Anteckningar från ett lärarhåll - några tankar
om juridisk undervisning
Jan Kellgren
Linköping University Post Print
N.B.: When citing this work, cite the original article.
Original Publication:
Jan Kellgren , Anteckningar från ett lärarhåll - några tankar om juridisk undervisning, 2007,
Bihanget (programtidning för de affärsjuridiska programmen vid LiU), (1), 15.
Postprint available at: Linköping University Electronic Press
(UEMXGHQ DWW VlJD QnJRW RP OlUDUJlUQLQJHQ
nUVRPXQLYHUVLWHWVOlUDUHI|UVWL8SSVDOD
VHGDQYLG/L8 lUGHWPnQJDPLQQHQXQGULQJDU
RFK nVLNWHU VRP WUlQJHU VLJ Sn VnKlU Sn
HIWHUPLGGDJHQ DY PLQ VLVWD DUEHWVGDJ I|U
nUHW.U|QLNDQLQVNUlQNHUVLJWLOOQnJUDNRUWD
EHWUDNWHOVHU RFK GHVV LQQHKnOO VWnU I|U PLJ
RFKLQJHQDQQDQ
6\QHQSnOlUDUHQNDQPDQIXQGHUD|YHU)|UHQOlUDUH
VlUVNLOWGHQQ\EOLYQHNDQGHWNlQQDVVRPDWWPDQGLUHNW JHQRPµXSSK|MHOVHQµWLOOOlUDUHLVWXGHQWHUQDV|JRQLHWW VODJI|UYlQWDVEOLH[SHUWSnDOOWVRPU\PVLQRPGHWHJQD XQGHUYLVQLQJVlPQHW 'HW lU VMlOYVNULYHW DWW LQJHQ EOLU VNLFNOLJDUHEDUDDYDWWInXSSGUDJHWDWWXQGHUYLVDPHQ GHWNDQNlQQDVVRPDWWI|UYlQWQLQJDUQDlUDWWOlUDUHVND NXQQDPHUHOOHUPLQGUHDOOWLQRPVLWWlPQH6nlUDOOWVn LQWHIDOOHWLQWHHQVHIWHUHQOnQJWLGVRPOlUDUH²RFKGH VNDPDQLQWHKHOOHUEHK|YDJ|UD(QDQQDQVDNlUDWWGHQ VRPµVNDXWLVDOµRIWDKDUVWDUNDLQWUHVVHQDYDWWOlUDVLJ VLWW lPQH RUGHQWOLJW RFK DWW lYHQ VMlOYD XQGHUYLVQLQJHQ ELGUDUWLOODWWPDQOlUVLJHQKHOGHO
$OOWI|U VWRUD I|UYlQWQLQJDU Sn OlUDUHQV NXQVNDSHU KDU
I|UPRGOLJHQWLOOHQGHOVLQI|UNODULQJLHQQDLYNXQVNDSVV\Q LQQHElUDQGH XQJHIlU DWW PHVW NXQQLJ lU GHQ VRP YHW VYDUHQ Sn ÁHVW UlWWVIUnJRU (Q XQLYHUVLWHWVOlUDUH L MXULGLN VND GRFN YDUD EUD Sn P\FNHW PHU lQ GHQ UHQD QRUPNlQQHGRPHQWH[DWWGUDSDUDOOHOOHUSUREOHPDWLVHUD HQWXVLDVPHUD UHÁHNWHUD WROND RFK WHRUHWLVHUD ² PHQ QnJRW XSSVODJVYHUN L UHJHONXQVNDS EHK|YHU PDQ LQWH YDUD 0nQJD OlUDUH NlQQHU RFNVn DWW VWXGHQWHUQD KDU HQ |YHUGULYHQ UHVSHNW I|U GHP HOOHU GHUDV NXQVNDSHU 'HWNDQOHGDWLOODWWVWXGHQWHUQDLQWHYnJDUEMXGDSnVLJ VMlOYDDYUlGVODI|UDWWEORWWDHWW WUROLJHQRIWD|YHUVNDWWDW DYJUXQGVGMXSW NXQVNDSV|YHUWDJ 'HW lU GRFN P\FNHW VlOODQ MDJ VRP OlUDUH NlQQHU DWW IUnJRU lU RPRWLYHUDGH HOOHUGXPPD)UnJRUYLVDULVWlOOHWRIWDVWSnLQWUHVVHHOOHU