Vägen till ett effektivare förbättringsarbete : En fallstudie ur ett process- och organisationsperspektiv hos Trafikverket Region Öst
53
0
0
Full text
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
(3) *UQ>?*K>). !"#%$&&&. :9$& .7-5& '7& -& D7.$& $**$8'(,$& (D6.7,$D$%'& R7.+& 2& >& S-1$& 1'45I& 1$$%& *.7D& -& 6.78$11& -%5& 7.#-%(T-'(7%-)& 6$.16$8'(,$E& -'& '9$& :.-%167.'& >5D(%(1'.-'(7%& 3-1'$.%& ;$#(7%E&NR$5$%&U:.-*(+,$.+$'&;$#(7%&<1'VJ'. =.#>9*<&''. =-1)-&>%'$.&-%5&?$.,$&>%'$.&. -,#$&''. W4%$&@%5&@BCB&. ?$1$%&&&. ?-1'$.1&O$#.$$&(%&X41(%$11&>5D(%(1'.-'(7%E&=<>FBBE&CG&8.$5('1'. !.#9*&''. ?-.($&?/.%5-)&. @$6'A9*5&&& QD6.7,$D$%'E&87%'(%4741&(D6.7,$D$%'E&:7'-)&Y4-)('I&?-%-#$D$%'E&(D6.7,$D$%'& '77)1E,$.%D$%'E&)$-.%(%#&7.#-%(T-'(7%E&6.78$11E&)$-5$.19(6&-%5&87DD4%(8-'(7%J&&. ' B.*C9<$&&&. ;$#>95&''. :9$&'9$1(1&(%'$%51&'7&(5$%'(*I&5$*(8($%8($1&(%&'9$&(D6.7,$D$%'&6.78$11&-%5&6.7671$& D$-14.$1&7%&97R&'9$&84..$%'&.$174.8$1&-%5&'77)1&8-%&0$&41$5&D7.$&$**(8($%')IJ&' S7%1(5$.(%#& -&%7%26.70-0()('I& 1-D6)$& 5$6'9E& (%'$.,($R1& -%5& -8'(7%& .$1$-.89& 19-))& 0$& 87%548'$5& 0I& 8-1$& 1'45($1& -'& '9$& ;7-5& >5D(%(1'.-'(7%& ;$#(7%& ?")-.5-)$%& U!"#,$.+$'&;$#(7%&?")-.5-)$%VJ&. D947%.<"94<&'3**$8'(,$&(D6.7,$D$%'&(1&9-%5)$5&5(**$.$%')I&(%&$,$.I&87D6-%IE&'9-'&(1&R9I&'9$.$&(1& %7& 4%(,$.1-)& 1'.48'4.$& D7.$& 1488$11*4)& '9-%& -%7'9$.J& :9$& 1'.48'4.$& 1974)5& 0$& 5$,$)76$5&-%5&-5-6'$5&'7&$-89&16$8(*(8&7.#-%(T-'(7%1&%$$51J&>̇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
(5) ) ) ) ) ) ) ). ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ). !"#$$%&#%'()%*%+,$$%-./0#12%% 34.+%&#%'()%*%&'5%/#&#&6#/2% %,(7.$7#%&#%'()%*%+,$$%8()#/31'()!9% ) :%;,(#3,3<1%./)3=/><% ).
