@ÏÑ@/X Ê7X?EHOVÞQGSEÍ>2 3GSEHÖ$ $ß%Ó·=?6 PA=?61CD:/.1PH@BPgX Æ^Ì7@ Ü ÖVOQÎ QÌ7:56wÌA=?4AÊm:<N?Ê/,5.>=Z8>Ì7Ô =?6¢076w@BPW81,WC,5.>.1@eC8>N?Çm=?PH@e4*8>=Z×ÑǤ8;:<.1Ê/@8ST7:5C;K/@8;6S=Z481ÌA@QNZ=?4AK 81.1:<ÙC<X Ü ÖVOÎ ^=[6I: CD.>ÇTH81,/Ê5.1:/TAÌA=[C¢,/47@ÎuÈM:Ç%Ì7:56wÌ×Ñ0A47C8>=?,/4 ÈQ=|81Ì:/4,50H8>T70H8·6w=?ÕD@^,/×Ò ÉÇ*8>@B6 BÒ X Íu8%:5CDCD@DTH8;6-:56=?4ATA0H8m:Ô @e6161:<Ê/@¤,<×¢N?@D4AÊ/8>Ì ÏÑ,<× Ô : H=ZÔ0AÔ 64 ÉA=Z816;ÓV:/47P3,50H8>TA0A816%: <Î ÉA=Z8 Ô @B6>61:<Ê5@VPH=?Ê/@e6w8eXIÆ^ÌA@ Ü Ö-OQÎ :/NZÊ5,/.1=|81ÌAÔ LTA.>,JË=[PH@e6M:WË5@D.1Ç NZ2,JÈ CD,/N?NZ=[6w=?,/4TA.>,5É7:<É7=ZN?=|89Ç :56M=|8^81:/K/@B6 64 :<8w8>@eÔ TH816M81/, U47P89ÈM,Ô@B6>61:<Ê5@e6 ÈQ=|81ÌL8>ÌA@m61:<Ô @-ÌU:/6>ÌËJ:<N?0A@/EHT7.>,JË=[PH@eP8>Ì7:<8 81ÌA@¤ÌU:/6>ÌA@eP32=Z8>@eÔ)6-:/.>@W=?47PH@eTU@e47PH@e458m:<4UP@eØ*07:<N?N?ÇLN?=?K/@DN?Ç/X-ÖV:/6>ÌA=?4AÊÌ7:56-:/N?6>,)81ÌA@:5PHËJ:<4*81:/Ê/@ 81Ì7:J8W=Z8W=?47C.1@e:56w@B6V81ÌA@C,5Ô TA0H81:<8>=?,/47:/NI6wTh@D@BP:56%,/4AN?Ç#Ò RÉÇ*8>@B6)ÏÑÌ7:56wÌËJ:<N?0A@BÓ%:/.>@ C;ÌA@BC;K/@ePFE CD,/Ô T7:/.>@BPL8>,81ÌA@ )ÉÇ*8>@B6V.1@DTA.1@e6>@D4*81=Z4AÊ8>ÌA@8>,/81:<NN?@D4AÊ/8>ÌÐ,/×¢@e:/C;Ì#CD:<TA8>0A.1@ePT7:5C;K/@D8eX-Æ^Ì7@ 0U6w@-,<×yÉh,<81ÌÔ):/6>K*=?4AÊ:<47P)ÌU:/6>ÌA=Z47ʤ@D4U6w0A.1@e6 6w,¤8>Ì7:<8M@eË/@e.>ÇT7:/C;K5@8·=[6 0A4A=[Ø507@DN?Ç)=?PH@e4*8> = 7@ePÉ*Ç 81ÌA@mÌ7:56wÌLËJ:<N?0A@/X Æ^Ì7@)T7:/C;K5@816%:/.>@)6>@eØ*0A@D4*81=?:/NZN?ÇÐ.1@e:/P×Ñ.1,/Ô 81ÌA@)8>.;:/CD @ 7NZ@5E¥CD,/TA=?@eP=?4581,3:T7:/C;K5@8mË/@BCb8>,5. :/47P 81ÌA@D4RÌ7:/6>ÌA@ePFXÆ^ÌA@ Ü Ö-OQÎ VÌ7:56wÌ)ËJ:<N?0A@-=?6M6981,/.1@eP)=?4*8>,:mÌ7:/6>ÌË5@eCb81,/.·8>,/Ê5@81ÌA@D. ÈQ=|81Ì8>Ì7@ 074A=?Ø*0A@M=[PH@D4*8> = UCe:J8>=?,/4,<×h@e:/C;̤T7:/C;K5@8eEJ= X @/X?E8>ÌA@^=?47PH @ W=?48>ÌA@MT7:/C;K5@8Ë/@eC8>,5.eXÆ^ÌA@·81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô T U@DN[P%=?6gÔ):56wK5@eP =Z4%81ÌA@S×Ñ.;:<Ô @¢ÌA@B:/PH@e.gÉU@BCD:<0U6w@I=Z8¥C;Ì7:/4AÊ/@B6g:J8y@eË/@D.1Ç 3GSXBÆ^ÌA@¢Ô):/6>K=Z4AÊ^@e476w07.>@B6 81Ì7:J8 ,/4AN?! Ç ÉÇ*8>@B6V:<.1@WÌ7:56wÌ7@ePgEh698;:<.>8>=?4AÊ)×Ñ.1,/Ô 8>ÌA@ÍG ÌA@e:5PH@D.BXÆ^ÌA@Ì7:/6>ÌÐC,JË5@D.;6Q6w@eNZ@BCb8>@BP U@DN[PA6W=?48>ÌA@ÍG Ì7@e:/PA@D.W=?47CN?07PH=?4AÊ381ÌA@6>,/0A.;C@):/47PáPH@e6w8>=?47:J81=Z,54ÍG :/PAPA.>@B6>6>@e6eEFÍG ÌA@B:/PH@e. Í9PA@D4*8> = UCD:<8>=?,/4 7@DN[P :<47P¨,<81ÌA@D. U@DN[PA6ÐÏÑ=?47CDNZ07PA=Z4AÊáTh,5616w=?ÉAN?@3ÍG ,/TH81=Z,54761ÓXÆ^ÌA@,/4AN?Ç 7@eN?PA6 =?4¨8>ÌA@ÍG ÌA@e:5PH@D.8>ÌU:J8:<.1@R47,<8 Ì7:/6>ÌA@eP¡:<.1@81ÌA@3Æ^=ZÔ @DÎuÆ¥,<Î $F=?Ë/@ϯÆQ,Æ $¥Ó:/47PÝ81ÌA@3Ö@B:/PH@e. 2 Ì7@eC;KH6w07Ô 7@eN?PA6eEQ:/6 81ÌA@DÇ¡:<.1@3C;Ì7:<4AÊ5@eP :J8@eË/@e.>ÇÝ.1,/0A8>@D.BX ÐÉÇ*8>@B6),<× 8>Ì7@ÐÍG¹T7:ÇNZ,*:/P ϯ=Z4UCN?07PH=?4AÊáÍG,/TA8>=?,/476 :<4UPÝ@DË5@D4*8>0U:<NMT7:/PAPA=Z4AÊÓ:<.1@=?47CN?07PH@BPÝ=?4 81ÌA@RÌU:/6>̨:/6ÈM@DN?NXÝÆ^Ì7@ ÌU:/6>ÌË/@BCb8>,5.·=[6 6>,/.>8>@BPÐÏÑÉU:/6>@eP)0ATh,/48>ÌA@ Ì7:/6>ÌËJ:<N?0A@B61Ó¢ÉU@D×Ñ,/.1@VT7:5C;K/@8MÔ):J81C;Ì7=Z4AÊUE5=?4,5.1PH@e.¢81, =?Ô TA.1,JË/@-8>ÌA@WCD,/Ô TA0H8;:J8>=?,/4U:<NgTh@D.>×Ñ,/.1Ô :/47C@ uX.