SnSHGDJRJLVNDEHKRY²RIWDOlUMDJPLJP\FNHWDYGHP 6RPOlUDUHNlQQHUMDJLQWHVlOODQDWWMDJXQGHUYLVDUPHG HQLYLVVPnQDQQDQLQULNWQLQJlQYDGVWXGHQWHUQDVNXOOH |QVND-DJYHWDWWLQWHPLQVWPnQJDDYPLQDIRUVNDUNROOHJHU KDUHQOLNQDQGHXSSOHYHOVHLVLQXQGHUYLVQLQJ'HWYHUNDU JLYHWYLVPHGHQEHW\GDQGHJHQHUDOLVHULQJVRPDWWHQVWRU JUXSSVWXGHQWHU|QVNDUVLJHQXQGHUYLVQLQJVRPNXQGH EHVNULYDVVRPµVHUYHUDGNRQNUHWLRQµ6nGDQXQGHUYLVQLQJ NlQQHWHFNQDV DY DWW UHJOHUQD RFK UHJHOV\VWHPHWV UlWWVOLJD EHW\GHOVH I|UNODUDV Sn HWW HQGLPHQVLRQHOOW RFK OlWWIDWWOLJWVlWWXWDQSnWDJOLJSUREOHPDWLVHULQJHOOHUPHU WHRUHWLVHUDQGH HOOHU UHÁHNWHUDQGH DQVDWVHU PHQ NDQVNH NU\GGDW PHG HQ RFK DQQDQ PXVWLJ DQHNWRG IUnQ GHW SUDNWLVNDUlWWVOLYHW 1nJRQUHQRGODGVnGDQXQGHUYLVQLQJ WlQNHU MDJ DOGULJ OHYHUHUD WURWV DWW GHQ WUROLJHQ VNXOOH YDUDEnGHSRSXOlURFKJDQVNDOlWWDWWSUHVWHUD
9DGDQGHQQDKDOVWDUULJKHW"*UXQGHQOLJJHULWDQNDURP
VWXGHQWHUQDV RFK VDPKlOOHWV OnQJVLNWLJD Q\WWD -DJ VHU PLJSULPlUWVRPVWDWVWMlQVWHPDQRFKXQLYHUVLWHWVOlUDUH, GHVVDUROOHUOlJJHUMDJDWWMDJLQWHlUSnMREEHWLI|UVWDKDQG I|UDWWEOLSRSXOlUHOOHUI|UDWWPD[LPHUDHJHQQ\WWDQHOOHU QlULQJVOLYHWV RPHGHOEDUD DQYlQGQLQJ I|U VWXGHQWHUQD , VWlOOHW lU PLQ XSSJLIW DWW I|UV|ND VNROD DNDGHPLNHU VRPKDUHQP\FNHWYLGDUHNXQVNDSVSDOHWWlQDWWNlQQD WLOO UHJHOV\VWHPHWV LQQHKnOO 6MlOYIDOOHW lU GHW YLNWLJW DWW XWELOGDDIIlUVMXULVWHUVRPNODUDUVLJEUDLDUEHWVOLYHWPHQ PLQVWOLNDYLNWLJWlUDWWKDHQJUXQGOlJJDQGHI|UWURJHQKHW PHG DNDGHPLVND G\JGHU VRP DWW SUREOHPDWLVHUD DWW GUD SDUDOOHOOHU GLVNXWHUD RFK XWYlUGHUD WRONQLQJDU WRONQLQJVPHWRGHU RFK WRONQLQJVDUJXPHQW DWW J|UD UlWWVSROLWLVND RFK HWLVND DQDO\VHU RFK |YHU KXYXG WDJHW DWW Sn HWW LQVLNWVIXOOW VlWW UHÁHNWHUD RFK WHRUHWLVHUD NULQJ GH lPQHQ GH VWXGHUDW 'HWKDQGODURPDWWOlUDXW HWW VMlOYVWlQGLJW RFK NULWLVNW WlQNDQGH ² RFK GHW lU YnUW VDPKlOOVDQVYDU DWW SULRULWHUD GHQQD PnOVlWWQLQJ 'HW YHUNDU RFNVn VRP DWW PnQJD VWXGHQWHU HIWHU QnJUD nU LQVHUDWWGHQWUlQLQJLUHÁHNWLRQRFKWHRUHWLVHULQJVRPGH ÀFNXWVWnXQGHUXQLYHUVLWHWVnUHQLVMlOYDYHUNHWSnVLNWlU HWWLQWHOOHNWXHOOWGULYPHGHOPHGVW|UUHQlULQJVLQQHKnOOlQ GHQUHJHOH[HUFLVVRPPDQJO|PPHUERUWLHQPDWHULDVRP LDOODIDOOlQGUDVRIWD'HVVXWRP²RFKGHWWDlUDYVW|UVWD