(6) SRR=!XLLQA@?>=KYRSRT) E)SRL=WRSRT....................................................................................................................................1 EZE)U(%#19/+ ...............................................................................................................................1 EZG)[1&4',-(8.$,1./#..................................................................................................................2 EZ\)]<<+1(#$4,$%1.:/./# ..........................................................................................................3 EZI)[1&4',-0&1-9',1./#(1.........................................................................................................4 EZH)Q^08,........................................................................................................................................4 G);=>VWVLVTSQY*)@N=?N_T*RW=R .....................................................................................5 GZE)N,8,/$%(<'.#8)(/#1,<<$$588..............................................................................................5 GZG)N(')(:)-,8&+ .......................................................................................................................5 GZGZE)]1:(' ....................................................................................................................................6 GZGZG)WP9<./8,1:P9,1 ....................................................................................................................6 GZGZ\)*/('^$$,-./(1.9- ............................................................................................................7 GZ\)N(')(:)'.88,1(891.....................................................................................................................8 GZI)>1&:51+.#2,8..........................................................................................................................9 \)>=V?S)VK!)>SWST*?=)AV?QYRSRT .........................................................................................10 \ZE)Y:('.8,8$(14,8,).)$8(8'.#()&1#(/.$(8.&/,1.......................................................................10 \ZG)Q85/+.#()0"145881./#(1......................................................................................................11 \ZI);,+:,1%(/)&72)%&--9/.%(8.&/....................................................................................13 \ZH)[1&7,$$,1)&72)1&'',1 ...........................................................................................................14 \ZD)A(%8(4($,1(+,)4,$'98 ......................................................................................................16 \Z`)=/#(#,1(8)',+(1$%(<........................................................................................................16 \ZC)N51+,1./#(1M)-,8&+,1)&72):,1%8^# ...............................................................................18 I)=;[S?SQY)]RW=?Q@YRSRT.......................................................................................................19 IZE)Y:('.8,8$(14,8,).)?,#.&/);5'(1+(',/.............................................................................20 IZG)Q85/+.#()0"145881./#(1......................................................................................................21 IZI);,+:,1%(/)&72)%&--9/.%(8.&/....................................................................................22 IZH)[1&7,$$,1)&72)1&'',1 ...........................................................................................................22 IZD)A(%8(4($,1(+,)4,$'98 ......................................................................................................24 IZ`)=/#(#,1(8)',+(1$%(<........................................................................................................25 IZC)N51+,1./#(1M)-,8&+,1)&72):,1%8^# ...............................................................................26.
(7) H)*R*LaQ .......................................................................................................................................27 HZE)Y:('.8,8$(14,8,).)?,#.&/);5'(1+(',/.............................................................................27 HZG)Q85/+.#()0"145881./#(1......................................................................................................27 HZI);,+:,1%(/)&72)%&--9/.%(8.&/....................................................................................28 HZH)[1&7,$$,1)&72)1&'',1 ...........................................................................................................29 HZD)A(%8(4($,1(+,)4,$'98 ......................................................................................................30 HZ`)=/#(#,1(8)',+(1$%(<........................................................................................................31 HZC)N51+,1./#(1M)-,8&+,1)&72):,1%8^# ...............................................................................31 D)?=Q]L>*>)VK!)X>T_?WQLSQ>*);=W)[?VK=QQY*?>*........................................................33 DZE)?,$9'8(8 ................................................................................................................................33 DZG)[1&7,$$%(18()<3)0"145881./#$(14,8, ..............................................................................36 DZ\)X8#51+$'.$8()8.'')>1(0.%:,1%,8)?,#.&/)@$8)0"1),88),00,%8.:(1,)0"145881./#$(14,8, ......37 `)NSW*?=)AV?QYRSRT..................................................................................................................38 ?=A=?=RQ=? ...................................................................................................................................39 USL*T*)E)O)>?*ASYN=?Y=> ............................................................................................................. i USL*T*)G)O)SR>=?Nb]T]SW=);=W*?U=>*?=............................................................................. ii USL*T*)\)O)SR>=?Nb]T]SW=)=R!=>QK!=A=?............................................................................ iii USL*T*)I)O)A@?U_>>?SRTQ6)VK!)L=WRSRTQN=?Y>aT...........................................................iv USL*T*)H)6)YN*LS>=>Q[VLSKa .......................................................................................................v. AST]?A@?>=KYRSRT) AST]?)EB)>SLLN_T*TXRTQQ_>>)S)Q>]WS=R..............................................................................................5 AST]?)GB)=T=RYV;[VR=?*W)>=V?S;VW=LL)]>SA?XR)U=?T;*R)VK!)YL=AQb@Q);VW=LL)>?=) YV;[VR=R>=?)*N)VAA=RQSN)YN*LS>=>Q]>N=KYLSRT.............................................................18 AST]?)\B)KGc)[?VT?*;;=>Q)Aa?*)L=W ..........................................................................................20 AST]?)IB)=T=RYV;[VR=?*W)=;[S?S;VW=LL)]>SA?XR)U=?T;*R)VK!)YL=AQb@Q);VW=LL)>?=) YV;[VR=R>=?)*N)VAA=RQSN)YN*LS>=>Q]>N=KYLSRT.............................................................26 AST]?)HB)=T=RYV;[VR=?*W)*R*LaQ;VW=LL)]>SA?XR)U=?T;*R)VK!)YL=AQb@Q);VW=LL)>?=) YV;[VR=R>=?)*N)VAA=RQSN)YN*LS>=>Q]>N=KYLSRT.............................................................32 AST]?)DB)=T=R)]>*?U=>*W)[?VK=QQY*?>*........................................................................................36.