(16) . . 13 +
(17). 1 1
(18). O«40AÔÉU@e.Q,<×¥TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.;6 :/.>@-076w@BP=?4R8>ÌA@ßà ÆQÆ :<4U:<N?Ç6>=[6DEÈQÌA=[C;ÌR:/.>@-8>ÌA@ 81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô TA=Z47Ê =?4H×Ñ,5.>Ô):J81=Z,54 Ti ×Ñ,5.V: Ê/=?Ë/@e4RTU:/C;K/@D8eEH81ÌA@mTAN[:/CD@%×Ñ,/.Q81=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô TA=Z47ÊÐÏÑ= X @5XZE78>ÌA@W+O =?4*8>@D.>ׯ:/CD@ ,54ÐÈQÌA=[C;Ì38>Ì7@T7:5C;K/@D8VÈM:56VCe:<TH810A.>@BP7Ó:/47P81ÌA@6>=ZÕe@¤,/×I8>ÌA@T7:/C;K5@8VTU:Ç*N?,5:5PgX+7,/.-:R6wTh@eCD=hC TU:/C;K/@D8 EB8>ÌA@QßQà ÆQÆ=[6F@e6w8>=?Ô):J81@eP%ÉÇV8;:<K=?4AÊQ8>Ì7@¢8>=?Ô @·PH= h@e.>@e47C@ ÉU@D89È @e@D4%89ÈM,C,5476w@BC0H81=ZË5@ 81=ZÔ @B698;:<nÔ T76Q.1@e:5PH=Z47Ê586 7 Ï * Ó OW T Ti,j (n) = Ti (n) − Tj (n) =[6V8>ÌA@@e6w8>=?Ô :<8>@BP3,/4A@DÎ È^:Ç81.1:/476>=|881=ZÔ @ÉU@D89È @e@D4ÐTh,/=?4*816 i :/47P j ×Ñ,/.V8>ÌA@ OW T Ti,j (n) U T / : ; C / K D @ e 8 E .1@DTA.1@e6>@D4*8;6 8>ÌA@)81=ZÔ @B698;:<Ô T.>@B:/PH=?4AÊL81:/K/@e4á:<8W8>Ì7@Ô @e:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8mTh,/=?458 nth :i /47P Tj (n) T=[i6¤(n)81ÌA@R8>=?Ô@B698;:<Ô T¡.>@B:/PH=?4AÊÐ8;:<K5@D4 :<881ÌA@RÔ @B:/6>0A.>@eÔ @D4*8Th,/=?4*8 j XÝOQCeC0A.;:J81@ 61:<Ô TAN?@e6^,/×y81ÌA@ Ti (n) :/47P Tj (n) :<.1@-.1@eØ*0A@B6981@eP×Ñ,/.: C,5.>.1@eC8M@B6981=ZÔ):<8>=?,/4,<×¢ßQà ÆQÆ%X Æ^Ì7@D.1@:/.>@6>@DË/@e.1:/NQ6w,50A.1CD@e6 ,/×-@D.1.1,/.;6¤81Ì7:J8:/.>@LTh,5616w=?ÉAN?@3=Z4 ßà ÆQÆ @e6w8>=?Ô):J81=Z,54FX A,5. =?476w81:/47C@5Eg,/4A@,<× 8>ÌA@ Ô ,56w8%CD,/Ô Ô ,/46w,50A.1CD@e6-,<×·@e.>.1,/. =?4,/ÉA81:<=?4A=?4AÊ:/CDCD0A.;:J8>@¤8>=?Ô @e6w81:<Ô T76 :/.>@81ÌA@TA.1@e6>@D47CD@ ,<×QPH0ATAN?=?Ce:J81@)T7:/C;K5@816%=?4á8>Ì7@ 8>.;:JÙC8>.;:/CD@e6 8H
(19) E 4 uX A,5.m8>Ì7@PH0ATAN?=?Ce:J81@ TU:/C;K/@D816eE5:/NZN mÉÇ*8>@e6·Ì7:/6>ÌA@BP):<.1@Q=?PH@e4*8>=[CD:<NUÊ/=?Ë=Z4AÊ%81Ì076¢81ÌA@V61:<Ô @ Ü Ö-OQÎ VPH=?Ê/@B698BX Ü =Z47CD@Q8>Ì7@ Ô @B:/6>0A.>@eÔ @D4*8¢ @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6¢:<.1@QPH,/4A@Q=?4:m6w8>.1=?C8>N?ÇC,54*8>.1,/N?NZ@BP¤@e4*Ë=?.>,54AÔ @D4*8I8>Ì7@QTA.>,5É7:<É7=ZN?=|89Ç ,/×MPH07TANZ=[CD:<8>@ ,HCDCD0A.>.1@D4UC@=?6%@ *81.>@eÔ @DN?ÇÐNZ,JÈmXÍ4#ׯ:/Cb8BEF4A,3PH0AT7NZ=[CD:<8>@ ÍG³T7:/C;K5@816 Ì7:Ë5@Éh@D@e4 ,5É76>@D.1Ë/@eP=Z4,50A.Q @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6 uX.