YLNW²lUMXULGLNHQVNRQNUHWDRFKW\GOLJDNDUDNWlUHQP\FNHW WXQQDUHNDQVNHUHQWDYIDOVNDUHIHUQLVVDlQPnQJDWURU 0lQJGHU DY YLNWLJD UlWWVIUnJRU lU RNODUD HOOHU |SSQD I|U DUJXPHQWDWLRQ RP RPWRONQLQJ HOLNQ 9LGDUH XWPDQDV GHQ SHUVRQOLJD \UNHV PRUDOHQ HOOHU GHQ HYHQWXHOOD KXYXGPDQQHQVPRUDOLHQPlQJGIDOO(QGDVWGHQVRP NDQ VH P|QVWHU RFK VDPPDQKDQJ GUD SDUDOOHOOHU RFK VRP NODUDU DWW E\JJD XSS HWW YlOVWUXNWXUHUDW QRUPDWLYW UHVRQHPDQJ lYHQ QlU UlWWVNlOORUQD JHU RNODUD EHVNHG NODUDUVLJEUDQlUDJQDUQDVNLOMVIUnQYHWHWLUlWWVOLYHW-DJ WURURFNVnDWWGHWHQGDVWlUPHGHQVnGDQVMlOYVWlQGLJKHW RFKGLVWDQVWLOOMXULVW\UNHWVRPPDQNDQNlQQDDWWPDQ LQI|UVLJVMlOYSnHWWWURYlUGLJWVlWWNDQPRWLYHUDVLQDYDO L VYnUD IUnJRU ² GHW NDQ RFK E|U LQWH YDUD RYLNWLJW I|U VMlOVIULGHQ'HWlUI|LQWHµNXQVNDSHQRPGHWOlWWDµVRP JHUGHK|JDO|QHUQDXWDQI|UPnJDQDWWQDYLJHUDYlODYYlJW RFKPHGIUDPJnQJLGLPPLJDRFKULVNDEODIDUYDWWHQ
1lU GHW VHGDQ JlOOHU GH SHGDJRJLVND IRUPHUQD I|U
DWW OHYHUHUD GHW PDQ YLOO JH KDQGODU GHW RP DWW KLWWD HQ SHGDJRJLN VRP RSWLPHUDU VWXGHQWHUQDV OlUDUHQV RFK lPQHVRPUnGHWV I|UXWVlWWQLQJDU LQRP UDPHQ I|U WLOOJlQJOLJD UHVXUVHU 6|NDQGHW HIWHU GHQQD SHGDJRJLN LQQHIDWWDU HQ PlQJG ROLND DYYlJQLQJDU 7LOO H[HPSHO EUXNDU MDJ XQGUD |YHU RP GHW JHU ElVW LQOlUQLQJ DWW MDJYLVDUKXUMDJVMlOYWlQNHULROLNDIUnJRURFKKXUPLQ HQWXVLDVP I|U lPQHW VHU XW HOOHU RP GHW lU NORNDUH DWW OHYHUHUD HQ PHU EHKlUVNDG RFK OlWWVPlOW IUDPVWlOOQLQJ VRP OLJJHU QlUPDUH VWXGHQWHUQDV NXQVNDSVOlJH -DJ I|UV|NHU RIWD DWW I|UEHUHGD PLJ PHG YLVV W\QJGSXQNW Sn GHQ VHQDUH PnOVlWWQLQJHQ I|U DWW LQWH VHGDQ L VDOHQ
$QWHFNQLQJDUIUnQHWWOlUDUKnOO
±QnJUDWDQNDURPMXULGLVNXQGHUYLVQLQJ
KDPQDDOOWI|UGMXSWLGHQI|UVWQlPQGD«'HWNDQRFNVn QlPQDV DWW MDJ QXPHUD LQOHGHU PLQD NXUVHU PHG DWW XSSO\VD RP DWW PLQ XSSJLIW lU DWW YLVDVWXGHQWHUQDYDG GHPnVWHOlUDVLJVQDUDUHlQDWWOlUDGHPGHWGHPnVWH NXQQD/lUDUHQVNDLI|UVWDKDQGKMlOSDVWXGHQWHUQDDWW OlUD VLJ VMlOYD 'HW VDJGD KLQGUDU VMlOYIDOOHW LQWH DWW MDJ I|UV|NHU DWW I|UNODUD KXU UHJHOV\VWHPHW KlQJHU LKRS Sn HWWVlWWVRPVWXGHQWHUQDI|UVWnUHOOHUDWWMDJVWUlYDUHIWHU NRQWDNWRFKJODGDVWXQGHUPHGPLQDVWXGHQWHU,QWHKHOOHU EHW\GHUGHWDWWMDJVDNQDUEHKRYDYDWWYDUDXSSVNDWWDG (WW YLVVW PnWW DY SRSXODULWHW XWJ|U I| HQ I|UXWVlWWQLQJ I|UDWWNXQQDYHUNDSnEnGHOnQJRFKNRUWVLNW²I|UYDGlU Q\WWDQPHGHWWWRPWNODVVUXPHOOHUPHGHQDYRJWLQVWlOOG NODVV"'HWlUGRFNFHQWUDOWDWWYDUDNODU|YHUYLONDVRPlU GHHJHQWOLJDPnOVlWWQLQJDUQDPHGOlUDUJlUQLQJHQ