(8) Y*[S>=L)Ed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`V& 2. 1 (41).
(9) Y*[S>=L)Ed)SRL=WRSRT). 1+-&9-%'$.-1E&-%6-11-1&789&(D6)$D$%'$.-1&0L5$&6L&$''&)$5-.1+-612&789&7.#-%(1-'7.(1+&%(,L&*/.&-''& *L& $%& $%9$')(#& 9$)9$'11I%& 6L& +,-)('$'J8& a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b'7'-)+,-)('$'&6-.-)I1b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cD(11)I8+-1c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d&17D&$''&-5D(%(1'.-'(,'&1'/5J&M%5$.&5$&1$%-1'$&L.$%&9-.&578+&D"%#5$%& */.0"''.(%#1*/.1)-#& D(%1+-'& (%7D& ;$#(7%& ?")-.5-)$%& 789& '-+'$%& (& #$%7D*/.-%5$'& -,& */.0"''.(%#-.&9-.&,-.('&)L%#1-DJ&N7D&$K$D6$)&6L&5$''-& +-%&%"D%-1&-''&.$#(7%$%&L.&@BBe&*(8+&(%& $''&*/.1)-#&7D&-''&1+-6-&$%&#$D$%1-D&I'-&5".&.$#(7%$%1&,(+-.(-'*/.7.5%-%5$%&1+4))$&16-.-1J&_L& #.4%5& -,& */."%5.(%#-.& (& Q'21'.4+'4.$%& 789& %I-& Q'2,$.+'I#& 5./A5$& 5$'& "%5-& '())& @BB]& (%%-%& $''& #$D$%1-D'& -.0$'1.4D& 1+-6-5$1J& O$''-& +-%& 1$1& 17D& $%& )L%#& '(5& */.& $''& .$)-'(,'& )"''& L'#".5-'& */.1)-#J14&3K$D6)$'& 6L,(1-.& -''& 5-#$%1& */.0"''.(%#1-.0$'$& 971& ;$#(7%& ?")-.5-)$%& (%'$& 9L))$.&. 8. &\-18$))$1E&OJE&O-)$E&XJ&UC]^^V& &O-9)#--.5E&WJE&O-9)#--.52_-.+E&NJ&U@BB`V& 10 &O-,($1JE&WJ&U@BB`V& 11 &ND('9E&?J&$'&-)J&UC]^@V& 12 &O-,($1JE&WJ&U@BB`V& 13 &O-#$%1&%I9$'$.1&R$006)-'1& 14 &?4%')(#&+7DD4%(+-'(7%f&\(1-&:$5$%)A4%#E&W79-%%-&X$.#)4%5& 9. 2 (41).