(20) OV4A,<81ÌA@D.6>,/07.1CD@-,/×¥@D.1.1,/.;6·=[6^Ê/=?Ë/@e4RÉÇTh,5616w=?ÉAN?@-T7.>@B6w@e47C@%,<×0A4AÔ):J8;C;ÌA@ePRT7:5C;K/@8;6M=Z4L8>Ì7@ DC ,/N?NZ@BCb81@eP)81.1:<ÙC81.1:5C@e6eX 4AÔ):J8;C;ÌA@ePRT7:5C;K/@8;6·Ô):Ç ,HCDCD0A.^ÉU@BCD:<0U6w@ ,<×¥6>@DË5@D.;:<Nh.>@B:/6>,/476eE*@/X Ê7X?E N?,HCD:/NC.1,5616W81.1:<Ù)C:<8 ¢8>ÌA@e.>4A@D8Ì0AÉ76eE·T7:5C;K/@8;6 6w@e458 81,7EM,/. ,/.1=ZÊ5=Z4U:J8>=?4AÊ×Ñ.>,5Ô ,/4A@,/×V8>Ì7@ ÍG :/P7PH.>@B6>6>@e6,<×-.>,50H8>@e.16eE¢,/.×Ñ.;:<Ê/Ô @e458;:J81=Z,54Ý.>@BØ*0A=Z.1@eP =Z4¡:.>,50H8>@e.¤×Ñ,5. :/4 ,50H8>Ê5,/=?4AÊN?=Z47KhX à@Ì7:Ë5@ ,/É76>@D.1Ë/@BP#:Ë5@D.1ÇÐNZ,JÈ TA.1,/É7:/ÉA=?NZ=Z89Ç,/×M,HCDCD0A.1.>@e47C@ ,<×Q0A47Ô :<81C;ÌA@BPT7:/C;K5@816%=?4,/07. @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816eEQÈQÌA=[C;Ì=?6ÉU@D89È @e@D4 7X :/47P ×Ñ,/.Ô ,5.>@381Ì7:<4,54A@ÐÔ =?NZN?=Z,54 T7:5C;K/@8;6 T7.>,HC@B6>6>@ePFX¨Æ^ÌA@3C,547CN?076>=Z,54 81ÌA@D.1@×Ñ,5.>@L=[68>Ì7:<8 =Z8=[6 NZ=?K/@eNZÇá81Ì7:J8)0A4AÔ):<81C;ÌA@BP¨TU:/C;K/@D816:<.1@ CD.>@B:J81@ePmÉÇ%,<81ÌA@D.=Z4*81@D.>×Ñ@D.1.>=?4AÊQ81.1:<Ù)C/EJ@/X Ê7X?EJOVÞQGá:<47PW=Z4*8>@e.wÎu.1,/0H81@D.F81.1:<ÙC·:/6¥ÈM@DN?N*:56yTh,5616w=?ÉAN?@ PA=?61CD:/.1PH@BP3PA:J8;:<Ê5.1:/Ô 6VPH0A@8>,RCD,/4AÊ5@e6w8>=?,/43:Ë/,5=?P7:<47CD@m=Z4#.>,50H8>@e.16PA0A.>=?4AÊRÌA@e:ËÇ*Î N?,5:5PR8>.;:JÙC CD,/47PA=|81=Z,5476DX. . . 0 &^ÀSÅ. Q& ¾¿32. à@MÌ7:Ë/@MPH,/4A@^:40AÔÉU@e.S,<×7@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*816y8>, Ô@B:/6>0A.1@^ßà ÆQÆá=Z4ÍG#.1,/0H81@D.;6F0A4UPH@D.IPH= h@e.>@e4*8 N?,5:5PR:/47P8>.;:JÙC%C,/4UPH=|81=Z,5476 uX O U.16w8·6w@D8¢,<× @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6SÌ7:/6IÉh@D@e4)PH,/4A@^81,mÔ @e:/6>0A.1@M8>ÌA@QTA.1,HC@B6>6>=Z47Ê%PA@DN[:ÇW,<×g: .>,50H8>@e. ×Ñ,5.^ÍG¨T7:5C;K/@D816MC,/4*8;:<=?4A=Z47ÊÍ>2 3G :<4UP V+-G T7:ÇNZ,*:/PA6eXyÍu8QÌ7:56MÉU@e@D4L,/É76>@D.1Ë/@BP ×Ñ,/.^=?47698;:<47CD@ 81Ì7:J8M8>Ì7@-TA.1,HC@B6>6>=Z47ʤPH@DN[:Ç ,<×g81ÌA@m2 =[61C/, 5Ò %.>,50H8>@e.MCe:<4Éh@ :/TATA.1, H=ZÔ):J81@eP ÉÇ)/: %:/076>6>=[:<4 PA@D476>=|89ÇR:<47PR8>Ì7@mÔ@B:<4LTA.1,CD@e616w=?4AÊ PH@DN[:Ç=[6Q:<Éh,/0H8 µ6w@BC X OV4A,<81ÌA@D.6>@8Q,/×¥ @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @e458;6^=?6^.1@DÊ*:<.;PH=?4AÊW81ÌA@m.>,50H8>@e.QPH@DN[:Ç ×Ñ,/.: 6>=Z4AÊ5NZ@%PA:<81:Û7,JÈ :/47P Ô ,5.>@VP7:J81:WÛ7,JÈ6·:56¢ÈM@DN?Nh:56¢81,¤Ô @e:56w07.>@Q81ÌA@V@ÒJ@ PH@DN[:Ǥ×Ñ,5. :C;Ì7:<=?4),<×y.1,/0A8>@D.;6 uXI+V = h@e.>@e4*8 CD,/47PA=|81=Z,5476%×Ñ,/.W8>ÌA@N?=?4AK#0A8>=?NZ=?Õe:<8>=?,/4Ì7:Ë5@Éh@D@e4076>@ePÏ ρ 7 X 81, AX 5Ó%:/6WÈ @eNZNM:/6%×Ñ,5.m8>ÌA@ ÖV0A.;698^T7:<.;:<Ô @D8>@D.M,<×y8>ÌA@ 8>.;:JÙC-=Z4LN?=Z4AKÐÏ AX %8>, AX 5ÓXIÆ¥:/ÉANZ @ %6wÌA,JÈ6·8>Ì7@%6>0AÔ Ô):<.1Ç ,<× @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816Q:/47PR8>ÌA@W:56>6>,HC=[:J8>@BP)81.1:<Ù)C H T7:/.1:/Ô @8>@e.16eX Í43@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*/8 5EU,54ANZÇR8>Ì7@6>,/0A.;C@WCD,/Ô TA0H81@D.-OÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81@e6^81.1:<Ù)C¤:<47PÐÞ W=?6V.>@BC@e=ZË=?4AÊ 81.1:<ÙC%×Ñ.>,5Ô 81ÌA@¤CD,/Ô TA0H81@D.-O,/4AN?Ç/XVß-4A@¤TA.