(Q IUnJD VRP HQJDJHUDU EnGH PLJ RFK GH ÁHVWD OlUDUH
MDJ NlQQHU lU VWXGHQWHUQDV YDULHUDQGH SUHVWDWLRQHU RFK LQVDWVHU'HWlUQDWXUOLJWDWWVWXGLHSUHVWDWLRQHUQDYl[ODU EnGHPHOODQLQGLYLGHURFK|YHUWLGHQEHURHQGHSnVnYlO VWXGHQWHUQDV DPELWLRQ VRP LQWHOOHNWXHOOD RFK ROLND SUDNWLVNDI|UXWVlWWQLQJDU(QIUXVWUHUDQGHRFKVRPGHW YHUNDUW\YlUULQWHKHOWRYDQOLJVDPPDQVlWWQLQJDYGHVVD IDNWRUHU lU GH IDOO GlU EHJnYDGH VWXGHQWHU LQWH lJQDU VWXGLHUQDGHQWLGRFKLQWUHVVHVRPYRUH|QVNYlUW'HWlU QHGVOnHQGHQlUOlURPHGHORFKXSSJLIWHULQWHKDUSHQHWUHUDWV RUGHQWOLJW 'HW EOLU LQJD EUD NXQVNDSHU KHOOHU lYHQ RP GHW NDQVNHNRUWVLNWLJW NDQ Jn K\JJOLJW DWW NODUD WHQWRU RFK VHPLQDULHU HQGDVW PHG KMlOS DY I|UHOlVQLQJDUQDRFKVLQEHJnYQLQJ
-DJ NDQ XQGUD YDG MDJ VRP OlUDUH NDQ J|UD I|U DWW In
IDUW Sn VWXGLHLYHUQ 6lNHUW NDQ WH[ HQ VWLPXOHUDQGH XQGHUYLVQLQJJ|UDHQVNLOOQDGRFKVNDSDGULYIMlGUDUPHQ GHW ÀQQV EHJUlQVQLQJDU ([WUDMREE RFK H[WUDVWXGLHU IHVWDQGH RFK I|UHQLQJVOLY lU H[HPSHO Sn NRQNXUUHQWHU RPVWXGHQWHUQDVWLGVRPNDQYDUDVYnUDDWWVOn'lUWLOO lU GHW MX RFNVn DNWLYLWHWHU VRP GHW lU EUD DWW lJQD VLJ nW L ODJRP PlQJG HIWHUVRP GH NDQ JH YlUGHIXOOD NXQVNDSHUNRQWDNWHURFKHUIDUHQKHWHU0LQDXSSOHYHOVHU VRP OlUDUH YLG GHQ VWDUNW EHW\JVKHWVDGH VWXGLHPLOM|Q YLG MXULVWXWELOGQLQJHQ L 8SSVDOD J|U DWW MDJ LQWH WURU Sn VWXGLHKHWVVRPSDWHQWPHGLFLQ²lYHQRPGHWLQWHVlOODQ ELGUDU WLOO DWW OLWWHUDWXUHQ SHQHWUHUDV PHG HQ QlUD QRJ PDQLVN IUHQHVL 'HW lU DOOWVn NQDSSDVW KHOOHU GHQ UlWWD YlJHQ,GHVVDIUnJRUWURUMDJDWWGHWEHK|YVElWWUHGLDORJ PHOODQ OlUDUH RFK VWXGHQWHU RFK NDQVNH RFNVn DQGUD nWJlUGHU PHQ MDJ YHW LQWH YLOND 6DPWLGLJW YLOO MDJ VlJD DWWGHÁHVWDDIIlUVMXULGLVNDVWXGHQWHUQDlUEnGHEHJnYDGH RFKYlOI|UEHUHGGDVnLQJHQVNXJJD|YHUÁHUWDOHW
'HQ UROLJDVWH GHOHQ DY OlUDUJlUQLQJHQ lU VnNODUW
VnGDQD WLOOIlOOHQ GlU PDQ XSSOHYHU DWW KHOD JUXSSHQ lU PHG RFK ELGUDU PHG HJQD WHVHU IUnJRU SDUDOOHOOHU RFK SUREOHPDWLVHULQJDU HWF GlU GHW NlQQV VRP DWW µSROHWWHU E|UMDU IDOOD QHGµ KRV PnQJD VWXGHQWHU