(10) Y*[S>=L)Ed)SRL=WRSRT). DL''$'&7D&$%&/%1+-5&*/.0"''.(%#1'-+'J& Q& */.1'-& 9-%5& ,$.+-.& -16$+'$.& 17D& 5$%& 1'-#%$.-5$& */.0"''.(%#16.78$11$%& 789& (D6)$D$%'$.(%#16.70)$D-'(+& ,-.-& .$)$,-%'& -''& 0$-+'-E& 1%-.-.$& "%& D$5-.0$'-.%-1& $%1+()5-& */.0"''.(%#1*/.1)-#J&O".(#$%7D&".&*)/5$'&(&*/.0"''.(%#16.78$11$%&$%&(%'.$11-%'&789&0$'I5$)1$*4))& (-+''-#$)1$J& M'(*.L%& 5$'& *-+'4D& -''& ,-.+$%& 0.-& */.1)-#& $))$.& 1'/56.7#.-DD$'& S@d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
(11) Y*[S>=L)Ed)SRL=WRSRT). EZI)[1&4',-0&1-9',1./#(1) CJ&!()+-&-,#/.-%5$&*-+'7.$.&9-.&6L,$.+-'&*/.0"''.(%#1-.0$'$'&(&7.#-%(1-'(7%$%g&& @J&?$5&,()+-&L'#".5$.&+-%&:.-*(+,$.+$'&;$#(7%&<1'&466%L&$''&$**$+'(,-.$&*/.0"''.(%#1-.0$'$g&. EZH)Q^08,) 3K-D$%1-.0$'$'& -,1$.& -''& (5$%'(*($.-& -,#/.-%5$& *-+'7.$.& (& */.0"''.(%#1-.0$'$'& 789& */.$1)L& L'#".5$.&*/.&94.&5-#$%1&.$14.1$.&789&,$.+'I#&+-%&+7D6)$''$.-1J&&. 4 (41).
(12) Y*[S>=L)Gd);=>VWVLVTSQY*)@N=?N_T*RW=R). G));=>VWVLVTSQY*)@N=?N_T*RW=R) &-$'0(()(!0!$0'!<)%<)(!2*)$)'()*#*!/)'!5'/)*$61'0'3!$47!3)'47=6*($!4;<!74(0-)*#*!-#*=6*!7)(4/-#%)'! ?*! *)%)-#'(#! =6*! )G#7)'$#*>)()(@! B0/#*)! =6*$! *)$4')7#'3! 47! /#(#0'$#7%0'3! 4;<! (0%%-?3#38'3$$?((9! =6%F(!#-!<5*!5'/)*$61'0'3)'!$1#!522'8!(*4-?*/03<)(@!!. GZE)N,8,/$%(<'.#8)(/#1,<<$$588)) Q&5$%%-&1'45($&9-.&$%&-054+'(,&-%1-'1&,-)'1&5".&'$7.(%&789&$D6(.(%&4',$8+)-'1&6-.-))$))'E&5$)1&*/.& -''& (%'$& )L1-& 711& *-1'& ,(5& ,(11-& '$7.($.E& 5$)1& */.& -''& 4665.-#1#(,-.%-& 9-5$& 17D& /%1+$DL)& -''& (%'$.,A44%5$.1/+%(%#$%& #$%7D*/.5$1& (& $''& .$)-'(,'& '(5(#'& 1+$5$& 4%5$.& 1'45($6$.(75$%J& :$7.((%1-D)(%#$%& ,-.& $''& %-'4.)(#'& */.1'-& 1'$#& (& 4%5$.1/+%(%#$%E& -%5.-& 1'$#$'& #(8+& 4'& 6L& -''& #$%7D*/.-&5A46(%'$.,A4$.E&'.$5A$&1'$#$'&$%&I''$.)(#-.$&'$7.(#$%7D#L%#&789&1'$#&*I.-&-,1)4'-5$1& D$5& $''& #$D$%1-D'& -%-)I11$D(%-.(4DJ& =/.5$)$%& D$5& 5$'& /66%-& */.9L))%(%#11"''$'& ".& -''& .$)$,-%'-&789&-5$+,-'-&'$7.($.&)I*'1&*.-D&17D&".&-%6-11-5$&'())&5$%&0$*(%')(#-&,$.+)(#9$'$%J15&O$'& ,-%)(#-1'$& 1"''$'& -''& 0$1+.(,-& 4%5$.1/+%(%#1D7D$%'$%& 6L& ".& #$%7D& -''& ())41'.$.-& 5$11-& (& $%& '.-''D75$))J&?75$))$%1&7)(+-&5$)D7D$%'&-,1$.&-''&#$&4%5$.)-#&'())&4%5$.1/+%(%#$%1&.