>,HCD@e616Q=?6V076>@eP=?438>ÌA=[6VCe:/6>@%8>,Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@mGI:<.1@81, 81.1:<ÙC¤ÈQ=Z8>Ì α T7:/.1:/Ô@D8>@e. 6>ÌA,JÈQ4=?4#81:<É7NZ@):<4UP#:8>.;:JÙC=Z4*8>@e476>=|89Ç λ 81Ì7:J8¤CD,/.1.>@B6wTh,/4UPA6Q81, 81ÌA@3ÏÑÔ @e:56w07.>@BP7Ó ρ ËJ:/NZ0A@B6m6wÌ7,JÈQ4=?48;:<ÉAN?@/ X A0A.>8>ÌA@e.eEF8>ÌA@ T7:/.1:/Ô@D8>@e. β = 40 XÆ^ÌA@81.1:<Ù)C Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BP3=Z4#NZ=?4AK3Ì7:56 4A,× MÔÎuNZ=?K/@C;Ì7:<.;:/C8>@D.1=[6981=?Ce6DXWß-4AN?Ç 3G L:<4UP 3G :/.>@076w@BP381, Ce:<TH810A.1@ 81ÌA@^8>.;:JÙC/X¥Æ^ÌA@Q.1,/0H81@D.;6SÞVÒ :<47PÞ %:<.1@ 47,<8¢076>@ePLϯPH=?.1@eCb8IN?=Z47K¤Éh@89ÈM@D@D4 Þ Q:<4UP Ó :/47P81ÌA@ ÐG L:<47P 3G :<.1@W4A,/8 C,54A4A@BCb8>@BPÐ@e=|81ÌA@D.BX Æ^Ì7@W8>.;:/CD@e6-Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81@eP3C,5.>.1@e6>Th,/47P 81,)PH= @D.1@D4*8^ËJ:<N?0A@e6M×Ñ,5.MÉ70A.16w8>=?4A@B6>6^:<4UP)8>.;:JÙC-=Z4*81@D476>=|81=Z@B6Q:/6^6>ÌA,JÈQ4=?48;:<ÉAN?@ /X ·:5C;Ì8>.;:/CD@ =[6¤Ø*0A=Z8>@)É7=ZÊ:/47P=|8Ì7:/6W:/ÉU,50H8¤,54A@)Ô =ZN?NZ=?,/4TU:/C;K/@D816eXÆ^ÌA@.1@e:56w,54×Ñ,5.m8>ÌU:J8¤=[6mÉh@eCD:/076>@),<× 81ÌA@ÈM@DN?N|ÎuK4A,JÈQ4TA.>,5ÉAN?@DÔ)6m.1@DN[:J8>@BP#8>,8>Ì7@6wN?,JÈ C,/4Ë5@D.1Ê/@D4UC@8>,Ð6w8>@e:5PHÇ*Îu6w81:<8>@ =?4á8>ÌA@Ce:/6>@ ,/×Ì7@e:ËÇ*Î8;:<=?NZ@BPÈM,/.1KNZ,*:/PA6 uX Y=?4A@m81.1:5C@B6^Ì7:Ë/@%Éh@D@D43Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BP=?48>ÌA=[6Ce:/6>@/EAÈQÌA=[C;Ì3:<.1@ 6>ÌA,JÈQ4:/ 6
(21) h E gE81 , FX Í4 @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8WÒHEh8>ÌA@.1,/0H81@D.%Þ ¤=[6 .>@BC@D=?Ë=Z47Ê)8>.;:JÙCm×Ñ.1,/Ô Éh,<81Ì#CD,/Ô TA0H81@D.;6-O :<47P -X Æ^Ì7@m.>,50H8>@e.16QÞVÒ :/47PÞ :<.1@m6981=ZN?Ny4A,/8076>@eP:<47PR81ÌA@ 3G :<47P 3G :<.1@ 47,<8-CD,/4A4A@BCb81@eP @e=|81ÌA@D.BX¹Í4 81ÌA=[6LCe:/6>@/E C,/Ô TA0A8>@D.O =?6RÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81=Z47Ê 4A,54HÎ× MÔÎuNZ=?K/@8>.;:JÙCÐÈQ=Z8>Ì 8>ÌA@á61:<Ô @ C;ÌU:<.;:/Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6:/6=?4¨@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*8 LÈQÌA=?NZ@C,5Ô TA0H8>@e. =?6 Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>=?4AÊ#CD.>,*6>6¤8>.;:JÙCRÈQ=|81Ì × MÔÎuNZ=?K/@C;Ì7:/.1:5Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6-ÈQ=|81Ì H ≈ 0.9 :/47P ρ ≈ 0.1 =Z4:<N?N¢@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*816eXLß-4A@)Ì0A47PH.1@eP T7.>,HC@B6>6>@e6Q:/.>@%076>@ePR×Ñ,5.Q8>.;:JÙC Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81=Z,54R=?43C,/Ô TA0A8>@D. -X ¢Ë/@e.>ÇRTA.>,HCD@e616 Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@B6 V+-G 81.1:<ÙCWÈQ=Z8>ÌGS:/.>@D8>,LPH=?6w8>.1=?ÉA0H8>=?,/4×Ñ,/.-8>ÌA@T7:5C;K/@8 NZ@e4AÊ<81Ì76 ÈQ=|81Ì β = 40 :/47P α ,<×MPH= @D.1@D4*8 ËJ:/NZ0A@B6DES= X @5XZE XÆ^ÌA@81.1:<Ù)C Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BPáÉ*Ç#8>Ì7@ 8TA.1,CD@e616w@B6m:<.1@Ô = H@BP:J8 81ÌA@ -+VG«N?@DË/α@eNE=C.12,@e:<1.6, 8>=?4AÊ1.26>,8>Ì7@W× MÔÎ N?=ZK5@m8>.;:JÙC¤,/É76>@D.1Ë/@BPR=?4381ÌA@¤N?=Z47KhX OV6 :.1@e6>0ANZ8eEh4A=Z47@. . . . . . . . . .
(22) Æ¥:/ÉAN?@ 7 Ü 0AÔ Ô):<.1Ç,<×@ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6:<47P8>.;:JÙC Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81=Z,54T7:/.1:/Ô @8>@e.16 . α, ρ.