GYV DWW VYnUD VDNHU WLOO VLVW IDOOHU Sn SODWV L GHQ LQUH lPQHVNXQVNDSVNDUWDQ RFK GlU PDQ VRP OlUDUH O\FNDV µIn WLOOµQnJUD EUD LGpHU DY QnJRW VODJ'HNRPPHU GRFN LQWH DY VLJ VMlOY XWDQ NUlYHU EnGH I|UEHUHGHOVHU RFK OLWH EHJnYQLQJ IUnQ DOOD SDUWHU VDPW HQ JQXWWD WXU HOOHU YDG GHW QX lU VRP J|U DWW GH GlU IlQJVODQGH WLOOIlOOHQD LQÀQQHUVLJ'HWlULQWHKHOOHUDOOWLGVnOlWWDWWYHWDRPGHW PDQ VMlOY XSSOHYHU VRP IUXNWEDUW RFK LQWUHVVDQW RFNVn XSSVNDWWDVRFKI|UVWnVDYVWXGHQWHUQD(QIlOODNDQWH[ YDUDDWWXWJnIUnQDWWHQJDJHPDQJHWRFKNXQVNDSHQKRV GHVWXGHQWHUVRPXWPlUNHUVLJSRVLWLYWlUUHSUHVHQWDWLYW ² Vn lU GHW VMlOYNODUW LQWH 'HW lU GRFN IDUOLJW OlWW DWW WD IDVWD Sn GLDORJHQ PHG GHP VRP KlQJHU PHG ULNWLJW EUD RFK GHVVXWRP GHOWDU L GLVNXVVLRQHQ YLONHW L YlUVWD IDOO NDQJ|UDDWWDQGUDKDPQDULEDNYDWWQHW6DPWLGLJWNDQ MDJLQWHVHDQQDWlQDWWDOODVWXGHQWHUKDUHWWDQVYDUI|U DWW GUD L Q|GEURPVHQ RP PDQ LQWH KLQQHU PHG 8WDQ VQDEEIHHGEDFNIUnQVWXGHQWHUQDlUGHWVYnUWI|UOlUDUHQ DWWDYJ|UDYDGVRPlUUlWWQLYnSnXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ
0nQJD XWPDQLQJDU OLJJHU Sn YlJHQ WLOO GHQ SHUIHNWD
MXULGLNXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ OnQJW ÁHU lQ VRP NXQQDW WDV XSS KlU 1lU MDJ OlVHU GHQ KlU NU|QLNDQ WlQNHU MDJ DWW GHQ NDQVNH IUDPVWnU YlO NULWLVN 0LQD KLWWLOOVYDUDQGH nU VRP OlUDUH KDU GRFN YDULW IDQWDVWLVNW JLYDQGH RFK MDJ VNXOOH L GDJ LQWH NXQQD WlQND PLJ HWW DUEHWH XWDQ EHW\GDQGHXQGHUYLVQLQJVLQVODJ-DJXSSOHYHULQWHKHOOHU DWWSUREOHPHQVNXOOHGRPLQHUDELOGHQDYXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ $WW EnGH OlUDUH RFK VWXGHQWHU YHUNDU L K|J JUDG Q|MGD PHG VLQ YHUNVDPKHW RFK VLQD XSSOHYHOVHU KlU YLG /L8 RFKDWWYnUDDIIlUVMXULGLVNDPDJLDVWUDUO\FNDVVnÀQWSn DUEHWVPDUNQDGHQWDODULVWlOOHWI|UDWWEnGHXWELOGQLQJHQ RFK VWXGHQWHUQD KnOOHU K|J NYDOLWHW 6DPWLGLJW XSSOHYHU MDJGHIUnJRUVRPRYDQVNLVVHUDWVVRPYLNWLJD'HWlUDY VW|UVWD EHW\GHOVH DWW DUEHWHW PHG DWW I|UlGOD GHQ K|JUH XWELOGQLQJHQDOGULJWLOOnWVDYVWDQQD -DQ.HOOJUHQlUGRFHQWLDIIlUVUlWWYLGDYGHOQLQJHQI|U5lWWRFK UlWWVÀORVRÀ+DQXQGHUYLVDUIUDPI|UDOOWLI|UHWDJVEHVNDWWQLQJ