$14)'-'&789& L'#".51*/.1)-#J&&&. !!!!"#$%&&'()*+&',!. -./0&'"#%1./#%!. "#$%&,#'$*,2',!. )')+3((#*&')%&/*!. ) A.#91)EB)>.'':5#(#3/#$$588).)$89+.,/) GZG)N(')(:)-,8&+) O$%%-&1'45($&'-.&1(''&-,1'-D6&(%7D&'.-''D75$))$%1&.-D-.&789&1I*'-.&'())&-''&*/.$1)L&L'#".51*/.1)-#& */.&-''&,(5-.$4',$8+)-&$''&*/.0"''.(%#11I1'$D&971&:.-*(+,$.+$'&;$#(7%&<1'J&O$'&".&,".'&-''&%"D%-& -''&,(&17D&4%5$.1/+-.$&9-5$&$%&140A$+'(,&(%1'"))%(%#&789&,-.&(%,7),$.-5$&(&1-DD-%9-%#$'&(%%-%& $D6(.((%1-D)(%#$%E& $*'$.17D& ,(& ,-.& 1'-.+'& 6L,$.+-5$& *.L%& 4665.-#1#(,-.$%& 17D& +7D& D$5&. 15. &XA/.+)4%5E&?JE&_-4)117%E&MJ&U@BBeV&. 5 (41).
(13) Y*[S>=L)Gd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hV& 18 &3.(+117%E&\JEi($5$.19$(DE&_J&U@BB`V& 19 &S9.(1'$%1$%E&\J&U@BB`V& 20 &j4DD$117%E&3J&UC]^^V& 17. 6 (41).
(14) Y*[S>=L)Gd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`V& &j.(6$%0$.#E&_J&U@BB`V& 23 &j4DD$117%E&3J&UC]^^V& 22. 7 (41).
(15) Y*[S>=L)Gd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k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b6$$.&.$,($R$5bE&,()+$'&(%%$0".&-''&5$& ".&-%7%ID'&#.-%1+-5$&-,&70$.7$%5$&*7.1+-.$&*/.$&640)(8$.(%#$%J&& :$7.(-,1%(''$'&9-.&+7%1'.4$.-'1&D$5&4'#L%#164%+'&(&M).(+-&[$))1'$%&789&X$%#'&H)$*1A/1&0-1D75$))& b'.$& +7D67%$%'$.& -,& 7**$%1(,& +,-)('$'14',$8+)(%#b& 789& 9-.& +7D6)$''$.-1& D$5& -%%-%& '$7.(J& >''& -%5.-&'$7.($.%-&9-.&1-DD-%+766)-'1&9-.&4'/+-'&0-1D75$))$%E&,()+$'&#$%$.$.-.&$%&%I&'$7.(D75$))& 4'*7.D-'& $%0-.'& */.& 5$%%-& 1'45($& 789& 17D& 9-.& 1+-6-'& $''& '$7.$'(1+'& 4%5$.)-#& 17D& ".& D$.& -11(D()$.-5&'())&:.-*(+,$.+$'&;$#(7%&<1'J&>%)$5%(%#$%&'())&-''&'$7.($.%-&9-.&1-D)-'1&'())&$%&D75$))E& ,-.&*/.&-''&())41'.$.-&-.0$'16.78$11$%&6L&$''&/,$.1+L5)(#'&1"''J@`& :())&,L.&9A")6&*(8+&,(&'())#L%#&'())&!"#,$.+$'1&(%'.-%"'&*.L%&4665.-#1#(,-.%-E&*/.&-''&*L&$%&0()5&7D&94.& 1'/56.7#.-DD$'&789&6.78$11*)/5$'&1$.&4'&1-D'&,()+-&(%1'.4+'(7%$.&5$'&#$1J&N-D')(#-&*/.1)-#&17D& 9-.&.$#(1'.$.-'1&(&1'/56.7#.-DD$'&789&5$&-+'4$))-&*/.1)-#$%1&1'-5(4D&.$57,(1-5$1J&_L&5$''-&1"''& *(8+&,(&(%1I%&(&.4'(%$.&17D&*(%%1&*/.&1'"%5(#-&*/.0"''.(%#-.J&& 24. &W-8701$%E&OJ&U@BB@V& &S9.(1'$%1$%E&\J&$'&-)J&U@BBCV& 26 [$))1'$%E&MJE&H)$*1A/E&XJ&U@BBBV 25. 8 (41).