(23) . ! ! & ! ' ! ' #! ! ' #! & ! ' #! ' ! #! ! #! & ! #! '. %" $ )( %* ,+ % ,. ,/. "# "# %" "# $ "# )( "# %* "# ,+ "# %"# ,. "# ,/. α, ρ. ! ! & ! ' ! ' #! ! ' #! & ! ' #! ' ! #! ! #! & ! #! '. α, ρ. ! # ! # ! # ! # ! # ! # ! # ! # ! #. #! #! #! #! #! #! #! #! #! .
(24) $ $ %" $ $ $ )( $ %* $ ,+ $ %$ ,. $ ,/. α, ρ. #! #! & #! ' ! ' #! ! ' #! & ! ' #! ' ! # #! ! # #! & ! # #! '. . . . α,ρ. α,ρ. α,ρ. ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! . 81.1:5C@B6 Ì7:Ë/@Éh@D@D4Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@BPgE ÈQ=Z8>Ì PA=@D.1@D4*8 ρ ×Ñ,5.)8>ÌA@81.1:<ÙC,/É76>@D.1Ë/@eP¡:J8)81ÌA@6>=Z47K X ·Ë/@D.1Ç#8>.;:/C@)=[6¤:/ÉU,50H8¤,54A@Ô =ZN?N?=Z,54T7:/C;K5@816WNZ,54AÊ7X3Æ^ÌA@ÖV0A.;698¤TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.W,/×M81ÌA@ÉA=Z8.;:J81@ ÌU:/6MÉU@e@D4Ô @e:56w0A.1@eP)8>, ÉU@ H = 0.9 ×Ñ,/.^Ô ,56w8^,<×y81.1:5C@B6DXIÆ^ÌA@e.>@%:<.1@-Ì7,JÈ @eË/@D.M6w@eË/@e.1:/N781.1:5C@e6 6>ÌA,JÈQ=?4AÊN[:<.1Ê/@e.VËJ:<N?0A@B6×Ñ,5. ÏÑ@5X ÊUXZE Ó^×Ñ,5.%N?:/.>Ê5@ :<47PNZ,JÈ X¤Æ^ÌA@e6>@:/.>@¤8>.;:/CD@e6 CD,/.1.>@B6wTh,/4UPH=Z47Ê81,)8>.;:JÙC%ÈQH=Z8>Ì3=?4 74A=Z8>H@Ô =@e1.09 :<4yX à@¤:<.1@W:È^:<ρ.1@ ,/×S8>ÌA=[6TAα.1,/É7NZ@eÔLEUÈ @mÈ^:<4*81@eP Ì7,JÈ @eË/@D. 8>, 81@e6w8Q8>ÌA@m.1,/0A8>@D.^0A4UPH@D.Ë5@D.1Ç6w@eË/@e.>@%C,547PH=Z8>=?,/476eXSà#@%81ÌA@D.1@×Ñ,5.>@mPH=[PL4A,<8Q @ ACDNZ07PA@ 81ÌA@e6>@W81.1:5C@B6^×Ñ.>,5Ô ,/0A.- @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816eXY=?4A@8>.;:/CD@e6QÌ7:Ë5@WÉh@D@D4Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>@BPL=Z4Ð@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8%ÒAE ÈQÌ7=?C;Ì3:<.1@%6wÌA,JÈQ4:/6
(25) hE FE8>, FX 7,/.- @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8 7E781ÌA@CD,/Ô TA0H81@D.-O=?6-6981=ZN?NÊ/@D47@D.;:J8>=?4AÊ 81.1:<Ù)CWÈQ=|81Ì38>ÌA@6>:/Ô @¤C;Ì7:<.;:/CÎ 81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6-:/6-=Z4 @ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8 5XVÆ^ÌA@PA= @D.1@D47CD@¤=[681Ì7:J8 4A,JÈ :<N?NF81ÌA.>@e@CD,/Ô TA0H81@D.;6 Eg2 :/47P +¹:/.>@Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81=Z4AÊ× MÔÎuN?=ZK5@¤81.1:<Ù)C¤Û7,JÈ6eEÈQ=|81Ì H ≈ 0.9 :/47P ρ ≈ 0.1 X¤Æ^ÌA@e6>@ C,/Ô TA0A8>@D.;6 :/.>@Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>=?4AÊÐÉh,<81Ì Ô @D.1Ê/=?4AÊ381.1:<ÙC:<4UPÝC.1,5616w=?4AÊ81.1:<Ù)C/Xß-47@Ì0A47PH.1@ePÝTA.>,HCD@e616w@B6W:<.1@ 0U6w@BPÐ×Ñ,5.-81.1:<ÙCÊ5@D4A@e.1:<8>=?,/4Ð=?4@DË/@e.>ÇÐCD,/Ô TA0H81@D.BXÆ^ÌA@ Ê5@D4A@e.1:<8>@eP38>.;:JÙCÛ7,JÈ6%:<.1@ÉA.1,/K5@D4 07T=Z4 81ÌA@V.1,/0A8>@D.;6¢Þ 5E*Þ-Òm:<47P)+Þ m=Z4:WÈM:Ǥ8>Ì7:<8 ,/×@eË/@e.>ǤÛ7,JÈ =?6·Ô@e.>Ê5=Z47Ê%8>ÌA@V8>.;:JÙC CD,/Ô =?4AÊ)×Ñ.1,/Ô C,/Ô TA0A8>@D. O :<4UP8>ÌA@¤.>@B698V,/× ÏÚ×Ñ,5.V@eË/@D.1ÇÛU,JÈVÓ^=?6-C.1,5616w=?4AÊ 81ÌA@¤.1,/0H81@D.;6 ,54AN?Ç/XSY=?4A@Q8>.;:/CD@e6SÌ7:Ë5@^ÉU@e@D4 Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81@eP=Z4)@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*8 :56IÈM@DN?NE5ÈQÌA=?C;Ì):/.>@Q6>ÌA,JÈQ4:516 0
(26) hE 0 FE8>2 , 0 yX.
(27) . . ¥Ã (b¿32 Æ^Ì7@-C,5Ô TANZ@D8>@ 6w@D8 ,<×F.1@e6>0ANZ816·,/ÉH8;:<=?4A@eP)=?4:/NZNU@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*816 =[6 Ø*0A=Z8>@-N?:/.>Ê5@:<47P)=Z8 =[6 .>@eTU,5.w81@eP =?4 XIÍ4R8>ÌA@%×Ñ,5NZN?,JÈQ=?4AÊÈM@%.>@eTU,5.w8Q:<4L @ A:/ÔT7NZ@%,<×.>@B6w07N|8;6^,/ÉH8;:<=?4A@eP=Z4 @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @e458 ,/47NZÇ5X Æ:<É7NZ@WÒ.1@DTh,/.>816M8>Ì7@WÔ):<=?46w81:<8>=[6981=?Ce6Q,<×8>Ì7@ßQà ÆQÆ Ô @e:/6>0A.1@ePRÉU@D89È @e@D4L8>Ì7@WÊ/@e4A@D.;:J81,/. O¹:/47P8>ÌA@6>=Z47K XyÆ^ÌA@ Ô):<=?4á,/É76>@D.1ËJ:J81=Z,54Ð=Z481ÌA=?6¤CD:/6>@=?6m.1@DÊ*:<.;PH=?4AÊ81ÌA@ N?:/.>Ê5@PH=[6>T7:<.1=|89Ç ×Ñ,5.Q:<N?N6w81:<8>=[6981=?Ce6^C,/N?N?@eCb81@ePgE@ HCD@DTH8M×Ñ,/.M81ÌA@%Ô=?4A=?Ô¤0AÔXIà@m:<N[6w,,/É76>@D.1Ë/@ :WN[:<.1Ê/@V40AÔÉU@e.^,<× 61:<Ô TAN?@e6SÈQ=Z8>Ì N[:<.1Ê/@QPH@eN?:ÇH6eE<:<47PÈM@MÉh@DN?=?@DË/@^81Ì7:J8¢Ô ,*698¢,/×78>Ì7@DÔ :<.1@MPH07@^8>,WØ*0A@D07@D=?4AÊmPH@DN[:ÇH6 =?4.1,/0A8>@D.;6eX-à@PA,4A,/8-,/ÉU6w@e.>Ë5@¤:<4Ç36>:/Ô TANZ@ÈQ=|81Ì@ *81.>@eÔ @DN?ÇLN[:<.1Ê/@PH@DN[:Ç/EU8>Ì7@CD,/47CDNZ076>=?,/4 ,/×QÈQÌA=?C;Ìá=[6%8>ÌU:J8:/NZNI81ÌA.1@D@).1,/0H81@D.;6m6w@e@DÔ 8>,3ÈM,/.1KÐTA.1,/Th@D.1NZÇ5XRÆ^ÌA@:56>6>,HC=[:J8>@BPÌ7=?6w8>,5Ê/.;:<Ô)6 ÌU:Ë/@%ÉU@e@D43,5É76w@e.>Ë5@eP8>,ÌU:Ë/@m: %:<Ô Ô):JÎuNZ=?K/@W6>Ì7:/TU@mÈQ=Z8>ÌÐ: ÌA@B:ËÇ81:/=ZN X^Æ^ÌA@%81:/=ZN¥Ì7:/6QÉh@D@e4 ,5É76>@D.1Ë/@eP8>, N?,*,5K6>=ZÔ =?N?:/.^×Ñ,/.QÔ ,56w8Q,<×8>.;:/C@B6^:<47PL=Z8=?6QPH@eTU@e47PH@e458,54 α :<47P ρ X =?Ê/0A.1@ÐÒ6wÌA,JÈ6 @ A:<Ô TAN?@e6 ,<× 8>Ì7.>,50AÊ/ÌAT70H8Ï 3É7T761ÓÔ @B:/6>0A.>@BP =?4 @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*5 8 0 6 :<8 81ÌA@3,/0A8>TA0H8),/×%CD,/Ô TA0H81@D.)O ÏÑ0AT7TU@e.NZ@D×Ú8;Ó :/47PÝ81ÌA@Ð:/616>,CD=?:<8>@BPÌA=[6981,/Ê/.;:<Ô Ï¯0ATATh@D..1=?Ê/Ì*8;ÓX 3. 4. &2.
(28) Æ:<ÉAN?@¤Ò 7 Ü 07ÔÔ):/.>Ç,/×¢ßà ÆQÆ .1@e6>0ANZ816M×Ñ,5.Q@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8 . $ $ %" $ $ $ )( $ %* $ ,+ $ %$ ,. $ ,/. ! #! + &# .
(29) ! &! ++ . ! ' ! + -#! -#! #- ! ,-. #! '. ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ±. #! & #! /- & #! +&'+ #! . & #! . & #! ' #! & - #! + . . ,#+ ! - - . ! - ' & #- ! ' ,#+ ! ' &! &! '#! ' '#! '. #! .
(30) . ! . . ! . . . ! + ! + ! . . .
(31) . ! & ! & ! & ! & ! & ! & ! & ! & ! & . "! $#&%(') (* % . ,+ % ' . % && '# % ++ % +& ' % #, -+ % '# % , + -+ % . ' -. . ! . !' #! + . ! +#! +#! +#! . '#! -. Æ^Ì7@ÐC,/Ô TA0A8>@D.RO Ê/@D47@D.;:J8>@B6 =Z4¡81ÌA=?6CD:/6>@8>.;:JÙCLÈQ=Z8>Ì :/47P X ß-4¨81ÌA@ CD,/4*8>.;:<.1Ç/E C,/Ô TA0A8>@D.;6 EM2 :<47P¡+ Ê/@e4A@D.;:J81@ϯ@e:5C;Ì¡,/×V81αÌA@D=ÔÓ1.281.1:<Ù)CLÈQρ=Z8>=Ì α0.4= 1.2 :<47P X%Æ^ÌA@D=?.V81.1:<ÙCW=[6-É7.>,5K/@D4307T=?4Ð8>Ì7@¤.1,/0H81@D.;6-Þ 5EgÞVÒ:/47PÐÞ =Z4*8>,LÔ @D.1Ê/=?4AÊ)81.1:<Ù)C ρ = 0.1 Ï Ó:<4UP C.1,5616m81.1:<ÙCÏ ÓbX M@DN?,JÈ 8>Ì7@e6>@TAN?,<8;6=Z8 =?6:<N[6w,6wÌ7,JÈQ48>ÌA@R8>Ì7.>,50AÊ/ÌAT70H8 Ï 3ÉAT76;Ó Ô @e:/6>0A.1@eP:<8 81ÌA@mPH@e6w8>=?47:<8>=?,/6 4 :<4UP)8>Ì7@ :56>6>,HC=[:J8>@BP)ÌA=[6981,/Ê5.1:/ÔLX 4UPH@D.14A@e:<8>ÌR=|8^=?6 6>ÌA,JÈQ4¤8>ÌA@ßQà ÆQÆÝÔ@B:/6>0A.1@ePm=?4¤81ÌA=[6¥@ HTU@e.>=?