(16) Y*[S>=L)Gd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h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l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`V& &S9.(1'$%1$%E&\J&$'&-)J&U@BBCV&. 28. 9 (41).
(17) Y*[S>=L)\d)>=V?S)VK!)>SWST*?=)AV?QYRSRT)). \)>=V?S)VK!)>SWST*?=)AV?QYRSRT) Här redovisas de teorier som ligger till grund för analysen av förbättringsarbetet hos Region Mälardalen. De valda teorierna ger en sammanfattning av de olika perspektiv som tidigare forskning anammat, vilket syftar till att ge läsaren en uppfattning av betydelsefulla aspekter som påverkar kvalitetsarbete och ständiga förbättringar. I slutet av kapitlet illustreras en modell som summerar de tidigare beskrivna teorierna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k& UCV& ,".5$.(%#-.E& U@V& D$'75$.& 789& Uh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b*7+41$.-&6L&,-5&17D&0$9/,1& #/.-1& (5-#& */.& -''& *."DA-& *.-D#L%#& (D7.#7%bJ32& m-1(%E& >)-,(E& H4%'& 789& n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hV& 31 &O$R94.1'E&=J&$'&-)J&UC]]]V&=.I$.E&HJ&$'&-)J&U@BBeV& 32 &=.I$.E&HJ&$'&-)J&U@BBeV&1J&GBC& 33 &m-1(%E&?J&$'&-)&U@BBFV& 34 &O$-%E&?JE&[$)D1JE&?J&UC]]`V& 30. 10 (41).
(18) Y*[S>=L)\d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b*/.0"''.(%#b& 789& 5$11& ,(+'(#-& 6-.-D$'.-.& 0$9/,$.& +)-.#/.-1& */.& 1-D')(#-& D$5-.0$'-.$& (%7D& 7.#-%(1-'(7%$%& */.& -''& *L& $%& .4))%(%#& 6L& */.0"''.(%#1-.0$'$'J& N/.Z,(1'& 0$1+.(,$.& '.$& 7)(+-& %(,L$.& 6L& 94.& */.0"''.(%#-.& +-%& 4661'LE& UCV& -''& */.0"''.(%#$%& )I*'$.& $''& 5L)(#'& '())1'L%5& '())& $''& 0.-& '())1'L%5E& U@V& -''& */.0"''.(%#$%& '-.& *.L%& 5L)(#& 1('4-'(7%& '())& $%& D(%5.$& 5L)(#& 1('4-'(7%E& Uh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eV&1J&GBC& 37 &O$R94.1'E&=J&$'&-)J&UC]]]V&=.I$.E&HJ&$'&-)J&U@BBeV& 38 &>9.$%*$)'E&XJ&U@BBCVE&X$.#D-%E&XJE&H)$*1A/E&XJ&U@BBCV& 39 &N/.Z,(1'E&\J&U@BBFV& 36. 11 (41).