Ô @D4*8¥81,/Ê5@8>Ì7@D.SÈQ=|81ÌW81ÌA@Q:/616w,HC=[:J81@ePmÌ7=?6w8>,5Ê/.;:<ÔX ßà ÆQÆ =?6Q,5É76>@D.1Ë/@eP8>,)Ì7:Ë5@m6wTA=?K/@B6:/6^Ì7=ZÊ5Ì:56 8¤Ô)6eX 70A.w81ÌA@D.1Ô ,/.1@/EH=Z8V=[6:<N[6w, ,5É76w@e.>Ë5@eP 81Ì7:J8Q81ÌA@ßà ÆQÆ ÌA=[6981,/Ê5.1:/Ô¹Ì7:/6Q:ÌA@B:Ë*Ç81:<=?N X =?47:<N?N?Ç/ E 7Ê50A.>@ 6wÌA,JÈ6 81ÌA@%Ô@B:/6>0A.1@ePÔ @B:<4R:/47PRË:/.>=[:<4UC@ ,<×Sßà ÆQÆ ,5ÉH81:/=Z4A@BP)×Ñ,5.:<N?N 81ÌA.1@D@% @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @D4*8;6DXSÍu8Q=?6^,5É76>@D.1Ë/@eP)8>ÌA@m6w8>.1,/4AÊ PH@DTh@D4UPH@D47CD@%,<×y81ÌA@%Ô @e:<4:<4UP)8>Ì7@mË:/.>=[:<4UC@ ,548>.;:JÙCC;ÌU:<.;:/Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6¤:<47PN?=?4AKá0H8>=?NZ=?Õe:<8>=?,/476eX A0A.>8>ÌA@e.eES=Z8=[6:<N[6w,Ð,5É76>@D.1Ë/@eP#81Ì7:J8 =|8=?6 81ÌA@ α TU:<.;:<Ô @81@D.Q,<×8>Ì7@mÊ/@D47@D.;:J8>@BP81.1:<ÙC 8>Ì7:<8Ô,*6981NZÇR=Z4AÛ70A@D4UC@e6Q8>ÌA@W.1,/0A8>@D.QÉh@DÌU:Ë*=?,/.Q:<8 N[:<.1Ê/@ ρ X¢Æ^Ì7=?6M=[6 ,/×CD,/0A.;6w@V8>ÌA@mCD,/476>@eØ*0A@e47C@-,<×Ø*0A@e0A@D=?4AÊÉU@eÌ7:Ë=Z,5.eE*ÈQÌA=[C;Ì89ÇTA=[CD:/NZN?Ç)6wÌA,JÈ6 Ì7@e:ËÇ*Î8;:<=?NZ@BPPH@eN?:Ç3Th@D.>×Ñ,/.1Ô):<47CD@Lϯ@/X Ê7X?EFà#@e=ZÉ70ANZN¢PA=?6w8>.1=ZÉ70H8>=?,/4UÓ =?4#8>ÌA@)CD:56w@,<× 8>.;:JÙCÈQ=|81Ì $y,/4AÊ/ÎuÞV:<4AÊ5@ +-@DTh@D47PA@D47CD@/X. . . . . ÁW¾LÄ (Ã#2yÅDÁW¾ O³PH@BPH=[CD:J81@ePÔ@B:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8M6>ÇH6981@DÔ ×Ñ,5.MCD,/N?NZ@BCb8>=?4AÊÌA=?Ê/ÌHÎØ*07:<N?=|89Ç81.1:<Ù)CV8>.;:/CD@e6M:<47PÔ @e:/6>0A.>Î =?4AÊ@BÒ<@-PH@eN?:Ç Ì7:56 Éh@D@e4.1@DTh,/.>8>@BPgXÆ^Ì7@-Ô @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*8 =?4H×Ñ.1:56981.>0UCb8>07.>@ PH@e:/N?6MÈQ=Z8>ÌT7.>,5ÉANZ@eÔ)6 N?=?K/@W6>Ç*4UC;ÌA.>,54A=?Õe:J81=Z,54FEHÌA=?Ê/ÌHÎ:/CeC0A.;:/CDÇ =Z481=ZÔ @e6w81:/Ô TA=Z47Ê:<47PTA.1,HC@B6>6>=Z47Ê,/×SÔ0ANZ8>=?TANZ@%81.1:5C@B6 CD,/N?NZ@BCb81@eP :<8RËJ:<.1=Z,5076)Ô @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*8TU,5=Z4*8;6DX O Ô @e:56w07.>@eÔ@e4*8R698107PHÇ ,<פPA@DN[:Ç68>ÌA.1,/07Ê/Ì ÍG³.1,/0H81@D.;6 Ì7:/6%Éh@D@e4.1@DTh,/.>8>@BPgX)Æ^ÌA@)Ô @e:56w0A.1@DÔ @e458m6>@8>07T=[6%.1@DTh,/.>8>@eP#=?4á:PH@D81:/=ZN?@ePÈ^:Ç 81,/Ê5@8>Ì7@D.VÈQ=Z8>ÌÐ8>ÌA@6w@D8-,<×I@ Th@D.1=?Ô@e4*816 PH,/4A@5X Ü @eË/@D.;:<Ny=ZÔ Th,/.>81:<4*8-6w81:<8>=[6981=?Ce6VÌU:Ë/@mÉh@D@D4.>@DÎ Th,/.>8>@BP¤:/ÉU,50H8¥81ÌA@^PH@DN[:Ç%×Ñ,/.S:V.1,/0A8>@D.S:<4UPm×Ñ,/.S: C;Ì7:<=?4W,<×U.>,50H8>@e.16eXSß-0A..1@e6>0AN|8;6¥CD,/4 U.>Ô ,/8>ÌA@e. .1@e6>0ANZ816m.1@DTh,/.>8>@BP@e:<.1N?=Z@e.%8>Ì7:<8m8>ÌA@PA@DN[:Ç=?4ÍG .>,50H8>@e.16%=[6mÊ/@e4A@D.;:<N?N?ÇÐ=Z4AÛ70A@D4UC@ePáÉÇ8>.;:JÙC C;ÌU:<.;:/Cb81@D.1=?6w8>=[CD6eEBNZ=?4AKmC,547PH=Z8>=?,/476:<47PFE8>,-6>,/Ô @ @ 8>@e458BE<PH@8;:<=?N?6¥=?4¤Ì7:/.1PHÈ^:<.1@I=?ÔT7NZ@eÔ@e4*81:J81=Z,54 :/47P6>,<×Ú89È^:<.1@.1@DN?@e:/6>@e6eX¢ß-0A.¢×Ñ0H810A.1@-ÈM,/.1KÈQ=?N?NhÉh@%:<Éh,/0H8MÔ,HPH@eNZ=?4AÊ,<×F81ÌA@-,5ÉH81:/=Z47@eP).1@e6>0ANZ816eE 81,¤=?47CN?07PH@-TU,*6>6>=?ÉANZ@ C,5.>.1@DN[:J81=Z,5476I @ H=[6981@D4*8 Éh@89ÈM@D@e4Ø*0A@D07@VN?@D4AÊ/8>Ì76M:J8^:/P w:5C@D4*8·47,PA@e6eX¢ß-07. Ê5,5:/Nh=[6^81/, U47P:¤×Ñ,5.>Ô0AN[:¤×Ñ,5.^8>ÌA@m@ÒJ@mPH@eN?:Ç=?4:)C;Ì7:<=?4R,/×¥.1,/0H81@D.;6DX 0. ,.
(32) OWTT for More Data Flows − Chain of Routers A: ρ = 0.4, α = 1.2 B,C,D: 50+50 sources with ρ = 0.1 0.1 P[X1<X<X2]. Mbps. 10. 5. 0. 0. 1000. 2000. 3000. 4000. 5000. 6000. 0 0. 7000. 2. 4 6 Bitrate [Mbps]. 8. 10. 2. 4 6 Bitrate [Mbps]. 8. 10. 0.06 P[X1<X<X2]. Mbps. 10. 5. 0. 0.05. 0. 1000. 2000. 3000. 4000. 5000. 6000. 0.04 0.02 0 0. 7000. OWTT [ms]. 150 100 50. P[X1<X<X2]. 0 0 −3 x 10 8. 100000. 200000. 300000. 400000. 500000 600000 Sample Number. 700000. 800000. var: std.dev: median: mean: max: min:. 6 4. 900000. 1000000. 9. 10. 57 7.55 2.42 5.1 107 0.409. 2 0. 0. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5 OWTT [ms]. 6. 7. 8. =?Ê/0A.1@QÒ 7yÆ^ÌA.1,/07Ê/ÌATA0A8Ô @e:56w07.>@BPW:J8¢C,5Ô TA0H8>@e.IO ϯ0ATATh@D.IN?@×Ú8;ÓS:/47P¤:<8SCD,/Ô TA0H81@D. ÏÑÉh@DN?,JÈVÓ 81,/Ê5@8>Ì7@D.%ÈQ=|81Ì8>ÌA@):/616>,CD=?:<8>@BPÐÌA=[6981,/Ê5.1:/Ô 6ÏÑ.1=?Ê/Ì*8W6w=[PH@BÓX 47PH@e.>47@e:J81Ì 7¤ßQà ÆQÆ Ô@B:/6>0A.1@eP ×Ñ,5.QÔ ,/.1@%P7:J81:Û7,JÈ6^=?4:)C;Ì7:<=?4R,/×¥.1,/0H81@D.;6%ÏÑ @ HTh@D.1=ZÔ @e45+8 <Î *Ó ÈQ=|81Ì:56>6>,HC=[:J81@ePÌ7=?6w8>,5Ê/.;:<Ô 4. . ^À &Q¾RÄ &2 WOVNZÔ @e6 X?Em:<N?=[PH=Z4UPH= Ü XS:/47P@DKJ:<076>KJ:/6 XZE
(33)
(34) 3E Í·Æ ¨Þ 2 Ò 7E AX Ò M,JËÇm2-"X !UXZE 3@e.w81,HPH=ZÔ @BP 9,-Ö¤XÆ%X?E<Ö,,5Ê/ÌA=?@DÔ)6w8>.;: XZE V= 81@D.1ÈM:5:<NÖWX:<47P$#¢:/4 3=?@DÊ5ÌA@DÔ GSX?% E & '(*) ) + , .-/" 0 "#1 EOV2 GgO E 7,/.>8 2 ,5NZN?=Z4U6DEU2 ,5NZ,5.1:5PH,7E Ü OWEUÒ 5ÒAX 2M:/=?PA:)Ò %Y@D89È ,5.>K Ð@e:/6>0A.1@DÔ @D4*8 3@81.>=[CD6à X?E Ì*8w81T 7 #"#ÈQÈQÈmX CD:/=?P7:AX ,/.1Ê #,50H8>.1@e:5C;Ì #Ô @D8>.1=?Ce6wÈQ4Ê #eׯ:/ØhX Ô N C;ÌA@eC;K5@e2 P !/0A47@mÒ 2M:/.>N[6>6>,/4áGSX?
(35) E ¢KÉU@e.>ÊOWXS:<47P ¥=?@ePANZ@e. X?3 E 4%5 6 7( ' 8 69 - , ;: < =-/ > ?. =-
(36) 8-/ E¢2Qß Ü ÆÒ ÆQ+Ï 5Ó ÒHEAÒ AX 2 ,547698;:<4*8>=?4A@B6>CD0W+¤X?E/2M:<.1N?616w,54%GX?EJGS,/Th@e61C0WO¤XZ@ E 1 A CB/ DB D =-/ bE Æ¥@eC;ÌA47=?Ce:<NFÞQ@eTU,5.w8BE MNZ@eK*=?4AÊ5@-Í476w8>=Z8>0A8>@W,/×Æ¥@eC;ÌA4A,5NZ,5Ê/Ç5EHÒ 7EÍ ÜAÜ Y 7 8 <Î /X & &. . . . .
(37) .
Related documents
Thus, allowing for mixed equilibria gives different result, more in line with the deadline model in Jehiel & Moldovanu (1995a), where they also get delay with
Faktorer som skulle kunna påverka bedömningen av huruvida ett avtal ska anses otillåtet eller ej är bland annat storleken av transaktionsbeloppet från ursprungsföretaget
Patients with mild heart failure () may be able to engage in sexual intercourse without difficulty, while those with an HF.. exacerbation or more severe HF (may need to refrain
In order to analyze the impact of delay and delay variation on user‟s perceived quality in video streaming, we designed an experiment in which users were asked
Key words: distributed hash tables, structured overlay networks, distributed algorithms, distributed systems, group communication,
visar antalet korrekta bedömningar för positionen buckal och palatinal, accuracy, för de olika metoderna validerat med Cone Beam Computed Tomography, samt sensitivitet
Undersökningen har omfattat 26 stockar från småländska höglandet som p g a extrema dimensioner (diameter > 55 cm) lagts undan vid Unnefors Sågverk. Stockarna sågades och
I resultatet framkom det att kvinnor som genomgått en RALH i generell anestesi kombinerat med spinal självskattade sin smärta lägre än de kvinnor som erhållit generell anestesi 30