(19) Y*[S>=L)\d)>=V?S)VK!)>SWST*?=)AV?QYRSRT)). 1"#-& -''& #-D)-& '-%+$D/%1'$.& 789& 7.#-%(1-'7.(1+-& -#$.-%5$%& */.0)(.& 7*/."%5.-'J& !(5& $%& */."%5.(%#& -,& -%5.-& 7.5%(%#$%& */."%5.-1& (%,-%5-& '-%+$D/%1'$.& 789& $'-0)$.-5$& 0$'$$%5$%E& ,()+$'&4'#/.&-''&9$)-&1I1'$D$'&*/."%5.-1&789&D$5-.0$'-.%-&.$17%$.-.&-%%7.)4%5-J40&& =/."%5.(%#& -,& */.1'-& 7.5%(%#$%& 9-.& $%& 1'-.+& -%+%I'%(%#& '())& b'())*"))(#-& 6.70)$DbE& 17D& N/.Z,(1'& +-))-.&5$'J& :())*"))(#-&6.70)$D& ".&$%+)-.$&-''&466'"8+-E&$*'$.17D&0.(1'$.&789&*$)&+7..(#$.-1&*/.&-''& (%'$& -,,(+-& *.L%& 5$'& $'-0)$.-5$& 789& -88$6'$.-5$& 1I1'$D$'& (& ,$.+1-D9$'$%J& Q& .$#$)& .$,(5$.-1& 6.70)$D$%1& 1ID6'7D& 4'-%& -''& #L& '())& 07''$%& 789& )/1-& 5$%& $#$%')(#-& 7.1-+$%& '())& 6.70)$D$'J41& !(5-.$&+-%&5$''-&A"D*/.-1&D$5&>.#I.(1&*$%7D$%&7D&b1(%#$)2)776b&17D&'I5$.&6L&-''&D$5-.0$'-.$& (%'$&(*.L#-1"''$.E&4'.$5$.&$))$.&4%5$.1/+$.&0-+7D)(##-%5$&D(11'-#&(%%-%&5$&."''-.&'())&5$'J&!(5-.$& */.+)-.-.&>.#I.(1&-''&5$''-&1+-6-.&$%&7%5&8(.+$)&D$5&$''&5$*$%1(,'&0$'$$%5$& 789&D(11*/.1'L$)1$E& 17D&+-%&)$5-&'())&-''&D$5-.0$'-.$&1+I))$.&(*.L%&1(#&%".&6.70)$D&4661'L.J42&& =/."%5.(%#$%& -,& -%5.-& 7.5%(%#$%& +-%& 5.-1& )(%A$& '())& b+.7%(1+-& 6.70)$DbE& 17D& N/.Z,(1'& 1+.(,$.J& H.7%(1+-&6.70)$D&".&1,L.-.$&-''&466'"8+-&789&+.",$.&7D*-''-%5$&*/.0"''.(%#1(%1-'1$.E&$*'$.17D& *$)&789&0.(1'$.&".&(%0I##5-&789&-88$6'$.-5$&(&1I1'$D$'&17D&1+-&*/."%5.-1&'())&5$'&0"''.$J43&O$''-& +-%&",$%&5.-1&6-.-))$))$.&'())&>.#I.(1&0$#.$66&7D&b5740)$2)776b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i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
Related documents
Domstolsverket har bedömt att utredningen inte innehåller något förslag som påverkar Sveriges Domstolar på ett sådant sätt. Domstolsverket har därför inte något att invända
invändningar ska göras utifrån en objektiv bedömning och länsstyrelserna ska genom ”samverkan sinsemellan bidra till att urvalet av områden blir likvärdigt runt om i
Det saknas dessutom en beskrivning av vilka konsekvenser det får för kommunerna i ett läge där länsstyrelsen inte godkänner kommunens förslag på områden och kommunen behöver
Förslagen i promemorian innebär att innan en kommun gör en anmälan till Migrationsverket ska kommunen inhämta ett yttrande från länsstyrelsen över den eller de delar av kommunen
Huddinge kommun anser att de kommuner som likt Huddinge motiverat sina områdesval utifrån socioekonomiska förutsättningar och redan haft den dialog med länsstyrelsen som föreslås
Hultsfreds kommun anser att även kommuner utöver de som anges i bilaga 1 till förordningen (2018:151) om statsbidrag till kommuner med socioekono- miska utmaningar ska kunna
Jönköpings kommun har beretts möjlighet att lämna synpunkter på promemorian ” Ett ändrat fö rfa rande för att anmäla områd en som omfatt as av be gr änsni n gen av rätt en ti
Frågan som är utskickad för remiss handlar om förslag om att göra vissa ändringar i det anmälningsförfarande som gäller vilka områden som omfattas av en begränsning
